Global allostery model of hemoglobin. Modulation of O(2) affinity,cooperativity, and Bohr effect by heterotropic allosteric effectors

The O(2) equilibria of human adult hemoglobin have been measured in a wide range of solution conditions in the presence and absence of various allosteric effectors in order to determine how far hemoglobin can modulate its O(2) affinity. The O(2) affinity, cooperative behavior, and the Bohr effect of hemoglobin are modulated principally by tertiary structural changes, which are induced by its interactions with heterotropic allosteric effectors. In their absence, hemoglobin is a high affinity, moderately cooperative O(2) carrier of limited functional flexibility, the behaviors of which are regulated by the homotropic, O(2)-linked T/R quaternary structural transition of the Monod-Wyman-Changeux/Perutz model. However, the interactions with allosteric effectors provide such "inert" hemoglobin unprecedented magnitudes of functional diversities not only of physiological relevance but also of extreme nature, by which hemoglobin can behave energetically beyond what can be explained by the Monod-Wyman-Changeux/Perutz model. Thus, the heterotropic effector-linked tertiary structural changes rather than the homotropic ligation-linked T/R quaternary structural transition are energetically more significant and primarily responsible for modulation of functions of hemoglobin.     

Tertiary and quaternary effects in the allosteric regulation of animal hemoglobins

In the last decade, protein allostery has experienced a major resurgence, boosted by the extension of the concept to systems of increasing complexity and by its exploitation for the development of drugs. Expansion of the field into new directions has not diminished the key role of hemoglobin as a test molecule for theory and experimental validation of allosteric models. Indeed, the diffusion of hemoglobins in all kingdoms of life and the variety of functions and of quaternary assemblies based on a common tertiary fold indicate that this superfamily of proteins is ideally suited for investigating the physical and molecular basis of allostery and firmly maintains its role as a main player in the field. This review is an attempt to briefly recollect common and different strategies adopted by metazoan hemoglobins, from monomeric molecules to giant complexes, exploiting homotropic and heterotropic allostery to increase their functional dynamic range. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Oxygen Binding and Sensing Proteins.     

The structure of hemoglobin Creteil (beta 89 Ser replaced by Asn) is similar to that of abnormal human hemoglobins having sequence changes at Tyr 145 beta

In normal deoxyhemoglobin A, the beta chain COOH-terminal peptide adopts a well ordered structure which is needed for the full expression of allosteric action. Our crystallographic studies of deoxyhemoglobin Creteil (beta 89 Ser replaced by Asn), a variant hemoglobin characterized by high oxygen affinity and a very low level of allosteric function, show that replacement of Ser 89 beta by asparagine causes severe disordering of the beta chain COOH-terminal tetrapeptide. This results, as shown by our spectroscopic studies, in the destabilization of the quaternary structure of deoxyhemoglobin Creteil. We find, furthermore, that the changes in tertiary structure observed in deoxyhemoglobin Creteil are common to other variant hemoglobins having similar functional abnormalities but very different changes in primary structure. In particular, direct comparison of the difference electron density map of deoxyhemoglobin Creteil with that of deoxyhemoglobin Nancy (beta 145 Tyr replaced by Asp) suggests that these two abnormal hemoglobins may have the same mechanism of dysfunction despite the very different nature of their respective sequence changes.     

Effect of aromatic isothiocyanates on the functional properties of human hemoglobin. Role of the stereochemistry of the charged group

The effect of chemical modification of hemoglobin with six derivatives of benzene isothiocyanate has been studied. The negatively charged reagents (isothiocyanates of benzoic and benzenesulfonic acids) markedly inhibit the interaction of hemoglobin with allosteric effectors such as H+, Cl- and organic phosphates; the affinity for heme ligands in the absence of effectors is reduced but cooperativity is maintained, making these modified hemoglobins suitable models for a possible 'blood substitute'. The only uncharged reagent tested (isothiocyanate of benzenesulfonamide) increases the oxygen affinity of hemoglobin and affects only slightly the interaction with heterotropic ligands; its potential use as an antisickling drug is under study.     

