Behavioural responses of rats to gradual-fill carbon dioxide euthanasia and reduced oxygen concentrations

Carbon dioxide (CO₂) is widely used for euthanasia of laboratory rats, but little is known about the pain and distress caused by this procedure. Physiological and human self-report data suggest that CO₂ may cause pain and dyspnea, a sensation of breathlessness and increased respiratory effort, at the concentrations used for gradual-fill euthanasia. However, previous studies examining the behavioural responses of rats have reported conflicting results. In this study, detailed behavioural responses of rats were examined during gradual-fill CO₂ euthanasia and during gradual-fill with argon to produce a similar reduction in oxygen concentration. Animals were randomly allocated to the CO₂ or reduced oxygen treatment groups (n = 8 for both), and were first tested with air exposure and then with treatment gas exposure on the following day. Observations were taken for 105 s before and after gas flow began (baseline and exposure periods), as animals had ceased purposeful movement within 105 s of CO₂ flow starting. Behavioural changes from baseline during gas exposure were compared to changes during air exposure on control days. In comparison to air exposure, CO₂ resulted in increased activity, rearing, touching the nose to the chamber lid, escape behaviours and vocalizations. A small increase in touching the nose to the chamber lid was observed when oxygen concentrations were reduced with argon, but no other behavioural changes were observed. These results suggest that gradual-fill CO₂ euthanasia causes distress in rats, and that hypoxia alone is not a major cause of this distress.     

Rat aversion to isoflurane versus carbon dioxide

Some experts suggest that sedation of laboratory rodents with isoflurane before euthanasia with carbon dioxide (CO₂) is a humane alternative to euthanasia with CO₂ alone, but little research has compared aversion with these agents. Albino rats were tested in a light–dark box where they had the choice between remaining in a dark compartment filling with isoflurane or CO₂, or escaping to a lit compartment. Experiment 1 validated the procedure by confirming that rats responded to agent and light intensity. In experiment 2, 9/16 and 0/16 rats remained in the dark compartment until recumbent when initially exposed to isoflurane and CO₂, respectively. In experiment 3, more rats remained in the dark compartment until recumbent during initial (10/16) versus re-exposure (1/16) to isoflurane. These results indicate that initial exposure to CO₂ is more aversive than isoflurane, and that re-exposure to isoflurane is more aversive than initial exposure. We conclude that sedation with isoflurane is a refinement over euthanasia with CO₂ alone for rats that have not been previously exposed to inhalant anaesthetics.     

Combining Nitrous Oxide with Carbon Dioxide Decreases the Time to Loss of Consciousness during Euthanasia in Mice — Refinement of Animal Welfare?

Carbon dioxide (CO(2)) is the most commonly used euthanasia agent for rodents despite potentially causing pain and distress. Nitrous oxide is used in man to speed induction of anaesthesia with volatile anaesthetics, via a mechanism referred to as the "second gas" effect. We therefore evaluated the addition of Nitrous Oxide (N(2)O) to a rising CO(2) concentration could be used as a welfare refinement of the euthanasia process in mice, by shortening the duration of conscious exposure to CO2. Firstly, to assess the effect of N(2)O on the induction of anaesthesia in mice, 12 female C57Bl/6 mice were anaesthetized in a crossover protocol with the following combinations: Isoflurane (5%)+O(2) (95%); Isoflurane (5%)+N(2)O (75%)+O(2) (25%) and N(2)O (75%)+O(2) (25%) with a total flow rate of 3 l/min (into a 7 l induction chamber). The addition of N(2)O to isoflurane reduced the time to loss of the righting reflex by 17.6%. Secondly, 18 C57Bl/6 and 18 CD1 mice were individually euthanized by gradually filling the induction chamber with either: CO(2) (20% of the chamber volume.min-1); CO(2)+N(2)O (20 and 60% of the chamber volume.min(-1) respectively); or CO(2)+Nitrogen (N(2)) (20 and 60% of the chamber volume.min-1). Arterial partial pressure (P(a)) of O(2) and CO(2) were measured as well as blood pH and lactate. When compared to the gradually rising CO(2) euthanasia, addition of a high concentration of N(2)O to CO(2) lowered the time to loss of righting reflex by 10.3% (P<0.001), lead to a lower P(a)O(2) (12.55 ± 3.67 mmHg, P<0.001), a higher lactataemia (4.64 ± 1.04 mmol.l(-1), P = 0.026), without any behaviour indicative of distress. Nitrous oxide reduces the time of conscious exposure to gradually rising CO(2) during euthanasia and hence may reduce the duration of any stress or distress to which mice are exposed during euthanasia.     

