Comparing Symbiotic Efficiency between Swollen versus Nonswollen Rhizobial Bacteroids

Symbiotic rhizobia differentiate physiologically and morphologically into nitrogen-fixing bacteroids inside legume host nodules. The differentiation is apparently terminal in some legume species, such as peas (Pisum sativum) and peanuts (Arachis hypogaea), likely due to extreme cell swelling induced by the host. In other legume species, such as beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) and cowpeas (Vigna unguiculata), differentiation into bacteroids, which are similar in size and shape to free-living rhizobia, is reversible. Bacteroid modification by plants may affect the effectiveness of the symbiosis. Here, we compare symbiotic efficiency of rhizobia in two different hosts where the rhizobia differentiate into swollen nonreproductive bacteroids in one host and remain nonswollen and reproductive in the other. Two such dual-host strains were tested: Rhizobium leguminosarum A34 in peas and beans and Bradyrhizobium sp. 32H1 in peanuts and cowpeas. In both comparisons, swollen bacteroids conferred more net host benefit by two measures: return on nodule construction cost (plant growth per gram nodule growth) and nitrogen fixation efficiency (H₂ production by nitrogenase per CO₂ respired). Terminal bacteroid differentiation among legume species has evolved independently multiple times, perhaps due to the increased host fitness benefits observed in this study.Legume-rhizobia interactions vary widely across a diverse paraphyletic group of soil bacteria known for symbiotic nitrogen fixation inside root nodules of over 18,000 species of legumes throughout the world (Lewis et al., 2005). In several legume species, rhizobial cells are induced to swell during their differentiation into nitrogen-fixing bacteroids (Oono et al., 2010). These legume species belong to five different major papilionoid clades (inverted repeat-lacking clade, genistoids, dalbergioids, mirbelioids, and millettioids), a pattern suggestive of convergent evolution. Swelling apparently leads to terminal differentiation; swollen bacteroids no longer divide normally (Zhou et al., 1985). In other legume host species, bacteroid differentiation is less extreme, leading to nonswollen bacteroids. Nonswollen bacteroids are similar in shape and size to free-living rhizobia and divide normally once outside of their nodules. The proximate mechanisms for host-imposed bacteroid swelling have been investigated (Van de Velde et al., 2010), but what drove the repeated evolution of this trait? The multiple independent origins of host traits causing bacteroids to swell suggest that swollen bacteroids may provide more net benefit to legumes. Could the swelling of bacteroids improve nitrogen fixation efficiency (e.g. nitrogen fixed relative to carbon cost)? In this study, we compare symbiotic efficiencies of rhizobia in legume hosts that are evolutionarily diverged but share a common effective rhizobial strain, whose bacteroids are swollen in one host and nonswollen in the other.Variations among host species in benefits and costs of symbiosis with rhizobia are not commonly explored (Thrall et al., 2000) because legume species typically nodulate with only one group of rhizobia (e.g. Sinorhizobium sp. in Medicago), although some legumes and some rhizobia are more promiscuous. Rhizobium sp. NGR234 has the largest known host range but does not fix nitrogen effectively with any legume species currently recognized to induce swelling of rhizobial bacteroids (Pueppke and Broughton, 1999). Some Sinorhizobium fredii strains apparently fix nitrogen in certain cultivars of soybean (Glycine max; hosting nonswollen bacteroids) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa; hosting swollen bacteroids; Hashem et al., 1997), but our efforts to replicate these results did not lead to successful nodulation. Therefore, we studied two strains, a transgenic strain that nodulates beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) and peas (Pisum sativum) and a second wild strain harvested from cowpeas (Vigna unguiculata) that also nodulates peanuts (Arachis hypogaea). Beans and cowpeas are both within the Phaseolid group and do not induce terminal differentiation of rhizobial bacteroids. Peas