Fluorescence lifetime imaging: multi-point calibration, minimum resolvable differences, and artifact suppression

BACKGROUND: Frequency-domain fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) is finding increasing use in the analysis of biological systems. However, the calibration, determination of resolvable lifetime differences, and evaluation of artifacts have not been extensively treated. We describe a multi-point method for calibrating a frequency-domain FLIM system, characterize the minimum detectable heterogeneity and intra- and inter-image lifetime differences, discuss the statistical treatment of FLIM data, and suggest methods for minimizing artifacts. METHODS: A set of solutions exhibiting single-component lifetimes suffice for accurately calibrating a reference material with a single-component lifetime, even in the absence of accurate data on the lifetimes of the individual solutions or the reference material. We used a set of rhodamine 6G solutions quenched with varying concentrations of iodide, leading to lifetimes of 0.5--4.0 ns, to calibrate a 1 microM reference solution of rhodamine 6G in water. RESULTS: We measured a value of 4.11 ns with an estimated absolute error of +/-0.05 ns for the rhodamine 6G reference solution. With 57.7 MHz modulation, the minimum detectable inter-image lifetime difference was 0.1--0.15 ns and the minimum detectable intra-image lifetime difference was 4--5 ps, allowing solutions differing in lifetime by 40 and 70 ps to be easily distinguished. The minimum detectable lifetime heterogeneity was 50--80 ps. Evaluation of replicate measurements of single solutions demonstrated that inter-image instrument errors exceeded those predicted from intra-image statistics by more than an order of magnitude. We also measured lifetimes and heterogeneity in 4 GFP variants (WTGFP, EGFP, S65T, and EYFP) with the technique. CONCLUSION: The multi-point calibration method is applicable to any system consisting of single-component lifetimes. Applying the method in our FLIM microscope allowed us to demonstrate a previously unreported degree of lifetime resolution in a FLIM microscope. Cytometry 43:248-260;2001.     

Refractive index sensing of green fluorescent proteins in living cells using fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy

We show that fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) of green fluorescent protein (GFP) molecules in cells can be used to report on the local refractive index of intracellular GFP. We expressed GFP fusion constructs of Rac2 and gp91^phox, which are both subunits of the phagocyte NADPH oxidase enzyme, in human myeloid PLB-985 cells and showed by high-resolution confocal fluorescence microscopy that GFP-Rac2 and GFP-gp91^phox are targeted to the cytosol and to membranes, respectively. Frequency-domain FLIM experiments on these PLB-985 cells resulted in average fluorescence lifetimes of 2.70 ns for cytosolic GFP-Rac2 and 2.31 ns for membrane-bound GFP-gp91^phox. By comparing these lifetimes with a calibration curve obtained by measuring GFP lifetimes in PBS/glycerol mixtures of known refractive index, we found that the local refractive indices of cytosolic GFP-Rac2 and membrane-targeted GFP-gp91^phox are ∼1.38 and ∼1.46, respectively, which is in good correspondence with reported values for the cytosol and plasma membrane measured by other techniques. The ability to measure the local refractive index of proteins in living cells by FLIM may be important in revealing intracellular spatial heterogeneities within organelles such as the plasma and phagosomal membrane.     

Global analysis of fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy data

Global analysis techniques are described for frequency domain fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) data. These algorithms exploit the prior knowledge that only a limited number of fluorescent molecule species whose lifetimes do not vary spatially are present in the sample. Two approaches to implementing the lifetime invariance constraint are described. In the lifetime invariant fit method, each image in the lifetime image sequence is spatially averaged to obtain an improved signal-to-noise ratio. The lifetime estimations from these averaged data are used to recover the fractional contribution to the steady-state fluorescence on a pixel-by-pixel basis for each species. The second, superior, approach uses a global analysis technique that simultaneously fits the fractional contributions in all pixels and the spatially invariant lifetimes. In frequency domain FLIM the maximum number of lifetimes that can be fit with the global analysis method is twice the number of lifetimes that can be fit with conventional approaches. As a result, it is possible to discern two lifetimes with a single-frequency FLIM setup. The algorithms were tested on simulated data and then applied to separate the cellular distributions of coexpressed green fluorescent proteins in living cells.     

