Contraction of fibroblast-containing collagen gels: Initial collagen concentration regulates the degree of contraction and cell survival

Remodeling of extracellular matrix involves a number of steps including the recruitment, accumulation, and eventual apoptosis of parenchymal cells as well as the production, organization, and rearrangement of extracellular matrix produced by these cells. The culture of fibroblasts in three-dimensional gels made of type I collagen has been used as a model of tissue contraction which characterizes both wound repair and fibrosis. The current study was designed to determine the effect of initial collagen concentration on the ability of fibroblasts to contract collagen gels and on cell survival. Native type I collagen was extracted from rat tail tendons and used to prepare collagen gels with varying collagen concentrations (0.75-2.0 mg/ml). Human lung fibroblasts (HFL-1) were cast into the gels and cultured in Dulbecco modified Eagle medium with 0.1% fetal calf serum for 2 wk. The gel size, collagen content, and deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) content were determined. Gels prepared with an initial concentration of 0.75 mg/ml contracted more rapidly and to a smaller final size than gels prepared from 2 mg/ml initial collagen concentration (final size 7.1 versus 36.4% of initial size, P < 0.01). There was no significant degradation of the collagen in the gels under either condition. Hence, the dramatically increased contraction of the lower density gels resulted in a higher final density (P < 0.01). Cell density was estimated from DNA content. In low initial density gels, the final DNA content was significantly less than that in higher initial density gels (0.73 versus 1.88 microg/gel, P < 0.05). This was accompanied by an increased percentage of apoptotic cells at day 14 (43.3 versus 34.1%, P < 0.05). If the gels were maintained in the attached state which largely prevents contraction, apoptosis was significantly reduced, suggesting that contraction rather than matrix composition was a requirement for the increased apoptosis. In summary, these findings indicate that the initial matrix composition can lead to differing outcomes during fibroblast-mediated wound contraction.     

Photo-reconstituted collagen gel for tissue culture substrates

Dialysed acetic acid collagen extracts of rat-tail tendon, when mixed with an aqueous 0.05% solution of riboflavin-5′-phosphate in a ratio of 5:1, and dispensed onto coverslips, can be reconstituted by exposure to bright light for 5 min into gels suitable for the long-term cultivation of neural, muscle, and other tissues. They have a resilient, porous structure that readily accommodates to cell movements and allows outgrowing cells, and their processes, to migrate into the gel matrix and develop further. These gels can be formed near living cells in established cultures, permitting the transfer of culture ‘modules’ containing ACLAR inserts into a fresh base of photo-reconstituted collagen.     

Role of the α1β1 integrin complex in collagen gel contraction in vitro by fibroblasts

Matrix remodeling, critical to embryonic morphogenesis and wound healing, is dependent on the expression of matrix components, their receptors, and matrix proteases. The collagen gel assay has provided an effective model for the examination of the functional role(s) of each of these groups of molecules in matrix remodeling. Previous investigations have indicated that collagen gel contraction involves the β1 integrin family of matrix receptors and is stimulated by several growth factors, including TGF-β, PDGF, and angiotensin II. In particular, collagen gel remodeling by human cells involves the α2β1 and, to a lesser extent the α1β1 integrin complexes. The present studies were undertaken to determine the role of the α1 integrin chain, a collagen/laminin receptor, in collagen gel contration by rodent and avian fibroblasts. A high degree of correlation was found between the expression of the α1β1 integrin complex and the relative ability of cells to contract collagen gels. Further studies using antibodies and antisense oligonucleotides against the α1 integrin indicated a significant role for this integrin chain in contraction of collagen gels by rat cardiac fibroblasts. In addition, antibodies to the α1 integrin chain inhibited migration of these fibroblasts on a collagen substratum, suggesting that at least one role of this integrin is in migration of cells in collagen gels. These results indicate that the α1β integrin complex plays a significant role in cellular interactions with interstital collagen that are involved in matrix remodeling such as is seen during morphogenesis and wound healing. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The interaction of human papillary and reticular fibroblasts and human keratinocytes in the contraction of three-dimensional floating collagen lattices

