The Fbx4 tumor suppressor regulates cyclin D1 accumulation and prevents neoplastic transformation

Skp1-Cul1-F-box (SCF) E3 ubiquitin ligase complexes modulate the accumulation of key cell cycle regulatory proteins. Following the G(1)/S transition, SCF(Fbx4) targets cyclin D1 for proteasomal degradation, a critical event necessary for DNA replication fidelity. Deregulated cyclin D1 drives tumorigenesis, and inactivating mutations in Fbx4 have been identified in human cancer, suggesting that Fbx4 may function as a tumor suppressor. Fbx4(+/-) and Fbx4(-/-) mice succumb to multiple tumor phenotypes, including lymphomas, histiocytic sarcomas and, less frequently, mammary and hepatocellular carcinomas. Tumors and premalignant tissue from Fbx4(+/-) and Fbx4(-/-) mice exhibit elevated cyclin D1, an observation consistent with cyclin D1 as a target of Fbx4. Molecular dissection of the Fbx4 regulatory network in murine embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) revealed that loss of Fbx4 results in cyclin D1 stabilization and nuclear accumulation throughout cell division. Increased proliferation in early passage primary MEFs is antagonized by DNA damage checkpoint activation, consistent with nuclear cyclin D1-driven genomic instability. Furthermore, Fbx4(-/-) MEFs exhibited increased susceptibility to Ras-dependent transformation in vitro, analogous to tumorigenesis observed in mice. Collectively, these data reveal a requisite role for the SCF(Fbx4) E3 ubiquitin ligase in regulating cyclin D1 accumulation, consistent with tumor suppressive function in vivo.     

Alternative splicing variants of human Fbx4 disturb cyclin D1 proteolysis in human cancer

Fbx4 is a specific substrate recognition component of SCF ubiquitin ligases that catalyzes the ubiquitination and subsequent degradation of cyclin D1 and Trx1. Two isoforms of human Fbx4 protein, the full length Fbx4α and the C-terminal truncated Fbx4β have been identified, but their functions remain elusive. In this study, we demonstrated that the mRNA level of Fbx4 was significantly lower in hepatocellular carcinoma tissues than that in the corresponding non-tumor tissues. More importantly, we identified three novel splicing variants of Fbx4: Fbx4γ (missing 168–245nt of exon1), Fbx4δ (missing exon6) and a N-terminal reading frame shift variant (missing exon2). Using cloning sequencing and RT-PCR, we demonstrated these novel splice variants are much more abundant in human cancer tissues and cell lines than that in normal tissues. When expressed in Sk-Hep1 and NIH3T3 cell lines, Fbx4β, Fbx4γ and Fbx4δ could promote cell proliferation and migration in vitro. Concordantly, these isoforms could disrupt cyclin D1 degradation and therefore increase cyclin D1 expression. Moreover, unlike the full-length isoform Fbx4α that mainly exists in cytoplasm, Fbx4β, Fbx4γ, and Fbx4δ locate in both cytoplasm and nucleus. Since cyclin D1 degradation takes place in cytoplasm, the nuclear distribution of these Fbx4 isoforms may not be involved in the down-regulation of cytoplasmic cyclin D1. These results define the impact of alternative splicing on Fbx4 function, and suggest that the attenuated cyclin D1 degradation by these novel Fbx4 isoforms provides a new insight for aberrant cyclin D1 expression in human cancers.     

Genotoxic stress-induced cyclin D1 phosphorylation and proteolysis are required for genomic stability

While mitogenic induction of cyclin D1 contributes to cell cycle progression, ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis buffers this accumulation and prevents aberrant proliferation. Because the failure to degrade cyclin D1 during S-phase triggers DNA rereplication, we have investigated cellular regulation of cyclin D1 following genotoxic stress. These data reveal that expression of cyclin D1 alleles refractory to phosphorylation- and ubiquitin-mediated degradation increase the frequency of chromatid breaks following DNA damage. Double-strand break-dependent cyclin D1 degradation requires ATM and GSK3β, which in turn mediate cyclin D1 phosphorylation. Phosphorylated cyclin D1 is targeted for proteasomal degradation after ubiquitylation by SCF^{Fbx4-αBcrystallin}. Loss of Fbx4-dependent degradation triggers radio-resistant DNA synthesis, thereby sensitizing cells to S-phase-specific chemotherapeutic intervention. These data suggest that failure to degrade cyclin D1 compromises the intra-S-phase checkpoint and suggest that cyclin D1 degradation is a vital cellular response necessary to prevent genomic instability following genotoxic insult.     

