Idiotypic analysis of polyclonal and monoclonal anti-p-azophenylarsonate antibodies of BALB/c mice expressing the major cross-reactive idiotype of the A/J strain

The idiotypic cascade allows the induction of silent idiotypes, and as such, the immune system can be reprogrammed towards predetermined goals. To understand the genetic origin of silent idiotypes, we have used a system in which detailed structural and genetic information is available. The major cross-reactive idiotype (CRIA) of A/J mice (positive strain) immunized with arsonate coupled to a carrier can be regularly induced in BALB/c mice (negative strain) by anti-idiotypic treatment with or without subsequent antigen immunization. By using a panel of monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies, we have found that the germline-encoded CRIA displays a mosaic of at least five idiotopes. Polyclonal and monoclonal anti-arsonate antibodies prepared from idiotypically manipulated BALB/c mice have been studied. Four germline idiotopes are shared between the CRIA of the A/J strain and the CRIA-like idiotype induced in BALB/c mice. Furthermore, CRIA-like antibodies can appear "spontaneously" in some BALB/c mice immunized with antigen only. The data suggest that anti-idiotypic treatment in BALB/c mice selects a preexisting subset of antibodies. From the serological analysis, it is predicted that CRIA molecules from A/J and CRIA-like molecules from BALB/c employ different VH subgroups but share some components of the hypervariable regions. These predictions are tested in a forthcoming paper that describes the amino acid sequences of BALB/c monoclonal antibodies displaying the major cross-reactive idiotype of the A/J strain.     

Somatic mutations in the variable region of the lambda 2 chain of M315 suppression of antibodies to the idiotype of M315

BALB/c mice immunized with purified BALB/c myeloma protein M315 (alpha, lambda 2) produce anti-idiotypic antibody directed predominantly to a combinational (VH-315 + VL-315) determinant(s) of the M315 paratope (Sirisinha and Eisen, 1971; Tungkanak and Sirisinha, 1976). We examined whether the unique B cell response is influenced by pretreatment of mice with fragments or chains derived from M315 before immunization with M315. Intravenous (i.v.) injection of the Fv-315 fragment (VH-315 + VL-315) into normal BALB/c mice seven days before immunization with M315 resulted in marked suppression of anti-M315 idiotype antibodies. Studies on the structural requirement for suppression indicated that VL-315, but not VH-315, is involved. Structural comparison with a defined lambda 2 light (L) chain suggested that three contiguous amino acid residues in the third hypervariable loop of the variable (V) domain of the L chain of M315 are important for down-regulation of production of antibodies to the M315 idiotype.     

Genetic control of the immune response to staphylococcal nuclease. IX. Recombination between genes determining BALB/c antinuclease idiotypes and the heavy chain allotype locus.

The genetic linkage relationship of two antinuclease idiotypes produced by the BALB/c strain was investigated in the backcross (BALB/c x CB.20) X CB.20. These two idiotypes were detected by Lewis rat anti-idiotypic antisera prepared against affinity-purified A/J and SJL antinuclease antibodies, termed the A/J and SJL idiotypes, respectively. Both idiotypes were found to be linked to the IgCHa immunoglobulin heavy chain allotype locus. There was, however, a high frequency of recombination observed between both markers and the IgCHa locus, with eight of 83 backcross animals recombinant for the A/J idiotype and five of 83 recombinant for the SJL idiotype. All such recombinant animals were IgCHb/b homozygotes that had gained one or both idiotypes. These results are consistent with a genetic map of VHr region genes in the BALB/c strain in which genes determining the SJL idiotype are closer to the IgCHa allotype locus than are genes determining the A/J idiotype. This high frequency of recombination may indicate that the chromosome segment containing VH region genes is very large or that it has structural features that promote recombination.     

