Neonatally induced tolerance to soluble protein antigens. I. Analysis of B-cell and T helper cell function in mice tolerant to bovine serum albumin or fowl gamma-globulin

High dose tolerance to either bovine serum albumin (BSA) or fowl γ-globulin (FGG) was induced in CBA mice by neonatal injection. Tolerance to BSA lasted about 9 weeks, and that to FGG, about 18 weeks. Splenic B-cell function was analyzed using quantitative in vivo assays and in vitro limiting dilution analysis. Tolerogen-specific IgM- and non-IgM-producing B cells are depleted at least threefold in the spleens of tolerant mice. Tolerogen-specific T-helper-cell function was examined by immunization with haptenated antigens. Analysis of the recovery from tolerance indicates that the return to normal function in the tolerogen-specific B-cell and T helper fractions coincides with the return to normal responsiveness by the whole animal.     

Induction of tolerance to syngeneic IgE in neonatal mice

We have previously shown that adult A/J mice are tolerant to syngeneic IgE at the level of T cells, but not B cells. T cells of mice are responsive until the age of 2 to 3 wk, which correlates with the time of appearance of serum IgE. Tolerance can be induced earlier by neonatal administration of IgE in saline. We report here that purified nonimmune adult B cells, but not T cells, can transfer the state of tolerance to neonatal mice. As few as 2 x 10(6) B cells are effective. If IgE-bearing or IgE-secreting cells prove to be responsible, the amount of cell-bound IgE that can induce tolerance must be very small. The results also indicate that suppressor T cells do not have a major role in maintenance of self-tolerance to IgE.     

Cellular events in tolerance. VII. Decrease in tolerant spleens of PFC precursors stimulated in vitro by specific antigen or mitogen.

Spleen cells from adult mice rendered tolerant to the fluorescein (FL) hapten (as FL-sheep γ-globulin) were analyzed at limiting dilution for the numbers of precursors stimulatable either by specific antigen (FL-polymerized flagellin; FL-POL) or by a polyclonal B-cell activator (E. coli lipopolysaccharide; LPS). As expected, the number of PFC presursors activated by FL-POL was reduced more than fourfold in the spleens of FL-tolerant mice compared to normal controls. In contrast, LPS was able to trigger equivalent numbers of “FL-specific” PFC precursors in both normal and tolerant spleens. However, the clones stimulated by LPS were predominantly the “low-avidity” precursors in FL-tolerant spleens as shown by plaque inhibition studies. In addition, after FL-gelatin enrichment of normal or tolerant spleen cells, which contain equal numbers of antigen-binding cells, we found that purified cells from tolerant mice were in fact reduced in the numbers of clonable precursors upon LPS stimulation. Two other B-cell mitogens, POL and PPD, also failed to activate PFC precursors from FL-gelatin-purified tolerant spleen cells. Our results suggest that some high-avidity clones may be functionally deleted even in adult B-cell tolerance as previously noted for neonatal tolerance.     

Immunologic tolerance to dinitrophenylated human gamma globulin induced via colostrum

Immunologic unresponsiveness or tolerance was induced in neonatal mice via colostrum by injection of dinitrophenylated human gamma globulin (DNP-HGG) into the mother on the day of birth. Unresponsiveness persisted in the neonates for at least 21 weeks. This longlasting tolerance appeared to be the result of an unresponsiveness to the carrier determinants. Hapten-specific B-cell tolerance was assessed in mice receiving high- or low-epitope-density tolerogen and it was observed that the low-epitope-density tolerogen (DNP₁HGG) resulted in carrier-specific tolerance only. Although mice tolerized with the high-epitope-density conjugates were found to be slightly hyporesponsive in their in vivo B-cell responses, their in vitro hapten-specific responses were normal. This tolerant state induced via colostrum was compared to tolerance induced in utero. This earlier contact with tolerogen resulted in more profound alterations in hapten-specific B-cell responses. An additional interesting finding was that the colostrally induced tolerant state was transmitted to the next generation.     

