Avian muscular dystrophy: Thyroidal influence on pectoralis muscle growth and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase activity

The pectoralis muscles of dystrophic chickens (line 413) were hypertrophic on the basis of fresh weight and fat-free dry weight. They also had greater DNA content and greater glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) and 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase (6PGD) activities. Of the parameters measured, the largest differences between pectoralis muscles from dystrophic and normal (line 412) chickens were for DNA content and G6PD activity. These parameters were 4.3- and 6.7-fold, respectively, the values for control pectoralis at 5 wk of age. The average number of nuclei per unit length of isolated muscle fiber was also greater (approximately 3-fold) for the dystrophic pectoralis. Body weight and pectoralis fresh weight, fat-free dry weight, DNA content, G6PD activity and 6PGD activity were reduced significantly in propylthiouracil (PTU)-treated normal and dystrophic chickens. Moreover, the effects of PTU were more pronounced in the dystrophic strain. Thyroid deprivation significantly improved the righting ability of the dystrophic chickens, in addition to its influence on muscle hypertrophy and body growth. Thyroxine (T₄) replacement reversed the PTU effects in both strains. Of all the variables measured, total G6PD activity was the most affected by PTU treatment of dystrophic chickens and was only 16% of the control dystrophic value.In addition to the effects of thyroid deprivation on the expression of avian muscular dystrophy, we observed significant differences in thyroid-related variables in the two strains. The average thyroid weight at 4 wk and serum triiodothyronine level at 5 wk for dystrophic chickens were 65 and 76%, respectively, of the normal values. The results that we report here indicate that altered thyroid function affects the expression of avian muscular dystrophy.     

The increase in hexokinase activity in hereditary avian muscular dystrophy.

Hexokinase activity was found to be increased in both the more severely affected red (thigh) muscle of dystrophic chickens. The increase in activity was largely associated with the particulate fraction. These findings may indicate early events in the pathogenesis of avian muscular dystrophy.     

Calcium transport,ATPase activity and lipid composition in sarcoplasmic reticulum isolated from isogenic lines of normal and dystrophic chickens

Two new lines of chickens with near identical genotypes (greater than 90% isogeneity), one demonstrating avian dystrophy, were used for isolation of sarcopalsmic reticulum vesicles. Vesicles from line 433 (dystrophic) displayed reduced Ca²⁺-ATPase activity, phosphoenzyme formation and steady-state calcium transport capabilities in comparison with vesicles from line 03 (normal). Lipid analyses show that dystrophic vesicles have greater amounts of cholesterol and lesser amounts of phosphatidylcholine. The results support the use of isogenic chickens in further studies of avian dystrophy. However, the results also suggest that current sarcoplasmic reticulum vesicle purification procedures dependent on differential calcium accumulation may not fully achieve the intended purpose.     

Abnormal collagen synthesis in skeletal muscle of dystrophic chicken

Specific molecular properties of skeletal muscle collagens from normal and dystrophic chickens have been compared. When dystrophy develops in skeletal muscle tissue there was an increase in the amount of total collagen and an increased proportion of Type III collagen in the tissue. The results from the cross-link study as well as the analysis of the solubility of collagen showed that skeletal muscle of dystrophic chicken produces more immature collagen fibers compared to normal chicken. These findings strongly indicate an important role of collagen in the pathogenesis of the extensive connective tissue prolipheration characteristic of muscular dystrophies.     

Superoxide dismutase activity in early stages of development in normal and dystrophic chickens

Changes in superoxide dismutase activities in early stages of chronological development were investigated in normal and dystrophic chickens. Both cupro-zinc and manganese superoxide dismutase activities were significantly elevated in the dystrophic chickens studied as early as one week after hatching compared to those in the control. In control chickens, both cupro-zinc and manganese superoxide dismutase activities declined as they grew older. In dystrophic chickens, manganese superoxide dismutase activity declined gradually as they grew older as in the control. However, cupro-zinc superoxide dismutase activity increased until four weeks of age. The latter activity was still twice as high as that of the control at four months of age. Increased activities in superoxide dismutases in early stages of the development suggest presence of increased turnover of active oxygen species from the early stage of the disease in this avian muscular dystrophy. And the distinct time course of cupro-zinc superoxide dismutase activity suggests involvement of active oxygen species in pathogenesis of this disorder.     

