Shaping intraspecific variation: Development,ecology and the evolution of morphology and life history variation in tiger salamanders

The tiger salamander,Ambystoma tigrinum, is a geographically widespread, morphologically variable, polytipic species. It is among the most variable species of salamanders in morphology and life history with two larval morphs (typical and cannibal) and three adult morphs (metamorphosed, typical branchiate, cannibal branchiate) that vary in frequency between subspecies and between populations within subspecies. We report morphometric evidence suggesting that branchiate cannibals arose through intraspecific change in the onset or timing of development resulting in the wider head and hypertrophied tooth-bearing skull bones characteristic of this phenotype. We also quantified bilateral symmetry of gill raker counts and abnormalities, then evaluated fluctuating asymmetry as a measure of the developmental stability of each morph. There was a significant interaction between fluctuating asymmetry of developmental abnormalities in cannibals and typicals and the locality where they were collected, suggesting that relative stability of each phenotype could vary among populations. While altered timing of developmental events appears to have a role in the evolution and maintenance of morphs, novel phenotypes persist only under favorable ecological conditions. Predictability of the aquatic habitat, genetic variation, kinship, body size, intraspecific competition and predation all affect expression and survival of the morphs inA. tigrinum. This taxon provides an excellent model for understanding the diversity and complexity of developmental and ecological variables controlling the evolution and maintenance of novel phenotypes.     

Developmental stability in brown trout: are there any effects of heterozygosity or environmental stress?

We studied the developmental stability of brown trout, Salmo trutta L., in 10 populations (five acidified, five control) in Norway, measured as fluctuating asymmetry (FA) and departure from the morphological norm. We measured four meristic and four morphometric characters, and scored the level of biochemical heterozygosity at 49 loci (20 polymorphic). We reared eggs of a single population in a hatchery using four different water qualities (three replicates of each treatment) to test the effect of acidification stress on developmental instability. There were no significant differences in the level of FA, in departure from the morphological norm between brown trout sampled from lakes with acidified or control water qualities, or in brown trout hatched at different water qualities. There was no correlation between level of heterozygosity and FA or departure from the morphological norm, either when tested within populations or among populations. There were no single-locus effects on developmental stability tested for 11 loci. We conclude that measures of developmental stability or morphological variability are not useful for detecting acidification stress in brown trout. Furthermore, we conclude that developmental stability in our material varies independently of heterozygosity.     

Persistence of subtle departures from symmetry over multiple molts in individual brachyuran crabs: Relevance to developmental stability

Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) is generally viewed as a population-level character. It is described by some measure of the variance of the difference between the right and left sides for a collection of individuals. Very little is known of the developmental origins of FA, despite the fact that FA is widely used to estimatedevelopmental stability. We present a novel technique for examining the growth trajectory of the asymmetries that give rise to FA, and we explore two sample data sets for the brachyuran crabHemigrapsus nudus. We have traced the fate of these small, random deviations from perfect symmetry through three successive molts of individual crabs. Invertebrates that molt, and hence grow in discrete steps, provide an easily preserved record of their growth. Model II regressions of measurements from one molt versus the previous molt can help describe the stability of subtle departures from symmetry over time. Although any number of different patterns may occur, we identify four general cases: a) asymmetries vary at random throughout growth (random determination), b) asymmetries remain unchanged in sign and magnitude (constant asymmetries), c) asymmetries increase in proportion to character size and hence increase with growth (size-dependent asymmetries), and d) asymmetries persist, but are reduced in magnitude (damped asymmetries). Data from tenHemigrapsus nudus, measured for between 21 and 28 metrical, limb-segment characters over three successive molts, yielded associations most similar to our pattern ‘b’, although some subtle departures in the direction of pattern ‘c’ were also observed. Persistent asymmetries accounted for 26% and 20% of the variance among asymmetries between molts 1 and 2, and molts 2 and 3 respectively. Thus, in spite of large and rapid increments in the external size of the crab, these subtle asymmetries tended to persist in both direction and magnitude, from molt to molt. This result suggests either i) that individual crabs have a genetic predisposition towards asymmetry in a particular direction but contribute to a continuous and normal distribution ofR-L differences at the population level, or ii) that these subtle asymmetries arose at some earlier ontogenetic stage and were preserved through growth. Either interpretation has important ramifications for the study of FA. The first suggests that under some circumstances FA may not provide a valid measure of developmental instability, because subtle departures from symmetry in an individual may have a genetic basis. The second implies that subtle departures from bilateral symmetry are not ‘corrected’ as an individual grows.     

Evolution,developmental instability and the theory of acquisition

Despite major advances in the study of molecular and morphological evolution a substantial rift still exists between these two fields of endeavour. Phenotypic alteration through evolution results from a reallocation of resources which has as its origin the interplay between the production capability of the genes on the one side and the acquisitional need of the phenotype on the other. This process of allocation is coordinated through the environmental arena and is subject to mechanical, biological and economical constraints. Differences in the rates of morphological change at any level (molecular, cellular, organismal or population) depend on the level of environmental challenge, on the availability of variability and on the economics of supply and demand. Short run changes in response to severe environmental stress will be sudden and energetically expensive and will rely on stress-induced unmasking of genetic variability and loss of canalization. Long run changes will be gradual, energetically less costly and less dependent on genetic correlations.     

