Recent advances in three-dimensional multicellular spheroid culture for biomedical research

Many types of mammalian cells can aggregate and differentiate into 3-D multicellular spheroids when cultured in suspension or a nonadhesive environment. Compared to conventional monolayer cultures, multicellular spheroids resemble real tissues better in terms of structural and functional properties. Multicellular spheroids formed by transformed cells are widely used as avascular tumor models for metastasis and invasion research and for therapeutic screening. Many primary or progenitor cells on the other hand, show significantly enhanced viability and functional performance when grown as spheroids. Multicellular spheroids in this aspect are ideal building units for tissue reconstruction. Here we review the current understanding of multicellular spheroid formation mechanisms, their biomedical applications, and recent advances in spheroid culture, manipulation, and analysis techniques.     

Contact-mediated changes in cycloheximide-induced agglutinability of BHK cells

Suspension cultures of BHK cells grow in MEM supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum at about 50% the rate of corresponding monolayer cultures. If the serum supplement is reduced to 2% no increase in cell number is observed. When 10% serum is used small spheroids comprising 3–4 cells form within a 24 h period, but in 2 % serum the cells remain single over the same period. The addition of cycloheximide to contact-inhibited monolayer cultures induces high levels of ConA agglutinability within 6 h, yet growing non-confluent cells are rendered only about half as agglutinable by the same treatment. Cycloheximide treatment of suspension cultures causes growing cells to become agglutinable, but non-growing cells, which do not form spheroids, remain non-agglutinable even after 24 h of treatment. This suggests that the pronounced effect of cycloheximide on the agglutinability of contact-inhibited cells in monolayer culture reflects their confluence rather than suspended growth, and that the turnover rate of surface molecules determining the agglutinability state of cells is enhanced as cell-to-cell contact increases.     

Anchorage-independent colony formation of SV40 transformed BALB/c-3T3 cells in serum-free medium: role of cell- and serum-derived factors

The colony-forming response of SV40 transformed BALB/c-3T3 cells in agarose suspension culture was studied in a serum-free medium (with insulin, transferrin and serum albumin as the only macromolecular supplements) that was optimized for colony formation of fibronectin-attached monolayer cultures. In this serum-free medium, the SV3T3 cells fail to form colonies in agarose suspension. However, they can be induced to anchorage-independent colony formation by the growth factors that are additionally required by their untransformed counterparts for proliferation in monolayer culture. The SV3T3 cells are also rendered anchorage-independent for colony formation in serum-free medium by conditioned medium from dense monolayer serum-free SV3T3 cultures. These experiments suggest that it is the cell-substrate interaction that is responsible for the growth factor autonomy of fibronectin-attached transformed cells.     

Semliki forest virus-based expression for versatile use in receptor research

Semliki Forest virus (SFV) vectors have been generated for highly efficient studies on gene expression in a variety of mammalian host cells, including immortalized cell lines as well as primary cells in culture. Moreover, SFV expression has been scaled up for mammalian suspension cultures in spinner flasks and bioreactors for production of large quantities of recombinant proteins for drug screening and purification. The strong preference of expression in neuronal cells in primary cell cultures, in organotypic hippocampal slices and in vivo has made SFV vectors attractive for neurobiological studies. Additionally, the engineering of novel, less cytotoxic and temperature-sensitive SFV mutant vectors has further increased their application range.     

Changes in protein content per cell during growth of mouse L cells

The relationship between cell density and protein content per cell was examined in monolayer and suspension cultures of mouse L cells. In monolayer cultures, the protein content per cell reached a maximum at 6 h after plating and retained this level for 18 h. Thereafter, the protein content per cell declined gradually during the exponential growth phase and finally returned to the initial level at the stationary phase. The changes were neither due to the effect of trypsinization nor to the exhaustion of the medium. The protein content per cell in a sparse culture was always greater than that in a dense culture for monolayer culture of L cells. In suspension culture the increase of protein content per cell during the lag phase was similar to that found in monolayer cultures. However, the gradual decline of protein content per cell observed during the exponential phase of monolayer cultures was not detected during that of a suspension culture. The results suggest that the decrease of protein content per cell in monolayer cultures may be related to some function of cell plasma membrane which could be inhibited by a cell-to-cell contact.     

