Cell-mediated immunity: Correlation of mixed-leucocyte-macrophage migration inhibition with delayed-type hypersensitivity after immunization and donor-specific transfer of cell migration inhibition by dialyzable leucocyte extract

Active and adoptive sensitization of rhesus monkeys (Macacca mulatta) as well as the development of a novel sensitive in vitro cell migration inhibition assay for cell-mediated immunity (CMI) in this species are described. First, the correlation of mixed leucocyte-macrophage migration tests (LMMI) with the whole blood lymphocyte transformation (LT) and the delayed hypersensitivity skin test (DH) in immunized animals are shown. Second, these tests are used to demonstrate adoptive transfer of specific/nonspecific cellular immunity (CMI) with dialyzable leucocyte extract (DLE) from immunized donor to unimmunized recipient monkeys. Seventeen animals were immunized with keyhole limpet haemocyanin (KLH) or hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) in Freund's complete adjuvant (FCA) or with FCA alone. Acquisition of antigen-specific cellmediated immunity was detected by all three tests within 5 weeks of immunization. Positive LMMI responses were associated with positive DH and LT. However, there was no correlation between the magnitude or time of development of the three responses. Therefore, the LMMI test, like the LT test, is an in vitro parameter of DH, but reflects the activity of different subpopulations of lymphocytes and is regulated by different mechanisms. In addition, 12 naive animals received DLE. Within 3 weeks, transfer of sensitivity was detected towards antigens to which the recipients had previously not been reactive but the donors had been. An enhancement of transformation response to phytohaemagglutinin was also seen. Thus, rhesus DLE contains both donor-specific transfer factor-like and nonspecific adjuvant-like activities. In DLE recipients, unlike immunized animals, LMMI responses were dissociated from DH or LT responses in that positive LMMI was mostly seen with negative DH or LT to antigens. Therefore, LMMI emerged as the most sensitive assay for detecting adoptive transfer of CMI by DLE in vivo, supporting the view that different mechanisms regulate LMMI, LT, and DH.     

Antigen-mediated macrophage adherence inhibition

Antigen-mediated macrophage adherence inhibition (MAI) was studied in inbred rats immunized with various transplantation, tumour-specific and protein antigens. A macrophage-rich suspension of peritoneal cells (PC) was obtained from the peritoneal cavity of immunized and control animals by washing. The adherence to glass of PC was specifically inhibited by the addition of the antigens used for sensitization of PC donors or by related (cross-reacting) antigens but not with unrelated antigens. The MAI seems to be due to the direct interaction of the respective antigen with a corresponding PC receptor and not due to the humoral factor released from immune lymphocytes of PC population upon contact with the specific antigen.     

Host response to tissues placed in the anterior chamber of the eye: demonstration of migration inhibition factor and serum blocking activity.

Allograft immunity of rats to transplantation antigens was demonstrated by in vitro migration inhibition procedures. Spleen cell suspensions from rats sensitized to histocompatibility antigens by skin graft or anterior chamber implants failed to migrate normally in vitro when incubated in the presence of appropriate donor tissue extracts. Tissue grafts transplanted across both major and minor histocompatibility barriers had prolonged survival within the anterior chamber. However, 2 weeks after implantation, the recipient rats showed detectable sensitization to their implants. Serum from 14- to 32-day implant-bearing rats blocked the migration inhibition found in the implanted rats in the presence of corresponding tissue antigen. Such blocking activity was undetectable in the serum from rats which had implants for 7 days or after rejection of the implant was evident. MIF production in implanted and skin-grafted rats was evident at significantly different times in relation to the graft rejection. The asynchrony of MIF synthesis observed in these experimental animals leads us to postulate that the graft rejection and MIF production may be mediated by distinct lymphocyte populations. In addition, the route of the antigen presentation may account in part for the observed differences.     

Leukocyte migration inhibition demonstrates a human T-cell response to a membrane protein expressed in latent Epstein-Barr virus infection.

Leukocyte migration inhibition tests show that lymphocytes of Epstein-Barr virus-seropositive individuals recognize a Raji cell membrane antigen and a membrane protein encoded by Epstein-Barr virus in latently infected cells. Antiserum against the latter blocks the leukocyte migration inhibition triggered by both preparations, suggesting that the two antigens are associated with the same protein complex.     

