The influence of environmental manipulations on inter– and intra–individual variation in food acquisition and growth performance of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus

Repeated measurements of food intake made on juvenile Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus , held under different rearing conditions enabled examination of the effects of environmental manipulations on both intra– and inter–individual variations in food intake to be made. This permitted the assessment of the influences of differential food acquisition on individual growth rates and biomass gain. When charr were held in isolation individual fish showed relatively little day–to–day variability in food intake and inter–individual differences in intake were small ('base–fine' values). All fish exhibited positive rates of growth and the overall range was narrow. Nevertheless, there was a highly significant positive correlation between food intake and growth, indicating that those individuals that consumed the greatest quantities of food were also those that had the highest rates of weight gain. The rearing of charr in groups led to increases in both intra– and inter–individual variations in food intake to levels considerably above 'base–line'. This increased variability in food intake was reflected in rates of weight gain being more variable amongst the charr reared in groups, with fish that lost weight often being recorded. Manipulation of the rearing environment had marked influences upon intra–individual variability in food intake, inter–individual differences in food acquisition and rates of weight gain. High stocking densities and exposure of the fish to moderate water currents were most effective in reducing levels of variability to approach those observed under 'base–line' conditions.     

The effect of stocking density on the behaviour of Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus L.)

Recent studies have demonstrated that Arctic charr ( Salvelinus alpinus ) exhibit higher growth rates when held at high stocking densities. It has been argued that these increased growth rates are a result of decreased social interactions at the increased densities. The current study was designed to test this hypothesis by examining: (1) the frequency of agonistic interactions, (2) the proportion of time spent swimming and (3) growth rates among groups of young of the year Arctic charr held at different stocking densities. It was found that charr reared at higher densities exhibited significantly higher mean weights and lengths than those at the lower densities. The behavioural observations revealed that charr initiated significantly fewer agonistic interactions and spent a significantly greater amount of time shoaling at high densities than charr held at the medium or low densities. It is argued that these behavioural responses may serve to lower energy expenditures, resulting in the increased growth rates.     

The role of visual cues in the facilitation of growth in a schooling fish

Synopsis This study tested the hypothesis that visual contact between fish may result in enhanced rates of growth in a schooling fish. Juvenile chum salmon, Oncorhynchus keta, were held singly and reared in isolation or in visual contact with conspecifics. Fish were fed at either a low (6% body weight d^–1) or high (20% body weight d^–1) ration for 42d. Specific rates of weight gain were 18% greater at low ration and 38% greater at high ration for fish in visual contract with conspecifics than for those held in isolation. The results demonstrate a selective advantage of visual cues associated with schooling behavior and suggest that the efficacy of growth models for schooling fishes may be enhanced by the consideration of social interactions which may facilitate growth.     

Influence of body weight and temperature on growth rates of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus (L.)

When reared for a period of 6 months at a temperature of 10°C Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus , increased in weight from 18 g to approximately 135 g. Specific growth rates decreased as the fish increased in size and the relationship between size and growth rate could be described by the equation:
where G _w is specific growth rate and W is fish weight in grams. Temperature effects upon growth were examined using previously published data. Below the optimum growth temperature, the growth rate of a fish of given size could be predicted using the equation:
where T is the rearing temperature.
Rates of growth of Arctic charr were as high as those reported for other salmonid species reared under similar conditions. Preliminary results suggested that growth rates of charr may be lower in salt water than in fresh water.     

A comparison of growth patterns between a stunted and two large predatory Arctic charr populations under identical hatchery conditions

Arctic charr are characterized by an extensive variability in growth and body size in natural waters. Although growth traits may involve a significant heritable component, most of this intraspecific variation presumably is environmentally induced and thus attributable to phenotypic plasticity. In the present study, size-at-age and length–weight relationship (body condition) were assessed for three Finnish Arctic charr populations of different geographical origins and extreme size forms (a stunted vs. two large-growing, predatory charr) held under standardized rearing conditions for 3 years (up to 37 months after hatching). In particular, our interest was to investigate whether the differences in growth between the large and the stunted charr as observed in the wild populations would diminish when the fish are offered suitable food in abundance. Population-specific mean body size and condition differed significantly in 0+, 1+, 2+ and 3+ fish. However, the identical rearing conditions resulted in the originally stunted charr reaching a comparable final mean size (317 mm/427 g) as the large charr populations (343 mm/510 g and 359 mm/497 g). Some individuals were of the same size as their parents at spawning already at the age of 0+ years. Furthermore, length–weight regression residuals of the stunted charr developed to a notably high level, indicating the largest final condition mean. The increase of size variation (CV of weight) in stunted charr lasted for over two growth seasons, whereas in large charr it remained stable since the end of the first summer. Variations in mortality and sexual maturation at age 2 seemed to be less relevant factors affecting overall growth performance. The study demonstrates an example of the high plasticity involved in the growth of fish: the stunted charr possess a tremendous capacity for growth in a benign environment, virtually corresponding to that observed in the large predatory populations.     

