Effects of membrane lipids on the activity and processivity of purified γ-secretase

The 19-transmembrane multisubunit γ-secretase complex generates the amyloid β-peptide (Aβ) of Alzheimer's disease (AD) by intramembrane proteolysis of the β-amyloid precursor protein (APP). Despite substantial advances in elucidating how this protein complex functions, the effect of the local membrane lipid microenvironment on γ-secretase cleavage of substrates is still poorly understood. Using detergent-free proteoliposomes to reconstitute purified human γ-secretase, we examined the effects of fatty acyl (FA) chain length, saturation and double-bond isomerization, and membrane lipid polar headgroups on γ-secretase function. We analyzed γ-secretase activity and processivity [i.e., sequential cleavages in the APP transmembrane domain that convert longer Aβ species (e.g., Aβ(46)) into shorter ones (e.g., Aβ(40))] by quantifying the APP intracellular domain (AICD) and various Aβ peptides, including via a bicine/urea gel system that detects multiple Aβ lengths. These assays revealed several trends. (1) Switching from a cis to a trans isomer of a monounsaturated FA chain in phosphatidylcholine (PC) increased γ-activity, did not affect Aβ(42):Aβ(40) ratios, but decreased the ratio of long (≥42) versus short (≤41) Aβ peptides. (2) Increasing the FA carbon chain length (14, 16, 18, and 20) increased γ-activity, reduced longer Aβ species, and reduced the Aβ(42):Aβ(40) ratio. (3) Shifting the position of the double bond in 18:1(Δ9-cis) PC to the Δ6 position substantially reduced activity. (4) Gangliosides increased γ-activity but decreased processivity, thus elevating the Aβ(42):Aβ(40) ratio. (5) Phosphatidylserine decreased γ-activity but increased processivity. (6) Phosphatidylinositol strongly inhibited γ-activity. Overall, our results show that subtle changes in membrane lipid composition can greatly influence γ-secretase activity and processivity, suggesting that relatively small changes in lipid membrane composition may affect the risk of AD at least as much as presenilin or APP mutations do.     

Assembly of the presenilin γ-/ε-secretase complex

The presenilin complex is composed of four core proteins (presenilin 1 or presenilin 2, APH1, nicastrin, and PEN2). Several endogenous proteins have been reported to selectively modulate the function of the presenilin complexes; these include transmembrane trafficking protein, 21-KD (TMP21), CD147 antigen (basigin), the γ-secretase-activating protein (gSAP), and the orphan G-protein-coupled receptor 3. Because the structure and assembly of these complexes underlies their activity, this review will discuss current work on the assembly of the complex and on presenilin-interacting proteins that regulate secretase activity.     

Structure and mechanism of the γ-secretase intramembrane protease complex

γ-Secretase is a membrane protein complex that proteolyzes within the transmembrane domain of >100 substrates, including those derived from the amyloid precursor protein and the Notch family of cell surface receptors. The nine-transmembrane presenilin is the catalytic component of this aspartyl protease complex that carries out hydrolysis in the lipid bilayer. Advances in cryoelectron microscopy have led to the elucidation of the structure of the γ-secretase complex at atomic resolution. Recently, structures of the enzyme have been determined with bound APP- or Notch-derived substrates, providing insight into the nature of substrate recognition and processing. Molecular dynamics simulations of substrate-bound enzymes suggest dynamic mechanisms of intramembrane proteolysis. Structures of the enzyme bound to small-molecule inhibitors and modulators have also been solved, setting the stage for rational structure-based drug discovery targeting γ-secretase.     

The very many faces of presenilins and the γ-secretase complex

Presenilin is a central, catalytic component of the γ-secretase complex which conducts intramembrane cleavage of various protein substrates. Although identified and mainly studied through its role in the development of amyloid plaques in Alzheimer disease, γ-secretase has many other important functions. The complex seems to be evolutionary conserved throughout the Metazoa, but recent findings in plants and Dictyostelium discoideum as well as in archeons suggest that its evolution and functions might be much more diversified than previously expected. In this review, a selective survey of the multitude of functions of presenilins and the γ-secretase complex is presented. Following a brief overview of γ-secretase structure, assembly and maturation, three functional aspects are analyzed: (1) the role of γ-secretase in autophagy and phagocytosis; (2) involvement of the complex in signaling related to endocytosis; and (3) control of calcium fluxes by presenilins.     

