Sensory reconstruction of the fingertip using the bilaterally innervated sensory cross-finger flap

The authors present a series of 15 patients with large soft-tissue defects of the fingertips as a prospective, nonrandomized study. In all cases, reconstruction was achieved using a bilaterally innervated sensory cross-finger flap. This sensory fasciocutaneous flap relies on the dorsal branch of the proper digital nerves, which branch off at the level of the head of the proximal phalanx; sensory supply to the dorsal skin of the middle phalanx is thus ensured. The reconstructive procedure consists of two steps. First, the contralateral dorsal branch of the proper digital nerve is elevated with the flap at proximal interphalangeal joint level. Microsurgical coaptation is performed to the proximal nerve stump of the injured fingertip. After 3 weeks, when the pedicle is dissected, the second nerve is dissected and coapted. Clinical results were evaluated after 12 months. Because the regenerative distance is only 1.5 to 2.5 cm, good sensory regeneration should be expected. In nine of 16 flaps, sensory quality of S2+ (Highet) was present in the flap after 3 weeks. After 12 months, two-point discrimination was present in all patients, the values ranging between 2 and 6 mm (for two-point discrimination), with an average of 3.6 mm. The rate of complications was low. With acceptable additional operative action, a good functional result can be achieved. The indications of this method are discussed in comparison with other methods of fingertip reconstruction.     

Reestablishment of sensitivity in the latissimus dorsi transplant through anastomosis of the thoracodorsal nerve with sensitive nerves

The question as to whether anastomosis of sensory nerves is recommended for free transplants of the myocutaneous latissimus dorsi flap, reanastomosed by microvascular surgery, remains a controversial issue. In this study, a microsurgical nerve anastomosis was performed to sensitize a latissimus dorsi transplant. To determine sensation in the transplanted tissue, six patients were examined clinically. All patients had free transplants of latissimus dorsi flaps reanastomosed by microvascular surgery after tumor resection in the oral cavity. An anastomosis of the sensible auricular magnus nerve with the motor thoracodorsalis nerve was performed. Resulting sensation was determined clinically by testing for pain, temperature, pressure, two-point discrimination, and vibration. All patients showed sensation in the latissimus dorsi flap beginning between the third and the fifth month postoperatively. Therefore, resensitization of a large and voluminous myocutaneous latissimus dorsi flap should be attempted by a nerve anastomosis in this transplant.     

An innervated cross-finger flap for fingertip reconstruction

An innervated cross-finger flap for treatment of severe fingertip injuries is described. With this method, the dorsal skin over the middle phalanx, together with its sensory nerve, is transferred as a compound skin-nerve flap. A neurorrhaphy is performed between this nerve and the cut end of the digital nerve at the injury site. Seven of eight patients (88 percent) treated with this method (mean follow-up time 14.4 months) achieved measurable two-point discrimination. The average for those who did was 4.8 mm. A group of patients with similar injuries treated with standard cross-finger flaps exhibited slower sensory return that progressed to a lower level. In this group (mean follow-up time 16.3 months), three of six (50 percent) achieved measurable two-point discrimination with a mean value of 9 mm.     

A versatile one-stage neurovascular flap for fingertip reconstruction: the dorsal middle phalangeal finger flap.

The dorsal middle phalangeal finger flap is an extremely reliable flap that is indicated for fingertip injuries which require sensory reconstruction. This flap originates from the dorsum of the middle phalanx of the finger and is elevated with a vascular pedicle of the digital artery and the dorsal branch of the digital nerve. After transfer of the flap to the injured site, epineural neurorrhaphy is done between the digital nerve and the dorsal sensory branch of the flap. This flap can be thought of as an island flap of the innervated cross-finger flap that provides excellent sensory recovery and aesthetic improvement. We used this flap in a series of eight consecutive patients and were able to follow up seven patients for longer than 6 months (mean follow-up time 10.7 months). All patients achieved measurable two-point discrimination, with an average of 4.9 mm in the moving two-point discrimination. In this study, we report our consecutive series of the dorsal middle phalangeal finger flap and its versatile utility.     

