Model Studies of the Iron-Catalysed Haber-Weiss Cycle and the Ascorbate-Driven Fenton Reaction

Complementary hydroxylation assays and stopped-flow e.s.r. techniques have been employed in the investigation of the effect of various iron chelators (of chemical, biological and clinical importance) on hydroxyl-radical generation via the Haber-Weiss cycle and the ascorbate-driven Fenton reaction.

Chelators have been identified which selectively promote or inhibit various reactions involved in hydroxyl-radical generation (for example, NTA and EDTA promote all the reactions of both the Haber-Weiss cycle and the ascorbate-driven Fenton reaction, whereas DTPA and phytate inhibit the recycling of iron in these reactions). The biological chelators succinate and citrate are shown to be relatively poor catalysts of the Haber-Weiss cycle, whereas they are found to be effective catalysts of ·OH generation in the ascorbate-driven Fenton reaction.

It is also suggested that continuous redox-cycling reactions between iron, oxygen and ascorbate may represent an important mechanism of cell death in biological systems.     

Radical-driven Fenton reactions: studies with paraquat, adriamycin, and anthraquinone 6-sulfonate and citrate, ATP, ADP, and pyrophosphate iron chelates

Using paraquat, adriamycin, and anthraquinone 6-sulfonate, we have investigated the ability of radical-driven Fenton reactions to oxidize formate or deoxyribose when catalyzed by iron complexed with citrate, ADP, ATP, or pyrophosphate. Radicals were generated either radiolytically or enzymatically with xanthine oxidase or ferredoxin reductase. With each radical source, the citrate, ADP, and ATP complexes were at least 50% as active as Fe(EDTA) at catalyzing deoxyribose oxidation, and slightly less active as catalysts of CO2 formation from formate. Fe(pyrophosphate) was less efficient and in some cases inactive. Although it is not possible to definitively identify the oxidant involved, it behaved more like the hydroxyl radical than the proposed ferryl or peroxoferrous species formed in equivalent reactions catalyzed by nonchelated iron, which can oxidize deoxyribose but not formate. Chelator concentrations of 1-2 mM were required for maximum effect, which implies that the major effect of the chelators is on the reactivity of Fe2+ in the Fenton reaction with H2O2. This also suggests that any iron available physiologically could participate in the Fenton reaction in a nonchelated form, and produce a ferryl species rather than the hydroxyl radical. Reactions of the organic radicals contrast with the equivalent reactions of superoxide (Haber-Weiss reaction) for which the same iron chelates are all very inefficient catalysts. Fenton reactions driven by organic reducing radicals may therefore contribute more to the toxicity of redox cycling compounds than equivalent reactions of superoxide.     

The Haber-Weiss cycle--70 years later

The chain reactions HO* + H2O2 --> H2O + O2*- + H+ and O2*- + H+ + H2O2 --> O2 + HO* + H2O, commonly known as the Haber-Weiss cycle, were first mentioned by Haber and Willst?tter in 1931. George showed in 1947 that the second reaction is insignificant in comparison to the fast dismutation of superoxide, and this finding appears to have been accepted by Weiss in 1949. In 1970, the Haber-Weiss reaction was revived by Beauchamp and Fridovich to explain the toxicity of superoxide. During the 1970s various groups determined that the rate constant for this reaction is of the order of 1 M(-1) s(-1) or less, which confirmed George's conclusion. The reaction of superoxide with hydrogen peroxide was dropped from the scheme of oxygen toxicity, and superoxide became the source of hydrogen peroxide, which yields hydroxyl radicals via the Fenton reaction, Fe2+ + H2O2 --> Fe3+ + HO- + HO*. In 1994, Kahn and Kasha resurrected the Haber-Weiss reaction again, but this time the oxygen was believed to be in the singlet (1delta(g)) state. As toxicity arises not from a Fenton-catalysed Haber-Weiss reaction, but from the Fenton reaction, the Haber-Weiss reaction should not be mentioned anymore.     

