Differentiation in cultures derived from embryonic chicken muscle: I. Muscle-specific enzyme changes before fusion in EGTA-synchronized cultures

It is known that myoblast fusion fails to occur in cultures containing EGTA (a calcium-specific chelator) but occurs very rapidly after EGTA medium is replaced with standard high-calcium medium. On the basis of a careful analysis of the time course of fusion in cultures switched from EGTA to standard medium, it is proposed that this method of synchronization be used routinely in studies of the timing of different processes during in vitro myogenesis. The kinetics of accumulation of total enzyme activity for creatine kinase and fructose diphosphate aldolase indicate that the increases characteristic of terminal muscle differentiation begin prior to the experimentally imposed onset of fusion in EGTA-synchronized cultures. Additionally, the accumulation of M-creatine kinase subunits, also typical for muscle differentiation, is shown by microcomplement fixation to begin before the switch from EGTA to standard medium. Creatine kinase isoenzyme patterns also show that the transition from B- to M-subunit-containing creatine kinases occurs in EGTA cultures not switched to standard medium. Like EGTA, 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) reversibly prevents myoblast fusion. By adding EGTA and BrdUrd in different sequences to muscle cell cultures, it is shown that they act at different stages in the course of in vitro myogenesis. Cells cultured in EGTA from 23 to 69 hr after plating fused very rapidly when switched to medium containing BrdUrd. In the reverse experiment, in which BrdUrd preceded EGTA, no fusion occurred. Parallel experiments with 5-fluorodeoxyuridine suggest that cell division is necessary to reverse the inhibitory effect of BrdUrd, but not that of EGTA; this is consistent with the observed kinetics of fusion after switching to standard medium. These data strongly support a model of myogenesis in vitro in which two processes (one BrdUrd-sensitive, the other EGTA-sensitive) occur sequentially. In the first process, myogenic cells give rise to cells capable of producing molecules necessary for (terminal) skeletal muscle differentiation, including both those required for cell fusion and specific isoenzymes. The second process, fusion itself, can occur in the presence of BrdUrd or in the absence of cell division.     

Calcium and the control of muscle-specific creatine kinase accumulation during skeletal muscle differentiation in vitro.

A polyacrylamide gel separation method for creatine kinase (CPK) isoenzymes is described, and its use to determine muscle-specific CPK (M-CPK) levels in skeletal muscle cultures is illustrated. In cultures in which cell fusion has been prevented by very low Ca²⁺ concentrations, the increases in M-CPK after 96 hr are similar to those in control cultures. Slightly higher concentrations of Ca²⁺, however, inhibit both cell fusion and M-CPK accumulation. As the calcium concentration is gradually increased further, cell fusion is permitted, followed, at even higher Ca²⁺ levels, by M-CPK accumulation. These effects can be obtained both by adding EGTA to the culture medium and by using Ca²⁺-free culture medium and varying the Ca²⁺ concentration directly. The latter method has the advantage that deleterious effects of EGTA on cell attachment and cell numbers do not occur, even at the lowest Ca²⁺ concentrations. By revealing dramatic effects on CPK levels of small changes in external Ca²⁺ concentrations, these observations may resolve conflicting data in the literature on the question of whether cell fusion is a prerequisite for muscle-specific protein synthesis. Possible mechanisms for the two effects of Ca²⁺ on CPK specific activity (permissive at very low, but inhibitory at intermediate, concentrations) are considered, including membrane mediation, mediation by changes in ionized cytoplasmic Ca²⁺ levels, and possible involvement of cyclic nucleotides.     

