Many variable region genes are utilized in the antibody response of BALB/c mice to the influenza virus A/PR/8/34 hemagglutinin

We have examined how many different H chain variable (VH) and kappa-chain variable (Vk) germ-line genes are used in the antibody response to the influenza virus A/PR/8/34 hemagglutinin (PR8 HA), and have assessed how the expression of individual VH and/or Vk genes contributes to the generation of specificity for the HA. A panel of 51 hybridoma antibodies that recognize two antigenic regions on the HA were compared for the sequence of their Ig H and L chain V regions. The hybridomas were obtained from 28 individual BALB/c mice that had been immunized with PR8 under a variety of primary and secondary response immunization protocols. The degree and pattern of sequence similarity suggests that 29 different VH genes drawn from seven different VH gene families, and 25 different Vk genes drawn from 12 different Vk gene families were used in this panel. Based on current estimates of the total numbers of VH and Vk genes in the mouse, this suggests that between 2.5 and 10% of the entire VH and Vk germ-line repertoires were used by these hybridomas. Despite this extensive diversity, some V genes were repetitively identified among these hybridomas, and were most often expressed in the context of specific VH/Vk combinations. Because antibodies that used identical VH/Vk combinations also usually displayed similar reactivity patterns with a panel of mutant viruses, this indicates that VH/Vk pairing can be important in establishing the specificity of antibodies for the HA.     

Molecular analysis of heavy and light chains used by primary and secondary anti-(T,G)-A--L antibodies produced by normal and xid mice

The primary (1 degree) antibody response to (T,G)-A--L shows limited heterogeneity, consisting mostly of side chain-specific antibodies that bind GT and that express the TGB5 idiotype (Id). The secondary (2 degrees) response is very diverse: antibodies that bind the backbone A--L constitute a third of the response, and a high proportion of the side chain-specific antibodies do not bind GT and are TGB5 Id-. To provide a molecular basis for understanding this difference in repertoire expression, we analyzed the Ig genes used by heavy and light chains of 1 degree and 2 degrees side chain-specific anti-(T,G)-A--L hybridoma antibodies (HP). Southern blot restriction analysis and nucleotide sequence analysis of the expressed genes used by three TGB5 Id+ 2 degrees HP showed usage of three different VH genes in two VH gene families (36-60 and J558), different D segments, and two different Vk1 genes (the Vk1A and Vk1C subgroups). Thus, antibody heterogeneity in the 2 degrees response is contributed by combinatorial diversity of distinct germ-line genes. Nucleotide sequence analysis of the expressed genes used by TGB5 Id+ 1 degree HP showed use of highly homologous VH genes in the J558 VH gene family and highly homologous Vk1A genes. The majority of TGB5 Id+ 1 degree HP from different donors gave similar heavy and similar light chain gene rearrangements by Southern blot restriction analysis, after correction for known or potential J region differences. The combined nucleotide sequence and Southern blot restriction analysis data suggest that most 1 degree B cells use the same or very similar VH and Vk genes, i.e., the 1 degree response is paucigenic. Different D segments were used by the TGB5 Id+ 1 degree and 2 degrees HP that were sequenced, and there was no apparent correlation between TGB5 idiotypy and VH, D gene, or JH gene usage. However, all TGB5 Id+ HP sequenced used highly homologous genes from the Vk1 group. Expression of a Vk1 light chain correlates with, but is not sufficient for, TGB5 idiotypy, because one GT-binding, TGB5 Id- HP was found to use a Vk1C subgroup light chain. By Southern blot and nucleotide sequence analysis, the Vk genes used by two TGB5 Id+ 2 degrees HP from xid mice are highly homologous, if not identical to the Vk1A gene(s) used by 1 degree and 2 degrees Id+ HP from wild-type mice.     