The production of hydroxyl radical from hydrogen peroxide

The formation of hydroxyl radical (OH·) from the oxidation of glutathione, ascorbic acid, NADPH, hydroquinone, catechol, and riboflavin by hydrogen peroxide was studied using a range of enzymes and copper and iron complexes as possible catalysts. Copper-1,10-phenanthroline appears to catalyze the production of OH· from hydrogen peroxide without superoxide radical being formed as an intermediate, and without the involvement of a catalyzed Haber-Weiss (Fenton) reaction. Superoxide radical is involved, however, in the Cu²⁺ -catalyzed decomposition of hydrogen peroxide, and in the oxidation of glutathione by atmospheric oxygen. For this latter oxidation, copper-4,7-dimethyl-1,10-phenanthroline was found to be a much more effective catalyst than the copper complex of 1,10-phenanthroline, which is normally used. Mechanisms for these reactions are proposed, and the toxicological significance of the ability of a variety of biological reductants to provide a prolific source of OH· when oxidized by hydrogen peroxide is discussed.     

The involvement of biological quinones in the formation of hydroxyl radicals via the Haber-Weiss reaction

The present investigation was made to evaluate biologically relevant quinones as possible catalysts in the generation of hydroxyl radicals from hydrogen peroxide and superoxide radicals. ESR spectra demonstrated that menadione, plastoquinone, and ubiquinone derivatives could all be reduced to their semiquinone forms by electron transfer from superoxide radicals. Reductive homolytic cleavage of H₂O₂ was observed to be dependent upon the presence of semiquinones in the reaction medium. Our data strongly support the concept that quinones normally involved in physiological processes may also play a role as catalysts of the Haber-Weiss reaction in the biological generation of hydroxyl radicals.     

Study of a Fenton type reaction: effect of captopril and chelating reagents.

The purpose of this study was to determine if captopril, an angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor, could interact with iron ions and so modify a Fenton type reaction. Results indicate that different degrees of thiobarbituric acid-reactive substance from deoxyribose are obtained in an ascorbate-driven Fenton system depending on the order of addition of captopril and iron to the incubation medium. Similar results were obtained with the chelating reagents ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid and diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid, indicating that the buffer solution plays a relevant role when a particular iron complex is formed with a chelating agent. These metal complexes produce oxidizing species in a Fenton type system whose nature is discussed.     

Enhancement by catechols of hydroxyl-radical formation in the presence of ferric ions and hydrogen peroxide

The effect of caffeic acid, a kind of catechol, on the Fenton reaction was examined by using the ESR spin trapping technique. Caffeic acid enhanced the formation of hydroxyl radicals in the reaction mixture, which contained caffeic acid, hydrogen peroxide, ferric chloride, EDTA, and potassium phosphate buffer. Chlorogenic acid, which is an ester of caffeic acid with quinic acid, also stimulated the formation of the hydroxyl radicals. Quinic acid did not stimulate the reaction, suggesting that the catechol moiety in chlorogenic acid is essential to the enhancement of the hydroxyl-radical formation. Indeed, other catechols and related compounds such as pyrocatechol, gallic acid, dopamine, and noradrenaline effectively stimulated the formation of the hydroxyl radicals. The above results confirm the idea that the catechol moiety is essential to the enhancement. Ferulic acid, 4-hydroxy-3-methoxybenzoic acid, and salicylic acid had no effect on the formation of the hydroxyl radicals. The results indicate that the enhancement by the catechols of the formation of hydroxyl radicals is diminished if a methyl ester is formed at the position of the hydroxyl group of the catechol. In the absence of iron chelators such as EDTA, DETAPAC, desferrioxamine, citrate, and ADP, formation of hydroxyl radicals was not detected, suggesting that chelators are essential to the reaction. The enhancement of the formation of hydroxyl radicals is presumably due to the reduction of ferric ions by the catechols. Thus, the catechols may exert deleterious effects on biological systems if chelators such as EDTA, DETAPAC, desferrioxamine, citrate, and ADP are present.     