Pore-forming scissors? A first structural glimpse of γ-secretase

Amyloid plaques, which are composed of amyloid-beta peptide (Abeta), signify Alzheimer's disease pathology. Secretases generate Abeta by processing the beta-amyloid precursor protein. gamma-Secretase, a complex comprising four different proteins, liberates Abeta from its precursor by intramembrane proteolysis. The first impression of the shape of gamma-secretase has recently been revealed by electron microscopy. It indicates a spherical transmembrane particle with an interior chamber that, presumably, accommodates its catalytic residues, and two openings that might be exit sites for the cleavage products.     

Age-related modulation of γ-secretase activity in non-human primate brains

Age-dependent accumulation of the amyloid-β peptide (Aβ) in the brain is a pre-condition for development of Alzheimer's disease. A relative increase in the generation of longer Aβ species such as Aβ42 and Aβ43 is critical for Aβ deposition, but the underlying mechanism remains unresolved. Here, we performed a cell-free assay using microsome fractions of temporal cortex tissues from 42 cynomolgus monkeys and found that Aβ40-generating γ-secretase activity (γ40) decreased with age, whereas Aβ42-generating γ-secretase activity (γ42) was unaltered. In ELISAs, more than 80% of monkeys over 20-years old showed evidence of Aβ accumulation in the temporal cortex. The ratio of γ42 to γ40 increased with age and correlated with the level of accumulated Aβ. These results suggest that γ-secretase activity undergoes age-related, non-genetic modulation and that this modulation may cause Aβ accumulation in aging brains. Similar modulation may predispose aged human brains to Alzheimer's disease.     

Substrate sequence influences γ-secretase modulator activity, role of the transmembrane domain of the amyloid precursor protein

A subset of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs modulates the γ cleavage site in the amyloid precursor protein (APP) to selectively reduce production of Aβ42. It is unclear precisely how these γ-secretase modulators (GSMs) act to preferentially spare Aβ40 production as well as Notch processing and signaling. In an effort to determine the substrate requirements in NSAID/GSM activity, we determined the effects of sulindac sulfide and flurbiprofen on γ-cleavage of artificial constructs containing several γ-secretase substrates. Using FLAG-tagged constructs that expressed extracellularly truncated APP, Notch-1, or CD44, we found that these substrates have different sensitivities to sulindac sulfide. γ-Secretase cleavage of APP was altered by sulindac sulfide, but CD44 and Notch-1 were either insensitive or only minimally altered by this compound. Using chimeric APP constructs, we observed that the transmembrane domain (TMD) of APP played a pivotal role in determining drug sensitivity. Substituting the APP TMD with that of APLP2 retained the sensitivity to γ-cleavage modulation, but replacing TMDs from Notch-1 or ErbB4 rendered the resultant molecules insensitive to drug treatment. Specifically, the GXXXG motif within APP appeared to be critical to GSM activity. Consequently, the modulatory effects on γ-cleavage appears to be substrate-dependent. We hypothesize that the substrate present in the γ-secretase complex influences the conformation of the complex so that the binding site of GSMs is either stabilized or less favorable to influence the cleavage of the respective substrates.     

Structure activity relationship studies of tricyclic bispyran sulfone γ-secretase inhibitors

An investigation is detailed of the structure activity relationships (SAR) of two sulfone side chains of compound (?)-1a (SCH 900229), a potent, PS1-selective γ-secretase inhibitor and clinical candidate for the treatment of Alzheimer’s disease. Specifically, 4-CF₃ and 4-Br substituted arylsulfone analogs, (?)-1b and (?)-1c, are equipotent to compound (?)-1a. On the right hand side chain, linker size and terminal substituents of the pendant sulfone group are also investigated.     