Atypical regulation of a green lineage-specific B-type cyclin-dependent kinase

Cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) are the main regulators of cell cycle progression in eukaryotes. The role and regulation of canonical CDKs, such as the yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) Cdc2 or plant CDKA, have been extensively characterized. However, the function of the plant-specific CDKB is not as well understood. Besides being involved in cell cycle control, Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) CDKB would integrate developmental processes to cell cycle progression. We investigated the role of CDKB in Ostreococcus (Ostreococcus tauri), a unicellular green algae with a minimal set of cell cycle genes. In this primitive alga, at the basis of the green lineage, CDKB has integrated two levels of regulations: It is regulated by Tyr phosphorylation like cdc2/CDKA and at the level of synthesis-like B-type CDKs. Furthermore, Ostreococcus CDKB/cyclin B accounts for the main peak of mitotic activity, and CDKB is able to rescue a yeast cdc28(ts) mutant. By contrast, Ostreococcus CDKA is not regulated by Tyr phosphorylation, and it exhibits a low and steady-state activity from DNA replication to exit of mitosis. This suggests that from a major role in the control of mitosis in green algae, CDKB has evolved in higher plants to assume other functions outside the cell cycle.     

Distinct roles for cyclins E and A during DNA replication complex assembly and activation

Initiation of DNA replication is regulated by cyclin-dependent protein kinase 2 (Cdk2) in association with two different regulatory subunits, cyclin A and cyclin E (reviewed in ref. 1). But why two different cyclins are required and why their order of activation is tightly regulated are unknown. Using a cell-free system for initiation of DNA replication that is based on G1 nuclei, G1 cytosol and recombinant proteins, we find that cyclins E and A have specialized roles during the transition from G0 to S phase. Cyclin E stimulates replication complex assembly by cooperating with Cdc6, to make G1 nuclei competent to replicate in vitro. Cyclin A has two separable functions: it activates DNA synthesis by replication complexes that are already assembled, and it inhibits the assembly of new complexes. Thus, cyclin E opens a 'window of opportunity' for replication complex assembly that is closed by cyclin A. The dual functions of cyclin A ensure that the assembly phase (G1) ends before DNA synthesis (S) begins, thereby preventing re-initiation until the next cell cycle.     

Speeding through cell cycle roadblocks: Nuclear cyclin D1-dependent kinase and neoplastic transformation

Mitogenic induction of cyclin D1, the allosteric regulator of CDK4/6, is a key regulatory event contributing to G1 phase progression. Following the G1/S transition, cyclin D1 activation is antagonized by GSK3β-dependent threonine-286 (Thr-286) phosphorylation, triggering nuclear export and subsequent cytoplasmic degradation mediated by the SCF^{Fbx4-αBcrystallin} E3 ubiquitin ligase. Although cyclin D1 overexpression occurs in numerous malignancies, overexpression of cyclin D1 alone is insufficient to drive transformation. In contrast, cyclin D1 mutants refractory to phosphorylation-dependent nuclear export and degradation are acutely transforming. This raises the question of whether overexpression of cyclin D1 is a significant contributor to tumorigenesis or an effect of neoplastic transformation. Significantly, recent work strongly supports a model wherein nuclear accumulation of cyclin D1-dependent kinase during S-phase is a critical event with regard to transformation. The identification of mutations within SCF^{Fbx4-αBcrystallin} ligase in primary tumors provides mechanistic insight into cyclin D1 accumulation in human cancer. Furthermore, analysis of mouse models expressing cyclin D1 mutants refractory to degradation indicate that nuclear cyclin D1/CDK4 kinase triggers DNA re-replication and genomic instability. Collectively, these new findings provide a mechanism whereby aberrations in post-translational regulation of cyclin D1 establish a cellular environment conducive to mutations that favor neoplastic growth.     