Induction by Butyrate of Differentiated Properties in Cloned Murine Rhabdomyosarcoma Cells

A cell line derived from the murine rhabdomyosarcoma BW10139 (Dexter, Cancer Res. 37: 3136, 1977) was subcloned and examined with respect to growth and myogenic characteristics in the presence and absence of 1 mM butyrate. Without butyrate, these cells behave as typical transformed cells: they grow rapidly and chaotically, do not form multinucleated muscle fibers and have little or no creatine kinase activity. In the presence of 1 mM sodium butyrate or butyric acid, growth slows, cells become arranged in whorl patterns, and creatine kinase activities increase to levels comparable to those found in normal chick myoblasts immediately prior to cell fusion. The increase in creatine kinase activity is detectable within 2 h exposure to butyrate, reaches a maximum by 24 h, and the elevated level can be maintained for at least six weeks. The induction is reversible upon sequential addition, deletion, and readdition of butyrate to the culture medium. Isoenzyme analyses demonstrated that only the BB form of creatine kinease is induced; MM creatine kinase was not detected. Although formation of multinucleated cells increases after exposure to butyrate, no typical myotubes form. The results suggest that this rhabdomyosarcoma cell line can, under appropriate conditions, re-express some properties characteristic of skeletal muscle, but not the complete muscle phenotype.     

Role of Ca and Ca-activated protease in myoblast fusion

In this report, we have examined the effects of a calcium chelator, EGTA, and a calcium ionophore, A23187, on fusion of a cloned muscle cell line, L₆. Our results confirm that EGTA essentially blocks all myoblast fusion because the lateral alignment of presumptive myoblasts cannot occur in the absence of extracellular calcium. A23187, however, promotes the precocious fusion of myoblasts, apparently by facilitating Ca²⁺ transport into myoblasts. We have also demonstrated that a Ca²⁺-activated protease, CAP (mM), appears to relocate in response to the Ca²⁺ flux, changing from a random, dispersed distribution in proliferative myoblasts to a predominantly peripheral distribution in prefusion myoblasts. Coincident with the mM CAF relocation is an altered distribution of a surface glycoprotein, fibronectin. Extracellular fibronectin is seen in abundance in proliferating myoblasts, but is essentially absent from the surface of fusing myoblasts. We suggest that mM CAF when activated by Ca²⁺ influx may act to promote the release of fibronectin from the myoblast cell surface, thus providing a mechanism by which the membrane of the fusing myoblast may be rearranged to accommodate fusion.     

Differentiation in cultures derived from embryonic chicken muscle: II. Phosphorylase histochemistry and fluorescent antibody staining for creatine kinase and aldolase

The presence or absence of five proteins (glycogen phosphorylase, aldolase A, aldolase C, creatine kinase M, creatine kinase B) in the various classes of cells found in primary cultures derived from embryonic chick breast muscle was investigated using cytological staining methods. Histochemical staining for phosphorylase and indirect fluorescent antibody staining for aldolase A and C as well as for creatine kinases M and B showed the following: All five proteins were found in the many myotubes present in standard medium cultures and in the very few myotubes found in cultures containing 5-bromodeoxyuridine (10^?5M). The elongated bipolar cells prevented from fusing in medium containing EGTA also contain all five proteins. The flattened myogenic cells that predominate in the 5-bromodeoxyuridine-treated cultures contain no phosphorylase or creatine kinase M, though many of them contain creatine kinase B and aldolases A and C. These results are interpreted as indicating that: (1) phosphorylase and creatine kinase M, but not aldolase A, are suitable all-or-none markers for terminal muscle differentiation; (2) the small amounts of creatine kinase M detected in electrophoreses of 5-bromodeoxyruridine-treated cultures can be accounted for by the few myotubes present and are not due to “protodifferentiation” of large numbers of cells; (3) proteins typical of differentiated muscle are produced only in cells that have passed through the last step in myogenesis that is susceptible to 5-bromodeoxyuridine inhibition, and (4) if fusion is blocked by reducing the concentration of calcium ions, accumulation of characteristic muscle proteins can continue in those cells that have initiated terminal differentiation.     

Secretion of beta-hexosaminidase by cultured human skin fibroblasts. Kinetics, effect of temperature, cell density, serum concentration and pH.