SEMLIKI FOREST VIRUS-BASED EXPRESSION FOR VERSATILE USE IN RECEPTOR RESEARCH

ABSTRACT

Semliki Forest virus (SFV) vectors have been generated for highly efficient studies on gene expression in a variety of mammalian host cells, including immortalized cell lines as well as primary cells in culture. Moreover, SFV expression has been scaled up for mammalian suspension cultures in spinner flasks and bioreactors for production of large quantities of recombinant proteins for drug screening and purification. The strong preference of expression in neuronal cells in primary cell cultures, in organotypic hippocampal slices and in vivo has made SFV vectors attractive for neurobiological studies. Additionally, the engineering of novel, less cytotoxic and temperature-sensitive SFV mutant vectors has further increased their application range.     

Comparison of different culture modes for long-term expansion of neural stem cells

Neural stem cells (NSCs) can be cultured in two modes of suspension and monolayer in vitro. The cultured cells are different in both the ability to proliferate and heterogeneity. In order to find the appropriate methods for large-scale expansion of NSCs, we systematically compared the NSCs cultured in suspension with those cultured in monolayer. The forebrain tissue was removed from embryonic day 14 (E14) mice, then the tissue was dissociated into single-cell suspension by Accutase and mechanical trituration. The cells were cultured in both suspension and monolayer. The NSCs cultured in suspension and in monolayer were compared on viability, ability to proliferate and heterogeneity by fluorescent dyes, immunofluorescence and flow cytometry on DIV21 (21 days in vitro), DIV56 and DIV112, respectively. The results indicated that the NSCs cultured in both suspension and monolayer represented good viability in long-term cultures. But they displayed a distinct ability to proliferate in long-term cultures. The NSCs cultured in monolayer preceded those cultured in suspension on the ability to proliferate on DIV21 and DIV56, but no obvious difference on DIV112. The NSCs population cultured in suspension displayed more nestin-positive cells than those in monolayer during the whole process of culture. The NSCs population cultured in monolayer, however, displayed more βIII tubulin-positive cells than those in suspension in the same period. The suspension culture mode excels the monolayer culture mode for large-scale expansion of NSCs.     

Screening drug effects in patient‐derived cancer cells links organoid responses to genome alterations

Cancer drug screening in patient‐derived cells holds great promise for personalized oncology and drug discovery but lacks standardization. Whether cells are cultured as conventional monolayer or advanced, matrix‐dependent organoid cultures influences drug effects and thereby drug selection and clinical success. To precisely compare drug profiles in differently cultured primary cells, we developed DeathPro, an automated microscopy‐based assay to resolve drug‐induced cell death and proliferation inhibition. Using DeathPro, we screened cells from ovarian cancer patients in monolayer or organoid culture with clinically relevant drugs. Drug‐induced growth arrest and efficacy of cytostatic drugs differed between the two culture systems. Interestingly, drug effects in organoids were more diverse and had lower therapeutic potential. Genomic analysis revealed novel links between drug sensitivity and DNA repair deficiency in organoids that were undetectable in monolayers. Thus, our results highlight the dependency of cytostatic drugs and pharmacogenomic associations on culture systems, and guide culture selection for drug tests.     

Effect of stromal fibroblasts on antibody formation in cultures deficient in A-cells]

Stromal fibroblasts from the monolayer cultures of the rabbit thymus, spleen, and bone marrow when added to suspension cultures of non-adherent rabbit spleen cells had a significant effect on the response of the plaque-forming cells (PFC). Thymus-derived stromal fibroblasts caused an increase in the number of PFC, and bone marrow stromal fibroblasts suppressed the antibody formation in these cultures. Spleen-derived stromal fibroblasts influenced the PFC response similarly to adherent cells. Thymus-derived stromal fibroblasts irradiated by 5000 R influenced the PFC response in the same way as non-irradiated cells. The action of stromal fibroblasts on the antibody formation in the cultures depended on their attachment to the culture flask surface.     

