Mapping of the active site of alcohol dehydrogenase with low-molecular ligands

In search of an active alcohol dehydrogenase inhibitor, the structure of which may serve as the basis for a potential drug design, the active site of alcohol dehydrogenase containing NAD and Zn²⁺ ions was mapped using the method of molecular mechanics. Molecular docking was performed using a number of ligands containing characteristic functional groups: formate ion, ammonia, ammonium ion, methanol, and methylamine. Sites of preferable binding were revealed for each ligand and arranged in order of decreasing energy of binding to the enzyme. A comparison of the predicted ligand-binding sites and the experimental data on the location of water and inhibitor binding sites in the known structures of corresponding alcohol dehydrogenase complexes indicated a coincidence of the complex formation sites, which confirms the validity of the method and provides the requirements for a highly effective inhibitor (the pharmacophore model).     

Coenzyme binding in alcohol dehydrogenase

Crystallographic investigations of horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase have demonstrated that NAD is not a passive participant in the redox reactions catalysed by the enzyme. On the molecular level NAD acts as an activator which induces an active form of the enzyme. This is mediated by a large conformational change, making the active site dehydrated and by providing one part of the substrate-binding cleft. The catalytic events, substrate binding, inhibitor binding and the role of the catalytic zinc ion are discussed in relation to the role of NAD. Human alcohol dehydrogenase isoenzymes which have very different substrate specificities are discussed in relation to sequence differences.     

Complete amino acid sequence and characterization of the reaction mechanism of a glucosamine-induced novel alcohol dehydrogenase from Agrobacterium radiobacter (tumefaciens)

A glucosamine-induced novel alcohol dehydrogenase has been isolated from Agrobacterium radiobacter (tumefaciens) and its fundamental properties have been characterized. The enzyme catalyzes NAD-dependent dehydrogenation of aliphatic alcohols and amino alcohols. In this work, the complete amino acid sequence of the alcohol dehydrogenase was determined by PCR method using genomic DNA of A. radiobacter as template. The enzyme comprises 336 amino acids and has a molecular mass of 36 kDa. The primary structure of the enzyme demonstrates a high homology to structures of alcohol dehydrogenases from Shinorhizobium meliloti (83% identity, 90% positive) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (65% identity, 76% positive). The two Zn(2+) ion binding sites, both the active site and another site that contributed to stabilization of the enzyme, are conserved in those enzymes. Sequences analysis of the NAD-dependent dehydrogenase family using a hypothetical phylogenetic tree indicates that these three enzymes form a new group distinct from other members of the Zn-containing long-chain alcohol dehydrogenase family. The physicochemical properties of alcohol dehydrogenase from A. radiobacter were characterized as follows. (1) Stereospecificity of the hydride transfer from ethanol to NADH was categorized as pro-R type by NMR spectra of NADH formed in the enzymatic reaction using ethanol-D(6) was used as substrate. (2) Optimal pH for all alcohols with no amino group examined was pH 8.5 (of the C(2)-C(6) alcohols, n-amyl alcohol demonstrated the highest activity). Conversely, glucosaminitol was optimally dehydrogenated at pH 10.0. (3) The rate-determining step of the dehydrogenase for ethanol is deprotonation of the enzyme-NAD-Zn-OHCH(2)CH(3) complex to enzyme-NAD-Zn-O(-)CH(2)CH(3) complex and that for glucosaminitol is H(2)O addition to enzyme-Zn-NADH complex.     

Alcohol dehydrogenase from the fruitfly Drosophila melanogaster. Inhibition studies of the alleloenzymes AdhS and AdhUF