and peanuts both host terminally differentiated bacteroids but are in distant clades and likely have different genetic origins for traits that induce terminal differentiation (Oono et al., 2010). Also, the swollen bacteroids in peas are branched while those in peanuts are spherical.Differences in symbiotic qualities between swollen and nonswollen bacteroids have been previously explored in peanuts and cowpeas by Sen and Weaver (1980, 1981, 1984), who also hypothesized that swollen bacteroids are more beneficial to the host plant than nonswollen ones. They found 1.5 to 3 times greater acetylene reduction by nitrogenase (as well as plant nitrogen) per nodule mass in peanuts than in cowpeas at multiple nodule ages (Sen and Weaver, 1980). Acetylene reduction per bacteroid was also greater in peanuts than in cowpeas when measuring whole nodules, but this difference disappeared when isolated bacteroids were assayed (Sen and Weaver, 1984). They concluded that swelling of peanut bacteroids per se was not responsible for the higher rate of nitrogen fixation per bacteroid. They suggested that in cowpea nodules, with greater numbers of smaller bacteroids per nodule volume, availability of oxygen to each bacteroid might be restricted such that the rate of oxidative phosphorylation, necessary for nitrogen fixation, is reduced. Fixation rates per bacteroid may be different between hosts due to nodule gas permeability or bacteroid crowding within nodules. However, fixation efficiency (nitrogen fixed per carbon respired) would not necessarily be affected by these and may be more important for the host than the rate of fixation.Rhizobial performances are often compared by measuring the symbiotic benefits, e.g. rates of acetylene reduction or plant growth (Sen and Weaver, 1984; Hashem et al., 1997; Lodwig et al., 2005), but rarely by measuring the symbiotic costs, e.g. carbon consumed or respired. Up to 25% of a legume’s net photosynthate may be required for nitrogen fixation by rhizobia (Minchin et al., 1981). Faster fixation rates (mol nitrogen per s) can be beneficial for hosts, but carbon costs can also be important. Rhizobia that fix more nitrogen per carbon respired could free more carbon for other functions, including the option of supporting more nodules with the same amount of photosynthate. If legumes are sometimes carbon limited, then improved carbon-use efficiency could enhance plant fitness. Measuring both benefits and costs is therefore key to an accurate understanding of the symbiotic performance of a rhizobial strain.While we recognize the many physiological differences between peas and beans or peanuts and cowpeas, the fact that terminal differentiation induced by host legumes evolved multiple times independently (Oono et al., 2010) suggests there may be some consistent host symbiotic benefit, such as improved fixation efficiency. Here, we measured the efficiency of each of two strains as swollen bacteroids in one host and nonswollen bacteroids in another. We measured nitrogenase activity as hydrogen (H₂) production in an N₂-free atmosphere (Layzell et al., 1984; Witty and Minchin, 1998), and compared it to carbon dioxide (CO₂) respiration to estimate return on nodule operation cost. We also compared host biomass growth per total nodule mass growth to estimate return on nodule construction cost. To further assess carbon allocation to the different types of bacteroids, we also measured the average amounts per bacteroid of polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB), an energy storage compound that can comprise up to 50% of bacteroid dry weight (Trainer and Charles, 2006). A greater PHB accumulation per bacteroid may require a decreased allocation of carbon for nitrogenase activity within the bacteroids, and hence, less plant growth per carbon invested in bacteroids. We demonstrate that peas and peanuts that host swollen bacteroids have higher fixation efficiency as well as greater plant return on nodule construction than beans and cowpeas, respectively, nodulated with the same rhizobial strains. PHB was not consistently correlated with plant:nodule growth efficiency with the tested strains. These findings show that swollen bacteroids can indeed provide greater benefits to their legume hosts.     