Influence of the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus on expression of the VK1GAC light chain

The VK1GAC light chain represents the dominant V kappa structure employed in the antibody response of A/J mice to streptococcal group A carbohydrate ( GAC ). Two anti-idiotypic antisera, anti- Id5 and anti- Id20 , with specificity for the VK1GAC light chain were used to examine anti- GAC antibody responses in a series of inbred mouse strains that differ at the heavy chain constant region ( IgCH ) allotype locus. Both idiotypes were expressed in normal and immune sera from mice of most IgCH allotypes, except IgCHb (C57BL/6J) and IgCHf (CE/J). C57BL/6J mice expressed Id5 , but not Id20 , whereas CE/J mice did not express either idiotype. Testing of recombinant inbred strains between BALB/c and C57BL/6 indicated that the pattern of idiotype expression did not correlate with IgCH allotype. The C X B recombinants expressed all three idiotype patterns that were observed in the panel of inbred strains. Testing of allotype congenic mice between BALB/c and C57BL/6 showed that CB.20 and BC.8 mice were Id20 -, whereas BAB-14 mice were Id20 +, indicating that both VH and background (V kappa or regulatory) loci must be derived from BALB/c to obtain Id20 expression. The difference in the frequency of idiotype expression observed between BALB/c and BAB-14 mice indicates that the IgCH locus may exert a quantitative influence on the expression of this light chain. To examine the Id20 -, Id5 + antibodies of C57BL/6 mice, anti- GAC hybridomas were prepared. Of 16 C57BL/6-derived anti- GAC monoclonal antibodies, six were reactive with anti- Id5 and not with anti- Id20 . Isoelectric focusing of the purified kappa light chains from three of these antibodies revealed two distinct spectrotypes that co-migrated with the two known VK1GAC spectrotypes observed with A/J anti- GAC light chains. Idiotypic analysis of in vitro recombinants between the heavy and light chains of A/J and C57BL/6 monoclonal antibodies demonstrated that the C57BL/6 light chains were idiotypically similar to A/J light chains when they were free in solution or paired with A/J heavy chains. These results demonstrate that C57BL/6 mice can express a light chain that is very similar, if not identical, to the VK1GAC light chain, although the light chain is expressed in lower frequency and is paired with a distinct VH structure, which can mask expression of one of the VK1GAC idiotypes. These effects on V kappa expression map to at least three genetic loci: VH, CH, and an unlinked locus.     

Structural studies on induced antibodies with defined idiotypic specificities. V. The complete amino acid sequence of the light chain variable regions of anti-p-azophenylarsonate antibodies from A/J mice bearing a cross-reactive idiotype.

The complete amino acid sequence of the variable regions of light chains derived from anti-p-azophenylarsonate antibodies from A/J mice bearing a cross-reactive idiotype is reported. At least two and probably more than three distinct light chains are associated with this idiotypically characterized antibody. The antibodies have several differences in their "framework" structures but evidence is presented indicating that all three light chain hypervariable regions have a homogeneous sequence. The data are discussed in relation to the various theories of antibody diversity. In addition, the findings support the view that hypervariable regions, idiotypic determinants, and the antibody-combining site involve, to a large extent, the same molecular structures.     

A protective monoclonal anti-idiotypic vaccine to lethal Semliki Forest virus infection in BALB/c mice.

Two monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies (ab2 MAbs), designated 1.13A112 (immunoglobulin G type 2a [IgG2a]) and 1.13A321 (IgG1), were prepared against Semliki Forest virus (SFV)-neutralizing ab1 MAb UM 1.13. They were identified in hybridoma supernatant fluid by their capacity to block UM 1.13-mediated neutralization of SFV. Although the neutralization-blocking capacities of the ab2 MAbs did not differ, only 1.13A321 evoked SFV-neutralizing ab3 antibodies upon intracutaneous and subcutaneous immunization of BALB/c mice with 1.13A321 chemically cross-linked to keyhole limpet hemocyanin and combined with the adjuvant Quil A. SFV-neutralizing ab3 antibodies appeared in serum within 10 days after primary immunization, and neutralizing antibody titers could be as high as 1/1,000 at day 35. All mice who had developed SFV-neutralizing antibodies upon anti-idiotypic immunization survived an otherwise lethal challenge with virulent SFV. However, induction of SFV-neutralizing ab3 antibodies by ab2 MAb 1.13A321 proved to be genetically restricted to BALB/c mice; even haplotype-identical (H-2d) DBA/2 mice did not respond, and consequently those animals died after infection with virulent SFV.     