A comparative analysis of carbon dioxide displacement rates for euthanasia of the ferret

Though carbon dioxide asphyxiation is a common method of euthanasia for laboratory animals, species-specific guidelines have not been established for this procedure in the domestic ferret (Mustela putorius furo). The authors investigated the efficacy and stress effects of carbon dioxide euthanasia in 24 ferrets that had participated in previous experimental protocols. They euthanized ferrets by placing them in cages that were either prefilled with carbon dioxide or gradually filled at a displacement rate of 10%, 20% or 50% of the cage volume per min. Blinded observers subjectively evaluated ferret distress. Prefilling the cage or filling it at a rate of 50% volume per min resulted in less time to recumbency and to last breath than did filling the cage at a slower displacement rate. Slower carbon dioxide displacement rates also caused an increase in ferret blood glucose concentrations, which may indicate distress. Overall, observers found that prefilling the euthanasia cage caused the least stress to ferrets.     

Euthanasia of rats with carbon dioxide--animal welfare aspects

A method of inducing euthanasia by carbon dioxide (CO2) inhalation in the home cage of an animal is described and tested for distress by behavioural as well as by hormonal measures. The animals were maintained in their home cage while CO2 was induced at a flow of 6 l/min. The behaviour of the animals was measured continuously as were the serum concentrations of glucose, ACTH and corticosterone 30, 75 and 120 s after the CO2 was introduced into the cage. In order to test for distress, two groups of rats were pre-treated with acepromazine (orally) and pentobarbiturate (i.p. injection) respectively, in order to reduce possible distress caused by CO2 euthanasia, and were compared with control groups. There were no signs of distress by behavioural or by hormonal changes. All changes seen could be attributed to experimental effects and, especially as there was no difference between the pre-treated and the control groups of rats, it must be assumed that the described method of euthanasia is in concordance with animal welfare, it leads to rapid death without severe distress or pain, and it seems therefore to be 'humane'.     

The behaviour of chickens, mice and rats during euthanasia with chloroform, carbon dioxide and ether

Euthanasia of chickens, young and mature rats, and mice was assessed using chloroform, carbon dioxide and ether. Behavioural patterns were recorded to give some indication of the stress involved. Carbon dioxide induced collapse faster (11.2 +/- 0.4 s) than chloroform (18.9 +/- 0.4 s) or ether (greater than 60 s). With regard to the time taken to death, in carbon dioxide mice had the shortest time (48 +/- 10 s) and mature rats had the longest time (135 +/- 10 s). In chloroform, the only difference was the delayed onset of death (127 +/- 10 s) in the chicken. Behavioural patterns were similar for the chicken in carbon dioxide and chloroform, except for wing flapping, even when unconscious, in carbon dioxide. Chloroform is recommended as more aesthetically acceptable for euthanasia of chickens. Carbon dioxide is recommended for the euthanasia of both rats and mice, considering behavioural criteria. Ether is unsuitable as a euthanasia method as it is dangerous, slow acting and an irritant.     

Is carbon dioxide (CO2) a useful short acting anaesthetic for small laboratory animals?

The anaesthetic effect of carbon dioxide (CO2) was investigated under predetermined exposure times in rats, mice and guinea pigs with admixture of 20% of oxygen (O2), and with 20% of ambient air in rats. In rats first symptoms (median) were detectable between 7 and 9.5 s, the induction time (median) varied between 16 and 20.5 s and the surgical tolerance (median) was 40 s (after 60 s of exposure) and 53.5 s (after 120 s of exposure) to 80% CO2/20% O2. When O2 was replaced by ambient air, a surgical tolerance of 53.5 s (after 60 s of exposure) and 77 s (after 120 s of exposure) was measured. In mice the induction time to 80% CO2/20% O2 was 10 s and the surgical tolerance 19.5 s (after 120 s of exposure). Guinea pigs showed an induction period of 20 s and a surgical tolerance of 50 s (after 30 s of exposure) to 80% CO2/O2. Recovery was short and smooth in all species. This method of general anaesthesia seems to be suitable for short and painful interventions, mainly in rats, but also in guinea pigs.     

