In vitro viability of lymphoid cells from lines of mice genetically selected for high or low responsiveness to phytohemagglutinin

The kinetics of viability of lymph node and spleen cells of mice genetically selected for "high" or "low" in vitro lymphocyte responsiveness to PHA were studied in PHA or PPD-stimulated short-term cultures. Lo/PHA cells were found to be less viable than Hi/PHA cells in unstimulated control cultures. PHA improved the viability of Lo/PHA cells while inducing proliferation of Hi/PHA cells with the appearance of more and larger lymphoblasts in the latter. PPD only improved the viability of spleen cell cultures, more so for the Hi/PHA line. The interline difference in thymidine uptake was smaller after PPD than after PHA stimulation. Modifications of culture conditions designed to decrease the interline difference in cell viability lessened but did not abolish the separation between the two lines for the PHA response as measured by thymidine uptake.     

PHA-T cells in systemic lupus erythematosus and in rheumatoid arthritis: abnormalities in HLA class II antigen induction and in autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions

Analysis of T cells from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) identified a deficit in the induction of HLA Class II antigens by PHA although the proliferative response was normal and in the [3H]thymidine incorporation in autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) with PHA-T cells as stimulators. In RA these abnormalities were more marked in patients with active disease than in those in clinical remission. The deficit of autologous MLR with PHA-T cells was more marked than that of autologous MLR with non-T cells and of allogeneic MLR. Serum from patients with SLE and with RA did not display any detectable inhibitory activity on the induction of HLA Class II antigens by PHA, on the proliferative response of lymphocytes to PHA, on autologous MLR with PHA-T cells and with non-T cells as stimulators and on allogeneic MLR. These results suggest that the abnormalities we have identified reflect an intrinsic defect of T cells.     

Human T cells in cord blood: Abnormalities in Ia antigens induction by phytohemagglutinin and in autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions

About 25% of human T cells isolated from cord blood acquired Ia antigens following stimulation with phytohemagglutinin (PHA) for 72 hr. This percentage is markedly lower than that found in PHA-activated T-cell populations (PHA-T cells) isolated from peripheral blood of adults. The low expression of Ia antigens by human T cells from cord blood does not reflect abnormalities in the sensitivity to PHA stimulation and/or in the kinetics of induction of Ia antigens. PHA-T cells from cord blood display a low stimulatory activity in autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR). The defect does not reflect a nonspecific abnormality in the stimulatory activity of PHA-T cells from cord blood, since the latter do not differ from PHA-T cells from adults in their ability to stimulate allogeneic T cells from adults. Furthermore the defect does not reflect a nonspecific abnormality in the proliferative response of T cells from cord blood, since the latter display a normal proliferative response to PHA-T cells from adults. The defect in the proliferative response is not restricted to the autologous MLR with PHA-T cells, since it was found also in autologous MLR with non-T cells as stimulators. Correlation of the temporal evolution of the abnormalities of human T cells with the maturation of the immune system may contribute to our understanding of the role of Ia antigens in cell-cell interactions and of the biological significance of abnormalities of autologous MLR.     

Generation of natural killer-like activity in mixed lymphocyte-tumor cell cultures. II. Correlation between expression of HLA-DR antigens on the activated T cells and their cytotoxic capability

In this study, we investigated the role of DR antigens in human mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) at the responder cell level. Upon stimulation by allogeneic lymphocytes or leukemic cell lines, a large proportion of T cells underwent blastogenesis and began expressing DR antigens. Analysis by a fluorescence-activated cell sorter revealed that both subpopulations of large activated T cell blasts and of small T lymphocytes became DR+ by synthesis and/or uptake. Depletion of DR+ responder cells from 6-day-old MLRs by treatment with anti-DR monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) plus complement (C) reduced but did not completely abrogate the natural killer (NK)-like activity of the responder lymphocytes, suggesting that the MLR-induced cytotoxic cells include both DR+ and Dr- populations. The expression of NK-like activity by the responder cells was also greatly reduced upon addition of anti-DR mAbs (without C) at the start of the mixed cultures. This effect was observed regardless of the presence of DR antigens on the stimulator cells, indicating that the anti-DR mAbs can interact with the antigens present on both the stimulator and responder populations. These data show that during an MLR, the continued presence of DR antigens on the responding population is essential for the expression and maintenance of the proliferative and cytotoxic capabilities of these cells.     

