Stability of the Human Fragile X (CGG)n Triplet Repeat Array in Saccharomyces cerevisiae Deficient in Aspects of DNA Metabolism

Expanded trinucleotide repeats underlie a growing number of human diseases. The human FMR1 (CGG)(n) array can exhibit genetic instability characterized by progressive expansion over several generations leading to gene silencing and the development of the fragile X syndrome. While expansion is dependent upon the length of uninterrupted (CGG)(n), instability occurs in a limited germ line and early developmental window, suggesting that lineage-specific expression of other factors determines the cellular environment permissive for expansion. To identify these factors, we have established normal- and premutation-length human FMR1 (CGG)(n) arrays in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and assessed the frequency of length changes greater than 5 triplets in cells deficient in various DNA repair and replication functions. In contrast to previous studies with Escherichia coli, we observed a low frequency of orientation-dependent large expansions in arrays carrying long uninterrupted (CGG)(n) arrays in a wild-type background. This frequency was unaffected by deletion of several DNA mismatch repair genes or deletion of the EXO1 and DIN7 genes and was not enhanced through meiosis in a wild-type background. Array contraction occurred in an orientation-dependent manner in most mutant backgrounds, but loss of the Sgs1p resulted in a generalized increase in array stability in both orientations. In contrast, FMR1 arrays had a 10-fold-elevated frequency of expansion in a rad27 background, providing evidence for a role in lagging-strand Okazaki fragment processing in (CGG)(n) triplet repeat expansion.     

Cloned human FMR1 trinucleotide repeats exhibit a length- and orientation-dependent instability suggestive of in vivo lagging strand secondary structure.

The normal human FMR1 gene contains a genetically stable (CGG) n trinucleotide repeat which usually carries interspersed AGG triplets. An increase in repeat number and the loss of interspersions results in array instability, predominantly expansion, leading to FMR1 gene silencing. Instability is directly related to the length of the uninterrupted (CGG) n repeat and is widely assumed to be related to an increased propensity to form G-rich secondary structures which lead to expansion through replication slippage. In order to investigate this we have cloned human FMR1 arrays with internal structures representing the normal, intermediate and unstable states. In one replicative orientation, arrays show a length-dependent instability, deletions occurring in a polar manner. With longer arrays these extend into the FMR1 5'-flanking DNA, terminating at either of two short CGG triplet arrays. The orientation-dependent instability suggests that secondary structure forms in the G-rich lagging strand template, resolution of which results in intra-array deletion. These data provide direct in vivo evidence for a G-rich lagging strand secondary structure which is believed to be involved in the process of triplet expansion in humans.     

Genetic instabilities of triplet repeat sequences by recombination

The expansion of triplet repeat sequences is an initial step in the disease etiology of a number of hereditary neurological disorders in humans. Diseases such as myotonic dystrophy, Huntington's, several spinocerebellar ataxias, fragile X syndrome, and Friedreich's ataxia are caused by the expansions of CTG.CAG, CGG.CCG, or GAA.TTC repeats. The mechanisms of the expansion process have been investigated intensely in E. coli, yeast, transgenic mice, mammalian cell culture, and in human clinical cases. Whereas studies from 1994-1999 have implicated DNA replication and repair at the paused synthesis sites due to the unusual conformations of the triplet repeat sequences, recent work has shown that homologous recombination (gene conversion) is a powerful mechanism for generating massive expansions, in addition to, or in concert with, replication and repair.     

Secondary structure and dynamics of the r(CGG) repeat in the mRNA of the fragile X mental retardation 1 (FMR1) gene.

The CGG triplet repeat found within the 5'UTR of the FMR1 gene is involved in the pathogenesis of both fragile X syndrome and fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome (FXTAS). The repeat has been shown to form both hairpins and tetraplexes in DNA; however, the secondary structure of CGG-repeat RNA has not been well defined. To this end, we have performed NMR spectroscopy on in vitro transcribed CGG-repeat RNAs and see clear evidence of intramolecular hairpins, with no evidence of tetraplex structures. Both C*G and G*G base pairs form in the hairpin stem, though in a dynamic equilibrium of conformations. In addition, we investigated the effect of an AGG repeat interruption on hairpin stability; such interruptions are often interspersed within the CGG repeat element and are thought to modulate secondary structure of the RNA. While the AGG repeat lowers the Tm of the hairpin at low Mg2+ concentrations, this difference disappears at physiological Mg2+ levels.     

An origin of DNA replication in the promoter region of the human fragile X mental retardation (FMR1) gene

Fragile X syndrome, the most common form of inherited mental retardation in males, arises when the normally stable 5 to 50 CGG repeats in the 5' untranslated region of the fragile X mental retardation protein 1 (FMR1) gene expand to over 200, leading to DNA methylation and silencing of the FMR1 promoter. Although the events that trigger local CGG expansion remain unknown, the stability of trinucleotide repeat tracts is affected by their position relative to an origin of DNA replication in model systems. Origins of DNA replication in the FMR1 locus have not yet been described. Here, we report an origin of replication adjacent to the FMR1 promoter and CGG repeats that was identified by scanning a 35-kb region. Prereplication proteins Orc3p and Mcm4p bind to chromatin in the FMR1 initiation region in vivo. The position of the FMR1 origin relative to the CGG repeats is consistent with a role in repeat maintenance. The FMR1 origin is active in transformed cell lines, fibroblasts from healthy individuals, fibroblasts from patients with fragile X syndrome, and fetal cells as early as 8 weeks old. The potential role of the FMR1 origin in CGG tract instability is discussed.     