Lipid bilayer position and orientation of novel carprofens,modulators of γ-secretase in Alzheimer's disease

γ-Secretase is an integral membrane protein complex and is involved in the cleavage of the amyloid precursor protein APP to produce amyloid-β peptides. Amyloid-β peptides are considered causative agents for Alzheimer's disease and drugs targeted at γ-secretase are investigated as therapeutic treatments. We synthesized new carprofen derivatives, which showed γ-secretase modulating activity and determined their precise position, orientation, and dynamics in lipid membranes by combining neutron diffraction, solid-state NMR spectroscopy, and molecular dynamics simulations. Our data indicate that the carprofen derivatives are inserted into the membrane interface, where the exact position and orientation depends on the lipid phase. This knowledge will help to understand the docking of carprofen derivatives to γ-secretase and in the design of new potent drugs. The approach presented here promises to serve as a general guideline how drug/target interactions in membranes can be analyzed in a comprehensive manner.     

Importance of phospholipid bilayer integrity in the analysis of protein–lipid interactions

The integrity of supported phospholipid bilayer membranes is of crucial importance for the investigation of lipid–protein interactions. Therefore we recorded the formation of supported membranes on SiO₂ and mica by quartz crystal microbalance and controlled the integrity by atomic force microscopy. This study aims to analyze how membrane defects affect protein–lipid interactions. The experiments focused on a lipid mixture of POPC/DOPC/Chol/POPS/PI(4,5)P₂ (37:20:20:20:3) and the binding of the peripheral membrane associated protein annexin A2. We found that formation of a continuous undisturbed bilayer is an indispensable precondition for a reliable determination and quantification of lipid–protein-interactions. If membrane defects were present, protein adsorption causes membrane disruption and lipid detachment on a support thus leading to false determination of binding constants. Our results obtained for PI(4,5)P₂ and cholesterol containing supported membranes yield new knowledge to construct functional surfaces that may cover nanoporous substrates, form free standing membranes or may be used for lab-on-a-chip applications.     

Structure and function of γ-secretase

The γ-secretase complex is a prime target for pharmacological intervention in Alzheimer’s disease and so far drug discovery efforts have yielded a large variety of potent and rather specific inhibitors of this enzymatic activity. However, as γ-secretase is able to cleave a wide variety of physiological important substrates, the real challenge is to develop substrate-specific compounds. Therefore, obtaining structural information about γ-secretase is indispensable. As crystal structures of the complex will be difficult to achieve, applied biochemical approaches need to be integrated with structural information obtained from other intramembrane-cleaving proteases. Here we review current knowledge about the structure and function of γ-secretase and discuss the value of these findings for the mechanistic understanding of this unusual protease.     

Dissociation between the processivity and total activity of γ-secretase: implications for the mechanism of Alzheimer's disease-causing presenilin mutations

The amyloid β-peptide (Aβ), strongly implicated in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease (AD), is produced from the amyloid β-protein precursor (APP) through consecutive proteolysis by β- and γ-secretases. The latter protease contains presenilin as the catalytic component of a membrane-embedded aspartyl protease complex. Missense mutations in presenilin are associated with early-onset familial AD, and these mutations generally both decrease Aβ production and increase the ratio of the aggregation-prone 42-residue form (Aβ42) to the 40-residue form (Aβ40). The connection between these two effects is not understood. Besides Aβ40 and Aβ42, γ-secretase produces a range of Aβ peptides, the result of initial cutting at the ε site to form Aβ48 or Aβ49 and subsequent trimming every three or four residues. Thus, γ-secretase displays both overall proteolytic activity (ε cutting) and processivity (trimming) toward its substrate APP. Here we tested whether a decrease in total activity correlates with decreased processivity using wild-type and AD-mutant presenilin-containing protease complexes. Changes in pH, temperature, and salt concentration that reduced the overall activity of the wild-type enzyme did not consistently result in increased proportions of longer Aβ peptides. Low salt concentrations and acidic pH were notable exceptions that subtly alter the proportion of individual Aβ peptides, suggesting that the charged state of certain residues may influence processivity. Five different AD mutant complexes, representing a broad range of effects on overall activity, Aβ42:Aβ40 ratios, and ages of disease onset, were also tested, revealing again that changes in total activity and processivity can be dissociated. Factors that control initial proteolysis of APP at the ε site apparently differ significantly from factors affecting subsequent trimming and the distribution of Aβ peptides.     