Carbon dioxide for euthanasia: concerns regarding pain and distress, with special reference to mice and rats

Carbon dioxide (CO2) is the most commonly used agent for euthanasia of laboratory rodents, used on an estimated tens of millions of laboratory rodents per year worldwide, yet there is a growing body of evidence indicating that exposure to CO2 causes more than momentary pain and distress in these and other animals. We reviewed the available literature on the use of CO2 for euthanasia (as well as anaesthesia) and also informally canvassed laboratory animal personnel for their opinions regarding this topic. Our review addresses key issues such as CO2 flow rate and final concentration, presence of oxygen, and prefilled chambers (the animal is added to the chamber once a predetermined concentration and flow rate have been reached) versus gradual induction (the animal is put into an empty chamber and the gas agent(s) is gradually introduced at a fixed rate). Internationally, animal research standards specify that any procedure that would cause pain or distress in humans should be assumed to do so in non-human animals as well (Public Health Service 1986, US Department of Agriculture 1997, Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development 2000). European Union guidelines, however, specify a certain threshold of pain or distress, such as 'skilled insertion of a hypodermic needle', as the starting point at which regulation of the use of animals in experimental or other scientific procedures begins (Biotechnology Regulatory Atlas n.d.). There is clear evidence in the human literature that CO2 exposure is painful and distressful, while the non-human literature is equivocal. However, the fact that a number of studies do conclude that CO2 causes pain and distress in animals indicates a need for careful reconsideration of its use. Finally, this review offers recommendations for alternatives to the use of CO2 as a euthanasia agent.     

Gas Exchange of Algae: II. Effects of Oxygen, Helium, and Argon on the Photosynthesis of Chlorella pyrenoidosa

Changes in the oxygen partial pressure of air over the range of 8 to 258 mm of Hg did not adversely affect the photosynthetic capacity of Chlorella pyrenoidosa. Gas exchange and growth measurements remained constant for 3-week periods and were similar to air controls (oxygen pressure of 160 mm of Hg). Oxygen partial pressures of 532 and 745 mm of Hg had an adverse effect on algal metabolism. Carbon dioxide consumption was 24% lower in the gas mixture containing oxygen at a pressure 532 mm of Hg than in the air control, and the growth rate was slightly reduced. Oxygen at a partial pressure of 745 mm of Hg decreased the photosynthetic rate 39% and the growth rate 37% over the corresponding rates in air. The lowered metabolic rates remained constant during 14 days of measurements, and the effect was reversible after this time. Substitution of helium or argon for the nitrogen in air had no effect on oxygen production, carbon dioxide consumption, or growth rate for 3-week periods. All measurements were made at a total pressure of 760 mm of Hg, and all gas mixtures were enriched with 2% carbon dioxide. Thus, the physiological functioning and reliability of a photosynthetic gas exchanger should not be adversely affected by: (i) oxygen partial pressures ranging from 8 to 258 mm of Hg; (ii) the use of pure oxygen at reduced total pressure (155 to 258 mm of Hg) unless pressure per se affects photosynthesis, or (iii) the inclusion of helium or argon in the gas environment (up to a partial pressure of 595 mm of Hg).     

Comparative analysis of insect control by nitrogen, argon and carbon dioxide in museum, archive and herbarium collections

An investigation of insect control using non-toxic methods was carried out in museums, archives and herbaria in different climatic regions. The efficacy of using modified atmospheres including nitrogen, argon and carbon dioxide to eliminate insect families was evaluated. Analyses were performed on eight different species, and all their development stages, in the families Cerambicidae, Anobiidae, Dermestidae and Lyctidae in the Coleoptera. The modified atmospheres were used in several treatment systems, i.e. plastic bags of low permeability, a fumigation vacuum chamber and a fumigation bubble, and the most appropriate conditions for disinfestation of ancient objects were assessed. An argon atmosphere achieved the best results for insect elimination with a short exposure time. Different species of Coleoptera were found to be resistant to carbon dioxide. From this study, a model of insect control was used in situ for art and historical collections.     

Negative arterial-mixed expired PC02 gradient during acute and chronic hypercapnia.

In resting conscious dogs physiological dead space was calculated using the Bohr equation and measurements of arterial and mixed expired carbon dioxide tension. Whenever dogs inhaled carbon dioxide mixtures (5-10%) that had normal or low oxygen concentrations, the calculated dead space became negative. This paradox was based on the fact that the mixed expired carbon dioxide tension in resting hypercapnic dogs. Under these circumstances carbon dioxide was produced from the lung as measured by gas analyses and blood analyses. By the lung as measured by gas analyses and blood analyses. By reasoning this implies that "alveolar" carbon dioxide tension was higher than pulmonary venous carbon dioxide tension. The negative carbon dioxide gradient persisted at 14 days of chronic hypercapnia and reverted to normal within 10 min of breathing air after chronic hypercapnia. These findings suggest that the exchange of carbon dioxide in the lung cannot be explained solely on the basis of passive diffusion.     