Cyclin D1 Inhibits Cell Proliferation through Binding to PCNA and Cdk2

Cyclin D1 is known as a promoting factor for cell growth. We previously showed, however, that the expression of cyclin D1 increases markedly in senescent human fibroblastsin vitro.Here we investigate whether the overexpression of cyclin D1 inhibits cell proliferation. Colony formation after transfection with the cyclin D1 expression vector was repressed in NIH-3T3, TIG-1, CHO-K1, and HeLa cells, compared with those with mock and cyclin E expression vectors. A transient transfection assay demonstrated that the overexpression of cyclin D1 inhibited DNA synthesis of TIG-1 cells. The complexes of cyclin D1 with PCNA and cdk2 increased remarkably in senescent cells, compared with young counterparts. Excessive glutathioneS-transferase (GST)–cyclin D1 inhibited DNA replication and repressed cdk2-dependent kinase activityin vitro.DNA synthesis of NIH-3T3 transfectants with PCNA or cdk2 expression vectors was not inhibited by the overexpression of cyclin D1. These results indicate that an excessive level of cyclin D1 represses cell proliferation by inhibiting DNA replication and cdk2 activity through the binding of cyclin D1 to PCNA and cdk2, as it does in senescent cells.     

Early events in DNA replication require cyclin E and are blocked by p21CIP1

Using immunodepletion of cyclin E and the inhibitor protein p21WAF/CIP1, we demonstrate that the cyclin E protein, in association with Cdk2, is required for the elongation phase of replication on single-stranded substrates. Although cyclin E/Cdk2 is likely to be the major target by which p21 inhibits the initiation of sperm DNA replication, p21 can inhibit single-stranded replication through a mechanism dependent on PCNA. While the cyclin E/Cdk2 complex appears to have a role in the initiation of DNA replication, another Cdk kinase, possibly cyclin A/Cdk, may be involved in a later step controlling the switch from initiation to elongation. The provision of a large maternal pool of cyclin E protein shows that regulators of replication are constitutively present, which explains the lack of a protein synthesis requirement for replication in the early embryonic cell cycle.     

Rad52 recruitment is DNA replication independent and regulated by Cdc28 and the Mec1 kinase

Recruitment of the homologous recombination machinery to sites of double‐strand breaks is a cell cycle‐regulated event requiring entry into S phase and CDK1 activity. Here, we demonstrate that the central recombination protein, Rad52, forms foci independent of DNA replication, and its recruitment requires B‐type cyclin/CDK1 activity. Induction of the intra‐S‐phase checkpoint by hydroxyurea (HU) inhibits Rad52 focus formation in response to ionizing radiation. This inhibition is dependent upon Mec1/Tel1 kinase activity, as HU‐treated cells form Rad52 foci in the presence of the PI3 kinase inhibitor caffeine. These Rad52 foci colocalize with foci formed by the replication clamp PCNA. These results indicate that Mec1 activity inhibits the recruitment of Rad52 to both sites of DNA damage and stalled replication forks during the intra‐S‐phase checkpoint. We propose that B‐type cyclins promote the recruitment of Rad52 to sites of DNA damage, whereas Mec1 inhibits spurious recombination at stalled replication forks.     

Targeting the checkpoint kinase Chk1 in cancer therapy

A paramount objective of the eukaryotic cell division cycle is to overcome numerous internal and external insults to faithfully duplicate the genetic information once per every cycle. This is carried out by elaborate networks of genome surveillance signaling pathways, termed replication checkpoints. Central to replication checkpoints are two protein kinases, the upstream kinase ATR, and its downstream target kinase, Chk1. When the DNA replication process is interrupted, the ATR-Chk1 pathway transmits signals to delay cell cycle progression, and to maintain fork viability so that DNA duplication can resume after the initial damage is corrected. Previous studies showed that replicative stress not only activated Chk1, but also triggered the ubiquitin-dependent destruction of Chk1 in cultured human cells. In a recent study, we identified the F-box protein, Fbx6, as the mediator that regulates Chk1 ubiquitination and degradation in both normally cycling cells and during replication stress. We further showed that expression levels of Chk1 and Fbx6 exhibited an overall inverse correlation in both cultured cancer cell lines and in breast tumor tissues, and that defects in Chk1 degradation, for instance, due to reduced expression of Fbx6, rendered tumor cells resistant to anticancer treatment. Here we highlight those findings and their implications in the replication checkpoint and cellular sensitivity to cancer therapies.     

