人类疾病的动物模型

发展对人类疾病有效的预测、预防、诊断和治疗等途径,一直是人口健康领域关注的焦点.任何人类疾病似乎都可归咎于遗传背景和环境因素的共同作用,并影响到疾病的发生、病程、药物疗效和预后等.最有效的研究策略足直接针对患者的各方面临床研究,但这一策略常常会而临着同一临床症状却有不同病因(异质性)、个体差异显著(如治疗效果因人而异)以及难以回溯性地研究人类疾病的发生、发展(如发病以前的事件或经历)等问题,而且医学伦理学的要求使得大量医学研究和新药新疗法不能直接应用于人体,必须先有动物实验阐明其安全性和必要性.最佳的研究策略足创建人类疾病的动物模型,因为可严格地控制病因、遗传背景、环境因子等,也可跟踪性研究动物模型病症的发生、发展、治疗反应和结局等,但这一策略也常常面临着一系列问题和误解.对此,在<动物学研究>出版<灵长类动物与人类疾病模型>专刊之际,撰写此评述性论文,将系列问题和误解一一提出,并讨论其应对策略.     

Animal models of neurodegenerative diseases

Numerous evidences indicate that the phenotype of a neurodegenerative disease and its pathogenetic mechanism are only loosely linked. The phenotype is directly related to the topography of the lesions and is reproduced whatever the mechanism as soon as the same neurons are destroyed or deficient: the symptoms of Parkinson disease are mimicked by any destruction of the neurons of the substantia nigra, caused for instance by the toxin MPTP. This does not mean that idiopathic Parkinson disease is due to MPTP. In the same way, mouse lines such as Reeler, Weaver and Staggerer in which ataxia occurs spontaneously does not help to understand human ataxias: now that mutations responsible for these phenotypes have been identified, it appears that one is responsible for lissencephaly (mutation of the reelin gene) and the other two have no equivalent in man. Therapeutic attempts, however, rely on the understanding of the pathogenetic mechanisms. Introducing a mutated human transgene in the genome of an animal has, in many instances, significantly improved this understanding. Transgenic mice have proven useful in reproducing lesions seen in neurodegenerative disease such as the plaques of Alzheimer disease (in the APP mouse which has integrated the mutated gene of the amyloid protein precursor), the tau glial and neuronal accumulation (seen in cases of frontotemporal dementias due to tau mutation), the nuclear inclusions caused by CAG triplet expansion (seen in the mutation of Huntington disease and autosomal dominant spinocerebellar ataxias). These recent advances have fostered numerous therapeutic attempts. Transgenesis in drosophila and in the worm Caenorhabditis elegans have opened new possibilities in the screening of protein partners, modifier genes, and potential therapeutic molecules. However, it is also becoming clear that introducing a human mutated gene in an animal does not necessarily trigger pathogenetic cascades identical to those seen in the human disease. Human diseases have to be studied in parallel with their animal models to ensure that the model mimic at least a few original mechanisms, on which new therapeutics may be tested.     

Animal models of primary myocardial diseases

Feline and canine cardiomyopathies (primary myocardial diseases) were reviewed and divided into three groups based on the clinical, hemodynamic, angiocardiographic, and pathologic findings: (1) feline and canine hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, (2) feline and canine congestive (dilated) cardiomyopathy, and (3) feline restrictive cardiomyopathy. All three groups consisted predominantly of mature adult male cats and dogs. Cardiomyopathy in the hamster and turkey was also reviewed. The most common presenting signs were dyspnea and/or thromboembolism in the cat, systolic murmurs with gallop rhythms on auscultation, cardiomegaly with (groups 1 and 3) or without (group 2) pulmonary edema, abnormal electrocardiograms, elevated left ventricular end-diastolic pressures, and angiocardiographic evidence of mitral regurgitation with left ventricular concentric hypertrophy (group 1), left ventricular dilatation (group 2), or midventricular stenosis (group 3). Some cats in groups 1 and 3 also had evidence of left ventricular outflow obstruction. The principal pathologic findings in all of the cats and dogs were left atrial dilation, hypertrophy, increased septal:left ventricular free wall thickness ratio with disorganization of cardiac muscle cells (group 1); dilatation of the four chambers with degeneration of cardiac muscle cells (group 2); and extensive endocardial fibrosis and adhesion of the left ventricle (group 3). Aortic thromboembolism was commonly observed in the cats of all three groups. These clinical and pathologic findings indicate that cardiomyopathy in the cat or dog is similar to the three forms of cardiomyopathy in humans (hypertrophic, congestive, and restrictive).     

Animal models of complex diseases: an initial strategy

We speculated that the rise in atmospheric oxygen from 2 billion years ago was so integral for the evolution of biocomplexity that it must also associate strongly with complex diseases. As a remote test of this idea, we hypothesized that lines contrasting for disease and health would emerge from artificial selection for low and high aerobic treadmill running capacity. Eleven generations of selection in rats produced lines that differed by 347% in running capacity. The low line demonstrated health risk factors including higher visceral adiposity, blood pressure, insulin, and triglycerides. The high line was superior for VO2max, economy of running, heart function, and nitric oxide-induced vascular dilation.     