Different metal binding inhibitors of horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase, similarly affect the Drosophila melanogaster AdhS and AdhUF alleloenzymes. However, binding is generally weaker and the experiments show that the alleloenzymes although not zinc metalloenzymes, behave to the metal binding reagents very much as if they were. The metal-directed, affinity-labelling, imidazole derivative BrImPpOH reversibly inhibits, but does not inactivate the alleolenzymes. This confirms there is no active site metal atom with cysteine as a metal ligand, as found in zinc alcohol dehydrogenases. Pyrazole is a strong ethanol-competitive inhibitor of AdhS and AdhUF alleloenzymes. Formation of the ternary enzyme-NAD-pyrazole complex gives an absorption increase between 295-330 nm. This enables an active site titration to be performed and the determination of epsilon (305 nm) of 15.8 . 10(3) M-1 . cm-1. Inhibition experiments with imidazole confirm that with secondary alcohols such as propan-2-ol, a Theorell-Chance mechanism predominates, but with ethanol and primary alcohols, interconversion of the ternary complexes is rate limiting. Salicylate is a coenzyme competitive inhibitor and KEI suggests that the coenzyme adenosine binding region is similar is Drosophila and horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase. Drosophila alcohol dehydrogenase is found not to form a ternary complex with NADH and isobutyramide. In this and other properties it is like carboxymethyl liver alcohol dehydrogenase. Both Drosophila and carboxymethyl alcohol dehydrogenase bind coenzyme in a similar manner to native horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase, but substrate binding differs between each. Inhibition by Cibacrone blue, indicates that amino acid 192 which is lysine in AdhS and threonine in AdhUF, is located in the coenzyme-binding region. Proteolytic activity present in preparations of alcohol dehydrogenase from D. melanogaster, is considered due to a metalloprotease, for which BrImPpOH is a potent inactivator.     

Covalent binding of an NAD analogue to liver alcohol dehydrogenase resulting in an enzyme-coenzyme complex not requiring exogenous coenzyme for activity.

1. The NAD analogue, N6-[N-(6-aminohexyl)carbamoylmethyl]-NAD, was covalently bound to horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase in a carbodiimide-mediated reaction and in such a way that it was active with the very same enzyme molecule to which it was coupled. 2. The degree of substitution, i.e. the number of NAD analogues per enzyme subunit, could be varied (0.3-1.6). In one preparation 1.6 coenzyme molecules were bound per subunit; the alcohol dehydrogenase activity of this preparation was 40% of the activity obtained after addition of free NAD in excess. 3. It was calculated that every fourth active site of this preparation was provided with a covalently bound functioning coenzyme analogue, and that this analogue had a cycling rate of about 40 000 cycles/h in a coupled substrate assay. 4. The presence of the covalently bound coenzyme made the active sites difficult to inhibit with a competitive inhibitor. For example, 10 mM AMP inhibited the activity of the preparation by 50% whereas a reference system containing native alcohol dehydrogenase was inhibited by 80% in spite of the fact that the reference system contained about 20 000 times as high a concentration of coenzyme.     

Subunit interactions in liver alcohol dehydrogenase: A partial alkylation study.

The transient kinetics of aldehyde reduction by NADH catalyzed by liver alcohol dehydrogenase consist of two kinetic processes. This biphasic rate behavior is consistent with a model in which one of the two identical subunits in the enzyme is inactive during the reaction at the adjacent protomer. Alternatively, enzyme heterogeneity could result in such biphasic behavior. We have prepared liver alcohol dehydrogenase containing a single major isozyme; and the transient kinetics of this purified enzyme are biphasic.Addition of two [¹⁴C]carboxymethyl groups per dimer to the two “reactive” sulfhydryl groups (Cys46) yields enzyme which is catalytically inactive toward alcohol oxidation. Alkylated enzyme, as initially isolated by gel filtration chromatography at pH 7·5, forms an NAD⁺-pyrazole complex. However, the ability to bind NAD⁺-pyrazole is rapidly lost in pH 8·75 buffer; therefore, our alkylated preparations, as isolated by chromatography at pH 8·75, are inactive toward NAD⁺-pyrazole complex formation. We have prepared partially inactivated enzyme by allowing iodoacetic acid to react with liver alcohol dehydrogenase until 50% of the NAD⁺-pyrazole binding capacity remains; under these reaction conditions one [¹⁴C]carboxymethyl group is added per dimer. This partially alkylated enzyme preparation is isolated by gel filtration and has been aged sufficiently to lose NAD⁺-pyrazole binding ability at alkylated subunits. When solutions of native liver alcohol dehydrogenase and partially alkylated liver alcohol dehydrogenase containing the same number of unmodified active sites are allowed to react with substrate under single turnover conditions, partially alkylated enzyme is only half as reactive as native enzyme. This indicates that some molecular species in partially alkylated liver alcohol dehydrogenase that react with pyrazole and NAD⁺ during the active site titration do not react with substrate. These data are consistent with a model in which a subunit adjacent to an alkylated protomer in the dimeric enzyme is inactive toward substrate. In addition, NAD⁺-pyrazole binding at the protomers adjacent to alkylated subunits is slowly lost so that 75% of the enzyme-NAD⁺-pyrazole binding capacity is lost in 50% alkylated enzyme. These data supply strong evidence for subunit interactions in liver alcohol dehydrogenase.Binding experiments performed on partially alkylated liver alcohol dehydrogenase indicate that coenzyme binding is normal at a subunit adjacent to an alkylated protomer even though active ternary complexes cannot be formed. One hypothesis consistent with these results is the unavailability of zinc for substrate binding at the active site in subunits adjacent to alkylated protomers in monoalkylated dimer.     

