Native-like partially folded conformations and folding process revealed in the N-terminal large fragments of staphylococcal nuclease: a study by NMR spectroscopy

The N-terminal large fragments of staphylococcal nuclease (SNase), SNase110 (1-110 residues), SNase121 (1-121 residues), and SNase135 (1-135 residues), and the fragment mutants G88W110, G88W121, V66W110 and V66W121 were studied by heteronuclear multidimensional NMR spectroscopy. Ensembles of co-existent native-like partially folded and unfolded states were observed for fragments. The persistent native-like tertiary interaction drives fragments to be in partially folded states, which reveal native-like beta-barrel conformations. G88W and V66W mutations modulate the extent of inherent native-like tertiary interaction in fragment molecules, and in consequence, fragment mutants fold into native-like beta-subdomain conformations. In cooperation with the inherent tertiary interaction, 2 M TMAO (trimethylamine N-oxide) can promote the folding reaction of fragments through the changes of unfolding free energy, and a native-like beta-subdomain conformation is observed when the chain length contains 135 residues. Heterogeneous partially folded conformations of 1-121 and 1-135 fragments due to cis and trans X-prolyl bond of Lys116-Pro117 make a non-unique folding pathway of fragments. The folding reaction of fragments can be characterized as a hierarchical process.     

Partially folded states of staphylococcal nuclease highlight the conserved structural hierarchy of OB-fold proteins

We have been interested in whether three proteins that share a five-stranded beta-barrel "OB-fold" structural motif but no detectable sequence homology fold by similar mechanisms. Here we describe native-state hydrogen exchange experiments as a function of urea for SN (staphylococcal nuclease), a protein with an OB-fold motif and additional nonconserved elements of structure. The regions of structure with the largest stability and unfolding cooperativity are contained within the conserved OB-fold portion of SN, consistent with previous results for CspA (cold shock protein A) and LysN (anticodon binding domain of lysyl tRNA synthetase). The OB-fold also has the subset of residues with the slowest unfolding rates in the three proteins, as determined by hydrogen exchange experiments in the EX1 limit. Although the protein folding hierarchy is maintained at the level of supersecondary structure, it is not evident for individual residues as might be expected if folding depended on obligatory nucleation sites. Rather, the site-specific stability profiles appear to be linked to sequence hydrophobicity and to the density of long-range contacts at each site in the three-dimensional structures of the proteins. We discuss the implications of the correlation between stability to unfolding and conservation of structure for mechanisms of protein structure evolution.     

Sensitivity of NMR residual dipolar couplings to perturbations in folded and denatured staphylococcal nuclease

The invariance of NMR residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) in denatured forms of staphylococcal nuclease to changes in denaturant concentration or amino acid sequence has previously been attributed to the robustness of long-range structure in the denatured state. Here we compare RDCs of the wild-type nuclease with those of a fragment that retains a folded OB-fold subdomain structure despite missing the last 47 of 149 residues. The RDCs of the intact protein and of the truncation fragment are substantially different under conditions that favor folded structure. By contrast, there is a strong correlation between the RDCs of the full-length protein and the fragment under denaturing conditions (6 M urea). The RDCs of the folded and unfolded forms of the proteins are uncorrelated. Our results suggest that RDCs are more sensitive to structural changes in folded than unfolded proteins. We propose that the greater susceptibility of RDCs in folded states is a consequence of the close packing of the polypeptide chain under native conditions. By contrast, the invariance of RDCs in denatured states is more consistent with a disruption of cooperative structure than with the retention of a unique long-range folding topology.     

Biological function in a non-native partially folded state of a protein

As structural flexibility is known to be required for enzyme catalysis and pattern recognition and a significant fraction of eukaryotic proteins appear to be unfolded or contain unstructured regions, biological activity of conformational states distinct from fully folded structures could be more common than previously thought. By applying a procedure that allows the recovery of enzymatic activity to be monitored in real time, we show that a non-native state populated transiently during folding of the acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus is enzymatically active. The structural characterization of this partially folded state reveals that enzymatic activity is possible even if the catalytic site is structurally heterogeneous, whereas the remainder of the structure acts as a scaffold. These results extend the spectrum of biological functions carried out in the absence of a folded state to include enzyme catalysis.     