Animal models of HLA-B27-associated diseases

The HLA-B27 molecule is strongly associated with the spondyloarthropathies (SpA), a group of inflammatory conditions affecting the skeleton, the skin and several mucosae. The mechanism of this association remains unknown, largely because the HLA-B27 molecule displays normal function. A disease that closely mimicks SpA arises spontaneously in HLA-B27 transgenic rats. This disease is dependent on the presence of a normal bacterial flora and implicates the immune system. The presence of both CD4+ T cells and antigen presenting cells (APCs) expressing high levels of HLA-B27, seems of critical importance in its pathogenesis, whereas CD8+ T cells are dispensable. The T cell stimulatory function of APCs is disturbed by the HLA-B27 molecule. This disease could result from a failure of tolerance, related in part to high level of B27 expression in professional APCs and to the immune response to gut bacteria. In contrast, HLA-B27 transgenic mice have usually remained healthy. However, two types of inflammatory conditions affecting the skeleton, which arise in mice of susceptible background after exposure to a conventional bacterial flora, are increased by an HLA-B27 transgene. The first is ANKENT, a spontaneous ankylosing enthesitis that affects ankle and/or tarsal joints of ageing mice; the second is a spontaneous arthritis of hindpaws developing in mice lacking endogenous mbeta2m. As in rats, the absence of CD8+ T cells in the latter model, argues against the "arthritogenic peptide" hypothesis. In these mbeta2m0 mice, B27 free heavy chain could be implicated in the pathogenesis of arthritis by presenting extracellular peptides to CD4+ T cells.     

Animal models of polyglutamine diseases and therapeutic approaches

The dominant gain-of-function polyglutamine repeat diseases, in which the initiating mutation is known, allow development of models that recapitulate many aspects of human disease. To the extent that pathology is a consequence of disrupted fundamental cellular activities, one can effectively study strategies to ameliorate or protect against these cellular insults. Model organisms allow one to identify pathways that affect disease onset and progression, to test and screen for pharmacological agents that affect pathogenic processes, and to validate potential targets genetically as well as pharmacologically. Here, we describe polyglutamine repeat diseases that have been modeled in a variety of organisms, including worms, flies, mice, and non-human primates, and discuss examples of how they have broadened the therapeutic landscape.     

Peripheral vascular apparatus in some aquatic oligochaetes with special references to haplotaxids

The organization of the peripheral vascular apparatus in two haplotaxids has been studied and compared with that of other microdriles. Considerable differences in the circulatory systems of Pelodrilus leruthi and Haplotaxis gordioides, especially in relationships to the body wall muscle fibers, separate and distinguish the two animals. Different organizations of the peripheral apparatus that can be observed in these microdriles are: in the first species, capillary vessels have no contact with the body wall; in the second species, capillaries extend between the longitudinal muscle fibers until they reach the body surface, thus approaching the situation in megadriles where circulation can become intraepithelial.Generally, vessels hanging in the coelom are of a large diameter. When a capillary network related to the body wall muscle develops, vessels are small in diameter and their walls have variable numbers of contractile elements, ensuring the forced circulation of the blood.     

Endogenous CD8+ T cell expansion during regression of monoclonal EBV-associated posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorder.

There are experimental data which suggest that the primary immune effector cell responsible for maintaining immune surveillance against the outgrowth of EBV-transformed B cells in humans is the CTL, but in vivo proof of this is lacking. In this study we perform a series of cellular and molecular assays to characterize an autologous, endogenous immune response against a transplantation-associated, monoclonal, EBV+ posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorder (PTLD). Following allogeneic bone marrow transplantation, a patient developed a monoclonal PTLD of donor B cell origin. With a decrease in immune suppression, we document the emergence of endogenous, donor-derived CD3+CD8+ CTLs, followed by regression of the PTLD. The TCR Vbeta repertoire went from a polyclonal pattern prior to the development of PTLD to a restricted TCR Vbeta pattern during the outgrowth and regression of PTLD. Donor-derived CD3+CD8+ T lymphocytes displayed MHC class I-restricted cytolytic activity against the autologous EBV+ B cells ex vivo without additional in vitro sensitization. The striking temporal relationship between the endogenous expansion of a TCR Vbeta-restricted, CD3+CD8+ population of MHC class I-restricted CTL, and the regression of an autologous monoclonal PTLD, provides direct evidence in humans that endogenous CD3+CD8+ CTLs can be responsible for effective immune surveillance against malignant transformation of EBV+ B cells.     

In vitro and in vivo translational models for rare liver diseases

A challenge in developing effective treatments is the modeling of the human disease using in vitro and in vivo systems. Animal models have played a critical role in the understanding of disease pathophysiology, target validation, and evaluation of novel therapeutic agents. However, as the success rate from entry into clinical testing to drug approval remains low, it is critical to have high quality and well-validated models reflective of the disease condition. Additional experimental models are being developed based on functional in vitro 3D tissue models such as organoids and 3D bioprinted tissues. Because these 3D tissue models mimic closer the architecture, cell composition and physiology of native tissues, they are now being used as screening platforms in drug discovery and development and for tissue transplant in regenerative medicine. Here we review the current state-of-art of in vitro and in vivo translational models for the development of therapies for rare diseases of the liver.