Substrate specificity of insect trypsins and the role of their subsites in catalysis

Trypsins have high sequence similarity, although the responses of insect trypsins to chemical and natural inhibitors suggest they differ in specificities. Purified digestive trypsins from insects of four different orders were assayed with internally quenched fluorescent oligopeptides with two different amino acids at P1 (Arg/Lys) and 15 amino acid replacements in positions P1', P2', P2, and P3. The binding energy (deltaG(s), calculated from Km values) and the activation energy (deltaG(T)(double dagger), determined from kcat/Km values) were calculated. Dictyoptera, Coleoptera and Diptera trypsins hydrolyze peptides with Arg at P1 at least 3 times more efficiently than peptides with Lys at P1, whereas Lepidoptera trypsins have no preference between Arg and Lys at that position. The hydrophobicities of each subsite were calculated from the efficiency of hydrolysis of the different amino acid replacements at that subsite. The results suggested that insect trypsin subsites become progressively more hydrophobic along evolution. Apparently, this is an adaptation to resist plant protein inhibitors, which usually have polar residues at their reactive sites. Results also suggested that, at least in lepidopteran trypsins, S3, S2, S1', and S2' significantly bind the substrate ground state, whereas in the transition state only S1' and S2' do that, supporting aspects of the presently accepted mechanism of trypsin catalysis. Homology modeling showed differences among those trypsins that may account for the varied kinetic properties.     

Subsites of trypsin active site favor catalysis or substrate binding.

Enzymes enhance chemical reaction rates by lowering the activation energy, the energy barrier of the reaction leading to products. This occurs because enzymes bind the high-energy intermediate of the reaction (the transition state) more strongly than the substrate. We studied details of this process by determining the substrate binding energy (DeltaG(s), calculated from K(m) values) and the activation energy (DeltaG(T), determined from k(cat)/K(m) values) for the trypsin-catalyzed hydrolysis of oligopeptides. Plots of DeltaG(T) versus DeltaG(s) for oligopeptides with 15 amino acid replacements at each of the positions P(1)', P(1), and P(2) were straight lines, as predicted by a derived equation that relates DeltaG(T) and DeltaG(s). The data led to the conclusion that the trypsin active site has subsites that bind moieties of substrate and of transition state in characteristic ratios, whichever substrate is used. This was unexpected and means that each subsite characteristically favors substrate binding or catalysis.     

Subsite preferences of pepstatin-insensitive carboxyl proteinases from prokaryotes: kumamolysin, a thermostable pepstatin-insensitive carboxyl proteinase

Kumamolysin, a carboxyl proteinase from Bacillus novosp. MN-32, is characterized by its thermostability and insensitivity to aspartic proteinase inhibitors such as pepstatin, diazoacetyl-DL-norleucine methylester, and 1,2-epoxy-3-(p-nitro-phenoxy)propane. Here, its substrate specificity was elucidated using two series of synthetic chromogenic substrates: P(5)-P(4)-P(3)-P(2)-Phe*Nph (p-nitrophenylalanine: *cleavage site)-P(2)'-P(3)', in which the amino acid residues at the P(5)-P(2), P(2)' and P(3)' positions were systematically substituted. Among 74 substrates, kumamolysin was shown to hydrolyze Lys-Pro-Ile-Pro-Phe-Nph-Arg-Leu most effectively. The kinetic parameters of this peptide were K(m) = 41+/-5 microM, k(cat) = 176+/- 10 s(-1), and k(cat)/K(m) = 4.3+/-0.6 mM(-1) x s(-1). These systematic analyses revealed the following features: (i) Kumamolysin had a unique preference for the P(2) position. Kumamolysin preferentially hydrolyzed peptides having an Ala or Pro residue at the P(2) position; this was also observed for the pepstatin-insensitive carboxyl proteinase from Bacillus coagulans J-4 [J-4; Shibata et al. (1998) J. Biochem. 124, 642-647]. Other carboxyl proteinases, including Pseudomonas sp. 101 pepstatin-insensitive carboxyl proteinase (PCP) and Xanthomonas sp. T-22 pepstatin-insensitive carboxyl proteinase (XCP), preferred peptides having hydrophobic and bulky amino acid residue such as Leu at the P(2) position. (ii) Kumamolysin preferred such charged amino acid residues as Glu or Arg at the P(2)' position, suggesting that the S(2)' subsite of kumamolysin is occupied by hydrophilic residues, similar to that of PCP, XCP, and J-4. In general, the S(2)' subsite of pepstatin-sensitive carboxyl proteinases (aspartic proteinases) is hydrophobic in nature. Thus, the hydrophilic nature of the S(2)' subsite was confirmed to be a distinguishing feature of pepstatin-insensitive carboxyl proteinases from prokaryotes.     