Contribution to the Chemistry of Plasma-Activated Water

Plasma-activated water (PAW) was prepared by exposure to nonthermal plasma produced by a positive dc corona discharge in a transient spark regime. The activation of water was performed in atmosphere of various surrounding gases (air, nitrogen, carbon dioxide, and argon). This PAW retains its biological activity, measured on the mouse neuroblastoma cells culture, even after storage for more than one year. The highest hydrogen peroxide content was found for PAWs prepared in the atmospheres of argon or carbon dioxide, whereas the PAWs prepared in air and nitrogen exhibited lower hydrogen peroxide content. The acidity of PAWs mediated by nitric and nitrous acid formation displayed an opposite trend. It is concluded that the long-lasting biological effect of PAW is mediated by hydrogen peroxide in acid milieu only, whereas other possible active components decompose rapidly.     

A replacement for methoxyflurane (Metofane) in open-circuit anaesthesia

Methoxyflurane (Metofane) has been widely used as an open-circuit anaesthetic in small laboratory animals for several decades. Its low vapour pressure and high blood solubility have permitted its use in convenient and simple drop-chamber/nose-cone setups. Recently, following the decision by the primary manufacturer to discontinue production, it has become increasingly difficult to obtain methoxyflurane. We describe here a simple and effective adaptation of isoflurane, an excellent inhalation anaesthetic, to open-circuit drop-chamber/nose-cone anaesthesia. It was found that the vapour concentration of isoflurane could be continuously varied by dissolving the anaesthetic in propylene glycol and that a 20% solution produced effective anaesthesia such that in adult mice, 2 ml of 20% isoflurane in propylene glycol induced anaesthesia within 2 min in a one-litre drop chamber. Furthermore, anaesthesia maintenance with 20% isoflurane was tested in two sets of mice. In one set, surgical plane anaesthesia was maintained for 10 min in a head chamber. After removal of the chamber, the animals awoke within one minute and recovered without any indication of post-anaesthetic distress. The second set contained pregnant mice; here anaesthesia was maintained for between 10 and 12 min, during which laparotomy, exposure of one uterine horn, intrauterine injection and wound closure were completed. The recovery from anaesthesia was also within a minute and with no signs of distress. Healthy litters were delivered after a normal gestation. This isoflurane/propylene glycol procedure is simple, effective and humane, and is a good substitute for methoxyflurane.     

Nitrogen dioxide air pollution near ambient levels is an atherogenic risk primarily in obese subjects: a brief communication

Ambient exposure to nitrogen dioxide, a critical air pollutant in developed countries, is positively associated with cardiovascular mortality and morbidity. Although its cardiovascular effects are predominantly shown in patients with high risk of atherogenesis, no studies have elucidated whether daily exposure to nitrogen dioxide air pollution enhances atherogenic metabolisms, primarily in obese subjects who are susceptible to atherogenesis and subsequent cardiovascular diseases. We used male Otsuka Long-Evans Tokushima Fatty (OLETF) rats as obese subjects and Long-Evans Tokushima (LETO) rats as nonobese controls. The animals were continuously exposed to nitrogen dioxide at a concentration of 0, 0.16, 0.8, or 4.0 ppm from 8 weeks of age through 32 weeks. At 40 weeks of age, levels of body weight, triglyceride, and total cholesterol were significantly greater in the OLETF rats than in the LETO rats. A ratio of high-density lipoprotein (HDL) to total cholesterol was significantly smaller in the former than in the latter. In the LETO rats, nitrogen dioxide exposure significantly decreased only the levels of HDL as compared with clean air exposure. In the OLETF rats, however, nitrogen dioxide exposure at a concentration of 0.16 ppm significantly elevated triglyceride concentration and decreased the ratio of HDL to total cholesterol as well as the levels of HDL. Nitrogen dioxide air pollution near ambient levels is an atherogenic risk primarily in obese subjects.     

Precise Measurements of Carbon Dioxide Exchange by Illuminated Leaves near the Compensation Point

The results of precise measurements of rates of carbon dioxideassimilation at low external concentrations of carbon dioxideand of rates of carbon dioxide output into virtually carbondioxide-freeair show that linear extrapolations of the carbon dioxide intakecurve plotted against the external concentrations of carbondioxide give an exaggerated estimate of the rate of carbon dioxideoutput from illuminated leaves into carbon dioxide-free air. The shape of the exchange curve suggests that the rate of endogenousproduction of carbon dioxide changes at external concentrationsin the region of the carbon dioxide compensation point ().     

