Fate of ganglionic synapses and ganglion cell axons during normal and induced cell death

In order to understand the significance of cell death in the formation of neural circuits, it is necessary to determine whether before cell death neurons have (a) sent axons to the periphery; (b) reached the proper target organs; and (c) have established synaptic connections with them. Axon counts demonstrated that, after sending out initial axons, ciliary cells sprouted numerous collaterals at the time of peripheral synapse formation. Subsequently, large numbers of axons were lost from the nerves, slightly later than the onset of ganglion cell death. A secondary loss of collaterals later occurred unaccompanied by cell death. Measurements of conduction velocity and axon diameters indicated that all ganglion cell axons grew down the proper pathways from the start, but it was not possible to determine whether all axons had actually formed proper synapses. This was ascertained, however, in the ganglion itself where preganglionic fibres were shown to synapse selectively with all ganglion cells before cell death. During this period, degenerating preganglionic synapses were observed on normal cells. It can therefore be inferred that at least some preganglionics established proper synapses before dying and that a single synapse is not sufficient to prevent cell death. In this system neither preganglionic nor ganglionic cell death seems designed to remove improper connections but rather to remove cells that have not competed effectively for a sufficient number of synapses, resulting in a quantitative matching up of neuron numbers.     

Inhibitors of protein synthesis and RNA synthesis prevent neuronal death caused by nerve growth factor deprivation

We have developed an experimental paradigm to study the mechanism by which nerve growth factor (NGF) allows the survival of sympathetic neurons. Dissociated sympathetic neurons from embryonic day-21 rats were grown in vitro for 7 d in the presence of NGF. Neurons were then deprived of trophic support by adding anti-NGF antiserum, causing them to die between 24 and 48 h later. Ultrastructural changes included disruption of neurites, followed by cell body changes characterized by an accumulation of lipid droplets, changes in the nuclear membrane, and dilation of the rough endoplasmic reticulum. No primary alterations of mitochondria or lysosomes were observed. The death of NGF-deprived neurons was characterized biochemically by assessing [35S]methionine incorporation into TCA precipitable protein and by measuring the release of the cytosolic enzyme adenylate kinase into the culture medium. Methionine incorporation began to decrease approximately 18 h post-deprivation and was maximally depressed by 36 h. Adenylate kinase began to appear in the culture medium approximately 30 h after deprivation, reaching a maximum by 54 h. The death of NGF-deprived neurons was entirely prevented by inhibiting protein or RNA synthesis. Cycloheximide, puromycin, anisomycin, actinomycin-D, and dichlorobenzimidazole riboside all prevented neuronal death subsequent to NGF deprivation as assessed by the above morphologic and biochemical criteria. The fact that sympathetic neurons must synthesize protein and RNA to die when deprived of NGF indicates that NGF, and presumably other neurotrophic factors, maintains neuronal survival by suppressing an endogenous, active death program.     

Interactions between neurons and their targets during in vivo synaptogenesis.

In vivo synaptogenesis is described in a simple vertebrate system, the chick ciliary ganglion, a parasympathetic autonomic ganglion. An attempt is made to integrate anatomical, physiological and biochemical observations during synapse formation in the ganglion and in the peripheral target structures; the iris, ciliary muscle, and smooth muscle of the choroid coat. The relationship between synaptogenesis and neuron survival is explored, and it is shown that a critically timed interaction between the neuron and target organ is necessary for full neuronal maturation and survival. The existence of an active competition between neurons for survival is documented, and the possible relationship between neuronal cell death and specificity of connections is discussed.     

CELL DEATH IN THE EMBRYONIC CHICK SPINAL CORD

The events which occur in the death of visceromotor neurons of the cervical region of the chick embryo's spinal cord have been analyzed by electron microscopy. These normal degenerative events are compared with those in the lumbosacral cord where nerve cell death was induced by removal of peripheral organs. The initial set of degenerative changes include a decrease in nuclear size, the clumping of chromatin beneath the nuclear envelope, an increase in electron opacity of the cells, the disappearance of Golgi bodies, and the disaggregation of polysomes. These events are followed by the loss of the nuclear envelope and most of the endoplasmic reticulum, the appearance of bundles of filaments, and the formation of many ribosome crystals. Ribosome crystals are seen only in the dying cells. Their abundance may indicate a drastic reduction in RNA synthesis as one of the initial events which lead to the death of these neurons. The neurons are finally subdivided and engulfed by cells of the normal glial population, and further breakdown of the cell fragments occurs in large phagocytic vesicles of the gliocytes.     

