The History of Staining Logwood Dyes

Except for the cochineal derivatives, logwood extract was the first of the important modern stains to be employed in histology. Certain other natural dyes, such as madder and indigo, had been used earlier, but they are of little significance in discussing the history of staining, because none of them nor even alizarin, the derivative of madder, are of any appreciable significance in these days of synthetic dyes. Hematoxylin, on the other hand, still continues a very important stain, and it has played an interesting part in the history of staining.     

Staining human lymphocytes and onion root cell nuclei with madder root

We performed staining experiments on cells using natural dyes and different mordants using techniques that are used for wool and silk dyeing. The natural dye sources were madder root, daisy, corn cockle and yellow weed. Ferrous sulfate, copper sulfate, potassium tartrate, urea, potassium aluminum sulfate and potassium dichromate were used as mordants. Distilled water, distilled water plus ethanol, heptane, and distilled water plus methanol were used as solvents. All dye-mordant-solvent combinations were studied at pH 2.4, 3.2 and 4.2. The generic staining procedure was to boil 5–10 onion roots or stimulated human lymphocyte (SHL) preparations in a dye bath on a hot plate. Cells were examined at every half hour. For multicolor staining, madder-dyed lymphocytes were decolorized, then stained with Giemsa. The AgNOR technique was performed following the decolorization of Giemsa stained lymphocytes. Good results were obtained for both onion root cells and lymphocytes that were boiled for 3 h in a dye bath that included 4 g madder root, 4 g ferrous sulfate as mordant in 50 ml of 1:1 (v/v) methanol:distilled water. The pH was adjusted to 4.2 with 6 ml acetic acid. We conclude that madder root has potential as an alternative dye for staining biological materials.     

Staining human lymphocytes and onion root cell nuclei with madder root.

We performed staining experiments on cells using natural dyes and different mordants using techniques that are used for wool and silk dyeing. The natural dye sources were madder root, daisy, corn cockle and yellow weed. Ferrous sulfate, copper sulfate, potassium tartrate, urea, potassium aluminum sulfate and potassium dichromate were used as mordants. Distilled water, distilled water plus ethanol, heptane, and distilled water plus methanol were used as solvents. All dye-mordant-solvent combinations were studied at pH 2.4, 3.2 and 4.2. The generic staining procedure was to boil 5-10 onion roots or stimulated human lymphocyte (SHL) preparations in a dye bath on a hot plate. Cells were examined at every half hour. For multicolor staining, madder-dyed lymphocytes were decolorized, then stained with Giemsa. The AgNOR technique was performed following the decolorization of Giemsa stained lymphocytes. Good results were obtained for both onion root cells and lymphocytes that were boiled for 3 h in a dye bath that included 4 g madder root, 4 g ferrous sulfate as mordant in 50 ml of 1:1 (v/v) methanol:distilled water. The pH was adjusted to 4.2 with 6 ml acetic acid. We conclude that madder root has potential as an alternative dye for staining biological materials.     

Cytohistological and phytochemical study of madder root extracts obtained by ultrasonic and classical extractions

Introduction – Madder (Rubia tinctorum) has been used since ancient times as a source of pigments for dyeing and painting. Madder dyes are localised in roots and the native chemical population is composed of glycosiled and aglycone compounds. The aim of this study is to elaborate an efficient extraction process without any chemical denaturation of dyes. Objective – To compare an optimised ultrasonic process, using for madder dye extraction, with two conventional procedures and to determine the efficiency of ultrasound on these vegetable matrix. Methodology – Madder roots were extract in a methanol–water mixture in 37 : 63 (v/v) for ultrasound and 80 : 20 (v/v) for reflux and agitation. HPLC‐PAD analyses showed the anthraquinone proportion for each extraction process and their denaturing effects. Finally, cytohistological observations were made to show the consequence of each process on the cell organisation in madder roots. Results – The results showed that the amount of extracted dyes was higher with UAE than with agitation and reflux. HPLC‐PAD analysis revealed that the anthraquinone composition differed according to the extraction procedure. The UAE extracts presented an important richness in terms of anthraquinonic compounds that suggests a preserving effect. Cytohistological observations showed that the main alterations concerned the cell walls of phloem. After UAE the walls exhibited numerous pitted areas reflecting an ultrasound‐induced cavitation that enhances the extraction effectiveness of this method. Conclusion – The study has shown the improvement of madder roots extraction both quantitatively and qualitatively using the efficiency of ultrasound‐assisted extraction in comparison with magnetic agitation and reflux techniques. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Fluorescent dyes specific for quadruplex DNA.

