Nitric oxide and hydrogen cyanide as regulating factors of enzymatic antioxidant system in germinating apple embryos

Short-term (3 or 6 h) pre-treatment of apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) embryos with nitric oxide (NO) or hydrogen cyanide (HCN) induces transient accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) leading to dormancy removal and germination. We demonstrated that enhanced NO emission by apple embryos during early phase of germination “sensu stricto” is required for seed transition from dormant into non-dormant state, and may be described by the model of “nitrosative door”, analogous to “oxidative window”. Cellular ROS concentration, resulting from NO or HCN embryo pre-treatment, seems to be under severe control of antioxidant system. Activity of superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT), glutathione reductase (GR), glutathione peroxidase (GPX) and total peroxidases (Prxs) was determined during NO and HCN-mediated germination “sensu stricto” of embryos. CAT and SOD activity increased transiently 24 h after embryos pre-treatment, while GR and Prx activity was stimulated mainly after 96 h. The most evident alterations were detected in GPX activity, being more than threefold stimulated by NO or HCN. Based on this results, we conclude that these reactive molecules act simultaneously crossing their signaling pathways and we propose that ROS, reactive nitrogen species, HCN at accurate level are essential during seed germination as signaling factors.     

Nitric oxide,hydrogen cyanide and ethylene are required in the control of germination and undisturbed development of young apple seedlings

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) are emerging as important regulators of plant development (germination, flowering, senescence), acting as secondary messengers in cooperation with classical phytohormones. Apple seeds are dormant, unless they undergo a 3 month long cold stratification. Deep dormancy of isolated apple embryos can also be broken by short pre-treatment with HCN or NO with the effect associated with enhanced ethylene synthesis. Non-dormant embryos germinate well and young seedlings grown from non-dormant embryos do not exhibit any morphological anomalies, such as asymmetric growth and greening of cotyledons. One of the aims of this work was to investigate the correlation between RNS- mediated (HCN- and NO-dependent) dormancy removal and ROS (H₂O₂ and O₂^−•) accumulation in the embryos. The beneficial effect of NO and HCN on germination of dormant apple embryos has been associated with marked increases in H₂O₂ and O₂^−• concentration in the embryos at early germination stages. We also analyzed growth of young seedlings developed from embryos pre-treatment with HCN or NO or exposed to ethylene (ethephone) and its precursor 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC). ACC and ethephone removed all morphological anomalies of the seedlings (asymmetric growth and greening of cotyledons) but the radicle growth was rather slight. We propose that accumulation of ROS provoked by HCN and NO pre-treatment is required for embryo germination “sensu stricto”, while ethylene is required for post-germination seedling growth.     

The beneficial effect of small toxic molecules on dormancy alleviation and germination of apple embryos is due to NO formation

Deep dormancy of apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) seeds is terminated by a 3-month-long cold stratification. It is expressed by rapid germination of seeds and undisturbed growth of seedlings. However, stimulation of germination of isolated apple embryos is also observed after applying inhibitors of cytochrome c oxidase: nitric oxide (NO) or hydrogen cyanide (HCN) during the first 3–6 h of imbibition of dormant embryos. The aim of this work was to compare the effect of yet another toxic gaseous molecule carbon monoxide (CO) with the effects of HCN and NO on germination of apple embryos and growth and development of young seedlings. We demonstrated that stimulation of germination after short-term pre-treatment with HCN, NO or CO was accompanied by enhanced NO emission from the embryo axes during their elongation. Moreover, similarly high NO production from non-dormant embryos, after cold stratification, was detected. Therefore, we propose that NO may act as signaling molecule in apple embryo dormancy break.     