Synthesis of apolipoprotein A1 in skeletal muscles of normal and dystrophic chickens

We recently observed that, around the time of hatching, chick skeletal muscles synthesize and secrete apolipoprotein A1 (apo-A1) at high rates and that reinitiation of synthesis of this serum protein to high levels occurs in mature chicken breast muscle following surgical denervation (Shackelford, J. E., and Lebherz, H. G. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 7175-7180; 14829-14833). In the present work we investigate the effect of avian muscular dystrophy on the synthesis of apo-A1 in chicken muscles. The relative rate of synthesis of apo-A1 and levels of apo-A1 RNA in mature dystrophic breast (fast-twitch) muscle were about 6-fold higher than normal, while synthesis of apo-A1 in breast muscles derived from 2-day-old dystrophic chicks was close to normal. These observations suggest that the elevated apo-A1 synthetic rate in mature dystrophic breast muscle results from a failure of the diseased tissue to "shut down" apo-A1 synthesis to the normal level during postembryonic maturation. Apo-A1 synthesis in the "slow-twitch" lateral adductor muscle of dystrophic chickens was found to be normal. Our work is discussed in terms of the apparent similarities between the effects of surgical denervation and muscular dystrophy on the protein synthetic programs expressed by chicken skeletal muscles.     

Thyroidal involvement in the expression of avian muscular dystrophy

We showed previously that propylthiouracil (PTU), a thyroid inhibitor, could alleviate several major signs of hereditary muscular dystrophy in chickens. The goals of the present investigation were to: (1) determine whether a nearly athyroid condition (achieved within two days after hatching by surgical thyroidectomy plus PTU) during an 11-day period beneficially affects the dystrophic condition when followed by triiodothyronine (T3) replacement to 33 days of age; (2) determine the beneficial effects on the expression of avian dystrophy when the thyroidectomized-PTU-treated chickens received a wide range of moderate to low T3 replacement doses beginning by two days after thyroidectomy; and (3) examine the thyroid hormone receptor system in dystrophic muscle for a possible abnormality. Thyroid deprivation increased muscle function (righting ability) and reduced plasma creatine kinase activity in dystrophic chickens. The major thyroid-related abnormality in dystrophic pectoralis muscles was an increased maximum binding capacity of solubilized nuclear T3 receptors.     

Myofibrillar creatine kinase in Duchenne and avian muscular dystrophy

The presence and activity of the fraction of creatine kinase (CK) which was associated with myofibrils and located in the M line of the sarcomeres was determined in normal and dystrophic avian muscle and in normal and dystrophic (Duchenne) human muscle. Myofibrils were isolated from homogenates of muscle and washed nine times so as to remove nonmyofibrillar CK. In myofibrils from dystrophic muscle the enzyme CK was localized to the M line using immunofluorescent techniques and was enzymatically active. These results suggest that in both avian and Duchenne muscular dystrophy, there is not a myofibrillar disorder of the phosphocreatine shuttle.     

Thyroid status affects 5-HT2A receptor modulation of breathing before, during, and following exposure of hamsters to acute intermittent hypoxia

The BIO 14.6 hamster (dystrophic), animal model of limb girdle muscular dystrophy, exhibits low plasma triiodothyronine levels, muscle weakness, and decreased breathing. After exposure to acute intermittent bouts of hypoxia, dystrophic hamsters depress ventilation relative to baseline resulting in ventilatory long-term depression (LTD). Control hamsters may increase ventilation relative to baseline resulting in ventilatory long-term facilitation (LTF). Serotonin (5-HT) receptors, especially the 5-HT(2A) subtype, are involved in the development of LTF. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the role of 5-HT(2A) receptors in ventilatory and metabolic responses before, during, and following intermittent hypoxia in eleven euthyroid, nine dystrophic, and eleven propylthiouracil (PTU)-induced hypothyroid male hamsters. Animals received subcutaneous injections of vehicle or 0.5 mg/kg MDL (5-HT(2A) receptor antagonist). Plethysmography was used to evaluate ventilatory responses of the three groups to air, five bouts of 5 min of 10% oxygen, each interspersed with 5 min of air, followed by 60 min of exposure to air. CO(2) production was measured using the flow-through method. Vehicle-treated dystrophic and PTU-treated hamsters exhibited LTD. MDL decreased body temperature in all groups. After MDL treatment, the euthyroid group exhibited LTD. MDL treatment in the dystrophic, but not in the PTU-treated hamsters, maintained tidal volume, but did not reverse LTD. CO(2) production was increased in the euthyroid group with MDL treatment. Thus, 5-HT(2A) receptors affect body temperature, ventilation, and metabolism in hamsters. The differential responses noted in this study may be in part dependent on thyroid hormone status.     