Fluorescent dyes which are specific for duplex DNA have found a wide range of applications from staining gels to visualization of chromosomes. Porphyrin dyes have been found which are highly fluorescent in the presence of quadruplex but not duplex DNA. These dyes may offer a route to the specific detection of quadruplex DNA under biologically important conditions. There are three types of DNA quadruplex structures, and these may play important roles in telomere, centromere, triplet repeat, integration sites and other DNAs, and this first set of porphyrin dyes show some selectivity between the quadruplex types.     

How Romanowsky stains work and why they remain valuable — including a proposed universal Romanowsky staining mechanism and a rational troubleshooting scheme

Abstract

An introduction to the nomenclature and concept of “Romanowsky stains” is followed by a brief account of the dyes involved and especially the crucial role of azure B and of the impurity of most commercial dye lots. Technical features of standardized and traditional Romanowsky stains are outlined, e.g., number and ratio of the acidic and basic dyes used, solvent effects, staining times, and fixation effects. The peculiar advantages of Romanowsky staining are noted, namely, the polychromasia achieved in a technically simple manner with the potential for stain intensification of “the color purple.” Accounts are provided of a variety of physicochemically relevant topics, namely, acidic and basic dyeing, peculiarities of acidic and basic dye mixtures, consequences of differential staining rates of different cell and tissue components and of different dyes, the chemical significance of “the color purple,” the substrate selectivity for purple color formation and its intensification in situ due to a template effect, effects of resin embedding and prior fixation. Based on these physicochemical phenomena, mechanisms for the various Romanowsky staining applications are outlined including for blood, marrow and cytological smears; G-bands of chromosomes; microorganisms and other single-cell entities; and paraffin and resin tissue sections. The common factors involved in these specific mechanisms are pulled together to generate a “universal” generic mechanism for these stains. Certain generic problems of Romanowsky stains are discussed including the instability of solutions of acidic dye–basic dye mixtures, the inherent heterogeneity of polychrome methylene blue, and the resulting problems of standardization. Finally, a rational trouble-shooting scheme is appended.     

Aqueous solutions of some basic dyes--their use in the cytochemical detection of DNA

The paper contains results of staining DNA-aldehyde molecules with aqueous solutions of brilliant cresyl blue, thionin or neutral red, following Feulgen procedure and also reports on the use of aqueous solutions of these dyes, with primary amino group(s) in their molecules, for staining animal tissue nuclei after extraction of RNA with cold phosphoric acid. The pH of the dye solutions most suitable for optimum staining is 6.0. The time necessary for optimum staining of DNA-aldehydes and DNA-phosphate groups are 10 and 2 min respectively for tissues fixed in formalin, paraformaldehyde or Craf. Tissue fixed in Buin-fluid stain slower. The absorption curves of nuclei stained for DNA-aldehyde molecules and DNA-phosphate groups, stained with each of the three dyes are different from each other. The in vitro absorption curves of aqueous solutions of the three dyes have also been presented. Some implications of the results obtained are discussed.     

The cationic carbocyanine dyes Stains-all DBTC, and Ethyl-Stains-all, DBTC-3,3',9 triethyl.

A simple method is presented for distinguishing two closely related metachromatic carbocyanine dyes: Ethyl-Stains-all, a triethyl dye, and Stains-all, a diethyl methyl dye. This has become important since one lot of the triethyl dye was distributed erroneously under the diethyl methyl label. The dyes differ in solubility and in differential staining of macromolecules. Studies performed with both dyes are summarized.     