Control of rat C6 glioma cell proliferation: uncoupling of the inhibitory effects of hydrocortisone hormone in suspension and monolayer cultures

We undertook a comparative study of the effects of the hormone hydrocortisone (Hy) on C6 glioma cells grown in monolayer and in suspension in cultures. We found Hy reversibly renders C6 cells anchorage- and serum-dependent for their growth. In monolayer cultures, Hy was found to inhibit cell cycle traversing exclusively at G1 phase. In agarose suspension, Hy was found to block colony development. Hy-resistant variants were selected and isolated in agarose suspension. Examination of these variants showed that cells selected for Hy-resistance in suspension can be Hy sensitive when anchored to a solid substrate. We conclude that resistance to Hy in suspension and resistance to it in monolayer culture are two independent phenotypes.     

Establishment and characterization of an in vitro 3D ovarian cancer model for drug screening assays

The acquired drug chemoresistance represents the main challenge of the ovarian cancer treatment. In addition, the absence of an adequate in vitro model able to reproduce the native tumor environment can contribute to the poor success rate of pre-clinical studies of new compounds. Three-dimensional (3D) culture models have been recently used for drug screening purposes due to their ability to reproduce the main characteristics of in vivo solid tumors. Here we describe the establishment and characterization of 3D ovarian cancer spheroids using different adenocarcinoma tumor cell lines (SKOV-3 and OVCAR-3 cells) in two different 3D scaffold-free methods: forced-floating in ultra-low attachment (ULA) plates and hanging drop (HD). Spheroids were evaluated in both 3D cultures in order to establish the best condition to perform the drug response analysis with Paclitaxel, a common drug used to treat ovarian cancer. SKOV-3 and OVCAR-3 spheroids with the desired characteristics (roundness close to 1.0 and diameter in the 200–500 μm range) were obtained using both methods after addition of the methylcellulose (MC) in the culture medium (0.25% and 0.5%, w/v). We also observed the presence of microvilli on the surface of the spheroids, higher presence of apoptotic cells and higher drug resistance, when compared with 2D cultures. The 3D cultures obtained seem to provide more reliable results in terms of drug response than those provided by 2D monolayer culture. The forced floating method was considered more suitable and straightforward to generate ovarian cancer spheroids for drug screening/cytotoxicity assays.     

Increased thermoresistance developed during growth of small multicellular spheroids

Mammalian cells growing as multicell spheroids, an in vitro model of tumor microregions, have been shown previously to be more resistant than single cells from monolayer cultures to killing by ionizing radiation, hyperthermia, ultrasound, and chemotherapeutic drugs. Although the mechanisms by which cells in spheroids acquire these increased resistances are unknown, available evidence has indicated that intercellular contact mediates the process for ionizing radiation. This investigation was undertaken to evaluate the role of intercellular contact produced during growth of small spheroids on the sensitivity of EMT6/Ro mouse mammary tumor cells to moderate hyperthermia. Increased thermoresistance developed in small spheroids (approximately 70 micron diameter, 25 cells/spheroid), as measured by colony formation, after exposures to different temperatures in the range of 37 to 45 degrees C for periods less than or equal to 2 hr and at 42.5 degrees C for less than or equal to 8 hr. Experiments were performed to determine the relative contributions to this increased thermoresistance of 1) the extent of intercellular contact in spheroids of different cellular multiplicities, 2) differences in membrane damage influenced by trypsin heat treatment sequence, and 3) physiological changes associated with growth of cells as spheroids in suspension compared to monolayer culture. Treatment with trypsin prior to heating sensitized cells to killing by hyperthermia but did not account for the differential thermoresistance between cells from spheroids and monolayers. Spheroid multiplicity in the range of 1.16 to 76.2 cells/spheroid had no significant effect on cell survival after hyperthermia. However, cells grown in spinner suspension culture were more thermoresistant than cells from monolayer cultures and nearly as thermoresistant as cells in spheroids. From these data we conclude that the greater thermoresistance of EMT/Ro cells in spheroids is the result of cellular physiological changes associated with growth in suspension and is not mediated by intercellular contact.     

Difference in transport of leucine in attached and suspended 3T3 cells.

