共查询到20条相似文献,搜索用时 31 毫秒
1.
Anna Moreno Francesca Cappellaro Paolo Masoni Anna Amato 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2011,15(4):483-495
Applications of information and communications technology (ICT) for the management of environmental data, if used during the design and at the end of the product life cycle, can improve the environmental performance of products. This specific application of ICT for data management is called product data technology (PDT) and is based on the use of international standards developed by ISO TC184/SC4. PDT enables the computerized representations of information about products, processes, and their properties that are independent of any proprietary computer system or software application. The standard product data models are designed to integrate the necessary information about materials used in the product, and such information can be accessed and used at any point in the life cycle, from design to disposal. In the article, we present how PDT can support life cycle assessment (LCA) by focusing on a series of standards for communicating data for design and manufacture and standards for business and commercial information. Examples of possibilities for using PDT and semantic web for LCA data are introduced. The findings presented here are based on DEPUIS (Design of Environmentally‐Friendly Products Using Information Standards), a project aimed at improving the eco‐design of new products and services through the innovative use of new information standards. 相似文献
2.
Many authors have agreed on the interest of considering environmental concerns in the early stages of product development. However, most eco‐design tools are based on life cycle assessment principles and require a model to give information about the product's environmental performance. This modeling can have negative effects on team performance and on the potential for innovation, not to mention on the project's duration. Additionally, the model requires information that is not available in the early design stages. This article analyzes the potential of inferring conclusions about the life cycle stages with the highest impact by using similar products. From a database of previous products, environmental profile estimations are carried out, that is, the assessments of the contribution of each life cycle stage to the total impact and the variability of this measure. It is then possible to discard—or ensure consideration of—life cycle stages. Furthermore, the level of the conclusions is assessed on a five‐point scale. The proposed approach is applied to four case studies with different levels of abstraction and the relevance of the conclusions is assessed. The article resolves the problems regarding potential for estimating the distribution of the environmental impacts along the life cycle. 相似文献
3.
Environmental Life Cycle Costing and Sustainability: Insights from Pollution Abatement and Resource Recovery in Wastewater Treatment
下载免费PDF全文
![点击此处可从《Journal of Industrial Ecology》网站下载免费的PDF全文](/ch/ext_images/free.gif)
The relationship between environmental life cycle costing (ELCC) and sustainability was explored using two detailed wastewater case studies. The case studies were selected to increase the tension between existing market values and values for sustainability; the first case study considered incremental change to an existing plant and the second considered a paradigm shift in wastewater treatment. Pollution control provided the greatest cost savings for the first case study and provided a “win‐win” result—meeting existing standards and saving money. However, benefits for pollution control beyond current standards were not captured, which emphasized the role of standards to internalize as well as limit the values considered in ELCC. In the second case study, the value of water had the potential to change the focus of wastewater design from pollution abatement to resource recovery. However, social acceptance of recovered water and market access for resources created large risk for investment. The ELCC was also sensitive to the discount rate which limited longer‐term considerations. Other sustainability values such as scarcity and ecological thresholds were not captured. The ELCC code of practice suggests including such costs if likely in the foreseeable future; defining these values may also clarify the role of ELCC to evaluate sustainability over the life cycle. 相似文献
4.
Stefano Cucurachi Coen C. van der Giesen Reinout Heijungs Geert R. de Snoo 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2017,21(1):70-81
The portfolio of impacts that are quantified in life cycle assessment (LCA) has grown to include rather different stressors than those that were the focus of early LCAs. Some of the newest life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) models are still in an early phase of development and have not yet been included in any LCA study. This is the case for sound emissions and noise impacts, which have been only recently modeled. Sound emissions are matter‐less, time dependent, and bound to the physical properties of waves. The way sound emissions and the relative noise impacts are modeled in LCA can show how new or existing matter‐less impacts can be addressed. In this study, we analyze, through the example of sound emissions, the specific features of a matter‐less impact that does not stem from the use of a kilogram of matter, nor is related to the emission of a kilogram of matter. We take as a case study the production of energy by means of wind turbines, contradicting the commonly held assumption that windmills have no emissions during use. We show how to account for sound emissions in the life cycle inventory phase of the life cycle of a wind turbine and then calculate the relative impacts using a noise LCIA model. 相似文献
5.