The origins of uncooperative rhizobia

Mutualisms are thought to be destabilized by exploitative mutants that receive benefits from partners without reciprocation. Nonetheless, there is surprisingly little evidence for the spread of exploitation in mutualist populations. In particular mutualisms, non‐beneficial partners are commonplace and this raises the question of whether exploitation is invading as an adaptive strategy. Here, we highlight the legume–rhizobium mutualism as a key test case. Rhizobial bacteria fix nitrogen in legume roots in exchange for carbon from their hosts. However, non‐beneficial rhizobia are widespread, including non‐fixing and non‐nodulating strains. Recent research has shown that legumes can punish some uncooperative rhizobia and substantially reduce their fitness, but these sanctions must not be universally effective. Important questions about uncooperative rhizobia remain unresolved. (1) Is it adaptive for rhizobia to be uncooperative with hosts? (2) Do uncooperative rhizobia evolve from cooperative ancestors? (3) What are the mechanisms of rhizobial exploitation? We describe experimental approaches and testable hypotheses that address these gaps in our knowledge.     

Evolutionary dynamics of rhizopine within spatially structured rhizobium populations

Symbiosis between legumes and nitrogen-fixing bacteria is thought to bring mutual benefit to each participant. However, it is not known how rhizobia benefit from nodulating legume hosts because they fix nitrogen only after becoming bacteroids, which are terminally differentiated cells that cannot reproduce. Because undifferentiated rhizobia in and around the nodule can reproduce, evolution of symbiotic nitrogen fixation may depend upon kin selection. In some hosts, these kin may persist in the nodule as viable, undifferentiated bacteria. In other hosts, no viable rhizobia survive to reproduce after nodule senescence. Bacteroids in these hosts may benefit their free-living kin by enhancing production of plant root exudates. However, unrelated non-mutualists may also benefit from increased plant exudates. Rhizopines, compounds produced by bacteroids in nodules and catabolized only by related free-living rhizobia, may provide a mechanism by which bacteroids can preferentially benefit kin. Despite this apparent advantage, rhizopine genotypes are relatively rare. We constructed a mathematical model to examine how mixing within rhizobium populations influences the evolution of rhizopine genotypes. Our model predicts that the success of rhizopine genotypes is strongly dependent upon the spatial genetic structure of the bacterial population; rhizopine is more likely to dominate well-mixed populations. Further, for a given level of mixing, we find that rhizopine evolves under a positive frequency-dependent process in which stochastic accumulation of rhizopine alleles is necessary for rhizopine establishment. This process leads to increased spatial structure in rhizobium populations, and suggests that rhizopine may expand the conditions under which nitrogen fixation can evolve via kin selection.     

The Rhizobium--legume symbiosis.

The rhizobia are soil microorganisms that can interact with leguminous plants to form root nodules within which conditions are favourable for bacterial nitrogen fixation. Legumes allow the development of very large rhizobial populations in the vicinity of their roots. Infections and nodule formation require the specific recognition of host and Rhizobium, probably mediated by plant lectins. Penetration of the host by a compatible Rhizobium species usually provokes host root cell division to form the nodule, and a process of differentiation by both partners then ensues. In most cases the rhizobia alter morphologically to form bacteroids, which are usually larger than the free-living bacteria and have altered cell walls. At all stages during infection, the bacteria are bounded by host cell plasmalemma. The enzyme nitrogenase is synthesized by the bacteria and, if leghaemoglobin is present, nitrogen fixation will occur. Leghaemoglobin is a product of the symbiotic interaction, since the globin is produced by the plant while the haem is synthesized by the bacteria. In the intracellular habitat the bacteria are dependent upon the plant for supplies of energy and the bacteroids, in particular, appear to differentiate so that they are no longer able to utilize the nitrogen that they fix. Regulation of the supply of carbohydrate and the use of the fixed nitrogen thus appear to be largely governed by the host.     

Mineral constraints to nitrogen fixation

Mineral nturient defiencies are a major constraint limiting legume nitrogen fixation and yield. In this review general techniques for assessing nutrient involvement in symbiotic nitrogen fixation are described and specific methods are outlined for determining which developmental phase of the symbiosis is most sensitive to nutrient deficiency. The mineral nutrition of the Rhizobium component of the symbiosis is considered both as the free living organism in the soil and as bacteroids in root nodules. Rhizobial growth and survival in soils is not usually limited by nutrient availability. Multiplication of rhizobia in the legume rhizosphere is limited by low Ca availability. Nodule initiation is affected by severe Co deficiency through effects on rhizobia. Nodule development is limited by severe B deficiency via an effect on plant cell growth. Fe deficiency limits nodule development by affecting rhizobia and strains of rhizobia differ widely in their ability to acquire sufficient Fe for their symbiotic development. Nodule function requires more Mo than does the host plant, and in some symbioses nitrogen fixation may be specifically limited by low availability of Ca, Co, Cu and Fe. The importance of the peribacteriod membrane in determining nutrient availability to bacteroids is considered. It is concluded that the whole legume-Rhizobium symbiosis should be considered when improving legume growth and yield under nutrient stress conditions. Differences among rhizobial strains in their ability to obtain mineral nutrients from their environment may be agronomically important.     

Sanctions and mutualism stability: when should less beneficial mutualists be tolerated?

Why do mutualists perform costly behaviours that benefit individuals of a different species? One of the factors that may stabilize mutualistic interactions is when individuals preferentially reward more mutualistic (beneficial) behaviour and/or punish less mutualistic (more parasitic) behaviour. We develop a model that shows how such sanctions provide a fitness benefit to the individuals that carry them out. Although this approach could be applied to a number of symbioses, we focus on how it could be applied to the legume‐rhizobia interaction. Specifically, we demonstrate how plants can be selected to supply preferentially more resources to (or be less likely to senesce) nodules that are fixing more N₂ (termed plant sanctions). We have previously argued that appreciable levels of N₂ fixation by rhizobia are only likely to be selected for in response to plant sanctions. Therefore, by showing that plant sanctions can also be favoured by natural selection, we are able to provide an explanation for the stability of the plant‐legume mutualism.     