Leukocyte migration inhibition and leukocyte adherence inhibition (LMI- and LAI-assay) in cancer patients by using preparations from human fetuses]

The sensitization of lymphocytes from patients with different tumors was tested against a 3 M KCl-extract of fetal tissue (3.--6. month) by the leukocyte adherence inhibition assay (LAI) and by the leukocyte migration inhibition assay (LMI). Sensitization was compared with the reactivity of controls without any detectable tumor. In the LAI assay the leukocytes of 13/15 patients and 2/12 controls showed an inhibition of the adherence. In the LMI-assay 11/17 tumor-bearing patients and 6/18 controls reacted positive in the presence of the antigen preparation. The two methods demonstrated that patients bearing tumors of different histology are sensitized to fetal antigens.     

In vitro studies on transplantation immunity. II. The migration inhibition in homograft reactions in guinea pigs

The migration of peritoneal exudate cells from guinea pigs exhibiting transplantation immunity is inhibited in the presence of donor antigens. This inhibition of migration is demonstrable whether the donor transplantation antigens are presented in the form of viable cells (peritoneal exudate cells) or as particulate subcellular antigens (spleen microsomes). A greater degree of inhibition was observed when transplantation immunity was induced with lymphoid cells in Freud's adjuvant compared to sensitization with orthotopic skin grafts. There was no inhibition of migration in mixtures of normal allogeneic cells or when peritoneal cells from guinea pigs exhibiting tuberculin hypersensitivity were mixed with similar cells from normal animals. Finally, supernatants from cultures of sensitive lymphocytes plus donor antigens inhibited the migration of normal peritoneal cells indicating the presence of migration inhibitory factor (MIF) activity.     

Study of Delayed Hypersensitivity to Myxoviruses Induced by Vaccines

The delayed hypersensitivity response of guinea pigs to Bacillus Calmette-Gúerin (BCG) and myxovirus vaccines was investigated by use of the techniques of skin testing and inhibition of macrophage migration. A serum antibody response to the injected vaccines was readily demonstrable. Parainfluenza type 2 virus consistently failed to induce a delayed hypersensitivity state in 15 animals, even with the use of a virus adjuvant emulsion. Respiratory syncytial virus occupied an intermediate position in that positive delayed type skin tests of an erythematous nature were elicited following inoculation, but only two of seven guinea pigs yielded a positive migration inhibition test. In mumps-inoculated animals, skin testing gave rise to erythematous delayed skin reactions which varied from 0 to 20 mm in size. Migration inhibition could be demonstrated in 7 of 21 animals. In almost all guinea pigs inoculated with BCG, large, indurated, erythematous skin reactions were elicited, and inhibition of macrophage migration was readily demonstrated. The degree of skin reactivity was positively correlated with inhibition of macrophage migration. If the skin reaction to a specific antigen exceeded 9 mm of erythema, that antigen also inhibited macrophage migration. Skin testing proved to be the most sensitive indicator of viral hypersensitivity. Migration inhibition was demonstrated only when a greater than 8-mm skin reaction was evoked. This cellular hypersensitivity appeared to be a qualitative phenomenon, the expression of which could be heightened by the use of adjuvant. The applicability and sensitivity of the migration inhibition technique is considered relative to its use for in vitro monitoring of effects of viral vaccine inoculations.     

Antigen isolation from Rickettsia prowazekii cultured in FL cells and its use in the macrophage migration inhibition reaction

An antigen obtained from R. prowazekii cultivated in hydrocortisone-treated FL-cells possesses activity determined in the complement fixation test and the macrophage migration inhibition test. Such antigen can be used in the macrophage migration inhibition test with macrophages obtained from animals immunized with the preparations of rickettsial egg cultures.     

Migration inhibition by an agarose microdroplet assay: monitoring of tumor-associated antigens on a simian virus 40-induced sarcoma.

