Three-dimensional electron diffraction of PhoE porin to 2.8 A resolution

A three-dimensional set of electron diffraction intensities of PhoE porin embedded in trehalose extending to 2.8 A resolution has been collected and analyzed. The strongest high-resolution intensities are distributed as a figure of revolution about the z*-axis and are located primarily in a resolution range of 4.5 A to 5.0 A. Within this region, centered near 4.8 A resolution the brightest intensities are clustered about inclination angles of 35 degrees and 0 degrees from the a*, b* plane. This distribution of intensities indicates that the beta-sheet in PhoE porin is arranged to form a cylinder-like structure that contains major populations of beta-sheet strands tilted an average of 35 degrees and 0 degrees with respect to the membrane plane normal. This cylindrical structure has been seen previously in the high-resolution projection map of PhoE as an elliptical ring of high density.     

Structure of PhoE porin in projection at 3.5 A resolution.

The structure of PhoE porin in projection normal to the membrane plane has been determined to a resolution of about 3.5 A by electron crystallographic techniques. The purified protein was reconstituted with lipid to form two-dimensional crystals. High resolution images and electron diffraction patterns of these specimens embedded in trehalose were recorded to obtain respectively the structure factor phase information and the more accurate values of the amplitude. The projection map shows interesting features that are not seen in the earlier map at 6.5 A. Details of the trimeric ring-like structures in our earlier map are now resolved. Each ring-like structure consists of "beads" with interbead spacings of about 4-6 A. These beads are interpreted as the projections of beta-strands along the strands' axes. At the center of the trimeric structure, there is a low density region that we proposed previously to be the location of lipopolysaccharide. Within each ring-like structure, there are complicated features which may play an important role in the size, selectivity, and stability of the channel.     

Prediction of the general structure of OmpF and PhoE from the sequence and structure of porin from Rhodobacter capsulatus. Orientation of porin in the membrane.

By comparing the hydrophilicity profiles and sequences of porin from Rhodobacter capsulatus with those of OmpF and PhoE from Escherichia coli, a set of insertions and deletions for alignment of the sequences has been deduced. With this alignment a similar folding of OmpF and PhoE has been predicted as found by X-ray structure analysis of porin from Rhodobacter capsulates. Furthermore, the orientation of the porin trimer in the outer membrane was inferred from topological data on PhoE. According to this result a single channel of approx. 30 A diameter starts at the outer surface. Near the middle of the outer membrane bilayer this channel branches out into three separate channels, each running within a single porin monomer to the periplasmic surface.     

Chemical modification of the anion selectivity of the PhoE porin from the Escherichia coli outer membrane

The PhoE porin of Escherichia coli is induced by phosphate deprivation and when purified, forms moderately anion-selective channels in lipid bilayer membranes. To further investigate the basis of anion selectivity, PhoE was chemically acetylated with acetic anhydride. Acetylation modified the mobility and staining characteristics of the PhoE porin on SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis but the acetylated protein was still found in its normal trimeric state after solubilization in SDS at low temperatures. Furthermore, the acetylated PhoE porin retained its ability to reconstitute into lipid bilayer membranes and the single channel conductance in 1 M KCl was unaltered. Zero-current potential measurements demonstrated that whereas the native PhoE porin was anion-selective, a 30-40-fold increase in preference for cations upon acetylation resulted in the acetylated PhoE porin being cation-selective. Increasing the pH of KCl solutions bathing lipid bilayer membranes from pH 3 to pH 6 caused symmetrical 4-fold increases in the selectivity of both the native and acetylated PhoE proteins for cations. In contrast, increasing the pH from 7 to 9 caused a 2.5-fold increase in selectivity only for the native PhoE porin. These results suggest that the basis of anion selectivity in the native PhoE porin is fixed protonated amino groups (possibly on lysines) in or near the channel, and furthermore indicate that deprotonated carboxyl groups have a strong influence on ion selectivity.     

Porin channels in Escherichia coli: studies with liposomes reconstituted from purified proteins.