The temporal relation between the fusion of mononucleated myoblasts into multinucleated fibres and the quantitative changes in the activity of creatine kinase isoenzymes was determined in rat skeletal muscle cell cultures. The effect of actinomycin D on the isoenzyme transition was investigated. The activity of creatine kinase in cultures prior to the onset of cell fusion is predominantly of the BB type. During the phase of cell fusion, there is a manyfold increase in creatine kinase activity. This is due to the appearance or great increase in the activity of the MM isoenzyme. During this period, increase in the BB isoenzyme activity is very small. Inhibition of RNA synthesis by actinomycin D shortly before the onset of cell fusion did not prevent cell fusion and isoenzyme transition during the first 6 h following application of the drug.     

Expression of creatine kinase isoenzymes in myogenic cell lines.

Investigation of creatine kinase isoenzyme activity in several cloned myogenic cell lines showed differences in B-type subunit expression. In cultures of myoblasts isolated from rat skeletal muscle by selective cell plating and in the cell lines M58 and M41, the activity of the mononucleated cells was of the BB isoenzyme. After cell fusion, MM, MB, and BB isoenzymes were present; the main activity was of the MM isoenzyme. In the myogenic lines L8 and L84, in cultures of mononucleated cells, creatine kinase activity was absent or barely detectable. The high creatine kinase activity after cell fusion was of the MM type. No BB and MB activity was detected in these lines at any stage of differentiation. The difference in expression of creatine kinase isoenzymes seems not to affect the expression of other parameters of differentiation.     

Role of Ca2+ and Ca2+-activated protease in myoblast fusion

In this report, we have examined the effects of a calcium chelator, EGTA, and a calcium ionophore, A23187, on fusion of a cloned muscle cell line, L6. Our results confirm that EGTA essentially blocks all myoblast fusion because the lateral alignment of presumptive myoblasts cannot occur in the absence of extracellular calcium. A23187, however, promotes the precocious fusion of myoblasts, apparently by facilitating Ca2+ transport into myoblasts. We have also demonstrated that a Ca2+-activated protease, CAF (mM), appears to relocate in response to the Ca2+ flux, changing from a random, dispersed distribution in proliferative myoblasts to a predominantly peripheral distribution in prefusion myoblasts. Coincident with the mM CAF relocation is an altered distribution of a surface glycoprotein, fibronectin. Extracellular fibronectin is seen in abundance in proliferating myoblasts, but is essentially absent from the surface of fusing myoblasts. We suggest that mM CAF when activated by Ca2+ influx may act to promote the release of fibronectin from the myoblast cell surface, thus providing a mechanism by which the membrane of the fusing myoblast may be rearranged to accommodate fusion.     

Stimulation of liver cell DNA synthesis by oncomodulin, an MW 11 500 calcium-binding protein from hepatoma

Raising the calcium concentration, or adding the tumor-specific calcium-binding protein oncomodulin (but not a similar, calcium-binding protein such as skeletal muscle parvalbumin) stimulated DNA synthesis in non-neoplastic T51B rat liver cells, whose DNA-synthetic activity had been reduced by incubation in medium containing 0.02 mM calcium instead of the usual 1.8 mM calcium. A calcium: oncomodulin complex was probably the actual stimulator, because oncomodulin action was blocked by further reducing the ionic calcium concentration in the already calcium-deficient medium with EGTA. Oncomodulin was also able to stimulate DNA synthesis in T51B cell cultures, whose response to calcium addition had been blocked by trifluoperazine.     

Calcium ions are required for cell fusion mediated by the CD4-human immunodeficiency virus type 1 envelope glycoprotein interaction.

Calcium ions are required for fusion of a wide variety of artificial and biological membranes. To examine the role of calcium ions for cell fusion mediated by interactions between CD4 and the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein (gp120-gp41), we used two experimental systems: (i) cells expressing gp120-gp41 and its receptor CD4, both encoded by recombinant vaccinia viruses, and (ii) chronically infected cells producing low levels of HIV-1. Fusion was measured by counting the number of syncytia and by monitoring the redistribution of fluorescence dyes by video microscopy. Syncytia did not form in solutions without calcium ions. Addition of calcium ions partially restored the formation of syncytia. EDTA and EGTA [ethylene glycol-bis(beta-aminoethyl ether)-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid] blocked syncytium formation in culture media containing calcium ions. Membrane fusion as monitored by fluorescence dye redistribution also required calcium ions. Cell fusion increased with an increase in calcium ion concentration from 100 microM to 10 mM but was not affected by magnesium ions in the concentration range from 0 to 30 mM. Fibrinogen and fibronectin did not promote fusion in the absence or presence of Ca2+. Binding of soluble CD4 to gp120-gp41-expressing cells was not affected by Ca2+ and Mg2+. We conclude that Ca2+ is involved in postbinding steps in cell fusion mediated by the CD4-HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein interaction.     