Why do salmonid antipredator responses weaken in hatchery rearing?

The Arctic charr of Lake Saimaa are the most endangered fish population in Finland, and reintroduction programs have been unsuccessful. Low success of reintroduction programs has drawn attention to behavioural properties of hatcheryreared fish. Mortality due to predation often is a principal cause of failure. Antipredator behaviour may degenerate rapidly under hatchery conditions due to (i) reduced genetic variation in antipredator behaviour and/or (ii) selection that would favour bold and fast growing individuals and disfavour predator awareness supposedly associated with slow growth. To test the relative importance of these two factors we first analysed the amount of variation in innate antipredator responses between and within families of hatchery‐bred Arctic charr of the Lake Saimaa stock. We then tested whether fast growing individuals would show reduced responses to chemical cues from their natural predators compared to their slow growing counterparts. Based on the results we propose procedures for maintaining and improving antipredator skills of hatchery‐reared salmonids.     

Growth and mortality of Arctic charr and European whitefish reared at low temperatures

This comparative study explores how low temperatures affect the mortality and growth of first generation hatchery-reared progeny of subarctic populations of Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus L.) and European whitefish (Coregonus lavaretus L.). Replicate fish groups where held under simulated natural light regimes (70°N) at three constant temperatures (1, 3 and 6°C). The mortality of Arctic charr was low (≤1.4%) at all temperature treatments, whereas the mortality of whitefish increased with decreasing temperature from 6% at 6°C to 33% at 1°C. The Arctic charr exhibited higher growth rates than whitefish at all three temperature regimes. All groups of Arctic charr increased in weight, whereas whitefish held at 1°C did not gain weight throughout the experimental period of 133 days. Arctic charr exhibited a large intraspecific variability in growth leading to large variations in size-structure, whereas whitefish in contrast showed very homogenous growth and size-structure patterns; a dissimilarity probably related to species-specific differences in antagonistic behaviour. Evidently, Arctic charr are more cold water adapted than whitefish and are able to maintain growth at extremely low temperatures. Arctic charr thus appear to be the most suitable species for aquaculture at low water temperatures.     

The size structure of lacustrine Arctic charr (Pisces: Salmonidae) populations

The size structure of Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus) populations was analysed using published information; 44% of populations were bimodal, with both large (normal) and small (dwarf) morphs occurring within a cohort. The remaining populations were unimodal, consisting of normal-sized or of stunted adults. Bimodal populations increased in frequency with latitude and were characteristic of large, deep lakes with few fish species. The age and size at which bimodality developed, the size difference between the morphs, and the frequency of cannibalism in charr populations increased with latitude. A variety of genotypic and phenotypic explanations are examined. The evidence for specific differences between the morphs is unconvincing. Various competition and predation hypotheses fail to explain the occurrence of bimodality. Cannibalism does not cause bimodality despite being strongly associated with it since bimodality develops before charr become cannibalistic. Much of the variation in charr size structure is suggested to be a consequence of increased seasonality in food supply in more northerly environments, coupled with feeding size thresholds. The latter result in larger members of a cohort being able to maintain growth rates on seasonally abundant prey while smaller individuals which cannot catch these items form a second mode of more slowly growing fish. Bimodality is documented in a number of other, predominantly northern, fish species.     