3T3 cells in subconfluent culture take up leucine through a transport system which has a relatively high affinity for leucine (M system). When the culture becomes confluent, the M system is turned off and leucine is transported by another system which has a low affinity for leucine (S system). The M system is reactivated by transferring the cells into subconfluent cultures. In suspension cultures 3T3 cells, initiated from confluent cultures, the M system is not activated and leucine is transported by the S system. In cells suspended from subconfluent culture, the M system continues to operate at a high level for four hours and then is gradually turned off. Tumor virus transformed 3T3 cells (SV3T3 and Py3T3) grow quite well in suspension culture and transport leucine both in monolayer and suspension through a high affinity system, with a high Vmax value. A derivative of 3T3, 3T3/41, which grows in suspension much more slowly than tumor virus transformed 3T3 cells, also takes up leucine through a high affinity transport system both in monolayer and suspension but its Vmax value is lower than that of the transformed cells.     

The use of 3-D cultures for high-throughput screening: the multicellular spheroid model

Over the past few years, establishment and adaptation of cell-based assays for drug development and testing has become an important topic in high-throughput screening (HTS). Most new assays are designed to rapidly detect specific cellular effects reflecting action at various targets. However, although more complex than cell-free biochemical test systems, HTS assays using monolayer or suspension cultures still reflect a highly artificial cellular environment and may thus have limited predictive value for the clinical efficacy of a compound. Today's strategies for drug discovery and development, be they hypothesis free or mechanism based, require facile, HTS-amenable test systems that mimic the human tissue environment with increasing accuracy in order to optimize preclinical and preanimal selection of the most active molecules from a large pool of potential effectors, for example, against solid tumors. Indeed, it is recognized that 3-dimensional cell culture systems better reflect the in vivo behavior of most cell types. However, these 3-D test systems have not yet been incorporated into mainstream drug development operations. This article addresses the relevance and potential of 3-D in vitro systems for drug development, with a focus on screening for novel antitumor drugs. Examples of 3-D cell models used in cancer research are given, and the advantages and limitations of these systems of intermediate complexity are discussed in comparison with both 2-D culture and in vivo models. The most commonly used 3-D cell culture systems, multicellular spheroids, are emphasized due to their advantages and potential for rapid development as HTS systems. Thus, multicellular tumor spheroids are an ideal basis for the next step in creating HTS assays, which are predictive of in vivo antitumor efficacy.     

Glial shape and cytoskeletal protein synthesis

We investigated whether the shape of astroglial derived cells influences the expression of cytoskeletal proteins. In reaggregating cultures GFAP, vimentin and actin synthesis was approximately 52%, 50% and 37% the level found in monolayer cultures, respectively. Monolayer cultures consisted of polygonal shaped cells adhering to plastic, while reaggregating cultures were comprised of round cells growing in a suspension like culture. Additionally, human glioma cells induced to grow as round cells on poly-2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (polyhema) coated plastic exhibited a level of GFAP synthesis that was approximately 20% the level displayed by polygonal shaped cells grown on uncoated plastic. Glioma cells initially grown on a polyhema surface and replated onto uncoated plastic were capable of reinitiating GFAP synthesis. Thus, aterations in the synthesis of GFAP and other cytoskeletal proteins can occur when astrocytes change their shape.     

Growth of the IB-RS-2 Pig Kidney Cell Line in Suspension Culture and Its Susceptibility to Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus

The adaptation of the pig kidney cell line IB-RS-2, clone 60, to growth in suspension culture is described. When fully adapted, an approximate threefold increase in viable cells was obtained within 72 hr from initial cell concentrations of 5 x 10(5) per ml in culture volumes up to 1,500 ml. The monolayer cells (99th passage level) used to initiate the suspension cultures and the fully adapted suspension cells were shown to have an aneuploid chromosome karyotype, whereas earlier monolayer cultures (32nd passage level) had a pseudodiploid karyotype. Replicate virus titrations in monolayers prepared from suspension-adapted cells, IB-RS-2 monolayer cells, BHK monolayer cells, and in suckling mice showed that the suspension cells had retained sensitivity to foot-and-mouth disease virus. The geometric mean peak infectivity of seven strains of foot-and-mouth disease virus grown in IB-RS-2 suspension cells was 10(8.2) plaque-forming units per ml, with a mean complement-fixing activity of approximately 135 complement-fixing units per ml. These preliminary results indicate that submerged cultures of these cells on an industrial scale may be useful for commercial foot-and-mouth disease vaccine production.     