Lifestyle alternatives for rhizobia: mutualism, parasitism, and forgoing symbiosis

Strains of rhizobia within a single species can have three different genetically determined strategies. Mutualistic rhizobia provide their legume hosts with nitrogen. Parasitic rhizobia infect legumes, but fix little or no nitrogen. Nonsymbiotic strains are unable to infect legumes at all. Why have rhizobium strains with one of these three strategies not displaced the others? A symbiotic (mutualistic or parasitic) rhizobium that succeeds in founding a nodule may produce many millions of descendants. The chances of success can be so low, however, that nonsymbiotic rhizobia can have greater reproductive success. Legume sanctions against nodules that fix little or no nitrogen favor more mutualistic strains, but parasitic strains that use plant resources only for their own reproduction may do well when they share nodules with mutualistic strains.     

Competition between rhizobia under different environmental conditions affects the nodulation of a legume

Mutualistic symbiosis and nitrogen fixation of legume rhizobia play a key role in ecological environments. Although many different rhizobial species can form nodules with a specific legume, there is often a dominant microsymbiont, which has the highest nodule occupancy rates, and they are often known as the “most favorable rhizobia”. Shifts in the most favorable rhizobia for a legume in different geographical regions or soil types are not well understood. Therefore, in order to explore the shift model, an experiment was designed using successive inoculations of rhizobia on one legume. The plants were grown in either sterile vermiculite or a sandy soil. Results showed that, depending on the environment, a legume could select its preferential rhizobial partner in order to establish symbiosis. For perennial legumes, nodulation is a continuous and sequential process. In this study, when the most favorable rhizobial strain was available to infect the plant first, it was dominant in the nodules, regardless of the existence of other rhizobial strains in the rhizosphere. Other rhizobial strains had an opportunity to establish symbiosis with the plant when the most favorable rhizobial strain was not present in the rhizosphere. Nodule occupancy rates of the most favorable rhizobial strain depended on the competitiveness of other rhizobial strains in the rhizosphere and the environmental adaptability of the favorable rhizobial strain (in this case, to mild vermiculite or hostile sandy soil). To produce high nodulation and efficient nitrogen fixation, the most favorable rhizobial strain should be selected and inoculated into the rhizosphere of legume plants under optimum environmental conditions.     

Long‐term nitrogen addition causes the evolution of less‐cooperative mutualists

Human activities have altered the global nitrogen (N) cycle, and as a result, elevated N inputs are causing profound ecological changes in diverse ecosystems. The evolutionary consequences of this global change have been largely ignored even though elevated N inputs are predicted to cause mutualism breakdown and the evolution of decreased cooperation between resource mutualists. Using a long‐term (22 years) N‐addition experiment, we find that elevated N inputs have altered the legume–rhizobium mutualism (where rhizobial bacteria trade N in exchange for photosynthates from legumes), causing the evolution of less‐mutualistic rhizobia. Plants inoculated with rhizobium strains isolated from N‐fertilized treatments produced 17–30% less biomass and had reduced chlorophyll content compared to plants inoculated with strains from unfertilized control plots. Because the legume–rhizobium mutualism is the major contributor of naturally fixed N to terrestrial ecosystems, the evolution of less‐cooperative rhizobia may have important environmental consequences.     

Symbiosis specificity in the legume: rhizobial mutualism

Legume plants are able to engage in root nodule symbiosis with nitrogen-fixing soil bacteria, collectively called rhizobia. This mutualistic association is highly specific, such that each rhizobial species/strain interacts with only a specific group of legumes, and vice versa. Symbiosis specificity can occur at multiple phases of the interaction, ranging from initial bacterial attachment and infection to late nodule development associated with nitrogen fixation. Genetic control of symbiosis specificity is complex, involving fine-tuned signal communication between the symbiotic partners. Here we review our current understanding of the mechanisms used by the host and bacteria to choose their symbiotic partners, with a special focus on the role that the host immunity plays in controlling the specificity of the legume - rhizobial symbiosis.     

Sanctions and mutualism stability: why do rhizobia fix nitrogen?