Influence of inorganic phosphate and energy state on force in skinned cardiac muscle from freshwater turtle and rainbow trout

Inorganic phosphate, which increases in the hypoxic cardiac cell, depresses force development. The cardiac muscle of freshwater turtle maintains a remarkably high contractility during hypoxia; this may involve a low sensitivity to phosphate. Therefore, freshwater turtle and rainbow trout were compared with regard to Ca²⁺-activated force in skinned atrial trabeculae in a bath containing 3 mM ATP buffered by 15 mM creatine phosphate in the presence of creatine kinase. For turtle, an increase in phosphate from 0 mM to either 6 mM or 12 mM reduced maximal force by 50% and 80% respectively, whereas the Ca²⁺ activity eliciting half maximal force (Ca_0.5) was increased by 70% in 6 mM and could not be reliably recorded in 12 mM. For trout, the effects of phosphate were less pronounced. An increase from 0 mM to 12 mM did not affect maximal force significantly, but elevated Ca_0.5 by 70%. Hypoxia increases ADP as creatine phosphate is shifted to creatine, therefore, creatine phosphate was changed from 15 mM to 3 mM and creatine from 0 mM to 12 mM. After these changes, the elevation of phosphate from 0 mM to 12 mM had no significant effects for either turtle or trout. In conclusion, the high performance of turtle cardiac muscle during hypoxia does not involve a low sensitivity of the contractile system to phosphate. In addition, the effect of increased phosphate seems to be offset by a concomitant increase in ADP. Accepted: 28 June 1999     

Rate equation for creatine kinase predicts the in vivo reaction velocity: 31P NMR surface coil studies in brain, heart, and skeletal muscle of the living rat

Brain, heart, and skeletal muscle contain four different creatine kinase isozymes and various concentrations of substrates for the creatine kinase reaction. To identify if the velocity of the creatine kinase reaction under cellular conditions is regulated by enzyme activity and substrate concentrations as predicted by the rate equation, we used 31P NMR and spectrophotometric techniques to measure reaction velocity, enzyme content, isozyme distribution, and concentrations of substrates in brain, heart, and skeletal muscle of living rat under basal or resting conditions. The total tissue activity of creatine kinase in the direction of MgATP synthesis provided an estimate for Vmax (23.4 +/- 2.8, 62.4 +/- 4.5, and 224 +/- 16 mM/s) and exceeded the NMR-determined in vivo reaction velocities by an order of magnitude (4.1 +/- 1.2, 5.1 +/- 1.6, and 18.4 +/- 2.4 mM/s for brain, heart, and skeletal muscle, respectively). The isozyme composition varied among the three tissues: greater than 99% BB for brain; 14% MB, 61% MM, and 25% mitochondrial for heart; and 98% MM and 2% mitochondrial for skeletal muscle. The NMR-determined reaction velocities agreed with predicted values from the creatine kinase rate equation (r2 = 0.98; p less than 0.001). The concentrations of free creatine and cytosolic MgADP, being less than or equal to the dissociation constants for each isozyme, were dominant terms in the creatine kinase rate equation for predicting the in vivo reaction velocity. Thus, we observed that the velocity of the creatine kinase reaction is regulated by total tissue enzyme activity and by the concentrations of creatine and MgADP in a manner that is independent of isozyme distribution.     