A molecular and structural analysis of the VH and VK regions of monoclonal antibodies bearing the A48 regulatory idiotype

The results presented in this paper explore the molecular basis for expression of the A48 regulatory Id (RI). A48 RI+ mAb derived from idiotypically manipulated mice molecularly resembled the A48 and UPC 10 prototypes of this system by utilizing a VHX24-Vk10 combination. Id expression by these antibodies was not restricted by a particular D region sequence, JH, or JK segment, but quantitative differences in Id expression were associated with utilization of different members of the VK10 germ-line gene families. The VL sequences of these A48 RI+ mAb has identified amino acid residues lying in four different idiotope-determining regions which may contribute to the structural correlate of this Id. A comparative sequence analysis of the VH regions of these VHX24 utilizing A48 RI+ mAb with several A48 RI+ mAb utilizing VHJ558 or VH7183 VH genes as well as a hybrid transfectoma antibody derived from two A48 RI-, VHJ558 utilizing hybridomas, all suggested that four nonconsecutive positions which lie outside the idiotope-determining regions may contribute structural elements toward expression of this Id. The VH and VL regions of the A48RI+, VHX24-Vk 10+ mAb showed low to moderate levels of somatic mutation which showed different patterns of distribution between the complementary determining region (CDR) and framework regions in the H and L chains. Although the VK sequences contained 50% of the replacement mutations in the CDR, with a replacement/silent mutation ratio of 10, the CDR of the VH sequences contained only 31% of the replacement mutations with a replacement/silent mutation ratio of 0.69.     

The immune response toward beta-adrenergic ligands and their receptors. VIII. Extensive diversity of VH and VL genes encoding anti-alprenolol antibodies

The V region genes (VH and VL) used in the immune response of BALB/c mice to alprenolol, a synthetic beta-adrenergic ligand, were examined by Southern blot and nucleotide sequence analyses. Fourteen anti-alprenolol hybridomas utilize 10 different combinations of six Vk, one V lambda, eight VH, three JK, one J lambda, and three JH genes. In addition to the combinatorial association, somatic mutations and junctional variation of assembled genes further contribute to diversity of the anti-alprenolol response. Although differing both in length and structure, the five H-chain third complementarity-determining region analyzed contain several acidic residues. Neither V gene utilization, nor H-chain third complementarity-determining-region structure can be simply correlated with affinity of the antibodies for the ligand. The anti-alprenolol V genes were compared with the corresponding sequences of unrelated antibodies. Antibody 37A4 shares a VH gene with anti-(Glu60Ala30Tyr10)n random terpolymer and anti-nitrophenyl antibodies, and a Vk gene with two anti-oxazolone antibodies. Antibodies 14C3 and 17C1 use the same germ-line VH and Vk genes as do anti-anti-idiotypic antibodies of the (Glu60Ala30Tyr10) system. These data demonstrate the genetic diversity of the antibody response to alprenolol, and illustrate the extensive flexibility of the immune system.     

Complete heavy and light chain variable region sequence of anti-arsonate monoclonal antibodies from BALB/c and A/J mice sharing the 36-60 idiotype are highly homologous

Structural and serologic studies on murine A/J monoclonal anti-arsonate antibodies resulted in the identification of a second idiotype family (Id36-60) in addition to the predominant idiotype family (IdCR). Id36-60, unlike IdCR, is a dominant idiotype in the BALB/c strain but is a "minor" idiotype in the A/J strain. The complete heavy and light chain variable region (VH and VL) amino acid sequences of a representative Id36-60 hybridoma protein from both the A/J and BALB/c strains have been determined. There are only four amino acid sequence differences between the VH of antibody 36-60 (A/J) and antibody 1210.7 (BALB/c). Two of these differences arise from single nucleotide changes in which the A/J and BALB/c Id36-60 VH germline gene sequences differ. The two other differences are the result of somatic mutation in hybridoma protein 36-60. In addition, Id36-60 heavy chains employ the same D and JH3 segments in both strains. The entire Vk2 VL of 36-60 and 1210.7 differ by only two amino acids, suggesting that like the heavy chains, they are derived from highly homologous VL genes. The same Jk segment is used in both antibodies. A comparison of the amino acid sequence data from Id36-60-bearing hybridomas suggests that a heavy chain amino acid difference accounts for the diminished arsonate binding by the 1210.7 hybridoma protein. Because the 1210.7 heavy chain is the unmutated product of the BALB/c VH gene, somatic mutation in VH may be required to enhance Ars affinity in this system.     

