Co-operative binding interactions in affinity chromatography: Theoretical considerations

A theoretical relationship has been developed to allow the effect of free ligand concentration on the capacity of an affinity Chromatography matrix to be determined where the protein adsorbed shows co-operative binding. Computer simulations using literature values for association constants show that under optimal conditions resin capacity can be increased significantly in the presence of a small but finite concentration of free ligand. The model also allows prediction of the soluble ligand concentration required for biospecific elution. The results obtained suggest the possibility of a new elution technique, "reverse biospecific elution," that reduces the amount of free ligand required to effect elution.     

Surface-labelling studies on skeletal-muscle cells in vitro. Heterogeneity of iodinated cell-surface proteins.

Some theoretical aspects of the desorption of a column-bound protein by elution with its biospecific ligand are considered in cases where, in comparison with the unliganded protein, the protein-ligand complex has a diminished but finite affinity for the adsorbent. A quantity termed the biospecific sensitivity, B, is introduced to facilitate comparison between different systems. Biospecific sensitivity may be defined as the fractional change in standard free energy of adsorption on formation of the protein-ligand complex. The effects of a moderate-to-low biospecific sensitivity on theoretical desorption profiles have been examined by using a computer simulation of the classical multiple-plate column model. Desorption was simulated under various boundary conditions involving protein-adsorbent and protein-ligand affinities and the initial concentrations of adsorption sites, protein and ligand. These simulations suggest that, when the biospecific sensitivity is low, desorption is optimized if (a) the unliganded protein is adsorbed as weakly as possible, (b) the column is loaded to near-saturation with the required protein, (c) the free ligand concentration is many times greater than that giving near-saturation of the protein in free solution, and (d) protein contaminants with high affinity for the adsorbent, and present in large amount, are removed in preliminary purification steps.     

Molecular dynamics simulation of the cooperative adsorption of barley lipid transfer protein and cis-isocohumulone at the vacuum-water interface

Molecular dynamic simulations have been carried out on systems containing a mixture of barley lipid transfer protein (LTP) and cis-isocohumulone (a hop derived iso-alpha-acid) in one of its enol forms, in bulk water and at the vacuum-water interface. In solution, the cis-isocohumulone molecules bind to the surface of the LTP molecule. The mechanism of binding appears to be purely hydrophobic in nature via desolvation of the protein surface. Binding of hop acids to the LTP leads to a small change in the 3-D conformation of the protein, but no change in the proportion of secondary structure present in helices, even though there is a significant degree of hop acid binding to the helical regions. At the vacuum-water interface, cis-isocohumulone shows a high surface activity and adsorbs rapidly at the interface. LTP then shows a preference to bind to the preadsorbed hop acid layer at the interface rather than to the bare water-vacuum interface. The free energy of adsorption of LTP at the hop-vacuum-water interface is more favorable than for adsorption at the vacuum-water interface. Our results support the view that hop iso-alpha-acids promote beer foam stability by forming bridges between separate adsorbed protein molecules, thus strengthening the adsorbed protein layer and reducing foam breakdown by lamellar phase drainage. The results also suggest a second mechanism may also occur, whereby the concentration of protein at the interface is increased via enhanced protein adsorption to adsorbed hop acid layers. This too would increase foam stability through its effect on the stabilizing protein layer around the foam bubbles.     

Thermal and Structural Stability of Adsorbed Proteins

Experimental evidence suggests that proteins adsorbed to hydrophobic surfaces at low coverages are stabilized relative to the bulk. For larger coverages, proteins unfold and form β-sheets. We performed computer simulations on model proteins and found that: 1), For weakly adsorbing surfaces, unfolded conformations lose more entropy upon adsorption than folded ones. 2), The melting temperature, both in the bulk and at surfaces, decreases with increasing protein concentration because of favorable interprotein interactions. 3), Proteins in the bulk show large unfolding free energy barriers; this barrier decreases at stronger adsorbing surfaces. We conjecture that typical experimental temperatures appear to be below the bulk melting temperature for a single protein, but above the melting temperature for concentrated protein solutions. Purely thermodynamic factors then explain protein stabilization on adsorption at low concentrations. However, both thermodynamic and kinetic factors are important at higher concentrations. Thus, proteins in the bulk do not denature with increasing concentration due to large kinetic barriers, even though the aggregated state is thermodynamically preferred. However, they readily unfold upon adsorption, with the surface acting as a heterogeneous catalyst. The thermal behavior of proteins adsorbed to hydrophobic surfaces thus appears to follow behavior independent of their chemical specificity.     