The role of phosphotungstic and phosphomolybdic acids in connective tissue staining I. Histochemical studies

Synopsis An investigation of the role of phosphotungstic and phosphomolybdic acids in Mallory-like trichrome methods showed unexpectedly that, rather than acting as mordants to anionic dyes, these polyacids selectively blocked staining of all tissue components other than connective tissue fibres to Aniline Blue and other similar fibrereactive dyes. Connective tissue components were found to contain residues resembling histidine that are easily accessible to anionic dyes. Blocking towards typical anionic dyes for demonstrating plasma proteins, such as Biebrich Scarlet, was also demonstrated but was less complete. The blockade of both types of dye was labile if the staining times were extended; plasma dyes were more sensitive than fibre dyes in this respect. Histochemical reactions for tyrosine residues were blocked. In connective tissue, phosphotungstic acid did not block histidine residues demonstrable by the coupled tetrazonium reaction with previous iodination. Thus it is postulated that differential trichrome staining occurs by binding of Aniline Blue to basic residues in the connective tissue not blocked by phosphotungstic acid and subsequent replacement of the blocking agent by an anionic dye. The binding of phosphotungstic acid to both epithelium and connective tissue was demonstrated by the quenching of autofluorescence in these regions and by the reduction of the bound PTA to blue coloured products with titanium trichloride.     

Mechanism of connective tissue techniques I. The effect of dye concentration and staining time on anionic dye procedures

Summary Anionic dye connective tissue procedures were performed by staining for 5 min and 24 h with (a) 0.00018m and 0.0018m solutions of 28 dyes, and 0.018m solutions of 21 dyes in saturated picric acid (SPA), and (b) 0.0018m and 0.018m solutions of 20 dyes in 1% (w/v) phosphomolybdic acid (PMA). The staining obtained with dyes in SPA was classified as selective (no cytoplasmic staining), moderately selective (traces of cytoplasmic staining) and non-selective (all other staining patterns). The staining of collagen and cytoplasm with dyes in PMA was separately classified on a scale of 1–5 (1 = no staining, 5 = maximum staining). The selectivity of the staining obtained with SPA with solutions of dyes at concentrations of 0.00018m and 0.0018m, and both staining times, was correlated (p < 0.001) with an empirical sulphonic acid constant (SAC) defined as the (number of dye sulphonic acid groups/dye molecular weight) × 10³. Correlation with molecular weight was poor and was significant only when staining was performed with 0.00018m dye solutions for 24 h. The dyes were divisible into three groups: group 1 (selectivity independent, or almost independent of staining time), group 2 (selective to moderately selective when staining was performed for 5 min), and group 3 (non-selective). The SAC of the group 1 dyes differed significantly from those of the group 2 and 3 dyes. Selectivity was essentially lost at dye concentrations of 0.018m. The staining with acidic dyes (no amines or substituted amines) in PMA differed significantly (p < 0.001) from that obtained with amphoteric dyes (containing basic substituents). In general, acidic dyes stained cytoplasm. Amphoteric dyes with the exception of indigocarmine stained collagen. However, most of these dyes also stained cytoplasm. In contrast to the results obtained with dyes in SPA, selectivity correlated strongly with molecular weight and only poorly with the SAC. Staining time and dye concentration affected selectivity only when the acidic dyes were used for 5 min at concentrations of 0.0018m and 0.018m. The data obtained do not permit a clear distinction between the rate control and chemical affinity models for the mechanism of staining with anionic dyes. However, it seems possible that different groups of dyes stain by different mechanisms. Part of this work was performed by M.I., S.N., M.J. and L.M. in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the completion of Pathology 438. A partial account of this work was presented at the annual convention of the British Columbia Society of Medical Technology, Victoria, British Columbia, October 1991.     

Influence of some aldehyde blocking agents on staining of depurinized DNA with cationic dyes.

Rat liver, spleen and Walker carcinosarcoma imprints were subjected to depurinizing Feulgen hydrolysis and then treated with blocking agents of aldehyde groups. Such blockators as sodium bisulfite and hydroxylamine which multiplay additionally anionic groups in DNA and intensify the reactions with cationic dyes, ensuring anisotropic staining. Hydrazine lowers the binding of carionic dyes to DNA, instead phenylhydrazine, completely blocks both aldehyde and phosphate groups. When the imprints were treated with 2.4-dinitrophenylhydrazine, aldehyde and phosphate groups of apurinic acid were blocked, and DNA staining by cationic dyes occurred only on account of nitrogroups of the blocking agents which have been used. The staining reaction of cationic dyes after the use of anionogenic blocking agents of aldehyde groups is prospective not only for revealing DNA but also for several other compounds with natural or potential aldo- and ketogroups. However the reaction with phenylhydrazine can serve as a staining without removal of DNA prior to staining as an optional procedure.     