VH and VL gene usage by murine IgG antibodies that bind autologous insulin

To assess the recognition structures of antibodies that bind a self-Ag, we used mRNA analysis to identify the V region genes of IgG antibodies that bind autologous insulin. Four anti-insulin mAb from primary immunization of BALB/c mice use different combinations of H and L chain V region genes. Two VH genes are from the V-gam 3-2 and V-gam 3-8 families that are infrequently expressed in adult BALB/c mice, and two VH genes are members of the J558 family. Each anti-insulin antibody uses a different Vk gene family. Two antibodies express common Vk genes (Ox1 and Vk21C), whereas two other Vk genes are unusual in BALB/c mice. One Vk gene may represent a BALB/c equivalent of the VkOx2 subfamily and another is identical to a Vk used by anti-idiotypic antibodies from C57Bl/6 mice. When compared with known germ-line counterparts, all of the Vk sequences are close to germ-line configuration. In contrast, the germ-line counterparts for the anti-insulin VH genes are not known, however, they differ only in five to seven predicted amino acids from VH of other expressed antibodies. One antibody (mAb 123) differs in one amino acid in complementarity-determining regions 1 and 2 from the VH of the murine tumor BCL1, and another (mAb 126) employs an unmutated DFL16.1 germ-line D segment. These data suggest that antibodies binding autologous insulin use V gene components that are not extensively mutated, even when derived by immunization with heterologous insulin.     

Germline V genes encode viable motheaten mouse autoantibodies against thymocytes and red blood cells

Autoantibodies against thymocytes and RBC may contribute to the pathophysiology of homozygous viable motheaten (mev) autoimmune disease. Whether the production of these autoantibodies in mev mouse results from polyclonal nonspecific B cell activation or specific Ag-driven stimulation is not known. To understand the mechanisms involved in the induction of antithymocyte autoantibody response in mev mouse, we have studied the fine antigenic specificity, structure, and origin of three antithymocyte autoantibodies derived from mev splenic B cell hybridomas. Western blot analysis showed that these mAb bind to polypeptides of 33 and 105 kDa present in RBC and thymocytes, respectively. Additional specificities for the epitopes present in other polypeptides distinguished these three autoantibodies. Northern hybridization and flow microfluorimetry analysis indicated that these hybridomas are derived from the Ly1+ B cell subset. These autoreactive Ly-1 B cell hybridomas, chosen on the basis of their specificity, expressed L chain V genes from a single VK family (VK9) and VH genes from J606 and S107 families. Hybridomas UN34.11 and UN42.5 expressed the VK9 gene identical to that used by peritoneal Ly1+ B cells from various mouse strains and malignant B lymphoma cells secreting anti-mouse RBC treated with proteolytic enzyme bromelin and anti-SRBC antibodies. The third hybridoma, S2-14.2, used a VK9 gene identical to that expressed by MOPC41. None of the VK genes encoding these autoantibodies showed any somatic mutations. In the case of VH genes, the two hybridomas UN42.5 and S2-14.2 derived from two separate fusions, used identical VH genes from the J606 family. The third hybridoma UN34.11 used unmutated V11 germline VH gene, a member of the S107 family. Southern hybridizations, using oligonucleotide probes specific for CDR1 and CDR2, showed that the VH genes encoding the J606 autoantibodies were derived from a germline gene found in the 6.7-kb fragment of EcoRI-digested germline DNA. This germline VH gene is distinct from VH22.1 germline gene that codes for antigalactan antibodies. Sequence analysis of this gene showed perfect homology with the rearranged VH genes confirming the lack of somatic mutations. Thus, our data demonstrate that antithymocyte antibody response occurring in mev mouse is polyclonal and it involves Ly-1 B cells expressing unmutated germline VH and VK genes. These results indicate that antigen driven stimulation may not play an important role in the induction of anti-thymocyte antibody response in mev mouse.     