Neonatal tolerance induction to Mlsa. II. T cells induce tolerance to Mlsa

We have investigated the ability of murine T cell lines to induce neonatal tolerance to Mlsa (minor lymphocyte stimulating). Mlsb mice were injected within 24 hr of birth with MHC (major histocompatibility complex) identical T cell lines generated by culturing responders from Mlsa strains with stimulators from Mlsb strains. Injected mice were tested at 6 to 8 weeks of age for responses in either primary mixed leukocyte reaction or IL-2 limiting dilution analysis. Mlsa specific responses by injected tolerant mice relative to noninjected controls were reduced by 92-98% in MLR and by 2- to 10-fold in IL-2 LDA. In contrast, responses against third-party MHC antigens by either the injected or the noninjected mice were identical. Fifty percent of all mice injected with the T cell lines were tolerant to Mlsa. These results strongly suggest that murine T cells express the Mlsa gene product.     

Immunologic tolerance to HGG in mice. I. Suppression of the HGG response in normal mice with spleen cells or a spleen cell lysate from tolerant mice.

Adoptive transfer of spleen cells or spleen cell lysates from mice tolerant to human-gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppressed the response of normal syngeneic recipients to HGG. The suppressive activity could be transferred for over 100 days after tolerance induction. The suppression induced by both spleen cells and spleen cell lysate was found to be specific as evidenced by a normal response to a challenge with turkey-gamma-globulin or goat erythrocytes. The activity of the suppressive lysate could be removed by passing the material through an HGG immunoadsorbent column but not by passing it through an anti-HGG column or a BSA column. These results indicated that the factor had antigen specificity and was probably not antigen-antibody complexes. That this suppression was not due to a shifting of the kinetics of the antibody response has also been demonstrated. The antigen-specific suppressor factor in the tolerant spleen cell lysates was a protein with a m.w. of approximately 45,000 daltons. The kinetics of the appearance of both suppressor cells and suppressor factor were consistent with a mechanism of active suppression functioning in the maintenance of tolerance to HGG.     

Neonatal splenic suppressor cells in the chicken. I. In vivo suppression of the immune response to bovine serum albumin by normal and tolerized neonatal spleen cells

The presence of active splenic suppressor cells in neonatal chickens, either normal or tolerant to bovine serum albumin (BSA), was examined by assessment of their effect on both primary and adoptively transferred secondary responses to BSA or sheep red blood cells (SRC). Both normal and BSA tolerized spleen cells were shown to be highly suppressive of secondary anti-BSA responses generated by specifically primed adult spleen cells in inert recipients. Suppression of the secondary anti-BSA response by normal spleen cells was slightly less effective than that seen with BSA tolerant spleen cells. Transfer of BSA tolerant spleen cells into normal recipients, followed by BSA challenge, prevented any significant primary anti-BSA response. In contrast, transfer of normal spleen cells into normal recipients, followed by BSA challenge, failed to show any suppression of the resulting primary response. Neither normal nor BSA tolerant neonatal spleen cells were capable of suppressing either primary or secondary responses to SRC. Thus, chickens tolerized to BSA have suppressor cells specific for the tolerizing antigen. We present evidence that both the tolerance associated suppressors and the suppressors detected in normal neonatal chickens are T cells.     

Adaptive transfer of neonatally induced tolerance into normal mice

Neonatally induced tolerance in mice was adoptively transferred with living splenocytes into normal immunocompetent syngeneic adult recipients. It was also transferred passively with antisera from tolerant mice into syngeneic neonatal recipients. Immune splenocytes transferred anamnestic responsiveness rather than tolerance. No free antibody was detected by heat elution from tolerant spleen cells, but it was found in a form complexed with antigen and dissociable with acid. These results together with those reported in the accompanying paper on neonatal tolerance suggest a role for antibody in the induction and maintenance of this model of tolerance.     

Delayed hypersensitivity reaction to transplantation antigens in mice with induced tolerance for allo- and xenografts

The delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction (DTH) in mice tolerant to allo- and xenoantigens has been investigated. To induce tolerance adult mice were thymectomized and given 1 X 10(8) allogeneic or xenogeneic spleen cells and cyclophosphamide (200 mg/kg). Such mice failed to develop DTH to donor antigens, while DTH reaction to foreign allo- and xenoantigens was retained. Spleen cells of mice tolerant to alloantigens significantly suppressed the afferent and efferent DTH phases. The suppression was specific and T-cell-mediated. Spleen cells of mice tolerant to xenoantigens could suppress only the afferent DTH phase. The treatment of cells with anti-T-globulin and complement did not abrogate the suppression. The role of DTH suppressors in the induction and maintenance of transplantation tolerance is discussed.     