Interaction of NAD(H)-dependent dehydrogenases with active dyes and their complexes with transitional metal ions

The interaction of NAD(H)-dependent dehydrogenases--yeast alcohol dehydrogenase and rabbit muscle lactate dehydrogenase--with reactive dyes produced in the USSR was studied. The essential role of metal ions in specific binding of alcohol dehydrogenase and dyes was demonstrated by differential spectroscopy, circular dichroism spectroscopy and chromatography. Lactate dehydrogenase in contrast with alcohol dehydrogenase does not require metal ions for the binding of the above-said dyes. A comparative study of eluting abilities of selected desorption agents (imidazole, adenine, 8-oxyquinoline-5-sulfonic acid, NAD, AMP, EDTA) by alcohol dehydrogenase chromatography on adsorbents with light-resistant yellow 2KT-Cu(II) and orange 5K revealed the differences in competition of the dyes for NAD-binding sites of alcohol dehydrogenase. The participation of light-resistant yellow 2KT-Cu(II) in the formation of mixed complexes with imidazole, adenine, 8-oxyquinoline-5-sulfonic acid, NAD and EDTA suggests that the specific binding of alcohol dehydrogenase to light-resistant yellow 2KT-Cu(II) is due to coordination between the Cu(II) ion and the amino acid residue in alcohol dehydrogenase.     

Comparison of computer modelling and X-ray results of the binding of a pyrazole derivative to liver alcohol dehydrogenase

The binding to liver alcohol dehydrogenase of the inhibitor 2,4-(4-pyrazolyl)-butylisothiourea has been studied both by modelling experiments using computer graphics with interactive energy minimization and by X-ray crystallographic structure determination. For the modelling experiments, we used the program system TOM, which was developed in our laboratory as an extension of the program FRODO. Different strategies for using computer graphics with interactive energy minimization were tested. Two essentially different binding modes were found. One of these was favoured from energy minimizations using a potential energy function which was the sum of a Coulomb interaction term and two different van der Waals' interaction terms for non-bonded and torsional interactions. This binding mode was close to the crystallographic observed structure. The results show that flexibility of both ligand and receptor side-chains as well as main-chain conformations are important for docking to the active site of liver alcohol dehydrogenase.     

Biochemical properties of alcohol dehydrogenase from Drosophila lebanonensis.