Fibroblasts derived from the papillary and reticular dermis of human skin and human keratinocytes show differences in their abilities to contract floating three-dimensional gels constructed from type I collagen. Reticular fibroblasts produce greater gel contraction than papillary fibroblasts. When equal numbers of papillary and reticular fibroblasts are mixed in the gels, papillary fibroblasts consistently inhibit gel contraction by reticular fibroblasts indicating interaction between these cell types in the contraction process. Surprisingly, keratinocytes alone produce greater gel contraction than that produced by either fibroblast type. Cooperativity in the gel contraction process is observed when fibroblasts are incorporated into the collagen matrix and keratinocytes are seeded onto the gel surface. Keratinocytes and dermal fibroblasts adhere to the collagen fibril to induce gel contraction by different mechanisms. Fibroblast contraction of collagen gels does not require fibronectin but is a serum-dependent reaction. In contrast, keratinocyte contraction of collagen gels occurs in a serum-free environment. Polyclonal, affinity-purified antibodies to human plasma fibronectin at high concentrations do not inhibit gel contraction by keratinocytes, making unlikely the possibility that fibronectin synthesized by the keratinocyte is a significant factor in the gel contraction process. We are currently examining the possibilities either that keratinocytes are synthesizing other adhesion proteins or that receptors on the cell surface can interact directly with the collagen fiber.     

Fibroblasts retain their tissue phenotype when grown in three-dimensional collagen gels

Fibroblasts are responsible for the synthesis, assembly, deposition, and organization of extracellular matrix molecules, and thus determine the morphology of connective tissues. Deposition of matrix molecules occurs in extracellular compartments, where the sequential stages are under cellular control. Cell orientation/polarity is important in determining how the cell orients these extracytoplasmic compartments and therefore how the matrix is assembled and oriented. However, the control of cell orientation is not understood. Fibroblasts from three tissues with different morphologies were studied to determine whether cells maintained their characteristic phenotype. Fibroblasts from cornea, which in vivo are oriented in orthogonal layers along with their matrix; from tendon, a uniaxial connective tissue, where cells orient parallel to each other; and from dermis, a connective tissue with no apparent cellular orientation, were used to study cell morphology and orientation in three-dimensional collagen gels. The different cells were grown for 3 and 7 days in identical three-dimensional collagen gels with a nonoriented matrix. Confocal fluorescence microscopy demonstrated that corneal fibroblasts oriented perpendicular to one another at 3 days, and after 7 days in hydrated gels these cells formed orthogonal sheets. Tendon fibroblasts were shown by the same methods to orient parallel to one another in bundles at both 3 and 7 days, throughout the depth of the gel. Dermal fibroblasts showed no apparent orientation throughout the hydrated gels at either time point examined. The organization of these different cell types was consistent with their tissue of origin as was the cell structure and polarity. These studies imply that cellular and tissue phenotype is innate to differentiated fibroblasts and that these cells will orient in a tissue-specific manner regardless of the extracellular matrix present.     

The contraction of collagen matrices by dermal fibroblasts

Floating collagen gel cultures containing human foreskin fibroblasts have been observed to undergo a rapid contraction process. The initial rate of contraction (i.e., within the first 2 hr) was observed to be a linear function of cell number within the concentration range of 10(5)-10(6) cells/gel. Observation of thick, deresined sections of such contracting gels in the SEM, as well as observation of thin sections in the TEM, suggest that the fibroblasts exert a tension upon the surrounding collagen fibers. These observations further indicate that the fibroblasts migrate from the interior regions of the gel matrix and eventually form a monolayer of cells encapsulating the contracted collagen disc. These observations are discussed in terms of the possible mechanisms involved in gel contraction.     

Effects of mast cells on the behavior of isolated heart fibroblasts: modulation of collagen remodeling and gene expression

The extracellular matrix plays a critical role in the development and maintenance of the vertebrate heart. Changes in the accumulation, composition, or organization of the extracellular matrix are known to deleteriously affect heart function. Mast cells are thought to stimulate collagen expression and fibroblast proliferation accompanying fibrosis in some organs; however, the effects of mast cells on the heart interstitium are largely unexplored. The present studies were carried out to determine the effects of mast cells on isolated heart fibroblasts. Several in vitro assays were used including collagen gel contraction to examine the effects of mast cells on the function of isolated fibroblasts. Neonatal heart fibroblasts were cultured either with mast cells, mast cell-conditioned medium, or mast cell extracts, and their ability to contract collagen gels measured. Results from these experiments indicated that mast cells inhibit heart fibroblast migration and contraction of 3-dimensional collagen gels. Further experiments indicated that incubation of neonatal heart fibroblasts with extracts of mast cells altered the expression of collagen, matrix metalloproteases, and matrix receptors of the integrin family. These studies suggest that mast cells play an important role in the regulation of the cardiac interstitial matrix. Further studies are warranted to determine the mechanisms whereby mast cells modulate fibroblast activity.     