Nucleotide sequence of messenger RNA encoding VHDJH and VKJK of a highly conserved idiotype-defined primary response anti-hapten antibody.

The primary humoral immune response of mice to the hapten phthalate (Xmp) is focused upon two adjacent immunodominant negatively charged carboxyl groups on a benzene ring that are in positions meta and para to the azolinkage (i.e., Xmp) to the protein carrier keyhole limpet hemocyanin. A significant fraction of the anti-Xmp antibodies raised in several different inbred mouse strains (BALB/c, DBA/2, A/HeHa; C3H, and SM/J), and many wild mouse populations express a cross-reactive Id, CRIXmp-1. This CRIXmp-1 is conspicuously absent in C57BL/6 mice. In order to obtain a better understanding of the events and parameters that influence the selection and regulation of the primary response B cell repertoire, and to explore the structural basis of Ag binding, we have determined the nucleotide sequence of the entire V region gene complexes, which encode the H and L chains of these highly conserved and dominant CRIXmp-1+ antibodies. Our data establish that the H chain gene complex consists of a single VH germ-line gene that is identical to VH Oxazolone-1, encoding the H chain of another highly conserved and dominant cross-reactive Id family associated with the primary response to Oxazolone. In CRIXmp-1+ Xmp-specific hybridomas this gene is joined to a limited set of D region sequences that express a conserved amino acid motif-GLR. At least three of the five D regions examined are coded for by DFL16.2. This VHD complex can be utilized with one of three different JH region genes (JH1, JH2, and JH4) without any significant effect upon antibody fine specificity or Id. In spite of this lack of JH fidelity all of the CRIXmp-1+ hybridomas have precisely maintained the same length in the H chain CDR3 and FRW4 by altering either the length of the D segment or the length of JH. Nucleotide sequence analysis of the VL gene complex of CRIXmp-1+ anti-Xmp antibodies indicates that the L chain V region is also encoded by a single germ-line gene. The amino acid sequence predicted from the nucleotide sequence of the VKJK from Xmp-specific CRIXmp-1+ hybridomas is identical to the sequence of the anti-arsonate antibody 1210.7, which is the prototype of another Id family (CRI) that is conserved and dominant in BALB/c mice.     

Neonatal and adult primary B cells use the same germ-line VH and V kappa genes in their (T,G)-A-L-specific repertoire

Although there is a nonrandom usage of VH gene families by primary B cells early in ontogeny, at issue is whether the preferential rearrangement of 3' germ-line VH genes, e.g., VH7183 and VHQ52 family genes, influences the neonatal B cell repertoire that can be expressed in response to Ag. In order to address this issue, and to determine whether neonatal B cells can use the same germ-line VH and V kappa genes as adult B cells in their primary response, we have analyzed at the molecular level the neonatal antibody response to (T,G)-A-L and compared it with the adult primary response. Among the TGB5 Id+, GT+ antibodies, which dominate the neonatal response to (T,G)-A-L, two VH gene families were used: J558 (high frequency) and 36-60 (low frequency). The majority of Id+ neonatal hybridomas used the same germ-line VH gene (H10, from the VHJ558 family), but with enormous diversity in the D region, and one of two germ-line V kappa 1 genes (V kappa 1A, V kappa 1C). These are the same germ-line V-genes used by most primary adult Id+ hybridomas, and the frequency of expression of this germ-line V-gene combination appears equivalent in the neonatal and adult primary repertoires. Therefore, it is clear from this study that as early as day 5, neonatal B cells can use the same germ-line V-genes as adult primary B cells in their Ag-specific repertoire.     

Characteristics of murine monoclonal anti-CD4. Epitope recognition, idiotype expression, and variable region gene sequence.