Mobility of adsorbed proteins: a Brownian dynamics study

We simulate the adsorption of lysozyme on a solid surface, using Brownian dynamics simulations. A protein molecule is represented as a uniformly charged sphere and interacts with other molecules through screened Coulombic and double-layer forces. The simulation starts from an empty surface and attempts are made to introduce additional proteins at a fixed time interval that is inversely proportional to the bulk protein concentration. We examine the effect of ionic strength and bulk protein concentration on the adsorption kinetics over a range of surface coverages. The structure of the adsorbed layer is examined through snapshots of the configurations and quantitatively with the radial distribution function. We extract the surface diffusion coefficient from the mean square displacement. At high ionic strengths the Coulombic interaction is effectively shielded, leading to increased surface coverage. This effect is quantified with an effective particle radius. Clustering of the adsorbed molecules is promoted by high ionic strength and low bulk concentrations. We find that lateral protein mobility decreases with increasing surface coverage. The observed trends are consistent with previous theoretical and experimental studies.     

Labelling of colloidal gold with protein A. A quantitative study

Colloidal gold complexes with protein A are extensively used in immunocytochemistry as secondary reagents for the localization of antigens. However detailed information on the process and extent of adsorption of protein A onto gold particles, the optimal condition of preparation and the stability of such complexes are lacking. The adsorption isotherm of 125I-protein A onto gold particles (11.2 nm in diameter) was studied quantitatively with gold sols buffered at pH 4-7. At low coverage of the particles, the isotherm was independent of pH. However in the presence of a large excess of protein A, the highest coverage was obtained with a gold sol buffered at pH 5.1, the isoelectric point of the protein. The association constant was decreased at high coverage of the particles. Maximum binding of the complex to immobilized IgG occurred with particles labelled with at least 9 molecules of protein A. The complex was stable under storage with up to 12 molecules adsorbed per particle. At high coverage (26 molecules per particle), a progressive loss of protein A was observed. The optimum condition for preparing the complex are reported.     

Adsorption of RNase A on cationic polyelectrolyte brushes: a study by isothermal titration calorimetry

We present a study of the adsorption of a positively charged protein to a positively charged spherical polyelectrolyte brush (SPB) by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). ITC is used to determine the adsorption isotherm as a function of temperature and of salt concentration (at physiological pH 7.2). At low ionic strength, RNase A is strongly adsorbed by the SPB particles despite the fact that both the SPB particles and the protein are positively charged. Virtually no adsorption takes place when the ionic strength is raised through added salt. This is strong evidence for counterion release as the primary driving force for protein adsorption. We calculated that ~2 counterions were released upon RNase A binding. The adsorption of RNase A into like-charged SPB particles is entropy-driven, and protein protonation was not significant. Temperature-dependent measurements showed a disagreement between the enthalpy derived via the van't Hoff equation and the calorimetric enthalpy. Further analysis shows that van't Hoff analysis leads to the correct enthalpy of adsorption. The additional contributions to the measured enthalpy are potentially sourced from unlinked equilibria such as conformational changes that do not contribute to the binding equilibrium.     

Lipid demixing and protein-protein interactions in the adsorption of charged proteins on mixed membranes

The adsorption free energy of charged proteins on mixed membranes, containing varying amounts of (oppositely) charged lipids, is calculated based on a mean-field free energy expression that accounts explicitly for the ability of the lipids to demix locally, and for lateral interactions between the adsorbed proteins. Minimization of this free energy functional yields the familiar nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann equation and the boundary condition at the membrane surface that allows for lipid charge rearrangement. These two self-consistent equations are solved simultaneously. The proteins are modeled as uniformly charged spheres and the (bare) membrane as an ideal two-dimensional binary mixture of charged and neutral lipids. Substantial variations in the lipid charge density profiles are found when highly charged proteins adsorb on weakly charged membranes; the lipids, at a certain demixing entropy penalty, adjust their concentration in the vicinity of the adsorbed protein to achieve optimal charge matching. Lateral repulsive interactions between the adsorbed proteins affect the lipid modulation profile and, at high densities, result in substantial lowering of the binding energy. Adsorption isotherms demonstrating the importance of lipid mobility and protein-protein interactions are calculated using an adsorption equation with a coverage-dependent binding constant. Typically, at bulk-surface equilibrium (i.e., when the membrane surface is "saturated" by adsorbed proteins), the membrane charges are "overcompensated" by the protein charges, because only about half of the protein charges (those on the hemispheres facing the membrane) are involved in charge neutralization. Finally, it is argued that the formation of lipid-protein domains may be enhanced by electrostatic adsorption of proteins, but its origin (e.g., elastic deformations associated with lipid demixing) is not purely electrostatic.     

