Structural basis of double-stranded RNA recognition by the RIG-I like receptor MDA5

RIG-I, MDA5 and LGP2 are cytosolic pattern recognition receptors detecting single-stranded or double-stranded RNA in virally infected cells. The activation of RIG-I or MDA5 stimulates the secretion of type I interferons that play key roles in antiviral immune responses. The C-terminal domains (CTD) of RIG-I and LGP2 are responsible for RNA binding; however, it is not clear how MDA5 binds RNA. To understand the structural basis of dsRNA recognition by MDA5, we have determined the 1.45 Å resolution structure of the C-terminal domain of human MDA5. The structure revealed a highly conserved fold similar to the structures of RIG-I and LGP2 CTDs. NMR titration of MDA5 CTD with dsRNA demonstrated that a positively charged surface is involved in dsRNA binding. Mutagenesis and RNA binding studies showed that electrostatic interactions play primary roles in dsRNA recognition by MDA5. Like RIG-I and LGP2, MDA5 CTD preferentially binds dsRNA with blunt ends, but does not associate with dsRNA with either 5′ or 3′ overhangs. Molecular modeling of MDA5 CTD/dsRNA complex suggests that MDA5 CTD may recognize the first turn of blunt-ended dsRNA in a similar manner as LGP2.     

Solution Structures of Cytosolic RNA Sensor MDA5 and LGP2 C-terminal Domains: IDENTIFICATION OF THE RNA RECOGNITION LOOP IN RIG-I-LIKE RECEPTORS*

The RIG-I like receptor (RLR) comprises three homologues: RIG-I (retinoic acid-inducible gene I), MDA5 (melanoma differentiation-associated gene 5), and LGP2 (laboratory of genetics and physiology 2). Each RLR senses different viral infections by recognizing replicating viral RNA in the cytoplasm. The RLR contains a conserved C-terminal domain (CTD), which is responsible for the binding specificity to the viral RNAs, including double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) and 5′-triphosphated single-stranded RNA (5′ppp-ssRNA). Here, the solution structures of the MDA5 and LGP2 CTD domains were solved by NMR and compared with those of RIG-I CTD. The CTD domains each have a similar fold and a similar basic surface but there is the distinct structural feature of a RNA binding loop; The LGP2 and RIG-I CTD domains have a large basic surface, one bank of which is formed by the RNA binding loop. MDA5 also has a large basic surface that is extensively flat due to open conformation of the RNA binding loop. The NMR chemical shift perturbation study showed that dsRNA and 5′ppp-ssRNA are bound to the basic surface of LGP2 CTD, whereas dsRNA is bound to the basic surface of MDA5 CTD but much more weakly, indicating that the conformation of the RNA binding loop is responsible for the sensitivity to dsRNA and 5′ppp-ssRNA. Mutation study of the basic surface and the RNA binding loop supports the conclusion from the structure studies. Thus, the CTD is responsible for the binding affinity to the viral RNAs.     

Nonself RNA-sensing mechanism of RIG-I helicase and activation of antiviral immune responses

A DExD/H protein, RIG-I, is critical in innate antiviral responses by sensing viral RNA. Here we show that RIG-I recognizes two distinct viral RNA patterns: double-stranded (ds) and 5'ppp single-stranded (ss) RNA. The binding of RIG-I with dsRNA or 5'ppp ssRNA in the presence of ATP produces a common structure, as suggested by protease digestion. Further analyses demonstrated that the C-terminal domain of RIG-I (CTD) recognizes these RNA patterns and CTD coincides with the autorepression domain. Structural analysis of CTD by NMR spectroscopy in conjunction with mutagenesis revealed that the basic surface of CTD with a characteristic cleft interacts with RIG-I ligands. Our results suggest that the bipartite structure of CTD regulates RIG-I on encountering viral RNA patterns.     

Crystal structure of RIG-I C-terminal domain bound to blunt-ended double-strand RNA without 5' triphosphate

RIG-I recognizes molecular patterns in viral RNA to regulate the induction of type I interferons. The C-terminal domain (CTD) of RIG-I exhibits high affinity for 5' triphosphate (ppp) dsRNA as well as blunt-ended dsRNA. Structures of RIG-I CTD bound to 5'-ppp dsRNA showed that RIG-I recognizes the termini of dsRNA and interacts with the ppp through electrostatic interactions. However, the structural basis for the recognition of non-phosphorylated dsRNA by RIG-I is not fully understood. Here, we show that RIG-I CTD binds blunt-ended dsRNA in a different orientation compared to 5' ppp dsRNA and interacts with both strands of the dsRNA. Overlapping sets of residues are involved in the recognition of blunt-ended dsRNA and 5' ppp dsRNA. Mutations at the RNA-binding surface affect RNA binding and signaling by RIG-I. These results provide the mechanistic basis for how RIG-I recognizes different RNA ligands.     