Substrate-based design of reversible Pin1 inhibitors

Human Pin1, a peptidyl-prolyl cis/trans isomerase with high specificity to -Ser/Thr(PO(3)H(2))-Pro- motifs, is required for cell cycle progression. In an effort to design reversible Pin1 inhibitors by using a substrate structure based approach, a panel of peptides were applied to systematically analyze the minimal structural requirements for Pin1 substrate recognition. Pin1 catalysis (k(cat)/K(m) < 5 mM(-1) s(-1)) for Ala-Pro, Ser-Pro, and Ser(PO(3)H(2))-Pro was detected using direct UV-visible spectrophotometric detection of prolyl isomerization, while weak competitive inhibition of Pin1 by these dipeptides was observed (K(i) > 1 mM). Substrates with chain lengths extending from either the P2 to P1' or the P1 to P2' subsite gave k(cat)/K(m) values of 100 mM(-1) s(-1) for Ala-Ser(PO(3)H(2))-Pro and 38 mM(-1) s(-1) for Ser(PO(3)H(2))-Pro-Arg. For both Pin1 and its yeast homologue Ess1, the optimal subsite recognition elements comprise five amino acid residues with the essential Ser(PO(3)H(2)) in the middle position. The resulting substrate Ac-Ala-Ala-Ser(PO(3)H(2))-Pro-Arg-NH-4-nitroanilide possesses a very low cis/trans interconversion barrier in the presence of either Pin1 or Ess1, with k(cat)/K(m) = 9300 mM(-1) s(-1) and 12000 mM(-1) s(-1), respectively. The D-Ser(PO(3)H(2)) residue preceding proline could serve as a substrate-deactivating determinant without compromising ground state affinity. Similarly, substitution of the amide bond preceding proline with a thioxo amide bond produces a potent inhibitor. Pin1 is reversibly inhibited by such substrate analogue inhibitors with IC(50) values in the low micromolar range. The D-amino acid containing inhibitor also exhibits remarkable stability against phosphatase activity in cell lysate.     

Carboxy-monopeptidase substrate specificity of human cathepsin X

Cathepsin X is a papain-like cysteine protease with restricted positional specificity, acting primarily as a carboxy-monopeptidase. We mapped the specificities at the S2, S1, and S1' subsites of human cathepsin X by systematically and independently substituting the P2, P1, and P1' positions of the carboxy-monopeptidase substrate Abz-FRF(4NO(2)) with natural amino acids. Human cathepsin X has broad S2, S1, and S1' specificities within two orders of magnitude in k(cat)/K(M), excluding proline that is not tolerated at these subsites. Glycine is not favored in S2, but is among the preferred residues in S1 and S1', which highlights S2 as the affinity-determinant subsite. The presence of peculiar residues at several binding site positions (Asp76, His234, Asn75, and Glu72) does not translate into a markedly different sequence specificity profile relative to other human cathepsins. These findings suggest that a specific function of human cathepsin X is unlikely to result from sequence specificity, but rather from a combination of its unique positional specificity and the co-localization of enzyme and substrate in a specific cellular environment.     