Locomotor capacity and dominance in male lizards Lacerta monticola: a trade‐off between survival and reproductive success?

Trade-offs between reproduction and survival are important determinants of life-history characteristics of lizards. Organisms cannot increase the allocation of limited resources to reproduction without diverting a proportional amount of energy from another trait. Locomotor performance is an ecologically relevant trait that potentially influences survival by affecting the ability to escape from predators. Most studies have used female lizards as subjects because pregnancy is known to reduce their locomotor abilities, whereas little is known on costs of reproduction in males. In this study we suggest that in males of the lizard Lacerta monticola reproductive investment in morphological traits that confer dominance (i.e. head size) might lead to a low probability of survival by decreasing investment in other traits that affect locomotor performance (i.e. limb symmetry). We staged laboratory agonistic encounters between males and measured their morphology and burst speed on a race track to examine possible relationships between morphology, social dominance and locomotor capacity. Our results indicate that social dominance was positively related to relative head height, and that escape speed was negatively related to levels of fluctuating asymmetry in femur length, but also negatively related to relative head height. Males with greater relative head height also had more asymmetrical femurs, thus dominant males suffered a decrease in locomotor performance. Males with higher heads tend to dominate male–male interactions and hence may gain access to reproductive females, thus increasing their current reproduction success. However, this might occur at the expense of future survivorship mediated by a decrease in escape speed. Therefore, in male L. monticola there might be a trade-off between current reproductive success and survival.  © 2002 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2002; 77 , 201–209.     

Mandible asymmetry and genetic diversity in island populations of the common shrew, Sorex araneus

Mandibles from 13 island and six mainland populations of common shrews from the west coast of Scotland were subjected to geometric morphometric analysis in order to investigate the relationship between genetic diversity and fluctuating asymmetry. Although population mean shape fluctuating asymmetry (FA) and size FA were significantly inversely correlated with population genetic diversity this result was substantially due to one island. Sanda, the smallest island with by far the lowest genetic diversity, also had the highest FA. When Sanda was removed from the analysis, the relationship was not significant. There was no relationship between genetic diversity and FA at the individual level, whether measured as mean locus heterozygosity or d(2). In general, if genetic variation affects FA at all, the effect is weak and may only be of biological interest in very small populations.     

Zinc and cadmium accumulation in cabbage aphid (Brevicoryne brassicae) host plants and developmental instability

Developmental instability in morphological characters can occur during individual development due to various environmental stresses. Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) is often used as a measurement of developmental instability, but within-environment variation (CV_e) is also considered an indicator of developmental instability. Cabbage aphid ( Brevicoryne brassicae ) populations were reared on zinc- (Zn) or cadmium- (Cd) contaminated cabbage and radish plants. Developmental instability indicators were measured and their relations with fitness were explored. Results revealed that cabbage aphids exposed to Cd and Zn displayed considerable developmental instability, particularly fluctuating asymmetry. Differences in developmental instability between the two metals were also detected, as well as differences between the two developmental instability measurements. For almost all measured traits, FA was greater on Cd- and Zn-contaminated compared to non-contaminated host plants. In contrast, CV_e of some traits was greater on non-contaminated host plants, yet for other traits CV_e was greater on contaminated host plants. There were also non-significant inverse relationships between FA and fitness of cabbage aphid populations. Due to weak correlations between FA and different patterns of two developmental instability measurements, this study does not support the hypothesis that developmental instability is a useful bioindicator of environmental quality.     

The allometry of fluctuating asymmetry in southern African plants: flowers and leaves

Several studies of fluctuating asymmetry (FA) in animals show that secondary sexual characters used in signalling have a negative relationship between size and asymmetry. Larger sexual traits are presumably more costly to produce, which should lead to greater developmental stress and corresponding increases in asymmetry. In the absence of among individual variation in the ability to handle these costs, the relationship between size and asymmetry should thus be positive. A negative relationship therefore suggests that expression of these traits is condition-dependent. In plants, flowers act as signals for pollinators and may show similar trends to animal signals. Leaves which are uninvolved in signalling should not. Moller & Eriksson (1994) found that 89% of species ( n = 16 of 18) with insect-pollinated flowers showed a negative relationship between petal size and asymmetry, while 79% of species ( n = 15 of 19) showed a positive relationship between leaf size and asymmetry. I carried out a similar study of 18 plant species. The average relationship between petal size and asymmetry did not differ significantly from zero in those species showing measurable FA in flowers ( n = 12). The relationship was significantly negative in one species, and significandy positive in another. On average, leaves in species with FA did not show a significant positive relationship between size and asymmetry ( n = 7). There was no significant difference in the slopes of the relationship between size and asymmetry for leaves and flowers. Levels of floral asymmetry for species with FA were significandy repeatable on individual plants in 33% ( n = 4 of 12) of species, but leaf asymmetry was not significantly repeatable in any species. It is argued that condition-dependence of traits need not result in a negative relationship between size and asymmetry.