Tolerance induction during ontogeny. III. Carrier recognition by the immature and adult immune system determines tolerogenicity of hapten-carrier conjugates

Hapten-specific B-cell tolerance may be induced by nonimmunogenic hapten derivatives of carboxylmethylcellulose or methylcellulose (MC) in adult, neonatal, or irradiated fetal liver reconstituted mice. Such tolerance was shown to occur independent of T cells, and a receptor blockade has been ruled out as a causative mechanism. Oxidation and subsequent reduction of the vicinal hydroxyl groups of both carriers significantly reduces their tolerogenic potential in adult mice, yet their hapten derivatives remain nonimmunogenic. Such chemical modification of the carrier does not affect the molecular weight and not only does not reduce the binding avidity but increases it for either free antibody- or antigen-binding cells. We have examined the ability of the immature immune system to functionally discriminate between the nominal and the chemically modified hapten conjugate. Like adult mice, the immunologically immature animals were invariably capable of distinguishing between the tolerogenic and the nontolerogenic carrier. Mice treated during ontogenic development with 2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP)-MC were found to be hapten specifically tolerant when challenged at 4 weeks of age with the TI-2 antigen DNP-Ficoll (F) but not when challenged with the polyclonal activator lipopolysaccharide (LPS) or the TI-1 antigen DNP-Brucella. Moreover, neonatal mice treated for 8 weeks with 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl-ovalbumin (TNP-OVA) were hapten specifically tolerant when challenged with TNP-OVA or the TI-1 antigen TNP-LPS but responded to a challenge with the TI-2 antigen TNP-F. These data suggest that B-cell tolerance in adult as well as in immunologically immature mice is not only carrier dependent but, in addition, that the carrier selects the B subpopulation to be rendered unresponsive. The most popular version of the clonal abortion hypothesis puts no constraints upon the nature of the antigen as long as the B cell is ontogenically "predisposed" toward being rendered unresponsive upon contact with a ligand of sufficiently high binding avidity. Our data are at variance with this prediction.     

Neonatally induced tolerance to HGG: duration in B cells and absence of specific suppressor cells.

A specific, long lasting, tolerant state to human gamma-globulin (HCG) was established in neonatal A/J mice. These suckling mice received the tolerogen in the colostrum of their mother who had been injected with DHGG. The tolerant state could not be accounted for by "factors" other than HGG in the colostrum. The duration of this tolerance in the intact animal and in the B cell population was 16 to 18 weeks. Naturally occuring nonspecific suppressor cells were evident but specific suppressor cells could not be demonstrated. These results are discussed in relation to possible mechanisms of the induction of tolerance to self.     

Thymus dependency of neonatal tolerance induction in the absence of detectable suppressor cells

Neonatal thymectomy prevents tolerance induction with bovine serum albumin (BSA) in Wistar Furth (WF) rats whose thymus-derived (T) cell deficit is reconstituted with adult nonadherent peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL). Sham-thymectomized (STx) rats given PBL become tolerant. To establish whether the adult T cells become tolerant in STx rats, their carrier-reactivity was studied in a cooperative immune response following challenge with methylated BSA (mBSA). The results indicate that carrier-reactive cells, derived from PBL, do become tolerant of BSA in the presence, but not in the absence, of the thymus. To determine whether thymic function during tolerance induction is mediated by suppressor T cells, attempts were made to replace the thymus with various populations of thymocytes or lymphoid cells from neonatal or adult normal rats or neonatal BSA-injected rats. No cell population tried could substitute for the thymus during tolerance induction. In addition, it was found that BSA-tolerant rats with intact thymi do not contain either nonspecific suppressor cells whose activity can be boosted with mBSA or specific suppressor activity demonstrable on transfer to normal rats. Timed thymectomy experiments showed that the thymus is required for more than 2, but less than 5 to 7 days after tolerogen injection for significant tolerance induction. These results imply that the thymus itself is necessary for tolerance induction in a peripheral T-cell population and that its effect is not mediated by suppressor cells. It is suggested that peripheral T helper cells may periodically recirculate through the thymus, at least in young rats, and become tolerant of antigen complexed with Ia antigens in the thymic epithelium. Such a mechanism may be of great importance in the development of self-recognition.     

Cellular events in tolerance. VI. Neonatal vs adult B cell tolerance: differences in antigen-binding cell patterns and lipopolysaccharide stimulation.