Activation of an islet cell plasma membrane (Ca2+ + Mg2+)-ATPase by calmodulin and Ca-EGTA

Islet cell plasma membranes contain a calcium-stimulated and magnesium-dependent ATPase (Ca2+ + Mg2+)-ATPase) which requires calmodulin for maximum enzyme activity (Kotagal, N., Patke, C., Landt, M., McDonald, J., Colca, J., Lacy, P., and McDaniel, M. (1982) FEBS Lett. 137, 249-252). Investigations indicated that exogenously added calmodulin increases the velocity and decreases the Km for Ca2+ of the high affinity (Ca2+ + Mg2+)-ATPase. These studies routinely employed the chelator ethylene glycol bis(beta-aminoethyl ether)-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid (EGTA) to maintain Ca2+ concentrations in the submicromolar range. During the course of these investigations, it was found unexpectedly that increasing the concentrations of EGTA (0.1-4 mM) and total calcium in the media, while maintaining constant free Ca2+ levels, increased the velocity of the high affinity (Ca2+ + Mg2+)-ATPase. The free calcium concentrations under these conditions were verified by a calcium-sensitive electrode. The (Ca2+ + Mg2+)-ATPase maximally activated by 2-4 mM EGTA was not further stimulated by calmodulin, whereas camodulin stimulation increased as the concentration of EGTA in the media was decreased. A similar enhancement by Ca-EGTA was observed on active calcium transport by the plasma membrane-enriched fraction. Moreover, Ca-EGTA had a negligible effect on both active calcium transport as well as Ca2+-stimulated ATPase activity by the islet cell endoplasmic reticulum, processes which are not stimulated by calmodulin. The results indicate that stimulation by Ca-EGTA may be used to differentiate calcium transport systems by these subcellular organelles. Furthermore, the concentration of EGTA routinely employed to maintain free Ca2+ levels may itself obscure effects of calmodulin and other physiological agents on calcium-dependent activities.     

Purification and characterization of creatine kinase isozymes from the nurse shark Ginglymostoma cirratum

Creatine kinase from nurse shark brain and muscle has been purified to apparent homogeneity. In contrast to creatine kinases from most other vertebrate species, the muscle isozyme and the brain isozyme from nurse shark migrate closely in electrophoresis and, unusually, the muscle isozyme is anodal to the brain isozyme. The isoelectric points are 5.3 and 6.2 for the muscle and brain isozymes, respectively. The purified brain preparation also contains a second active protein with pI 6.0. The amino acid content of the muscle isozyme is compared with other isozymes of creatine kinase using the Metzger Difference Index as an estimation of compositional relatedness. All comparisons show a high degree of compositional similarity including arginine kinase from lobster muscle. The muscle isozyme is marginally more resistant to temperature inactivation than the brain isozyme; the muscle protein does not exhibit unusual stability towards high concentrations of urea. Kinetic analysis of the muscle isozyme reveals Michaelis constants of 1.6 mM MgATP, 12 mM creatine, 1.2 mM MgADP and 50 mM creatine phosphate. Dissociation constants for the same substrate from the binary and ternary enzyme-substrate complex do not differ significantly, indicating limited cooperatively in substrate binding. Enzyme activity is inhibited by small planar anions, most severely by nitrate. Shark muscle creatine kinase hybridizes in vitro with rabbit muscle or monkey brain creatine kinase; shark brain isozyme hybridizes with monkey brain or rabbit brain creatine kinase. Shark muscle and shark brain isozymes, under a wide range of conditions, failed to produce a detectable hybrid.     

The presence and binding characteristics of calmodulin in microsomal preparations enriched in sarcoplasmic reticulum from rabbit skeletal muscle

ATP-dependent oxalate facilitated calcium transport in sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) preparations obtained from rabbit vastus lateralis muscle (fast skeletal muscle; F_sr) and soleus (slow skeletal muscle; S_sr) was determined. Addition of exogenous calmodulin did not stimulate calcium transport in either F_sr or S_sr preparations. F_sr and S_sr previously washed in 1 mM EGTA demonstrated a reduced capacity to transport Ca²⁺; the exogenous addition of calmodulin (0.24 μM) under these conditions, did not restore uptake activity but significantly decreased the steady-state level of Ca²⁺ uptake. Extracts of skeletal SR prepared by treatment with 0.2 mM EDTA and boiling produced significantly more stimulation of red cell Ca²⁺ATPase activity than extracts prepared by boiling alone. This stimulation of red cell Ca²⁺-ATPase was inhibited to a significant extent by $\text{48}\text{80}$, a known anti-calmodulin agent. Radioimmunoassay revealed that extracts prepared by boiling or EDTA-treatment followed by boiling contained considerable amounts of calmodulin. Washing with 1 mM EGTA, though, did not release any calmodulin from SR. These studies reveal that calmodulin is present in both F_sr and S_sr and can only be removed by harsh treatments. The role of calmodulin in skeletal muscle Ca²⁺-transport remains to be determined.     