Defining the substrate specificity of mouse cathepsin P

Cathepsin P is a recently discovered placental cysteine protease that is structurally related to the more ubiquitously expressed, broad-specificity enzyme, cathepsin L. We studied the substrate specificity requirements of recombinant mouse cathepsin P using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) peptides derived from the lead sequence Abz-KLRSSKQ-EDDnp (Abz, ortho-aminobenzoic acid and EDDnp, N-[2,4-dinitrophenyl]ethylenediamine). Systematic modifications were introduced resulting in five series of peptides to map the S(3) to S(2)(') subsites of the enzyme. The results indicate that the subsites S(1), S(2), S(1)('), and S(2)('), present a clear preference for hydrophobic residues. The specificity requirements of the S(2) subsite were found to be more restricted, preferring hydrophobic aliphatic amino acids. The S(3) subsite of the enzyme presents a broad specificity, accepting negatively charged (Glu), positively charged (Lys, Arg), and hydrophobic aliphatic or aromatic residues (Val, Phe). For several substrates, the activity of cathepsin P was markedly regulated by kosmotropic salts, particularly Na(2)SO(4). No significant effect on secondary or tertiary structure could be detected by either circular dichroism or size exclusion chromatography, indicating that the salts most probably disrupt unfavorable ionic interactions between the substrate and enzyme active site. A substrate based upon the preferred P(3) to P(2)(') defined by the screening study, ortho-aminobenzoic-Glu-Ile-Phe-Val-Phe-Lys-Gln-N-(2,4-dinitrophenyl)ethylenediamine (cleaved at the Phe-Val bond) was efficiently hydrolyzed in the absence of high salt. The k(cat)/K(m) for this substrate was almost two orders of magnitude higher than that of the original parent compound. These results show that cathepsin P, in contrast to other mammalian cathepsins, has a restricted catalytic specificity.     

High affinity small protein inhibitors of human chymotrypsin C (CTRC) selected by phage display reveal unusual preference for P4' acidic residues

Human chymotrypsin C (CTRC) is a pancreatic protease that participates in the regulation of intestinal digestive enzyme activity. Other chymotrypsins and elastases are inactive on the regulatory sites cleaved by CTRC, suggesting that CTRC recognizes unique sequence patterns. To characterize the molecular determinants underlying CTRC specificity, we selected high affinity substrate-like small protein inhibitors against CTRC from a phage library displaying variants of SGPI-2, a natural chymotrypsin inhibitor from Schistocerca gregaria. On the basis of the sequence pattern selected, we designed eight inhibitor variants in which amino acid residues in the reactive loop at P1 (Met or Leu), P2' (Leu or Asp), and P4' (Glu, Asp, or Ala) were varied. Binding experiments with CTRC revealed that (i) inhibitors with Leu at P1 bind 10-fold stronger than those with P1 Met; (ii) Asp at P2' (versus Leu) decreases affinity but increases selectivity, and (iii) Glu or Asp at P4' (versus Ala) increase affinity 10-fold. The highest affinity SGPI-2 variant (K(D) 20 pm) bound to CTRC 575-fold tighter than the parent molecule. The most selective inhibitor variant exhibited a K(D) of 110 pm and a selectivity ranging from 225- to 112,664-fold against other human chymotrypsins and elastases. Homology modeling and mutagenesis identified a cluster of basic amino acid residues (Lys(51), Arg(56), and Arg(80)) on the surface of human CTRC that interact with the P4' acidic residue of the inhibitor. The acidic preference of CTRC at P4' is unique among pancreatic proteases and might contribute to the high specificity of CTRC-mediated digestive enzyme regulation.     