Structural studies on induced antibodies with defined idiotypic specificities. I. The heavy chains of anti-p-azophenylarsonate antibodies from A/J mice bearing a cross-reactive idiotype.

Amino acid sequence analysis has been performed on three groups of heavy (H) chains of A/J mice. H chains derived from unimmunized animals were compared to anti-p-azophenylarsonate (anti-Ar) antibodies which were further subdivided into those possessing and those depleted of a cross-reacting idiotype (CRI). It was found that anti-Ar antibodies bearing the CRI are homogeneous through the first hypervariable region of the H chain. The same sequence was obtained for pooled antibody isolated from the ascites fluid of 18 A/J mice or from a single mouse. The H chains appear to belong to a minor V-H subgroup. In the first 30 positions Anti-Ar antibodies depleted of the CRI had the same sequence as those containing the CRI (with small amounts of heterogeneity at some positions), but contained a mixture of sequences in the first hypervariable region of the H chain. These studies indicate that antibodies with similar specificity and with identical framework sequences, but which differ in their hypervariable regions, contain different idiotypic determinants, and support the concept that the idiotypic determinants reside primarily within hypervariable regions.     

Molecular mapping of idiotopes of anti-arsonate antibodies

As part of understanding molecular function in structural terms, we have been attempting to map the idiotypic topography of specific anti-arsonate (Ars) antibodies. A panel of anti-Ars hybridomas of which the complete primary sequences are known were used. These molecules show a varied reactivity profile with a panel of monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies. By judicious chain recombination experiments and chemical modifications that altered this reactivity profile, we were able to identify particular amino acid residues or discreet regions of anti-Ars antibodies as having crucial roles in the expression of idiotypic determinants. Idiotopes were mapped to the heavy chain second hypervariable region and D segment, and to the light chain first and third hypervariable regions.     

Structural definition by antibody engineering of an idiotypic determinant

Using computer-aided techniques for predicting molecular structure, we constructed an atomic model of the variable domain of a murine anti-thyroglobulin antibody whose immunodominant idiotypic determinant (Id62) was mapped by site-directed mutagenesis and immunochemical analysis. We previously showed that under experimental conditions this idiotype activates anti-idiotypic B cells and T cells, and modulates the response to thyroglobulin in mice. Because idiotype interactions are considered of physiological importance for immune regulation, we studied this idiotype as a model to understand the relationship between function and structure. To determine the contribution of heavy- and light-chain variable domains to the idiotype structure, we constructed chimeric expression vectors and introduced them into the (non-secreting) P3X63Ag8.653 myeloma cell line. Mutants of the heavy-chain variable domain were obtained by site-directed mutagenesis and transfected into the murine (lambda 1) light-chain producer J558L cell line. The expressed proteins were purified from culture supernatants of transfected cells and characterized. We provide evidence that the third hypervariable loop (D region) of the heavy-chain variable domain is the structural correlate of the idiotypic determinant of this autoantibody and is independent from the nature of the associated light chain. Substitution of residues of the first and second complementarity-determining regions do not affect idiotype expression. The results described here are discussed in relation to our understanding, at a molecular level, of the interaction of idiotopes with B- and T-cell compartments.     

Relationship of idiotypes of the anti-p-azophenylarsonate antibodies of A/J and BALB/c mice

It has previously been shown that A/J anti-Ar antibodies contain 2 different families of cross-reactive idiotypes, referred to as the major and minor idiotypes populations. The present report shows that the minor A/J idiotype is related to a major idiotype of BALB/c anti-Ar antibodies. Anti-idiotype directed against the minor A/J idiotype binds 5 to 10% of A/J anti-Ar but an average of about 40% of BALB/c anti-Ar. This BALB/c population corresponds to the major BALB/c anti-Ar idiotype. For individual BALB/c anti-Ar preparations the maximum percentages of antibody bound by anti-id directed to A/J or BALB/c anti-Ar are very similar. Anti-id reactive with the minor A/J idiotypic population suppressed the formation of the BALB/c major idiotype when injected into BALB/c mice. Adsorption experiments showed that only about one-third of the minor A/J population is related to the BALB/c idiotype and that the expression of this idiotype is highly variable in individual A/J sera. Several types of evidence, obtained with hybridoma products expressing the major A/J idiotype, revealed no detectable relationship between the major A/J and BALB/c anti-Ar idiotypes.     

