Selective binding by the RNA binding domain of PKR revealed by affinity cleavage

The RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR) is regulated by the binding of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) or single-stranded RNAs with extensive duplex secondary structure. PKR has an RNA binding domain (RBD) composed of two copies of the dsRNA binding motif (dsRBM). The dsRBM is an alpha-beta-beta-beta-alpha structure present in a number of proteins that bind RNA, and the selectivity demonstrated by these proteins is currently not well understood. We have used affinity cleavage to study the binding of PKR's RBD to RNA. In this study, we site-specifically modified the first dsRBM of PKR's RBD at two different amino acid positions with the hydroxyl radical generator EDTA.Fe. Cleavage by these proteins of a synthetic stem-loop ligand of PKR indicates that PKR's dsRBMI binds the RNA in a preferred orientation, placing the loop between strands beta1 and beta2 near the single-stranded RNA loop. Additional cleavage experiments demonstrated that defects in the RNA stem, such as an A bulge and two GA mismatches, do not dictate dsRBMI's binding orientation preference. Cleavage of VA(I) RNA, an adenoviral RNA inhibitor of PKR, indicates that dsRBMI is bound near the loop of the apical stem of this RNA in the same orientation as observed with the synthetic stem-loop RNA ligands. This work, along with an NMR study of the binding of a dsRBM derived from the Drosophila protein Staufen, indicates that dsRBMs can bind stem-loop RNAs in distinct ways. In addition, the successful application of the affinity cleavage technique to localizing dsRBMI of PKR on stem-loop RNAs and defining its orientation suggests this approach could be applied to dsRBMs found in other proteins.     

Identification of binding sites for both dsRBMs of PKR on kinase-activating and kinase-inhibiting RNA ligands

The RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR) is an interferon-induced, RNA-activated enzyme that phosphorylates and inhibits the function of the translation initiation factor eIF-2. PKR has a double-stranded RNA-binding domain (dsRBD) composed of two copies of the dsRNA binding motif (dsRBM). PKR's dsRBD is involved in the regulation of the enzyme as dsRNAs of cellular and viral origins bind to the dsRBD, leading to either activation or inhibition of PKR's kinase activity. In this study, we site-specifically modified each of the dsRBMs of PKR's dsRBD with the hydroxyl radical generator EDTA small middle dotFe and performed cleavage studies on kinase-activating and kinase-inhibiting RNAs. These experiments led to the identification of binding sites for the individual dsRBMs on various RNA ligands including a viral activating RNA (TAR from HIV-1), a viral inhibiting RNA (VA(I) RNA from adenovirus), an aptamer RNA that activates PKR, and a small synthetic inhibiting RNA. These results indicate that some RNAs interact only with one dsRBM, while others can bind both dsRBMs of PKR. In addition, EDTA small middle dotFe modification coupled with site-directed mutagenesis was used to assess the extent of cooperativity in the binding of the two dsRBMs. These experiments support the hypothesis that simultaneous binding of both dsRBMs of PKR occurs on kinase activating RNA ligands.     

Controlling activation of the RNA-dependent protein kinase by siRNAs using site-specific chemical modification

The RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR) is activated by binding to double-stranded RNA (dsRNA). Activation of PKR by short-interfering RNAs (siRNAs) and stimulation of the innate immune response has been suggested to explain certain off-target effects in some RNA interference experiments. Here we show that PKR's kinase activity is stimulated in vitro 3- to 5-fold by siRNA duplexes with 19 bp and 2 nt 3′-overhangs, whereas the maximum activation observed for poly(I)•poly(C) was 17-fold over background under the same conditions. Directed hydroxyl radical cleavage experiments indicated that siRNA duplexes have at least four different binding sites for PKR's dsRNA binding motifs (dsRBMs). The location of these binding sites suggested specific nucleotide positions in the siRNA sense strand that could be modified with a corresponding loss of PKR binding. Modification at these sites with N²-benzyl-2′-deoxyguanosine (BndG) blocked interaction with PKR's dsRBMs and inhibited activation of PKR by the siRNA. Importantly, modification of an siRNA duplex that greatly reduced PKR activation did not prevent the duplex from lowering mRNA levels of a targeted message by RNA interference in HeLa cells. Thus, these studies demonstrate that specific positions in an siRNA can be rationally modified to prevent interaction with components of cellular dsRNA-regulated pathways.     