Structural features of influenza A virus panhandle RNA enabling the activation of RIG-I independently of 5′-triphosphate

Retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG-I) recognizes specific molecular patterns of viral RNAs for inducing type I interferon. The C-terminal domain (CTD) of RIG-I binds to double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) with the 5′-triphosphate (5′-PPP), which induces a conformational change in RIG-I to an active form. It has been suggested that RIG-I detects infection of influenza A virus by recognizing the 5′-triphosphorylated panhandle structure of the viral RNA genome. Influenza panhandle RNA has a unique structure with a sharp helical bending. In spite of extensive studies of how viral RNAs activate RIG-I, whether the structural elements of the influenza panhandle RNA confer the ability to activate RIG-I signaling has been poorly explored. Here, we investigated the dynamics of the influenza panhandle RNA in complex with RIG-I CTD using NMR spectroscopy and showed that the bending structure of the panhandle RNA negates the requirement of a 5′-PPP moiety for RIG-I activation.     

Structural basis for the activation of innate immune pattern-recognition receptor RIG-I by viral RNA

RIG-I is a key innate immune pattern-recognition receptor that triggers interferon expression upon detection of intracellular 5'triphosphate double-stranded RNA (5'ppp-dsRNA) of viral origin. RIG-I comprises N-terminal caspase activation and recruitment domains (CARDs), a DECH helicase, and a C-terminal domain (CTD). We present crystal structures of the ligand-free, autorepressed, and RNA-bound, activated states of RIG-I. Inactive RIG-I has an open conformation with the CARDs sequestered by a helical domain inserted between the two helicase moieties. ATP and dsRNA binding induce a major rearrangement to a closed conformation in which the helicase and CTD bind the blunt end 5'ppp-dsRNA with perfect complementarity but incompatibly with continued CARD binding. We propose that after initial binding of 5'ppp-dsRNA to the flexibly linked CTD, co-operative tight binding of ATP and RNA to the helicase domain liberates the CARDs for downstream signaling. These findings significantly advance our molecular understanding of the activation of innate immune signaling helicases.     

Identification of Loss of Function Mutations in Human Genes Encoding RIG-I and MDA5: IMPLICATIONS FOR RESISTANCE TO TYPE I DIABETES*

Retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG-I) and melanoma differentiation-associated gene 5 (MDA5) are essential for detecting viral RNA and triggering antiviral responses, including production of type I interferon. We analyzed the phenotype of non-synonymous mutants of human RIG-I and MDA5 reported in databases by functional complementation in cell cultures. Of seven missense mutations of RIG-I, S183I, which occurs within the second caspase recruitment domain repeat, inactivated this domain and conferred a dominant inhibitory function. Of 10 mutants of MDA5, two exhibited loss of function. A nonsense mutation, E627*, resulted in deletion of the C-terminal region and double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) binding activity. Another loss of function mutation, I923V, which occurs within the C-terminal domain, did not affect dsRNA binding activity, suggesting a novel and essential role for this residue in the signaling. Remarkably, these mutations are implicated in resistance to type I diabetes. However, the A946T mutation of MDA5, which has been implicated in type I diabetes by previous genetic analyses, affected neither dsRNA binding nor IFN gene activation. These results provide new insights into the structure-function relationship of RIG-I-like receptors as well as into human RIG-I-like receptor polymorphisms, antiviral innate immunity, and autoimmune diseases.Innate and adaptive immune systems constitute the defense against infections by pathogens. Immediately after an infection occurs, various cells in the body sense the virus and initiate antiviral responses in which type I IFN² plays a critical role, both in viral inhibition and in the subsequent adaptive immune response (1). The production of IFN is initiated when sensor molecules such as Toll-like receptors (TLRs) and RLRs detect virus-associated molecules. TLRs detect pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) at the cell surface or in the endosome in immune cells such as dendritic cells and macrophages (2). RLRs sense viral RNA in the cytoplasm of most cell types and induce antiviral responses, including the activation of IFN genes (3). RLRs include RIG-I, MDA5, and laboratory of genetics and physiology 2 (LGP2).It is proposed that RLRs sense and activate antiviral signals through the coordination of their functional domains (4). The N-terminal region of RIG-I and MDA5 is characterized by two repeats of CARD and functions as an activation domain (3). This domain is responsible for the transduction of signals downstream to IFN-β promoter stimulator 1 (IPS-1) (also known as MAVS, VISA, and Cardif). The primary sequence of the CTD, consisting of ∼140 amino acids, is conserved among RLRs. The CTD of RIG-I functions as a viral RNA-sensing domain as revealed by biochemical and structural analyses (5, 6). Both dsRNA and 5′-ppp-ssRNA, which are generated in the cytoplasm of virus-infected cells, are recognized by a basic cleft structure of RIG-I CTD. In addition to its RNA recognition function, the CTD of RIG-I and LGP2 functions as a repression domain through interaction with the activation domain. The repression domain is responsible for keeping RIG-I inactive in non-stimulated cells (3, 7). The helicase domain, with DEXD/H box-containing RNA helicase motifs, is the largest domain found in RLRs. Once dsRNA or 5′-ppp-ssRNA is recognized by the CTD, the helicase domain causes structural changes to release the activation domain. ATP binding and/or its hydrolysis is essential for the conformational change because Walker''s ATP-binding site within the helicase domain is essential for signaling by RIG-I and MDA5.Analyses of knock-out mice have revealed that RIG-I and MDA5 recognize distinct RNA viruses (8, 9). Picornaviruses are detected by MDA5, but many other viruses such as influenza A, Sendai, vesicular stomatitis, and Japanese encephalitis are detected by RIG-I. The difference is based on the distinct non-self RNA patterns generated by viruses, as demonstrated by the finding that RIG-I is selectively activated by dsRNA or 5′-ppp ssRNA, whereas MDA5 is activated by long dsRNA (10–12).Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) of the human RIG-I and MDA5 genes including several non-synonymous SNPs (nsSNPs), which potentially alter the function of the proteins encoded, are reported in databases. In this report, we investigated the functions of nsSNPs of RIG-I and MDA5 by functional complementation using respective knock-out cells. We identified loss of function mutations of RIG-I and MDA5. Notably, two MDA5 mutations, E627* and I923V, recently reported to have a strong association with resistance to T1D (13), were severely inactive. The results suggest a novel molecular mechanism for the activation of RLRs and will contribute to our understanding of the functional effects of RLR polymorphisms and the critical relationship between RLR nsSNPs and diseases.     