Monoclonal antibodies to streptococcal group A carbohydrate. I. A dominant idiotypic determinant is located on Vk

In an effort to better define the antibody repertoire to streptococcal group A carbohydrate (GAC), somatic cell hybrids were prepared from A/J mice immunized with streptococcal vaccine. Most antibodies were IgG3K and IgMK, while 2 of 26 antibodies were lambda type. Each of the IgG3 antibodies had a distinct isoelectric point consistent with previous estimates of clonal repertoires of approximately 200. IEF analysis of the L chains, however, showed that about half of the antibodies produce a common L chain, called VK1GAC, previously identified in A/J anti-GAC serum antibodies. Additional support for the structural similarity of these L chains was gained by developing an idiotype antiserum to VK1GAC. All proteins with the common L chain spectrotype react strongly with anti-VK1GAC. Thus, it appears that anti-GAC antibodies are composed of H chains bearing a few VH regions pairing with a few L chains.     

Relation of a cross-reactive idiotype to genetic control of the immune response.

Antibodies elicited in strain A mice by immunization with keyhole limpet hemocyanin-p-azophenylarsonate (KLH-Ar) produce anti-Ar antibodies, some of which share a cross-reactive idiotype (CRI); in general, 20 to 70% of the antihapten antibody population carries the idiotype. Large amounts of antibody can be produced by the induction of ascitic fluids, using a 9:1 ratio of complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) to antigen. Antibodies with the CRI can be isolated by isoelectric focusing from selected mice that have produced a high concentration of the CRI. The H chains exhibit a single homogeneous sequence through the first hypervariable region and, when isolated from a large number of individual mice, appear to be invariant in the first framework region. These findings indicate that somatic mutation is not a significant factor in the determination of framework sequences. Appearance of the CRI can be suppressed in adult A/J mice by administration of rabbit anti-idiotypic antiserum prior to immunization. Such suppressed mice produce normal concentrations of anti-Ar antibodies lacking the CRI. Anti-idiotypic antibodies produced against such antibodies failed to show cross-reactivity with anti-Ar antibodies arising in idiotypically suppressed or nonsuppressed A/J mice. The great sensitivity of the assay indicates that the number of such "private" idiotypes, all present on anti-Ar antibodies of a single strain, must be extremely large; this supports a somatic mechanism for the generation of diversity. The "private" idiotypes arising in suppressed, hyperimmunized mice can be adoptively transferred into multiple, irradiated (200 R) recipients by injections of spleen cells or of cells from ascitic fluids. The use of ascitic fluids permits the rapid production of a colony of mice bearing the idiotype. This should facilitate structural studies of a variety of idiotypically different molecules sharing the same (anti-Ar) specificity, as well as studies of the mechanism of suppression.     

Antibody response against a possible arthritogenic epitope on human type II collagen induced by anti-idiotypic antibody

We reported the presence of three distinct epitopes commonly present on murine and human type II collagen (CII), observed using mAb. To investigate the possible involvement of these epitopes in collagen-induced arthritis, we raised rabbit anti-idiotypic antibodies that may bear the internal image of these epitopes. Anti-idiotypic antibodies developed against three anti-CII mAb designated as 1-5, 2-14, and 2-15 were demonstrated to recognize idiotype expressed on Ag-binding site (paratope) of their related mAb. Anti-CII antibody response specific for a given epitope could be induced in DBA/1J mice upon immunization with anti-idiotypic antibodies coupled to keyhole limpet hemocyanin. Anti-idiotypic antibody to 1-5 antibody in particular could stimulate all DBA/1J mice for production of anti-CII antibody possessing Ag specificity and idiotype similar to those of 1-5 antibody. Although the mice immunized with anti-1-5 antibody alone did not develop arthritis, they did show a much more enhanced antibody response against a given epitope than did control mice non-treated with anti-idiotypic antibody upon the subsequent immunization with human CII. Some of the mice immunized with anti-1-5 antibody and challenged with human CII developed arthritis, whereas the control mice did not. These findings strongly suggest that a common epitope recognized by 1-5 antibody might be involved in the induction of arthritis.     