In vivo formation of single-strand breaks in DNA by hydrogen peroxide is mediated by the Haber-Weiss reaction

Phenanthroline and bipyridine, strong chelators of iron, protect DNA from single-strand break formation by H2O2 in human fibroblasts. This fact strongly supports the concept that these DNA single-strand breaks are produced by hydroxyl radicals generated by a Fenton-like reaction between intracellular Fe2+ and H2O2: H2O2 + Fe2+----Fe3+ + OH- + OH: Corroborating this idea is the fact that thiourea, an effective OH radical scavenger, prevents the formation of DNA single-strand breaks by H2O2 in nuclei from human fibroblasts. The copper chelator diethyldithiocarbamate, a strong inhibitor of superoxide dismutase, greatly enhances the in vivo production of DNA single-strand breaks by H2O in fibroblasts. This supports the idea that Fe3+ is reduced to Fe2+ by superoxide ion: O divided by 2 + Fe3+----O2 + Fe2+; and therefore that the sum of this reaction and the Fenton reaction, namely the so-called Haber-Weiss reaction, H2O2 + O divided by 2----O2 + OH- + OH; represents the mode whereby OH radical is produced from H2O2 in the cell. EDTA completely protects DNA from single-strand break formation in nuclei. The chelator therefore removes iron from the chromatin, and although the Fe-EDTA complex formed is capable of reacting with H2O2, the OH radical generated under these conditions is not close enough to hit DNA. Therefore iron complexed to chromatin functions as catalyst for the Haber-Weiss reaction in vivo, similarly to the role played by Fe-chelates in vitro.     

In vitro characteristics of 1-phenyl-3-methyl-4-acylpyrazol-5-ones iron chelators

Iron chelators represent a group of structurally different compounds sharing the ability of iron binding. The group has been evolving in recent years mainly due to novel experimental indications associated with variable requirements for iron chelators. A group of synthetic 1-phenyl-3-methyl-4-acyl-pyrazol-5-ones has been known for many years but data on their potential biological activity are rather limited.In this study, we analysed a series of these compounds for their iron-chelating properties as well as for their effects on iron based Fenton chemistry. For the former ferrozine spectrophotometric method and for the latter HPLC method with salicylic acid were used.All of the tested compounds were very efficient ferric chelators but their ferrous-chelating effects differed according to the acyl substitution. Notwithstanding various ferrous chelation activities, the individual Fe²⁺-affinities were not significantly different through pathophysiologically relevant pH conditions and some of the tested substances were more potent ferrous chelators at pH 4.5 than clinically used standard deferoxamine. Of particular interest is H₂QpyQ /2,6-bis[4(1-phenyl-3-methylpyrazol-5-one)carbonyl]pyridine/ which iron-chelating affinity increased when pH was decreasing. In spite of ferrous chelation differences, most of the tested acylpyrazolones were similarly active powerful inhibitors of Fenton chemistry as deferoxamine.Conclusively, acylpyrazolones are efficient iron chelators and H₂QpyQ may represent a prototype of novel specific chelators designated particularly for chelation at acidic conditions.     

Iron is the intracellular metal involved in the production of DNA damage by oxygen radicals.

The metal chelators 1,10-phenanthroline and 2,9-dimethyl-1,10-phenanthroline (neocuproine) showed distinct abilities to prevent hydroxyl radical formation from hydrogen peroxide and Cu+ or F2(2+) (Fenton reaction) as determined by electron spin resonance. o-Phenanthroline prevented both Fe- and Cu-mediated Fenton reactions whereas neocuproine only prevented the Cu-mediated Fenton reaction. Because only 1,10-phenanthroline but not neocuproine prevented DNA strand-break formation in hydrogen peroxide-treated mammalian fibroblasts it appears that the Fe-mediated, as compared to the Cu-mediated, intranuclear Fenton reaction is responsible for DNA damage.     