Accommodation of single amino acid insertions by the native state of staphylococcal nuclease

Single alanine and glycine insertions were introduced at 20 randomly selected positions in staphylococcal nuclease. The resulting changes in catalytic activity and in stability to guanidine hydrochloride denaturation indicate that the native state structure is frequently able to accommodate the extra residue without great difficulty, even insertions within secondary structural elements such as alpha helices and beta sheets. On average, an inserted residue reduces the free energy of denaturation (delta GH2O) by an amount roughly comparable to an alanine or glycine substitution for one of the residues flanking the site of insertion. Several positions outside of the enzyme active site were found where insertions, but not substitutions, lead to structural changes that modify catalytic activity and the circular dichroism spectrum. Amino acid insertions represent a virtually unexplored class of genetic mutation that may prove complementary to amino acid substitutions for engineering proteins with altered functional and structural properties.     

A peptide model for proline isomerism in the unfolded state of staphylococcal nuclease.

Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy has been used to investigate a synthetic peptide (YVYKPNNTHE) corresponding to residues 113 to 122 of staphylococcal nuclease. In the major folded state of the protein this region forms a type VIa beta-turn containing a cis Lys116-Pro117 peptide bond. There is, however, no evidence for any significant population of such a turn in the peptide in aqueous solution and the X-Pro bond is predominantly in the trans configuration. The peptide exhibits several well-resolved minor resonances due to the presence of a small fraction (4 +/- 2%) of the cis-proline isomer. The ratio of cis to trans isomer populations was found to be independent of temperature between 5 degrees C and 70 degrees C, indicating that delta H for the isomerism is close to zero. Using magnetization transfer techniques the rate of trans to cis interconversion was found to be 0.025(+/- 0.013) s-1 at 50 degrees C. The thermodynamics and kinetics of isomerism in the peptide are very similar to those estimated for the Lys116-Pro117 peptide bond in unfolded nuclease, suggesting that the cis-trans equilibrium in the unfolded protein is largely determined by the residues adjacent to Pro117 in the sequence. These results are consistent with previous suggestions that the cis-proline bond is stabilized late in the folding process and that the predominance of the cis form in folded nuclease is due to stabilizing interactions within the protein that give rise to a favorable enthalpy term.     

Thermodynamics of staphylococcal nuclease denaturation. I. The acid-denatured state.

Using high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry, we reexamined the thermodynamics of denaturation of staphylococcal nuclease. The denaturational changes in enthalpy and heat capacity were found to be functions of both temperature and pH. The denatured state of staphylococcal nuclease at pH 8.0 and high temperature has a heat capacity consistent with a fully unfolded protein completely exposed to solvent. At lower pH values, however, the heat capacity of the denatured state is lower, resulting in a lower delta Cp and delta H for the denaturation reaction. The acid-denatured protein can thus be distinguished from a completely unfolded protein by a defined difference in enthalpy and heat capacity. Comparison of circular dichroism spectra suggests that the low heat capacity of the acid-denatured protein does not result from residual helical secondary structure. The enthalpy and heat capacity changes of denaturation of a less stable mutant nuclease support the observed dependence of delta H on pH.     

Cold denaturation of staphylococcal nuclease

It has been shown that the structure of staphylococcal nuclease breaks down reversibly both at a temperature increase above 20 degrees C and at its decrease. Both the heat and cold denaturations of protein are well approximated by a transition between two states differing in heat capacity, which means that the whole protein molecule represents a unique cooperative system with a well developed hydrophobic core. The transfer to a denatured state at a temperature decrease is accompanied by heat release and leads to a complete loss of the unique tertiary structure, decrease of the helicity and increase of the hydrodynamic volume of the molecule.     

Characterization of the stable, acid-induced, molten globule-like state of staphylococcal nuclease.

Titration of a salt-free solution of native staphylococcal nuclease by HCl leads to an unfolding transition in the vicinity of pH 4, as determined by near- and far-UV circular dichroism. At pH 2-3, the protein is substantially unfolded. The addition of further HCl results in a second transition, this one to a more structured species (the A state) with the properties of an expanded molten globule, namely substantial secondary structure, little or no tertiary structure, relatively compact size as determined by hydrodynamic radius, and the ability to bind the hydrophobic dye 1-anilino-8-naphthalene sulfonic acid. The addition of anions, in the form of neutral salts, to the acid-unfolded state at pH 2 also causes a transition leading to the A state. Fourier transform infrared analysis of the amide I band was used to compare the amount and type of secondary structure in the native and A states. A significant decrease in alpha-helix structure, with a corresponding increase in beta or extended structure, was observed in the A state, compared to the native state. A model to account for such compact denatured states is proposed.     