Regulation of arachidonate-induced platelet aggregation by the lipoxygenase product, 12-hydroperoxyeicosatetraenoic acid

Two lines of genetically involved and control chickens were compared with regard to the onset of muscle dystrophy during the early stages of growth ex ovo. Definite structural and functional involvement of pectoralis muscle developed within the first 4-5 weeks. In parallel experiments, microsomal membranes were obtained weekly from pectoralis muscle during the first 14 weeks ex ovo. The microsomes were studied with respect to ultrastructural features, protein composition, Ca2+ uptake and ATPase activity. Microsomal preparations obtained from all newborn chickens contain two types of vesicles: one type reveals an asymmetric distribution and 'high density' of particles on freeze-fracture faces which is characteristic of sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) membrane; the other type reveals a symmetric distribution and 'low density' of particles. The yield of 'low density' microsomes from muscle of normal birds is very much reduced as the chicks grow from 1 to 4-5 weeks ex ovo. On the contrary, it remains high in chicks developing muscle dystrophy. Ca2+ uptake and coupled ATPase activity are found to be of nearly identical specific activity in control and genetically involved newborn chicks. The specific activity of the control birds, however, increases as the chicks grow from 1 to 4-5 weeks of age, while the specific activity of the dystrophic birds remains low. Such a difference appears to be related to the relative representation of sarcoplasmic reticulum and 'low density' vesicles in the microsomal preparations. It is concluded that failure to obtain a normal differentiation of muscle cell membranes is a basic defect noted in the early growth of genetically involved chickens. This defect appears along with the earliest signs of the dystrophic process.     

Vasomotor effects of noradrenaline, acetylcholine, histamine, 5-hydroxytryptamine and bradykinin on snake (Trimeresurus flavoviridis) basilar arteries

We investigated the responsiveness of basilar arterial rings isolated from snakes to noradrenaline (NA), acetylcholine (ACh), histamine (His), 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT), mammalian bradykinin (BK) and rattlesnake BK. We also examined whether endothelial cells were involved in the responsiveness to ACh, BK, rattlesnake BK and in their resting vascular tone. NA and 5-HT induced concentration-dependent contractions. The cumulative concentration response curves of NA and 5-HT were shifted to the right in parallel by phentolamine (an alpha antagonist) and methiothepin (a 5-HT(1) and 5-HT(2) antagonist), respectively. However, ketanserin (a 5-HT(2) antagonist) had no effect on the cumulative concentration response curve of 5-HT. His, ACh, BK and rattlesnake BK had no effect on resting vascular tone; however, rattlesnake BK and sodium nitroprusside relaxed arteries precontracted by 5-HT. The rattlesnake BK-induced relaxations were almost abolished by L-nitro arginine (L-NA, a nitric oxide synthase inhibitor). L-NA and indomethacin (a cyclooxygenase inhibitor) had no effect on resting vascular tone or on precontracted arteries. These results suggest that alpha and 5-HT(1) receptor subtypes might be important in arterial contraction. Endothelial cells might play an important role in the responsiveness of snake basilar arteries to rattlesnake BK, but they might not be involved in the responsiveness to ACh, BK and in resting vascular tone.     