Double-layered collagen gel hemisphere for cell invasion assay: successful visualization and quantification of cell invasion activity

Although various methods for collagen gel-based cell invasion assays have been described, there continues to be a need for a simpler and more objective assay. Here, we describe an easy-to-prepare double-layered collagen gel hemisphere (DL-CGH) system that satisfies these requirements, and we demonstrate the advantages of this new system for visualizing cell movements during invasion. DL-CGH consists of a central core collagen layer surrounded by an outer cover collagen layer. A droplet of collagen I solution (containing cells to be examined) naturally forms a small hemisphere on the bottom of the culture dish. After this central core layer gels, a second droplet is placed atop the first gel, encapsulating it completely. The hemisphere is submerged in the medium and cultured. The invasive activity of cells that infiltrate from the inner to the outer layer can be evaluated optically. Using this in vitro system, we measured the inhibitory effect of E-cadherin expression on cancer cell invasion. DL-CGH also allowed visualization of interactions between invading cancer cells and the stroma. Cancer cells, which lack the proteases required for direct entrance into the three-dimensional collagen matrix, were seen to slip like amoebas through matrix gaps generated by the pericellular proteolytic activity of fibroblasts. [Supplementary materials are available for this article. Go to the publisher's online edition of Cell Communication and Adhesion for the following free supplemental resources: Movies 1-3; 4a and b].     

Regulation of fibroblast proliferation in three-dimensional collagen gel matrix

Summary Fibroblastsin vivo reside in a three-dimensional (3-D) matrix. The 3-D culture method using collagen gels provides valuable information, but is also has some practical difficulties. In particular, the changes caused by the contraction of gels and the occasional abrupt detachment from the underlying surface have made extended culture difficult. In this study, the 3-D culture method was modified in order to observe the cells with minimal change of substrata for longer periods. The proliferation characteristics of fibroblasts cultured in gels in response to fetal calf serum (FCS), to two defined growth factors, insulin and platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF), and to a growth inhibitory factor, prostaglandin E₂ (PGE₂), were evaluated with this system in comparison with monolayer cultured fibroblasts. The DNA content of fibroblasts cultured both in gels and on dishes increased in response to FCS in a concentration-dependent manner. The proliferation of gel-cultured fibroblasts, however, was lower than that of dish-cultured cells, and higher concentrations of serum were necessary for proliferation. The response of gel-cultured cells to PDGF was also less than that of dish-cultured cells. In addition, fibroblasts cultured in gel culture did not respond to insulin, while the fibroblasts on dishes responded to insulin in a concentration-dependent manner. In contrast to the reduced response to growth stimulators, PGE₂ inhibited proliferation in gel culture and in monolayer culture similarly. The reduced responsiveness to growth stimulation but equivalent response to growth inhibition may account for reduced proliferation of fibroblasts in 3-D culture.     

The effects of a collagenous extracellular matrix on fibroblast membrane organization : An ESR spin label study

Human skin fibroblasts, both in suspension and cultured within a three-dimensional collagen matrix have been examined by electron spin resonance ESR using the probe 5-doxyl stearic acid. The order of the plasma membrane was found to be strongly influenced by the collagen matrix, being greater for cells within the collagen gel than in suspension. The collagen cultures used in this study were either left attached to the walls of the plastic culture dish (‘attached’ gels) or dislodged and allowed to float freely in the culture medium (‘floating’ gels). Membrane order increased with time in attached gels, reaching a steady value after 2–3 h. A further increase in order was observed when floating gels were prepared 24 h later. Cell morphology within the collagen gel culture was observed to vary considerably, with time and mode of culture. Increased order, over that observed in suspension, was also found for cells attached to other substrata. The data indicate that the increase in membrane order observed in cells embedded within a three-dimensional collagen gel matrix compared with cells in suspension does not correlate with a particular cell morphology in the gel, but rather appears to result from the establishment of adhesive interactions with the surrounding collagen fibres.     