Gas exchange properties of goat hemoglobins A and C

Hypoxic or anemic goats with the A hemoglobin genotype switch to the production of hemoglobin C, resulting in a reduced blood oxygen affinity. However, the physiologic consequences of this switch are not clear. We therefore studied the gas exchange properties of the two hemoglobin types. We found that purified hemoglobins A and C have very similar oxygen affinities and H+ Bohr effects, but in the presence of CO2, the affinity of hemoglobin C is substantially less than that of hemoglobin A. That this is not a nonspecific ionic effect is suggested by identical effects of NaCl on O2 binding to the two proteins and by a 2-fold higher capacity of hemoglobin C to bind CO2. The data can be explained by a class of CO2 binding sites in the beta C chain whose affinity is much higher than that of either of the primary sites or of those in Hb A. Our results suggest that in hemoglobin C-containing red cells CO2 acts as a potent allosteric effector, analogous to the role played by 2,3-diphosphoglycerate in human red blood cells. Goat hemoglobin C may have advantages over hemoglobins A or B in O2 transport under hypoxic conditions or in anemia.     

Structural and thermodynamic aspects of cooperativity in the homodimeric hemoglobin from Scapharca inaequivalvis

The homodimeric cooperative hemoglobin from the mollusk Scapharca inaequivalvis displays an unusual subunit assembly with respect to vertebrate hemoglobins. The intersubunit contact region is formed by the two heme-carrying E and F helices, which bring the two hemes in contact with each other. At variance with tetrameric vertebrate hemoglobins, the ligand binding is not accompanied by a significant quaternary transition. The major ligand-linked changes are tertiary and are limited to the heme pocket and subunit interface. These unique structural features of HbI are not easily reconciled with the classical thermodynamic models used to describe cooperative ligand binding in vertebrate hemoglobins. The lack of distinct quaternary states and the absence of allosteric effectors suggested that cooperativity in HbI is entirely homotropic in origin. Thereafter, high resolution X-ray crystallographic data displayed the preferential binding of water molecules at the intersubunit interface in the unliganded protein with respect to the liganded one. These ordered water molecules were thus proposed to act as heterotropic effectors in HbI. The contribution of specific water binding to the observed cooperativity in HbI is discussed in the framework of the enthalpy-entropy compensation effect emerging from previous accurate equilibrium oxygen binding measurements.     

Linked functions in allosteric proteins: Extension of the concerted (MWC) model for ligand-linked subunit assembly and its application to human hemoglobins

The allosteric model of Monod et al. (1965) (MWC) has been extended to take into account the effects of subunit dissociation. The problem is formulated theoretically in terms of a general model for two allosteric species (dimers and tetramers) linked by a polymerization reaction. Relationships are presented for interpreting the dimer-tetramer association constants in terms of allosteric model parameters.Sub-cases of the general model were tested against recent experimental data on the oxygenation-linked dimer-tetramer equilibria in normal human hemoglobin and in the variant hemoglobin Kansas (β₁₀₂, Asp → Thr). The objectives of these analyses were: (1) to find the simplest models capable of describing the linked dimer-tetramer equilibria in the two hemoglobin systems, and (2) to evaluate the corresponding model parameters so that allosteric properties of the two hemoglobins may be compared.In the simplest version of the model, the dimer is half of an R-state tetramer. This model was found to be excluded unequivocally by the data for both normal hemoglobin and hemoglobin Kansas when the α and β chains have equal binding affinities. When this two-state model was modified to permit non-equivalent affinities for the chains, the model could be fitted to hemoglobin Kansas, but not to hemoglobin A. A model, in which the dimers are allowed to exist in a state different from the tetramer R state, was found to be consistent with the data for hemoglobin A, with equivalent binding by the α and β chains. For hemoglobin A, the unliganded R-state tetramers have a different subunit dissociation energy from that of fully liganded R-state tetramers. The simplest model capable of describing both hemoglobin A and hemoglobin Kansas was obtained by extending this three-state model to permit (but not require) functional non-equivalence of the α and β chains. For these MWC models, unique estimates were obtained for the model parameters.The allosteric constants for tetrameric hemoglobins A and Kansas are approximately equal. The value obtained from hemoglobin A is similar to previous estimates, whereas the value for hemoglobin Kansas is lower than previously estimated (Edelstein, 1971) by approximately two orders of magnitude. The low affinity of hemoglobin Kansas tetramer does not arise from an unusually high allosteric constant favoring the T-state species. It is largely the consequence of a greatly reduced oxygen affinity of β chains in the T state, and reduced values for the ratio between affinities in the R and T states.     