Effect of anti-beta2-microglobulin on antigen and allogeneic lymphocyte-induced proliferation of human lymphocytes.

The effect of anti-beta2-microglobulin (beta2m) on the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), and an antigen-induced proliferative response was studied. Anti-beta2m IgG and Fab' fragments completely inhibited the MLR. Preincubation of stimulator or responder cells with anti-beta2m suggested that the major effect of anti-beta2m may be on the responder cell population. A clear-cut effect on responder cells was demonstrated by showing that anti-beta2m completely inhibited a MLR in which the stimulator population was a beta2m negative lymphoblastoid cell line. Anti-beta2m also inhibited PPD-induced proliferation of sensitized lymphocytes. The kinetics of this inhibition indicated that anti-beta2m added within the first 18 hr of stimulation was effective in inhibiting the proliferative response. These data are discussed in light of the hypothesis that beta2m may be a subunit of an antigen receptor on T cells.     

Delayed hypersensitivity and migration inhibition in two lines of mice genetically selected for high or low responsiveness to phytohemagglutinin

Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) and cell migration inhibition (MI) were studied in two lines of mice genetically selected for the high (Hi/PHA) or low (Lo/PHA) in vitro response of their lymphoid cells to phytochemagglutinin (PHA). A rapid photoelectric procedure for reading cell migrations enabled the study of MI over a wide range (10 log) of antigen concentrations in vitro. Hi/PHA mice required immunization with a 10 times higher dose of ovalbumin (OVA) in Freund's complete adjuvant (FCA) than Lo/PHA mice for a comparable response in DTH (footpad swelling) and MI of their induced peritoneal exudate cells (PEC). Lo/PHA spleen showed marked bizonal MI on Day 5 after immunization with low doses (0.1 and 0.5 micrograms) of OVA in FCA, one peak being obtained in presence of in vitro concentrations of 10(-3) or 10(-2) micrograms/ml OVA and another peak at 1 or 10 micrograms/ml, whereas Hi/PHA spleen showed stimulation of migration. In contrast, MI in Lo/PHA spleen failed to persist beyond Day 19, whereas it appeared progressively in Hi/PHA spleen, being maximal by Day 27. Low-zone inhibition in Hi/PHA spleen and PEC was lacking or poor even after immunization with higher doses of OVA in FCA. The implications of these findings are discussed.     

Selective abrogation of alloreactivity via priming in the presence of aphidicolin, a specific inhibitor of DNA polymerase

Aphidicolin, a specific and direct inhibitor of eukaryotic DNA polymerase alpha, was used to investigate its impact on immunologic reactions in vitro. Dose response curve of the inhibitory effect was studied in murine and human primary allogeneic responses, as well as the proliferative responses to both PHA and Con A mitogens. The presence of aphidicolin during the allosensitization phase in secondary MLR of mice splenocytes resulted in complete abolishment of the subsequent response directed against the priming alloantigens, whereas alloreactivity to unrelated alloantigen-bearing cells was inhibited to a much lesser degree. The allosensitized aphidicolin-treated cells lost the ability to respond to subsequent PHA stimulation, but were capable of exerting a high responsiveness to Con A. The presence of aphidicolin during the allosensitization phase in secondary MLR of human mononuclear cells resulted in markedly decreased alloreactivity directed against the priming cells, but spared the subsequent response to unrelated alloantigens and to both PHA and Con A mitogenic stimuli. It is suggested that aphidicolin may be used for selective inactivation of proliferating cells without interfering with immunologic functions of other quiescent subsets. Aphidicolin may thus be a useful agent for induction of specific unresponsiveness in experimental models of allogeneic transplantation.     