Arguments against the significance of the Fenton reaction contributing to signal pathways under in vivo conditions

One of the common explanations for oxidative stress in the physiological milieu is based on the Fenton reaction, i.e. the assumption that radical chain reactions are initiated by metal-catalyzed electron transfer to hydrogen peroxide yielding hydroxyl radicals. On the other hand — especially in the context of so-called “iron switches” — it is postulated that cellular signaling pathways originate from the interaction of reduced iron with hydrogen peroxide.

Using fluorescence detection and EPR for identification of radical intermediates, we determined the rate of iron complexation by physiological buffer together with the reaction rate of concomitant hydroxylations of aromatic compounds under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. With the obtained overall reaction rate of 1,700 M^-1s^-1 for the buffer-dependent reactions and the known rates for Fenton reactions, we derive estimates for the relative reaction probabilities of both processes.

As a consequence we suggest that under in vivo conditions initiation of chain reactions by hydroxyl radicals generated by the Fenton reaction is of minor importance and hence metal-dependent oxidative stress must be rather independent of the so-called “peroxide tone”. Furthermore, it is proposed that — in the low (subtoxic) concentration range — hydroxylated compounds derived from reactions of “non-free” (crypto) OH radicals are better candidates for iron-dependent sensing of redox-states and for explaining the origin of cellular signals than the generation of “free” hydroxyl radicals.     

On the limited ability of superoxide to release iron from ferritin

Reductive release of iron from ferritin may catalyze cytotoxic radical reactions like the Haber-Weiss reaction. The ability of .O2- to mobilize Fe(II) from ferritin was studied by using the xanthine/xanthine oxidase reaction, with and without superoxide dismutase, and with bathophenanthroline sulphonate as the chelator. Not more than one or two Fe(II)/ferritin molecules could be released by an .O2(-)-dependent mechanism, even after repeated exposures of ferritin to bursts of .O2-. The amount of releaseable iron depended on the size and the age of the iron core, but not on the iron content of the protein shell of ferritin which was manipulated by chelators and addition of FeCl3. The kinetic characteristics of the .O2(-)-mediated iron release indicated the presence of a small pool of readily available iron at the surface of the core. The very limited .O2(-)-dependent release of iron from ferritin is compatible with a protective role of ferritin against toxic iron-catalyzed reactions.     

Dusts causing pneumoconiosis generate .OH and produce hemolysis by acting as Fenton catalysts

Silicates causing pneumoconiosis function as Fenton catalysts to generate hydroxyl radicals (.OH) when incubated with hydrogen peroxide and a reducing substance. In contrast, silicates which do not cause pneumoconiosis demonstrate no Fenton activity. Catalytic activity is decreased by pretreatment of silicates with the iron chelators deferoxamine or transferrin. Hemolysis from silicates is decreased by interventions which remove superoxide anion or hydrogen peroxide from the medium, or by pretreatment of dusts with iron chelators. Thus, asbestos and nonfibrous silicates may cause pneumoconiosis through a common oxidant mechanism by catalyzing production of toxic .OH radicals in the lung.     

Inhibition of the Iron-Catalysed Formation of Hydroxyl Radicals by Nitrosouracil Derivatives: Protection of Mitochondrial Membranes Against Lipid Peroxidation