Why do rhizobia expend resources on fixing N(2) for the benefit of their host plant, when they could use those resources for their own reproduction? We present a series of theoretical models which counter the hypotheses that N(2) fixation is favoured because it (i) increases the exudation of useful resources to related rhizobia in the nearby soil, or (ii) increases plant growth and therefore the resources available for rhizobia growth. Instead, we suggest that appreciable levels of N(2) fixation are only favoured when plants preferentially supply more resources to (or are less likely to senesce) nodules that are fixing more N(2) (termed plant sanctions). The implications for different agricultural practices and mutualism stability in general are discussed.     

Nitrogen fixation and carbon metabolism in legume nodules

A large amount of energy is utilized by legume nodules for the fixation of nitrogen and assimilation of fixed nitrogen (ammonia) into organic compounds. The source of energy is provided in the form of photosynthates by the host plant. Phosphoenol pyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) enzyme, which is responsible for carbon dioxide fixation in C4 and crassulacean acid metabolism plants, has also been found to play an important role in carbon metabolism in legume root nodule. PEPC-mediated CO2 fixation in nodules results in the synthesis of C4 dicarboxylic acids, viz. aspartate, malate, fumarate etc. which can be transported into bacteroids with the intervention of dicarboxylate transporter (DCT) protein. PEPC has been purified from the root nodules of few legume species. Information on the relationship between nitrogen fixation and carbon metabolism through PEPC in leguminous plants is scanty and incoherent. This review summarizes the various aspects of carbon and nitrogen metabolism in legume root nodules.     

A mechanistic molecular test of the plant-sanction hypothesis in legume–rhizobia mutualism

The origin and persistence of mutualism is difficult to explain because of the widespread occurrence of exploitative, ‘cheating’ partners. As a policing strategy stabilising intraspecific cooperation, host sanctions against non-N₂ fixing, cheating symbionts have been proposed to stabilise mutualism in legume-rhizobium symbiosis. Mechanism of penalisations would include decreased nodular rhizobial viability and/or early nodule senescence. We tested these potential mechanisms of penalisations in split-root experiments using two soybean varieties and two rhizobial strains, a cooperative, normal N₂-fixing strain and an isogenic non-fixing derivative. We found no differences in the number of viable rhizobia recovered from nodules and no differential expression of a nodular senescence molecular marker. Thus, our results do not support the hypothesis of plant sanctions acting against cheating rhizobia in our experimental conditions.     

Improvement of biological nitrogen fixation in Egyptian winter legumes through better management of Rhizobium

The diversity of rhizobia nodulating common bean ( Phaseolus vulgaris), berseem clover (Trifolium alexanderinum) and lentil (Lens culinaris) was assessed using several characterization techniques, including nitrogen fixation efficiency, intrinsic antibiotic-resistance patterns (IAR), plasmid profiles, serological markers and rep-PCR fingerprinting. Wide diversity among indigenous rhizobial populations of the isolates from lentil, bean and clover was found. Strikingly, a large percentage of the indigenous rhizobial population was extremely poor at fixing nitrogen. This emphasizes the need to increase the balance of highly efficient strains within the rhizobial population. Use of high-quality inocula strains that survive and compete with other less-desired and less-efficient N2-fixing rhizobia represents the best approach to increase biological nitrogen fixation of the target legume. In field-grown lentils, the inoculant strains were not able to outcompete the indigenous rhizobia and the native lentil rhizobia occupied 76–88% of the total nodules formed on inoculated plants. Nitrogen fixation by lentils, estimated using the ¹⁵N isotope dilution technique, ranged between 127 to 139 kg ha-1 in both inoculated and un-inoculated plants. With berseem clover, the inoculant strains were highly competitive against indigenous rhizobia and occupied 52–79% of all nodules. Inoculation with selected inocula improved N2 fixation by clover from 162 to 205 kg ha-1 in the three cuts as compared with 118 kg ha-1 in the un-inoculated treatment. The results also indicated the potential for improvement of N2 fixation by beans through the application of efficient N2-fixing rhizobia.     