Paradoxical interactions between human delta hepatitis agent RNA and the cellular protein kinase PKR.

The genome of the human delta hepatitis agent is a circular, highly structured single-stranded RNA lacking regular runs of RNA-RNA duplex longer than 15 bp. We have tested the ability of delta agent RNA to participate in reactions with a protein containing a motif which confers the ability to bind double-stranded RNA (dsRNA). Surprisingly, highly purified delta agent RNA preparations from which all traces of contaminating dsRNA have been removed activate PKR, the dsRNA-dependent protein kinase activity of mammalian cells (also known as DAI, P1-eIF-2, and p68 kinase). This behavior is in marked contrast to the interaction of PKR with a number of other highly structured viral single-stranded RNAs, which inhibit, rather than stimulate, activation of this kinase. PKR activation leads to inhibition of protein synthesis in the rabbit reticulocyte lysate system. Paradoxically, delta RNA failed to elicit the expected PKR-mediated inhibition of cell-free translation. Instead, delta RNA interfered with PKR activation and the translational block induced by dsRNA. We conclude that the interaction of PKR and delta agent RNA may represent a new category of protein-RNA interactions involving the dsRNA binding motif.     

Recognition of double-stranded RNA by proteins and small molecules

Molecular recognition of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) is a key event for numerous biological pathways including the trafficking, editing, and maturation of cellular RNA, the interferon antiviral response, and RNA interference. Over the past several years, our laboratory has studied proteins and small molecules that bind dsRNA with the goal of understanding and controlling the binding selectivity. In this review, we discuss members of the dsRBM class of proteins that bind dsRNA. The dsRBM is an approximately 70 amino acid sequence motif found in a variety of dsRNA-binding proteins. Recent results have led to a new appreciation of the ability of these proteins to bind selectivity to certain sites on dsRNA. This property is discussed in light of the RNA selectivity observed in the function of two proteins that contain dsRBMs, the RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR) and an adenosine deaminase that acts on dsRNA (ADAR2). In addition, we introduce peptide-acridine conjugates (PACs), small molecules designed to control dsRBM-RNA interactions. These intercalating molecules bear variable peptide appendages at opposite edges of an acridine heterocycle. This design imparts the potential to exploit differences in groove characteristics and/or base-pair dynamics at binding sites to achieve selective binding.     

RNA Dimerization Promotes PKR Dimerization and Activation

The double-stranded RNA (dsRNA)-activated protein kinase [protein kinase R (PKR)] plays a major role in the innate immune response in humans. PKR binds dsRNA non-sequence specifically and requires a minimum of 15-bp dsRNA for one protein to bind and 30-bp dsRNA to induce protein dimerization and activation by autophosphorylation. PKR phosphorylates eukaryotic initiation factor 2α, a translation initiation factor, resulting in the inhibition of protein synthesis. We investigated the mechanism of PKR activation by an RNA hairpin with a number of base pairs intermediate between these 15- to 30-bp limits: human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transactivation-responsive region (TAR) RNA, a 23-bp hairpin with three bulges that is known to dimerize. TAR monomers and dimers were isolated from native gels and assayed for RNA and protein dimerization to test whether RNA dimerization affects PKR dimerization and activation. To modulate the extent of dimerization, we included TAR mutants with different secondary features. Native gel mixing experiments and analytical ultracentrifugation indicate that TAR monomers bind one PKR monomer and that TAR dimers bind two or three PKRs, demonstrating that RNA dimerization drives the binding of multiple PKR molecules. Consistent with functional dimerization of PKR, TAR dimers activated PKR while TAR monomers did not, and RNA dimers with fewer asymmetrical secondary-structure defects, as determined by enzymatic structure mapping, were more potent activators. Thus, the secondary-structure defects in the TAR RNA stem function as antideterminants to PKR binding and activation. Our studies support that dimerization of a 15- to 30-bp hairpin RNA, which effectively doubles its length, is a key step in driving activation of PKR and provide a model for how RNA folding can be related to human disease.     