Survival, synaptogenesis, and regeneration of adult mouse spiral ganglion neurons in vitro

The inner ear spiral ganglion is populated by bipolar neurons connecting the peripheral sensory receptors, the hair cells, with central neurons in auditory brain stem nuclei. Hearing impairment is often a consequence of hair cell death, e.g., from acoustic trauma. When deprived of their peripheral targets, the spiral ganglion neurons (SGNs) progressively degenerate. For effective clinical treatment using cochlear prostheses, it is essential to maintain the SGN population. To investigate their survival dependence, synaptogenesis, and regenerative capacity, adult mouse SGNs were separated from hair cells and studied in vitro in the presence of various neurotrophins and growth factors. Coadministration of fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2) and glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) provided support for long-term survival, while FGF-2 alone could strongly promote neurite regeneration. Fibroblast growth factor receptor FGFR-3-IIIc was found to upregulate and translocate to the nucleus in surviving SGNs. Surviving SGNs formed contacts with other SGNs after they were deprived of the signals from the hair cells. In coculture experiments, neurites extending from SGNs projected toward hair cells. Interestingly, adult mouse spiral ganglion cells could carry out both symmetric and asymmetric cell division and give rise to new neurons. The authors propose that a combination of FGF-2 and GDNF could be an efficient route for clinical intervention of secondary degeneration of SGNs. The authors also demonstrate that the adult mammalian inner ear retains progenitor cells, which could commit neurogenesis.     

Age-associated synapse elimination in mouse parasympathetic ganglia

Little is known about the effects of aging on synapses in the mammalian nervous system. We examined the innervation of individual mouse submandibular ganglion (SMG) neurons for evidence of age-related changes in synapse efficacy and number. For approximately 85% of adult life expectancy (30 months) the efficacy of synaptic transmission, as determined by excitatory postsynaptic potential (EPSP) amplitudes, remains constant. Similarly, the number of synapses contacting individual SMG neurons is also unchanged. After 30 months of age, however, some neurons (23%) dramatically lose synaptic input exhibiting both smaller EPSP amplitude and fewer synaptic boutons. Attenuation of both the amplitude and frequency of miniature EPSPs was also observed in neurons from aged animals. Electron micrographs revealed that, although there were many vesicle-laden preganglionic axonal processes in the vicinity of the postsynaptic membrane, the number of synaptic contacts was significantly lower in old animals. These results demonstrate primary, age-associated synapse elimination with functional consequences that cannot be explained by pre- or postsynaptic cell death.     

Somatostatin-like immunoreactivity in the retinae of adult and embryonic chickens

Somatostatin, a tetradecapeptide that inhibits growth hormone release, has a widespread distribution in the central and peripheral nervous systems and other cell types. In the present investigation, the chicken neural retina was studied for the presence of structures exhibiting somatostatin-like immunoreactivity by utilizing an indirect immunofluorescence technique. Controls for specificity of staining were performed on alternate sections. Several types of distinctly labeled neurons and their processes were evident in sections of adult and late embryonic retinae. Cresyl violet staining showed that these neurons, which were scattered peripherally and more numerous centrally, occupied several strata within the inner nuclear, inner plexiform, and ganglion cell layers. Labeled neurites of immunoreactive perikarya coursed within these layers as well, often approaching other immunoreactive cells and fibers. The morphology and position of the somatostatin-containing neurons indicated that these neurons were amacrine, horizontal, or ganglion associational cells. These findings indicate that somatostatin is first detectable in the retina during the late embryonic stages of the chicken.     