Gregor Wernet Christopher Mutel Stefanie Hellweg Konrad Hungerbühler 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2011,15(1):96-107
In many cases, policy makers and laymen perceive harmful emissions from chemical plants as the most important source of environmental impacts in chemical production. As a result, regulations and environmental efforts have tended to focus on this area. Concerns about energy use and greenhouse gas emissions, however, are increasing in all industrial sectors. Using a life cycle assessment (LCA) approach, we analyzed the full environmental impacts of producing 99 chemical products in Western Europe from cradle to factory gate. We applied several life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) methods to cover various impact areas. Our analysis shows that for both organic and inorganic chemical production in industrial countries, energy‐related impacts often represent more than half and sometimes up to 80% of the total impacts, according to a range of LCIA methods. Resource use for material feedstock is also important, whereas direct emissions from chemical plants may make up only 5% to 10% of the total environmental impacts. Additionally, the energy‐related impacts of organic chemical production increase with the complexity of the chemicals. The results of this study offer important information for policy makers and sustainability experts in the chemical industry striving to reduce environmental impacts. We identify more sustainable energy production and use as an important option for improvements in the environmental profile of chemical production in industrial countries, especially for the production of advanced organic and fine chemicals. 相似文献
6.
Steel‐versus‐Concrete Debate Revisited: Global Warming Potential and Embodied Energy Analyses based on Attributional and Consequential Life Cycle Perspectives
下载免费PDF全文
![点击此处可从《Journal of Industrial Ecology》网站下载免费的PDF全文](/ch/ext_images/free.gif)
《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2017,21(1):82-100
In the study of sustainable building materials, the comparison of the life cycle environmental performance of steel and reinforced concrete has been a popular and important topic. Based in Singapore, this is one of the first studies in the literature that applies both attributional and consequential life cycle approaches to compare the global warming potential and embodied energies of these two materials, which are widely used for the structural parts of buildings. It was found that 1 kilogram (kg) of steel can be replaced by 1 or 4.25 kg of reinforced concrete. Two consequential scenarios for each of three combinations of primary and secondary steel were assessed. It was found that reinforced concrete produces less carbon dioxide emissions and incurs less embodied energy in most of these cases, but when different sustainable primary steel‐making technologies were incorporated, these results may be reversed. We applied consequential life cycle assessment and scenario analysis to describe how changes in the demand for structural steel and reinforced concrete in Singapore's building industry give rise to different environmental impacts. Specifically, the consequential life cycle approach revealed that, over the short term, the impact of substituting steel with reinforced concrete depends on the difference in impacts resulting from the transportation of these two materials within Singapore. Based on these lessons, integrated technology policies to improve the overall sustainability of using steel for construction were proposed. 相似文献
7.
For the practical implementation of the assessment of environmental impact, actual procedures and data requirements should be clarified so that industrial decision makers understand them. Researchers should consider local risks related to processes and environmental impact throughout the life cycle of products simultaneously to supervise these adverse effects appropriately. Life cycle assessment (LCA) is a useful tool for quantifying the potential impact associated with a product life cycle. Risk assessment (RA) is a widely used tool for identifying chemical risks in a specific situation. In this study, we integrate LCA and RA for risk‐based decision making by devising a hierarchical activity model using the type‐zero method of integrated definition language (IDEF0). The IDEF0 activity modeling language has been applied to connect activities with information flows. Process generation, evaluation, and decision making are logically defined and visualized in the activity model with the required information. The activities, information flows, and their acquisitions are revealed, with a focus on which data should be collected by on‐site engineers. A case study is conducted on designing a metal cleaning process reducing chemical risks due to the use of a cleansing agent. LCA and RA are executed and applied effectively on the basis of integrated objective settings and interpretation. The proposed activity model can be used as a foundation to incorporate such assessments into actual business models. 相似文献
8.
David Hunkeler 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2006,11(6):371-382
Background, Aim and Scope
Societal assessment is advocated as one of the three pillars in the evaluation of, and movement toward, sustainability. As
is the case with the well established LCA, and the emerging LCC, societal life cycle assessment should be developed in such
as way as to permit relative product comparisons, rather than absolute analyses. The development of societal life cycle assessment
is in its infancy, and important concepts require clarification including the handling of the more than two hundred social
indicators. Therefore, any societal life cycle assessment methodology must explain why it is midpoint- or endpoint-based as
well as its reasons to be complimentary with, or included within, life cycle assessment.