The RIG-I-like Receptor LGP2 Recognizes the Termini of Double-stranded RNA

The RIG-I-like receptors (RLRs), RIG-I and MDA5, recognize single-stranded RNA with 5′ triphosphates and double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) to initiate innate antiviral immune responses. LGP2, a homolog of RIG-I and MDA5 that lacks signaling capability, regulates the signaling of the RLRs. To establish the structural basis of dsRNA recognition by the RLRs, we have determined the 2.0-Å resolution crystal structure of human LGP2 C-terminal domain bound to an 8-bp dsRNA. Two LGP2 C-terminal domain molecules bind to the termini of dsRNA with minimal contacts between the protein molecules. Gel filtration chromatography and analytical ultracentrifugation demonstrated that LGP2 binds blunt-ended dsRNA of different lengths, forming complexes with 2:1 stoichiometry. dsRNA with protruding termini bind LGP2 and RIG-I weakly and do not stimulate the activation of RIG-I efficiently in cells. Surprisingly, full-length LGP2 containing mutations that abolish dsRNA binding retained the ability to inhibit RIG-I signaling.The innate immune response is the first line of defense against invading pathogens; it is the ubiquitous system of defense against microbial infections (1). Toll-like receptors (TLRs)³ and RIG-I (retinoic acid-inducible gene 1)-like receptors (RLRs) play key roles in innate immune response toward viral infection (2-5). Toll-like receptors TLR3, TLR7, and TLR8 sense viral RNA released in the endosome following phagocytosis of the pathogens (6). RIG-I-like receptors RIG-I and MDA5 detect viral RNA from replicating viruses in infected cells (3, 7, 8). Stimulation of these receptors leads to the induction of type I interferons (IFNs) and other proinflammatory cytokines, conferring antiviral activity to the host cells and activating the acquired immune responses (4, 9).RIG-I discriminates between viral and host RNA through specific recognition of the uncapped 5′-triphosphate of single-stranded RNA (5′ ppp ssRNA) generated by viral RNA polymerases (10, 11). In addition, RIG-I also recognizes double-stranded RNA generated during RNA virus replication (7, 12). Transfection of cells with synthetic double-stranded RNA stimulates the activation of RIG-I (13, 14). Synthetic dsRNA mimics, such as polyinosinic-polycytidylic acid (poly(I·C)), can activate MDA5 when introduced into the cytoplasm of cells. Digestion of poly(I·C) with RNase III transforms poly(I·C) from a ligand for MDA5 into a ligand for RIG-I, suggesting that MDA5 recognizes long dsRNA, whereas RIG-I recognizes short dsRNA (15). Studies of RIG-I and MDA5 knock-out mice confirmed the essential roles of these receptors in antiviral immune responses and demonstrated that they sense different sets of RNA viruses (12, 16).RIG-I and MDA5 contain two caspase recruiting domains (CARDs) at their N termini, a DEX(D/H) box RNA helicase domain, and a C-terminal regulatory or repressor domain (CTD). The helicase domain and the CTD are responsible for viral RNA binding, whereas the CARDs are required for signaling (3, 8). The current model of RIG-I activation suggests that under resting conditions RIG-I is in a suppressed conformation, and viral RNA binding triggers a conformation change that leads to the exposure of the CARDs for the recruitment of the downstream protein IPS-1 (also known as MAVS, Cardif, or VISA) (14, 17). Limited proteolysis of the RIG-I·dsRNA complex showed that RIG-I residues 792-925 of the CTD are involved in dsRNA and 5′ ppp ssRNA binding (14). The CTD of RIG-I overlaps with the C terminus of the previously identified repressor domain (18). The structures of RIG-I and LGP2 (laboratory of genetics and physiology 2) CTD in isolation have been determined by x-ray crystallography and NMR spectroscopy (14, 19, 20). A large, positively charged surface on RIG-I recognizes the 5′ triphosphate group of viral ssRNA (14, 19). RNA binding studies by titrating RIG-I CTD with dsRNA and 5′ ppp ssRNA suggested that overlapping sets of residues on this charged surface are involved in RNA binding (14). Mutagenesis of several positively charged residues on this surface either reduces or disrupts RNA binding by RIG-I, and these mutations also affect the induction of IFN-β in vivo (14, 19). However, the exact nature of how the RLRs recognize viral RNA and how RNA binding activates these receptors remains to be established.LGP2 is a homolog of RIG-I and MDA5 that lacks the CARDs and thus has no signaling capability (21, 22). The expression of LGP2 is inducible by dsRNA or IFN treatment as well as virus infection (21). Overexpression of LGP2 inhibits Sendai virus and Newcastle disease virus signaling (21). When coexpressed with RIG-I, LGP2 can inhibit RIG-I signaling through the interaction of its CTD with the CARD and the helicase domain of RIG-I (18). LGP2 could suppress RIG-I signaling by three possible ways (23): 1) binding RNA with high affinity, thereby sequestering RNA ligands from RIG-I; 2) interacting directly with RIG-I to block the assembly of the signaling complex; and 3) competing with IKKi (IκB kinase ε) in the NF-κB signaling pathway for a common binding site on IPS-1. To elucidate the structural basis of dsRNA recognition by the RLRs, we have crystallized human LGP2 CTD (residues 541-678) bound to an 8-bp double-stranded RNA and determined the structure of the complex at 2.0 Å resolution. The structure revealed that LGP2 CTD binds to the termini of dsRNA. Mutagenesis and functional studies showed that dsRNA binding is likely not required for the inhibition of RIG-I signaling by LGP2.     

Conformational rearrangements of RIG-I receptor on formation of a multiprotein:dsRNA assembly

The retinoic acid inducible gene-I (RIG-I)-like family of receptors is positioned at the front line of our innate cellular defence system. RIG-I detects and binds to foreign duplex RNA in the cytoplasm of both immune and non-immune cells, and initiates the induction of type I interferons and pro-inflammatory cytokines. The mechanism of RIG-I activation by double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) involves a molecular rearrangement proposed to expose the N-terminal pair of caspase activation recruitment domains, enabling an interaction with interferon-beta promoter stimulator 1 (IPS-1) and thereby initiating downstream signalling. dsRNA is particularly stimulatory when longer than 20 bp, potentially through allowing binding of more than one RIG-I molecule. Here, we characterize full-length RIG-I and RIG-I subdomains combined with a stimulatory 29mer dsRNA using multi-angle light scattering and size-exclusion chromatography–coupled small-angle X-ray scattering, to build up a molecular model of RIG-I before and after the formation of a 2:1 protein:dsRNA assembly. We report the small-angle X-ray scattering–derived solution structure of the human apo-RIG-I and observe that on binding of RIG-I to dsRNA in a 2:1 ratio, the complex becomes highly extended and flexible. Hence, here we present the first model of the fully activated oligomeric RIG-I.     