Expanded bed adsorption of human serum albumin from very dense Saccharomyces cerevesiae suspensions on fluoride-modified zirconia.

The adsorption of proteins from high cell density yeast suspensions on mixed-mode fluoride-modified zirconia (FmZr) particles (38 to 75 microm, surface area of 29 m(2)/g and density of 2.8 g/cm(3)) was investigated using human serum albumin (HSA) added to Saccharomyces cerevesiae as the model expression host. Because of the high density of the porous zirconia particles, HSA (4 mg/mL) can be adsorbed from a 100 g dry cell weight (DCW)/L yeast suspension in a threefold-expanded bed of FmZr. The expanded bed adsorption of any protein from a suspension containing >50 g DCW/L cells has not been previously reported. The FmZr bed expansion characteristics were well represented by the Richardson-Zaki correlation with a particle terminal velocity of 3.1 mm/s and a bed expansion index of 5.4. Expanded bed hydrodynamics were investigated as a function of bed expansion using residence time distribution studies with sodium nitrite as the tracer. The adsorption of HSA on FmZr exhibited features of multicomponent adsorption due to the presence of dimers. The protein binding capacity at 5% breakthrough decreased from 22 mg HSA/mL settled bed void volume for 20 g DCW/L yeast to 15 mg HSA/mL settled bed void volume for 40 g DCW/L yeast and remained unchanged for the higher yeast concentrations (60 to 100 g DCW/L). However, the batch (or equilibrium) binding capacity decreased monotonically as a function of yeast concentration (20 to 100 g DCW/L) and the binding capacity at 100 g DCW/L yeast was fivefold lower compared with that at 20 g DCW/L yeast. The lower batch binding capacity at high cell concentrations resulted from the adsorption of cells at the surface of the particles restricting access of HSA to the intraparticle surface area. Batch (or equilibrium) and column HSA adsorption results indicated that the adsorption of HSA on FmZr occurred at a time scale that may be much faster than that of yeast cells. The zirconia particles were cleaned of adsorbed HSA and yeast with a total of 1500 to 2000 column volumes (over many cycles) of 0. 25 M NaOH, without any significant effect on the chromatographic performance.     

Interaction between photoexcited rhodopsin and peripheral enzymes in frog retinal rods. Influence on the postmetarhodopsin II decay and phosphorylation rate of rhodopsin

The major peripheral and soluble proteins in frog rod outer segment preparations, and their interactions with photoexcited rhodopsin, have been compared to those in cattle rod outer segments and found to be similar in both systems. In particular the GTP-binding protein (G) has the same subunit composition, the same abundance relative to rhodopsin (1/10) and it undergoes the same light and nucleotide-dependent interactions with rhodopsin in both preparations. Previous work on cattle rod outer segments has shown that photoexcited rhodopsin (R*), in a state identified with metarhodopsin II, associates with the G protein as a first step to the light-activated GDP/GTP exchange on G. The complex R*-G is stable in absence of GTP, but is rapidly dissociated by GTP owing to the GDP/GTP exchange reaction. Low bleaching extents (less than 10% R*) in absence of GTP therefore create predominantly R*-G complexes, whereas bleaching in presence of GTP creates free R*. We report here that, under conditions of complexed R*, two reactions of R* in frog rod outer segments are highly perturbed as compared to free R*: (a) the spectral decay of metarhodopsin II (MII) into later photoproducts, and (b) the phosphorylation of R* by an ATP-dependent protein kinase. a) The spectral measurements have been performed using linear dichroism on oriented frog rod outer segments; this technique allows discrimination between MII and later photoproducts absorbing at the same wavelength. Association of R* with G leads to a strong reduction of the amount of MIII formed and to an acceleration of the decay of MIII. Furthermore, MII is significantly stabilized, in agreement with the hypothesis that MII is the intermediate which binds to G. b) The phosphorylation of R* is strongly inhibited under conditions of R*-G complex formation as compared to free R*. Interferences between reactions at the three sites involved in R* are discussed: the retinal binding site in the hydrophobic core is sensitive to the presence of GTP-binding protein at its binding site on the cytoplasmic surface of R*; the kinase and the GTP-binding protein compete for access to their respective binding sites, both located on the surface of R*. We also observed a slow and nucleotide-dependent light-induced binding of a protein of molecular weight 50 000, which we consider as the equivalent of the 48 000 Mr light-dependent protein previously identified in cattle rod outer segments.     