Inhibition of PKR activation by the proline-rich RNA binding domain of the herpes simplex virus type 1 Us11 protein

Upon activation by double-stranded RNA in virus-infected cells, the cellular PKR kinase phosphorylates the translation initiation factor eukaryotic initiation factor 2 (eIF2) and thereby inhibits protein synthesis. The gamma 34.5 and Us11 gene products encoded by herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) are dedicated to preventing the accumulation of phosphorylated eIF2. While the gamma 34.5 gene specifies a regulatory subunit for protein phosphatase 1 alpha, the Us11 gene encodes an RNA binding protein that also prevents PKR activation. gamma 34.5 mutants fail to grow on a variety of human cells as phosphorylated eIF2 accumulates and protein synthesis ceases prior to the completion of the viral life cycle. We demonstrate that expression of a 68-amino-acid fragment of Us11 containing a novel proline-rich basic RNA binding domain allows for sustained protein synthesis and enhanced growth of gamma 34.5 mutants. Furthermore, this fragment is sufficient to inhibit activation of the cellular PKR kinase in a cell-free system, suggesting that the intrinsic activities of this small fragment, notably RNA binding and ribosome association, may be required to prevent PKR activation.     

Inhibition of PACT-mediated activation of PKR by the herpes simplex virus type 1 Us11 protein

PACT, a protein activator of PKR, can cause inhibition of cellular protein synthesis and apoptosis. Here, we report that the Us11 protein of herpes simplex virus type 1 can block PKR activation by PACT both in vitro and in vivo. Although Us11 can bind to both PKR and PACT, mutational analyses revealed that the binding of Us11 to PKR, and not to PACT, was essential for its inhibitory action. Similar analyses also revealed that the inhibitory effect was mediated by an interaction between the C-terminal half of Us11 and the N-terminal domain of PKR. The binding of Us11 to PKR did not block the binding of PKR to PACT but prevented its activation. Us11 is the first example of a viral protein that can inhibit the action of PACT on PKR.     

Interactions between double-stranded RNA regulators and the protein kinase DAI.

The interferon-induced protein kinase DAI, the double-stranded RNA (dsRNA)-activated inhibitor of translation, plays a key role in regulating protein synthesis in higher cells. Once activated, in a process that involves autophosphorylation, it phosphorylates the initiation factor eIF-2, leading to inhibition of polypeptide chain initiation. The activity of DAI is controlled by RNA regulators, including dsRNA activators and highly structured single-stranded RNAs which block activation by dsRNA. To elucidate the mechanism of activation, we studied the interaction of DAI with RNA duplexes of discrete sizes. Molecules shorter than 30 bp fail to bind stably and do not activate the enzyme, but at high concentrations they prevent activation by long dsRNA. Molecules longer than 30 bp bind and activate the enzyme, with an efficiency that increases with increasing chain length, reaching a maximum at about 85 bp. These dsRNAs fail to activate at high concentrations and also prevent activation by long dsRNA. Analysis of complexes between dsRNA and DAI suggests that at maximal packing the enzyme interacts with as little as a single helical turn of dsRNA (11 bp) but under conditions that allow activation the binding site protects about 80 bp of duplex. When the RNA-binding site is fully occupied with an RNA activator, the complex appears to undergo a conformational change.     

The binding of double-stranded RNA and adenovirus VAI RNA to the interferon-induced protein kinase

The protein kinase from human cells dependent on double-stranded (ds) RNA is a 68-kDa protein (p68 kinase), the level of which is enhanced significantly in cells treated with interferon. When activated by low concentrations of dsRNA, the p68 kinase becomes phosphorylated and thereby catalyzes the phosphorylation of the protein-synthesis initiation factor, eIF2. Here, we have purified the p68 kinase to homogeneity using a specific monoclonal antibody to investigate its capacity to bind dsRNA, poly(I).poly(C). Our study suggest that p68 kinase has high- and low-affinity binding sites: the high-affinity binding site is responsible for the activation and the low-affinity binding site for the inhibition of kinase activity. This is in accord with the fact that autophosphorylation of p68 kinase occurs at low concentrations of dsRNA whereas high concentrations of dsRNA inhibit its autophosphorylation. We have also investigated the binding of adenoviral VAI RNA to the purified p68 kinase and have found that the affinity of this binding is lower than that of poly(I).poly(C). We show that VAI RNA can activate or inhibit autophosphorylation of p68 kinase in a dose-dependent manner, i.e. activation at less than or equal to 1 microgram/ml or inhibition at greater than 1 microgram/ml of VAI RNA. In spite of its lower affinity of binding, VAI RNA cannot be displaced by poly(I).poly(C) or reovirus dsRNA. These data confirm our previous results to illustrate that VAI RNA can bind p68 kinase and cause its inactivation irreversably.     