Dence for a gene in rats affecting lymphocyte responsiveness to PHA

A gene controlling high responsiveness of lymphocytes to in vitro stimulation by PHA was transferred from the Lewis strain of rats to the BN background by ten generations of backcrossing. The high-responder phenotype was initially defined on the basis of incorporation of³H-thymidine, but we show that this trait also involves higher levels of mitotic activity than are observed with low responder lymphocytes. This gene is not closely linked to any histocompatibility locus which could be detected by skin grafting, and it does not appear to affect the proportion of T lymphocytes.     

Thymopoietin enhances the allogeneic response and cyclic GMP levels of mouse peripheral, thymus-derived lymphocytes.

The action of the purified thymic factor, thymopoietin, on populations of post-thymic lymphocytes has been studied. Thymopoietin, at concentrations as low as 1.5 ng/ml, uniquely enhanced the proliferative response of peripheral T cells from lymph node and spleen to allogeneic stimulation. Enhancement of the allogeneic response (MLR) was not produced by several polypeptide hormones, including insulin, ACTH, HCG, or Ubiquitin. Treatment of spleen cells with anti-Thy-1 antiserum almost completely abolished the MLR. Thymopoietin's stimulatory effects could not reverse this. Thymopoietin treatment of Thy-1+-enriched spleen cell populations enhanced the MLR even when thymopoietin was removed as early as 2 min after incubation with responding cells. The interaction of thymopoietin with peripheral Thy-1+ cell populations produced a rapid and transient rise in cyclic GMP levels and slightly decreased cyclic AMP levels. These results suggest that thymopoietin interacts with one or more Thy-1+ subpopulations and that this interaction involves early changes in cyclic nucleotide metabolism.     

Stimulation of AIDS lymphocytes with calcium ionophore (A23187) and phorbol ester (PMA): studies of cytoplasmic free Ca, IL-2 receptor expression, IL-2 production, and proliferation

We have studied whether the decreased lymphocyte proliferative responses of AIDS lymphocytes to stimulation by mitogens and antigens may be overcome when challenged with a combination of calcium ionophore A23187 and phorbol ester PMA. Comparison of the proliferative response of lymphocytes from nine patients with AIDS with the response of lymphocytes from nine control subjects showed that the response of AIDS lymphocytes was severely decreased when stimulated with PHA and no further response could be achieved by stimulation with A23187/PMA. On the other hand, no significant difference between the PHA-induced rise of cytoplasmic free calcium concentration ([Ca2+]1) in normal and AIDS lymphocytes was observed. The percentage of cells expressing IL-2 receptors (CD25) was also normal both after addition of PHA and after addition of A23187/PMA and the expression was normal on both CD4 and CD8 cells. The production of IL-2 in normal lymphocytes stimulated with A23187/PMA was 33 times higher than that after stimulation with PHA. In AIDS lymphocytes the production of IL-2 induced by all activators was severely decreased compared to control subjects, although the production of IL-2 after stimulation with A23187/PMA was higher than that in control lymphocytes after stimulation with PHA. The present study shows that a direct activation of protein kinase C combined with mobilization of cytoplasmic calcium does not overcome the lymphocyte proliferative deficiency of AIDS lymphocytes.     

Recessive T cell response to poly (Glu50Tyr50) possibly caused by self tolerance

The proliferative T cell response of inbred mouse strains to the random copolymer poly(Glu50Tyr50) (GT) was found to fall into two categories. Some strains responded only marginally (delta cpm values less than 10,000 and stimulation indices less than 3), whereas other strains mounted a substantial response (delta cpm 10,000 to 80,000, SI 3 to 30). The response is controlled by the A alpha and A beta loci of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), as well as by genes not linked to the MHC. Because the response is selectively inhibited by monoclonal antibodies specific for the A alpha A beta molecule, we assume that its control by A loci is manifested as an A-restriction of the participating T (Ly-1high, Ly-2-) cells. It is of interest that the responsiveness is recessive in F1 hybrids of responder and nonresponder strains that are H-2-identical, but differ at their genetic background. Nonresponsiveness of these F1 mice is caused neither by a defect of antigen presentation, nor the result of immune suppression on priming or at the effector phase of the response. It is most likely the consequence of clonal deletion during the establishment of self-tolerance.     