Monoclonal anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies of Igha BALB/c and Ighb C.B20 mice display striking similarities

Allotype Ighb congenic C.B20 mice when immunized with dextran B1355S are unable to produce anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies that express the VH-associated cross-reactive IdX idiotype. This intrastrain-specific idiotype is normally associated only with the anti-dextran response of Igha mice of which BALB/c is a prototype strain. In this study we have obtained monoclonal hybridoma antibodies specific for the alpha (1----3) glucosidic linkage of dextran from C.B20 mice that were presensitized with rabbit anti-IdX antibodies. These antibodies display the light chain isotype distribution, the H chain amino terminal sequence, share VH-associated IdX idiotypic determinants, and finally the similar fine specificity for dextrans observed for anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies of BALB/c mice.     

The majority of human monoclonal IgM rheumatoid factors express a "primary structure-dependent" cross-reactive idiotype

Genetic studies of human immunoglobulin variable regions have been hampered by the lack of anti-idiotypic antibodies that recognize specific heavy and light chain variable region sequences. Sixty percent of human monoclonal IgM anti-IgG autoantibodies (rheumatoid factors [RF]) from unrelated individuals share a cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) termed Wa. In previous experiments in which we used an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, we reported that a synthetic peptide (PSL2), corresponding to the second hypervariable region in the kappa light chain of a monoclonal IgM-RF (Sie), induced rabbit antibodies reactive with several RF paraproteins. In the present experiments, to avoid interference due to the human IgM-RF binding toward rabbit IgG, the reactivity of the anti-PSL2 antibody to the separated heavy and light chains of multiple IgM proteins and Bence-Jones proteins was assessed by the Western blot technique. The PSL2-induced anti-CRI reacted well with the separated kappa chains from 10 out of 12 IgM-RF, zero out of four light chains from IgM proteins lacking anti-IgG activity, and one out of six kappa Bence-Jones proteins. The results show that the PSL2-CRI is associated with RF and is not a kappa subgroup marker. Furthermore, a comparison of the reported light chain sequences of the PSL2-CRI-positive IgM-RF suggests that the majority of human IgM-RF light chains derive from a single germ-line VK gene or from a family of closely related VK genes that is highly conserved in the human population. Synthetic peptide-induced anti-CRI provide a potent tool for analyzing the genetic basis of CRI and abnormal autoantibody production in humans.     

Complete heavy and light chain variable region sequence of anti-arsonate monoclonal antibodies from BALB/c and A/J mice sharing the 36-60 idiotype are highly homologous

Structural and serologic studies on murine A/J monoclonal anti-arsonate antibodies resulted in the identification of a second idiotype family (Id36-60) in addition to the predominant idiotype family (IdCR). Id36-60, unlike IdCR, is a dominant idiotype in the BALB/c strain but is a "minor" idiotype in the A/J strain. The complete heavy and light chain variable region (VH and VL) amino acid sequences of a representative Id36-60 hybridoma protein from both the A/J and BALB/c strains have been determined. There are only four amino acid sequence differences between the VH of antibody 36-60 (A/J) and antibody 1210.7 (BALB/c). Two of these differences arise from single nucleotide changes in which the A/J and BALB/c Id36-60 VH germline gene sequences differ. The two other differences are the result of somatic mutation in hybridoma protein 36-60. In addition, Id36-60 heavy chains employ the same D and JH3 segments in both strains. The entire Vk2 VL of 36-60 and 1210.7 differ by only two amino acids, suggesting that like the heavy chains, they are derived from highly homologous VL genes. The same Jk segment is used in both antibodies. A comparison of the amino acid sequence data from Id36-60-bearing hybridomas suggests that a heavy chain amino acid difference accounts for the diminished arsonate binding by the 1210.7 hybridoma protein. Because the 1210.7 heavy chain is the unmutated product of the BALB/c VH gene, somatic mutation in VH may be required to enhance Ars affinity in this system.     