Myofibrillar protein degradation in the chicken. 3-Methylhistidine release in vivo and in vitro in normal and genetically muscular-dystrophic chickens

Myofibrillar protein degradation was measured in 4-week-old normal (line 412) and genetically muscular-dystrophic (line 413) New Hampshire chickens by monitoring the rates of 3-methylhistidine excretion in vivo and in vitro. A method of perfusing breast and wing muscles was developed and the rate of 3-methylhistidine release in vitro was measured between 30 and 90min of perfusion. During this perfusion period, 3-methylhistidine release from the muscle preparation was linear, indicating that changes in 3-methylhistidine concentration of the perfusate were the result of myofibrillar protein degradation. Furthermore, the viability of the perfused muscle was maintained during this interval. After 60min of perfusion, ATP, ADP and creatine phosphate concentrations in pectoral muscle were similar to muscle freeze-clamped in vivo. Rates of glucose uptake and lactate production were constant during the perfusion. In dystrophic-muscle preparations, the rate of 3-methylhistidine release in vitro (nmol/h per g of dried muscle) was elevated 2-fold when compared with that in normal muscle. From these data the fractional degradation rates of myofibrillar protein in normal and dystrophic pectoral muscle were calculated to be 12 and 24% respectively. Daily 3-methylhistidine excretion (nmol/day per g body wt.) in vivo was elevated 1.35-fold in dystrophic chickens. Additional studies revealed that the anti-dystrophic drugs diphenylhydantoin and methylsergide, which improve righting ability of dystrophic chickens, did not alter 3-methylhistidine release in vitro. This result implies that changes in myofibrillar protein turnover are not the primary lesion in avian muscular dystrophy. From tissue amino acid analysis, the myofibrillar 3-methylhistidine content per g dry weight of muscle was similar in normal and dystrophic pectoral muscle. More than 96% of the 3-methylhistidine present in pectoral muscle was associated with the myofibrillar fraction. Dystrophic myofibrillar protein contained significantly less 3-methylhistidine (nmol/g of myofibrillar protein) than protein from normal muscle. This observation supports the hypothesis that there may be a block in the biochemical maturation and development of dystrophic muscle after hatching. Free 3-methylhistidine (nmol/g wet wt.) was elevated in dystrophic muscle, whereas blood 3-methylhistidine concentrations were similar in both lines. In summary, the increased myofibrillar protein catabolism demonstrated in dystrophic pectoral muscle correlates with the increased lysosomal cathepsin activity in this tissue as reported by others.     

Oxidation state of tissue thiol groups and content of protein carbonyl groups in chickens with inherited muscular dystrophy.

Indirect evidence suggests that oxidative stress may play a role in the pathogenesis of inherited muscular dystrophy, but the significance and precise extent of this contribution is poorly understood. Compared with normal muscle, significantly higher contents of glutathione, glutathione disulphide, protein-glutathione mixed disulphides and protein carbonyl groups, and significantly lower contents of free protein thiol groups, were found in pectoralis major muscle of genetically dystrophic chickens (the muscle affected by this disease) at 4 weeks of age. Other tissues did not show such marked disease-related differences. Interestingly, the protein pool in normal, but not dystrophic, pectoralis major muscle was relatively less oxidized in relation to the glutathione pool as compared with other tissues studied. The mechanisms by which this unique relationship between the thiol pools is maintained remain unknown. Although the physiological consequences of the increased content of protein carbonyl groups and the altered thiol pools in dystrophic muscle are not clear, the changes evident at such a young age are consistent with the occurrence of oxidative stress and may reflect significant damage to cellular proteins in this disease.     

The levels of creatine kinase and adenylate kinase in the plasma of dystrophic chickens reflect the rates of loss of these enzymes from the circulation

The rates of loss of adenylate kinase and creatine kinase from the circulation after intravenous injection of homogenous chicken skeletal muscle enzymes were examined to determine the role of plasma clearance rates in determining the plasma levels of these enzymes in normal and dystrophic chickens. The rapid clearance of adenylate kinase activity (average half-life of 5 min) and the slower biphasic clearance of creatine kinase activity (average half-lives of 0.95 and 11 hr) are consistent with the elevation of creatine kinase but not adenylate kinase in the blood plasma of dystrophic chickens compared to normal chickens. The rates of clearance of these enzymes were similar in normal chickens compared to dystrophic chickens. Radioiodinated enzymes were cleared at similar, but slightly more rapid rates than the loss of enzyme activity. The loss of adenylate kinase activity from the circulation may be due in part to inactivation since adenylate kinase activity is rapidly inactivated in serum in vitro, and because no increase in adenylate kinase activity is observed in the most specific sites of clearance of the radioiodinated enzyme, the liver and spleen. The comparison of enzyme activities in press juices to the activities in high-ionic-strength homogenates of muscle tissue from normal and dystrophic muscle, indicates that adenylate kinase activity is not associated with intracellular structures to the extent that would prohibit release from dystrophic muscle tissue. These results, and those presented previously with regard to plasma levels and clearance rates of AMP aminohydrolase and pyruvate kinase in normal and dystrophic chickens (11) support our hypothesis that the rates of loss of muscle enzyme activities from the circulation are important in determining the circulating levels of muscle enzymes in dystrophic chickens. Furthermore, from the measurement of plasma levels and clearance rates of creatine kinase, it was estimated that the efflux rate of creatine kinase from dystrophic muscle tissue is 2.0% of the total breast muscle creatine kinase per day.     