Role of individual chains of HLA-DR antigens in activation of T cells induced by alloantigens

The role of HLA-DR antigens in the activation of T cells in the allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) was studied by using antibodies raised against the alpha, beta or the complex of both chains of the HLA-DR antigens. Antisera directed against the alpha or the beta chain strongly inhibited the T-cell proliferative response when added at the begining of MLR cultures but not 72 h later. T cells from MLR cultures treated with either alpha-chainor beta-chain-specific antibodies did not respond to interleukin-2 (IL-2) by proliferating, whereas T cells from non-anti-DR-treated cultures showed a proliferative response to IL-2 stimulation. However, neither the anti-alpha chain nor the anti-beta chain serum was able to inhibit continuous proliferation of already activated, IL-2-reactive T cells supported by IL-2. In MLR, OKT4⁺ but not OKT8⁺ lymphocytes synthesized IL-2. This function was abrogated by the alpha-chain-specific antibody but not by the anti-beta chain serum. Interleukin-1 (IL-1) did not reverse the inhibitory activity on IL-2 synthesis of the alpha-chain antibody, while IL-1 promoted the production of IL-2 in MLR cultures not exposed to the anti-DR sera. In addition, nonstimulated OKT4⁺ cells were unresponsive to IL-1 and did not produce IL-2. From these results, it is concluded that HLA-DR antigens participate actively in the activation of T cells by allogeneic non-T cells. Thus, both the alpha and beta chains of HLA-DR antigens render resting T cells sensitive to IL-2. In addition, the alpha but not the beta chain participates in the production of IL-2 by enabling OKT4⁺ lymphocytes to respond to IL-1 and subsequently to synthesize IL-2. Once T cells have acquired responsiveness to IL-2 and this growth factor has been produced there is no further requirement for HLA-DR antigens. Continuous proliferation and growth of IL-2-reactive T cells depends on the availability of interleukin-2.     

Identical genetic control of MLC reactivity to different MHC incompatibilities,independent of production of and response to IL-2

The inbred strain STS/A exhibits a higher proliferative response in the mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) to stimulator cells of all 11 tested inbred mouse strains with 10 different major histocompatibility complex (MHC) haplotypes, as well as to stimulation with IL-2 than does the strain BALB/cHeA. However, alloantigen-stimulated BALB/c cells produce more IL-2 than STS/A cells. To study the genetic basis of these differences, we used 20 recombinant congenic strains (RCS) of the CcS/Dem series. Each of these CcS/Dem RC strains contains a different subset of about 12.5% of genes from the STS/A strain and the remaining approximately 87.5% of BALB/c origin genes. As a result the multiple non-linked genes responsible for phenotypic differences between BALB/c and STS/A became separated into different CcS/Dem strains. The strain distribution pattern (SDP) of high or low MLC response of individual CcS/Dem strains to stimulator cells of four different strains was almost identical, indicating that differences in responsiveness, rather than the alloantigenic difference itself, determine the magnitude of the response, and that the responsiveness to different alloantigens is largely controlled by the same genes. The SDP of IL-2 stimulation was different from that of MLC responsiveness. The differences in the proliferative responses observed among individual CcS/Dem strains were not due to differences in numbers of CD3⁺, CD4⁺ or CD8⁺ cells or to the observed differences in IL-2 production, and hence they likely reflect genetically determined intrinsic properties of T cells. These results show that a set of non-linked genes controls proliferative responses in MLC irrespective of the MHC haplotype of the stimulator cells, and that stimulation with IL-2 and production of IL-2 are controlled by different subsets of genes. Since the genomes of all RCS are extensively characterized by microsatellite markers, they can be used to map the genes controlling proliferative responsiveness to stimulation with alloantigens and IL-2.     