Kinetics and thermodynamics of protein adsorption: a generalized molecular theoretical approach

The thermodynamics and kinetics of protein adsorption are studied using a molecular theoretical approach. The cases studied include competitive adsorption from mixtures and the effect of conformational changes upon adsorption. The kinetic theory is based on a generalized diffusion equation in which the driving force for motion is the gradient of chemical potentials of the proteins. The time-dependent chemical potentials, as well as the equilibrium behavior of the system, are obtained using a molecular mean-field theory. The theory provides, within the same theoretical formulation, the diffusion and the kinetic (activated) controlled regimes. By separation of ideal and nonideal contributions to the chemical potential, the equation of motion shows a purely diffusive part and the motion of the particles in the potential of mean force resulting from the intermolecular interactions. The theory enables the calculation of the time-dependent surface coverage of proteins, the dynamic surface tension, and the structure of the adsorbed layer in contact with the approaching proteins. For the case of competitive adsorption from a solution containing a mixture of large and small proteins, a variety of different adsorption patterns are observed depending upon the bulk composition, the strength of the interaction between the particles, and the surface and size of the proteins. It is found that the experimentally observed Vroman sequence is predicted in the case that the bulk solution is at a composition with an excess of the small protein, and that the interaction between the large protein and the surface is much larger than that of the smaller protein. The effect of surface conformational changes of the adsorbed proteins in the time-dependent adsorption is studied in detail. The theory predicts regimes of constant density and dynamic surface tension that are long lived but are only intermediates before the final approach to equilibrium. The implications of the findings to the interpretation of experimental observations is discussed.     

Electrophoresis of adsorbed DNA

The electrophoresis mobilities of native calf thymus DNA adsorbed on the charged solid particles were measured by a micro-electrophoretic method as functions of pII, ionic strength, and DNA concentration. The mobility data confirm the adsorption of DNA both on the positively charged alumina and negatively charged resin particles at wide range of pH and ionic strength. The mobility data also indicate significant DNA adsorption by negatively charged glass in the acidic range of pH. The electrophoretic mobilities of DNA adsorbed on different substrate particles under identical conditions do not differ widely, indicating the major role of the adsorbed DNA rather than the covered substrate in controlling the charge behavior of the particle. The mobilities of the adsorbed DNA at salt pH are of a comparable order of magnitude to those for the dissolved DNA in solution. The mobility of the adsorbed heat-denatured and alkali-denatured DNA is lower than that of the native adsorbed DNA under identical conditions of pH and ionic strength.     

alpha-Amylase adsorption on starch crystallites

The goal of this work was to characterize the adsorption of Bacillus subtills alpha-amylase onto crystalline starchy materials of the B-type polymorph. Monodisperse spherulitic particles (R z6; 5.0 mum), essentially resistant to alpha-amylolysis at 25 degrees C were prepared from short amylose chains (DP(n) approximately 15). The alpha-amylase adsorbed specifically onto the spherulites, and adsorption was found to be a prerequisite step for hydrolysis. Adsorption was inhibited by the presence of maltose and maltotriose in the reaction mixture. Adsorption isotherm of the enzyme on the particles showed a well developed plateau of 1.62 mug/cm(2) at 25 degrees C corresponding to a monolayer adsorption process. The binding free energy calculated from the initial slope of the isotherm was DeltaG approximately -20.7 kJ/mol. This is smaller than published values for the binding of alpha-amylase to soluble amylosic chains (DeltaG < -30 kJ/mol).     

