Fibromodulin-null mice have abnormal collagen fibrils, tissue organization, and altered lumican deposition in tendon

Fibromodulin is a member of a family of connective tissue glycoproteins/proteoglycans containing leucine-rich repeat motifs. Several members of this gene family bind to fibrillar collagens and are believed to function in the assembly of the collagen network in connective tissues. Here we show that mice lacking a functional fibromodulin gene exhibit an altered morphological phenotype in tail tendon with fewer and abnormal collagen fiber bundles. In fibromodulin-null animals virtually all collagen fiber bundles are disorganized and have an abnormal morphology. Also 10-20% of the bundles in heterozygous mice are similar to the abnormal bundles in fibromodulin-null tail tendon. Ultrastructural analysis of Achilles tendon from fibromodulin-null mice show collagen fibrils with irregular and rough outlines in cross-section. Morphometric analysis show that fibromodulin-null mice have on the average thinner fibrils than wild type animals as a result of a larger preponderance of very thin fibrils in an overall similar range of fibril diameters. Protein and RNA analyses show an approximately 4-fold increase in the content of lumican in fibromodulin-null as compared with wild type tail tendon, despite a decrease in lumican mRNA. These results demonstrate a role for fibromodulin in collagen fibrillogenesis and suggest that the orchestrated action of several leucine-rich repeat glycoproteins/proteoglycans influence the architecture of collagen matrices.     

Glycosaminoglycans show a specific periodic interaction with type I collagen fibrils

Current wisdom on intermolecular interactions in the extracellular matrix assumes that small proteoglycans bind collagen fibrils on highly specific sites via their protein core, while their carbohydrate chains interact with each other in the interfibrillar space. The present study used high-resolution scanning electron microscopy to analyse the interaction of two small leucine-rich proteoglycans and several glycosaminoglycan chains with type I collagen fibrils obtained in vitro in a controlled, cell-free environment. Our results show that most ligands directly influence the collagen fibril size and shape, and their aggregation into thicker bundles. All chondroitin sulphate/dermatan sulphate glycosaminoglycans we tested, except chondroitin 4-sulphate, bound to the fibril surface in a highly specific way and, even in the absence of any protein core, formed regular, periodic interfibrillar links resembling those of the intact proteoglycan. Only intact decorin, however, was able to organize collagen fibrils into fibres compact enough to mimic in vitro the superfibrillar organization of natural tissues. Our data indicate that multiple interaction patterns may exist in vivo, may explain why decorin- or biglycan-knockout organisms show milder effects than can be expected, and may lead to the development of better, simpler engineered biomaterials.     

Estimation of the binding force of the collagen molecule-decorin core protein complex in collagen fibril

Decorin belongs to the small leucine proteoglycans family and is considered to play an important role in extracellular matrix organization. Experimental studies suggest that decorin is required for the assembly of collagen fibrils, as well as for the development of proper tissue mechanical properties. In tendons, decorins tie adjoining collagen fibrils together and probably guarantee the mechanical coupling of fibrils. The decorin molecule consists of one core protein and one glycosaminoglycan chain covalently linked to a serine residue of the core protein. Several studies have indicated that each core protein binds to the surface of collagen fibrils every 67 nm, by interacting non-covalently to one collagen molecule of the fibril surface, while the decorin glycosaminoglycans extend from the core protein to connect to another decorin core protein laying on adjacent fibril surface. The present paper investigates the complex composed of one decorin core protein and one collagen molecule in order to obtain their binding force. For this purpose, molecular models of collagen molecules type I and decorin core protein were developed and their interaction energies were evaluated by means of the molecular mechanics approach. Results show that the complex is characterized by a maximum binding force of about 12.4 x 10(3) nN and a binding stiffness of 8.33 x 10(-8) N/nm; the attained binding force is greater than the glycosaminoglycan chain's ultimate strength, thus indicating that overloads are likely to damage the collagen fibre's mechanical integrity by disrupting the glycosaminoglycan chains rather than by causing decorin core protein detachment from the collagen fibril.     