Materials and Methods:
A geographically specific midpoint based societal life cycle assessment methodology, which employs labour hours as an intermediate
variable in the calculation has been developed and evaluated against an existing LCA comparing two detergents. The methodology
is based on using an existing life cycle inventory and, therefore, has identical system boundaries and functional units to
LCA. The societal life cycle assessment methodology, much like LCA, passes from inventory, through characterisation factors,
to provide an ultimate result. In analogy to economics and cost estimation, societal life cycle assessment combines, into
its statistics, both data as well as estimates, some of which are correlated to elements of the LCI. It focuses on the work
hours required to meet basic needs.A geographically specific midpoint based societal life cycle assessment methodology, which
employs labour hours as an intermediate variable in the calculation has been developed and evaluated against an existing LCA
comparing two detergents. The methodology is based on using an existing life cycle inventory and, therefore, has identical
system boundaries and functional units to LCA. The societal life cycle assessment methodology, much like LCA, passes from
inventory, through characterisation factors, to provide an ultimate result. In analogy to economics and cost estimation, societal
life cycle assessment combines, into its statistics, both data as well as estimates, some of which are correlated to elements
of the LCI. It focuses on the work hours required to meet basic needs.
Results:
The societal life cycle assessment of an appended case study indicates that Detergent 2 generates, relative Detergent 1, approximately
20% less employment in Russia, 35% less in France, and approximately five times more in Canada and South Africa, the latter
derived from its higher aluminium content. There is essentially no difference in the employment in the use country (Switzerland)
nor in Morocco, where some of the waste disposal was assumed to take place.
Discussion:
Given that housing is more affordable, in terms of shelter units per labour hour, in South Africa, compared to Europe, it
is, therefore, of no surprise that Detergent 2 provides a societal benefit in terms of housing. Detergent 2 does, however,
result in dematerialization, in that its environmental impact is lower (LCI). Therefore, as less resources are employed and
labour required, in extraction, production and transport, the societal benefits in health care, education and necessities,
a grouped variable, are lower for Detergent 2. This is despite the employment shift away from Europe and to less 'developed'
regions.
Conclusions:
The assessment of societal impacts involves several hundred specific indicators. Therefore, aggregation is, if not impossible,
at least heavily value laden and, therefore, not recommended. The impact of a societal action, derived from a product purchase
or otherwise, is also highly local. Given this, societal life cycle assessment, carried through to the midpoints, and based
on an existing LCI, has been developed as a methodology. The results, for an existing LCA-detergent case, illustrate that
societal life cycle assessment provides a means to investigate how policy and policy makers can be linked to sustainable development.
The sensitivity analyses also clarify the decisions in regards to product improvement.
Recommendations and Perspectives:
The goal of societal life cycle assessment is not to make decisions, but rather to point out tradeoffs to decision- or policy-makers.
This case, and the methodology that it is based on, permit such a comparison. Substituting Detergent 2 for Detergent 1 reduces
resource use at the expense of an increase in atmospheric and terrestrial emissions. Access to housing is improved, though
at the expense of education, health care and necessities. As a recommendation, one would look at the fact that the majority
of indicators are superior for Detergent 2 relative to Detergent 1and seek to improve the aqueous emissions in Detergent 2
via a change in the formulation. An energy or fossil fuel substitution at the site of production could also improve the societal
benefits in terms of education and health care.
While societal life cycle assessment remains in its infancy, a methodology does exist. The field can, therefore, be viewed
in a similar way to LCA in the early 1990s, with a need to validate, consolidate and, ultimately, built toward a standard.
The contribution is aimed at contributing to such a discussion and therefore proposes that a societal life cycle assessment
be LCI-derived, geographically specific, based on mid-points, and use employment as an intermediate variable. 相似文献
9.
Background, Goal and Scope The research presented here represents one part of GlaxoSmithKline’s (GSK) efforts to identify and improve the life cycle
impact profile of pharmaceutical products. The main goal of this work was to identify and analyze the cradle-to-gate environmental
impacts in the synthesis of a typical Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient (API). A cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment of a
commercial pharmaceutical product is presented as a case study.
Methods Life cycle inventory data were obtained using a modular gate-to-gate methodology developed in partnership with North Carolina
State University (NCSU) while the impact assessment was performed utilizing GSK’s sustainability metrics methodology.
Results and Discussion Major contributors to the environmental footprint of a typical pharmaceutical product were identified. The results of this
study indicate that solvent use accounts for a majority of the potential cradle-to-gate impacts associated with the manufacture
of the commercial pharmaceutical product under study. If spent solvent is incinerated instead of recovered the life-cycle
profile and impacts are considerably increased.