Use of fluorescent dyes as molecular probes for the study of multidrug resistance

Fluorescence microscopy has shown that 18 different fluorescent dyes, staining various intracellular structures in transformed hamster fibroblasts (DM-15), did not stain or stained weakly multidrug-resistant cells selected from DM-15 by colchicine. Reduced staining by fluorescent dyes was characteristic also of five other tested multidrug-resistant cell lines of hamster and mouse origin, selected by actinomycin D, colcemid, rubomycin, and ruboxyl. The intensity of staining of two revertant cell lines was similar to that of parental sensitive cells. All tested inhibitors of multidrug resistance, including weak detergent, metabolic inhibitors, calcium channel blockers, calmodulin inhibitors, and reserpine, restored normal staining of multidrug-resistant cells. The dyes accumulated in resistant cells in presence of these inhibitors left the cells several minutes after the removal of the inhibitor from the incubation medium. Sensitive cells retained the dyes for several hours. The efflux of the dyes from resistant cells is an active process since it occurred even in the presence of the dyes in the incubation medium. The efflux could be blocked by all tested inhibitors of multidrug resistance and it is possibly a basic mechanism of the reduced staining of resistant cells. These data support the idea that multidrug resistance is based on active nonspecific efflux of the drugs and indicate that the simple procedure of cell staining can be used for the detection of resistant cells and further study of the phenomenon of multidrug resistance.     

Comparisons of Pyronin Dyes Obtained from Various Commercial Sources. 1. History

The history of pyronin dyes is discussed, beginning with the synthesis of pyronin Y(G) in 1889. The chemical structures of the dyes are given in addition to references to literature describing methods of synthesis. The early histological use of pyronins is described as well as the distribution and use of pyronins in the U. S. A. and Europe. Further discussion is devoted to the use of pyronins for histochemical demonstration of ribonucleic acid, especially in relation to sources, dye variability, contamination, and substitution by rhodamines. Additional studies with improved pyronins are advocated to evaluate histochemical staining mechanisms and to investigate possible quantitative uses.     

Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains I. The Staining Properties of Thionin and its Derivatives as Compared with Their Chemical Formulae

An investigation has been made of the staining properties of eight dyes of the thionin group. The dyes studied are as follows: tetra-ethyl thionin, asymmetrical di-ethyl thionin, tetra-methyl thionin (methylene blue), tri-methyl thionin (azure B), asymmetrical di-methyl thionin (azure A), symmetrical di-methyl thionin, mono-methyl thionin (azure C), and unsubstituted thionin. The staining properties were tested on sections of paraffin embedded material following five different methods of fixation. No counterstain was employed. It was shown that there was a general correlation between the extent of ethylation or methylation of the dyes and their staining properties. As one passes from tetra-ethyl thionin down the series to thionin itself, there is a progressive decrease in the amount of green showing in the preparations, and an increase in the amount of red present, also an increase in the metachromatic effects, and in the intensity of nuclear staining. There seems, also, to be a similar relation between staining qualities on the one hand and the color and solubility of the dye base on the other.     

Optimization of staining conditions for microalgae with three lipophilic dyes to reduce precipitation and fluorescence variability

When the fluorescence signal of a dye is being quantified, the staining protocol is an important factor in ensuring accuracy and reproducibility. Increasingly, lipophilic dyes are being used to quantify cellular lipids in microalgae. However, there is little discussion about the sensitivity of these dyes to staining conditions. To address this, microalgae were stained with either the lipophilic dyes often used for lipid quantification (Nile Red and BODIPY) or a lipophilic dye commonly used to stain neuronal cell membranes (DiO), and fluorescence was measured using flow cytometry. The concentration of the cells being stained was found not to affect the fluorescence. Conversely, the concentration of dye significantly affected the fluorescence intensity from either insufficient saturation of the cellular lipids or formation of dye precipitate. Precipitates of all three dyes were detected as events by flow cytometry and fluoresced at a similar intensity as the chlorophyll in the microalgae. Prevention of precipitate formation is, therefore, critical to ensure accurate fluorescence measurement with these dyes. It was also observed that the presence of organic solvents, such as acetone and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), were not required to increase penetration of the dyes into cells and that the presence of these solvents resulted in increased cellular debris. Thus, staining conditions affected the fluorescence of all three lipophilic dyes, but Nile Red was found to have a stable fluorescence intensity that was unaffected by the broadest range of conditions and could be correlated to cellular lipid content.     

Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains I. The Staining Properties of Thionin and its Derivatives as Compared with Their Chemical Formulae

An investigation has been made of the staining properties of eight dyes of the thionin group. The dyes studied are as follows: tetra-ethyl thionin, asymmetrical di-ethyl thionin, tetra-methyl thionin (methylene blue), tri-methyl thionin (azure B), asymmetrical di-methyl thionin (azure A), symmetrical di-methyl thionin, mono-methyl thionin (azure C), and unsubstituted thionin. The staining properties were tested on sections of paraffin embedded material following five different methods of fixation. No counterstain was employed. It was shown that there was a general correlation between the extent of ethylation or methylation of the dyes and their staining properties. As one passes from tetra-ethyl thionin down the series to thionin itself, there is a progressive decrease in the amount of green showing in the preparations, and an increase in the amount of red present, also an increase in the metachromatic effects, and in the intensity of nuclear staining. There seems, also, to be a similar relation between staining qualities on the one hand and the color and solubility of the dye base on the other.     

Detection of myelination using a novel histological probe.

Current methods for myelin staining in tissue sections include both histological and immunohistochemical techniques. Fluorescence immunohistochemistry, which uses antibodies against myelin components such as myelin basic protein, is often used because of the convenience for multiple labeling. To facilitate studies on myelin, this paper describes a quick and easy method for direct myelin staining in rodent and human tissues using novel near-infrared myelin (NIM) dyes that are comparable to other well-characterized histochemical reagents. The near-infrared fluorescence spectra of these probes allow fluorescent staining of tissue sections in multiple channels using visible light fluorophores commonly used in immunocytochemistry. These dyes have been used successfully to detect normal myelin structure and myelin loss in a mouse model of demyelination disease.     

Quirks of dye nomenclature. 11. Safranine and its relatives

Safranine was one of the earliest coal tar dyes following mauveine. By the end of the 19th century, many alkylated derivatives of safranine had been made. The history, identity, names, manufacture, analysis, toxicity, textile dyeing, and biological staining applications, plus some nonstaining uses of safranine, phenosafranine, methylene violet, amethyst violet, azocarmine, and Magdala red are described here.     

Traditional staining for routine diagnostic pathology including the role of tannic acid. 1. Value and limitations of the hematoxylin-eosin stain

The components of the hematoxylin and eosin (H & E) stain (i.e. hemalum and eosin Y), their contributions to the typical staining pattern, and the reasons why the H & E stains are the preferred oversight stains for routine diagnostic histopathology are discussed. The essential diagnostic significance of effective nuclear staining by hemalum, providing information on nuclear morphology and texture, is emphasized; as is the ironic advantage for routine diagnostic histopathology of the limited range of colors provided by H & E staining, that allows recognition of significant features under low microscopic magnifications. Standardization of hemalum is considered, along with probable reasons why users show resistance to such a concept. Counterstaining with anionic (acid) dyes is discussed, as is the important phenomenon of contrast. The particular advantages and disadvantages of eosin Y and phloxin B as counterstains to hemalum are outlined. The concept of an “ideal routine histological stain” is considered, and H & E is compared to such an ideal case. Finally, deficiencies of H & E staining are discussed, and a program to develop an improved oversight stain is introduced.     

Traditional staining for routine diagnostic pathology including the role of tannic acid. 1. Value and limitations of the hematoxylin-eosin stain

The components of the hematoxylin and eosin (H & E) stain (i.e. hemalum and eosin Y), their contributions to the typical staining pattern, and the reasons why the H & E stains are the preferred oversight stains for routine diagnostic histopathology are discussed. The essential diagnostic significance of effective nuclear staining by hemalum, providing information on nuclear morphology and texture, is emphasized; as is the ironic advantage for routine diagnostic histopathology of the limited range of colors provided by H & E staining, that allows recognition of significant features under low microscopic magnifications. Standardization of hemalum is considered, along with probable reasons why users show resistance to such a concept. Counterstaining with anionic (acid) dyes is discussed, as is the important phenomenon of contrast. The particular advantages and disadvantages of eosin Y and phloxin B as counterstains to hemalum are outlined. The concept of an “ideal routine histological stain” is considered, and H & E is compared to such an ideal case. Finally, deficiencies of H & E staining are discussed, and a program to develop an improved oversight stain is introduced.