We have characterized a series of mouse monoclonal anti-CD4 and describe both their CD4 epitope recognition and Id expression. We also determined the V region gene sequences of these antibodies in an attempt to correlate epitope recognition and Id expression with V region sequence. All of these preparations recognize epitopes that cluster around the HIV gp120 binding site on the human CD4 molecule. However, we observed differences in epitope recognition among the anti-CD4 preparations, based on either competitive inhibition assays or functional assays, such as syncytium inhibition. Analysis of Id specificities using a polyclonal anti-Id generated against anti-Leu 3a indicated that five of the seven monoclonal anti-CD4 expressed a shared Id. Based on V region gene sequences, the V region kappa-chain (V[kappa]) from each of the seven antibodies was encoded by the V[kappa]21 gene family and expressed the J[kappa]4 gene segment. Those preparations that expressed the shared Id with anti-Leu 3a have virtually identical V[kappa] sequences, with a high degree of homology in the CDR. The VH region gene sequences of six of the seven antibodies also shared overall homology and appeared to be encoded by the J558 VH gene family. The seventh anti-CD4 VH region is encoded for by the VHGAM gene family. The majority of these antibodies used JH3 gene segment, although the JH2 and JH4 gene segments were also represented. In addition, several of these antibodies share a common sequence organization within their V-D-J joining regions that appears to involve N and P sequences to generate unique D segments. Together, these data suggest that differences in epitope recognition among the monoclonal anti-CD4 may reflect sequence variability primarily within the CDR3 region of both V[kappa] and VH. The basis for the detection of a shared Id most likely reflects the high degree of homology within the V[kappa] region sequences. In addition, these data, which are based on a limited analysis, suggest the possible restricted use of V region germ-line gene families in the secondary antibody response of BALB/c mice to specific epitopes on the human CD4 molecule.     

Molecular analysis of a germ line-encoded idiotypic marker of pathogenic human lupus autoantibodies

Id-16/6 is an idiotypic marker found in both IgM and IgG antibodies, as well as in the tissue lesions of patients with SLE. The prototypic Id-16/6+ mAb is 18/2, whose VH3-derived H chain is encoded by an unmutated germ-line gene. We found that the H chains of VH3-derived Id-16/6+ antibodies contain the major determinants of Id-16/6. Moreover, B cell clones from which those antibodies were harvested produce RNA that hybridized under conditions of high stringency to oligonucleotide probes corresponding to the CDR of the VH segment of 18/2. Western blots of Id-16/6+ mAbs with anti-Id confirmed the association of the Id with H chains. Id-16/6 can identify a subgroup of VH3-derived antibodies we have termed the 18/2 CDR family. However, Id-16/6 can also be expressed in some antibodies unrelated to the 18/2 CDR family. No characteristic Ag-binding specificity was found among the members of the 18/2 CDR family. The principal phenotypic feature shared by all known members of the family is Id-16/6.     

Molecular basis of an isogeneic anti-idiotypic response.

The nucleotide sequences of the variable region genes expressed in the heavy and light chains of six isogeneic anti-idiotope antibodies recognizing idiotopes on two closely related antibodies with specificity for the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) were determined. In two independently derived anti-idiotope cell lines the same or strongly homologous V kappa, VH and D region genes had originally been rearranged. The two lines express long and partly homologous N sequences (presumed to be not of germ line origin) at the border of D, resulting in CDR3s of unusual length. An unusually long CDR3, partly encoded by N sequences, is also present in the heavy chain of a third anti-idiotope antibody. The VH regions of the three remaining anti-idiotope antibodies originate from a single VH gene which belongs to the same VH group as the VH genes expressed in the other anti-idiotopes. Two of these antibodies, expressing similar V, D and J elements, had been isolated from the same mouse and appear to have diverged from the same B cell precursor by at least two rounds of somatic mutation. Somatic point mutations have occurred in most, if not all anti-idiotope V region sequences. In two instances somatic mutations in J increase the structural homology between anti-idiotopes. The anti-idiotypic response in this system is thus genetically restricted and may depend upon the selection of non-germ line sequences, suggesting an explanation for the low frequency at which anti-idiotope antibodies are expressed in this system.     