The numbers and fate of antigen-binding cells (ABC) in neonatal and adult mice rendered tolerant to fluorescein (FL)-labeled heterologous gamma-globulins were studied. Similar numbers of FL-ABC were observed 1 day after tolerogen in both adult and neonatal mouse spleens: by 7 days after tolerization, no FL-ABC were observed in either case. Reinjection with FL-tolerogen at 7 days led to the detection of normal numbers of ABC in adult mice but significantly reduced numbers in neonates. This suggests that neonatal ABC either have been deleted or have failed to resynthesize surface receptors. Two weeks after tolerance induction, spleen cells from these tolerant mice were cultured with Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a polyclonal B cell mitogen, or with specific antigen. Tolerant adult spleen cells made an equivalent anti-FL response to that of the uninjected controls when stimulated with LPS, but were unresponsive to specific antigenic triggering. In contrast, spleen cells from neonatally tolerized mice were unresponsive to either specific or nonspecific (LPS) stimulation. Thus, these neonatally tolerized spleen cells lose sensitivity to polyclonal-stimulating agents (along with their receptors), or more simply, are deleted.     

Autoimmune syndrome after induction of neonatal tolerance to alloantigens: effects of in vivo treatment with anti-T cell subset monoclonal antibodies

BALB/c (H-2d) mice rendered tolerant to h-2b alloantigens by neonatal injection of semiallogeneic (C57BL/6 X BALB/c)F1 spleen cells develop autoimmune features due to an abnormal activation of persisting F1 donor B cells. The role of T cells in this autoimmune syndrome was studied by in vivo treatment of tolerant mice with anti-L3T4(GK-1.5) or anti-Ly-2 (H-35-17.2) monoclonal antibodies. The treatment of tolerant mice from day 2 to day 21 of life with anti-L3T4 MAb completely prevented the occurrence of circulating immune complexes of anti-ssDNA anti-Sm and anti-hapten (FITC) IgG antibodies as well as the glomerular deposition of Ig that were usually seen in untreated tolerant mice. This effect persisted for at least 6 wk after stopping this treatment. When the injections of anti-L3T4 MAb were delayed until day 15 of life, a very significant decrease of the autoimmune manifestations was still observed. Treatment of tolerant mice with anti-Ly-2 MAb during the same period had no effects on the autoimmune disease as compared with untreated tolerant mice. No effects on the maintenance of tolerance vs H-2b alloantigens were observed after treatment with anti-L3T4 MAb, as followed by the decrease of CTL and CTL-p alloreactivity and by the persistence of F1 donor B cells, indicated by the presence of Ig bearing the Ighb donor allotype. These results suggest the existence of interactions between L3T4+ T cells and persisting autoreactive B cells from F1 donor origin in the development of the autoimmune syndrome after neonatal induction of transplantation tolerance.     

Antigen-antibody complexes produced in chickens tolerant to bovine serum albumin.

A radioimmunoassay for circulating soluble antigen-antibody complexes is described. The assay detects complexes either in antigen or antibody excess. Soluble complexes were found in the sera of chickens tolerant to bovine serum albumin (BSA). The complexes appeared in the serum as soon as 7 days following neonatal induction of tolerance. The amount of complexes reached a peak between 1 to 2 weeks of age and disappeared by 6 weeks when responsiveness returned. The complexes were found in the bottom third of a 10 to 40% sucrose density gradient and by analytical ultracentrifugation indicated a size of 22.8S. If tolerant chickens were challenged with BSA at 2, 4 or 6 weeks, the disappearance of complexes was not accelerated, and a proportion of the previously tolerant chickens exhibited a heightened antibody response.     

Factors associated with the development of neonatal tolerance after the administration of a plasmid DNA vaccine

A plasmid DNA vaccine encoding the circumsporozoite protein of malaria (pCSP) induces tolerance rather than immunity when administered to newborn mice. We find that this tolerance persists for >1 yr after neonatal pCSP administration and interferes with the induction of protective immunity in animals challenged with live sporozoites. Susceptibility to tolerance induction wanes rapidly with age, disappearing within 1 wk of birth. Higher doses of plasmid are more tolerogenic, and susceptibility to tolerance is not MHC-restricted. CD8+ T cells from tolerant mice suppress the in vitro Ag-specific immune response of cells from adult mice immunized with pCSP. Similarly, CD8+ T cells from tolerant mice transfer nonresponsiveness to naive syngeneic recipients. These findings clarify the cellular basis and factors contributing to the development of DNA vaccine-induced neonatal tolerance.     