Breaking the apple embryo dormancy by nitric oxide involves the stimulation of ethylene production

Mature seeds of apple (Mallus domestica Borb. cv. Antonówka) are dormant and do not germinate unless their dormancy is removed by several weeks of moist-cold treatment. We investigated the effect of short-term (3 h) nitric oxide (NO) pretreatment on breaking of apple embryonic dormancy expressed as inhibition of germination and morphological abnormalities of young seedlings. Imbibition of embryos isolated from dormant apple seeds with sodium nitroprusside (SNP) or S-nitroso,N-acetyl penicillamine (SNAP) as NO donors resulted in enhanced germination. Moreover, NO treatment removed morphological abnormalities of seedlings developing from dormant embryo. The NO scavenger 2-(4-carboxyphenyl)-4,4,5,5-teramethylimidazoline-1-oxyl-3 oxide (cPTIO) removed the above effects. NO-mediated breaking of embryonic dormancy correlated well with enhanced ethylene production. Inhibitor of ethylene synthesis (AOA) reversed the stimulatory effect of NO donors on embryo germination. Additionally SNP reduced embryo sensitivity to exogenously applied ABA ensuing dormancy breakage. We can conclude that NO acts as a regulatory factor included in the control of apple embryonic dormancy breakage by stimulation of ethylene biosynthesis.     

Dormancy alleviation by NO or HCN leading to decline of protein carbonylation levels in apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) embryos

Deep dormancy of apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) embryos can be overcome by short-term pre-treatment with nitric oxide (NO) or hydrogen cyanide (HCN). Dormancy alleviation of embryos modulated by NO or HCN and the first step of germination depend on temporary increased production of reactive oxygen species (ROS). Direct oxidative attack on some amino acid residues or secondary reactions via reactive carbohydrates and lipids can lead to the formation of protein carbonyl derivatives. Protein carbonylation is a widely accepted covalent and irreversible modification resulting in inhibition or alteration of enzyme/protein activities. It also increases the susceptibility of proteins to proteolytic degradation. The aim of this work was to investigate protein carbonylation in germinating apple embryos, the dormancy of which was removed by pre-treatment with NO or HCN donors. It was performed using a quantitative spectrophotometric method, while patterns of carbonylated protein in embryo axes were analyzed by immunochemical techniques. The highest concentration of protein carbonyl groups was observed in dormant embryos. It declined in germinating embryos pre-treated with NO or HCN, suggesting elevated degradation of modified proteins during seedling formation. A decrease in the concentration of carbonylated proteins was accompanied by modification in proteolytic activity in germinating apple embryos. A strict correlation between the level of protein carbonyl groups and cotyledon growth and greening was detected. Moreover, direct in vitro carbonylation of BSA treated with NO or HCN donors was analyzed, showing action of both signaling molecules as protein oxidation agents.     

Dormancy removal of apple seeds by cold stratification is associated with fluctuation in H2O2, NO production and protein carbonylation level

Reactive oxygen (ROS) and nitrogen (RNS) species play a signaling role in seed dormancy alleviation and germination. Their action may be described by the oxidative/nitrosative “window/door”. ROS accumulation in embryos could lead to oxidative modification of protein through carbonylation. Mature apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) seeds are dormant and do not germinate. Their dormancy may be overcome by 70–90 days long cold stratification. The aim of this work was to analyze the relationship between germinability of embryos isolated from cold (5 °C) or warm (25 °C) stratified apple seeds and ROS or nitric oxide (NO) production and accumulation of protein carbonyl groups. A biphasic pattern of variation in H₂O₂ concentration in the embryos during cold stratification was detected. H₂O₂ content increased markedly after 7 days of seeds imbibition at 5 °C. After an additional two months of cold stratification, the H₂O₂ concentration in embryos reached the maximum. NO production by the embryos was low during entire period of stratification, but increased significantly in germination sensu stricto (i.e. phase II of the germination process). The highest content of protein carbonyl groups was detected after 6 weeks of cold stratification treatment. Fluctuation of H₂O₂ and protein carbonylation seems to play a pivotal role in seed dormancy alleviation by cold stratification, while NO appears to be necessary for seed germination.     