Probing the effect of glycosaminoglycan depletion on integrin interactions with collagen I fibrils in the native extracellular matrix environment

Fibrillar collagen–integrin interactions in the extracellular matrix (ECM) regulate a multitude of cellular processes and cell signalling. Collagen I fibrils serve as the molecular scaffolding for connective tissues throughout the human body and are the most abundant protein building blocks in the ECM. The ECM environment is diverse, made up of several ECM proteins, enzymes, and proteoglycans. In particular, glycosaminoglycans (GAGs), anionic polysaccharides that decorate proteoglycans, become depleted in the ECM with natural aging and their mis-regulation has been linked to cancers and other diseases. The impact of GAG depletion in the ECM environment on collagen I protein interactions and on mechanical properties is not well understood. Here, we integrate ELISA protein binding assays with liquid high-resolution atomic force microscopy (AFM) to assess the effects of GAG depletion on the interaction of collagen I fibrils with the integrin α2I domain using separate rat tails. ELISA binding assays demonstrate that α2I preferentially binds to GAG-depleted collagen I fibrils in comparison to native fibrils. By amplitude modulated AFM in air and in solution, we find that GAG-depleted collagen I fibrils retain structural features of the native fibrils, including their characteristic D-banding pattern, a key structural motif. AFM fast force mapping in solution shows that GAG depletion reduces the stiffness of individual fibrils, lowering the indentation modulus by half compared to native fibrils. Together these results shed new light on how GAGs influence collagen I fibril–integrin interactions and may aid in strategies to treat diseases that result from GAG mis-regulation.     

Tendon proteoglycans: biochemistry and function

Tendon remodeling occurs in response to changes in loading and mobilization. Though the normal mechanical function depends on precise alignment of collagen fibrils, it is proteoglycans that regulate collagen fibrillogenesis and thus, indirectly, tendon function. In this paper we discuss the basic biochemical structure of several members of two proteoglycans families. Decorin, biglycan, fibromodulin and lumican, all members of the small leucine-rich proteoglycans family, bind to collagen fibrils and are active participants in fibrillogenesis. Aggrecan and versican, two members of large modular proteoglycans or lecticans, and their partner hyaluronan likely provide tendon tissues with a high capacity to resist high compressive and tensile forces associated with loading and mobilization. We present data from our laboratory showing that proteoglycans and glycosaminoglycan content increases not only with growth but also with loading of young avian gastrocnemius tendons. Specifically, an increase in the content of keratan sulfate, chondroitin sulfate and hyaluronan was observed. Moderate exercise for several weeks led not only to a further increase in total proteoglycans content but also to qualitative changes in proteoglycan make up.     

Targeted Disruption of Decorin Leads to Abnormal Collagen Fibril Morphology and Skin Fragility

Decorin is a member of the expanding group of widely distributed small leucine-rich proteoglycans that are expected to play important functions in tissue assembly. We report that mice harboring a targeted disruption of the decorin gene are viable but have fragile skin with markedly reduced tensile strength. Ultrastructural analysis revealed abnormal collagen morphology in skin and tendon, with coarser and irregular fiber outlines. Quantitative scanning transmission EM of individual collagen fibrils showed abrupt increases and decreases in mass along their axes, thereby accounting for the irregular outlines and size variability observed in cross-sections. The data indicate uncontrolled lateral fusion of collagen fibrils in the decorindeficient mice and provide an explanation for the reduced tensile strength of the skin. These findings demonstrate a fundamental role for decorin in regulating collagen fiber formation in vivo.     

Conformation and sequence evidence for two-fold symmetry in left-handed beta-helix fold