Protein localization in living cells and tissues using FRET and FLIM

Interacting proteins assemble into molecular machines that control cellular homeostasis in living cells. While the in vitro screening methods have the advantage of providing direct access to the genetic information encoding unknown protein partners, they do not allow direct access to interactions of these protein partners in their natural environment inside the living cell. Using wide-field, confocal, or two-photon (2p) fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy, this information can be obtained from living cells and tissues with nanometer resolution. One of the important conditions for FRET to occur is the overlap of the emission spectrum of the donor with the absorption spectrum of the acceptor. As a result of spectral overlap, the FRET signal is always contaminated by donor emission into the acceptor channel and by the excitation of acceptor molecules by the donor excitation wavelength. Mathematical algorithms are required to correct the spectral bleed-through signal in wide-field, confocal, and two-photon FRET microscopy. In contrast, spectral bleed-through is not an issue in FRET/FLIM imaging because only the donor fluorophore lifetime is measured; also, fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) measurements are independent of excitation intensity or fluorophore concentration. The combination of FRET and FLIM provides high spatial (nanometer) and temporal (nanosecond) resolution when compared to intensity-based FRET imaging. In this paper, we describe various FRET microscopy techniques and its application to protein-protein interactions.     

Fluorescence lifetime imaging of calcium using Quin-2.

We describe the use of a new imaging technology, fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM), for the imaging of the calcium concentrations based on the fluorescence lifetime of a calcium indicator. The fluorescence lifetime of Quin-2 is shown to be highly sensitive to [Ca2+]. We create two-dimensional lifetime images using the phase shift and modulation of the Quin-2 in response to intensity-modulated light. The two-dimensional phase and modulation values are obtained using a gain-modulated image intensifier and a slow-scan CCD camera. The lifetime values in the 2D image were verified using standard frequency-domain measurements. Importantly, the FLIM method does not require the probe to display shifts in the excitation or emission spectra, which may allow Ca2+ imaging using other Ca2+ probes not in current widespread use due to the lack of spectral shifts. Fluorescence lifetime imaging can be superior to stationary (steady-state) imaging because lifetimes are independent of the local probe concentration and/or intensity, and should thus be widely applicable to chemical imaging using fluorescence microscopy.     

Simultaneous detection of multiple green fluorescent proteins in live cells by fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy

The green fluorescent protein (GFP) has proven to be an excellent fluorescent marker for protein expression and localisation in living cells [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]. Several mutant GFPs with distinct fluorescence excitation and emission spectra have been engineered for intended use in multi-labelling experiments [6] [7] [8] [9]. Discrimination of these co-expressed GFP variants by wavelength is hampered, however, by a high degree of spectral overlap, low quantum efficiencies and extinction coefficients [10], or rapid photobleaching [6]. Using fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16], four GFP variants were shown to have distinguishable fluorescence lifetimes. Among these was a new variant (YFP5) with spectral characteristics reminiscent of yellow fluorescent protein [8] and a comparatively long fluorescence lifetime. The fluorescence intensities of co-expressed spectrally similar GFP variants (either alone or as fusion proteins) were separated using lifetime images obtained with FLIM at a single excitation wavelength and using a single broad band emission filter. Fluorescence lifetime imaging opens up an additional spectroscopic dimension to wavelength through which novel GFP variants can be selected to extend the number of protein processes that can be imaged simultaneously in cells.     

Localization of protein-protein interactions in live cells using confocal and spectral imaging FRET microscopy

Microscopy has become an essential tool for cellular protein investigations. The development of new fluorescent markers such as green fluorescent proteins generated substantial opportunities to monitor protein-protein interactions qualitatively and quantitatively using advanced fluorescence microscope techniques including wide-field, confocal, multiphoton, spectral imaging, lifetime, and correlation spectroscopy. The specific aims of the investigation of protein dynamics in live specimens dictate the selection of the microscope methodology. In this article confocal and spectral imaging methods to monitor the dimerization of alpha enhancer binding protein (C/EBPalpha) in the pituitary GHFT1-5 living cell nucleus have been described. Also outline are issues involved in protein imaging using light microscopy techniques and the advantages of lifetime imaging of protein-protein interactions.     