Macrophage migration inhibition assays, with a direct agarose microdroplet method, were used to monitor TAA activity of preparations of SV-40-induced mKSA cells. These preparations included cell-free crude membranes, papain-solubilized and NP40 detergent-solubilized membrane extracts from mKSA tumor cells. The assay was extremely sensitive and could detect migration inhibition reactivity with all three types of antigenic preparations with concentrations as low at 250 ng protein/ml. The reactivities were quite reproducible from experiment to experiment using the same or different lots of these antigen preparations, and the reactivities were specific in that peritoneal exudate cells from BALB/c mice, immunized with antigenically unrelated but syngeneic plasmacytomas, were not inhibited by these antigens. The results demonstrated the usefulness of this assay in rapidly detecting small concentrations of partially purified TAA preparations by using small number of immune cells.     

Transfer of osteosarcoma-specific cell-mediated immunity in hamsters by rabbit dialyzable leukocyte extracts

We have investigated the transfer of specific cell-mediated immunity (CMI) to osteosarcoma-associated antigens (OSAA) to hamsters with dialyzable leukocyte extracts (DLE) from OSAA-immunized rabbits. The transfer of specific CMI was determined by leukocyte adherence inhibition (LAI) assay and skin testing. DLE was prepared from rabbits immunized with OSAA, purified protein derivative (PPD), or fibrosarcoma cell plasma membrane preparation (FSM). Control DLE was prepared from rabbits injected with 0.85% NaCl. Significant leukocyte adherence inhibition was observed with leukocytes from hamsters that had received OSAA-specific, PPD-specific, and FSM-specific rabbit DLE, when OSAA, PPD, and FSM were used as antigens, respectively. Similarly, significant ear swelling after injection of OSAA, PPD, or FSM was observed only in hamsters that had received DLE from rabbits immunized with OSAA, PPD, or FSM, respectively. These results suggest that CMI specific for OSAA, PPD, or FSM can be transferred to normal hamsters by DLE from immunized rabbits.     

Cell-mediated immunity to viruses measured by the indirect agarose technique of leukocyte migration inhibition

The indirect agarose technique of leukocyte migration inhibition has been used to measure the response of human peripheral blood lymphocytes to several viruses. Using commercially available viral antigens, the indirect assay was found to be more sensitive than the direct agarose technique. Supernatants from cultures of sensitive lymphocytes with virus contained a nondialysable factor which inhibited the migration of polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMN). Under strict conditions of assay, whereby all culture supernatants were tested together on the same PMN preparation, the degree of migration inhibition obtained in response to mumps virus correlated well with the size of the skin test reaction to mumps. A similar relationship was shown for PPD. A good correlation existed also between the degree of migration inhibition and the lymphocyte transformation response for each of these two antigens.     

Tumour-associated antigens in culture medium of malignant melanoma cell strains

Summary The presence of melanoma-associated antigens naturally shed from cultured melanoma cells in spent culture medium was investigated by means of a leukocyte migration test and culture medium from four melanoma and two control cell strains.Leukocytes from 29/64 melanoma patients showed a positive reaction with spent culture medium from at least one melanoma cell strain, whereas leukocytes from only 4/25 patients with other cancers and 1/30 normal donors reacted. On the other hand, leukocytes from only 8/51 melanoma patients reacted with control culture medium. Only melanoma patients' leukocytes reacted with two or more of the melanoma cell strains used. Culture media from two melanoma cell strains were more reactive (25.3% and 29.4% positive tests with melanoma patients' leukocytes) than others (12.5% and 17.2% positive tests); this may represent either a qualitative difference (i.e., different antigens) or a quantitative one (i.e., different levels of antigen expression according to tissue culture conditions). Both inhibition and stimulation of migration were observed, but with one exception, on a given occasion, leukocytes from the same donor always reacted in the same way (i.e., either inhibition or stimulation). Migration stimulation was observed mainly with melanoma patients' leukocytes, and more especially when leukocytes were sampled from patients within a few weeks from tumour removal; migration stimulation may thus reflect a particular state of sensitization in patients.From the evidence obtained in these studies, it is concluded that spent culture medium from melanoma cell strains contains melanoma-associated antigen (s) that is (are) reactive in the leukocyte migration test and that this may contribute to the study of specific antitumour reactivity in patients and to the study and purification of tumour-associated antigens by providing an homogeneous source of antigens spontaneously released from tumour cells in conditions close to natural ones.     

Lack of leukocyte migration inhibition by hepatitis B surface antigen in hepatocellular carcinoma patients.