Collagen type V enhances matrix contraction by human periodontal ligament fibroblasts seeded in three-dimensional collagen gels

Extracellular matrix components play an important role in modulating cellular activity. To study such capacities of the matrix, fibroblasts are frequently cultured in a three-dimensional gel and contraction is assessed as a measure of cellular activity. Since a connective tissue contains several types of collagen, we investigated the effect of gels composed of collagen I alone or in combination with 10% collagen III and/or 5% collagen V on contraction by human periodontal ligament fibroblasts. Gels containing collagen V contracted much faster than those without this type of collagen. Blocking of the integrin beta1-subunit with an activity-blocking antibody delayed (gels with collagen V) or almost completely blocked (gels without collagen V) contraction. Use of an antibody directed against integrin alpha2beta1 resulted in delay of gel contraction for gels both with and without collagen V. Anti-integrin alpha v beta3 or RGD peptides partially blocked contraction of gels containing collagen V, but had no effect on gels consisting of collagen I alone. The beta1-containing integrins are involved in the basal contraction by fibroblasts that bind to collagens I and III. The enhanced contraction, stimulated by collagen V, appears to be mediated by integrin alpha v beta3. We conclude that collagen V may play an important modulating role in connective tissue contraction. Such a modulation may occur during the initial stages of wound healing and/or tissue regeneration.     

Cultured epidermis influences the fibril organization of purified type I collagen gels

Purified type I collagen gel used as culture substrate was composed of unstriated fibrils. Before culture, gel fragments were coated with culture medium with or without fetal calf serum (FCS+ coated or FCS- coated gels). Each gel fragment was apposed to a fragment of frog skin at the medium/air interface in Trowell culture chamber. After 7 days at 20 degrees C, the coated gels were covered with newly formed epidermis containing fibronectin localized around the keratinocytes, whose morphology was considerably modified. Fibroblast-shaped keratinocytes were localized in the anterior zone of the newly formed epidermis on FCS+ gels. The long axis of the cells was parallel to the gel surface, where numerous unstriated fibrils were located. Polyhedral keratinocytes were located in the posterior zone on FCS+ gels or the anterior and posterior zones on FCS- gels with the long axis perpendicular to the gel surface. Numerous cross-striated fibrils were found under the cultured keratinocytes in the vicinity of the basal filipodia. This model is useful for the study of collagen gel reorganization by keratinocytes.     

Lymphocyte migration into three-dimensional collagen matrices: a quantitative study

Lymphocytes have been plated onto the surface of three-dimensional gels of native collagen fibers, and their distribution throughout the three- dimensional collagen matrix has been determined in a quantitative fashion at various times thereafter. Information regarding the total number of applied cells may be obtained by this means. Lymphocyte penetration into the collagen gel does not appear to involve the expression of collagenolytic activity, nor does it require the presence of serum. Analysis of the kinetics of lymphocyte penetration into the gel matrix indicates that lymphocytes are migrating in a "random-walk" fashion. Our objective has been to establish a model system for studying the cell-matrix and cell-cell interactions which influence the pattern of lymphocyte recirculation in vivo and the results presented here are discussed in this context.     

The collagen recognition sequence for fibroblasts depends on collagen topography

We found that the peptide Gly-Arg-Gly-Glu-Ser-Pro (GRGESP) inhibited spreading of human fibroblasts inside collagen gels and markedly decreased gel contraction, but this peptide had no effect on cell spreading on collagen-coated surfaces. On the other hand, the peptide Gly-Arg-Gly-Asp-Ser-Pro (GRGDSP), which inhibited cell spreading on collagen-coated surfaces, did not inhibit cell spreading within collagen gels and was a less effective inhibitor of collagen gel contraction than GRGESP. Based on these findings, we conclude that human fibroblasts can interact with different collagen cell recognition sequences depending upon topographical organization of the collagen.     