The glycosaminoglycan (GAG) side-chains of small leucine-rich proteoglycans have been postulated to mechanically cross-link adjacent collagen fibrils and contribute to tendon mechanics. Enzymatic depletion of tendon GAGs (chondroitin and dermatan sulfate) has emerged as a preferred method to experimentally assess this role. However, GAG removal is typically incomplete and the possibility remains that extant GAGs may remain mechanically functional. The current study specifically investigated the potential mechanical effect of the remaining GAGs after partial enzymatic digestion.A three-dimensional finite element model of tendon was created based upon the concept of proteoglycan mediated inter-fibril load sharing. Approximately 250 interacting, discontinuous collagen fibrils were modeled as having a length of 400 μm, being composed of rod elements of length 67 nm and E-modulus 1 GPa connected in series. Spatial distribution and diameters of these idealized fibrils were derived from a representative cross-sectional electron micrograph of tendon. Rod element lengths corresponded to the collagen fibril D-Period, widely accepted to act as a binding site for decorin and biglycan, the most abundant proteoglycans in tendon. Each element node was connected to nodes of any neighboring fibrils within a radius of 100 nm, the slack length of unstretched chondroitin sulfate. These GAG cross-links were the sole mechanism for lateral load sharing among the discontinuous fibrils, and were modeled as bilinear spring elements. Simulation of tensile testing of tendon with complete cross-linking closely reproduced corresponding experiments on rat tail tendons. Random reduction of 80% of GAG cross-links (matched to a conservative estimate of enzymatic depletion efficacy) predicted a drop of 14% in tendon modulus. Corresponding mechanical properties derived from experiments on rat tail tendons treated in buffer with and without chondroitinase ABC were apparently unaffected, regardless of GAG depletion. Further tests for equivalence, conservatively based on effect size limits predicted by the model, confirmed equivalent stiffness between enzymatically depleted tendons and their native controls.Although the model predicts that relatively small quantities of GAGs acting as primary collagen cross-linking elements could provide mechanical integrity to the tendon, partial enzymatic depletion of GAGs should result in mechanical changes that are not reflected in analogous experimental testing. We thus conclude that GAG side chains of small leucine-rich proteoglycans are not a primary determinant of tensile mechanical behavior in mature rat tail tendons.     

The role of small leucine-rich proteoglycans in collagen fibrillogenesis

Small leucine-rich proteoglycans/proteins (SLRPs) are associated with collagen fibril formation, and therefore important for the proper formation of extracellular matrices. SLRPs are differentially expressed in tissues and during pathological conditions, contributing to the development of connective tissue properties. The binding of SLRPs to collagens have recently been characterized, and may give some clues to the significance of these interactions. In this mini review, we summarize published work in this field, and propose several mechanisms for how SLRPs can control collagen matrix structure and function. SLRPs appear to influence collagen cross-linking patterns. We also propose that the SLRP-collagen interactions can assist in the process of juxtaposing the collagen monomers by steric hindrance or by directly connecting two collagen monomers during the fibril growth.     

Electron microscopic autoradiography of 35SO4-labelled material closely associated with collagen fibrils in mammalian synovium and ear cartilage.

Synopsis Electron microscopic autoradiography of connective tissue obtained from mice and rabbits previously injected with³⁵SO₄ indicated that sulphated proteoglycans are localized on collagen fibrils. Ruthenium Red-positive transverse belts surrounding fibrils near the a-bands were heavily labelled, but fine lateral filaments of Ruthenium Red-positive material were not. These filaments, which interconnect collagen fibrils in a variety of connective tissues may represent linear aggregations of hyaluronic acid, glycoproteins and non-sulphated or long-lived sulphated proteoglycans.     

Heparan sulfate proteoglycans from mouse mammary epithelial cells. Cell surface proteoglycan as a receptor for interstitial collagens

A heparan sulfate-rich proteoglycan is on the surface of NMuMG mouse mammary epithelial cells apparently intercalated into their plasma membranes. Mild treatment of the cells with trypsin releases the GAG-bearing region (ectodomain) of this molecule as a discrete proteoglycan which is readily purified. At physiological pH and ionic strength, the ectodomain binds collagen types I, III, and V but not types II, IV, or denatured type I. The proteoglycan binds to a single class of high affinity saturable sites on type I collagen fibrils, sites which are selective for heparin-like glycosaminoglycans. The binding of NMuMG cells to type I collagen duplicates that of their cell surface proteoglycan; cells bind to native but not denatured collagen, and binding is inhibited by heparin but not by other glycosaminoglycans. These binding properties suggest that cell surface heparan sulfate proteoglycans could act as receptors for interstitial collagens and mediate changes in cell behavior induced by collagenous matrices.     