The effect of ketamine/xylazine and carbon dioxide on plasma luteinizing hormone releasing hormone and testosterone concentrations in the male Norway rat

The effect of a commonly used anaesthetic, ketamine/xylazine and/or carbon dioxide (CO(2)) on plasma luteinizing hormone releasing hormone (LHRH) and testosterone concentrations was determined in male Sprague-Dawley rats. These values were compared with values obtained from pre-anaesthetic control samples. Ketamine/xylazine treatment did not significantly affect testosterone concentrations. In contrast, LHRH started to decrease one hour after ketamine/xylazine administration and continued to significantly decrease after 24 h. In addition, in the CO(2) euthanasia-only group, LHRH concentrations were also significantly decreased. These results suggest that ketamine/xylazine anaesthesia followed by CO(2) euthanasia 24 h later is exerting a significant effect on LHRH concentrations 24 h after anaesthetizing, while only having a slight effect on testosterone, and that CO(2) is exerting an immediate significant effect on LHRH. In conclusion, LHRH analysis should be avoided after ketamine/xylazine anaesthesia and CO(2) euthanasia.     

Report of the 2006 RSPCA/UFAW Rodent Welfare Group meeting

The RSPCA/UFAW Rodent Welfare Group holds a one-day meeting every autumn to discuss current welfare research and to exchange views on rodent welfare issues. A key aim of the group is to encourage people to think about the lifetime experience of laboratory rodents, ensuring that every potential influence on their well-being has been reviewed and refined. Speakers at the 2006 meeting presented preliminary findings of ongoing studies and discussed regulatory updates. Topics included the housing and husbandry of mice and rats, refining the use of rodents in asthma research, good practice for the euthanasia of rodents using carbon dioxide and achieving reduction by sharing genetically modified mice.     

Extreme tolerance to ammonia fumes in African naked mole-rats: animals that naturally lack neuropeptides from trigeminal chemosensory nerve fibers

Naked mole-rats (Heterocephalus glaber) naturally lack neuropeptides associated with the signaling of chemical irritants from C type trigeminal nerve fibers. The goal of the present study was to assess behavioral responses of these animals to stimulation of the trigeminal chemosensory system, and to determine if stimulation would increase post-synaptic activity in the trigeminal nucleus, as seen in laboratory mice and rats. The results show that naked mole-rats are behaviorally insensitive to capsaicin solution applied to the nostrils and to ammonia fumes in a behavioral avoidance test. Centrally, the number of c Fos labeled cells in the spinal trigeminal nucleus increased from exposure to ammonia although the magnitude of the increase was less than for rats. The increase observed in naked mole-rats likely reflects activity from glutamate release, which appears insufficient to drive pain and aversion behaviors. The results support the idea that neuropeptides in the C fibers of the trigeminal system may be required to signal the aversive quality of specific chemical irritants. The natural lack of neuropeptides in naked mole-rats may be an adaptation to living in a challenging subterranean environment with extremely high levels of ammonia and carbon dioxide, stimuli known to excite trigeminal chemosensory C fibers.     

Microbial gas balance measurements: Basic interrelations and error estimation

The given paper represents formulae for calculation of oxygen consumption and of carbon dioxide formation in a microbial culture obtained from corrected measuring data of gas balance measurements. Basic relations between these measuring data the respiration quotient RQ were derived. The influence of measuring error to the accuracy of determination of oxygen consumption and of carbon dioxide formation at the analysis of gas concentrations and of air flow is discussed. It is shown that the determination of carbon dioxide formation rate is possible in many cultivation regimes with better accuracy than the determination of oxygen uptake rate.     

Comparison of Isoflurane and Carbon Dioxide Anesthesia in Chilean Rose Tarantulas (Grammostola rosea)

This study investigated the use of two anesthetic agents, isoflurane and carbon dioxide, in Chilean rose tarantulas (Grammostola rosea). We compared the onset, duration of anesthesia, and recovery time with both gases, and made observations regarding the effects of the anesthetic protocols. Subjectively, episodes for the isoflurane animals were uneventful. The spiders were calm throughout and did not respond adversely to gas exposure. Conversely, animals anesthetized with carbon dioxide experienced violent inductions and recoveries; the tarantulas appeared agitated when the carbon dioxide flow began. Seizure‐like activity and defecation would frequently be noted prior to induction with carbon dioxide. Neither isoflurane nor carbon dioxide seemed to have any clinically apparent short‐ or long‐term impact. The animals were all normal for at least 1‐year postexperiment. Future studies should focus on defining the impact, if any, that these anesthetic agents have on the health of invertebrate species. Zoo Biol. 32:101‐103, 2013. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.