Extended binding inhibitors of chymotrypsin that interact with leaving group subsites S1'-S3'

We have synthesized inhibitors of chymotrypsin, based on fluoromethyl ketones, that bind at S and S' subsites. "Small" inhibitors of serine proteases, which have previously been synthesized, only interact with S subsites. The parent compound is Ac-Leu-ambo-Phe-CF2H (1) (Ki = 25 X 10(-6) M). This inhibitor was modified by successively replacing H of the -CF2H group by -CH2CH2CONHCH3, (4), -CH2CH2CONH-Leu-NHMe (5), -CH2CH2CONH-Leu-Val-OEt (6), and -CH2CH2CONH-Leu-Arg-OMe (7). Corresponding Ki values are 7.8 (4), 0.23 (5), 0.21 (6), and 0.014 (7) microM. Extending 5 to 6 by addition of Val-OEt at P3' does not decrease Ki. In contrast, extension of 5 to 7 by incorporating Arg-OMe at P3' decreases Ki approximately 15-fold, suggesting interaction between Arg and the S3' subsite but no corresponding interaction at that subsite with Val. These results are in accordance with results obtained with the homologous family of avian ovomucoid third domain proteins. Proteins with Arg at the P3' position show highly favorable interactions with the protease at the S3' subsite [Park, S. J. (1985) Ph.D. Thesis, Purdue University; M. Laskowski, Jr., personal communication]. These results establish that incorporation of residues which interact with S' subsites significantly increases the efficacy of inhibitors and that valuable information concerning the most effective amino acid composition of small inhibitors can be obtained from the amino acid sequence of protein inhibitors.     

Study on substrate specificity at subsites for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 3CL protease

Autocleavage assay and peptide-based cleavage assay were used to study the substrate specificity of 3CL protease from the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus. It was found that the recognition between the enzyme and its substrates involved many positions in the substrate, at least including residues from P4 to P2＇. The deletion of either P4 or P2＇ residue in the substrate would decrease its cleavage efficiency dramatically. In contrast to the previous suggestion that only small residues in substrate could be accommodated to the S 1＇ subsite, we have found that bulky residues such as Tyr and Trp were also acceptable. In addition, based on both peptide-based assay and autocleavage assay, Ile at the PI＇ position could not be hydrolyzed, but the mutant L27A could hydrolyze the Ile peptide fragment. It suggested that there was a stereo hindrance between the S 1＇ subsite and the side chain of Ile in the substrate. All 20 amino acids except Pro could be the residue at the P2＇ position in the substrate, but the cleavage efficiencies were clearly different. The specificity information of the enzyme is helpful for potent anti-virus inhibitor design and useful for other coronavirus studies.     

Novel, potent P2-P3 pyrrolidine derivatives of ketoamide-based cathepsin K inhibitors

Starting from a potent pantolactone ketoamide cathepsin K inhibitor discovered from structural screening, conversion of the lactone scaffold to a pyrrolidine scaffold allowed exploration of the S(3) subsite of cathepsin K. Manipulation of P3 and P1' groups afforded potent inhibitors with drug-like properties.     

Kinetic and modeling studies of S3-S3' subsites of HIV proteinases.

Kinetic analysis and modeling studies of HIV-1 and HIV-2 proteinases were carried out using the oligopeptide substrate [formula: see text] and its analogs containing single amino acid substitutions in P3-P3' positions. The two proteinases acted similarly on the substrates except those having certain hydrophobic amino acids at P2, P1, P2', and P3' positions (Ala, Leu, Met, Phe). Various amino acids seemed to be acceptable at P3 and P3' positions, while the P2 and P2' positions seemed to be more restrictive. Polar uncharged residues resulted in relatively good binding at P3 and P2 positions, while at P2' and P3' positions they gave very high Km values, indicating substantial differences in the respective S and S' subsites of the enzyme. Lys prevented substrate hydrolysis at any of the P2-P2' positions. The large differences for subsite preference at P2 and P2' positions seem to be at least partially due to the different internal interactions of P2 residue with P1', and P2' residue with P1. As expected on the basis of amino acid frequency in the naturally occurring cleavage sites, hydrophobic residues at P1 position resulted in cleavable peptides, while polar and beta-branched amino acids prevented hydrolysis. On the other hand, changing the P1' Pro to other amino acids prevented substrate hydrolysis, even if the substituted amino acid had produced a good substrate in other oligopeptides representing naturally occurring cleavage sites. The results suggest that the subsite specificity of the HIV proteinases may strongly depend on the sequence context of the substrate.     