Purified Drosophila lebanonensis alcohol dehydrogenase (Adh) revealed one enzymically active zone in starch gel electrophoresis at pH 8.5. This zone was located on the cathode side of the origin. Incubation of D. lebanonensis Adh with NAD+ and acetone altered the electrophoretic pattern to more anodal migrating zones. D. lebanonensis Adh has an Mr of 56,000, a subunit of Mr of 28 000 and is a dimer with two active sites per enzyme molecule. This agrees with a polypeptide chain of 247 residues. Metal analysis by plasma emission spectroscopy indicated that this insect alcohol dehydrogenase is not a metalloenzyme. In studies of the substrate specificity and stereospecificity, D. lebanonensis Adh was more active with secondary than with primary alcohols. Both alkyl groups in the secondary alcohols interacted hydrophobically with the alcohol binding region of the active site. The catalytic centre activity for propan-2-ol was 7.4 s-1 and the maximum velocity of most secondary alcohols was approximately the same and indicative of rate-limiting enzyme-coenzyme dissociation. For primary alcohols the maximum velocity varied and was much lower than for secondary alcohols. The catalytic centre activity for ethanol was 2.4 s-1. With [2H6]ethanol a primary kinetic 2H isotope effect of 2.8 indicated that the interconversion of the ternary complexes was rate-limiting. Pyrazole was an ethanol-competitive inhibitor of the enzyme. The difference spectra of the enzyme-NAD+-pyrazole complex gave an absorption peak at 305 nm with epsilon 305 14.5 X 10(3) M-1 X cm-1. Concentrations and amounts of active enzyme can thus be determined. A kinetic rate assay to determine the concentration of enzyme active sites is also presented. This has been developed from active site concentrations established by titration at 305 nm of the enzyme and pyrazole with NAD+. In contrast with the amino acid composition, which indicated that D. lebanonensis Adh and the D. melanogaster alleloenzymes were not closely related, the enzymological studies showed that their active sites were similar although differing markedly from those of zinc alcohol dehydrogenases.     

A simple novel method for determination of an inhibition constant by isothermal titration microcalorimetry. The effect of fluoride ion on urease

Abstract

A simple novel method was introduced for determination of an inhibitor binding constant (Kj) and enthalpy of binding by isothermal titration microcalorimetry technique. This method was applied to the binding of fluoride ion, as an inhibitor, with the active sites of jack bean urease at pH = 7.0 (Tris 30 mM) and T = 300°K. The dissociation equilibrium constant measured by this method was markedly consistent with the inhibition constant obtained from assay of enzyme activity in the presence of fluoride ion.     

Identification of a modifier site on acetylcholinesterase with affinity for d-tubocurarine

Decamethonium and d-tubocurarine displace N-methylacridinium ion, a potent fluorescent inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase, from the surface of the enzyme. Decamethonium is competitive with N-methylacridinium which indicates that the binding sites for these ligands overlap. However, the displacement of N-methylacridinium ion by d-tubocurarine requires the existence of a binding site for d-tubocurarine in addition to the active site. Since the affinities for d-tubocurarine at both sites are comparable, two well defined ligand binding sites must exist for each catalytic site that is titratable by 7-dimethylcarbamyl-N-methylquinolinium iodide.     

A low-resolution 3D model of the tetrameric alcohol dehydrogenase from Sulfolobus solfataricus

We describe the computation of a model of the thermophilic NAD-dependent homotetrameric alcohol dehydrogenase from the archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus (SsADH). Modeling is based on the knowledge that each monomer contains two Zn ions with catalytic and structural function, respectively. In the database of known structures, proteins with similar functions are either dimers containing two zinc ions per monomer or tetramers with one zinc ion per monomer. In any case, the sequence identity of the target to the possible templates is low. A threading procedure is therefore developed which includes constraints taking into account residue conservation both at the zinc ion binding and at the monomer-monomer interaction sites in the tetrameric unit. The model is consistent with previously reported data. Furthermore, cross-linking experiments are described which support the computed tetrameric model.     

Resonance Raman investigation of an enzyme-inhibitor complex.

The resonance Raman spectrum has been recorded for two different binary complexes formed between 2-carboxy-2'-hydroxy-5'-sulfoformazylbenzene (zincon) and liver alcohol dehydrogenase. The shifts in the zincon spectrum upon complexation with enzyme in one complex are similar to those in model compounds containing azo or formazyl linkages upon complexation of these with zinc. The results are interpreted in terms of complexation of zincon to a zinc atom at the enzyme active site. Since zincon is a coenzyme competitive inhibitor, it is probably bound at or near the coenzyme binding site; the results of this study, therefore, are useful in understanding the chemistry of zinc at the enzyme active site.     