Thermal denaturation of staphylococcal nuclease

The fully reversible thermal denaturation of staphylococcal nuclease in the absence and presence of Ca2+ and/or thymidine 3',5'-diphosphate (pdTp) from pH 4 to 8 has been studied by high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry. In the absence of ligands, the denaturation is accompanied by an enthalpy change of 4.25 cal g-1 and an increase in specific heat of 0.134 cal K-1 g-1, both of which are usual values for small globular proteins. The temperature (tm) of maximal excess specific heat is 53.4 degrees C. Each of the ligands, Ca2+ and pdTp, by itself has important effects on the unfolding of the protein which are enhanced when both ligands are present. Addition of saturating concentrations of these ligands raises the denaturational enthalpy to 5.74 cal g-1 in the case of Ca2+ and to 6.72 cal g-1 in the case of pdTp. The ligands raise the tm by as much as 11 degrees C depending on ligand concentration. From the variation of the denaturational enthalpies with ligand concentrations, binding constants at 53 degrees C equal to 950 M-1 and 1.4 X 10(4) M-1 are estimated for Ca2+ and pdTp, respectively, and from the enthalpies at ligand saturation, binding enthalpies at 53 degrees C of -15.0 and -19.3 kcal mol-1.     

Backbone dynamics of apocytochrome b5 in its native, partially folded state

The backbone dynamics in the native state of apocytochrome b5 were studied using 15N nuclear magnetic spin relaxation measurements. The field (11.7 and 14.1 T) and temperature (10-25 degrees C) dependence of the relaxation parameters (R1, R2, and R1rho) and the 1H-15N NOE established that the protein undergoes multiple time scale internal motions related to the secondary structure. The relaxation data were analyzed with the reduced spectral density mapping approach and within the extended model-free framework. The apoprotein was confirmed to contain a disordered heme-binding loop of approximately 30 residues with dynamics on the sub-nanosecond time scale (0.6 < S2 < 0.7, 100 ps < taue < 500 ps). This loop is attached to a structured hydrophobic core, rigid on the picosecond time scale (S2 > 0.75, taue < 50 ps). The inability to fit the data for several residues with the model-free protocol revealed the presence of correlated motion. An exchange contribution was detected in the transverse relaxation rate (R2) of all residues. The differential temperature response of R2 along the backbone supported slower exchange rates for residues in the loop (tauex > 300 micros) than for the folded polypeptide chain (tauex < 150 micros). The distribution of the reduced spectral densities at the 1H and 15N frequencies followed the dynamic trend and predicted the slowing of the internal motions at 10 degrees C. Comparison of the dynamics with those of the holoprotein [Dangi, B., Sarma, S., Yan, C., Banville, D. L., and Guiles, R. D. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 8289-8302] demonstrated that binding of the heme alters the time scale of motions both in the heme-binding loop and in the structured hydrophobic core.     

Electrostatic effects in unfolded staphylococcal nuclease

Structure-based calculations of pKa values and electrostatic free energies of proteins assume that electrostatic effects in the unfolded state are negligible. In light of experimental evidence showing that this assumption is invalid for many proteins, and with increasing awareness that the unfolded state is more structured and compact than previously thought, a detailed examination of electrostatic effects in unfolded proteins is warranted. Here we address this issue with structure-based calculations of electrostatic interactions in unfolded staphylococcal nuclease. The approach involves the generation of ensembles of structures representing the unfolded state, and calculation of Coulomb energies to Boltzmann weight the unfolded state ensembles. Four different structural models of the unfolded state were tested. Experimental proton binding data measured with a variant of nuclease that is unfolded under native conditions were used to establish the validity of the calculations. These calculations suggest that weak Coulomb interactions are an unavoidable property of unfolded proteins. At neutral pH, the interactions are too weak to organize the unfolded state; however, at extreme pH values, where the protein has a significant net charge, the combined action of a large number of weak repulsive interactions can lead to the expansion of the unfolded state. The calculated pKa values of ionizable groups in the unfolded state are similar but not identical to the values in small peptides in water. These studies suggest that the accuracy of structure-based calculations of electrostatic contributions to stability cannot be improved unless electrostatic effects in the unfolded state are calculated explicitly.     