Soluble part of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) tissue extracts with or without hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) was tested against leukocytes of 13 histologically confirmed HCC patients. Inhibition of leukocyte migration was observed in 9 out of 13 cases when tested by soluble HCC extract containing HBsAg, while inhibition of lukocyte migration was observed in 8 out of 13 cases when tested by solublp greater than 0.05, by Fisher's exact test). In the meantime, soluble HCC extract with or without HBsAg did not significantly cause inhibition of leukocyte migration in 12 non-HCC patients. Therefore, it is concluded that inhibition of leukocyte migration in HCC patients is caused by the tumor-associated antigen, not caused by HBsAg.     

Relation between Delayed Skin Reactivity and Macrophage Migration Inhibition or Lymphocyte Transformation in Tuberculin-Type Hypersensitivity and Jones-Mote Hypersensitivity

Precise time-course studies on delayed skin reaction, lymphocyte transformation and macrophage migration inhibition were carried out from day 3 to 270 and from day 3 to 120, respectively, in guinea pigs immunized with bovine gamma-globulin (BGG) in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) and those immunized with BGG in incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA). a) Delayed skin reactions could be elicited for a long period of time after immunization with BGG in CFA in the presence of prominent antibody production and were accompanied by induration. b) Delayed reactions could be elicited transiently after immunization with BGG in IFA and were not accompanied by induration. c) At the peak of hypersensitivity, infiltrating cells at the reaction sites were composed largely of mononuclear cells and basophils, respectively, in the animals immunized with BGG in CFA and those immunized with BGG in IFA. d) Uptake of ³H-thymidine by lymphocytes was increased remarkably in the presence of BGG when cells were obtained at early stages after immunization by both methods. e) Macrophage migration inhibition was strongly positive in animals immunized with BGG in CFA but weakly positive in those immunized with BGG in IFA. Increased lymphocyte transformation preceded the appearance of a positive migration inhibition. f) After immunization with BGG in CFA, Jones-Mote hypersensitivity appeared to precede the development of tuberculin-type hypersensitivity.     

Leukocyte migration inhibition studies with Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) determined nuclear antigen (EBNA) in relation to the EBV-carrier status of the donor

Cell extracts from EBV-genome-carrying cell lines inhibit the migration of leukocytes from EBV-positive but not seronegative healthy donors. In the present study extracts from EBV-negative lines and their own in vitro EBV-converted sublines were used to induce migration inhibition with leukocytes from seronegative and seropositive individuals. A clear difference was found between the extracts from EBV-negative and positive cell lines. Significant migration inhibition could be obtained with antigen(s) associated with the virus nonproducer state. Since EBNA is known to be expressed by all nonproducer EBV-genome-carrying cells, we have compared the effect of partially purified EBNA and correspondingly prepared mock-EBNA on the leukocyte migration. Purified EBNA inhibited the leukocyte migration of EBV seropositives, whereas mock-EBNA had no such effect.     

Cells involved in cell-mediated and transplantation immunity in the rabbit. IV. The organ localization of the cells capable of migrating in vitro. Inhibition of migration by immunizing antigen

Rabbits were immunized with ovalbumin emulsified in complete Freund's adjuvant subcutaneously or with ovalbumin (OA) in saline intravenously. They were skin tested at intervals of time in order to determine the optimal sensitization time for the induction of the delayed skin reaction. The rabbits were also sacrificed and cell suspensions were prepared from the following organs: spleen, thymus, bone marrow, lymph nodes (popliteal), appendix, sacculus rotundus, and Peyer's patches. Peritoneal exudate cells were also obtained. These cell suspensions were tested for their ability to be inhibited in their migration in vitro by the specific sensitizing antigen. It was observed that the migration of all of the cell suspensions except for the bone marrow and peritoneal exudate cells could be inhibited by OA, but not by BGG, a non-cross-reacting antigen. Inhibition of migration was most marked at 3–4 weeks postsensitization and was negligible by 8–12 weeks, at a time when the delayed skin reaction was as extensive as in the early postsensitization period. Furthermore, the migration of cells of rabbits immunized with OA in saline intravenously was also markedly inhibited. It is concluded that, in the rabbit, different cell pathways are operative in the induction of the delayed skin reaction, on the one hand, and the facilitation of migration inhibition, on the other.     