Calcium-dependent activation of tryptophan hydroxylase by ATP and magnesium

Tryptophan hydroxylase [EC 1.14.16.4; L-tryptophan, tetrahydropteridine: oxygen oxidoreductase (5-hydroxylating)] in rat brainstem extracts is activated 2 to 2.5-fold by ATP and Mg⁺⁺ in the presence of subsaturating concentrations of the cofactor 6-methyltetrahydropterin (6MPH₄). The activation of tryptophan hydroxylase under these conditions results from a reduction in the apparent K_m for 6MPH₄ from 0.21 mM to 0.09 mM. The activation requires Mg⁺⁺ and ATP but is not dependent on either cAMP or cGMP. The effect of ATP and Mg⁺⁺ on enzyme activity was enhanced by μM concentrations of Ca⁺⁺ and totally blocked by EGTA. These data suggest that tryptophan hydroxylase can be activated by a cyclic nucleotide independent protein kinase which requires low calcium concentrations for the expression of its activity.     

In vitro myogenesis : Expression of muscle specific function in the absence of cell fusion

Correlation of cell fusion with other muscle specific functions observed in vivo and in vitro has suggested the possibility that the fusion process itself might be involved in the mechanism of controlled expression of differentiated function. In order to test this possibility in primary cultures of fetal calf myoblasts, we have established conditions of Ca²⁺ depletion which block cell fusion. Under these conditions, three separate markers of muscle specific differentiation were measured: creatine phosphokinase, a soluble enzyme; myosin heavy chain, a component of the contractile apparatus; and acetylcholine receptor, an integral membrane protein. The data indicate that the expression of the three functions studied is independent of the fusion process, and therefore that cell fusion plays no major role in the switch on of differentiated gene expression.     

A cell surface phosphoprotein of 48 kDa specific for myoblast fusion

The data we present here permit us to affirm that a 48 kDa phosphoprotein is the target of extracellular Ca2+ during fusion. It is detected only in fusion-competent L6 myoblasts and not in the fusion-defective spontaneous stable variants we isolated. The phosphorylation of this protein species can be totally inhibited by culturing myoblasts in a medium containing low Ca2+ concentrations (0.250 mM). However, under such conditions myoblasts do not fuse, but withdraw from the cell cycle and accumulate the muscle isoform of creatine kinase (M-CK). The results we have obtained support the following conclusions: (1) in fusion-competent cells, overall Ca2+-dependent phosphorylation of cell surface proteins appears to be necessary, but is not sufficient by itself for myoblast fusion; (2) the phosphorylation of a 48 kDa protein species is required for cell fusion; and (3) the phosphorylation of this 48 kDa protein is independent of other main events of cellular differentiation.     

Decreased mitochondrial creatine kinase activity in dystrophic chicken breast muscle alters creatine-linked respiratory coupling