Characterization of monoclonal antibodies specific for sequential influenza A/PR/8/34 virus variants

A panel of monoclonal antibodies specific for a corresponding panel of sequentially selected variants of influenza A/PR/8/34 virus has been established. Although the monoclonal antibodies are paratypically distinct, idiotypic relatedness has been observed. Two cross-reactive idiotypes have been defined that are associated with the 7183 and S107 VH gene families, respectively. Three of the four monoclonal antibodies utilize the VK21 group of light chains, and three VH genes belong to the VH7183 family and one to the VH S107 family. Antibodies encoded by genes deriving from the VH7183 family share a cross-reactive idiotype, a marker of the VH region as well as distinct individual idiotopes. These antibodies are produced by different clones using related VH and VK genes.     

Idiotypic analysis of anti-GL phi antibodies. I. Identification and strain distribution of GL-1 idiotypes

We utilized both the inhibition of antigen binding and direct idiotype binding methods to identify a new set of common idiotype determinants on anti-GL antibodies of various mouse strains. Three anti-idiotypic antisera, each prepared against individually purified B10.WB anti-GL phi antibodies, were able to detect antibody-combining site-associated common idiotypic determinants, designated GL-1 idiotype(s), in antisera with GLT-binding activity obtained from all mouse strains except strains bearing Igh-1e allotype. Anti-GL phi antisera obtained from rabbits, guinea pigs, and rats did not express detectable levels of GL-1 idiotypes. Nonresponder mice to GL phi, upon immunization with GL-F gamma G or GL phi-F gamma G produced anti-GL antibodies expressing GL-1 idiotypes. Although the magnitude of the immune response to various GL-containing polymers is controlled by distinct Ir genes, the common GL-related antigenic determinants on these polymers are able to induce anti-GL antibodies with GL-1 idiotypic specificities.     

Many variable region genes are utilized in the antibody response of BALB/c mice to the influenza virus A/PR/8/34 hemagglutinin

We have examined how many different H chain variable (VH) and kappa-chain variable (Vk) germ-line genes are used in the antibody response to the influenza virus A/PR/8/34 hemagglutinin (PR8 HA), and have assessed how the expression of individual VH and/or Vk genes contributes to the generation of specificity for the HA. A panel of 51 hybridoma antibodies that recognize two antigenic regions on the HA were compared for the sequence of their Ig H and L chain V regions. The hybridomas were obtained from 28 individual BALB/c mice that had been immunized with PR8 under a variety of primary and secondary response immunization protocols. The degree and pattern of sequence similarity suggests that 29 different VH genes drawn from seven different VH gene families, and 25 different Vk genes drawn from 12 different Vk gene families were used in this panel. Based on current estimates of the total numbers of VH and Vk genes in the mouse, this suggests that between 2.5 and 10% of the entire VH and Vk germ-line repertoires were used by these hybridomas. Despite this extensive diversity, some V genes were repetitively identified among these hybridomas, and were most often expressed in the context of specific VH/Vk combinations. Because antibodies that used identical VH/Vk combinations also usually displayed similar reactivity patterns with a panel of mutant viruses, this indicates that VH/Vk pairing can be important in establishing the specificity of antibodies for the HA.     

Anti-idiotypic treatment of BALB/c mice induces CRIa-bearing suppressor cells with altered Igh-restricted function

The ABA-specific antibody response of A/J mice (Igh Ie) is dominated by the CRIa idiotype. In contrast, BALB/c mice (Igh Ia) do not produce CRIa-bearing anti-ABA antibodies after antigenic challenge. We have shown previously that treatment with rabbit anti-CRIa (R-anti-CRIa) induces the expression of "CRIa-like" anti-arsonate antibodies in BALB/c mice. In the present report, we demonstrate that R-anti-CRIa treatment enables BALB/c mice to respond to A/J ABA-specific first-order suppressor molecules (TsF1). Manipulated BALB/c also produced CRIa bearing ABA-specific immune response. Thus, R-anti-CRIa treatment induces a change in the characteristic Igh restriction pattern typically seen in this system. These data suggest that Igh restriction in the ABA-specific T suppressor cell pathway is the result of CRIa+ dominance in the T suppressor cell response of A/J mice. The effectiveness of idiotypic manipulation in inducing the expression of a given idiotype at both the B cell and T suppressor cell levels is discussed.