Sensitive areolar reconstruction in using a neurocutaneous island flap based on the medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve.

Sensory reconstruction has recently been stressed in breast reconstruction. However, there are no reports concerning the reconstruction of a sensitive areola. The bilateral reconstruction of a sensitive areola using a neurocutaneous flap based on the medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve is reported. The flap was harvested from the distal third of the forearm as an island flap and tunneled to reach the apex of the new breast, which was previously reconstructed using a 135-cc, gel-filled, silicone prosthesis covered by a latissimus dorsi myocutaneous flap. Six months later, fine sensibility in the reconstructed areola was demonstrated. The patient could perceive light touch, pain, and 14 mm two-point discrimination. At 2 months after surgery, 50 percent of cutaneous faulty stimulus location was observed. However, at 4 and 6 months after surgery, faulty location disappeared. Six months after harvesting the medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve, the sensory deficit was minimal; it included a hypoesthesic zone of 4 to 7 cm and an anesthesic zone of 2.5 to 5 cm on the middle third of the forearm. Fifteen months after the procedure, no hypoesthesic zone was observed; only a 2 to 3 cm anesthesic zone on the proximal medial side of the forearm existed. This sensory deficit passed unnoticed by the patient. The technique developed here is a refinement in breast reconstruction, and we think it should be used in selected patients.     

Clinical nerve reconstruction with a bioabsorbable polyglycolic acid tube

Microneurosurgical techniques to reconstruct nerve gaps with nerve grafts frequently fail to achieve excellent functional results and create donor-site morbidity. In the present study, 15 patients had gaps of 0.5 to 3.0 cm (mean 1.7 cm) in digital nerves reconstructed by one surgeon with a bioabsorbable polyglycolic acid (PGA) tube. A final evaluation of sensibility was done by a second surgeon at a mean postoperative interval of 22.4 months (range 11 to 32 months). These were all secondary reconstructions. The evaluation included a digital nerve block with local anesthetic for the intact (not reconstructed) digital nerve. Excellent functional sensation (moving two-point discrimination less than or equal to 3 mm and/or static two-point discrimination less than or equal to 6 mm) was present in 33 percent and good functional sensation (moving two-point discrimination of 4 to 7 mm and/or static two-point discrimination of 7 to 15 mm) in 53 percent of the digital nerve reconstructions. One patient with poor sensory recovery and one with no recovery were judged as functional failures (14 percent). Absence of pain at the site of reconstruction was judged by the patient to be excellent in 40 percent, good in 33 percent, and poor in 27 percent. We conclude that reconstruction of nerve gaps of up to 3.0 cm with a bioabsorbable PGA tube gives clinical results at least comparable to the classic nerve graft technique while avoiding donor-site morbidity.     

Reconstruction of the weight-bearing surface of the foot with nonneurosensory free flaps

Neurotized fasciocutaneous flaps and split-skin grafted muscle flaps are the most frequently used free flap alternatives for the reconstruction of weight-bearing surfaces of the foot. An objective comparison of the innate characteristics of these two flap types, with respect to long-term stability, has not been possible because sensory reinnervation in the fasciocutaneous flaps has been a confounding factor. This study compares nonsensate fasciocutaneous flaps (n = 9) with nonsensate split-skin grafted muscle flaps (n = 11), with mean follow-up periods of 34.3 and 31.3 months, respectively. Patients completed a form that included questions regarding degree of pain at the operative site, presence of ulcers, ability to wear normal shoes, employment status, and time spent standing on foot. Touch and deep sensation were evaluated with Semmes-Weinstein and vibration tests, respectively. Significantly less pain and less ulceration (p < 0.05) were observed in the fasciocutaneous group. Semmes-Weinstein monofilament tests revealed poorer results with split-skin grafted muscle flaps, compared with fasciocutaneous flaps. These results indicate that even if the sensory protection of fasciocutaneous flaps is not considered, these flaps have superior properties, compared with split-skin grafted muscle flaps.     