Intraspecific competition and density dependence of food consumption and growth in Arctic charr

1. Intraspecific competition for restricted food resources is considered to play a fundamental part in density dependence of somatic growth and other population characteristics, but studies simultaneously addressing the interrelationships between population density, food acquisition and somatic growth have been missing. 2. We explored the food consumption and individual growth rates of Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus in a long-term survey following a large-scale density manipulation experiment in a subarctic lake. 3. Prior to the initiation of the experiment, the population density was high and the somatic growth rates low, revealing a severely overcrowded and stunted fish population. 4. During the 6-year period of stock depletion the population density of Arctic charr was reduced with about 75%, resulting in an almost twofold increase in food consumption rates and enhanced individual growth rates of the fish. 5. Over the decade following the density manipulation experiment, the population density gradually rose to intermediate levels, accompanied by corresponding reductions in food consumption and somatic growth rates. 6. The study revealed negative relationships with population density for both food consumption and individual growth rates, reflecting a strong positive correlation between quantitative food intake and somatic growth rates. 7. Both the growth and consumption rate relationships with population density were well described by negative power curves, suggesting that large density perturbations are necessary to induce improved feeding conditions and growth rates in stunted fish populations. 8. The findings demonstrate that quantitative food consumption represents the connective link between population density and individual growth rates, apparently being highly influenced by intraspecific competition for limited resources.     

Individual variation in distribution, activity and growth rate of Arctic charr kept in a three-tank system

The movements and distribution of groups of Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus were examined in a rearing system that offered a choice between two different feeding tanks separated by a larger non-feeding tank. The passages of individual fish were monitored continuously during a period of 3 weeks using the PIT (passive integrated transponder)-tag technique. The primary aim was to examine if only some charr were occupying the feeding tanks, thereby excluding other individuals, and whether differences in visit activity explained within-group variation in individual growth. On average, about 35 of the 40 charr in each group shoaled in the large non-feeding tank leaving only five individuals in the feeding tanks. Charr that spent a long total time in one of the feeding tanks made frequent excursions to the other tanks resulting in a continuous exchange of individuals. Individual growth rates were correlated positively with visit activity rather than with the total time spent in the feeding tanks. Thus, individuals with low growth rate spent as much time in feeding tanks as charr with high growth rate. However, less successful fish tended to visit the feeding tanks at night when the feeders were switched off. Based on behavioural and growth results obtained in this experiment, the use of multitank systems in the cultivation of Arctic charr is discussed.     

Migration, growth and survival of wild and hatchery-reared anadromous Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus) in Finnmark, Northern Norway

Two groups of anadromous Arctic charr ( Salvelinus alpinus ) (size 200–350 mm) reared in heated water (6–12° C) under simulated natural photoperiod were individually tagged and released in spring 1988. The fish were released at two sites, in the estuary of the River Halselva and in the fjord, 2 km from the river mouth. Growth, timing of migration and survival of these hatchery-reared fish was compared to that of wild anadromous charr of the same size over a 4-year period. The hatchery-reared charr had poorer growth than the wild fish during their first year in sea water. They also resided longer in the sea and had a slightly lower survival than wild fish. During the second year, hatchery-reared charr displayed good growth, and after the third sea-season the fish were ready for slaughter at a size of approximately 800g. The results suggest that the successful development of Arctic charr ranching will be dependent upon production and release strategies that lead to improved migratory and feeding behaviour of the fish during their first season at sea.     

Vaccination influences growth of Arctic charr

There is limited knowledge about the effects of oil-based vaccines on the growth of Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus, in particular at different rearing temperatures. One-year-old Arctic charr were immunized intraperitoneally at 2.9 degrees C with a metabolizable oil-adjuvanted, bivalent vaccine containing killed typical and atypical Aeromonas salmonicida bacteria. After vaccination the non-vaccinated (controls) and vaccinated individually marked fish were held for 20 d at 10.0 degrees C and then for 7 wk at 10.3, 14.1 or 18.1 degrees C. During the first 20 d at 10.0 degrees C the growth rate (G) was higher for non-vaccinated than vaccinated fish. Thereafter vaccinated charr had higher G than control fish at 10.3 and 14.1 degrees C. In contrast, at 18.1 degrees C there was no difference in G and therefore no compensation of earlier growth suppression in vaccinated fish was observed at that temperature. The study indicates that vaccination has no ultimate negative effects on the growth of Arctic charr at temperatures ranging from 10.3 to 14.1 degrees C.     