Lotus hosts delimit the mutualism–parasitism continuum of Bradyrhizobium

Symbioses are modelled as evolutionarily and ecologically variable with fitness outcomes for hosts shifting on a continuum from mutualism to parasitism. In a classic example, rhizobia fix atmospheric nitrogen for legume hosts in exchange for photosynthetic carbon. Rhizobial infection often enhances legume growth, but hosts also incur interaction costs because of root tissues and or metabolites needed to support symbionts in planta. Rhizobia exhibit genetic variation in symbiotic effectiveness, and ecological changes in light or mineral nitrogen availability can also alter the benefits of rhizobial infection for hosts. The net effects of symbiosis thus can range from mutualistic to parasitic in a context‐dependent manner. We tested the extent of the mutualism–parasitism continuum in the legume–rhizobium symbiosis and the degree to which host investment can shape its limits. We infected Lotus strigosus with sympatric Bradyrhizobium genotypes that vary in symbiotic effectiveness. Inoculations occurred under different mineral nitrogen and light regimes spanning ecologically relevant ranges. Net growth benefits of Bradyrhizobium infection varied for Lotus and were reduced or eliminated dependent on Bradyrhizobium genotype, mineral nitrogen and light availability. But we did not detect parasitism. Lotus proportionally reduced investment in Bradyrhizobium as net benefit from infection decreased. Lotus control occurred primarily after infection, via fine‐scale modulation of nodule growth, as opposed to control over initial nodulation. Our results show how divestment of symbiosis by Lotus can prevent shifts to parasitism.     

Sulfate is transported at significant rates through the symbiosome membrane and is crucial for nitrogenase biosynthesis

Legume–rhizobia symbioses play a major role in food production for an ever growing human population. In this symbiosis, dinitrogen is reduced (“fixed”) to ammonia by the rhizobial nitrogenase enzyme complex and is secreted to the plant host cells, whereas dicarboxylic acids derived from photosynthetically produced sucrose are transported into the symbiosomes and serve as respiratory substrates for the bacteroids. The symbiosome membrane contains high levels of SST1 protein, a sulfate transporter. Sulfate is an essential nutrient for all living organisms, but its importance for symbiotic nitrogen fixation and nodule metabolism has long been underestimated. Using chemical imaging, we demonstrate that the bacteroids take up 20‐fold more sulfate than the nodule host cells. Furthermore, we show that nitrogenase biosynthesis relies on high levels of imported sulfate, making sulfur as essential as carbon for the regulation and functioning of symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Our findings thus establish the importance of sulfate and its active transport for the plant–microbe interaction that is most relevant for agriculture and soil fertility.     

Efficiency of partner choice and sanctions in Lotus is not altered by nitrogen fertilization

Eukaryotic hosts must exhibit control mechanisms to select against ineffective bacterial symbionts. Hosts can minimize infection by less-effective symbionts (partner choice) and can divest of uncooperative bacteria after infection (sanctions). Yet, such host-control traits are predicted to be context dependent, especially if they are costly for hosts to express or maintain. Legumes form symbiosis with rhizobia that vary in symbiotic effectiveness (nitrogen fixation) and can enforce partner choice as well as sanctions. In nature, legumes acquire fixed nitrogen from both rhizobia and soils, and nitrogen deposition is rapidly enriching soils globally. If soil nitrogen is abundant, we predict host control to be downregulated, potentially allowing invasion of ineffective symbionts. We experimentally manipulated soil nitrogen to examine context dependence in host control. We co-inoculated Lotus strigosus from nitrogen depauperate soils with pairs of Bradyrhizobium strains that vary in symbiotic effectiveness and fertilized plants with either zero nitrogen or growth maximizing nitrogen. We found efficient partner choice and sanctions regardless of nitrogen fertilization, symbiotic partner combination or growth season. Strikingly, host control was efficient even when L. strigosus gained no significant benefit from rhizobial infection, suggesting that these traits are resilient to short-term changes in extrinsic nitrogen, whether natural or anthropogenic.     

Interactive effects of synthetic nitrogen fertilizer and composted manure on ammonia volatilization from soils

The mutualism between legumes and nitrogen-fixing soil bacteria (rhizobia) is a key feature of many ecological and agricultural systems, yet little is known about how this relationship affects aboveground interactions between plants and herbivores. We investigated the effects of the rhizobia mutualism on the abundance of a specialized legume herbivore on soybean plants. In a field experiment, soybean aphid (Aphis glycines) abundances were measured on plants (Glycine max) that were either (1) treated with a commercial rhizobial inoculant, (2) associating solely with naturally occurring rhizobia, or (3) given nitrogen fertilizer. Plants associating with naturally occurring rhizobia strains exhibited lower aphid population densities compared to those inoculated with a commercial rhizobial preparation or given nitrogen fertilizer. Genetic analyses of rhizobia isolates cultured from field plants revealed that the commercial rhizobia strains were phylogenetically distinct from naturally occurring strains. Plant size, leaf nitrogen concentration, and nodulation density were similar among rhizobia-associated treatments and did not explain the observed differences in aphid abundance. Our results demonstrate that plant–rhizobia interactions influence plant resistance to insect herbivores and that some rhizobia strains confer greater resistance to their mutualist partners than do others.