Cyclin E/Cdk2 is required for sperm maturation, but not DNA replication, in early sea urchin embryos

The cell cycle is driven by the activity of cyclin/cdk complexes. In somatic cells, cyclin E/cdk2 oscillates throughout the cell cycle and has been shown to promote S-phase entry and initiation of DNA replication. In contrast, cyclin E/cdk2 activity remains constant throughout the early embryonic development of the sea urchin and localizes to the sperm nucleus following fertilization. We now show that cyclin E localization to the sperm nucleus following fertilization is not unique to the sea urchin, but also occurs in the surf clam, and inhibition of cyclin E/cdk2 activity by roscovitine inhibits the morphological changes indicative of male pronuclear maturation in sea urchin zygotes. Finally, we show that inhibition of cyclin E/cdk2 activity does not block DNA replication in the early cleavage cycles of the sea urchin. We conclude that cyclin E/cdk2 activity is required for male pronuclear maturation, but not for initiation of DNA replication in early sea urchin development.     

Adenovirus E1B55K region is required to enhance cyclin E expression for efficient viral DNA replication

Adenoviruses (Ads) with E1B55K mutations can selectively replicate in and destroy cancer cells. However, the mechanism of Ad-selective replication in tumor cells is not well characterized. We have shown previously that expression of several cell cycle-regulating genes is markedly affected by the Ad E1b gene in WI-38 human lung fibroblast cells (X. Rao, et al., Virology 350:418-428, 2006). In the current study, we show that the Ad E1B55K region is required to enhance cyclin E expression and that the failure to induce cyclin E overexpression due to E1B55K mutations prevents viral DNA from undergoing efficient replication in WI-38 cells, especially when the cells are arrested in the G(0) phase of the cell cycle by serum starvation. In contrast, cyclin E induction is less dependent on the function encoded in the E1B55K region in A549 and other cancer cells that are permissive for replication of E1B55K-mutated viruses, whether the cells are in the S phase or G(0) phase. The small interfering RNA that specifically inhibits cyclin E expression partially decreased viral replication. Our study provides evidence suggesting that E1B55K may be involved in cell cycle regulation that is important for efficient viral DNA replication and that cyclin E overexpression in cancer cells may be associated with the oncolytic replication of E1B55K-mutated viruses.     

DNA damage-dependent cyclin D1 proteolysis: GSK3β holds the smoking gun

Ubiquitin mediated degradation of cyclin D1 following the G1/S transition counters its mitogen-dependent accumulation during G1 phase of the cell cycle. Although the cellular machinery responsible for this process has been identified, how this regulatory pathway interfaces to cellular stress responses, often referred to as checkpoints, remains to be established. One intensely investigated checkpoint is the cellular response to DNA damage. When DNA damage is sensed, the corresponding DNA damage checkpoint triggers the inhibition of CDK-dependent cell cycle progression, with arrest coordinated by induction of CDK inhibitors and rapid degradation of specific cyclins, such as cyclin D1. In recent work, we identified a phosphorylation- and Fbx4-dependent cyclin D1 degradation mechanism in response to genotoxic stress.18 This work revealed that loss of cyclin D1 regulation compromises the intra-S-phase response to DNA damage, promoting genomic instability and sensitization of cells to S-phase chemotherapy, highlighting a potential therapeutic strategy for cancers exhibiting cyclin D1 accumulation.     

Cyclin A-dependent kinase activity affects chromatin binding of ORC, Cdc6, and MCM in egg extracts of Xenopus laevis.

The initiation of DNA replication in eukaryotes requires the loading of the origin recognition complex (ORC), Cdc6, and minichromosome maintenance (MCM) proteins onto chromatin to form the preinitiation complex. In Xenopus egg extract, the proteins Orc1, Orc2, Cdc6, and Mcm4 are underphosphorylated in interphase and hyperphosphorylated in metaphase extract. We find that chromatin binding of ORC, Cdc6, and MCM proteins does not require cyclin-dependent kinase activities. High cyclin A-dependent kinase activity inhibits the binding and promotes the release of Xenopus ORC, Cdc6, and MCM from sperm chromatin, but has no effect on chromatin binding of control proteins. Cyclin A together with ORC, Cdc6 and MCM proteins is bound to sperm chromatin in DNA replicating pseudonuclei. In contrast, high cyclin E/cdk2 was not detected on chromatin, but was found soluble in the nucleoplasm. High cyclin E kinase activity allows the binding of Xenopus ORC and Cdc6, but not MCM, to sperm chromatin, even though the kinase does not phosphorylate MCM directly. We conclude that chromatin-bound cyclin A kinase controls DNA replication by protein phosphorylation and chromatin release of Cdc6 and MCM, whereas soluble cyclin E kinase prevents rereplication during the cell cycle by the inhibition of premature MCM chromatin association.