Study of the conversion of GDP-mannose into GDP-fucose in Nereids: a biochemical marker of oocyte maturation

The high-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of carp hemoglobin have been compared to those of human normal adult hemoglobin. Carp deoxy and carbonmonoxy hemoglobins in the deoxy-type quaternary state exhibit two downfield exchangeable proton resonances as compared to four seen in human normal adult deoxyhemoglobin. This suggests that two of the hydrogen bonds present in human normal adult deoxyhemoglobin are absent or occur in very different environments in carp hemoglobin. One of the exchangeable proton resonances of carp hemoglobin, while present in the deoxy-type quaternary state of the carbonmonoxy and deoxy derivatives, is absent in the oxy-type quaternary state of both, in agreement with the assignments of these quaternary structures by other methods. The ring-current-shifted proton resonances (sensitive tertiary structural markers) of carp carbonmonoxyhemoglobin are substantially different from those of human normal adult hemoglobin. The aromatic proton resonance region of carp hemoglobin has fewer resonances than that of human normal adult hemoglobin, consistent with its much reduced histidine content. The hyperfine-shifted proximal histidyl NH-exchangeable proton resonances of carp hemoglobin suggest that during the transition from the oxy to the deoxy quaternary structure, there is a greater alteration in the heme pocket of one type of subunits (presumably the beta chain) than that in the other subunit. The present results suggest that there are differences in both tertiary and quaternary structures between carp and human normal adult hemoglobins which could contribute to the great differences in the functional properties between these two proteins.     

Novel mechanisms of pH sensitivity in tuna hemoglobin: a structural explanation of the root effect

The crystal structure of hemoglobin has been known for several decades, yet various features of the molecule remain unexplained or controversial. Several animal hemoglobins have properties that cannot be readily explained in terms of their amino acid sequence and known atomic models of hemoglobin. Among these, fish hemoglobins are well known for their widely varying interactions with heterotropic effector molecules and pH sensitivity. Some fish hemoglobins are almost completely insensitive to pH (within physiological limits), whereas others show extremely low oxygen affinity under acid conditions, a phenomenon called the Root effect. X-ray crystal structures of Root effect hemoglobins have not, to date, provided convincing explanations of this effect. Sequence alignments have signally failed to pinpoint the residues involved, and site-directed mutagenesis has not yielded a human hemoglobin variant with this property. We have solved the crystal structure of tuna hemoglobin in the deoxy form at low and moderate pH and in the presence of carbon monoxide at high pH. A comparison of these models shows clear evidence for novel mechanisms of pH-dependent control of ligand affinity.     

The stepwise mutation model: an experimental evaluation utilizing hemoglobin variants