A new series of metal ligands containing the 1,3-dimethyl-6-amino-5-nitrosouracil moiety has been synthesized and they have been studied as potential inhibitors of iron-dependent lipid peroxidation. For this purpose, these new derivatives have been tested in the Fenton induced deoxyribose degradation assay, which allows a quantitative measurement of their inhibitory effect towards hydroxyl radical generation. When iron(II) is complexed by these ligands, a strong inhibition of deoxyribose degradation is observed, especially in the case of tris-[2-(1,3-dimethyl-5-nitrosouracil-6-yl)aminoethyl] amine (5). This inhibitory effect is clearly related to a specific complexation of iron(II) and is not due to the direct scavenging of hydroxyl radical by the ligand. Inhibition of the iron mediated Fenton reaction presumably results from inactivation of the reactivity of the metal center towards hydrogen peroxide. These derivatives, as well as long alkyl chain substituted nitrosouracils were evaluated in the protection of biological membranes against lipid peroxidation (induced by iron(II)/ dihydroxyfumaric acid and determined with the 2-thiobarbituric acid test). Ligand 5 inhibited lipid peroxidation at a rate similar to Desferal (desferrioxamine B) and slightly higher than bathophenanthroline sulphonate (BPS), which are respectively good iron(III) and iron(II) chelators. When covalently bound with a long alkyl chain, the increase of lipophilic character of the ligand allows its location near the mitochondrial membrane, where lipid peroxidation occurs. Lower concentrations (IC₅₀ = 4 μM) are then necessary to inhibit lipid peroxidation. This IC₅₀ concentration should be compared to those obtained for Trolox (IC₅₀ = 3 μM) or the 21-aminosteroid U74500A (IC₅₀ = 1 μM) described previously.     

Cytochrome P450 and steroid hydroxylase activity in mouse olfactory and vomeronasal mucosa

Neopterin and 7,8-dihydroneopterin, two compounds which are secreted by activated macrophages, have been shown to interfere with radicals generated by cellular and certain chemical systems. Reduced pterins were reported to scavenge whereas aromatic pterins promoted or reduced radical mediated reactions or had no effect. However, recently it was found that high concentrations of 7, 8-dihydroneopterin enhanced luminol dependent chemiluminescence and T-cell apoptosis, suggesting an enhancement of free radical formation. In this study hydroxylation of salicylic acid was used for detection of hydroxyl radicals. It is shown that in solutions of 7,8-dihydroneopterin hydroxyl radicals were formed in the absence of any radical source. The presence of EDTA chelated iron enhanced hydroxyl radical formation. Whereas the addition of iron accelerated the hydroxylation reaction, 7,8-dihydroneopterin was responsible for the amount of hydroxylation products. In the presence of superoxide dismutase or catalase, as well as by helium purging, hydroxylation was inhibited. Our data suggest that in solutions of 7, 8-dihydroneopterin superoxide radicals are generated which are converted to hydroxyl radicals by Fenton or Haber-Weiss type reactions. While superoxide might be generated during autoxidation of ferrous iron, dihydroneopterin seems to be involved in regeneration of ferrous iron from the ferric form.     

The Autoxidation of Iron(Ii) in Aqueous Systems: The Effects of Iron Chelation by Physiological, Non-Physiological and Therapeutic Chelators on the Generation of Reactive Oxygen Species and the Inducement of Biomolecular Damage

The ability of various iron(II)-complexes of biological, clinical and chemical interest to reduce molecular oxygen to reactive oxy-radicals has been investigated using complementary oxygen-uptake studies and e.s.r. techniques. It is demonstrated that although the rate of oxygen reduction by a given iron complex is directly related to its redox potential [thus complexes with low values of E⁰ for the Fe(III)/Fe(II) couple are the most effective reductants of oxygen], the overall ability of an iron(II) complex to induce oxidative biomolecular damage is also determined by its ability to undergo redox-cycling reactions with reducing radicals formed following the reaction of hydroxyl radicals with organic substrates present in the system (e.g. metal-ion chelators and organic buffers). Evidence is presented to suggest that the “Good” buffer MOPS forms a reducing radical following attack by -OH, and hence encourages the autoxidation of iron with the generation of oxy-radicals (as also observed for some of the chelates studied); this may have important implications for the use of such buffers in free-radical studies.     