An effect of avian hereditary muscular dystrophy on the reaction of troponin-C with its antibody

Antibody prepared against troponin-C, the calcium binding component of the troponin complex, was reacted with I band segments, and the distribution of antibody binding was assessed by immuno-electron microscopy. The I segments were isolated from glycerinated pectoral muscle which was prepared from normal adult chickens and from dystrophic chickens of strain 308. The antibody was deposited at 384 Å ± 7 Å intervals along the thin filaments of the normal muscle. In contrast to the normal controls the dystrophic muscle did not exhibit a distinct periodicity when reacted with anti-troponin-C. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate revealed that although protein bands corresponding to troponin-C could be observed in the gels of the dystrophic preparations, the troponin-C band had migrated slower than that from normal thin filaments. It is concluded that avian muscular dystrophy produces an alteration of the structure of troponin-C resulting in (1) an inability of the protein to combine with its specific antibody and (2) a change in its electrophoretic behavior.     

Acetylcholinesterase in singly and multiply innervated muscles of normal and dystrophic chickens. II. Effects of denervation.

Neural regulation of mature normal fast twitch muscle of the chicken suppresses high activity, extrajunctional localization, and isozyme forms of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) characteristic of embryonic, denervated and dystrophic muscle. Normal adult slow tonic muscle ofthe chicken retains intermediate levels of activity and embryonic isozyme forms but not extrajunctional activity; it is not affected by muscular dystrophy. The hypothesis that neural regulation of the AChE system is lacking in slow tonic muscle and thus not affected by dystrophy was tested by denervating the fast twitch posterior latissimus dorsi and slow tonic anterior latissimus dorsi muscles of normal and dystrophic chickens. Extrajunctional AChE activity and embryonic isozyme forms increased, then declined, in both muscles. The results suggest that ocntrol of AChE is qualitatively similar in slow tonic and fast twitch muscle of the chicken.     

Diversity of fast myosin heavy chain expression during development of gastrocnemius, bicep brachii, and posterior latissimus dorsi muscles in normal and dystrophic chickens

The expression of fast myosin heavy chain (MHC) isoforms was examined in developing bicep brachii, lateral gastrocnemius, and posterior latissimus dorsi (PLD) muscles of inbred normal White Leghorn chickens (Line 03) and genetically related inbred dystrophic White Leghorn chickens (Line 433). Utilizing a highly characterized monoclonal antibody library we employed ELISA, Western blot, immunocytochemical, and MHC epitope mapping techniques to determine which MHCs were present in the fibers of these muscles at different stages of development. The developmental pattern of MHC expression in the normal bicep brachii was uniform with all fibers initially accumulating embryonic MHC similar to that of the pectoralis muscle. At hatching the neonatal isoform was expressed in all fibers; however, unlike in the pectoralis muscle the embryonic MHC isoform did not disappear. With increasing age the neonatal MHC was repressed leaving the embryonic MHC as the only detectable isoform present in the adult bicep brachii muscle. While initially expressing embryonic MHC in ovo, the post-hatch normal gastrocnemius expressed both embryonic and neonatal MHCs. However, unlike the bicep brachii muscle, this pattern of expression continued in the adult muscle. The adult normal gastrocnemius stained heterogeneously with anti-embryonic and anti-neonatal antibodies indicating that mature fibers could contain either isoform or both. Neither the bicep brachii muscle nor the lateral gastrocnemius muscle reacted with the adult specific antibody at any stage of development. In the developing posterior latissimus dorsi muscle (PLD), embryonic, neonatal, and adult isoforms sequentially appeared; however, expression of the embryonic isoform continued throughout development. In the adult PLD, both embryonic and adult MHCs were expressed, with most fibers expressing both isoforms. In dystrophic neonates and adults virtually all fibers of the bicep brachii, gastrocnemius, and PLD muscles were identical and contained embryonic and neonatal MHCs. These results corroborate previous observations that there are alternative programs of fast MHC expression to that found in the pectoralis muscle of the chicken (M.T. Crow and F.E. Stockdale, 1986, Dev. Biol. 118, 333-342), and that diversification into fibers containing specific MHCs fails to occur in the fast muscle fibers of the dystrophic chicken. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that avian muscular dystrophy is a developmental disorder that is associated with alterations in isoform switching during muscle maturation.     