Interaction of substrates and inhibitors with the homoserine dehydrogenase of kinase-inactivated aspartokinase I.

The aspartokinase activity of the aspartokinase-homoserine dehydrogenase complex of Escherichia coli was affinity labeled with substrates ATP, aspartate, and feedback inhibitor threonine. Exchange-inert ternary adducts of Co(III)-aspartokinase and either ATP, aspartate or threonine were formed by oxidation of corresponding Co(II) ternary complexes with H2O2. The ternary enzyme-Co(III)-threonine adduct (I) had 3.8 threonine binding sites per tetramer, one-half that of the native enzyme. The binding of threonine to I was still cooperative as determined by equilibrium dialysis (nH = 2.2) or by studying inhibition of residual dehydrogenase activity (nH = 2.7). Threonine still protected the SH groups of I against 5,5'-dithiobis(2-nitrobenzoate) (DTNB) reaction but the number of SH groups reacting with thiol reagents (DTNB) was reduced by 1-2 per subunit in the absence of threonine. This suggests either that Co(III) is bound to the enzyme via sulfhydryl groups or that 1-2SH groups are buried or rendered inaccessible in I. The binding of threonine to sites not blocked by the affinity labeling produced changes in the circular dichroism of the complex comparable to changes produced by threonine binding to native enzyme and also protected against proteolytic digestion. The major conformational changes produced by threonine are thus ascribable to binding at this one class of regulatory sites. The interactions of kinase substrates with various aspartokinase-Co(III) complexes containing ATP, aspartate, or threonine and a threonine-insensitive homoserine dehydrogenase produced by mild proteolysis were studied. The inhibition of homoserine dehydrogenase by kinase substrates is not due to binding of these inhibitors at the kinase active site but was shown to be due to binding to sites within the dehydrogenase domain of the enzyme. L-alpha-Aminobutyrate, a presumed threonine analogue, also inhibits the dehydrogenase by binding at the same or similar sites in the dehydrogenase domain and not at threonine regulatory site.     

Human glutathione-dependent formaldehyde dehydrogenase. Structures of apo,binary, and inhibitory ternary complexes

The human glutathione-dependent formaldehyde dehydrogenase is unique among the structurally studied members of the alcohol dehydrogenase family in that it follows a random bi bi kinetic mechanism. The structures of an apo form of the enzyme, a binary complex with substrate 12-hydroxydodecanoic acid, and a ternary complex with NAD+ and the inhibitor dodecanoic acid were determined at 2.0, 2.3, and 2.3 A resolution by X-ray crystallography using the anomalous diffraction signal of zinc. The structures of the enzyme and its binary complex with the primary alcohol substrate, 12-hydroxydodecanoic acid, and the previously reported binary complex with the coenzyme show that the binding of the first substrate (alcohol or coenzyme) causes only minor changes to the overall structure of the enzyme. This is consistent with the random mechanism of the enzyme where either of the substrates binds to the free enzyme. The catalytic-domain position in these structures is intermediate to the "closed" and "open" conformations observed in class I alcohol dehydrogenases. More importantly, two different tetrahedral coordination environments of the active site zinc are observed in these structures. In the apoenzyme, the active site zinc is coordinated to Cys44, His66 and Cys173, and a water molecule. In the inhibitor complex, the coordination environment involves Glu67 instead of the solvent water molecule. The coordination environment involving Glu67 as the fourth ligand likely represents an intermediate step during ligand exchange at the active site zinc. These observations provide new insight into metal-assisted catalysis and substrate binding in glutathione-dependent formaldehyde dehydrogenase.     

Structure of the complex of active site metal-depleted horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase and NADH.

The complex between active site-specific metal-depleted horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase and NADH has been studied with X-ray crystallographic methods to 2.9 A resolution. The electron density maps revealed that only the catalytic zinc ions are removed, whereas the non-catalytic zinc sites ae fully occupied. A gross conformational change in the protein induced by co-enzyme binding takes place in this enzyme species despite the absence of the metal ion in the catalytic center. This circumstance is of great importance in the understanding and further analysis of the trigger mechanisms operating during the conformation transition in alcohol dehydrogenase, since the catalytic center is located at the hinge region for a domain rotation in the subunit, and the metal atom is essential for catalysis. The overall protein structure is the same as that of an NADH complex of the native zinc enzyme and the co-enzyme is bound in a similar manner. The local structural changes observed are restricted to the empty metal binding site.     