Purification and characterization of the human γ-secretase activating protein

Alzheimer's disease is a fatal neurological disorder that is a leading cause of death, with its prevalence increasing as the average life expectancy increases worldwide. There is an urgent need to develop new therapeutics for this disease. A newly described protein, the γ-secretase activating protein (GSAP), has been proposed to promote elevated levels of amyloid-β production, an activity that seems to be inhibited using the well-establish cancer drug, imatinib (Gleevec). Despite much interest in this protein, there has been little biochemical characterization of GSAP. Here we report protocols for the recombinant bacterial expression and purification of this potentially important protein. GSAP is expressed in inclusion bodies, which can be solubilized using harsh detergents or urea; however, traditional methods of refolding were not successful in generating soluble forms of the protein that contained well-ordered and homogeneous tertiary structure. However, GSAP could be solubilized in detergent micelle solutions, where it was seen to be largely α-helical but to adopt only heterogeneous tertiary structure. Under these same conditions, GSAP did not associate with either imatinib or the 99-residue transmembrane C-terminal domain of the amyloid precursor protein. These results highlight the challenges that will be faced in attempts to manipulate and characterize this protein.     

Identification of presenilin 1-selective γ-secretase inhibitors with reconstituted γ-secretase complexes

Accumulation of the β-amyloid (Aβ) peptides is one of the major pathologic hallmarks in the brains of Alzheimer's disease (AD) patients. Aβ is generated by sequential proteolytic cleavage of the amyloid precursor protein (APP) catalyzed by β- and γ-secretases. Inhibition of Aβ production by γ-secretase inhibitors (GSIs) is thus being pursued as a target for treatment of AD. In addition to processing APP, γ-secretase also catalyzes proteolytic cleavage of other transmembrane substrates, with the best characterized one being the cell surface receptor Notch. GSIs reduce Aβ production in animals and humans but also cause significant side effects because of the inhibition of Notch processing. The development of GSIs that reduce Aβ production and have less Notch-mediated side effect liability is therefore an important goal. γ-Secretase is a large membrane protein complex with four components, two of which have multiple isoforms: presenilin (PS1 or PS2), aph-1 (aph-1a or aph-1b), nicastrin, and pen-2. Here we describe the reconstitution of four γ-secretase complexes in Sf9 cells containing PS1--aph-1a, PS1--aph-1b, PS2--aph-1a, and PS2--aph-1b complexes. While PS1--aph-1a, PS1--aph-1b, and PS2--aph-1a complexes displayed robust γ-secretase activity, the reconstituted PS2--aph-1b complex was devoid of detectable γ-secretase activity. γ-Secretase complexes containing PS1 produced a higher proportion of the toxic species Aβ42 than γ-secretase complexes containing PS2. Using the reconstitution system, we identified MRK-560 and SCH 1500022 as highly selective inhibitors of PS1 γ-secretase activity. These findings may provide important insights into developing a new generation of γ-secretase inhibitors with improved side effect profiles.     

Increased expression of PS1 is sufficient to elevate the level and activity of γ-secretase in vivo

Increase in the generation and deposition of amyloid-β (Aβ) plays a central role in the development of Alzheimer's Disease (AD). Elevation of the activity of γ-secretase, a key enzyme required for the generation for Aβ, can thus be a potential risk factor in AD. However, it is not known whether γ-secretase can be upregulated in vivo. While in vitro studies showed that expression of all four components of γ-secretase (Nicastrin, Presenilin, Pen-2 and Aph-1) are required for upregulation of γ-secretase, it remains to be established as to whether this is true in vivo. To investigate whether overexpressing a single component of the γ-secretase complex is sufficient to elevate its level and activity in the brain, we analyzed transgenic mice expressing either wild type or familial AD (fAD) associated mutant PS1. In contrast to cell culture studies, overexpression of either wild type or mutant PS1 is sufficient to increase levels of Nicastrin and Pen-2, and elevate the level of active γ-secretase complex, enzymatic activity of γ-secretase and the deposition of Aβ in brains of mice. Importantly, γ-secretase comprised of mutant PS1 is less active than that of wild type PS1-containing γ-secretase; however, γ-secretase comprised of mutant PS1 cleaves at the Aβ42 site of APP-CTFs more efficiently than at the Aβ40 site, resulting in greater accumulation of Aβ deposits in the brain. Our data suggest that whereas fAD-linked PS1 mutants cause early onset disease, upregulation of PS1/γ-secretase activity may be a risk factor for late onset sporadic AD.