Conclusions This case study provided GSK with key insights into the life-cycle impacts of pharmaceutical products. It also helped to establish
a well-documented approach to using life cycle within GSK and fostered the development of a practical methodology that is
applicable to strategic decision making, internal business processes and other processes and tools. 相似文献
10.
Implementing a Dynamic Life Cycle Assessment Methodology with a Case Study on Domestic Hot Water Production
下载免费PDF全文
![点击此处可从《Journal of Industrial Ecology》网站下载免费的PDF全文](/ch/ext_images/free.gif)
Didier Beloin‐Saint‐Pierre Annie Levasseur Manuele Margni Isabelle Blanc 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2017,21(5):1128-1138
This work contributes to the development of a dynamic life cycle assessment (DLCA) methodology by providing a methodological framework to link a dynamic system modeling method with a time‐dependent impact assessment method. This three‐step methodology starts by modeling systems where flows are described by temporal distributions. Then, a temporally differentiated life cycle inventory (TDLCI) is calculated to present the environmental exchanges through time. Finally, time‐dependent characterization factors are applied to the TDLCI to evaluate climate‐change impacts through time. The implementation of this new framework is illustrated by comparing systems producing domestic hot water (DHW) over an 80‐year period. Electricity is used to heat water in the first system, whereas the second system uses a combination of solar energy and gas to heat an equivalent amount of DHW at the same temperature. This comparison shows that using a different temporal precision (i.e., monthly vs. annual) to describe process flows can reverse conclusions regarding which case has the best environmental performance. Results also show that considering the timing of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduces the absolute values of carbon footprint in the short‐term when compared with results from the static life cycle assessment. This pragmatic framework for the implementation of time in DLCA studies is proposed to help in the development of the methodology. It is not yet a fully operational scheme, and efforts are still required before DLCA can become state of practice. 相似文献
11.
Rajesh Mehta Milad Golkaram Jack T. W. E. Vogels Tom Ligthart Eugene Someren Spela Ferjan Jelmer Lennartz 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2023,27(5):1266-1276
To achieve climate neutrality ambitions, greenhouse gas emissions from the transport sector need to be reduced by at least 90% by 2050. To support industry and policy makers on mitigating actions on climate goals it is important to holistically compare and reduce life cycle environmental impacts of road passenger vehicles. A web-based sustainability assessment tool named battery electric vehicle sustainability impact assessment model, BEVSIM, is developed to assess the environmental, circularity, and economic performance of the materials, sub-systems, parts, and individual components of battery electric vehicles and internal combustion engine vehicles. This tool allows to measure and compare impacts resulting from recycling technologies, end-of-life scenarios, and future scenarios resulting from changes in grid mixes. This paper explains the purpose of the tool, its functionality and design as well as the underlying assumptions. 相似文献
12.
生命周期管理研究述评 总被引:3,自引:2,他引:3
生命周期管理起源于生命周期思想,它是生命周期思想在实践中的具体应用,是面向可持续生产和消费,对产品、工艺和服务的全生命周期环境影响进行的综合管理,是解决复合生态系统中结构无序、效率不高和代谢冗余的有效途径,是基于生命周期评价原则与框架的一种环境管理手段或环境管理体系。全面回顾了生命周期管理的起源与内涵,阐述了生命周期管理与生命周期评价的区别与联系,梳理了生命周期管理与环境管理体系的关系。对生命周期管理在产品、企业、行业及城市等层次上的具体应用进行了总结与述评,并对其今后需深入研究的方向进行了展望。 相似文献
13.
Pere Fullana i Palmer Rita Puig Alba Bala Grau Baquero Jordi Riba Marco Raugei 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2011,15(3):458-475
Life cycle assessment (LCA) is a widely accepted methodology to support decision‐making processes in which one compares alternatives, and that helps prevent shifting of environmental burdens along the value chain or among impact categories. According to regulation in the European Union (EU), the movement of waste needs to be reduced and, if unavoidable, the environmental gain from a specific waste treatment option requiring transport must be larger than the losses arising from transport. The EU explicitly recommends the use of LCA or life cycle thinking for the formulation of new waste management plans. In the last two revisions of the Industrial Waste Management Programme of Catalonia (PROGRIC), the use of a life cycle thinking approach to waste policy was mandated. In this article we explain the process developed to arrive at practical life cycle management (LCM) from what started as an LCA project. LCM principles we have labeled the “3/3” principle or the “good enough is best” principle were found to be essential to obtain simplified models that are easy to understand for legislators and industries, useful in waste management regulation, and, ultimately, feasible. In this article, we present the four models of options for the management of waste solvent to be addressed under Catalan industrial waste management regulation. All involved actors concluded that the models are sufficiently robust, are easy to apply, and accomplish the aim of limiting the transport of waste outside Catalonia, according to the principles of proximity and sufficiency. 相似文献
14.