The development of regular seasonal habitat shifts in a landlocked Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus L., population

Parts of the Arctic charr population of the subarctic Lake Visjön in north-west Sweden migrate upstream during the spring to two small, recently eutrophied and very productive lakes. Large repeat migrants arrive first, followed by young first-time migrants. Charr in the small lakes grow more rapidly than those resident in L. Visjön. In early September mature fish leave the lakes, followed by immature fish later in September and in October. Overwintering and spawning takes place in L. Visjön. Migratory females attain maturity at age 4 years and resident females at age 6 years. The migrant fish return annually until they are 5–6 years old. This limit may be due to reduced relative growth benefits of the habitat shift for larger individuals. The rapid development of these regular habitat shifts could be explained by an internally fixed exploratory behaviour in these Arctic charr that makes the detection and utilization of distant feeding resources possible. Migrants will possess a considerably higher fitness, if survival rates for migratory and resident fish are equal.     

The Importance of Egg Size and Social Effects for Behaviour of Arctic Charr Juveniles

Early behaviour can determine food intake and growth rate with important consequences for life history and survival in fishes. Egg size is known to affect growth rate of young Arctic charr but its influence on the development of behaviour is poorly documented. It is believed that egg size influence on growth and potentially on the behaviour of young fish decreases over time, minimized by the effects of social factors. Shortly after first feeding, we examined differences in mobility and foraging of Arctic charr in relation to egg size and social environment. The behaviour of juveniles from small and large eggs was compared five times over the course of development and in three different experimental settings: long‐term isolation (isolation before hatching), short‐term isolation vs. group rearing and mixed size group vs. homogeneous size groups. Egg size affected foraging behaviour and mobility of fish: fish coming from large eggs were more mobile and foraged more than fish coming from small eggs. Social environment affected foraging behaviour, mobility and space use: fish in a group were more mobile, foraged more and responded faster to food delivery than isolated fish. The interaction of egg size and social effects was seen primarily in foraging activities but did not affect mobility or space use. Large fish in groups foraged more than the three other groups: large fish in isolation, small fish in groups and small fish in isolation. Agonistic behaviour was rarely observed and there was no significant effect of group composition on agonistic behaviour. We discuss the importance of egg size and social effects at early stages of development with a focus on the evolutionary ecology of Arctic charr.     

Development of spinal deformities in Atlantic salmon and Arctic charr fed diets supplemented with oxytetracycline

Some individuals within populations of Atlantic salmon Salmo salar and Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus fed diets supplemented with oxytetracycline (OTC) developed spinal deformations. Possible differences in feed intake and growth of spinally deformed fish relative to fish without any deformities were investigated. Amongst Atlantic salmon, 17% of the fish fed OTC-supplemented feed developed spinal fractures, whereas none of the fish receiving the basic feed did so. Despite deformation of the spinal column, the injured fish continued to feed and grow, but at lower rates than unaffected individuals. In contrast to Atlantic salmon, Arctic charr showed no signs of spinal fractures at any time during the 65-day experiment.     

Effect of feeding frequency on food intake and growth of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus L.

Social interactions and dominance hierarchy effects are important factors governing rates of growth of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus L. The effects of hierarchy were increased as access to food became more restricted, i.e. feeding frequency was reduced, but these effects could not be attributed to direct competition for food since fish were fed to satiation at each feeding period. The results suggest that, whilst some fish on the restricted feeding regime were able to maintain good rates of growth, feeding by the majority of the fish was inhibited by the presence of larger individuals. Due to the importance of these hierarchy effects it was not possible to demonstrate physiological adaptations in fish allowed infrequent access to food.     

Diet, gastric evacuation rates and food consumption in a stunted population of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus L., in Takvatn, northern Norway

Diet and food consumption of a stunted population of Arctic charr in Takvatn, northern Norway, was studied throughout the ice-free season. Chironomid pupae dominated the diet in June, July and August, while zooplankton and three-spined sticklebacks dominated in September and October. Estimates of gastric evacuation rates were obtained from laboratory experiments with wild-caught, acclimated charr, and these estimates were used for in situ estimation of food consumption from weights of stomach contents. The daily food consumption was greatest in July, after which it decreased markedly towards autumn. The estimated food intake rates were low, especially in September and October. The food supply appears to be restricted, which is probably the main reason why the charr in Takvaln exhibit stunted growth.     