Polyamines and Nitric Oxide Link in Regulation of Dormancy Removal and Germination of Apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) Embryos

Polyamines (PAs) belong to plant growth regulators and in complex with classical phytohormones take part in regulation of seed dormancy and germination. Although the impact of reactive oxygen (ROS) and nitrogen (RNS) species on seed germination is well described, the cross talk of PAs with ROS/RNS has never been analyzed. Due to the close connection of PAs and ethylene biosynthetic pathways to arginine (Arg)-dependent NO biosynthesis we investigated production of nitric oxide (NO), peroxynitrite (ONOO^?) and the level of O ₂ ^?? or H₂O₂ in apple embryos, germination of which was PA regulated. PAs: putrescine (Put) and spermidine (Spd) in contrast to spermine (Spm) stimulated germination of apple embryos. Among amino acids, stimulation of germination was observed in Arg and ornithine (Orn) only. Dormancy removal of embryos by PAs was associated with increased accumulation of H₂O₂ and O ₂ ^?? in embryonic axes. At the same stage of completion of sensu stricto germination the stimulatory effect of PAs (Put and Spd) and amino acids, mainly Arg and Orn, was accompanied by enhanced NO and ONOO^? production in embryonic axis. The beneficial effect of PAs (Put and Spd) and their precursors on germination of apple embryos was removed by NO scavenging, suggesting a crucial role of NO in termination of embryo germination and radicle growth. Moreover, activity of polyamine oxidase in embryo axes was greatly enhanced by embryo fumigation with NO. Our data demonstrate the interplay of RNS/ROS with PAs and point to NO action as an integrator of endogenous signals activating germination.     

Assessment of the Germination Potential of Brassica oleracea Seeds Treated with Karrikin 1 and Cyanide,Which Modify the Ethylene Biosynthetic Pathway

The relationship between ethylene and cyanide (HCN) and karrikin 1 (KAR1) in dormancy release was studied in secondary dormant Brassica oleracea L. (Chinese cabbage) seeds. Freshly harvested seeds of Brassica oleracea usually have poor germination potential. Karrikin1 (KAR1) and cyanide (HCN) are able to stimulate seed germination. However, the stimulatory effects of these two chemicals depend on the activation of the ethylene biosynthesis pathway and on ethylene perception. In this study, KAR1 and HCN application increased the activity of ethylene and of two ethylene biosynthesis enzymes, ACC synthase (ACS) and ACC oxidase (ACO). KAR1 and HCN collectively promoted the accumulation of 1 aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC). In the presence of NO (nitric oxide) and KAR1, ACS and ACO activities reached their maximum levels after 36 and 42 h, respectively. Ethylene inhibitors suppressed seed germination by approximately 55%, whereas the respiratory inhibitors SHAM and NaN3 inhibited seed germination by 5–10% in the presence of HCN and KAR1. KAR1 and HCN collectively reduced the abscisic acid (ABA) content in seeds, increased the gibberellic acid (GA) content and released seed dormancy. The expression of ethylene biosynthesis genes and ethylene receptor genes (BOACO1, BOACS1, BOACS3, BOACS4, BOACS5, BOACS7, BOACS9, BOACS11, BOETR1 and BOETR2) provided further evidence of the involvement of ethylene in KAR1 and HCN-induced germination. BOACO1, BOACS1, BOACS5, BOACS7, BOACS9, BOACS11, BOETR1 and BOETR2 genes were up regulated in the presence of KAR1 and HCN, while the remaining genes were down regulated. The expression of various ethylene biosynthesis and ethylene receptor genes suggested functional diversification and variations in seed sensitivity in the presence of KAR1 and HCN. Therefore, in the current study, KAR1 and HCN application effectively induced the germination of B. oleracea seeds (approximately 97% germination rate) after 6 days by modifying the ethylene biosynthetic pathway.