Rates of diffusion of uncharged and charged solute molecules through porin channels were determined by using liposomes reconstituted from egg phosphatidylcholine and purified Escherichia coli porins OmpF (protein 1a), OmpC (protein 1b), and PhoE (protein E). All three porin proteins appeared to produce channels of similar size, although the OmpF channel appeared to be 7 to 9% larger than the OmpC and PhoE channels in an equivalent radius. Hydrophobicity of the solute retarded the penetration through all three channels in a similar manner. The presence of one negative charge on the solute resulted in about a threefold reduction in penetration rates through OmpF and OmpC channels, whereas it produced two- to tenfold acceleration of diffusion through the PhoE channel. The addition of the second negatively charged group to the solutes decreased the diffusion rates through OmpF and OmpC channels further, whereas diffusion through the PhoE channel was not affected much. These results suggest that PhoE specializes in the uptake of negatively charged solutes. At the present level of resolution, no sign of true solute specificity was found in OmpF and OmpC channels; peptides, for example, diffused through both of these channels at rates expected from their molecular size, hydrophobicity, and charge. However, the OmpF porin channel allowed influx of more solute molecules per unit time than did the equivalent weight of the OmpC porin when the flux was driven by a concentration gradient of the same size. This apparent difference in "efficiency" became more pronounced with larger solutes, and it is likely to be the consequence of the difference in the sizes of OmpF and OmpC channels.     

Effects of pore mutations and permeant ion concentration on the spontaneous gating activity of OmpC porin

Porins are trimers of beta-barrels that form channels for ions and other hydrophilic solutes in the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. The X-ray structures of OmpF and PhoE show that each monomeric pore is constricted by an extracellular loop that folds into the channel vestibule, a motif that is highly conserved among bacterial porins. Electrostatic calculations have suggested that the distribution of ionizable groups at the constriction zone (or eyelet) may establish an intrinsic transverse electrostatic field across the pore, that is perpendicular to the pore axis. In order to study the role that electrostatic interactions between pore residues may have in porin function, we used spontaneous mutants and engineered site-directed mutants that have an altered charge distribution at the eyelet and compared their electrophysiological behavior with that of wild-type OmpC. We found that some mutations lead to changes in the spontaneous gating activity of OmpC porin channels. Changes in the concentration of permeant ions also altered this activity. These results suggest that the ionic interactions that exist between charged residues at the constriction zone of porin may play a role in the transitions between the channel's closed and open states.     

Densely packed beta-structure at the protein-lipid interface of porin is revealed by high-resolution cryo-electron microscopy

Porin is an integral membrane protein that forms channels across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. Electron microscopic studies of negatively stained two-dimensional porin crystals have shown three stain accumulations per porin trimer, revealing the locations of pores spanning the membrane. In this study, reconstituted porin lattices embedded in glucose were investigated using the low-dose technique on a cryo-electron microscope equipped with a helium-cooled superconducting objective lens. The specimen temperature was maintained at 5 K to yield an improved microscopic and specimen stability. Under these conditions, we obtained for the first time electron diffraction patterns from porin lattices to a resolution of 3.2 A and images showing optical diffraction up to a resolution of 4.9 A. Applying correlation averaging techniques to the digitized micrographs, we were able to reconstruct projected images of the porin trimer to a resolution of up to 3.5 A. In the final projection maps, amplitudes from electron diffraction and phases from these images were combined. The predominant feature is a high-density narrow band (about 6 A in thickness) that delineates the outer perimeter of the trimer. Since the molecule consists of almost exclusively beta-sheet structure, as revealed by spectroscopic data, we conclude that this band is a cylindrical beta-pleated sheet crossing the membrane nearly perpendicularly to its plane. Another intriguing finding is a low-density area (about 70 A2) situated in the centre of the trimer.     

Effects of pH on bacterial porin function.

Porin is a trimeric channel-forming protein in the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. Functions of the porins OmpF, OmpC, and PhoE from Escherichia coli K12 were analyzed at various pHs. Preliminary results from bilayer lipid membrane and liposome swelling assays indicated that in vitro porin has at least two open-channel configurations with a small and a large size. The small channels were stabilized at low pH while the larger channels were detected under basic conditions. The size switch occurred over a very narrow range near neutral pH, and the two major open-channel configurations responded differently to variations in voltage. The presence of two or more pH-dependent substates of porin could explain the variability in pore diameter measured by others and suggests a more dynamic role for porin in the cell.     

High-resolution electron diffraction of reconstituted PhoE porin

PhoE porin has been reconstituted with phospholipid, forming large membrane patches. Electron diffraction shows that the reconstituted PhoE porin forms highly coherent crystalline arrays, giving structural information to a resolution of 3.4 A. The crystal form is of the orthorhombic space group P2(1)2(1)2, with unit cell dimensions a = 150 A and b = 129 A. Images of negatively stained PhoE crystalline patches show that there are four PhoE porin trimers in a unit cell.     