Natural mouse and human antibodies bind to a peptide derived from a germline VH chain. Evidence for evolutionary conserved self-binding locus

Murine antibodies derived from the V1 S107/T15 germline structure combined with Vk 22 L chains express the property of self-binding. Previous studies have shown that the self-binding is mediated by the Fab fragment involving structures of the hapten binding site. The molecular locus of self-binding has also been identified by showing that a peptide derived from the CDR2/FR3 region of the V1 S107 H chain inhibits self-binding. We have addressed the question of whether self-binding antibodies interact with peptides that inhibit self-binding. We found that labeled TEPC15 (T15) binds to immobilized VH (50-73) peptide; the peptide binding is specific because different CDR peptides and other unrelated peptides do not inhibit this binding. Furthermore, the hapten phosphorylcholine is a potent inhibitor for the T15-peptide binding. We have demonstrated the presence of naturally occurring antibodies that bind to the T15H(50-73) peptide in the sera of different strains of mice and also in humans, indicating that the CDR2/FR3 sequence of T15 is a conserved Id determining region. We have isolated peptide-specific antibodies from pooled normal human Ig preparations. Human anti-peptide antibodies have self-binding properties similar to their murine counterparts. This interspecies conserved peptide binding of antibodies that are self-binding indicates the existence of an evolutionarily important and biologically active site.     

Restriction in V kappa gene use and antigen selection in anti-myeloperoxidase response in mice

Anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic Abs, directed primarily toward myeloperoxidase (MPO) and proteinase 3, are detected in the majority of patients with distinct forms of small vessel vasculitides and pauci-immune necrotizing glomerulonephritis. However, the origin of these autoantibodies remains unknown. We studied the V region gene use in murine anti-MPO Abs derived from Spontaneous Crescentic Glomerulonephritis/Kinjoh mice. A total of 13 anti-MPO-producing hybridomas were generated from four unimmunized mice. Ten of the 13 hybridomas (corresponding to 3 of 4 clones) expressed Vkappa1C but differed in their use of VH genes. The remaining three hybridomas expressed a Vkappa5 gene. Anti-MPO hybridomas from individual mice were derived from single clones as deduced by sequence similarity and splice-site identity. We found a statistically significant bias of amino acid replacement mutations to the complementarity-determining regions (CDR) in the Vkappa1C-expressing hybridomas. Intriguingly, all 10 Vkappa1C hybridomas share a lysine to glutamate mutation in the CDR1. To determine the effects of somatic V gene mutations on binding to MPO, we generated an anti-MPO Ab with an unmutated Vkappa1C L chain and compared its ability to bind MPO with its mutated counterpart. The mutated hybridoma-derived Ab has a 4.75-fold higher avidity for MPO than the unmutated Ab. These results suggest that: 1) the L chain plays a dominant role in determining Ab specificity to MPO, 2) the anti-MPO Ab response is oligoclonal, consistent with Ag selection, and 3) MPO is a driving Ag in the murine anti-MPO Ab response.     

Immunologic memory to phosphocholine keyhole limpet hemocyanin. Recurrent mutations in the lambda 1 light chain increase affinity for antigen.

Anti-phosphocholine (PC)-keyhole limpet hemacyanin hybridomas representative of a memory response that express the lambda 1 L chain isotype have a high reactivity to PC-protein. A common feature of these hybridomas possessing high affinity for PC-protein is the occurrence of somatic mutations resulting in replacement changes in three CDR2 positions of the lambda 1 L chain. The influence of each of these three positions on the Ag binding properties of these antibodies was examined by site-specific mutagenesis and expression of recombinant antibody molecules by transfected cells. Affinity measurements and fine specificity profile determinations demonstrated the importance of the three lambda 1 CDR2 positions in Ag binding. Compared to antibodies expressing germline lambda 1, including one with an additional junctional serine that is not encoded by V or J, those antibodies possessing critical changes in CDR2 would have a strong selective advantage based on affinity differences for Ag. Sequence analysis of a group of clonally related hybridomas expressing mutated lambda 1 genes allowed construction of a hypothetical genealogic tree that suggests selection based on changes in CDR2 of lambda 1 in the absence of H chain mutations. The results are consistent with stepwise acquisition of mutations and selection based on affinity constraints.     