The stepwise mutation model of Ohta and Kimura (1973) was proposed to explain patterns of genetic variability revealed by means of electrophoresis. The assumption that electrophoretic mobility was principally determined by unit changes in net molecular charge has been criticized by Johnson (1974, 1977). This assumption has been tested directly using hemoglobin. Twenty-seven human hemoglobin variants with known amino acid substitutions, and 26 nonhuman hemoglobins with known sequences were studied by starch gel electrophoresis. Of these hemoglobins, 60 to 70% had electrophoretic mobilities that could be predicted solely on the basis of net charge calculated from the amino acid composition alone, ignoring tertiary structure. Only four hemoglobins showed a mobility that was clearly different from an expected mobility calculated using only the net charge of the molecule. For the remaining 30% of hemoglobins studied, mobility was determined by a combination of net charge and other unidentified components, probably reflecting changes in ionization of some amino acid residues as a result of small alterations in tertiary structure due to the amino acid substitution in the variant. For the nonhuman hemoglobins, the deviation of a sample from its expected mobility increased with increasing amino acid divergence from human hemoglobin A.-It is concluded that the net electrostatic charge of a molecule is the principal determinant of electrophoretic mobility under the conditions studied. However, because of the significant deviation from strict stepwise mobility detected for 30 to 40% of the variants studied, it is further concluded that the infinite-allele model of Kimura and Crow (1964) or a "mixed model" such as that proposed by Li (1976) may be more appropriate than the stepwise mutation model for the analysis of much of the available electrophoretic data from natural populations.     

Hemoglobin from the Antarctic fish Notothenia coriiceps neglecta. 1. Purification and characterisation

Antarctic fishes live at a constant temperature of -1.8 degrees C, in an oxygen-rich environment. In comparison with fishes that live in temperate or tropical waters, their blood contains less erythrocytes and hemoglobin. A study was initiated on the structure and function of Antarctic fish hemoglobin. The erythrocytes of the Antarctic benthic teleost Notothenia coriiceps neglecta, of the family Nototheniidae, have been shown to contain two hemoglobins, accounting for about 90% and 5% of the total content. These hemoglobins have been isolated, and obtained in crystalline form. They are tetramers and contain two pairs of globin chains. The globin chains of each hemoglobin have been purified and characterised. The two hemoglobins appear to have one of the two globin chains in common. The Root and Bohr effects have been investigated in erythrocytes, 'stripped' hemolysates and pure hemoglobins, indicating that the functional properties are finely regulated by pH and allosteric effectors.     

Amino acid sequence of alpha-chain of hemoglobin IV from trout (Salmo irideus)

The amino acid sequence of the alpha-chain of trout hemoglobin (Hb) IV is given, thus completing the primary structure of the hemoglobin component of trout's blood characterized by the Root effect. The trout Hb IV alpha-chain consists of 142 amino acid residues; comparison with the corresponding sequences from human and carp hemoglobins shows differences of 50.0 and 35.9%, respectively. A difference of 39.6% is found with the alpha-chain of trout Hb I, the other major hemoglobin component of trout blood, devoid of heterotropic effects.     

Allosteric effect of water in fish and human hemoglobins

Prompted by the reported lack of solvation effects on the oxygen affinity of fish (trout I) hemoglobin that questioned allosteric water binding in human hemoglobin A (Bellelli, A., Brancaccio, A., and Brunori, M. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 4742-4744), we have investigated solvation effects in fish and human hemoglobins by means of the osmotic stress method and allosteric analysis. In contrast to the earlier report, we demonstrate that water potential does affect oxygen affinity of trout hemoglobin I in the presence of inert solutes like betaine. Moreover, we show that upon oxygenation electrophoretically anodic hemoglobin from trout and eel bind a similar number of water molecules as does human hemoglobin A, whereas the cathodic hemoglobins of trout and eel bind smaller, but mutually similar, numbers of water molecules. Addition of cofactors strongly increases the number of water molecules bound to eel hemoglobin A (as in human hemoglobin) but only weakly affects water binding to eel hemoglobin C.     

Increased oxygen affinity with normal heterotropic effects in hemoglobin Loire [alpha 88(F9)Ala----Ser]

Increased homotropic allosteric effect, while maintaining normal heterotropic effects, was observed in hemoglobin Loire. The oxygen binding curves, at equilibrium, and the kinetic measurements demonstrated that the substitution of alpha 88(F9) Ala for a Ser results in increased oxygen affinity and decreased n50 value. The function of the residues involved in the Bohr effect or in the regulation by 2,3-bisphosphoglycerate is not altered. The effects of bezafibrate, which binds specifically to the alpha chains, was similar to that observed in Hb A. The functional properties of Hb Loire may be explained by a slight displacement of some key residues of the C-terminal region of the alpha chain destabilizing the T structure.     