Proteoglycan: collagen interactions in connective tissues. Ultrastructural, biochemical, functional and evolutionary aspects

Electron histochemical investigations of mammalian and echinoderm tissues, using cupromeronic blue to stain proteoglycans (PGs) specifically in critical electrolyte concentration methods, showed that collagen fibrils are associated with keratan sulphate and chondroitin (dermatan) sulphate ('tadpole') PGs at the a, c, d and e bands on the fibril surface, giving rise to the 'one proteoglycan: one binding site' hypothesis. Intra-fibrillar PGs have been observed, distributed in a regular way which suggests that collagen fibrils are aggregates of 'protofibrils', some of which carry PGs at their surfaces. A scheme for remodelling of collagen fibrils, based on recycling of these protofibrils, is outlined. The choice of which tadpole PG to use to carry out a given function is decided to a considerable extent by the availability of oxygen to the relevant tissue element.     

Structural correlations in the family of small leucine-rich repeat proteins and proteoglycans

The family of small leucine-rich repeat proteins and proteoglycans (SLRPs) contains several extracellular matrix molecules that are structurally related by a protein core composed of leucine-rich repeats (LRRs) flanked by two conserved cysteine-rich regions. The small proteoglycan decorin is the archetypal SLRP. Decorin is present in a variety of connective tissues, typically "decorating" collagen fibrils, and is involved in important biological functions, including the regulation of the assembly of fibrillar collagens and modulation of cell adhesion. Several SLRPs are known to regulate collagen fibrillogenesis and there is evidence that they may share other biological functions. We have recently determined the crystal structure of the protein core of decorin, the first such determination of a member of the SLRP family. This structure has highlighted several correlations: (1) SLRPs have similar internal repeat structures; (2) SLRP molecules are far less curved than an early model of decorin based on the three-dimensional structure of ribonuclease inhibitor; (3) the N-terminal and C-terminal cysteine-rich regions are conserved capping motifs. Furthermore, the structure shows that decorin dimerizes through the concave surface of its LRR domain, which has been implicated previously in its interaction with collagen. We have established that both decorin and opticin, another SLRP, form stable dimers in solution. Conservation of residues involved in decorin dimerization suggests that the mode of dimerization for other SLRPs will be similar. Taken together these results suggest the need for reevaluation of currently accepted models of SLRP interaction with their ligands.     

Influence of decorin on the mechanical, compositional, and structural properties of the mouse patellar tendon

The interactions of small leucine-rich proteoglycans (SLRPs) with collagen fibrils, their association with water, and their role in fibrillogenesis suggests that SLRPs may play an important role in tendon mechanics. Some studies have assessed the role of SLRPs in the mechanical response of the tendon, but the relationships between sophisticated mechanics, assembly of collagen, and SLRPs have not been well characterized. Decorin content was varied in a dose dependent manner using decorin null, decorin heterozygote, and wild type mice. Quantitative measures of mechanical (tension and compression), compositional, and structural changes of the mouse patellar tendon were evaluated. Viscoelastic, tensile dynamic modulus was increased in the decorin heterozygous tendons compared to wild type. These tendons also had a significant decrease in total collagen and no structural changes compared to wild type. Decorin null tendons did not have any mechanical changes; however, a significant decrease in the average fibril diameter was found. No differences were seen between genotypes in elastic or compressive properties, and all tendons demonstrated viscoelastic mechanical dependence on strain rate and frequency. These results suggest that decorin, a member of the SLRP family, plays a role in tendon viscoelasticity that cannot be completely explained by its role in collagen fibrillogenesis. In addition, reductions in decorin do not cause large changes in indentation compressive properties, suggesting that other factors contribute to these properties. Understanding these relationships may ultimately help guide development of tissue engineered constructs or treatment modalities.     