Regulation of idiotope expression. IV. Genetic linkage of two D region-dependent T15 idiotopes to the IgH allotype

The idiotopic (Id) repertoire of antibody response to phosphocholine was studied in mouse strains with different IgH allotypes. The T15 idiotype-bearing (T15+) serum antibody and antibody plaque-forming cells (PFC) were characterized with four monoclonal anti-Id that recognize distinct Id determinants on T15+ antibody encoded by VH-1 (of the S107 gene family), DH FL16.1, JH-1 and Vk22 germ-line genes. We have previously shown that expression of the Id designated AB1-2 and B36-82 depends on the third hypervariable loop (D region), whereas the other Id, MaId5-4 and B24-44, are influenced by VH structures outside of the D region. All four Id were expressed in the PC-response of all mouse strains tested, except the Ighj strains (C3H/HeJ, CBA/H-T6, PL/j), where the D region-dependent Id, AB1-2 and B36-82, were absent. The other Id, however, were normally expressed on individual PFC as well as the serum antibody of the Ighj strains. Expression of AB1-2 and B36-82 on 50% of PFC occurred in (BALB/c-Igha x C3H/HeJ-Ighj)F1 mice. The absence of Id correlated with a unique RFLP of the S107 gene family in Ighj strains. Finally, Id expression segregated with the appropriate RFLP pattern in individual (BALB/c x C3H/HeJ)F2 mice. These data demonstrate a selective genetic linkage of discrete T15 Id determinants, AB1-2 and B36-82 with the Igh allotype. By comparing these results with the available Ig sequences, we suggest that the Ighj allotype may be associated with an allelic form of the DH-FL16.1 segment which with VH-1, JH-1, and the Vk 22 code for the phosphocholine-specific antibody in the mouse.     

The specificity properties that distinguish members of a set of homologous anti-digoxin antibodies are controlled by H chain mutations

Five murine A/J strain anti-digoxin mAb (35-20, 40-40, 40-120, 40-140, and 40-160) have highly homologous H and L chain V regions, only differing by somatic mutation, yet differ in affinity and specificity. The availability of the VH and VL genomic clones from one hybridoma, 40-140, has now allowed studies involving in vitro mutagenesis and chain recombination among these five hybridomas. To determine the relative contributions of the mutations found in either VH or VL to the overall binding properties of these antibodies, we recombined the 40-140VH with the VL of each hybridoma. The 40-140VH gene was transfected into hybridoma variants that produce only VL. The recombinant antibodies show that the mutations present in VH, rather than in VL, affect the fine specificity properties of these antibodies, whereas, the mutations among both VH and VL chains are important in determining antigen affinity. From mutations present in VH that affect fine specificity properties, the comparison of the antibody sequences, and from the previously measured binding properties, we predicted and tested selected VH mutations for their ability to alter specificity or affinity by doing site-directed in vitro mutagenesis. The results for the somatic mutations found in this group of antibodies show: 1) VH mutations control the fine specificity properties that distinguish different members of this group; 2) in particular, VH residues 54 and 55 in CDR2 control the distinguishing characteristics of specificities between these antibodies; and 3) by mutagenesis, we had the unusual result of being able to alter Ag specificity without affecting affinity. A computer model of the 40-140 antibody binding site was generated which indicates that VH residues 54 and 55 are highly accessible.     