S(1)' and S(2)' subsite specificities of human plasma kallikrein and tissue kallikrein 1 for the hydrolysis of peptides derived from the bradykinin domain of human kininogen

The S(1)' and S(2)' subsite specificities of human tissue kallikrein 1 (KLK1) and human plasma kallikrein (HPK) were examined with the peptide series Abz-GFSPFRXSRIQ-EDDnp and Abz-GFSPFRSXRIQ-EDDnp [X=natural amino acids or S(PO(3)H(2))]. KLK1 efficiently hydrolyzed most of the peptides except those containing negatively charged amino acids at P(1)' and P(2)' positions. Abz-GFSPFRSSRIQ-EDDnp, as in human kininogen, is the best substrate for KLK1 and exclusively cleaved the R-S bond. All other peptides were cleaved also at the F-R bond. The synthetic human kininogen segment Abz-MISLMKRPPGFSPFRS(390)S(391)RI-NH(2) was hydrolyzed by KLK1 first at R-S and then at M-K bonds, releasing Lys-bradykinin. In the S(390) and S(391) phosphorylated analogs, this order of hydrolysis was inverted due to the higher resistance of the R-S bond. Abz-MISLMKRPPG-FSPFRSS(PO(3)H(2))(391)RI-NH(2) was hydrolyzed by KLK1 at M-K and mainly at the F-R bond, releasing des-(Arg(9))-Lys-Bk which is a B1 receptor agonist. HPK cleaved all the peptides at R and showed restricted specificity for S in the S(1)' subsite, with lower specificity for the S(2)' subsite. Abz-MISLMKRPPGFSPFRSSRI-NH(2) was efficiently hydrolyzed by HPK under bradykinin release, while the analogs containing S(PO(3)H(2)) were poorly hydrolyzed. In conclusion, S(1)' and S(2)' subsite specificities of KLK1 and HPK showed peculiarities that were observed with substrates containing the amino acid sequence of human kininogen.     

Substrate specificity of beta-collagenase from Clostridium histolyticum

The substrate specificity of beta-collagenase from Clostridium histolyticum has been investigated by measuring the rate of hydrolysis of more than 50 tri-, tetra-, penta-, and hexapeptides covering the P3 to P3' subsites of the substrate. The choice of peptides was patterned after sequences found in the alpha 1 and alpha 2 chains of type I collagen. Each peptide contained either a 2-furanacryloyl (FA) or cinnamoyl (CN) group in subsite P2 or the 4-nitrophenylalanine (Nph) residue in subsite P1. Hydrolysis of the P1-P1' bond produces an absorbance change in these chromophoric peptides that has been used to quantitate the rates of their hydrolysis under first order conditions ([S] much less than KM) from kcat/KM values have been obtained. The identity of the amino acids in all six subsites (P3-P3') markedly influences the hydrolysis rates. In general, the best substrates have Gly in subsites P3 and P1', Pro or Ala in subsite P2', and Hyp, Arg, or Ala in subsite P3'. This corresponds well with the frequency of occurrence of these residues in the Gly-X-Y triplets of collagen. In contrast, the most rapidly hydrolyzed substrates do not have residues from collagen-like sequences in subsites P2 and P1. For example, CN-Nph-Gly-Pro-Ala is the best known substrate for beta-collagenase with a kcat/KM value of 4.4 X 10(7) M-1 min-1, in spite of the fact that there is neither Pro nor Ala in P2 or Hyp nor Ala in P1. These results indicate that the previously established rules for the substrate specificity of the enzyme require modification.     

Substrate specificity of the streptococcal cysteine protease.