A randomized prospective study of polyglycolic acid conduits for digital nerve reconstruction in humans

This article reports the first randomized prospective multicenter evaluation of a bioabsorbable conduit for nerve repair. The study enrolled 98 subjects with 136 nerve transections in the hand and prospectively randomized the repair to two groups: standard repair, either end-to-end or with a nerve graft, or repair using a polyglycolic acid conduit. Two-point discrimination was measured by a blinded observer at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months after repair. There were 56 nerves repaired in the control group and 46 nerves repaired with a conduit available for follow-up. Three patients had a partial conduit extrusion as a result of loss of the initially crushed skin flap. The overall results showed no significant difference between the two groups as a whole. In the control group, excellent results were obtained in 43 percent of repairs, good results in 43 percent, and poor results in 14 percent. In those nerves repaired with a conduit, excellent results were obtained in 44 percent, good results in 30 percent, and poor results in 26 percent (p = 0.46). When the sensory recovery was examined with regard to length of nerve gap, however, nerves with gaps of 4 mm or less had better sensation when repaired with a conduit; the mean moving two-point discrimination was 3.7 +/- 1.4 mm for polyglycolic acid tube repair and 6.1 +/- 3.3 mm for end-to-end repairs (p = 0.03). All injured nerves with deficits of 8 mm or greater were reconstructed with either a nerve graft or a conduit. This subgroup also demonstrated a significant difference in favor of the polyglycolic acid tube. The mean moving two-point discrimination for the conduit was 6.8 +/- 3.8 mm, with excellent results obtained in 7 of 17 nerves, whereas the mean moving two-point discrimination for the graft repair was 12.9 +/- 2.4 mm, with excellent results obtained in none of the eight nerves (p < 0.001 and p = 0.06, respectively). This investigation demonstrates improved sensation when a conduit repair is used for nerve gaps of 4 mm or less, compared with end-to-end repair of digital nerves. Polyglycolic acid conduit repair also produces results superior to those of a nerve graft for larger nerve gaps and eliminates the donor-site morbidity associated with nerve-graft harvesting.     

Free microvascular muscle flaps with skin graft reconstruction of extensive defects of the foot: a clinical and gait analysis study

Over the past 4 years at the Massachusetts General Hospital 18 patients have been treated for extensive defects (mean size 130 cm2) of the foot at or below the medial and lateral malleoli. These patients have been treated with free muscle flaps covered with thick split-thickness skin grafts. Full muscle flap survival has been seen in each patient, and all patients are currently ambulatory. A subgroup of nine patients are weight-bearing directly upon their skin grafts covering transferred muscle. All patients are walking without chronic breakdown over a mean follow-up of over 19 months with the exception of a single patient who has had breakdown in a region of redundant improperly tailored muscle flap. None of the skin grafted muscles has significant cutaneous sensibility. Detailed gait analysis of these patients has confirmed the weight-bearing capabilities of free muscle flaps with skin grafts and has proven to be an excellent method of foot reconstruction evaluation. It would appear from this study that cutaneous sensibility may not be necessary for successful reconstruction of the weight-bearing surface of the foot. This method of reconstruction should be considered when local tissues are not suitable for plantar foot reconstruction.     