High resolution crystal structures and molecular dynamics studies reveal substrate binding in the porin Omp32

The porin Omp32 is the major outer membrane protein of the bacterium Delftia acidovorans. The crystal structures of the strongly anion-selective porin alone and in complex with the substrate malate were solved at 1.5 and 1.45 A resolution, respectively, and revealed a malate-binding motif adjacent to the channel constriction zone. Binding is mediated by interaction with a cluster of two arginine residues and two threonines. This binding site is specific for Omp32 and reflects the physiological adaptation of the organism to organic acids. Structural studies are combined with a 7-ns unbiased molecular dynamics simulation of the trimeric channel in a model membrane. Molecular dynamics trajectories show how malate ions are efficiently captured from the surrounding bulk solution by the electrostatic potential of the channel, translocated to the binding site region, and immobilized in the constriction zone. In accordance with these results, conductance measurements with Omp32 inserted in planar lipid membranes revealed binding of malate. The anion-selective channel Omp32 is the first reported example of a porin with a 16-stranded beta-barrel and proven substrate specificity. This finding suggests a new view on the correlation of porin structure with substrate binding in specific channels.     

Topology of PhoE porin: the 'eyelet' region

A model for the topology of the PhoE porin has been proposed according to which the polypeptide traverses the outer membrane sixteen times mostly as amphipathic β-sheets, thereby exposing eight loops at the cell surface. Until now, no evidence has been obtained for the surface exposure of the third loop. Recently, the structure of porin of Rhodobacter capsulatus has been determined. The proposed model of PhoE is very similar to the structure of the R capsulatus porin, which has an ‘eyelet’ region, extending into the interior of the pore. The proposed third external loop of PhoE might form a similar ‘eyelet’ region. To determine the location of the predicted third external loop of PhoE, multiple copies of an oligonucleotide linker encoding an antigenic determinant of VP1 protein of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) were inserted. All hybrid proteins were properly inserted in the outer membrane. The monoclonal antibody MA11, directed against the linear FMDV epitope, was able to bind only to intact cells expressing a hybrid PhoE protein with at least three copies of the FMDV epitope present. Antibiotic sensitivity tests and single-channel conductance measurements revealed that the insertions influenced the channel size. These results are consistent with a location of the third loop of PhoE within the pore channel.     

Homology models of the Yersinia pseudotuberculosis and Yersinia pestis general porins and comparative analysis of their functional and antigenic regions

The amino acid sequences of the Yersinia pseudotuberculosis porin (YPS) and Y. pestis porin (YPT) have recently deduced but their three-dimensional structures were not known. These sequences were analyzed using the servers 3D-PSSM and PredPort. The YPS and YPT porins were shown to have a high degree of identity (above 50%) in primary and secondary structures. The three-dimensional models of the Yersinia pseudotuberculosis porin (YPS) and Y. pestis porin (YPT) were obtained using the homology modeling approach, SWISS-MODEL Protein Modeling Server and 3-D structure of PhoE porin from E. coli as template. The superposition of the Calpha-atoms of the monomers of the Yersinia porins and PhoE porin gave a root mean square deviations of 0.47 A and 0.43 A for YPS and YPT respectively. Yersinia porins were found to be very similar in their three-dimensional structure to other non-specific enterobacterial porins, having the same features of overall fold and disposition of loop L3. The intrinsic structures of the monomer pores of YPS and YPT were investigated and their conductances were predicted with the program HOLE. The good correspondence between the theoretical and experimental magnitudes of YPS conductance was found. The Yersinia porins were determined to be unusual in containing the substitution, Glu replaced by Val, in a highly conserved pentapeptide (Pro-Glu-Phe-Gly-Gly-Asp), located in the loop L3 tip that disturbs the functionally important cluster of the acidic amino acids in the constriction site. Comparative analysis of structural organization of YPS and E. coli OmpF porin in the regions involved in subunit association and pore lumen was performed. The YPS porin functional properties were predicted. The differences between these porins in polar interactions playing a significant role in stabilization of the porin trimers were found and discussed in term of the variations in trimer stability. The Yersinia porins were shown to have the highest degree of the structural similarity. The differences between the porins were observed in their external loops. Their loops L6 and loops L8 showed 71.4 and 52.9% of sequence identity, respectively. The arrangement of charged residues clustered in the channel external vestibule of these porins was found to be also different suggesting the possible differences in their functional properties. The surface exposed regions of Yersinia porins involved in their potential sequential antigenic determinants were compared. The structural basis of their cross reactivity and antigenic differences is discussed.     