Apoptosis of inner hair cells caused by laser ablation of their spiral ganglion neurons in cultures of the mouse organ of Corti

Laser beam ablation of spiral ganglion neurons was performed in seven organotypic cultures of the newborn mouse cochlea between 5 and 8 days in vitro, with a recovery period of from 18 hours to 3 days. Direct somatic injury (laser or mechanical) inflicted on hair cells does not necessarily cause their death; many of them survive, repair damage and re-establish their neurosensory connections. By contrast, laser irradiation and ablation of their afferent spiral ganglion neurons causes a most spectacular degeneration of sensory cells within 18–48 hours after the insult. Ultrastructurally, the degenerated hair cells—characteristically the inner hair cells—display “dark-cell vacuolar degeneration” that combines the signs of apoptotic death (the peripheral condensation of nuclear chromatin and nuclear pyknosis) with signs of cell edema, vacuolization and necrosis. The ultimate condensation of the cytoplasm gives the dead cells a jet black appearance. The irradiated spiral ganglion neurons die displaying similar pathological characteristics. The extent and locus of inner hair cell degeneration correspond to that of ablated spiral ganglion neurons: ultimately the ablation of one neuron causes degeneration of a single inner hair cell within the closest radial segment of the afferent innervation. The elimination of spiral ganglion neurons by mechanical means does not affect hair cell survival. It is inferred that the laser pulse acts as a stimulus depolarizing the neuronal membrane of the spiral ganglion neurons and their radial fibers and causing the excitotoxic death of their synaptic sensory cells through excessive stimulation of the glutamatergic receptors. Reciprocal pre-and postsynaptic synapses between the afferent dendrites and inner hair cells in culture could possibly serve as entryways of the stimulus. The pathogenesis of this apparent transsynaptically-induced apoptotic death of inner hair cells will be further examined in culture.     

Inhibition of repulsive guidance molecule,RGMa, increases afferent synapse formation with auditory hair cells

The peripheral fibers that extend from auditory neurons to hair cells are sensitive to damage, and replacement of the fibers and their afferent synapse with hair cells would be of therapeutic interest. Here, we show that RGMa, a repulsive guidance molecule previously shown to play a role in the development of the chick visual system, is expressed in the developing, newborn, and mature mouse inner ear. The effect of RGMa on synaptogenesis between afferent neurons and hair cells, from which afferent connections had been removed, was assessed. Contact of neural processes with hair cells and elaboration of postsynaptic densities at sites of the ribbon synapse were increased by treatment with a blocking antibody to RGMa, and pruning of auditory fibers to achieve the mature branching pattern of afferent neurons was accelerated. Inhibition by RGMa could thus explain why auditory neurons have a low capacity to regenerate peripheral processes: postnatal spiral ganglion neurons retain the capacity to send out processes that respond to signals for synapse formation, but expression of RGMa postnatally appears to be detrimental to regeneration of afferent hair cell innervation and antagonizes synaptogenesis. Increased synaptogenesis after inhibition of RGMa suggests that manipulation of guidance or inhibitory factors may provide a route to increase formation of new synapses at deafferented hair cells. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Develop Neurobiol 74: 457–466, 2014     

Age‐associated synapse elimination in mouse parasympathetic ganglia

Little is known about the effects of aging on synapses in the mammalian nervous system. We examined the innervation of individual mouse submandibular ganglion (SMG) neurons for evidence of age‐related changes in synapse efficacy and number. For approximately 85% of adult life expectancy (30 months) the efficacy of synaptic transmission, as determined by excitatory postsynaptic potential (EPSP) amplitudes, remains constant. Similarly, the number of synapses contacting individual SMG neurons is also unchanged. After 30 months of age, however, some neurons (23%) dramatically lose synaptic input exhibiting both smaller EPSP amplitude and fewer synaptic boutons. Attenuation of both the amplitude and frequency of miniature EPSPs was also observed in neurons from aged animals. Electron micrographs revealed that, although there were many vesicle‐laden preganglionic axonal processes in the vicinity of the postsynaptic membrane, the number of synaptic contacts was significantly lower in old animals. These results demonstrate primary, age‐associated synapse elimination with functional consequences that cannot be explained by pre‐ or postsynaptic cell death. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Neurobiol 60: 214–226, 2004     

The development of the pattern of retinal ganglion cells in the chick retina: mechanisms that control differentiation