Structural and functional analysis reveals that human OASL binds dsRNA to enhance RIG-I signaling

The oligoadenylate synthetase (OAS) enzymes are cytoplasmic dsRNA sensors belonging to the antiviral innate immune system. Upon binding to viral dsRNA, the OAS enzymes synthesize 2′-5′ linked oligoadenylates (2-5As) that initiate an RNA decay pathway to impair viral replication. The human OAS-like (OASL) protein, however, does not harbor the catalytic activity required for synthesizing 2-5As and differs from the other human OAS family members by having two C-terminal ubiquitin-like domains. In spite of its lack of enzymatic activity, human OASL possesses antiviral activity. It was recently demonstrated that the ubiquitin-like domains of OASL could substitute for K63-linked poly-ubiquitin and interact with the CARDs of RIG-I and thereby enhance RIG-I signaling. However, the role of the OAS-like domain of OASL remains unclear. Here we present the crystal structure of the OAS-like domain, which shows a striking similarity with activated OAS1. Furthermore, the structure of the OAS-like domain shows that OASL has a dsRNA binding groove. We demonstrate that the OAS-like domain can bind dsRNA and that mutating key residues in the dsRNA binding site is detrimental to the RIG-I signaling enhancement. Hence, binding to dsRNA is an important feature of OASL that is required for enhancing RIG-I signaling.     

Structural and biochemical studies of RIG-I antiviral signaling

Retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG-I) is an important pattern recognition receptor that detects viral RNA and triggers the production of type-I interferons through the downstream adaptor MAVS (also called IPS-1, CARDIF, or VISA). A series of structural studies have elaborated some of the mechanisms of dsRNA recognition and activation of RIG-I. Recent studies have proposed that K63-linked ubiquitination of, or unanchored K63-linked polyubiquitin binding to RIG-I positively regulates MAVS-mediated antiviral signaling. Conversely phosphorylation of RIG-I appears to play an inhibitory role in controlling RIG-I antiviral signal transduction. Here we performed a combined structural and biochemical study to further define the regulatory features of RIG-I signaling. ATP and dsRNA binding triggered dimerization of RIG-I with conformational rearrangements of the tandem CARD domains. Full length RIG-I appeared to form a complex with dsRNA in a 2:2 molar ratio. Compared with the previously reported crystal structures of RIG-I in inactive state, our electron microscopic structure of full length RIG-I in complex with blunt-ended dsRNA, for the first time, revealed an exposed active conformation of the CARD domains. Moreover, we found that purified recombinant RIG-I proteins could bind to the CARD domain of MAVS independently of dsRNA, while S8E and T170E phosphorylation-mimicking mutants of RIG-I were defective in binding E3 ligase TRIM25, unanchored K63-linked polyubiquitin, and MAVS regardless of dsRNA. These findings suggested that phosphorylation of RIG inhibited downstream signaling by impairing RIG-I binding with polyubiquitin and its interaction with MAVS.     

The RIG-I ATPase domain structure reveals insights into ATP-dependent antiviral signalling

RIG-I detects cytosolic viral dsRNA with 5' triphosphates (5'-ppp-dsRNA), thereby initiating an antiviral innate immune response. Here we report the crystal structure of superfamily 2 (SF2) ATPase domain of RIG-I in complex with a nucleotide analogue. RIG-I SF2 comprises two RecA-like domains 1A and 2A and a helical insertion domain 2B, which together form a 'C'-shaped structure. Domains 1A and 2A are maintained in a 'signal-off' state with an inactive ATP hydrolysis site by an intriguing helical arm. By mutational analysis, we show surface motifs that are critical for dsRNA-stimulated ATPase activity, indicating that dsRNA induces a structural movement that brings domains 1A and 2A/B together to form an active ATPase site. The structure also indicates that the regulatory domain is close to the end of the helical arm, where it is well positioned to recruit 5'-ppp-dsRNA to the SF2 domain. Overall, our results indicate that the activation of RIG-I occurs through an RNA- and ATP-driven structural switch in the SF2 domain.     