Effects of Distribution Choice on the Modeling of Life Cycle Inventory Uncertainty: An Assessment on the Ecoinvent v2.2 Database
下载免费PDF全文
![点击此处可从《Journal of Industrial Ecology》网站下载免费的PDF全文](/ch/ext_images/free.gif)
Stéphanie Muller Christopher Mutel Pascal Lesage Réjean Samson 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2018,22(2):300-313
Life cycle inventory data have multiple sources of uncertainty. These data uncertainties are often modeled using probability density functions, and in the ecoinvent database the lognormal distribution is used by default to model exchange uncertainty values. The aim of this article is to systematically measure the effect of this default distribution by changing from the lognormal to several other distribution functions and examining how this change affects the uncertainty of life cycle assessment results. Using the ecoinvent 2.2 inventory database, data uncertainty distributions are switched from the lognormal distribution to the normal, triangular, and gamma distributions. The effect of the distribution switching is assessed for both impact assessment results of individual products system, as well as comparisons between product systems. Impact assessment results are generated using 5,000 Monte Carlo iterations for each product system, using the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) 2001 (100‐year time frame) method. When comparing the lognormal distribution to the alternative default distributions, the difference in the resulting median and standard deviation values range from slight to significant, depending on the distributions used by default. However, the switch shows practically no effect on product system comparisons. Yet, impact assessment results are sensitive to how the data uncertainties are defined. In this article, we followed what we believe to be ecoinvent standard practice and preserved the “most representative” value. Practitioners should recognize that the most representative value can depart from the average of a probability distribution. Consistent default distribution choices are necessary when performing product system comparisons. 相似文献
15.
16.
Martin C. Heller Susan E. M. Selke Gregory A. Keoleian 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2019,23(2):480-495
Scrutiny of food packaging environmental impacts has led to a variety of sustainability directives, but has largely focused on the direct impacts of materials. A growing awareness of the impacts of food waste warrants a recalibration of packaging environmental assessment to include the indirect effects due to influences on food waste. In this study, we model 13 food products and their typical packaging formats through a consistent life cycle assessment framework in order to demonstrate the effect of food waste on overall system greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and cumulative energy demand (CED). Starting with food waste rate estimates from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, we calculate the effect on GHG emissions and CED of a hypothetical 10% decrease in food waste rate. This defines a limit for increases in packaging impacts from innovative packaging solutions that will still lead to net system environmental benefits. The ratio of food production to packaging production environmental impact provides a guide to predicting food waste effects on system performance. Based on a survey of the food LCA literature, this ratio for GHG emissions ranges from 0.06 (wine example) to 780 (beef example). High ratios with foods such as cereals, dairy, seafood, and meats suggest greater opportunity for net impact reductions through packaging‐based food waste reduction innovations. While this study is not intended to provide definitive LCAs for the product/package systems modeled, it does illustrate both the importance of considering food waste when comparing packaging alternatives, and the potential for using packaging to reduce overall system impacts by reducing food waste. 相似文献
17.
Longitudinal Analysis of the Eco‐Design Management Standardization Process in Furniture Companies
下载免费PDF全文
![点击此处可从《Journal of Industrial Ecology》网站下载免费的PDF全文](/ch/ext_images/free.gif)
Beñat Landeta‐Manzano Germán Arana‐Landín Patxi RuizdeArbulo Pablo DíazdeBasurto 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2017,21(5):1356-1369
This article discusses how eco‐design management standards have been adopted and the environmental and economic results that have been obtained by the Spanish furniture manufacturers. This is precisely the industry sector in Spain where the dissemination of eco‐design standards has been most important. Using multiple case‐study methodology, the research has shown that, in three companies, more than 90% of the environmental impact of the companies’ products occurs within the manufacturing phase. Companies have implemented tools for life cycle assessment with eco‐indicators values that allow them to assess complex products and evaluate their significant environmental impacts at each stage. The environmental strategies of these companies are based on the continuous improvement of the internal processes and the review and monitoring of their activities. In this approach, the proper choice of materials and the environmental management of the supply chain are the main problems for companies. The outcomes achieved by the companies included some improvements, such as a greater control of product management and a reduction in operating costs, that have allowed them to obtain competitive advantages. Moreover, the adoption of standard management has enabled the companies to drive innovation of products, improve the image of companies and their products, significantly reduce the environmental impact of their products, and adapt to new, more demanding environmental laws and regulations. 相似文献
18.