Origin of calcium-induced minimum in bulk compressional modulus of lipid membranes. Configurational entropy of adsorbed Ca2+

Addition of Ca2+ to a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine lamellar system decreases the bulk compressional modulus (increases compressibility) of the membrane (S. Aruga, R. Kataoka and S. Mitaku, Biophys. Chem. 21 (1985) 265). The bulk modulus was reported to show a minimum value at 10 mM Ca2+ within the temperature range 20-45 degrees C. In the present report, the occurrence of this minimum in the bulk modulus is explained quantitatively as a result of fluctuation in the number of Ca2+ adsorbed onto the lipid bilayer surface. From this theory, the change in apparent molal volume of Ca2+ upon surface adsorption is estimated to be 5.7 cm3 mol-1, which appears to be a reasonable value. The number of adsorbed Ca2+ at the concentration where the bulk modulus assumes the minimum value is half of the number of allowable adsorption sites on lipid membranes. The configurational entropy of the adsorbed Ca2+ attains a maximum at the minimum point.     

Circular dichroism studies on conformational changes in protein molecules upon adsorption on ultrafine polystyrene particles

The conformational changes in well-characterized model proteins [bovine ribonuclease A (RNase A), horseradish peroxidase, sperm-whole myoglobin, human hemoglobin, and bovine serum albumin (BSA)] upon adsorption on ultrafine polystyrene (PS) particles have been studied using circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. These proteins were chosen with special attention to molecular flexibility. The ultrafine PS particles were negatively charged and have average diameters of 20 or 30 nm. Utilization of these ultrafine PS particles makes it possible to apply the CD technique to determine the secondary structure of proteins adsorbed on the PS surface. Effects of protein properties and adsorption conditions on the extent of the changes in the secondary structure of protein molecules upon adsorption on ultrafine PS particles were studied. The CD spectrum changes upon adsorption were significant in the "soft" protein molecules (myoglobin, hemoglobin, and BSA), while they were insingnificant in the "rigid" proteins (RNase A and peroxidase). The soft proteins sustained a marked decrease in alpha-helix content upon adsorption. Moreover, the native alpha-helix content, which is given as the percentage of the alpha-helix content in the free proteins, of adsorbed BSA was found to decrease with decreasing pH and increase with increasing adsorbed amount. These observations confirm some well-known hypotheses for the confirmational chages in protein molecules upon adsorption. (c) 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Discontinuous formation and desorption of clusters during particles adsorption at surfaces

A theoretical model was derived to describe the discontinuous formation and desorption of clusters during particle adsorption at surfaces. Two steps were investigated: (1) time-dependent adsorption, where we found that the initial slope and the limiting magnitude of an adsorption isotherm depend on the clusters' distribution. A higher magnitude of both the adsorption and desorption rates appear to contract the time scale and hence increase the initial slope. Decreasing the geometrical parameter, q, which represents the shape of an adsorbed cluster, enhances the growth of large clusters on the surface. (2) A concentration dependence model shows that the number of adsorbed molecules increases with increases in the value of n (nucleation capacity). Furthermore, higher rates of adsorption provide steeper initial slopes (higher affinity of, molecules to surface). Decreasing q from 2 to 1, i.e. from a circular to a linear cluster formation, slightly decreases the magnitude of the isotherms.     

A study of selective adsorption of Na+ and other alkali-metal ions on isolated proteins: a test of the salt-linkage hypothesis

According to the salt-linkage hypothesis (a part of the association-induction hypothesis), the binding of alkali-metal ions on isolated proteins may be low as a result of the masking of cation-binding fixed anionic groups by the formation of "salt linkages" between them and fixed cationic groups. This hypothesis has been verified in a quantitative manner by the measurement of free and adsorbed Na+ in solutions of bovine hemoglobin titrated with increasing concentration of NaOH. In addition this communication presents data indicating (1) wide variability in the extent of Na+ adsorption among different isolated proteins and even among different samples of the same protein, (2) auto-cooperativity in the pH titration and Na+ adsorption, and (3) selectivity of the liberated fixed anionic groups for different alkali-metal ions in the rank order Na greater than Li greater than K greater than Rb, Cs.     