Neurons in both vertebrate and invertebrate eyes are organized in regular arrays. Although much is known about the mechanisms involved in the formation of the regular arrays of neurons found in invertebrate eyes, much less is known about the mechanisms of formation of neuronal mosaics in the vertebrate eye. The purpose of these studies was to determine the cellular mechanisms that pattern the first neurons in vertebrate retina, the retinal ganglion cells. We have found that the ganglion cells in the chick retina develop as a patterned array that spreads from the central to peripheral retina as a wave front of differentiation. The onset of ganglion cell differentiation keeps pace with overall retinal growth; however, there is no clear cell cycle synchronization at the front of differentiation of the first ganglion cells. The differentiation of ganglion cells is not dependent on signals from previously formed ganglion cells, since isolation of the peripheral retina by as much as 400 microm from the front of ganglion cell differentiation does not prevent new ganglion cells from developing. Consistent with previous studies, blocking FGF receptor activation with a specific inhibitor to the FGFRs retards the movement of the front of ganglion cell differentiation, while application of exogenous FGF1 causes the precocious development of ganglion cells in peripheral retina. Our observations, taken together with those of previous studies, support a role for FGFs and FGF receptor activation in the initial development of retinal ganglion cells from the undifferentiated neuroepithelium peripheral to the expanding wave front of differentiation.     

Connectivity of identified central synapses in the cricket is normal following regeneration and blockade of presynaptic activity

Cercal sensory neurons in the cricket innervate interneurons in the central nervous system (CNS) and provide a model system for studying the formation of central synapses. When axons of the sensory neurons were transected during larval development, the cell bodies and the soma-bearing portion of axons, which are located within the cercus, survived but lost their excitability for 9-10 days. During this period, the sensory neurons grew new axons and reinnervated the terminal abdominal ganglion. Physiological recordings showed that sensory neurons of known identity reestablished monosynaptic contacts with their normal postsynaptic interneuron. Moreover, each synapse exhibited a characteristic strength indistinguishable from the intact synapse in an unoperated cricket. Since this selective connectivity was apparent immediately after the excitability of the axotomized sensory neurons was restored, action potentials in the sensory neurons appear to be unnecessary for normal synaptic regeneration to occur. Consistent with this, the reinnervation process was unaffected even when action potentials in the sensory neurons were blocked by tetrodotoxin (TTX) immediately following axotomy until just before testing. During the normal course of development, the characteristic strength of individual synapses changes systematically, resulting in the developmental rearrangement of these synapses (Chiba et al., 1988). This synaptic rearrangement was also unaffected when action potentials in the sensory neurons were blocked by TTX for the last 30% of larval development. Therefore, in the cricket cercal sensory system, both regeneration of the central synapses following axotomy of the presynaptic sensory neurons and the normal rearrangement of connectivity during larval development appear not to require axonal action potentials.     

The Ability of Diphenylpiperazines to Prevent Neuronal Death in Dorsal Root Ganglion Neurons In Vitro After Nerve Growth Factor Deprivation and In Vivo After Axotomy

Abstract: The mechanism of neuroprotection by the calcium channel antagonist flunarizine against neuronal death is unknown. We investigated the ability of other calcium channel antagonists (cinnarizine, nimodipine, nicardipine, diltiazem, and verapamil), calmodulin antagonists, and calpain inhibitors to prevent neuronal death in rat dorsal root ganglion neurons in vitro after nerve growth factor (NGF) deprivation and the ability of cinnarizine and diltiazem to protect in vivo after axotomy. In vitro, only neurons treated with cinnarizine or flunarizine were protected from death after withdrawal. In vivo, cinnarizine, but not diltiazem, protected dorsal root ganglion neurons in rats after unilateral sciatic nerve crush. Intracellular calcium concentration ([Ca²⁺],) was evaluated with fura 2 after NGF deprivation In vitro. Neurons "committed to die" 24 h after NGF deprivation displayed a decline in [Ca^a+], before visible morphological deterioration consistent with cell death. The influx of extracellular calcium was not necessary to produce neuronal death. Neurons deprived of NGF gradually lost the ability to respond to elevated external potassium with an increase in [Ca²⁺], during the first 24 h after trophic factor deprivation. After 24 h, neurons deprived of NGF could not be rescued by readministration of NGF. Neurons protected from cell death with diphenylpiperazines maintained their response to high external potassium, suggesting continued membrane integrity. We speculate that diphenylpiperazines may protect sensory neurons via an unknown mechanism that stabilizes cell membranes.     