Sensory reinnervation in microsurgical reconstruction of the heel

Six sensory reinnervation techniques were carried out in 10 patients who underwent reconstruction of the weight-bearing surface of the heel by microsurgical free-tissue transfer. The techniques include the use of neurovascular island flaps, neurosensory flaps, sensory nerve grafts to skin flaps, coaptation of the sensory nerve to the motor nerve of the muscle flaps, direct sensory nerve transfer, and sensory nerve graft transfer. In all patients, some sensation developed, characterized by sensation to light touch, to dull objects, to pinprick, to pain, and to tickling. Three patients developed the ability to distinguish sharp from dull objects and the sensation of pain. The remaining seven had the sensation of touch to various mechanical stimuli. In nine patients, the sensation is located in the weight-bearing surface of the reconstructed heel. Five patients bear weight on the reconstructed surface at least 6 hours per day. Three participate actively in sports. Split-thickness skin graft-muscle flaps were more prone to breakdown than skin flaps. Full-thickness skin flaps appear necessary for the production of pain sensation and the more discriminating sensations. Preliminary results suggest a functional benefit after sensory reinnervation.     

A reverse ulnar hypothenar flap for finger reconstruction

A reverse-flow island flap from the hypothenar eminence of the hand was applied in 11 patients to treat palmar skin defects, amputation injuries, or flexion contractures of the little finger. There were three female and eight male patients, and their ages at the time of surgery averaged 46 years. A 3 x 1.5 to 5 X 2 cm fasciocutaneous flap from the ulnar aspect of the hypothenar eminence, which was located over the abductor digiti minimi muscle, was designed and transferred in a retrograde fashion to cover the skin and soft-tissue defects of the little finger. The flap was based on the ulnar palmar digital artery of the little finger and in three patients was sensated by the dorsal branch of the ulnar nerve or by branches of the ulnar palmar digital nerve of the little finger. Follow-up periods averaged 42 months. The postoperative course was uneventful for all patients, and all of the flaps survived without complications. The donor site was closed primarily in all cases, and no patient complained of significant donor-site problems. Satisfactory sensory reinnervation was achieved in patients who underwent sensory flap transfer, as indicated by 5 mm of moving two-point discrimination. A reverse island flap from the hypothenar eminence is easily elevated, contains durable fasciocutaneous structures, and has a good color and texture match to the finger pulp. This flap is a good alternative for reconstruction of palmar skin and soft-tissue defects of the little finger.     

Sensibility and cutaneous reinnervation in free flaps

Sensibility and sensory reinnervation were investigated in 19 free flaps, predominantly located on the lower extremities, between 2 months and 3 years after flap transfer. All patients showed deep pressure sensibility. In 10 of the patients, primarily those examined late after surgery, a heat pain threshold was obtained at about 50 degrees C. None of the patients had superficial sensibility of any other modality. No neurofilament-positive sensory nerve fibers were observed in the dermis or epidermis. In one patient nerve fibers were detected in the subcutaneous tissue. It is concluded that patients will have deep pressure sensibility of the flap area even early after the operation and that most patients will develop a heat pain sensitivity, probably due to subcutaneous reinnervation.     

Comparison of innervated and noninnervated free flaps in oral reconstruction.

Thirteen patients who had undergone ablative surgery for advanced squamous cell carcinoma in which more than half of the tongue had been resected underwent reconstruction in which the cutaneous nerve of a free flap was anastomosed to the stump of the transected lingual nerve. Eight of the patients underwent reconstruction with an innervated anterolateral thigh flap and five patients underwent reconstruction with an innervated rectus abdominis musculocutaneous flap. Sensory recovery of the flap at least 6 months postoperatively was compared in these 13 patients and in 16 additional patients who received noninnervated versions of the same flaps for the same defect. The degree of sensory recovery of innervated thigh flaps was significantly greater than that of noninnervated ones in all modalities and that of innervated rectus abdominis flaps was also greater than that of noninnervated flaps, except for hot and cold perception. These results indicate that sensory regrowth occurs in most areas through the surgically created pathways. However, results of Semmes-Weinstein testing showed that recovery did not reach the level of protective sensation in either type of innervated flap. Although these findings must be followed by additional objective and functional tests and the need for sensory reeducation should be considered, this simple operative procedure can improve postoperative intraoral function and should be attempted whenever possible after ablative surgery.     