Increased contractility in vascular smooth muscle of dystrophic hamsters

To investigate the "vascular" hypothesis of muscular dystrophy, the sensitivity and contractility of aortic spiral strips of dystrophic (BIO 14.6) and normal (FIB) hamsters have been determined to various smooth muscle agonists. The results obtained with cumulative dose-response curves show that there is no increase in the sensitivity of the dystrophic compared with the normal aorta to noradrenaline, phenylephrine, isoproterenol, histamine, or 5-hydroxytryptamine. However, there was a significant increase in the force generated by aortic strips of the dystrophic animals to all agonists. Determination of noncollagen and collagen protein showed that there was no difference in the relative proportions of these proteins in the aortas from the two strains. The results show that in this animal model of dystrophy an increased response to vasopressor amines occurs and is in accordance with that expected of the vascular hypothesis.     

Enzymological studies on hereditary avian muscular dystrophy.

White and red muscles of normal and genetically dystrophic chickens were compared with regards to activity levels of three soluble enzymes, glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase, creatine phosphokinase, and acetyl phosphatase. In dystrophic white muscle (pectoral), activity of the two sulfhydryl enzymes, glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase and creatine phosphokinase, was preferentially lost from the sarcoplasm resulting in decreased specific activities. By contrast, acetyl phosphatase was preferentially retained and showed increased specific activity. Dystrophic white muscle had decreased sulfhydryl content in the soluble proteins, severe reduction in muscle mass, fatty infiltration, and fragmentation of fibers. Red dystrophic muscles (thigh) were minimally involved in accordance with the known sparing of red fibers. Enzyme activities were correlated with histological observations. The results suggested that the disease process in dystrophic white muscle may be related to alterations in the sulfhydryl groups of proteins. The data are correlated with the beneficial effects of our treatment of hereditary avian dystrophy with the sulfhydryl compound, penicillamine (Chou, T.H., Hill, E.J., Bartle, E., Woolley, K., LeQuire, V., Olson, W., Roelofs, R., and Park, J.H. (1975) J. Clin. Invest. 56, 842-849).     

Myosin isoforms in normal and dystrophic chickens

The myosin isoform content in the affected fibers of chickens with inherited muscular dystrophy has been investigated with a new high-performance liquid chromatographic procedure for separation of the tryptic fragments of myosin subfragment 1 (S-1). The results indicate that dystrophic muscle contains substantial amounts of normal adult myosin, together with various myosin species present in normal 5-day posthatch chickens. Confirmation was obtained by comparative peptide mapping of the S-1 tryptic fragments and by N-terminal sequencing of 20-kDa species. Together with data on other contractile proteins and certain metabolic enzymes [Obinata, T., Takano-Ohmura, H., & Matsuda, R. (1980) FEBS Lett. 120, 195-198; Mikasa, T., Takeda, S., Shimizu, T., & Kitaura, T. (1981) J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 89, 1951-1962; Feit, H., & Domke, R. (1982) Cell Motil. 2, 309-315; Cosmos, E. (1966) Dev. Biol. 13, 163-181; Cosmos, E., & Butler, J. (1967) in Exploratory Concepts in Muscular Dystrophy and Related Disorders (Milhorat, A. R., Ed.) pp 197-204, Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam], the results are consistent with the hypothesis that there is a general defect in muscle maturation in avian dystrophy.