Ligand-dependent Bohr effect of Chrionomus hemoglobins.

The O2 and CO Bohr effects of monomeric and dimeric hemoglobins of the insect Chironomus thummi thummi were determined as proton releases upon ligation. For the O2 Bohr effect of the monomeric hemoglobin III a maximum value of 0.20 H+/heme was obtained at pH 7.5. Upon ligation with CO, however, only 0.04 H+/heme were released at the same pH. In agreement with this finding isoelectric focusing experiments revealed different isoelectric points for O2-liganded and CO-liganded states of hemoglobin III. Analogous results were obtained in the cases of the monomeric hemoglobin IV and the dimeric hemoglobins of Chironomus thummi thummi; here O2 Bohr effects of 0.43 and 0.86 H+/heme were observed. For the corresponding CO Bohr effects values of 0.08 and 0.31 H+/heme were obtained respectively. On the basis of the available structural data the reduced CO Bohr effect in hemoglobin III is discussed as arising from a steric hindrance of the CO ligand by the side chain of isoleucine-E11, obstructing the movement of the heme-iron upon reaction with carbon monoxide. It should, however, be noted that ligands, according to their different electron donor and acceptor properties, may generally induce different conformational changes and thus different Bohr effects, in those hemoglobins in which distinct tertiary and/or quaternary constraints have not evolved. The general utilization of CO instead of O2 as allosteric effector is ruled out by the results reported here.     

The crystal structure of bar-headed goose hemoglobin in deoxy form: the allosteric mechanism of a hemoglobin species with high oxygen affinity

The crystal structure of a high oxygen affinity species of hemoglobin, bar-headed goose hemoglobin in deoxy form, has been determined to a resolution of 2.8 A. The R and R(free) factor of the model are 0.197 and 0.243, respectively. The structure reported here is a special deoxy state of hemoglobin and indicates the differences in allosteric mechanisms between the goose and human hemoglobins. The quaternary structure of the goose deoxy hemoglobin shows obvious differences from that of human deoxy hemoglobin. The rotation angle of one alphabeta dimer relative to its partner in a tetramer molecule from the goose oxy to deoxy hemoglobin is only 4.6 degrees, and the translation is only 0.3 A, which are much smaller than those in human hemoglobin. In the alpha(1)beta(2) switch region of the goose deoxy hemoglobin, the imidazole ring of His beta(2)97 does not span the side-chain of Thr alpha(1)41 relative to the oxy hemoglobin as in human hemoglobin. And the tertiary structure changes of heme pocket and FG corner are also smaller than that in human hemoglobin. A unique mutation among avian and mammalian Hbs of alpha119 from proline to alanine at the alpha(1)beta(1 )interface in bar-headed goose hemoglobin brings a gap between Ala alpha119 and Leu beta55, the minimum distance between the two residues is 4.66 A. At the entrance to the central cavity around the molecular dyad, some residues of two beta chains form a positively charged groove where the inositol pentaphosphate binds to the hemoglobin. The His beta146 is at the inositol pentaphosphate binding site and the salt-bridge between His beta146 and Asp beta94 does not exist in the deoxy hemoglobin, which brings the weak chloride-independent Bohr effect to bar-headed goose hemoglobin.     

A resonance Raman study of Ambystoma tigrinum hemoglobins: evidence for intraspecies hemepocket variations

Using resonance Raman difference spectroscopy, the Raman-active vibrational modes of hemoglobins from adult, neotenic, and larval forms of the salamander, Ambystoma tigrinum have been compared to each other and to human hemoglobin. The local heme environment of the adult and neotenic proteins were identical and differed from that of the larval protein. Differences were observed in modes sensitive to porphyrin pi electron density and axial ligation. Systematic differences were also observed between human and adult salamander hemoglobins particularly in modes sensitive to the heme vinyl environment. The relationship between these environmental differences, oxygen binding affinity, and the effects of allosteric modulators are discussed.