Crystal structure of Omp32, the anion-selective porin from Comamonas acidovorans, in complex with a periplasmic peptide at 2.1 A resolution

BACKGROUND: Porins provide diffusion channels for salts and small organic molecules in the outer membrane of bacteria. In OmpF from Escherichia coli and related porins, an electrostatic field across the channel and a potential, originating from a surplus of negative charges, create moderate cation selectivity. Here, we investigate the strongly anion-selective porin Omp32 from Comamonas acidovorans, which is closely homologous to the porins of pathogenic Bordetella and Neisseria species. RESULTS: The crystal structure of Omp32 was determined to a resolution of 2.1 A using single isomorphous replacement with anomalous scattering (SIRAS). The porin consists of a 16-stranded beta barrel with eight external loops and seven periplasmic turns. Loops 3 and 8, together with a protrusion located within beta-strand 2, narrow the cross-section of the pore considerably. Arginine residues create a charge filter in the constriction zone and a positive surface potential at the external and periplasmic faces. One sulfate ion was bound to Arg38 in the channel constriction zone. A peptide of 5.8 kDa appeared bound to Omp32 in a 1:1 stoichiometry on the periplasmic side close to the symmetry axis of the trimer. Eight amino acids of this peptide could be identified, revealing specific interactions with beta-strand 1 of the porin. CONCLUSIONS: The Omp32 structure explains the strong anion selectivity of this porin. Selectivity is conferred by a positive potential, which is not attenuated by negative charges inside the channel, and by an extremely narrow constriction zone. Moreover, Omp32 represents the anchor molecule for a peptide which is homologous to proteins that link the outer membrane to the cell wall peptidoglycan.     

Porin channels in Escherichia coli: studies with beta-lactams in intact cells

Wild-type Escherichia coli K-12 produces two porins, OmpF (protein 1a) and OmpC (protein 1b). In mutants deficient in both of these "normal" porins, secondary mutants that produce a "new" porin, protein PhoE (protein E), are selected for. We determined the properties of the channels produced by each of these porins by measuring the rates of diffusion of various cephalosporins through the outer membrane in strains producing only one porin species. We found that all porin channels retarded the diffusion of more hydrophobic cephalosporins and that with monoanionic cephalosporins a 10-fold increase in the octanol-water partition coefficient of the solute produced a 5- to 6-fold decrease in the rate of penetration. Electrical charges of the solutes had different effects on different channels. Thus, with the normal porins (i.e., OmpF and OmpC proteins) additional negative charge drastically reduced the penetration rate through the channels, whereas additional positive charge significantly accelerated the penetration. In contrast, diffusion through the PhoE channel was unaffected by the presence of an additional negative charge. We hypothesize that the relative exclusion of hydrophobic and negatively charged solutes by normal porin channels is of ecological advantage to E. coli, which must exclude hydrophobic and anionic bile salts in its natural habitat. The properties of the PhoE porin are also consistent with the recent finding (M. Argast and W. Boos, J. Bacteriol. 143:142-150, 1980; J. Tommassen and B. Lugtenberg, J. Bacteriol. 143:151-157, 1980) that its biosynthesis is derepressed by phosphate starvation; the channel may thus act as an emergency pore primarily for the uptake of phosphate and phosphorylated compounds.     

E.coli PhoE porin has an opposite voltage-dependence to the homologous OmpF.

We used patch clamp analysis to compare the electrophysiological behavior of two related porins from Escherichia coli, the anion-specific PhoE and the cation-selective OmpF. Outer membrane fractions were obtained from strains expressing just one of these porin types, and the channels were reconstituted into liposomes without prior purification. We show that the orientation of the reconstituted channels is not random and is the same for both PhoE and OmpF. Like cation-selective porins, PhoE shows fast and slow gating to closed levels of various amplitudes, testifying that the channels visit multiple functional states and behave as cooperative entities. The voltage-dependence of PhoE closure is asymmetric, but strikingly, occurs at voltages of inverse polarity from those promoting closures of OmpC and OmpF. Both slow kinetics and inverse voltage-dependence are removed when 70 amino acids from the N-terminal of OmpF are introduced into the homologous region of PhoE. This novel observation regarding the voltage-dependence of the two channel types, along with published results on PhoE and OmpF mutants, allows us to propose a molecular mechanism for voltage sensing and sensor charge movements in bacterial porins. It also offers new cues on the possible physiological relevance in bacteria of this common form of channel modulation.     