Addressing the Life Cycle of Sewers in Contrasting Cities through an Eco‐Efficiency Approach
下载免费PDF全文
![点击此处可从《Journal of Industrial Ecology》网站下载免费的PDF全文](/ch/ext_images/free.gif)
Anna Petit‐Boix Carla Arnal Desirée Marín Alejandro Josa Xavier Gabarrell Joan Rieradevall 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2018,22(5):1092-1104
Evaluating the sustainability of the urban water cycle is not straightforward, although a variety of methods have been proposed. Given the lack of integrated data about sewers, we applied the eco‐efficiency approach to two case studies located in Spain with contrasting climate, population, and urban and sewer configurations. Our goal was to determine critical variables and life cycle stages and provide results for decision making. We used life cycle assessment and life cycle costing to evaluate their environmental and economic impacts. Results showed that both cities have a similar profile, albeit their contrasting features, that is, operation and maintenance, was the main environmental issue (50% to 70% of the impacts) and pipe installation registered the greatest economic capital expenditure (70% to 75%) due to labor. The location of the wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) is an essential factor in our analysis mainly due to the topography effects (e.g., the annual pump energy was 13 times greater in Calafell). Using the eco‐efficiency portfolio, we observed that sewers might be less eco‐efficient than WWTPs and that we need to envision their design in the context of an integrated WWTP‐sewer management to improve sewer performance. In terms of methodological approach, the bidimensional nature of eco‐efficiency enables the benchmarking of product systems and might be more easily interpreted by the general public. However, there are still some constraints that should be addressed to improve communication, such as the selection of indicators discussed in the article. 相似文献
19.
碳足迹核算的国际标准概述与解析 总被引:2,自引:0,他引:2
各种层面上的碳足迹核算在全球气候变化控制领域得到了越来越多的关注。但是,这些关于碳足迹核算的相关国际标准繁多,彼此之间的关系复杂,不利于研究领域和工业界对这些标准进行应用与交流,限制了碳足迹核算的发展进度与深度。对目前已有的国际主要碳足迹核算标准及生命周期评价标准进行了整理,梳理出这些国际标准的一些基本特征,绘制了国际标准之间的关系图;并进一步从生命周期评价步骤的角度出发,解析了各种国际标准在这些阶段上的相关内容,以及每一个阶段上各标准相关规定中的不同特点及逻辑关系。对促进我国碳足迹核算相关研究与实践工作具有一定的理论与现实参考意义。 相似文献
20.
Ricky Speck Susan Selke Rafael Auras James Fitzsimmons 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2016,20(1):18-28
When software is used to facilitate life cycle assessments (LCAs), the implicit assumption is that the results obtained are not a function of the choice of software used. LCAs were done in both SimaPro and GaBi for simplified systems of creation and disposal of 1 kilogram each of four basic materials (aluminum, corrugated board, glass, and polyethylene terephthalate) to determine whether there were significant differences in the results. Data files and impact assessment methodologies (Impact 2002, ReCiPe, and TRACI 2) were ostensibly identical (although there were minor variations in the available ReCiPe version between the programs that were investigated). Differences in reported impacts of greater than 20% for at least one of the four materials were found for 9 of the 15 categories in Impact 2002+, 7 of the 18 categories in ReCiPe, and four of the nine categories in TRACI. In some cases, these differences resulted in changes in the relative rankings of the four materials. The causes of the differences for 14 combinations of materials and impact categories were examined by tracing the results back to the life cycle inventory data and the characterization factors in the life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) methods. In all cases examined, a difference in the characterization factors used by the two programs was the cause of the differing results. As a result, when these software programs are used to inform choices, the result can be different conclusions about relative environmental preference that are functions purely of the software implementation of LCIA methods, rather than of the underlying data. 相似文献