Mechanism of mda-5 Inhibition by Paramyxovirus V Proteins

The RNA helicases encoded by melanoma differentiation-associated gene 5 (mda-5) and retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG-I) detect foreign cytoplasmic RNA molecules generated during the course of a virus infection, and their activation leads to induction of type I interferon synthesis. Paramyxoviruses limit the amount of interferon produced by infected cells through the action of their V protein, which binds to and inhibits mda-5. Here we show that activation of both mda-5 and RIG-I by double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) leads to the formation of homo-oligomers through self-association of the helicase domains. We identify a region within the helicase domain of mda-5 that is targeted by all paramyxovirus V proteins and demonstrate that they inhibit activation of mda-5 by blocking dsRNA binding and consequent self-association. In addition to this commonly targeted domain, some paramyxovirus V proteins target additional regions of mda-5. In contrast, V proteins cannot bind to RIG-I and consequently have no effect on the ability of RIG-I to bind dsRNA or to form oligomers.     

The Thermodynamic Basis for Viral RNA Detection by the RIG-I Innate Immune Sensor

RIG-I is a cytoplasmic surveillance protein that contributes to the earliest stages of the vertebrate innate immune response. The protein specifically recognizes 5′-triphosphorylated RNA structures that are released into the cell by viruses, such as influenza and hepatitis C. To understand the energetic basis for viral RNA recognition by RIG-I, we studied the binding of RIG-I domain variants to a family of dsRNA ligands. Thermodynamic analysis revealed that the isolated RIG-I domains each make important contributions to affinity and that they interact using different strategies. Covalent linkage between the domains enhances RNA ligand specificity while reducing overall binding affinity, thereby providing a mechanism for discriminating virus from host RNA.     

Structure and function of LGP2, a DEX(D/H) helicase that regulates the innate immunity response

RNA recognition receptors are important for detection of and response to viral infections. RIG-I and MDA5 are cytoplasmic DEX(D/H) helicase proteins that can induce signaling in response to RNA ligands, including those from viral infections. LGP2, a homolog of RIG-I and MDA5 without the caspase recruitment domain required for signaling, plays an important role in modulating signaling by MDA5 and RIG-I, presumably through heterocomplex formation and/or by serving as a sink for RNAs. Here we demonstrate that LGP2 can be coexpressed with RIG-I to inhibit activation of the NF-kappaB reporter expression and that LGP2 protein produced in insect cells can bind both single- and double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), with higher affinity and cooperativity for dsRNA. Electron microscopy and image reconstruction were used to determine the shape of the LGP2 monomer in the absence of dsRNA and of the dimer complexed to a 27-bp dsRNA. LGP2 has striking structural similarity to the helicase domain of the superfamily 2 DNA helicase, Hef.     

The RIG-I ATPase core has evolved a functional requirement for allosteric stabilization by the Pincer domain

Retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG-I) is a pattern recognition receptor expressed in metazoan cells that is responsible for eliciting the production of type I interferons and pro-inflammatory cytokines upon detection of intracellular, non-self RNA. Structural studies of RIG-I have identified a novel Pincer domain composed of two alpha helices that physically tethers the C-terminal domain to the SF2 helicase core. We find that the Pincer plays an important role in mediating the enzymatic and signaling activities of RIG-I. We identify a series of mutations that additively decouple the Pincer motif from the ATPase core and show that this decoupling results in impaired signaling. Through enzymological and biophysical analysis, we further show that the Pincer domain controls coupled enzymatic activity of the protein through allosteric control of the ATPase core. Further, we show that select regions of the HEL1 domain have evolved to potentiate interactions with the Pincer domain, resulting in an adapted ATPase cleft that is now responsive to adjacent domains that selectively bind viral RNA.     

Rsp5 WW domains interact directly with the carboxyl-terminal domain of RNA polymerase II