Outer-membrane protein PhoE from Escherichia coli forms anion-selective pores in lipid-bilayer membranes

Porin PhoE of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli was isolated and purified. Reconstitution experiments with lipid bilayer membranes showed that this protein formed pores which had a single channel conductance of 210 pS at 0.1 M KCl. The PhoE pores were obviously not voltage-controlled or regulated. In contrast to pores formed by the OmpF porin from E. coli the PhoE channel was found to be anion-selective at neutral pH. Chloride is about three to ten times more permeable through the pore than alkali ions. On the basis of the observed pH dependence of the permeability ratio of anions and cations, this anionic selectivity is explained by the assumption that the PhoE pore contains an excess of fixed positive charges.     

A tetrameric porin limits the cell wall permeability of Mycobacterium smegmatis

Mycobacteria protect themselves with an outer lipid bilayer, which is the thickest biological membrane hitherto known and has an exceptionally low permeability rendering mycobacteria intrinsically resistant against many antibiotics. Pore proteins mediate the diffusion of hydrophilic nutrients across this membrane. Electron microscopy revealed that the outer membrane of Mycobacterium smegmatis contained about 1000 protein pores per microm(2), which are about 50-fold fewer pores per microm(2) than in Gram-negative bacteria. The projection structure of the major porin MspA of M. smegmatis was determined at 17 A resolution. MspA forms a cone-like tetrameric complex of 10 nm in length with a single central pore. Thus, MspA is drastically different from the trimeric porins of Gram-negative bacteria and represents a new class of channel proteins. The formation of MspA micelles indicated that the ends of MspA have different hydrophobicities. Oriented insertion of MspA into membranes was demonstrated in lipid bilayer experiments, which revealed a strongly asymmetrical voltage gating of MspA channels at -30 mV. The length of MspA is sufficient to span the outer membrane and contributes in combination with the tapering end of the pore and the low number of pores to the low permeability of the cell wall of M. smegmatis for hydrophilic compounds.     

Orientation of porin channels in the outer membrane of Bordetella pertussis

We have examined the surface topography and channel connectivity of a naturally crystalline porin that is known to be functional, and whose structure has not been perturbed by detergent extraction, A three-dimensional density map, calculated from two independent tilt series of negatively stained cell envelopes, reveals three separate channels per trimer on one side (the ‘smooth’ side), and a single common opening at the other (‘rough’) side. This arrangement is consistent with the molecular structures recently determined at high resolution by X-ray crystallography for three other porins after detergent solubilization, and implies that the Bordetella pertussis porin may have the same kind of folding. Surface relief maps calculated from electron micrographs of cell envelopes contrasted by unidirectional shadowing clearly show that the side with single opening (i.e. the rough side) represents the external surface.     

One single lysine residue is responsible for the special interaction between polyphosphate and the outer membrane porin PhoE of Escherichia coli

Site-directed mutagenesis was performed with the phosphate starvation-inducible outer membrane porin PhoE of Escherichia coli K-12 to study the molecular basis of its anion selectivity. Lysines 18, 29, 64, and 125 were replaced by glutamic acids, and the properties of the mutant porins were investigated in in vivo and in vitro experiments. Lipid bilayer experiments showed that all these mutations had no influence on the pore structure because PhoE and the mutants had the same single channel conductance in KCl solution. Selectivity measurements revealed that the mutations changed the ionic selectivity of PhoE, but the change was dependent on the location of the lysine. Replacement of Lys18 and Lys29 by glutamic acid had a relatively small influence. The effect of the Lys64 substitution was somewhat larger, and the effect of the replacement of Lys125 resulted in the most drastic change in selectivity and in the loss of the interaction of PhoE with polyphosphate, whereas the replacement of the other lysines had no effect on the polyphosphate interaction behavior. The results are consistent with the assumption that the charge spot in PhoE consists of only 1 lysine per monomer, located in position 125 of the primary sequence and probably close to the pore interior.     

The three-dimensional structure of porin from Rhodobacter capsulatus at 3 A resolution

The crystal structure of porin from Rhodobacter capsulatus strain 37b4 has been solved at 3.0 A (1 A = 0.1 nm) resolution by multiple isomorphous replacement and solvent-flattening. The three pores of the trimer are well defined in the electron density map. Each pore consists of a 16-stranded beta-barrel which traverses the membrane as a tube. Near its center the tube is narrowed by chain segments protruding from the inner wall of the barrel that form an eye-let with an irregular cross-section of about 6 A by 10 A. The eye-let has an axial length of about 10 A; it defines the exclusion limit for diffusing particles.