Naturally occurring and induced neuronal death in the chick embryo in vivo requires protein and RNA synthesis: evidence for the role of cell death genes.

Treatment of chick embryos in ovo for 10-12 hr with inhibitors of protein and RNA synthesis during the peak time of normal cell death (Embryonic Day 8) for motoneurons and dorsal root ganglion cells markedly reduces the number of degenerating neurons in these populations. The massive neuronal death induced by the early absence of the limbs was also blocked almost completely by these agents. Further, the death of neurons following peripheral axotomy at the end of the normal cell death period (Embryonic Day 10) was reduced significantly by treatment with inhibitors of biosynthetic reactions. These results indicate that, in vivo, naturally occurring neuronal death, neuronal death induced by the absence of peripheral targets, and axotomy-induced neuronal death later in development all require active gene expression and protein and RNA synthesis. Therefore, neuronal death in a variety of situations may reflect the expression of a developmental fate that can normally only be overridden or suppressed by specific environmental signals (e.g., neurotrophic molecules).     

Loss And Survival of Spiral Ganglion Neurons in the Guinea Pig After Intracochlear Perfusion with Aminoglycosides

Loss of cochlear hair cells results in a loss of ganglion cells and further neurodegenerative changes throughout the auditory pathway. Understanding more about the early stages of ganglion cell loss in vivo may lead to ways of ameliorating or preventing the loss of these neurons. To examine these stages, the effects of intracochlear perfusion with aminoglycoside antibiotics on the organ of Corti and spiral ganglion cells were evaluated in young adult guinea pigs at survival periods ranging from 1 hour to 12 weeks, using immunocytochemical and ultrastructural techniques. At 1 hour survival a base-to-apex gradient of damage was indicated in the cochlea by the appearance of severely damaged hair cells and injured ganglion cells in the basal coil while in the apical coil, hair cells were damaged but intact and ganglion cells appeared normal. By 4 hours the appearance of severely disrupted hair cells and damaged ganglion cells had extended throughout the cochlea. The ultrastructural appearance of many injured ganglion cells demonstrated features characteristic of cell death including condensed cytoplasm, non-marginal clumping of nuclear chromatin, and wrinkled nuclear membrane. Despite the loss of many ganglion cells, a population of these cells remained at 12 weeks survival. These contained large amounts of rough endoplasmic reticulum, were unmyelinated apart from the central process and were surrounded by satellite cells. These features are typical of ganglion cells during development, before the onset of hearing. Immunolabelling of cochlear whole mounts after hair cell destruction with protein gene product 9.5 (PGP 9.5) revealed the presence of neural elements in the organ of Corti at up to 12 weeks survival. These may associated with the remaining ganglion cells. In these surviving ganglion cells, the intense labelling with PGP 9.5 together with the increase in rough endoplasmic reticulum, indicates the presence of active protein synthesis which may be connected with their survival.     

Morphofunctional study of the organization of the peripheral parenchyma of Acoela Oxyposthia praedator

The ultrastructure of undifferentiated cells in the peripheral parenchyma of Oxyposthia praedator was studied, along with the ways of their differentiation. The type I cells (3.5-4.0 microns in diameter) undergo mitotic division, while the type II cells (9 microns in diameter) produce specialized cells of the parenchyma. At the beginning of secretory cell differentiation one cistern of the rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER) is formed by the outer membrane of the nuclear envelope, the formation of other cisternae follows. The Golgi complex is formed simultaneously. The differentiated secretory cells are characterized by the abundance of RER cisternae and Golgi complexes. In the course of differentiation of other cell types RER cisternae are formed by several portions of the nuclear envelope. The Golgi complex appears in cells 12-14 microns long. The differentiation of digestive cells is characterized by autophagy. Autophagosomes are formed by RER cisternae. The consecutive stages of autophagosome formation are described. Using a cytochemical reaction revealing acid phosphatase the process of digestion of the autophagosome content was followed.     