Suppression of interleukin-2 production by human concanavalin A-induced suppressor cells

When PHA-activated normal responder cells (R cells) were cocultured with mononuclear cells (MN cells) which had been preincubated for 48 hr in medium alone (C cells) an enhanced proliferative response was observed. This enhancement was only obtained when the R cells were cultured with allogeneic C cells or when PHA was in the cocultures for the entire culture period. This effect was due to greater production of interleukin 2 (IL-2) by irradiated C cells in the presence of allogeneic or mitogenic stimulation. Con A-treated mononuclear cells (S cells) cultured with PHA-activated allogeneic or autologous responder cells showed reduced [3H]thymidine incorporation and IL-2 production as compared to activated R cells alone. Glutaraldehyde-treated S cells (which retained the ability to absorb IL-2) did not affect the proliferative response or IL-2 production by the R cells, indicating that passive absorption of IL-2 was not entirely responsible for suppression induced by S cells. S cells, pretreated with IL-2, still inhibited R-cell activity. These results show that Con A-treated MN cells suppressed or prevented [3H]thymidine incorporation by actively inhibiting IL-2 production.     

Some requirements for the response of separated T-cell sub-populations to the mitogens phytohaemagglutinin and concanavalin A.

The proliferative response of various separated populations of mouse spleen and thymus lymphocytes to the mitogen phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) was not a direct function of the level of responsive T cells, but was governed by other regulatory effects. These included a stimulation by adherent macrophages, an inhibition by a separate population of adherent cells and an adherent cell independent restriction of proliferation at high cell concentration. In contrast, the proliferative response to Concanavalin A (Con A) was more closely related to the level of responsive T cells. All density and electrophoretically isolated sub-sets of splenic T cells appeared capable of a proliferative response to PHA and Con A, although under some conditions the PHA responsiveness of certain fractions was suppressed. In the thymus, the minor low theta sub-population appeared capable of response to both mitogens, and accounted for all the activity of the unfractioned thymus cells. No response to either mitogen could be obtained from the major, high theta thymocyte population.     

T cell proliferative responses to a mitogen derived from Mycoplasma arthritidis are controlled by the accessory cell

Cell-free supernatants from broth cultures of Mycoplasma arthritidis (MAS) induce vigorous proliferative responses in thymus-derived T lymphocytes from H2k or H2d strains of mice. Populations of lymphoid cells from mice of H2b, H2q, or H2s haplotypes do not respond to this stimulus. Previous studies with lymphoid cells from congenic and recombinant strains of mice indicate that the T cell proliferative response induced by MAS is controlled by a gene(s) that maps to the I-E/C subregion of the murine major histocompatibility complex (MHC). The T cell proliferative response induced by MAS is dependent upon the presence of a population of la+, radioresistant accessory cells (AC). Data presented here demonstrates that responder strain AC that have been pulsed with MAS (followed by extensive washing) induced vigorous proliferative responses in subsequently added T cell populations. Pulsing of T cells with MAS, followed by the addition of AC, however, did not result in T cell proliferation. MAS was found to stimulate (responder X nonresponder) F1 T cells to proliferate if the MAS was presented in the context of either responder or (responder X nonresponder) F1 AC; nonresponder strain AC were ineffective in this regard. Nonresponder strain T cells were found to be capable of responding to MAS if it was presented in the context of responder strain AC, even if the T cells and AC were completely allogeneic. Thus, nonresponder strain T cells mounted vigorous proliferative responses if the MAS was presented in the context of responder strain AC. Conversely, responder strain T cells did not respond to MAS presented in the context of nonresponder strain AC. In addition, lymphoid cells from a B10 leads to B6AF1 radiation bone marrow chimera were also found to be capable of responding to MAS, but only in the presence of AC that expressed cell surface determinants controlled by the I-E/C subregion. The data presented here indicate that MAS-induced T cell proliferative responses are controlled at the level of the AC by a gene(s) that maps to the I-E/C subregion of the MHC.     

The multiple mixed lymphocyte reaction: variables important in the test as a measure of lymphocyte competence in man.