Submicromolar hydrogen peroxide disrupts the ability of Fur protein to control free-iron levels in Escherichia coli

In aerobic environments, mutants of Escherichia coli that lack peroxidase and catalase activities (Hpx(-)) accumulate submicromolar concentrations of intracellular H(2)O(2). We observed that in defined medium these strains constitutively expressed members of the Fur regulon. Iron-import proteins, which Fur normally represses, were fully induced. H(2)O(2) may antagonize Fur function by oxidizing the Fur:Fe(2+) complex and inactivating its repressor function. This is a potential problem, as in iron-rich environments excessive iron uptake would endanger H(2)O(2)-stressed cells by accelerating hydroxyl-radical production through the Fenton reaction. However, the OxyR H(2)O(2)-response system restored Fur repression in iron-replete Luria-Bertani medium by upregulating the synthesis of Fur protein. Indeed, when the OxyR binding site upstream of fur was disrupted, Hpx(-) mutants failed to repress transporter synthesis, and they exhibited high levels of intracellular free iron. Mutagenesis and bacteriostasis resulted. These defects were eliminated by mutations or chelators that slowed iron import, confirming that dysregulation of iron uptake was the root problem. Thus, aerobic organisms must grapple with a conundrum: how to monitor iron levels in oxidizing environments that might perturb the valence of the analyte. The induction of Fur synthesis by the OxyR response comprises one evolutionary solution to that problem.     

A site-specific mechanism for free radical induced biological damage: the essential role of redox-active transition metals

The metal-mediated site-specific mechanism for free radical-induced biological damage is reviewed. According to this mechanism, cooper- or iron-binding sites on macromolecules serve as centers for repeated production of hydroxyl radicals that are generated via the Fenton reaction. The aberrations induced by superoxide, ascorbate, isouramil, and paraquat are summarized. An illustrative example is the enhancement of double-strand breaks by ascorbate/copper. Prevention of the site-specific free radical damage can be accomplished by using selective chelators for iron and copper, by displacing these redox-active metals with other redox-inactive metals such as zinc, by introducing high concentrations of hydroxyl radicals scavengers and spin trapping agents, and by applying protective enzymes that remove superoxide or hydrogen peroxide. Histidine is a special agent that can intervene in free radical reactions in variety of modes. In biological systems, there are traces of copper and iron that are at high enough levels to catalyze free-radical reactions, and account for such deleterious processes. In the human body Fe/Cu = 80/1 (w/w). Nevertheless, both (free) copper and iron are soluble enough, and the rate constants of their reduced forms with hydrogen peroxide are sufficiently high to suggest that they might be important mediators of free radical toxicity.     

Superoxide dismutase enhances the formation of hydroxyl radicals in the reaction of 3-hydroxyanthranilic acid with molecular oxygen.

Superoxide dismutase (SOD) enhanced the formation of hydroxyl radicals, which were detected by using the e.s.r. spin-trapping technique, in a reaction mixture containing 3-hydroxyanthranilic acid (or p-aminophenol), Fe3+ ions, EDTA and potassium phosphate buffer, pH 7.4. The hydroxyl-radical formation enhanced by SOD was inhibited by catalase and desferrioxamine, and stimulated by EDTA and diethylenetriaminepenta-acetic acid, suggesting that both hydrogen peroxide and iron ions participate in the reaction. The hydroxyl-radical formation enhanced by SOD may be considered to proceed via the following steps. First, 3-hydroxyanthranilic acid is spontaneously auto-oxidized in a process that requires molecular oxygen and yields superoxide anions and anthranilyl radicals. This reaction seems to be reversible. Secondly, the superoxide anions formed in the first step are dismuted by SOD to generate hydrogen peroxide and molecular oxygen, and hence the equilibrium in the first step is displaced in favour of the formation of superoxide anions. Thirdly, hydroxyl radicals are generated from hydrogen peroxide through the Fenton reaction. In this Fenton reaction Fe2+ ions are available since Fe3+ ions are readily reduced by 3-hydroxyanthranilic acid. The superoxide anions do not seem to participate in the reduction of Fe3+ ions, since superoxide anions are rapidly dismuted by SOD present in the reaction mixture.