The streptococcal pyrogenic exotoxin B (SpeB) is an important factor in mediating Streptococcus pyogenes infections. SpeB is the zymogen of the streptococcal cysteine protease (SCP), of which relatively little is known regarding substrate specificity. To investigate this aspect of SCP function, a series of internally quenched fluorescent substrates was designed based on the cleavage sites identified in the autocatalytic processing of SpeB to mature SCP. The best substrates for SCP contain three amino acids in the nonprimed position (i.e. AIK in P(3)-P(2)-P(1)). Varying the length of the substrate on the primed side of the scissile bond has a relatively lower effect on activity. The highest activity (k(cat)/K(M) = 2.8 +/- 0.6 (10(5) x m(-1)s(-1)) is observed for the pentamer 3-aminobenzoic acid-AIKAG-3-nitrotyrosine, which spans subsites S(3) to S(2)' on the enzyme. High pressure liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry analyses show that the substrates are cleaved at the site predicted from the autoprocessing experiments. These results show that SCP can display an important level of endopeptidase activity. Substitutions at position P(2) of the substrate clearly indicate that the S(2) subsite of SCP can readily accommodate substrates containing a hydrophobic residue at that position and that some topological preference exists for that subsite. Substitutions in positions P(3), P(1), and P(1)' had little or no effect on SCP activity. The substrate specificity outlined in this work further supports the similarity between SCP and the cysteine proteases of the papain family. From the data regarding the identified or proposed natural substrates for SCP, it appears that this substrate specificity profile may also apply to the processing of mammalian and streptococcal protein targets by SCP.     

Effect of secondary substrate binding in penicillopepsin: contributions of subsites S3 and S2' to kcat

The kinetic parameters kcat, KM, and kcat/KM were determined at 25 degrees C and pH 4.5, 5.5, and 6.0 for the series of penicillopepsin substrates Ac-Alam-Lys-(NO2)Phe-Alan-amide, where (NO2)Phe is p-nitrophenylalanine and m and n equal 0-3. KM values at pH 6.0 were the same for all 12 peptides and averaged 0.088 +/- 0.02 mM but increased to different degrees at lower pH. In contrast, kcat values increased with increasing chain length. At pH 6 and at the pH optimum of kcat, the largest increases (about 37-fold on average) were obtained when alanine residues were added in positions P2' and P3. Only 1-2-fold increases were observed for positions P2, P3', P4, and P4'. These results show that occupation of subsites S2' and S3 is largely responsible for the rate enhancements caused by secondary substrate interactions with this series of peptides. Additional support for an important role of subsite S3 comes from the observation that the two peptides where m = 1 and n = 1 or 2, respectively, are cleaved not only between lysine and p-nitrophenylalanine but also between the latter and alanine, suggesting that occupation of subsite S3 by the N-terminal alanine overcomes the unfavorable interaction of alanine in subsite P1'. Subsite S3 is also important in the binding of pepstatin analogues and in transpeptidation reactions. It is proposed that the roles of subsites S3 and S2' are to facilitate the conversion of the first enzyme-substrate complex into a productive complex and to assist in the distortion of the scissile bond.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Substrate analog inhibitors of HIV-1 protease containing phenylnorstatine as a transition state element

Substrates of HIV-1 protease are classified into three groups (A, B and C) based on the amino acid residues present at P1' and P2' sites. Replacement of the scissile amide bond by phenylnorstatine in representative substrate analog sequences from class A, B and C, yielded inhibitors of HIV-1 protease. Of the twelve inhibitors synthesized in this series, class C substrate analog inhibitors are more potent inhibitors (Ki's 3.3-24 microM) than either class A or class B inhibitors. In this series of inhibitors, the (2S,3S) isomer of phenylnorstatine is preferred over the other isomers as a "transition state element" for design of inhibitors of HIV-1 protease.     