Dynamic fluorescence anisotropy imaging microscopy in the frequency domain (rFLIM)

We describe a novel variant of fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM), denoted anisotropy-FLIM or rFLIM, which enables the wide-field measurement of the anisotropy decay of fluorophores on a pixel-by-pixel basis. We adapted existing frequency-domain FLIM technology for rFLIM by introducing linear polarizers in the excitation and emission paths. The phase delay and intensity ratios (AC and DC) between the polarized components of the fluorescence signal are recorded, leading to estimations of rotational correlation times and limiting anisotropies. Theory is developed that allows all the parameters of the hindered rotator model to be extracted from measurements carried out at a single modulation frequency. Two-dimensional image detection with a sensitive CCD camera provides wide-field imaging of dynamic depolarization with parallel interrogation of different compartments of a complex biological structure such as a cell. The concepts and technique of rFLIM are illustrated with a fluorophore-solvent (fluorescein-glycerol) system as a model for isotropic rotational dynamics and with bacteria expressing enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) exhibiting depolarization due to homotransfer of electronic excitation energy (emFRET). The frequency-domain formalism was extended to cover the phenomenon of emFRET and yielded data consistent with a concentration depolarization mechanism resulting from the high intracellular concentration of EGFP. These investigations establish rFLIM as a powerful tool for cellular imaging based on rotational dynamics and molecular proximity.     

Fluorescence lifetime: Beating the IRF and interpulse window

Fluorescence lifetime imaging captures the spatial distribution of chemical species across cellular environments employing pulsed illumination confocal setups. However, quantitative interpretation of lifetime data continues to face critical challenges. For instance, fluorescent species with known in vitro excited-state lifetimes may split into multiple species with unique lifetimes when introduced into complex living environments. What is more, mixtures of species, which may be both endogenous and introduced into the sample, may exhibit 1) very similar lifetimes as well as 2) wide ranges of lifetimes including lifetimes shorter than the instrumental response function or whose duration may be long enough to be comparable to the interpulse window. By contrast, existing methods of analysis are optimized for well-separated and intermediate lifetimes. Here, we broaden the applicability of fluorescence lifetime analysis by simultaneously treating unknown mixtures of arbitrary lifetimes—outside the intermediate, Goldilocks, zone—for data drawn from a single confocal spot leveraging the tools of Bayesian nonparametrics (BNP). We benchmark our algorithm, termed BNP lifetime analysis, using a range of synthetic and experimental data. Moreover, we show that the BNP lifetime analysis method can distinguish and deduce lifetimes using photon counts as small as 500.     

Time-resolved fluorescence microscopy.

In fluorescence microscopy, the fluorescence emission can be characterised not only by intensity and position, but also by lifetime, polarization and wavelength. Fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM) can report on photophysical events that are difficult or impossible to observe by fluorescence intensity imaging, and time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy imaging (TR-FAIM) can measure the rotational mobility of a fluorophore in its environment. We compare different FLIM methods: a chief advantage of wide-field time-gating and phase modulation methods is the speed of acquisition whereas for time-correlated single photon counting (TCSPC) based confocal scanning it is accuracy in the fluorescence decay. FLIM has been used to image interactions between proteins such as receptor oligomerisation and to reveal protein phosphorylation by detecting fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). In addition, FLIM can also probe the local environment of fluorophores, reporting, for example, on the local pH, refractive index, ion or oxygen concentration without the need for ratiometric measurements.     