Collagen phagocytosis by fibroblasts is regulated by decorin

Decorin is a small, leucine-rich proteoglycan that binds to collagen and regulates fibrillogenesis. We hypothesized that decorin binding to collagen inhibits phagocytosis of collagen fibrils. To determine the effects of decorin on collagen degradation, we analyzed phagocytosis of collagen and collagen/decorin-coated fluorescent beads by Rat-2 and gingival fibroblasts. Collagen beads bound to gingival cells by alpha2beta1 integrins. Binding and internalization of decorin/collagen-coated beads decreased dose-dependently with increasing decorin concentration (p < 0.001). Inhibition of binding was sustained over 5 h (p < 0.001) and was attributed to interactions between decorin and collagen and not to decorin-collagen receptor interactions. Both the non-glycosylated decorin core protein and the thermally denatured decorin significantly inhibited collagen bead binding (approximately 50 and 89%, respectively; p < 0.05). Mimetic peptides corresponding to leucine-rich repeats 1-3, encompassed by a collagen-binding approximately 11-kDa cyanogen bromide fragment of decorin and leucine-rich repeats 4 and 5, previously shown to bind to collagen, were tested for their ability to inhibit collagen bead binding. Although the synthetic peptide 3 alone exhibited saturable binding to collagen, neither peptides 3 nor 1 and 2 markedly inhibited phagocytosis. Leucine-rich repeat 3 bound to a triple helical peptide containing the alpha2 integrin-binding site of collagen. When collagen beads were co-incubated with peptides 3 and 4, inhibition of collagen phagocytosis (55%) was equivalent to intact native/recombinant core protein. Thus a novel collagen binding domain in decorin acts cooperatively with leucine-rich repeat 4 to mask the alpha2beta1 integrin-binding site on collagen, an important sequence for the phagocytosis of collagen fibrils.     

Review: history of the amyloid fibril

Rudolph Virchow, in 1854, introduced and popularized the term amyloid to denote a macroscopic tissue abnormality that exhibited a positive iodine staining reaction. Subsequent light microscopic studies with polarizing optics demonstrated the inherent birefringence of amyloid deposits, a property that increased intensely after staining with Congo red dye. In 1959, electron microscopic examination of ultrathin sections of amyloidotic tissues revealed the presence of fibrils, indeterminate in length and, invariably, 80 to 100 A in width. Using the criteria of Congophilia and fibrillar morphology, 20 or more biochemically distinct forms of amyloid have been identified throughout the animal kingdom; each is specifically associated with a unique clinical syndrome. Fibrils, also 80 to 100 A in width, have been isolated from tissue homogenates using differential sedimentation or solubility. X-ray diffraction analysis revealed the fibrils to be ordered in the beta pleated sheet conformation, with the direction of the polypeptide backbone perpendicular to the fibril axis (cross beta structure). Because of the similar dimensions and tinctorial properties of the fibrils extracted from amyloid-laden tissues and amyloid fibrils in tissue sections, they have been assumed to be identical. However, the spatial relationship of proteoglycans and amyloid P component (AP), common to all forms of amyloid, to the putative protein only fibrils in tissues, has been unclear. Recently, it has been suggested that, in situ, amyloid fibrils are composed of proteoglycans and AP as well as amyloid proteins and thus resemble connective tissue microfibrils. Chemical and physical definition of the fibrils in tissues will be needed to relate the in vitro properties of amyloid protein fibrils to the pathogenesis of amyloid fibril formation in vivo.     

The decorin sequence SYIRIADTNIT binds collagen type I

Decorin belongs to the small leucine-rich repeat proteoglycan family, interacts with fibrillar collagens, and regulates the assembly, structure, and biomechanical properties of connective tissues. The decorin-collagen type I-binding region is located in leucine-rich repeats 5-6. Site-directed mutagenesis of this 54-residue-long collagen-binding sequence identifies Arg-207 and Asp-210 in leucine-rich repeat 6 as crucial for the binding to collagen. The synthetic peptide SYIRIADTNIT, which includes Arg-207 and Asp-210, inhibits the binding of full-length recombinant decorin to collagen in vitro. These collagen-binding amino acids are exposed on the exterior of the beta-sheet-loop structure of the leucine-rich repeat. This resembles the location of interacting residues in other leucine-rich repeat proteins.     

Fibrillogenesis of collagen types I, II, and III with small leucine-rich proteoglycans decorin and biglycan

Collagen has found use as a scaffold material for tissue engineering as well as a coating material for implants with a view to enhancing osseointegration through mimicry of the bone extracellular matrix in vivo. The aim of this study was to compare the collagen types I, II, and III with regard to their ability to bind the small leucine-rich proteoglycans (SLRPs) decorin and biglycan during fibrillogenesis in vitro in phosphate buffer. In addition, the influence of SLRPs on the proportion of collagen molecules incorporated into fibrils during fibrillogenesis in vitro at high and low ionic strength was investigated, as were their effects on the morphology of collagen fibrils and the speed of fibrillogenesis. Considerably more biglycan than decorin was bound by all three collagen types. Collagen II bound significantly more SLRPs in fibrils than collagen I and III. Decorin and biglycan decreased the proportion of collagen molecules of all three collagen types incorporated into fibrils in similar fashion. Biglycan affected neither fibril diameter nor the speed of fibrillogenesis. Decorin reduced the fibril diameter of all three collagen types. The differences in SLRP-binding ability between collagen types could be of significance when selecting collagen type and/or SLRPs as scaffold materials for tissue engineering or implant coatings.     