Beta 1 integrin-mediated collagen gel contraction is stimulated by PDGF

The attachment of primary rat hepatocytes and fibroblasts to collagen type I is mediated by non-RGD-dependent beta 1 integrin matrix receptors. In this report we describe a novel 96-well microtiter plate assay for the quantification of fibroblast-mediated contraction of floating collagen type I gels. Fetal calf serum and platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF), but not transforming growth factor-beta 1, stimulated primary rat heart fibroblasts and normal human diploid fibroblasts (AG 1518) to contract collagen gels to less than 10% of the initial gel volume within a 24-h incubation period. Rabbit polyclonal antibodies directed to the rat hepatocyte integrin beta 1-chain inhibited the PDGF-stimulated collagen gel contraction. The inhibitory activity on contraction of the anti-beta 1 integrin IgG could be overcome by adding higher doses of PDGF. The contraction process was not blocked by anti-fibronectin IgG nor by synthetic peptides containing the tripeptide Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD), in concentrations that readily blocked fibroblast attachment to fibronectin-coated planar substrates. Autologous fibronectin or control peptides containing the tripeptide Arg-Gly-Glu were without effect. Immunofluorescence microscopy on fibroblasts grown within collagen gels revealed a punctate distribution of the beta 1 integrin and a lack of detectable levels of endogenously produced fibronectin. Collectively these data suggest a role for integrin collagen receptors with affinity for collagen fibers, distinct from the previously described RGD-dependent fibronectin receptors, in the fibronectin-independent PDGF-stimulated collagen gel contraction process.     

Neurite growth in 3D collagen gels with gradients of mechanical properties

We have designed and developed a microfluidic system to study the response of cells to controlled gradients of mechanical stiffness in 3D collagen gels. An 'H'-shaped, source-sink network was filled with a type I collagen solution, which self-assembled into a fibrillar gel. A 1D gradient of genipin--a natural crosslinker that also causes collagen to fluoresce upon crosslinking--was generated in the cross-channel through the 3D collagen gel to create a gradient of crosslinks and stiffness. The gradient of stiffness was observed via fluorescence. A separate, underlying channel in the microfluidic construct allowed the introduction of cells into the gradient. Neurites from chick dorsal root ganglia explants grew significantly longer down the gradient of stiffness than up the gradient and than in control gels not treated with genipin. No changes in cell adhesion, collagen fiber size, or density were observed following crosslinking with genipin, indicating that the primary effect of genipin was on the mechanical properties of the gel. These results demonstrate that (1) the microfluidic system can be used to study durotactic behavior of cells and (2) neurite growth can be directed and enhanced by a gradient of mechanical properties, with the goal of incorporating mechanical gradients into nerve and spinal cord regenerative therapies.     

Molecular mobility of soluble collagen

Conformation structure of soluble collagen in anhydrous form, films and gels was studied by broad line NMR. An analysis of spectra points to partial ordering of polymer chains in the films and possible formation of secondary structure of collagen molecules by alpha-helix type. Distinction of gel spectra from those of films is explained by unordered rotation movements of the chain fragments at the expense of "superspiralization" of collagen molecules.     

Connective tissue morphogenesis by fibroblast traction : I. Tissue culture observations

We find that the force fibroblasts use to propel themselves (traction) is sufficiently strong to distort collagen gels and to form patterns of tension, compression, and alignment similar to the wrinkling patterns previously observed on silicone rubber. Experiments with hygroscopic salts and with rapidly growing (but weakly contractile) transformed fibroblasts indicate that these distortions of collagen do not result from dehydration or other chemical consequences of cell metabolism but are direct effects of cell contractility. Between explants of fibroblasts the centripetal traction aligns collagen fibers into linear tracts as much as 4 cm long. Immediately adjacent to explants the effect of traction is to compress the collagen fibers into a dense, capsule-like circumferential wrapping. Aligned tracts are also formed when populations of fibroblasts are dispersed in the collagen matrix and its contraction is then resisted by fixed points. When developing limb cartilages are explanted into collagen gels, points on the cartilage surface become cross-connected with tracts of aligned collagen. When muscle cells are co-cultured with cartilage the traction draws them into the aligned tracts to form facsimiles of actual muscles. We propose that this tractional structuring is the mechanism by which ligaments, tendons, and muscles become organized during development.