In order to utilize the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) as an assay of T-lymphocyte competence, pools of target lymphocytes obtained from different individuals are used to increase the magnitude and decrease the variation of the in vitro response. We evaluated variations in MLR response due to variations in target cell populations. Response increased with an increased target/responder cell ratio. Peak response occurred with a target/responder cell ratio of between 1:1 and 1:4. Response to a pool of lymphocytes from different individuals increased as the number of individuals contributing to the pool increased. Peak stimulation occurred with three to four different donors to the target cell pool. Stimulation produced by pooled target cells resulted in a higher mean index of stimulation and decreased variation of response as compared to stimulation produced by target cells from individual donors. Stimulation produced by pooled target cells was approximately equal to the sum of the stimulation produced by each of the target cell populations acting alone. These findings indicate a practical method of modifying the MLR as a test of T-lymphocyte function.     

Genetic control of murine T cell proliferative responses to Mycobacterium leprae. V. Evidence for cross-reactivity between host antigens and Mycobacterium leprae

T cell proliferative responses to Mycobacterium leprae were measured by immunization of mice at the base of the tail with Ag and challenging lymphocytes from draining lymph nodes in culture with M. leprae. C57BL/10J and B10.BR mice were identified as low responder mice and the congenic strains B10.M, B10.Q, and B10.AKM as high responders whereas F1 (high x low) hybrid mice were found to be low responders. The cellular basis of low responsiveness did not appear to result from a defect in Ag-presenting cells or the activation of suppressor T cells by M. leprae. The influence of the environment in which T cells developed on responsiveness to M. leprae was analyzed in chimeric mice prepared by irradiating F1(C57BL/10J x B10.M) mice and reconstituting with bone marrow from C57BL/10J, B10.M, or F1 donors. Six weeks later, chimeric mice were immunized with M. leprae, lymph node cells were subsequently prepared, and H-2 phenotyped and challenged in culture with M. leprae Ag. T cell proliferative responses were found to be low in all cases, similar to those observed using lymph node cells from F1 hybrid mice. These results suggested that high responder B10.M lymphocytes developing in the irradiated F1 mice became tolerized to antigenic determinants found on M. leprae. This implied cross-reactive epitopes existed between some mouse strains and M. leprae. Low responsiveness to M. leprae in low responder and F1 hybrid mice may result from tolerance to H-2-encoded Ag that show cross-reactivity with M. leprae.     

Immunological Potential of the in vitro Mixed Skin Cell-Leukocyte Reaction

THE mixed skin cell-leukocyte reaction (MSLR) is an in vitro reaction between dissociated skin cells and allogeneic peripheral blood leukocytes. It is similar in its immunological implications to the reaction between allogeneic leukocytes, commonly known as the mixed leukocyte reaction (MLR) or the mixed lymphocyte interaction (MLI). In the latter, immunological recognition between lymphocytes from genetically disparate donors can be detected and measured either by blastoid transformation, enhanced mitotic rate or induction of DNA synthesis^1–4. This system has been useful in the study of the transfer of transplantation immunity in vivo by lymphocytes sensitized in vitro⁵ and also in the identification of tissue incompatibility between donor and recipient^{6, 7}. In studies with inbred strains of rats the proliferative phase of the MLR has been shown to possess characteristics required for an immunological response; that is, selectivity and specificity^{8, 9}. Furthermore, mouse peripheral lymphocytes sensitized in mixed culture with allogeneic lymphocytes have been shown to engender immunospecific destruction of target cells¹⁰, an event which is directly associated with allograft rejection.     

Simple sugars inhibit proliferation of human T lymphocytes in autologous and allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reactions

Several oligo- and monosaccharides were studied for their capacity to modulate lymphocyte proliferation in human allogeneic and autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR). A defined subset of sugars showed a marked inhibitory effect on lymphocyte proliferative response in the majority of the allogeneic MLR combinations studied. The inhibitory effect disappeared when sugars were added to allogeneic MLR 96 hr after the beginning of culture. These sugars also showed a significant inhibitory power on autologous MLR, performed by using T- and non-T-enriched lymphocytes from the same donor. The reported data suggest that carbohydrate determinants are involved in the proliferative response of human lymphocytes in both autologous and allogeneic MLR.