Interactions of the acid and base catalysts on staphylococcal nuclease as studied in a double mutant.

The mechanism of the phosphodiesterase reaction catalyzed by staphylococcal nuclease is believed to involve concerted general acid-base catalysis by Arg-87 and Glu-43. The mutual interactions of Arg-87 and Glu-43 were investigated by comparing kinetic and thermodynamic properties of the single mutant enzymes E43S (Glu-43 to Ser) and R87G (Arg-87 to Gly) with those of the double mutant, E43S + R87G, in which both the basic and acidic functions have been inactivated. Denaturation studies with guanidinium chloride, CD, and 600-MHz 1D and 2D proton NMR spectra, indicate all enzyme forms to be predominantly folded in absence of the denaturant and reveal small antagonistic effects of the E43S and R87G mutations on the stability and structure of the wild-type enzyme. The free energies of binding of the divalent cation activator Ca2+, the inhibitor Mn2+, and the substrate analogue 3',5'-pdTp show simple additive effects of the two mutations in the double mutant, indicating that Arg-87 and Glu-43 act independently to facilitate the binding of divalent cations and of 3',5'-pdTP by the wild-type enzyme. The free energies of binding of the substrate, 5'-pdTdA, both in binary E-S and in active ternary E-Ca(2+)-S complexes, show synergistic effects of the two mutations, suggesting that Arg-87 and Glu-43 interact anticooperatively in binding the substrate, possibly straining the substrate by 1.6 kcal/mol in the wild-type enzyme. The large free energy barriers to Vmax introduced by the R87G mutation (delta G1 = 6.5 kcal/mol) and by the E43S mutation (delta G2 = 5.0 kcal/mol) are partially additive in the double mutant (delta G1+2 = 8.1 kcal/mol). These partially additive effects on Vmax are most simply explained by a cooperative component to transition state binding by Arg-87 and Glu-43 of -3.4 kcal/mol. The combination of anticooperative, cooperative, and noncooperative effects of Arg-87 and Glu-43 together lower the kinetic barrier to catalysis by 8.1 kcal/mol.     

A dynamic bundle of four adjacent hydrophobic segments in the denatured state of staphylococcal nuclease.

In an earlier study of the denatured state of staphylococcal nuclease (Wang Y, Shortle D, 1995, Biochemistry 34:15895-15905), we reported evidence of a three-strand antiparallel beta sheet that persists at high urea concentrations and is stabilized by a local "non-native" interaction with four large hydrophobic residues. Because the amide proton resonances for all of the involved residues are severely broadened, this unusual structure is not amenable to conventional NMR analysis and must be studied by indirect methods. In this report, we present data that confirm the important role of interactions involving four hydrophobic residues (Leu 36, Leu 37, Leu 38, and Val 39) in stabilizing the structure formed by the chain segments corresponding to beta 1-beta 2-beta 3-h, interactions that are not present in the native state. Glycine substitutions for each of these large hydrophobic residues destabilizes or disrupts this beta structure, as assessed by HN line sharpening and changes in the CD spectrum. The 13C resonances of the carbonyl carbon for several of the residues in this structure indicate conformational dynamics that respond in a complex way to addition of urea or changes in sequence. Studies of hydrogen exchange kinetics in a closely related variant of staphylococcal nuclease demonstrate the absence of the stable hydrogen bonding between the strands expected for a native-like three-strand beta sheet. Instead, the data are more consistent with the three beta strand segments plus the four adjacent hydrophobic residues forming a dynamic, aligned array or bundle held together by hydrophobic interactions.     

Characterization of the residual structure in the unfolded state of the Delta131Delta fragment of staphylococcal nuclease

The determination of the conformational preferences in unfolded states of proteins constitutes an important challenge in structural biology. We use inter-residue distances estimated from site-directed spin-labeling NMR experimental measurements as ensemble-averaged restraints in all-atom molecular dynamics simulations to characterise the residual structure of the Delta131Delta fragment of staphylococcal nuclease under physiological conditions. Our findings indicate that Delta131Delta under these conditions shows a tendency to form transiently hydrophobic clusters similar to those present in the native state of wild-type staphylococcal nuclease. Only rarely, however, all these interactions are simultaneously realized to generate conformations with an overall native topology.     