Wide-field photon counting fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy: application to photosynthesizing systems

Fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) is a technique that visualizes the excited state kinetics of fluorescence molecules with the spatial resolution of a fluorescence microscope. We present a scanningless implementation of FLIM based on a time- and space-correlated single photon counting (TSCSPC) method employing a position-sensitive quadrant anode detector and wide-field illumination. The standard time-correlated photon counting approach leads to picosecond temporal resolution, making it possible to resolve complex fluorescence decays. This allows parallel acquisition of time-resolved images of biological samples under minimally invasive low-excitation conditions (<10mW/cm²). In this way unwanted photochemical reactions induced by high excitation intensities and distorting the decay kinetics are avoided. Comparably low excitation intensities are practically impossible to achieve with a conventional laser scanning microscope, where focusing of the excitation beam into a tight spot is required. Therefore, wide-field FLIM permits to study Photosystem II (PS II) in a way so far not possible with a laser scanning microscope. The potential of the wide-field TSCSPC method is demonstrated by presenting FLIM measurements of the fluorescence dynamics of photosynthetic systems in living cells of the chlorophyll d-containing cyanobacterium Acaryochloris marina.     

Setup and characterization of a multiphoton FLIM instrument for protein-protein interaction measurements in living cells.

BACKGROUND: Fluorescence lifetime microscopy (FLIM) is currently one of the best techniques to perform accurate measurements of interactions in living cells. It is independent of the fluorophore concentration, thus avoiding several common artifacts found in F?rster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) imaging. However, for FLIM to achieve high performance, a rigorous instrumental setup and characterization is needed. METHODS: We use known fluorophores to perform characterization experiments in our instrumental setup. This allows us to verify the accuracy of the fluorescence lifetime determination, and test the linearity of the instrument by fluorescence quenching. RESULTS: We develop and validate here a protocol for rigorous characterization of time-domain FLIM instruments. Following this protocol, we show that our system provides accurate and reproducible measurements. We also used HeLa cells expressing proteins fused to Green Fluorescent Proteins variants (CFP and YFP) to confirm its ability to detect interactions in living cells by FRET. CONCLUSIONS: We report a well-designed protocol in which precise and reproducible lifetime measurements can be performed. It is usable for all confocal-based FLIM instruments and is a useful tool for anyone who wants to perform quantitative lifetime measurements, especially when studying interactions in living cells using FRET.     

Correlated fluorescence quenching and topographic mapping of Light-Harvesting Complex II within surface-assembled aggregates and lipid bilayers

Light-Harvesting Complex II (LHCII) is a chlorophyll-protein antenna complex that efficiently absorbs solar energy and transfers electronic excited states to photosystems I and II. Under excess light intensity LHCII can adopt a photoprotective state in which excitation energy is safely dissipated as heat, a process known as Non-Photochemical Quenching (NPQ). In vivo NPQ is triggered by combinatorial factors including transmembrane ΔpH, PsbS protein and LHCII-bound zeaxanthin, leading to dramatically shortened LHCII fluorescence lifetimes. In vitro, LHCII in detergent solution or in proteoliposomes can reversibly adopt an NPQ-like state, via manipulation of detergent/protein ratio, lipid/protein ratio, pH or pressure. Previous spectroscopic investigations revealed changes in exciton dynamics and protein conformation that accompany quenching, however, LHCII-LHCII interactions have not been extensively studied. Here, we correlated fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) of trimeric LHCII adsorbed to mica substrates and manipulated the environment to cause varying degrees of quenching. AFM showed that LHCII self-assembled onto mica forming 2D-aggregates (25–150?nm width). FLIM determined that LHCII in these aggregates were in a quenched state, with much lower fluorescence lifetimes (~0.25?ns) compared to free LHCII in solution (2.2–3.9?ns). LHCII-LHCII interactions were disrupted by thylakoid lipids or phospholipids, leading to intermediate fluorescent lifetimes (0.6–0.9?ns). To our knowledge, this is the first in vitro correlation of nanoscale membrane imaging with LHCII quenching. Our findings suggest that lipids could play a key role in modulating the extent of LHCII-LHCII interactions within the thylakoid membrane and so the propensity for NPQ activation.     