Interferon-beta induction through toll-like receptor 3 depends on double-stranded RNA structure

Type I interferons (IFN-alpha/beta) play an essential role in both innate and adaptive antiviral immune responses. IFN- beta is produced by fibroblasts and myeloid dendritic cells (DCs) upon viral infection or in response to doublestranded RNA (dsRNA). Several intracellular molecules having a dsRNA-binding motif such as dsRNA-dependent protein kinase recognize dsRNA in a sequence-independent manner and induce antiviral innate responses. Toll-like receptor (TLR) 3, a member of TLR family proteins, recognizes extracellular dsRNA and activates NF- kappaB and the IFN-beta promoter leading to the induction of IFN-beta production. Here we analyzed the dsRNA structure capable of inducing TLR3-mediated IFN-beta production using various synthetic RNA duplexes. In contrast to the recognition of dsRNA by intracellular molecules, TLR3 preferentially recognizes polyriboinocinic:polyribocytidylic acid (poly(I:C)) rather than synthetic virus-derived dsRNAs. 2'-O-methyl or 2'-fluoro modification of cytidylic acid abolished the IFN-beta-inducing ability of the poly(I:C) duplex, and these modified dsRNAs inhibited poly(I:C)-induced TLR3-mediated IFN-beta production by fibroblasts and DCs. In addition, poly(dI:dC), a non-IFN inducer, also blocked poly(I:C)-induced IFN-beta induction. Since TLR3 is localized in the intracellular compartment of DCs where signaling occurs, modified dsRNAs may compete with poly(I:C) for binding to the cell-surface receptor that transfers dsRNA into TLR3-enriched vesicles. Thus, TLR3 recognizes a unique dsRNA structure that largely differs from those recognized by other dsRNA-binding proteins.     

Binding of double-stranded RNA to protein kinase PKR is required for dimerization and promotes critical autophosphorylation events in the activation loop

Protein kinase PKR is activated by double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) and phosphorylates translation initiation factor 2alpha to inhibit protein synthesis in virus-infected mammalian cells. PKR contains two dsRNA binding motifs (DRBMs I and II) required for activation by dsRNA. There is strong evidence that PKR activation requires dimerization, but the role of dsRNA in dimer formation is controversial. By making alanine substitutions predicted to remove increasing numbers of side chain contacts between the DRBMs and dsRNA, we found that dimerization of full-length PKR in yeast was impaired by the minimal combinations of mutations required to impair dsRNA binding in vitro. Mutation of Ala-67 to Glu in DRBM-I, reported to abolish dimerization without affecting dsRNA binding, destroyed both activities in our assays. By contrast, deletion of a second dimerization region that overlaps the kinase domain had no effect on PKR dimerization in yeast. Human PKR contains at least 15 autophosphorylation sites, but only Thr-446 and Thr-451 in the activation loop were found here to be critical for kinase activity in yeast. Using an antibody specific for phosphorylated Thr-451, we showed that Thr-451 phosphorylation is stimulated by dsRNA binding. Our results provide strong evidence that dsRNA binding is required for dimerization of full-length PKR molecules in vivo, leading to autophosphorylation in the activation loop and stimulation of the eIF2alpha kinase function of PKR.     

The La antigen inhibits the activation of the interferon-inducible protein kinase PKR by sequestering and unwinding double-stranded RNA.