Pt(CN)2-4 and Au(CN)-2: potential general probes for anion-binding sites of proteins. 35Cl and 81Br nuclear-magnetic-resonance studies.

Nuclear magnetic quadrupole relaxation appears to be a general method for studying the binding of anions to proteins. This is shown by the increase in transverse quadrupole relaxation rate of 35Cl- and 81Br- in the presence of horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase, lysozyme, trypsin, alpha-chymotrypsin, human carbonic anhydrase, fructose-1,6-bisphosphate aldolase and human serum albumin. Of the many possible binding sites at the surface of a protein (e.g. positively charged amino acid side-chains) only a few account for the main part of the relaxation enhancement. This is shown by the decrease in 35Cl- and 81Br- relaxation rate on addition of functional ligands. Large, kinetically inert, complex anions like Pt(CN)2-4 and Au(CN)-2 are found to act as strong competitors towards halogen ions for the high-affinity anion binding sites of a number of proteins. Titrations with complex anions following the 35Cl- or 81Br- relaxation rates are found to be helpful in attempts to elucidate binding mechanisms. Especially, the complex anions may be useful probes for the discrimination between general and metallic anion binding sites in proteins and they also permit correlation of information from X-ray investigations of crystals with that from physical measurements in solution. From the change in halide ion quadrupole relaxation rate on addition of strongly binding ligands the quadrupole coupling constants of the high affinity Cl- and Br- binding sites are estimated using certain assumptions. It is found that for several proteins, comprising the metal-free proteins but also alcohol dehydrogenase and Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase, the 35Cl quadrupole coupling constants have approximately the same values. For some other metallo-proteins like carbonic anhydrase and a zinc - serum-albumin complex considerably greater quadrupole coupling constants were obtained. The estimated quadrupole coupling constants are used as a basis for a discussion of the interactions involved in anion-protein interactions.     

Topographical characterization of the ubiquinone reduction site of glucose dehydrogenase in Escherichia coli using depth-dependent fluorescent inhibitors.

Membrane-bound glucose dehydrogenase in Escherichia coli possesses a binding site for ubiquinone as well as glucose, metal ion and pyrroloquinoline quinone. To probe the depth of the ubiquinone binding site in the membrane environment, we synthesized two types of fluorenyl fatty acids which bear an inhibitor mimic moiety (i.e., specific inhibitor capsaicin) close to the fluorene located at different positions in the alkyl tail chain; one close to the polar carbonyl head group (alpha-(3, 4-dimethoxyphenyl)acetyloxy-7-nonyl-2-fluoreneacetic acid, alpha-DFA), and the other in the middle of the chain (theta-(3, 4-dimethoxyphenyl)acetyloxy-7-ethyl-2-fluorenenonanoic acid, theta-DFA). Mixed lipid vesicles consisting of phosphatidylcholine (PC) and alpha-DFA or theta-DFA were prepared by sonication method, and fluorescent quenching against a hydrophilic quencher, iodide anion, was examined. The vesicles containing alpha-DFA were more susceptible to quenching than those containing theta-DFA, indicating that the fluorene and consequently capsaicin mimic moiety are located at different depths in the lipid bilayer depending upon the position of attachment to the alkyl tail chain. The purified glucose dehydrogenase was reconstituted into PC vesicles which consisted of PC and alpha-DFA or theta-DFA with various molar ratios. For both types of reconstituted vesicles, the extent of inhibition of short-chain ubiquinone reduction activity increased with increases in the molar ratio of fluorenyl fatty acid to PC. The ubiquinone reduction activity was more significantly inhibited in the reconstituted vesicles containing alpha-DFA compared to those containing theta-DFA. Our findings strongly suggested that the ubiquinone reduction site in glucose dehydrogenase is located close to the membrane surface rather than in the hydrophobic membrane interior.