RSP5 is an essential gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and was recently shown to form a physical and functional complex with RNA polymerase II (RNA pol II). The amino-terminal half of Rsp5 consists of four domains: a C2 domain, which binds membrane phospholipids; and three WW domains, which are protein interaction modules that bind proline-rich ligands. The carboxyl-terminal half of Rsp5 contains a HECT (homologous to E6-AP carboxyl terminus) domain that catalytically ligates ubiquitin to proteins and functionally classifies Rsp5 as an E3 ubiquitin-protein ligase. The C2 and WW domains are presumed to act as membrane localization and substrate recognition modules, respectively. We report that the second (and possibly third) Rsp5 WW domain mediates binding to the carboxyl-terminal domain (CTD) of the RNA pol II large subunit. The CTD comprises a heptamer (YSPTSPS) repeated 26 times and a PXY core that is critical for interaction with a specific group of WW domains. An analysis of synthetic peptides revealed a minimal CTD sequence that is sufficient to bind to the second Rsp5 WW domain (Rsp5 WW2) in vitro and in yeast two-hybrid assays. Furthermore, we found that specific "imperfect" CTD repeats can form a complex with Rsp5 WW2. In addition, we have shown that phosphorylation of this minimal CTD sequence on serine, threonine and tyrosine residues acts as a negative regulator of the Rsp5 WW2-CTD interaction. In view of the recent data pertaining to phosphorylation-driven interactions between the RNA pol II CTD and the WW domain of Ess1/Pin1, we suggest that CTD dephosphorylation may be a prerequisite for targeted RNA pol II degradation.     