Dystrophic chicken breast muscle mitochondria contain significantly less mitochondrial creatine kinase than normal breast muscle mitochondria. Breast muscle mitochondria from normal 16- to 40-day-old chickens contain approximately 80 units of mitochondrial creatine kinase per unit of succinate:INT (p-iodonitrotetrazolium violet) reductase, a mitochondrial marker, while dystrophic chicken breast muscle mitochondria contain 36-44 units. Normal chicken heart muscle mitochondria contain about 10% of the mitochondrial creatine kinase per unit of succinate:INT reductase as normal breast muscle mitochondria. The levels in heart muscle mitochondria from dystrophic chickens are not affected significantly. Evidence is presented which shows that the reduced level of mitochondrial creatine kinase in dystrophic breast muscle mitochondria is responsible for an altered creatine linked respiration. First, both normal and dystrophic breast muscle mitochondria respire with the same state 3 and state 4 respiration. Second, the post-ADP state 4 rate of respiration of normal breast muscle mitochondria in the presence of 20 mM creatine continues at the state 3 rate. However, the state 4 rate of dystrophic breast muscle mitochondria and mitochondria from other muscle types with a low level of mitochondrial creatine kinase, such as heart muscle and 5-day-old chicken breast muscle, is slower than the state 3 rate. Third, dystrophic breast mitochondria synthesize ATP at the same rate as normal breast muscle mitochondria but rates of creatine phosphate synthesis in 20-50 mM Pi are reduced significantly. Finally, increasing concentrations of Pi displace mitochondrial creatine kinase from mitoplasts of normal and dystrophic breast muscle mitochondria with the same apparent KD, indicating that the outer surface of the inner mitochondrial membrane and the mitochondrial creatine kinase from dystrophic muscle are not altered.     

Determination of the affinity of each component of a composite quaternary transition-state analogue complex of creatine kinase

Recombinant rabbit muscle creatine kinase (CK) was titrated with MgADP in 50 mM Bicine and 5 mM Mg(OAc)2, pH 8.3, at 30.0 degrees C by following a decrease in the protein's intrinsic fluorescence. In the presence of 50 mM NaOAc, but in the absence of added creatine or nitrate, MgADP has an apparent K(d) of 135 +/- 7 microM, and the total change in fluorescence on saturation (Delta%F) is 15.3 +/- 0.3%. Acetate was used as the anion in this experiment because it does not promote the formation of a CK.MgADP.anion.creatine transition-state analogue complex (TSAC) [Millner-White and Watts (1971) Biochem. J. 122, 727-740]. In the presence of 80 mM creatine, but no nitrate, the apparent K(d) for MgADP remains essentially unchanged at 132 +/- 10 microM, while Delta%F decreases slightly to 13.2 +/- 0.3%. In the presence of 10 mM nitrate, but no creatine, the apparent K(d) is once again essentially unchanged at 143 +/- 23 microM, but the Delta%F is markedly reduced to 4.2 +/- 0.2%. The presence of both 10 mM nitrate and 80 mM creatine during titration reduces the apparent K(d) for MgADP 10-fold to 13.7 +/- 0.7 microM, and Delta%F increases to 20.6 +/- 0.3%, strongly suggesting that the simultaneous presence of saturating levels of creatine and nitrate increases the affinity of CK for MgADP and promotes the formation of the enzyme*MgADP*nitrate*creatine TSAC. When the fluorescence of CK was titrated with MgADP in the presence of 80 mM creatine and fixed saturating concentrations of various anions, apparent K(d) values for MgADP of 132 +/- 10 microM, 25.2 +/- 1.3 microM, 18.8 +/- 0.9 microM, 13.7 +/- 0.7 microM, and 6.4 +/- 0.7 microM were observed as the anion was changed from acetate to formate to chloride to nitrate to nitrite, respectively. This is the same trend reported by Millner-White and Watts for the effectiveness of various monovalent anions in forming the CK.MgADP.anion.creatine TSAC. On titration of CK with MgADP in the presence of 80 mM creatine and various fixed concentrations of NaNO3, the apparent K(d) for MgADP decreases with increasing fixed concentrations of nitrate. A plot of the apparent K(d) for MgADP vs [NO3-] suggests a K(d) for nitrate from the TSAC of 0.39 +/- 0.07 mM. Similarly, titration with MgADP in the presence of 10 mM NaNO3 and various fixed concentrations of creatine gives a value of 0.9 +/- 0.4 mM for the dissociation of creatine from the TSAC. The data were used to calculate K(TDAC), the dissociation constant of the quaternary TSAC into its individual components, of 3 x 10(-10) M3. To our knowledge this is the first reported dissociation constant for a ternary or quaternary TSAC.