In Situ Activity of Suspended and Immobilized Microbial Communities as Measured by Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging

In this study, the feasibility of fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM) for measurement of RNA:DNA ratios in microorganisms was assessed. The fluorescence lifetime of a nucleic acid-specific probe (SYTO 13) was used to directly measure the RNA:DNA ratio inside living bacterial cells. In vitro, SYTO 13 showed shorter fluorescence lifetimes in DNA solutions than in RNA solutions. Growth experiments with bacterial monocultures were performed in liquid media. The results demonstrated the suitability of SYTO 13 for measuring the growth-phase-dependent RNA:DNA ratio in Escherichia coli cells. The fluorescence lifetime of SYTO 13 reflected the known changes of the RNA:DNA ratio in microbial cells during different growth phases. As a result, the growth rate of E. coli cells strongly correlated with the fluorescence lifetime. Finally, the fluorescence lifetimes of SYTO 13 in slow- and fast-growing biofilms were compared. For this purpose, biofilms developed from activated sludge were grown as autotrophic and heterotrophic communities. The FLIM data clearly showed a longer fluorescence lifetime for the fast-growing heterotrophic biofilms and a shorter fluorescence lifetime for the slow-growing autotrophic biofilms. Furthermore, starved biofilms showed shorter lifetimes than biofilms supplied with glucose, indicating a lower RNA:DNA ratio in starved biofilms. It is suggested that FLIM in combination with SYTO 13 represents a useful tool for the in situ differentiation of active and inactive bacteria. The technique does not require radioactive chemicals and may be applied to a broad range of sample types, including suspended and immobilized microorganisms.     

Development and characterization of green fluorescent protein mutants with altered lifetimes

Multiple-probe fluorescence imaging applications demand an ever-increasing number of resolvable probes, and the use of fluorophores with resolvable fluorescence lifetimes can help meet this demand. Green fluorescent protein (GFP) and its variants have been widely used in spectrally resolved multiprobe imaging, but as yet, there has not been a systematic set of mutants generated with resolvable lifetimes. Therefore, to generate such mutants, we have utilized error-prone PCR and fluorescence lifetime imaging to screen for mutants of UV-excited green fluorescent protein (GFPuv) that exhibit altered fluorescence decay lifetimes. This has resulted in the isolation of GFPuv mutants displaying at least three distinctly different lifetimes in the range of 1.9-2.8 ns. Mutation of Y145 to either histidine or cysteine was found to shift the fluorescence lifetime of GFPuv from 3.03 +/- 0.03 to 2.78 +/- 0.05 ns for the Y145H mutant and to 2.74 +/- 0.05 ns for Y145C. Some of the shorter-lifetime mutants exhibited excitation peaks that were red-shifted relative to their maximal absorption, indicating that the mutations allowed the adoption of additional conformations relative to wtGFPuv. The utility of these mutants for applications in simultaneous imaging and quantification is shown by the ability to quantify the composition of binary mixtures in time-resolved images using a single detector channel. The application of the screening method for generating lifetime mutants of other fluorescent proteins is also discussed.     

Probing the Dynamics of Doxorubicin-DNA Intercalation during the Initial Activation of Apoptosis by Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscopy (FLIM)

Doxorubicin is a potent anthracycline antibiotic, commonly used to treat a wide range of cancers. Although postulated to intercalate between DNA bases, many of the details of doxorubicin’s mechanism of action remain unclear. In this work, we demonstrate the ability of fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) to dynamically monitor doxorubicin-DNA intercalation during the earliest stages of apoptosis. The fluorescence lifetime of doxorubicin in nuclei is found to decrease rapidly during the first 2 hours following drug administration, suggesting significant changes in the doxorubicin-DNA binding site’s microenvironment upon apoptosis initiation. Decreases in doxorubicin fluorescence lifetimes were found to be concurrent with increases in phosphorylation of H2AX (an immediate signal of DNA double-strand breakage), but preceded activation of caspase-3 (a late signature of apoptosis) by more than 150 minutes. Time-dependent doxorubicin FLIM analyses of the effects of pretreating cells with either Cyclopentylidene-[4-(4-chlorophenyl)thiazol-2-yl)-hydrazine (a histone acetyltransferase inhibitor) or Trichostatin A (a histone deacetylase inhibitor) revealed significant correlation of fluorescence lifetime with the stage of chromatin decondensation. Taken together, our findings suggest that monitoring the dynamics of doxorubicin fluorescence lifetimes can provide valuable information during the earliest phases of doxorubicin-induced apoptosis; and implicate that FLIM can serve as a sensitive, high-resolution tool for the elucidation of intercellular mechanisms and kinetics of anti-cancer drugs that bear fluorescent moieties.     