The foldon substructure of staphylococcal nuclease

To search for submolecular foldon units, the spontaneous reversible unfolding and refolding of staphylococcal nuclease under native conditions was studied by a kinetic native-state hydrogen exchange (HX) method. As for other proteins, it appears that staphylococcal nuclease is designed as an assembly of well-integrated foldon units that may define steps in its folding pathway and may regulate some other functional properties. The HX results identify 34 amide hydrogens that exchange with solvent hydrogens under native conditions by way of large transient unfolding reactions. The HX data for each hydrogen measure the equilibrium stability (ΔG_HX) and the kinetic unfolding and refolding rates (k_op and k_cl) of the unfolding reaction that exposes it to exchange. These parameters separate the 34 identified residues into three distinct HX groupings. Two correspond to clearly defined structural units in the native protein, termed the blue and red foldons. The remaining HX grouping contains residues, not well separated by their HX parameters alone, that represent two other distinct structural units in the native protein, termed the green and yellow foldons. Among these four sets, a last unfolding foldon (blue) unfolds with a rate constant of 6 × 10^− 6 s^− 1 and free energy equal to the protein's global stability (10.0 kcal/mol). It represents part of the β-barrel, including mutually H-bonding residues in the β4 and β5 strands, a part of the β3 strand that H-bonds to β5, and residues at the N-terminus of the α2 helix that is capped by β5. A second foldon (green), which unfolds and refolds more rapidly and at slightly lower free energy, includes residues that define the rest of the native α2 helix and its C-terminal cap. A third foldon (yellow) defines the mutually H-bonded β1-β2-β3 meander, completing the native β-barrel, plus an adjacent part of the α1 helix. A final foldon (red) includes residues on remaining segments that are distant in sequence but nearly adjacent in the native protein. Although the structure of the partially unfolded forms closely mimics the native organization, four residues indicate the presence of some nonnative misfolding interactions. Because the unfolding parameters of many other residues are not determined, it seems likely that the concerted foldon units are more extensive than is shown by the 34 residues actually observed.     

Structural and energetic differences between insertions and substitutions in staphylococcal nuclease.

In a previous study, the small protein staphylococcal nuclease was shown to readily accommodate single alanine and glycine insertions, with average losses in stability comparable to substitutions at the same sites (PROT. 7:299-305, 1990). To more fully explore this unexpected adaptability to changes in residue spacing, 2 double amino acid insertions (alanyl-glycine, glycyl-glycine) and 3 additional single amino acid insertions with dissimilar side chains (proline, leucine, and glutamine) were constructed at 10 of the sites previously studied. At 8 of these sites, the type of amino acid side chain on the inserted residue significantly influenced the stability of the mutant protein. However, at 9 of the 10 sites, the double insertions were found to be no more destabilizing than the single alanine or glycine insertions. In contrast, double substitution mutations of staphylococcal nuclease, which replace two adjacent residues with alanine, do not show this striking degree of non-additivity. A comparison of the effects of single glutamine and single glycine insertions with alanyl-glycine insertions indicates that insertion of alanine into the peptide backbone is, on average, less destabilizing than appending the equivalent atoms onto the side chain of a glycine insertion. To explain their very different energetic effects, we propose that, unlike most substitutions, the inserted residue(s) must induce lateral displacements of the polypeptide chain, forcing the folded conformation away from that of wild type. The resulting obligatory shifts in the positioning of residues flanking the insertion generate a large number of degrees of freedom around which the mutant structure can relax.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

A model of the changes in denatured state structure underlying m value effects in staphylococcal nuclease.

Hydrogen exchange kinetics were measured on the native states of wild type staphylococcal nuclease and four mutants with values of mGuHCl (defined as dDeltaG/d[guanidine hydrochloride]) ranging from 0.8 to 1.4 of the wild type value. Residues within the five-strand beta-barrel of wild type and E75A and D77A, two mutants with reduced values of m GuHCl, were significantly more protected from exchange than expected on the basis of global stability as measured by fluorescence. In contrast, mutants V23A and M26G with elevated values of mGuHCl approach a flat profile of more or less constant protection independent of position in the structure. Differences in exchange protection between the C-terminus and the beta-barrel region correlate with mGuHCl, suggesting that a residual barrel-like structure becomes more highly populated in the denatured states of m- mutants and less populated in m+ mutants. Variations in the population of such a molten globule-like structure would account for the large changes in solvent accessible surface area of the denatured state thought to underlie m value effects.