Innervated radial thenar flap combined with radial forearm flap transfer for thumb reconstruction

A radial thenar flap combined with radial forearm flap was used for the reconstruction of the ipsilateral thumb in four patients. Vascular supply of the combined flap was based on the radial artery and extending the vascular pedicle to the superficial palmar branch of the radial artery. The flap was sensated by the palmar branch of the superficial radial nerve. The size of the flap averaged 15 x 5 cm and the innervated region of the thenar eminence was an area approximately 5 x 3 cm located over the proximal parts of the abductor pollicis brevis and opponens pollicis muscles. The flap was transferred as a free flap in three patients and as an advancement flap in one patient. The flaps survived completely without complications. Satisfactory restoration of sensation was achieved in the flap area, as shown by 6 mm of average moving two-point discrimination. This combined flap may be a feasible reconstructive option for large palmar defects of the fingers such as degloving injuries.     

Extremity reconstruction using the free deltoid flap

The deltoid fasciocutaneous flap is a thin, reliable flap that is easily dissected from the posterolateral arm. It has large-caliber vessels and is capable of sensory reinnervation to portions of the flap above the deltoid/triceps groove through the lateral brachial cutaneous nerve. There is little sensory return to the large vascular territory, which can be extended inferiorly below the deltoid triceps groove. The donor site can be closed primarily or skin grafted and when large may be objectionable to some patients. The flap is an excellent choice for extremity soft-tissue reconstruction on the plantar or palmar surfaces. Protective sensibility has returned to all reinnervated flaps. We present our experience in 10 patients with extremity problems.     

Comparison between sensitive and nonsensitive free flaps in reconstruction of the heel and plantar area

In this study, 12 cases of reconstruction of the heel and plantar area since 1982 are reviewed. Six nonsensate muscle free flaps and six sensate fasciocutaneous flaps were used, respectively. Categories assessed were the time interval for return to daily living activities, sensation to light touch, pinprick, Semmes-Weinstein monofilament test of the reconstructed area for sensory evaluation; and results of pedograms (maximal pressure, pressure distribution, and total contact area of the plantar surface). Follow-up periods were between 2 and 14 years, with an average of 6 years. Better sensory results and early return to daily living activities were observed in the sensate flap group, but the defects were smaller in this group. Despite the slightly longer time to return to daily living activities and worse sensory results, long-term follow-up showed that patients with nonsensate flaps had no difficulty in performing living activities if they continued to be careful and to use some kind of protective shoes. The results of the pedogram analyses were similar between the two groups with regard to total contact area of the reconstructed foot in relation to the healthy foot. Pressure values of the reconstructed areas in sensate flaps were found to be close to pressure values in the same weight areas of the normal foot. The differences between pressure values of the sensate and nonsensate flaps were statistically significant (p < 0.001). Therefore, in reconstruction of the weight-bearing surface of the foot, each case should be evaluated individually. The reconstructive method should be chosen according to the location and soft-tissue requirements of the defect.     

Sensory restoration of the skin graft on a free muscle flap: experimental rabbit study.

Transplantation of a muscle flap with free skin graft for wound coverage is a common procedure in reconstructive microsurgery. However, the grafted skin has little or no sensation. Restoration of the sensibility of the grafted skin on the transferred muscle is critically important, especially in palmar hand, plantar foot, heel, and oral cavity reconstruction. The purpose of this study was to investigate the possibility of sensory restoration of the grafted skin on a trimmed muscle surface that has been sensory neurotized after sensory nerve-to-motor nerve transfer, using the rabbit gracilis muscle as an animal model. The ipsilateral saphenous nerve (sensory) was transferred to the motor nerve of the gracilis muscle for sensory neurotization. A 4 x 4-cm2 area of skin island over the midportion of the gracilis muscle was harvested as a full-thickness skin graft. The upper half of the gracilis muscle was then excised, becoming a rough surface. The harvested skin was reapplied on the trimmed rough surface of the muscle. After 6 months, retrograde and antegrade horseradish peroxidase labeling studies were performed through skin and muscle injection. The group with a free skin graft was compared with the group with an intact surface of the gracilis muscle. This study clearly shows that sensory nerves can regenerate and penetrate into the trimmed muscle surface and grow into the overlying grafted skin. However, if the muscle surface is intact as with the compared group, sensory reinnervation of the grafted skin is not possible.     