Behavioural responses of naive Arctic charr young to chemical cues from salmonid and non-salmonid fish

The ability to distinguish among chemical cues from multiple predators is of key adaptive value for many prey fish. We examined the attractiveness and repulsiveness of chemical stimuli from different coexisting fish species fed on different diets on the behaviour of hatchery reared Arctic charr young in a Y-maze fluviarum, where the charr could choose between two sides either with control water or stimulus water with fish odour. We used stimuli from (1) matching sized conspecifics, large (2) Arctic charr, (3) salmon, (4) brown trout and (5) brown trout fed on Arctic charr fry. Other salmonids were given pellet food. Additional fish odour treatments included piscivorous (6) pike and (7) burbot. In the control trials both sides received control water. Arctic charr young were expected to respond adaptively to the stimuli from coexisting piscivorous fish. The charr most strongly preferred water with the odour of their matching sized conspecifics, which was the only fish odour they were familiar with before the experiments. They also showed significant preference for other salmonid odours, even though these fish are potential predators on small charr. Chemical stimuli from pike and burbot, on the contrary, were strongly avoided, and burbot odour even prevented the charr to swim and enter the lateral halves of the fluviarum. Moreover, odour from brown trout fed on Arctic charr fry was avoided when compared to stimuli from trout fed on pellets. Although the Arctic charr young were completely naive regarding piscivores, the fact that they could distinguish between different predator taxa and diets on the basis of chemical cues only reflects the long coevolutionary history of these fish populations.     

Takvatn Through 20 Years: Long-term Effects of an Experimental Mass Removal of Arctic Charr, Salvelinus Alpinus, From a Subarctic Lake

Between 1984 and 1989, the experimental removal of 31 tons (666000 fish) of stunted Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus, from Takvatn in northern Norway, had strong effects on the populations of Arctic charr, brown trout, Salmo trutta, and three-spined sticklebacks, Gasterosteus aculeatus. The littoral catch per unit effort (CPUE) of charr had decreased by 90% in 1990 and then increased to about 50% of the initial level by 1994 while the pelagic CPUE had decreased to zero. Growth in both charr and trout greatly improved when the charr density had decreased, and large fish of both species appeared in the catches. These large fish became predators on small charr in the littoral zone. The incidence of trout increased from below 1% to 15% from 1988 to 1999 after a brief peak at 30% in 1992 and 1993. The charr population attained a bimodal size distribution and did not return to the stunted state during the 10 years following the intensive fishing period. The mass removal experiment showed that it is possible to change the structure of a charr population by intensive fishing. Predation on small charr from cannibals and large trout was probably essential for maintaining the new population structure. An increase in the growth of young charr from 1995 to 1997 was related to a high consumption of Daphnia and Eurycercus. Rapid changes in the growth of charr followed the density fluctuations in sticklebacks, which show large annual variations in this system; the rapid changes in charr growth were probably caused by variations in the competition intensity for cladoceran prey between young charr and sticklebacks. Twenty years of data has provided important information, but even more time is needed to follow the long-term trends in northern lakes such as Takvatn.     

Seasonal changes in food consumption and growth of Arctic charr exposed to either simulated natural or a 12:12 LD photoperiod at constant water temperature

Immature male and female and maturing male Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus were held at constant temperature (4° C) under either simulated natural photoperiod (nLD) or constant photoperiod (12:12 LD) conditions, and feed intake and growth were monitored at monthly intervals over 13 months. Food was supplied in excess during a 5-h period each day, and daily consumption was determined using X-radiography. Food consumption and growth of both immature and maturing fish showed distinct seasonal cycles irrespective of photoperiod treatment. Feed intake and growth rates were highest in mid-summer and lowest in autumn. The fact that seasonal cycles persisted under constant photoperiod (12:12 LD) and temperature conditions suggests that circannual rhythms of food consumption and growth exist in the absence of seasonal changes in these environmental cues. The data support the view that seasonal changes in food consumption and growth in the Arctic charr are driven by endogenous rhythms. Reductions in feeding and growth in autumn occurred about 1 month earlier in the maturing males than in the immature fish. Males that matured under the 12:12 LD regime displayed a growth cycle that was delayed in comparison with that shown by the maturing males held under nLD.