Comparative study of in vitro expansion of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells

Bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BMD-MSCs) are of great interest for tissue engineering, but require expansion before they can be used for therapeutic applications. We compared three different culture techniques for their potential for large scale expansion of rat BMD-MSCs, i.e. monolayer cultures, stirred suspension cultures and pour-off cultures, and found that pour-off cultures supported the biggest expansion in BMD-MSCs as measured by the fibroblastic-colony forming unit assay (CFU-f). BMD-MSCs expanded in stirred suspension cultures stopped proliferating altogether and, although monolayer cultures allowed for expansion of BMD-MSCs, they favoured a differentiated phenotype over uncommitted MSCs. Only BMD-MSCs expanded in pour-off cultures were able to differentiate into both osteoblastic and adipocytic lineages and maintain CFU-f numbers. These data suggest that pour-off cultures are a viable method of BMD-MSC expansion.     

Increased yield of mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) by cultivation of monolayer-derived mammary tumor cells in suspension

Summary The MJY-alpha epithelial-like mammary tumor cell line was adapted for cultivation in suspension using a shaker culture technique. Replication of suspension (MJY-beta) cells was more sensitive than monolayer cells to decreases in the concentration of serum in the medium. Comparison of amino acid incoerporation and lactate production rates revealed additional differences between monolayer and suspension cultures. In addition, growth in susfpension resulted in 10- to 400-fold increases in mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) production by the mammary tumor cells. Incrases in MMTV yield were detected within 48 h of culture initiation and MMTV production remained elevated throughout 20 cell passages in suspension. Exposure of MJY-beta cells to 14 μM hydrocorticone further increased MMTV yield two-to five-fold. The MJY-beta suspension cultures demonstrated that these epithelial-like cells do not require attachment to a solid substrate for replication or for MMTV production. Loss of structural polarization associated with growth as a monolayer resulted in stimulation of MMTV production greater than and independent of steroid exposure. This work was supported by the T. J. Martell Foundation for Cancer and Leukemia Research and by USPHS grant 5P-30CA23102. F. M. is a trainee on MSTP grant GM07280 from the National Institute of Health. This work was submitted in partial fullfillment of the requirements for the Ph. D. degree (F. M.).     

The role of p21cip1 in adaptation of CHO cells to suspension and protein-free culture

The up-regulation of cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p21 has been shown to enhance productivity of monoclonal antibodies and has been linked to various regulatory processes. To identify the potential role of p21 in adaptation to suspension and protein-free cultures, we studied the survival and growth of anchorage- and serum-dependent CHO cell lines that differed only in the period of p21-induced arrest. p21 overexpression led to rapid adaptation of cells to suspension and protein-free cultures. The period taken to achieve adaptation was correlated with the time the cells were arrested after transfer from the monolayer and serum-fed culture. Interestingly, cell aggregation associated with protein-free suspension culture was reduced in p21 culture in response to the loss of cellular adherence. The processes of adaptation to suspension and arrest did not decrease monoclonal antibody productivity. In contrast, following adaptation to protein-free growth media, an overall increase in specific productivity was observed. The ability of cells to survive in protein-free suspension cultures was due to the requirement of G1 cells to growth factors and to their relatively high resistance to the hydrodynamic forces. This improved process has the advantage of reducing the duration of critical path activity for developing CHO commercial cell lines from 72 to 36 days.     

A rapid assay for fusion of embryonic chick myoblasts

A rapid and sensitive assay for measuring myoblast fusion in suspension cultures of embryonic chick pectoral myoblasts is described. Fusion-competent cells are generated by growth in suspension using a low calcium medium. Fusion-promoting levels of calcium are added, and the suspensions incubated for 1–6 h. The cells are then trypsinized to disperse cellular aggregates and sized in a Coulter particle counter. This assay minimizes many of the artifacts inherent in measurements of fusion in monolayer cultures, and is designed for the rapid screening of agents for their effects on fusion.