Substrate binding mode and its implication on drug design for botulinum neurotoxin A

The seven antigenically distinct serotypes of Clostridium botulinum neurotoxins, the causative agents of botulism, block the neurotransmitter release by specifically cleaving one of the three SNARE proteins and induce flaccid paralysis. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has declared them as Category A biowarfare agents. The most potent among them, botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNT/A), cleaves its substrate synaptosome-associated protein of 25 kDa (SNAP-25). An efficient drug for botulism can be developed only with the knowledge of interactions between the substrate and enzyme at the active site. Here, we report the crystal structures of the catalytic domain of BoNT/A with its uncleavable SNAP-25 peptide (197)QRATKM(202) and its variant (197)RRATKM(202) to 1.5 A and 1.6 A, respectively. This is the first time the structure of an uncleavable substrate bound to an active botulinum neurotoxin is reported and it has helped in unequivocally defining S1 to S5' sites. These substrate peptides make interactions with the enzyme predominantly by the residues from 160, 200, 250 and 370 loops. Most notably, the amino nitrogen and carbonyl oxygen of P1 residue (Gln197) chelate the zinc ion and replace the nucleophilic water. The P1'-Arg198, occupies the S1' site formed by Arg363, Thr220, Asp370, Thr215, Ile161, Phe163 and Phe194. The S2' subsite is formed by Arg363, Asn368 and Asp370, while S3' subsite is formed by Tyr251, Leu256, Val258, Tyr366, Phe369 and Asn388. P4'-Lys201 makes hydrogen bond with Gln162. P5'-Met202 binds in the hydrophobic pocket formed by the residues from the 250 and 200 loop. Knowledge of interactions between the enzyme and substrate peptide from these complex structures should form the basis for design of potent inhibitors for this neurotoxin.     

Coevolution and subsite decomposition for the design of resistance-evading HIV-1 protease inhibitors

Drug resistance sharply limits the effectiveness of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) protease inhibitors in acquired immunodeficiency syndrome therapy. In previous work, we presented methods for design of resistance-evading inhibitors using a computational coevolution technique. Here, we report subsite decomposition experiments that examine the relative importance and roles of each subsite in HIV protease, and the constraints on robust inhibitor design that are imposed by possible resistance mutations in each subsite. The results identify several structural features of robust resistance-evading inhibitors for use in drug design, and show their basis in the constraints imposed by the range of allowable mutation in the protease. In particular, the results identify the P3 and P3' sites as being particularly sensitive to protease mutation: inhibitors designed to fill the S3 and S3' sites of the wild-type protease will be susceptible to viral resistance, but inhibitors with side-chains smaller than a phenylalanine residue at P3 and P3', preferably medium-sized amino acids in the range from valine to leucine and isoleucine residues, will be more robust in the face of protease resistance mutation.     

Studies on the subsite specificity of rat nardilysin (N-arginine dibasic convertase)

The subsite specificity of rat nardilysin was investigated using fluorogenic substrates of the type 2-aminobenzoyl-GGX(1)X(2)RKX(3)GQ-ethylenediamine-2,4- dinitrophenyl, where P(2), P(2)', and P(3) residues were varied. (The nomenclature of Schechter and Berger (Schechter, I., and Berger, A. (1967) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 27, 157-162) is used where cleavage of a peptide occurs between the P(1) and P(1)' residues, and adjacent residues are designated P(2), P(3), P(2)', P(3)', etc.) There was little effect on K(m) among different residues at any of these positions. In contrast, residues at each position affected k(cat), with P(2) residues having the greatest effect. The S(3), S(2), and S(2)' subsites differed in their amino acid preference. Tryptophan and serine, which produced poor substrates at the P(2) position, were among the best P(2)' residues. The specificity at P(3) was generally opposite that of P(2). Residues at P(2), and to a lesser extent at P(3), influenced the cleavage site. At the P(2) position, His, Phe, Tyr, Asn, or Trp produced cleavage at the amino side of the first basic residue. In contrast, a P(2) Ile or Val produced cleavage between the dibasic pair. Other residues produced intermediate effects. The pH dependence for substrate binding showed that the enzyme prefers to bind a protonated histidine. A comparison of the effect of arginine or lysine at the P(1)' or P(1) position showed that there is a tendency to cleave on the amino side of arginine and that this cleavage produces the highest k(cat) values.