Mapping the heparin-binding sites on type I collagen monomers and fibrils

The glycosaminoglycan chains of cell surface heparan sulfate proteoglycans are believed to regulate cell adhesion, proliferation, and extracellular matrix assembly, through their interactions with heparin-binding proteins (for review see Ruoslahti, E. 1988. Annu. Rev. Cell Biol. 4:229-255; and Bernfield, M., R. Kokenyesi, M. Kato, M. T. Hinkes, J. Spring, R. L. Gallo, and E. J. Lose. 1992. Annu. Rev. Cell Biol. 8:365-393). Heparin-binding sites on many extracellular matrix proteins have been described; however, the heparin-binding site on type I collagen, a ubiquitous heparin-binding protein of the extracellular matrix, remains undescribed. Here we used heparin, a structural and functional analogue of heparan sulfate, as a probe to study the nature of the heparan sulfate proteoglycan-binding site on type I collagen. We used affinity coelectrophoresis to study the binding of heparin to various forms of type I collagen, and electron microscopy to visualize the site(s) of interaction of heparin with type I collagen monomers and fibrils. Using affinity coelectrophoresis it was found that heparin has similar affinities for both procollagen and collagen fibrils (Kd's approximately 60-80 nM), suggesting that functionally similar heparin- binding sites exist in type I collagen independent of its aggregation state. Complexes of heparin-albumin-gold particles and procollagen were visualized by rotary shadowing and electron microscopy, and a preferred site of heparin binding was observed near the NH2 terminus of procollagen. Native or reconstituted type I collagen fibrils showed one region of significant heparin-gold binding within each 67-nm period, present near the division between the overlap and gap zones, within the "a" bands region. According to an accepted model of collagen fibril structure, our data are consistent with the presence of a single preferred heparin-binding site near the NH2 terminus of the collagen monomer. Correlating these data with known type I collagen sequences, we suggest that the heparin-binding site in type I collagen may consist of a highly basic triple helical domain, including several amino acids known sometimes to function as disaccharide acceptor sites. We propose that the heparin-binding site of type I collagen may play a key role in cell adhesion and migration within connective tissues, or in the cell- directed assembly or restructuring of the collagenous extracellular matrix.     

Direct measurement of the rupture force of single pair of decorin interactions

Decorin is one important member of the family of small leucine-rich proteoglycans, which are widely distributed in connective tissues in the body such as tendon and ligament. Decorin may be responsible for collagen fibril connection in those tissues. A recent hypothesis suggests that decorin may bind to collagen with its core protein while binding to another decorin through the interaction with their glycosaminoglycan (GAG) chains. However, there is no direct evidence supporting this hypothesis to date. In this study, the interaction of decorin GAG chains was directly determined for the first time. The rupture force of single bonds between decorins (GAG chains interaction) was determined directly as 16.5+/-5.1 pN using a laser tweezers/interferometer single molecular nanomechanical testing system. This information can improve our understanding of the mechanical properties of connective tissues at the molecular level.     

SLRP interaction can protect collagen fibrils from cleavage by collagenases

Decorin, fibromodulin and lumican are small leucine-rich repeat proteoglycans (SLRPs) which interact with the surface of collagen fibrils. Together with other molecules they form a coat on the fibril surface which could impede the access to collagenolytic proteinases. To address this hypothesis, fibrils of type I or type II collagen were formed in vitro and treated with either collagenase-1 (MMP1) or collagenase-3 (MMP13). The fibrils were either treated directly or following incubation in the presence of the recombinant SLRPs. The susceptibility of the uncoated and SLRP-coated fibrils to collagenase cleavage was assessed by SDS/PAGE. Interaction with either recombinant decorin, fibromodulin or lumican results in decreased collagenase cleavage of both fibril types. Thus SLRP interaction can help protect collagen fibrils from cleavage by collagenases.