The lock-washer: a reconciliation of the RIG-I activation models

RIG-I belongs to a type of intracellular pattern recognition receptors involved in the recognition of viral RNA by the innate immune system. A report by Peisley et al. published in Nature provides the crystal structure of human RIG-I revealing a tetrameric architecture of the RIG-I 2-CARD domain bound by three K63-linked ubiquitin chains, uncovering its activation mechanism for downstream signaling.The recognition of microbial-derived nucleic acids and the correct and specific activation of the molecular machinery governing the mammalian immune response are paramount to host survival during viral infection. Viral RNA represents a key trigger for the activation and mobilization of a series of pattern recognition receptors (PRRs) such as the Toll-like receptor (TLR) and retinoic acid-inducible gene 1 (RIG-I)-like receptor (RLR) families. While the TLRs are restricted to the cell surface or inside endosomal compartments, the RLRs are present in the cytosol and act as the key sentinels of actively invading and replicating viruses.The RLR family of receptors, RIG-I and Melanoma Differentiation-Associated protein 5 (MDA-5), are characterised by 3 distinct signaling domains critical for viral RNA recognition and response. The C-terminal repressor domain and the internal ATPase-containing DExD/H-box helicase domain of RIG-I function together to facilitate binding of viral dsRNA which contain either a 5′-ppp motif or 5′ blunt-end base-paired RNA with a triphosphate motif, moieties absent on self-nucleic acids¹. Upon viral RNA ligation, two N-terminal caspase activation and recruitment domains (CARD), known as 2-CARD, on RIG-I propagate signal transduction via interactions with mitochondrial antiviral signaling protein (MAVS)². Recent molecular and structural studies have elucidated the mechanisms by which RLR-activated MAVS mediates the antiviral response. During RIG-I signaling, MAVS forms large multimeric prion-like filaments on the mitochondrial membrane which are essential for RIG-I-mediated type I interferon (IFN) production³. Such functional aggregates are capable of recruiting key downstream signaling components such as members of TNF receptor associated factors (TRAF) family, resulting in the activation of the MAPKs, the NF-κB pathway and interferon regulatory factor 3/7 (IRF3/7) and consequently culminating in the upregulation of protective IFNs and pro-inflammatory cytokines. Viral infection is sufficient to convert nearly all endogenous detectable MAVS to functionally active aggregates, and interestingly this phenomenon can be recapitulated in vitro using only mitochondria, RIG-I and K63-linked ubiquitin chains, underscoring the functional importance of polyubiquitination events during RIG-I signaling⁴.In contrast to the well-documented and -accepted paradigm of MAVS activation, the model of RIG-I-mediated activation has remained incompletely understood. The classical model holds that RIG-I remains in an auto-repressed state in the absence of ligand. Upon viral recognition, the E3 ubiquitin ligase tripartite motif 25 (TRIM25) binds to the 2-CARD domain of RIG-I, resulting in the covalent conjugation of K63-linked polyubiquitin chains to induce a conformation change in the receptor and facilitate a “release” of the 2-CARD domain for MAVS interaction and activation⁵. However, this simple release model of the 2-CARD domain does not reconcile with recent compelling reports that RIG-I can act as a receptor for unanchored, non-covalently attached ubiquitin chains and that polyubiquitination of RIG-I induces the oligomerization of a heterotetrameric complex consisting of 4 RIG-I and 4 K63-ubiqutin chain molecules^6,7. In addition, although K63-ubiquitination is essential for the signaling potential of isolated 2-CARD molecules, full-length RIG-I can form filaments around the ends of dsRNA molecules, allowing 2-CARD regions of RIG-I molecules to come into close proximity to each other and facilitate MAVS aggregation in an ubiquitin-independent manner⁸.Although such conflicting reports seem to propose vastly different models of RIG-I activation, an elegent study published in Nature by Peisley et al.⁹ uses biochemical and structural studies to reconcile the different models and they finally offer a unified understanding of RIG-I receptor activation. They resolved the crystal structure of human RIG-I 2-CARD in complex with K63-ubiquitin at 3.7 Å. The structure revealed the tetrameric architecture of RIG-I 2-CARD bound by three K63 ubiquitin chains (Figure 1). Crystallization and structure determination reveal that four 2-CARD subunits form a tetrameric helical assembly, termed the “lock washer”, with the two ends displaced by half the thickness of 2-CARD.Open in a separate windowFigure 1A model of RIG-I-mediated antiviral response.Two key questions arise from the RIG-I 2-CARD structure. First, how does the tetrameric architecture of RIG-I serve as a platform to activate downstream signaling? The CARD domain belongs to the death domain (DD) superfamily, members of which have a similar three-dimensional fold. The structures of other DD oligomers such as Myddosome, PIDDosome, or FAS-FADD complex have recently been resolved. The assembly of DD oligomers is usually mediated at six surface areas, with the helical oligomeric structure of upstream signaling molecules serving as a scaffold to assemble the downstream DD oligomers through helical extension. In the current study, the authors show that the assembly and stability of the tetramer and its IFN-β signaling potential are dependent on several intermolecular and intramolecular CARD interactions by generating mutants on different interaction surfaces and analyzing their tetramer formation and IFN-β induction abilities. MAVS filament formation assays indicate that the helical tetrameric structure of RIG-I 2-CARD serves as the platform for MAVS-CARD filament assembly, with the top surface of the second CARD as the primary site for MAVS recruitment⁹.The second pertinent question addressed is how the interaction between ubiquitin and 2-CARD contributes to downstream signaling? Unlike other DD oligomers, tetramer formation of isolated RIG-I 2-CARD requires K63-linked ubiquitin chains. The structure predicts that longer ubiquitin chains might wrap around the 2-CARD tetramer at 1:4 or 2:4 molar ratios to stabilize the 2-CARD tetramerization. Another key problem addressed in this study is the relationship between the covalent conjugation and non-covalent binding of K63-ubiquitin in stabilizing 2-CARD tetramers during RIG-I signaling. The authors challenge previous publications on the significance of 6 lysine (K) residues in both covalent conjugation and non-covalent K63-ubiquitin binding.The authors show that only K6 is covalently conjugated with K63-ubiquitin chains and that non-covalent binding of K63-ubiquitin to 2-CARD can induce a further stabilization of the tetramer complex. RIG-I filament formation on dsRNA with appropriate length can also compensate for the requirement of both covalent and non-covalent K63-ubiquitin binding. Thus they arrive at the conclusion that these three mechanisms might act synergistically for signal activation. This compensatory mechanism could guarantee the detection of foreign pathogen RNA in case of the absence of one or two of the mechanisms or may allow an amplification of the signal potential. One could speculate that such functional redundancy in the initiation stage of signal activation may be a common theme in other innate immunity pathways.The significance of this study lies in the resolution of the structural basis of the activated RIG-I 2-CARD tetramer and its initiation of MAVS aggregation and filament formation — the first elements of the dsRNA sensing signaling cascade that lead to production of type I IFNs and pro-inflammatory cytokines. It provides another detailed example of DD oligomers and adds to the growing realization of a common role of oligomeric molecular scaffolds in mediating innate immune signaling. Such exciting findings will no doubt instigate further study into the exact molecular interactions and mechanisms controlling dsRNA sensing. For example, the authors use a crystallized K115A/R117A 2-CARD double mutant for structural analysis; although it retains the ability to tetramerize with K63-ubiquitin and activate type I IFNs, the structure might still not be consistent with the wild-type 2-CARD and this may warrant further investigation. Furthermore, whether the RIG-I signaling activation mechanism that derived from this structure could be generalized and applied to other CARD domain receptors such as MDA-5, NOD1, NOD2, IPAF and NLRP1 will require further investigation. By utilizing advanced structural determination techniques coupled with sophisticated in vitro assays such as those described in this study, these questions will no doubt be addressed in the near future.