Breast reconstruction using the sensate latissimus dorsi musculocutaneous flap

The authors performed immediate breast reconstruction on four patients using a sensate latissimus dorsi musculocutaneous flap accompanied by neurorrhaphy during the past 6 years. In the neurorrhaphy, the lateral cutaneous branch of the dorsal primary divisions of the seventh thoracic nerve, which controls the sensation of the myocutaneous flap, was anastomosed to the lateral cutaneous branch of the fourth intercostal nerve, which controls the sensation of the breast. The subjects consisted of four patients whose postoperative follow-up period was 14 to 29 months, with an average of 19.3 months. The control subjects consisted of 10 cases with a latissimus dorsi musculocutaneous flap whose sensory nerve had not been reconstructed (postoperative follow-up period, 15 to 49 months; average, 26.9 months). The sensory examination included tests of touch, pain, and temperature. The innervated musculocutaneous flap sensation showed gradual recovery at about 6 months after surgery and reached the value of the normal side after about 1 year. In the control subjects, the recovery was gradual after more than 1 year and reached the value of the normal side in only some of the control subjects. On the basis of these findings, the authors consider the present technique to be useful for the recovery of sensation in immediate breast reconstruction.     

A prospective clinical evaluation of autogenous vein grafts used as a nerve conduit for distal sensory nerve defects of 3 cm or less

The purpose of this study was to determine the efficacy of autogenous vein grafts as nerve grafts (AVNC) for bridging of small peripheral sensory nerve gaps as compared with direct repair and with conventional nerve grafting techniques (ANG). Patients with painful neuroma or segmental nerve injury of 3 cm were chosen as the test group. Those amenable to direct repair were classified as controls. Between 1982 to 1988, a total of 22 patients were enrolled in this study. A total of 34 nerves were repaired, 15 with a venous nerve conduit, 4 with a sural nerve graft, and 15 with direct repair. Significant symptom relief and satisfactory sensory function return were uniformly observed. The two-point discrimination measurements indicated superiority of direct repair and probably of conventional nerve grafting. However, the universally favorable patient acceptance and the return of measurable two-point discrimination indicates the effectiveness of autogenous vein grafts as nerve conduits when selectively applied to bridge a small nerve gap (less than or equal to 3 cm) on nonessential peripheral sensory nerves.     

Autogenous vein graft repair of digital nerve defects in the finger: a retrospective clinical study

Twenty-two digital nerve repairs were performed in the finger using autogenous vein grafts. Eighty-two percent of the repairs were available for follow-up. Results of sensibility return were assessed using moving two-point discrimination, Semmes-Weinstein monofilaments, and vibratory testing. Two-point discrimination averaged 4.6 mm for 11 acute digital nerve repairs using vein conduits 1 to 3 cm in length. Delayed digital nerve repair with vein conduits yielded poor results. Semmes-Weinstein values demonstrated comparable levels of return of slowly adapting fiber/receptors to the quickly adapting fiber/receptors, as evidenced by moving two-point discrimination tests. Vibratory sensibility was present in all. A review of previous experiences with end-to-end digital neurorrhaphies and digital nerve grafting suggests that repair of 1- to 3-cm gaps in digital nerves with segments of autologous vein grafts appears to give comparable results to nerve grafting. Further laboratory and clinical research is necessary to better define the role of interpositional vein conduits for repair of peripheral nerves.