Mechanisms of suppressed cell-mediated immunity and impaired antigen-induced interleukin 2 production in granuloma-bearing mice

Pulmonary granulomas were induced in BALB/c mice immunized with methylated bovine serum albumin in complete Freund's adjuvant by the intratracheal injection of plain agarose beads or beads conjugated to specific antigen. Large hypersensitivity granulomas developed around antigen-coupled beads in immunized animals. Smaller but still prominent granulomatous reactions developed around plain beads in immunized mice. In nonimmunized animals, both plain and antigen conjugated beads produced very small granulomas. Granuloma formation in sensitized animals was associated with suppressed delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions induced by the footpad injection of specific and nonspecific antigens. Lymph node cells from sensitized granuloma-bearing mice with cutaneous anergy showed suppressed specific and nonspecific antigen-induced proliferative responses in vitro. These cells also showed suppressed interleukin 2 production in response to specific antigen. Although no soluble suppressive factor was detected in granuloma extracts, suppressor cells were found in lymph nodes of granuloma-bearing mice, which could inhibit antigen-induced production of interleukin 2 by lymph node cells from immunized mice. Antigen-specific immunoglobulin G antibody production was not suppressed in immunized granuloma-bearing mice. Previous studies from our laboratory have demonstrated migration inhibition factor and interleukin 1 activities in aqueous extracts prepared from granuloma-bearing lungs of immunized mice. These results and the findings reported here indicate that granuloma formation and the associated anergy observed in this system are primarily expressions of cell-mediated immunity; selective suppression of in vivo and in vitro expressions of cell-mediated immunity in granuloma-bearing mice may be due to impaired antigen-induced interleukin 2 production; and such impairment is caused by suppressor cells.     

Leukocytic Hypersensitivity in Experimental Group A Streptococcal Infections

Skin hypersensitivity to streptococcal antigens was demonstrated in 15 New Zealand red rabbits that were sensitized by intracutaneous injections with group A streptococci, and leukocytic hypersensitivity, as determined by in vitro inhibition of leukocyte migration, was demonstrated in 11 of the rabbits. The skin hypersensitivity persisted for at least 8 weeks, whereas the leukocytic hypersensitivity generally waned rather rapidly. The leukocytic hypersensitivity reappeared in the infected rabbits that had developed this hypersensitivity. However, it did not reappear on reimmunization with living streptococci of the type originally employed, whereas it did reappear with living but not heat-killed streptococci of another M type.     

Leukocyte migration inhibition by a specific antigen in human typhoid fever.

Cellular reactivity to heat-killed Salmonella typhi antigen was investigated by the leukocyte migration inhibition (LMI) method in 33 S. typhi infected patients and in 32 control persons. In the typhoid group a statistically significant LMI was observed as compared to the members of the control group. A correlation was found between the level of the cellular sensitivity and the time elapsed between onset of the disease and performance of the test. Previous typhoid vaccination had no influence on the LMI. No correlation was found between the agglutinin titres and the sensitivity demonstrated by the LMI test. The value of the method in studies of cellular immunity in typhoid fever is discussed.     

Cellular immunity in man: correlation of leukocyte migration inhibition factor formation and delayed hypersensitivity

The formation of leukocyte migration inhibition factor (MIF) by the lymphocytes of 13 normal persons immune to the protein antigen keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) has been investigated. KLH-induced MIF formation expressed as percent migration was compared with delayed hypersensitivity, antibody, and in vitro lymphocyte blastogenic responses to this antigen. Individuals were studied 404–840 days (median 540 days) after their last exposure to KLH. Nine persons had delayed hypersensitivity to KLH and 10 had circulating KLH antibody. The lymphocytes of 11 showed an in vitro blastogenic response to KLH stimulation, while the lymphocytes of nine produced MIF after KLH stimulation. The mean percent migration for the subjects with KLH delayed hypersensitivity was 48.2 (range 20.4–70.4) compared with 133 (range 120–161) for the four persons who did not have KLH delayed hypersensitivity (P < 0.05). The correlation coefficient between the precent migration and delayed hypersensitivity was ?0.78 (P < 0.01). No correlation was demonstrated between migration inhibition and the other parameters of immunity.