Fluorescence lifetime imaging.

We describe a new fluorescence imaging methodology in which the image contrast is derived from the fluorescence lifetime at each point in a two-dimensional image and not the local concentration and/or intensity of the fluorophore. In the present apparatus, lifetime images are created from a series of images obtained with a gain-modulated image intensifier. The frequency of gain modulation is at the light-modulation frequency (or a harmonic thereof), resulting in homodyne phase-sensitive images. These stationary phase-sensitive images are collected using a slow-scan CCD camera. A series of such images, obtained with various phase shifts of the gain-modulation signal, is used to determine the phase angle and/or modulation of the emission at each pixel, which is in essence the phase or modulation lifetime image. An advantage of this method is that pixel-to-pixel scanning is not required to obtain the images, as the information from all pixels is obtained at the same time. The method has been experimentally verified by creating lifetime images of standard fluorophores with known lifetimes, ranging from 1 to 10 ns. As an example of biochemical imaging we created life-time images of Yt-base when quenched by acrylamide, as a model for a fluorophore in distinct environments that affect its decay time. Additionally, we describe a faster imaging procedure that allows images in which a specific decay time is suppressed to be calculated, allowing rapid visualization of unique features and/or regions with distinct decay times. The concepts and methodologies of fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM) have numerous potential applications in the biosciences. Fluorescence lifetimes are known to be sensitive to numerous chemical and physical factors such as pH, oxygen, temperature, cations, polarity, and binding to macromolecules. Hence the FLIM method allows chemical or physical imaging of macroscopic and microscopic samples.     

Time-resolved FRET fluorescence spectroscopy of visible fluorescent protein pairs

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a powerful method for obtaining information about small-scale lengths between biomacromolecules. Visible fluorescent proteins (VFPs) are widely used as spectrally different FRET pairs, where one VFP acts as a donor and another VFP as an acceptor. The VFPs are usually fused to the proteins of interest, and this fusion product is genetically encoded in cells. FRET between VFPs can be determined by analysis of either the fluorescence decay properties of the donor molecule or the rise time of acceptor fluorescence. Time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy is the technique of choice to perform these measurements. FRET can be measured not only in solution, but also in living cells by the technique of fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM), where fluorescence lifetimes are determined with the spatial resolution of an optical microscope. Here we focus attention on time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy of purified, selected VFPs (both single VFPs and FRET pairs of VFPs) in cuvette-type experiments. For quantitative interpretation of FRET–FLIM experiments in cellular systems, details of the molecular fluorescence are needed that can be obtained from experiments with isolated VFPs. For analysis of the time-resolved fluorescence experiments of VFPs, we have utilised the maximum entropy method procedure to obtain a distribution of fluorescence lifetimes. Distributed lifetime patterns turn out to have diagnostic value, for instance, in observing populations of VFP pairs that are FRET-inactive.     

Wide-Field Multi-Parameter FLIM: long-term minimal invasive observation of proteins in living cells

Time-domain Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscopy (FLIM) is a remarkable tool to monitor the dynamics of fluorophore-tagged protein domains inside living cells. We propose a Wide-Field Multi-Parameter FLIM method (WFMP-FLIM) aimed to monitor continuously living cells under minimum light intensity at a given illumination energy dose. A powerful data analysis technique applied to the WFMP-FLIM data sets allows to optimize the estimation accuracy of physical parameters at very low fluorescence signal levels approaching the lower bound theoretical limit. We demonstrate the efficiency of WFMP-FLIM by presenting two independent and relevant long-term experiments in cell biology: 1) FRET analysis of simultaneously recorded donor and acceptor fluorescence in living HeLa cells and 2) tracking of mitochondrial transport combined with fluorescence lifetime analysis in neuronal processes.