Blockade of PARP activity attenuates poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation but offers only partial neuroprotection against NMDA-induced cell death in the rat retina

Recent reports have linked neuronal cell death by necrosis to poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase-1 (PARP-1) hyperactivation. It is believed that under stress, the activity of this enzyme is up-regulated, resulting in extensive poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation of nuclear proteins, using NAD(+) as its substrate, which, in turn, leads to the depletion of NAD(+). In efforts to restore the level of NAD(+), depletion of ATP occurs, resulting in the shutdown of ATP-dependent ionic pumps. This results in cell swelling and eventual loss of membrane selectivity, hallmarks of necrosis. Reports from in vitro and in vivo studies in the brain have shown that NMDA receptor activation stimulates PARP activity and that blockade of the enzyme provides substantial neuroprotection. The present study was undertaken to determine whether PARP activity is regulated by NMDA in the rat retina, and whether blockade of PARP activity provides protection against toxic effects of NMDA. Rat retinas exposed to intravitreal injections containing NMDA, with or without the PARP inhibitor N-(6-oxo-5, 6-dihydrophenanthridin-2-yl)-(N,-dimethylamino) acetamide hydrochloride (PJ-34), were assessed for changes in PARP-1 activity as evidenced by poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation (PAR), loss of membrane integrity, morphological indicators of apoptosis and necrosis, and ganglion cell loss. Results showed that: NMDA increased PAR formation in a concentration-dependent manner and caused a decline in retinal ATP levels; PJ-34 blockade attenuated the NMDA-induced formation of PAR and decline in ATP; NMDA induced the loss of membrane selectivity to ethidium bromide (EtBr) in inner retinal neurons, but loss of membrane selectivity was not prevented by blocking PARP activity; cells stained with EtBr, or reacted for TUNEL-labeling, displayed features characteristic of both apoptosis and necrosis. In the presence of PJ-34, greater numbers of cells exhibited apoptotic features; PJ-34 provided partial neuroprotection against NMDA-induced ganglion cell loss. These findings suggest that although blockade of PARP activity fully attenuates NMDA-induced PAR formation and loss of retinal ATP content, and improves the survival of select populations of ganglion cells, this approach does not provide full neuroprotection. In contrast, blockade of PARP activity promotes apoptotic-like cell death in the majority of cells undergoing cell death. Furthermore, these studies show that the loss of membrane selectivity is not dependent upon PAR formation or the resulting decline of ATP, and suggests that an alternative pathway, other than PARP activation, exists to mediate this event.     

Early patterns of neuronal degeneration in the retina of the goldfish after optic nerve sectioning

The early patterns of retinal degeneration were studied in the goldfish after optic nerve sectioning by l.m. and e.m. Beginning on the 2nd postsurgical day there was an initial degeneration of neurons in the ganglion cell and inner nuclear layers of the central retina. Massive ganglion cell degeneration in the whole retina (60%) as well as degeneration of neurons in inner and outer nuclear layer of the peripheral retina was evident around the 7th postsurgical day. The early degenerating cells appeared to be cones and cone bipolars.     

Cell death and neuronal replacement during formation of the avian ciliary ganglion

Programmed cell death is a prominent feature of embryonic development and is essential in matching the number of neurons to the target tissues that are innervated. Although a decrease in neuronal number which coincides with peripheral synaptogenesis has been well documented in the avian ciliary ganglion, it has not been clear whether cell death also occurs earlier. We observed TUNEL-positive neurons as early as stage 24, with a large peak at stage 29. This cell death at stage 29 was followed by a statistically significant (P < 0.0001) decrease in total neuron number at stage 31. The total number of neurons was recovered by stage 33/34. This suggested that dying neurons were replaced by new neurons. This replacement process did not involve proliferation because bromodeoxyuridine applied at stages 29 and 31 was unable to label neurons harvested at stage 33/34. The peak of cell death at stage 29 was increased 2.3-fold by removal of the optic vesicle and was reduced by 50% when chCNTF was overexpressed. Taken together, these results suggest that the regulation of neuron number in the ciliary ganglion is a dynamic process involving both cell death and neural replacement from postmitotic precursors prior to differentiation and innervation of target tissues.