Somatic evolution of diversity among anti-phosphocholine antibodies induced with Proteus morganii

The variable region sequences of light and heavy chains (VL and VH) were determined for 11 hybridoma antibodies produced in response to the PC moiety on Proteus morganii. These hybridomas were derived from two separate fusions, one obtained from mice early in a secondary response and the other from late in a secondary response. All of these antibodies possessed a cross-reactive idiotype found on anti-PC antibodies in the M603 family, and exhibited preferential specificity for PC in the context of P. morganii. We found that all of the antibodies were derived from a single VH/VL pair. VH was encoded by V1, DFL16.1 and JH1, and VL was encoded by a consensus VK8 gene and JK5. Antibodies differed from each other by somatic point mutations that occurred at a high rate. The mutations in VL were approximately one-third as abundant as those in VH and were randomly distributed throughout the molecule. Mutations in VH were concentrated in CDR 2 and 3 and had a replacement to silent ratio that was three to six times greater than predicted from random accumulation. Based on the sequence data, a single genealogic tree with multiple branches could accommodate all the hybrids from a fusion. We concluded that in both examples the anti-PC response arose by somatic mutation and stepwise selection from a single precursor. Antigen binding studies with these 11 hybridomas and a 12th that had no mutations revealed that the acquisition of preferential specificity for antigen was dependent on somatic mutation of germline genes. Additional binding studies demonstrated that continued selection during clonal expansion was probably antigen driven. An unexpected finding was five independently selected antibodies from one fusion that had identically mutated VH and VL sequences. We suggest that the hypermutation mechanism is not a continuously active process during clonal expansion and that it is regulated, probably during the mid to late phase of the primary response.     

Relationship of human variable region heavy chain germ-line genes to genes encoding anti-DNA autoantibodies

In order to identify the V region genes encoding systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)-derived anti-DNA autoantibodies, we have determined the nucleotide sequence of heavy chain mRNA from several DNA-binding immunoglobulins secreted by human hybridomas. We used the technique of cDNA primer extension for determining sequences of the VH, D, and JH gene segments of anti-DNA autoantibodies from three different primary hybridoma growths from an SLE patient and one hybridoma from a leprosy patient. Immunoglobulins from two of the SLE hybridomas expressed the same idiotype, Id-16/6, which is also expressed on immunoglobulins in sera of patients with active SLE. Their mRNA sequences showed complete homology to each other in the V, D, and J genes and more than 99% homology to the VH26 germ-line gene sequence, a member of the human VHIII gene family. The VH mRNA sequence of the third SLE hybridoma, 21/28, which was idiotypically unrelated to the other two, was 93% homologous to a different VH germ-line gene sequence, HA2, a member of the human VHI gene family. The fourth anti-DNA-producing hybridoma, 8E10, was derived from a leprosy patient of different ethnic origin than the SLE patient. It was idiotypically related to 21/28 and expressed a VH segment gene identical to that of 21/28. Hybridomas 21/28 and 8E10 shared sequence homology with the VH26 anti-DNA antibodies in the first complementarity-determining region. In addition, 21/28 shared sequence homology with the Id-16/6+ group in the region encoded by the D and J gene segments. Our findings indicate that some SLE autoantibodies are encoded by unmodified or scarcely modified VH germ-line genes that are conserved in the human population and identify two distinct VH germ-line genes that can encode segments of anti-DNA immunoglobulins.     

Clustered H chain somatic mutations shared by anti-p-azophenylarsonate antibodies confer enhanced affinity and ablate the cross-reactive idiotype

A cluster of four consecutive CDR2 somatic mutations are shared by the VH regions of two independently isolated hybridoma antibodies with specificity for p-azophenylarsonate (Ars). The mutations appear to be derived by a series of independent events. To assess the influence of these shared somatic mutations on antibody affinity for Ars and on idiotypy, we introduced them, via site-directed mutagenesis, into the V region of an anti-Ars antibody that was otherwise unmutated and we eliminated them from the mutated context of one of the two antibodies in which they were originally found. Results of affinity measurements by fluorescence quenching and of idiotypic binding assays performed on these engineered mutants demonstrated that the shared mutations increased affinity for Ars and eliminated the predominant Id associated with strain A anti-Ars antibodies and four of five idiotypes defined by anti-idiotypic mAb. These results support the interpretation that a strong affinity-based selection pressure has favored the clonal expansion of B cells with receptors containing these mutations despite the loss of a predominant Id. Thus, in producing antibodies containing V regions conferring high affinity for Ag, the combined processes of somatic mutation and clonal selection have generated a common structural solution through parallel repeats.