     

Ethylene in seed dormancy and germination

The role of ethylene in the release of primary and secondary dormancy and the germination of non-dormant seeds under normal and stressed conditions is considered. In many species, exogenous ethylene, or ethephon – an ethylene-releasing compound - stimulates seed germination that may be inhibited because of embryo or coat dormancy, adverse environmental conditions or inhibitors (e.g. abscisic acid, jasmonate). Ethylene can either act alone, or synergistically or additively with other factors. The immediate precursor of ethylene biosynthesis, 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), may also improve seed germination, but usually less effectively. Dormant or non-dormant inhibited seeds have a lower ethylene production ability, and ACC and ACC oxidase activity than non-dormant, uninhibited seeds. Aminoethoxyvinyl-glycine (AVG) partially or markedly inhibits ethylene biosynthesis in dormant or non-dormant seeds, but does not affect seed germination. Ethylene binding is required in seeds of many species for dormancy release or germination under optimal or adverse conditions. There are examples where induction of seed germination by some stimulators requires ethylene action. However, the mechanism of ethylene action is almost unknown.
The evidence presented here shows that ethylene performs a relatively vital role in dormancy release and seed germination of most plant species studied.     

Action of ferric and aluminium ions on the dormancy breakage of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Stylosanthes humilis</Emphasis> seeds

Dormancy of scarified seeds of Stylosanthes humilis was broken by acidic Al³⁺ and Fe³⁺ solutions. Fe⁺³-stimulated seeds exhibited a high activity of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) oxidase and produced great amounts of ethylene, which showed correlated with the germination process. In addition, specific inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis and action largely depressed the Fe³⁺-stimulated germination, leading to the conclusion that the ion broke dormancy by triggering ethylene production by the seeds. By contrast, inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis and action did not impair germination of Al³⁺-stimulated dormant seeds. Moreover, ethylene production and activity of ACC oxidase of Al³⁺-treated seeds was substantially decreased by inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis, but germination kept large. Together these data suggest that ethylene biosynthesis was not required in the chain of events triggered by Al³⁺ leading to dormancy breakage. Methyl viologen (MV), a reactive oxygen species-generating compound, broke dormancy of seeds to the same extent as Al³⁺ did. Germination of both Al³⁺- and MV-stimulated dormant seeds was inhibited by sodium selenate, an antioxidant compound; selenate, however had no effect on germination of Fe³⁺-stimulated seeds. Together these data indicate that the mechanisms underlying the germination of Al³⁺- and Fe³⁺-treated seeds are not the same.     

Nitric oxide and HCN reduce deep dormancy of apple seeds

Nitric oxide (NO) and cyanide (HCN) are small gaseous molecules that have been intensively studied to explain their role in plant development, metabolism and reaction to stresses. Cyanide and NO are known to be produced endogenously during early phase of seed germination or are present in the environment. Both molecules regulate breakage of seed dormancy and accelerate seed germination. Regulatory role of cyanide in breaking of dormancy seems to be understood to some extend, while the NO mode of action is much less explained. However, some similarities could be suggested. The mechanisms involved in HCN-dependent dormancy breakage in apple embryos are summarized in relation to NO-donor mediated stimulation of germination.     

Expression of MdCAS1 and MdCAS2, encoding apple beta-cyanoalanine synthase homologs, is concomitantly induced during ripening and implicates MdCASs in the possible role of the cyanide detoxification in Fuji apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) fruits

Fruit ripening involves complex biochemical and physiological changes. Ethylene is an essential hormone for the ripening of climacteric fruits. In the process of ethylene biosynthesis, cyanide (HCN), an extremely toxic compound, is produced as a co-product. Thus, most cyanide produced during fruit ripening should be detoxified rapidly by fruit cells. In higher plants, the key enzyme involved in the detoxification of HCN is β-cyanoalanine synthase (β-CAS). As little is known about the molecular function of β-CAS genes in climacteric fruits, we identified two homologous genes, MdCAS1 and MdCAS2, encoding Fuji apple β-CAS homologs. The structural features of the predicted polypeptides as well as an in vitro enzyme activity assay with bacterially expressed recombinant proteins indicated that MdCAS1 and MdCAS2 may indeed function as β-CAS isozymes in apple fruits. RNA gel-blot studies revealed that both MdCAS1 and MdCAS2 mRNAs were coordinately induced during the ripening process of apple fruits in an expression pattern comparable with that of ACC oxidase and ethylene production. The MdCAS genes were also activated effectively by exogenous ethylene treatment and mechanical wounding. Thus, it seems like that, in ripening apple fruits, expression of MdCAS1 and MdCAS2 genes is intimately correlated with a climacteric ethylene production and ACC oxidase activity. In addition, β-CAS enzyme activity was also enhanced as the fruit ripened, although this increase was not as dramatic as the mRNA induction pattern. Overall, these results suggest that MdCAS may play a role in cyanide detoxification in ripening apple fruits.     