The La (SS-B) autoimmune antigen is an RNA-binding protein that is present in both nucleus and cytoplasm of eukaryotic cells. The spectrum of RNAs that interact with the La antigen includes species which also bind to the interferon-inducible protein kinase PKR. We have investigated whether the La antigen can regulate the activity of PKR and have observed that both the autophosphorylation of the protein kinase that accompanies its activation by dsRNA and the dsRNA-dependent phosphorylation of the alpha subunit of polypeptide chain initiation factor eIF-2 by PKR are inhibited in the presence of recombinant La antigen. This inhibition is partially relieved at higher concentrations of dsRNA. Once activated by dsRNA the protein kinase activity of PKR is insensitive to the La antigen. We have demonstrated by a filter binding assay that La is a dsRNA binding protein. Furthermore, when recombinant La is incubated with a 900 bp synthetic dsRNA or with naturally occurring reovirus dsRNA it converts these substrates to single-stranded forms. We conclude that the La antigen inhibits the dsRNA-dependent activation of PKR by binding and unwinding dsRNA and that it may therefore play a role in the regulation of this protein kinase in interferon-treated or virus-infected cells.     

Activation of the protein kinase PKR by short double-stranded RNAs with single-stranded tails

The human RNA-activated protein kinase PKR is an interferon-induced protein that is part of the innate immune response and inhibits viral replication. The action of PKR involves RNA-dependent autophosphorylation leading to inhibition of translation. PKR has an N-terminal dsRNA-binding domain that can interact non-sequence specifically with long (>33 bp) stretches of dsRNA leading to activation. In addition, certain viral and cellular RNAs containing non-Watson-Crick structures and multiple, shorter dsRNA sections can regulate PKR. In an effort to identify novel binders and possible activators of PKR, we carried out selections on a partially structured dsRNA library using truncated and full-length versions of PKR. A library with 10(11) sequences was constructed and aptamers that bound to His6-tagged proteins were isolated. Characterization revealed a novel minimal RNA motif for activation of PKR with the following unified structural characteristics: a hairpin with a nonconserved imperfect 16-bp dsRNA stem flanked by 10-15-nt single-stranded tails, herein termed a "ss-dsRNA motif." Boundary experiments revealed that the single-stranded tails flanking the dsRNA core provide the critical determinant for activation. The ss-dsRNA motif occurs in a variety of cellular and viral RNAs, suggesting possible novel functions for PKR in nature.     

Characterization of the direct physical interaction of nc886, a cellular non-coding RNA, and PKR

We have recently shown that nc886 (pre-miR-886 or vtRNA2-1) is not a genuine microRNA precursor nor a vault RNA, but a novel type of non-coding RNA that represses PKR, a double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) dependent kinase. Here we have characterized their direct physical association. PKR’s two RNA binding domains form a specific and stable complex with nc886’s central portion, without any preference to its 5′-end structure. By binding to PKR with a comparable affinity, nc886 competes with dsRNA and attenuates PKR activation by dsRNA. Our data suggest that nc886 sets a threshold for PKR activation so that it occurs only during genuine viral infection but not by a minute level of fortuitous cellular dsRNA.     

Monoclonal antibodies to double-stranded RNA as probes of RNA structure in crude nucleic acid extracts.

We describe four monoclonal antibodies (MAB) which specifically recognize double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) together with their use in new methods for detecting and characterizing dsRNA in unfractionated nucleic acid extracts. The specificity of the antibodies was analyzed using a panel of 27 different synthetic and naturally occurring nucleic acids. All four antibodies reacted in a highly specific manner with long dsRNA helices, irrespective of their sequence; no binding to single-stranded RNA homopolymers or to DNA or RNA-DNA hybrids was observed. The apparent affinity of the antibodies to short (less than or equal to 11 bp) RNA helices was very low in all test systems used: only background levels of binding were obtained on single-stranded RNA species which contain double-helical secondary structures (e.g. rRNA, tRNA, viroid RNA). A sandwich ELISA and a dsRNA-immunoblotting procedure have been established which allow detection and characterization of dsRNA by MAB even in the presence of a large excess of other nucleic acids. In combination with temperature-gradient gelelectrophoresis (TGGE) not only the molecular weights but also the highly characteristic Tm-values of conformational transitions of individual dsRNA species could be determined by immunoblotting. An example of the general use of these methods for the detection of plant virus infections is demonstrated with groundnut rosette virus (GRV) dsRNAs. We were able to estimate the dsRNA content of infected leaves, identify the dsRNA species present in crude extracts and to determine the Tm- values of GRV dsRNA-3.