Suppressor cells in tolerance to HGG: kinetics and cross-suppression in high dose tolerance--absence in low dose tolerance.

Spleen cells from mice made tolerant with high doses of human gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppress the immune response of normal, syngeneic, spleen cells. These suppressor cells were found to be cross-reactive in that they would suppress the immune response of normal spleen cells to bovine gamma-globulin (BGG) as well as to HGG. In contrast, suppressor cells could not be demonstrated in spleens of mice made tolerant with low doses of HGG (i.e., T-cell tolerance), nor could they be found in high dose tolerant mice following a second injection of DHGG at a time when the initial suppressor activity had waned. The role of suppressor cells in the induction, maintenance, and loss of tolerance is discussed.     

Maturation of the lymphoid system. I. Induction of tolerance in neonates with a T-dependent antigen that is an obligate immunogen in adults.

A/J mice displayed a striking ontogenetic difference in the capacity to respond to DNP-Ficoll, a T-independent antigen, and to aggregated human gamma-globulin (AHGG), a T-dependent antigen. Thus, whereas responses to DNP-Ficoll of 4-day-old mice were similar in magnitude to those of adult animals, responses to AHGG did not become pronounced until mice were some 30 to 40 days of age. The inability of young animals to respond to AHGG was reflective of a negative consequence of lymphocyte/antigen interaction, since such mice became specifically unresponsive to subsequent challenges with AHGG. Unresponsiveness induced by neonatal injection of AHGG lasted 50 to 60 days, in contrast to that induced by deaggregated HGG, which persisted some 100 days longer. The unresponsive state induced by injection of neonates with AHGG maintained itself upon adoptive transfer and did not appear to be linked to suppressive factors associated with either serum or lymphoid cells for its maintenance. Finally, AHGG was also shown to be capable of inducing unresponsiveness in neonatal, athymic mice. These results demonstrate that AHGG, the normally immunogenic form of HGG in adult mice, can serve as an effective tolerogen when administered into a neonatal environment.     

Cellular events in tolerance IX: Maintenance of immunological tolerance in the presence of normal B-cell precursors and in the absence of demonstrable suppression

The cellular events involved in immunological tolerance to fluoresceinated sheep gammaglobulin (FL-SGG) were analyzed at the level of hapten-specific B cells. One single iv injection of FL-SGG induced tolerance as measured by challenge with thymus-dependent (FL-KLH) or thymus-independent (FL-Ficoll) antigens in vivo or thymus-independent (FL-LPS) antigen in vitro. As noted earlier, unresponsiveness was maintained until 6–8 weeks after tolerance induction. Limiting-dilution precursor analysis demonstrated a reduction in B-cell precursors on Day 7 after tolerogen treatment; precursor frequencies returned to control levels by 3–4 weeks. This recovery of precursors in the presence of stable tolerance was not due to suppressor activity. Rather, results show that tolerant hapten-specific B cells are clonally anergic and display a reduced burst size in response to antigen. Hence, unresponsiveness is maintained in the presence of apparently normal precursor levels by an intrinsic defect in antigen-specific B cells.     

Induction and mechanism of tolerance to bovine serum albumin in mice given total lymphoid irradiation (TLI).

BALB/c mice given total lymphoid irradiations (TLI) were injected i.p. with bovine serum albumin (BSA) in saline, and challenged with DNP-BSA in complete Freund's adjuvant 6 weeks later. The latter animals made no anti-DNP antibody response as measured by a modified Farr assay, but made a normal anti-DNP response after challenge with DNP-BGG in adjuvant. Normal mice or mice given whole body irradiation were not tolerized by the i.p. injection of BSA in saline. Spleen cells from unresponsive mice (TLI + BSA in saline) suppressed the adoptive secondary anti-DNP response of sublethally irradiated syngeneic hosts given BSA-primed T cells, DNP-BSA-primed B cells, and DNP-BSA in saline. The suppressor cells were antigen specific, and were inactivated by in vitro treatment with anti-Thy 1.2 antiserum and complement. The findings suggest that soluble antigens administered to mice after TLI evoke a state of tolerance that is maintained by antigen-specific suppressor T cells. A similar mechanism may be involved in the maintenance of tolerance to allografts. These findings may have important clinical implications for patients treated with TLI for lymphoid malignancies.