Immunolabeling efficiency of protein A-gold complexes

A systematic study of the adsorption of protein A on colloidal gold particles varying in size from 5-16 nm was performed at different protein concentrations. The number of protein A molecules bound per colloidal particle was evaluated and the Scatchard analysis of the adsorption parameters was applied for each size of the colloid. The binding of protein A to the colloidal gold surface exhibited the same affinity pattern for all of the particle sizes. At low concentrations of stabilizing protein, adsorption took place with high affinity (Kd 1.96-3.3 nM) and the maximum number of protein A molecules attached with this affinity correlated well with the surface of the particle. At higher concentrations of protein A, adsorption exhibited a significantly lower affinity (Kd 530-800 nM), and no saturation was recorded. Competition by albumin did not reveal a preferential removal of the "low-affinity" bound protein A molecules, contradicting the model of successive shells of stabilizing protein around the colloidal particle. The immunolabeling efficiency of conjugates having the same size of gold nucleus but carrying different numbers of protein A molecules was comparatively investigated by quantitative post-embedding immunocytochemistry. Protein A-gold formed with 5-10-nm colloids gave the highest intensity of labeling when carrying the maximum number of protein A molecules that could be adsorbed with high affinity. Overloading as well as underloading these complexes resulted in a significant decrease of their immunoreactivity. The most efficient conjugates were obtained when stabilization was performed with 6 micrograms protein A/ml gold sol of 5 and 10 nm particle diameter, and 15 micrograms protein/ml of 15-nm colloid.     

Versatility of mixed-function adsorbents in biospecific protein desorption: Accidental affinity and an improved purification of aspartate transcarbamoylase from wheat germ

Under appropriate experimental conditions (usually but not invariably including low ionic strength) wheat germ aspartate transcarbamoylase can be specifically desorbed by the substrate, carbamoyl phosphate, from hydroxyapatite, from N-(3-carboxypropionyl)aminooctyl-Sepharose, from 10-carboxydecylamino-Sepharose, from Cibacron Blue F3GA-Sepharose, and from Coomassie Blue R250-Sepharose. Experimental evidence suggests that (a) the enzyme is adsorbed at heterogeneous sites on each column, only some of which are susceptible to substrate-specific desorption; (b) in none of these cases is the initial adsorption essentially biospecific, i.e., these are not cases of classical affinity chromatography; (c) in the case of 10-carboxydecylamino-Sepharose, and therefore presumably also in the other cases, the desorption is biospecific, i.e., involves the formation of the catalytically significant enzyme-carbamoyl phosphate complex. Substrate-specific desorption in these cases appears to derive from “accidental” affinity between, on the one hand, clusters of active (ionic, hydrophobic, aromatic, etc.) groups on the protein and, on the other, complementary clusters on the adsorbent, some of these interactions being perturbed when the ligands binds to the protein. Biospecific desorption from 10-carboxydecylamino-Sepharose has been incorporated as the sole chromatographic step in a new, 8000-fold purification of the enzyme. It is suggested that biospecific desorption from essentially nonbiospecific adsorbents could explain some published purifications currently described as “affinity chromatography.”     

Examination of protein adsorption in fluidized bed and packed bed columns at different temperatures using frontal chromatographic methods

The influences of various experimental parameters on the dynamic adsorption capacity (DAC) and the dynamic adsorption rate (DAR) of a biomimetic affinity silica-based adsorbent in fluidized and packed bed columns operated under plug flow conditions and at different temperatures have been investigated with different inlet concentrations of hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL) and human serum albumin (HSA). The DACs as well as the DARs of both the fluidized and packed beds were examined at 10% saturation (i.e., at the QB value) and the experimental data compared with the corresponding data obtained from batch equilibrium adsorption procedures. Parameters examined included the fluid superficial velocity and protein concentration and their effect on the binding capacity and column efficiency. Consistent with various results reported from this and other laboratories on the behavior of biospecific affinity adsorbents derived from porous silica and zirconia particles, adsorbents prepared from Fractosil 1000 were found to exhibit appropriate rheological characteristics in fluidized bed systems under the experimental conditions. Moreover, changes in temperature resulted in a more significant effect on the breakthrough profiles of HSA compared to HEWL with the immobilized Cibacron Blue F3G-A with Fractosil 1000 adsorbent. This result suggests that temperature effects can possibly be employed profitably in some processes as part of a strategy to enhance column performance with fluidized bed systems for selective recovery of target proteins. At relatively low superficial velocities of the feed, the DARs with HEWL and HSA were similar for both the fluidized and packed bed column systems, whereas, at high superficial velocities, the DARs for these proteins were larger with the packed bed columns.