The Arabidopsis aleurone layer responds to nitric oxide, gibberellin, and abscisic acid and is sufficient and necessary for seed dormancy

Seed dormancy is a common phase of the plant life cycle, and several parts of the seed can contribute to dormancy. Whole seeds, seeds lacking the testa, embryos, and isolated aleurone layers of Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) were used in experiments designed to identify components of the Arabidopsis seed that contribute to seed dormancy and to learn more about how dormancy and germination are regulated in this species. The aleurone layer was found to be the primary determinant of seed dormancy. Embryos from dormant seeds, however, had a lesser growth potential than those from nondormant seeds. Arabidopsis aleurone cells were examined by light and electron microscopy, and cell ultrastructure was similar to that of cereal aleurone cells. Arabidopsis aleurone cells responded to nitric oxide (NO), gibberellin (GA), and abscisic acid, with NO being upstream of GA in a signaling pathway that leads to vacuolation of protein storage vacuoles and abscisic acid inhibiting vacuolation. Molecular changes that occurred in embryos and aleurone layers prior to germination were measured, and these data show that both the aleurone layer and the embryo expressed the NO-associated gene AtNOS1, but only the embryo expressed genes for the GA biosynthetic enzyme GA3 oxidase.     

Cyanide controls enzymes involved in lipid and sugar catabolism in dormant apple embryos during culture

The activities of alkaline lipase (EC 3.1.1.3, AlkL), isocitrate lyase (EC 4.1.3.1. ICL), pyruvate kinase (EC 2.7.1.40. PK) and glucose–6–phosphate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.49, G6PDH) were determined in cultured, dormant embryos of apple (Malus domestica Borb. cv. Antonówka), pretreated with gaseous HCN. The C₆/C₁ , ratio was estimated in the same material. The activities of AlkL and ICL were not stimulated by HCN pretreatment until the period of maximum stimulation of germination. The activity of G6PDH was inhibited by cyanide only late during the culture of embryos. Therefore, the changes in these activities are considered to be the result and not the cause of enhanced germination. On the other hand, also PK, active very early during the culture of embryos, was modified as a result of the treatment. The cyanide-induced changes in activity of this enzyme in cotyledons (inhibition followed by stimulation) were similar to those in the whole embryo, whereas its changes in the embryonal axis (stimulation followed by inhibition) resembled CN-induced changes in PK in axes of apple seeds submitted to cold stratification (Bogatek and Lewak 1988). The estimation of C₆/C₁ ratios partly confirmed these observations. A role of HCN-induced modifications of PK activity in embryonal dormancy is proposed.     

Interaction of karrikinolide and ethylene in controlling germination of dormant <Emphasis Type="Italic">Avena fatua</Emphasis> L. caryopses

Caryopses of Avena fatua L. are dormant after harvest and germinate poorly at 20 °C. Dormancy was released by after-ripening the dry caryopses in the dark at 25 °C for 3 months. Karrikinolide (butenolide, 3-methyl-2H-furo[2,3-c]pyran-2-one, KAR₁), in contrast to exogenous ethylene and the precursor of ethylene biosynthesis 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), completely overcame dormancy. The effect of KAR₁ was not affected by aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG), α-aminoisobutyric acid (AIB) and CoCl₂, inhibitors of ACC synthase and oxidase, respectively. 2,5-Norbornadiene (NBD), a reversible inhibitor of ethylene binding to its receptor, counteracted the stimulatory effect of KAR₁. Ethylene, ethephon and ACC counteracted and AVG reinforced inhibition caused by norbornadiene. Inhibition due to norbornadiene, applied during the first 3 days of imbibition in the presence of KAR₁, disappeared after transfer to air or ethylene. The obtained results confirm that KAR₁ breaks dormancy and indicate that ethylene alone plays no role in releasing dormancy of Avena fatua caryopses. KAR₁ probably did not relieve dormancy via the stimulation of ethylene biosynthesis. Some level of endogenous ethylene is probably required for ethylene action, which might be required for releasing dormancy by KAR₁ or for subsequent germination of caryopses after removing dormancy.     

Seed Dormancy in Acer pseudoplatanus L.: the Role of the Covering Structures

The present studies with Acer pseudoplatanus L. suggest thatthe covering structures play an important and multiple rolein the dormancy of the fruit. Whole fruits and seeds with thetesta intact required a period of chilling at 5 °C beforedormancy was broken whereas bare embryos germinated immediatelyat 20 °C without pretreatment. This suggested that dormancywas coat-imposed and that the testa was responsible for thiseffect. Germination of dormant seeds was inhibited by lightwhereas the non-dormant bare embryos showed little response.Studies on the manner in which the testa imposed dormancy onthe embryo indicated that restriction on oxygen uptake, wateruptake, mechanical restriction to embryo enlargement, and thepresence of germination inhibitors in the testa were not limitingfactors at this stage of dormancy. Results from leaching experimentssuggest that dormancy was the result of the restriction by thetesta of the outward diffusion of a germination inhibitor(s)present in the embryo. In seeds that had nearly completed theirstratification requirements, the covering structures seemedto act in a manner other than by preventing the leaching ofan inhibitor from the embryo. At this point the physical propertiesof the covering structures seem to determine any further delaysin germination by the mechanical restriction of embryo enlargementby the testa and by restriction of oxygen uptake by the pericarp.     

Participation of GA3, ethylene,NO and HCN in germination of Amaranthus retroflexus L. seeds with various dormancy levels

Amaranthus retroflexus seeds were dormant at 25 °C in the darkness and in the light, and also at 35 °C in the darkness. GA₃ and ethylene partially removed dormancy at 35 °C in the darkness and at 25 °C in the light. Dormancy was removed by 1–5 days of treatment with nitric oxide or cyanide. The effect of NO and HCN was inhibited by cPTIO, thus the effect of HCN was NO dependent. Dry storage for 16 weeks could partially release dormancy only at 35 °C, but not at 25 °C. Dry storage increased the response to light, GA₃ and ethylene. The response to GA₃ and ethylene at 25 °C was enhanced with increasing storage temperature. GA₃, ethylene and nitric oxide could substitute dry storage and stratification in partially dormant seeds.     

Polyamines and ethylene in the removal of embryonal dormancy in apple seeds

Putrescine (Put), spermidine (Spd) and spermine (Spm) were found in seeds of apple ( Malus domestica Borkh. cv. Antonovka), in amounts that increased in the order given. The levels slowly decreased during 30 days of stratification. Exogenous polyamines (PAs) affected germination of isolated embryos in a way dependent on the type of polyamine, its concentration, and the state of the embryo dormancy. The effect of Put and Spd on germination was stimulatory, while that of Spm was inhibitory. Stimulation of germination was also observed when embryos were treated with arginine, ornithine and methionine. Canavanine inhibited germination, and this effect was reversed by arginine or Put. Ethephon, aminooxyacetic acid (AOA) and aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) present during seed stratification had no effect on the levels of endogenous PAs. Put and Spd did not change ethylene production, neither during seed stratification nor during embryo germination, whereas Spm reduced ethylene evolution. The data suggest that Spm plays a role in the maintenance of dormancy by preventing ethylene production, while Put and Spd participate in dormancy removal, independently of ethylene.