Interactions between the Werner syndrome helicase and DNA polymerase delta specifically facilitate copying of tetraplex and hairpin structures of the d(CGG)n trinucleotide repeat sequence

Werner syndrome (WS) is an inherited disorder characterized by premature aging and genomic instability. The protein encoded by the WS gene, WRN, possesses intrinsic 3' --> 5' DNA helicase and 3' --> 5' DNA exonuclease activities. WRN helicase resolves alternate DNA structures including tetraplex and triplex DNA, and Holliday junctions. Thus, one function of WRN may be to unwind secondary structures that impede cellular DNA transactions. We report here that hairpin and G'2 bimolecular tetraplex structures of the fragile X expanded sequence, d(CGG)(n), effectively impede synthesis by three eukaryotic replicative DNA polymerases (pol): pol alpha, pol delta, and pol epsilon. The constraints imposed on pol delta-catalyzed synthesis are relieved, however, by WRN; WRN facilitates pol delta to traverse these template secondary structures to synthesize full-length DNA products. The alleviatory effect of WRN is limited to pol delta; neither pol alpha nor pol epsilon can traverse template d(CGG)(n) hairpin and tetraplex structures in the presence of WRN. Alleviation of pausing by pol delta is observed with Escherichia coli RecQ but not with UvrD helicase, suggesting a concerted action of RecQ helicases and pol delta. Our findings suggest a possible role of WRN in rescuing pol delta-mediated replication at forks stalled by unusual DNA secondary structures.     

Triplet repeat DNA structures and human genetic disease: dynamic mutations from dynamic DNA

Fourteen genetic neurodegenerative diseases and three fragile sites have been associated with the expansion of (CTG)_n•(CAG)_n, (CGG)_n•(CCG)_n, or (GAA)_n•(TTC)_n repeat tracts. Different models have been proposed for the expansion of triplet repeats, most of which presume the formation of alternative DNA structures in repeat tracts. One of the most likely structures, slipped strand DNA, may stably and reproducibly form within triplet repeat sequences. The propensity to form slipped strand DNA is proportional to the length and homogeneity of the repeat tract. The remarkable stability of slipped strand DNA may, in part, be due to loop-loop interactions facilitated by the sequence complementarity of the loops and the dynamic structure of three-way junctions formed at the loop-outs.     

Evidence that methylation of the FMR-I locus is responsible for variable phenotypic expression of the fragile X syndrome.

DNA at the FMR-1 locus was analyzed by Southern blot using probe StB12.3 in an unusual fragile X family with six brothers, three of whom are affected with fragile X to varying degrees, two of whom are nonpenetrant carriers, and one of whom is unaffected. Fragile X chromosome studies, detailed physical examinations, and psychological testing were completed on all six. Two of the affected brothers and the two nonpenetrant brothers were found to be methylation mosaics. The three affected males spanned the phenotypic and cognitive spectrum of the fragile X syndrome. A correlation was seen between the degree of methylation and the phenotypic expression identified in the three affected males. The two males initially classified as nonpenetrant were found to have mild phenotypic expression which consisted of minor cognitive deficits and a partial physical phenotype. These two, who were negative on fragile X chromosome studies, were found on DNA analysis to have large broad smears, with approximately 97% of the DNA unmethylated. The results described here indicate that some "nonpenetrant" carrier males may have varying amounts of methylation of the FMR-1 region, which can result in mild expression of the fragile X syndrome. The apparently mild phenotypic and cognitive expression of the fragile X syndrome in the two males, initially classified as nonpenetrant, who are mosaic for hypermethylation of an expansion of the CGG repeat in the premutation range, indicates that expression of the syndrome is not confined to males with large, hypermethylated expansions (full mutation) but has instead a gradient effect with a threshold for the full expression of the phenotype.     

A female compound heterozygote (pre- and full mutation) for the CGG FMR1 expansion

Fragile X syndrome is the most common cause of inherited mental retardation. The incidence has been estimated to be 1 in 1250 males and 1 in 2000 females. Molecular studies have shown that 95% of fragile X syndrome cases are caused by the expansion of a CGG triplet in the FMR1 gene with hypermethylation of the adjacent CpG island. In spite of the high incidence of this syndrome, a female with both FMR1 genes in the expanded form has never been reported. We present here a female from the Canary Islands presenting mental retardation and attention problems. Molecular analysis has revealed that both of her FMR1 genes have the CGG expansion, one with a premutation and the other with a full mutation. We have studied the CGG repeat in the FMR1 gene in 64 members of her family and detected 33 normal individuals, 14 carriers with the premutation (1 male and 13 females), and 18 individuals with full mutations (8 males and 10 females). The index case illustrates that the possibility of both parents being carriers of the fragile X syndrome premutation should be considered in consanguineous families or in small communities. Received: 4 April 1996 / Revised: 3 May 1996     

DNA structure, mutations, and human genetic disease.

The etiology of fragile X syndrome, myotonic dystrophy and Kennedy's disease has been attributed to the massive expansion of triplet repeat DNA sequences. This review details the relationships between the structural diversity of DNA, its secondary structure or DNA-directed mutagenesis, and the expansion of triplet repeats.     

Molecular analysis of a ring chromosome X in a family with fragile X syndrome

The phenotypically normal sister of a patient affected by fragile X syndrome was referred for genetic counselling and was found to carry a mosaic karyotype 46,X,r(X)/45,X. Because the probability of the simultaneous chance occurrence of fragile X syndrome and a ring chromosome X in the same family is very low, we postulated that the breakpoint of the ring chromosome X originated in the cytogenetic break in Xq27.3 responsible for fragile X syndrome. In order to determine the relative positions of the breakpoint on the ring chromosome X and the (CGG)n unstable sequence responsible for the fragile X mutation, we used molecular markers to analyse the telomeric regions of chromosome X in this family. The results showed that the ring chromosome X was the maternal fragile X chromosome and that the telomeric deletion on the long arm encompassed the (CGG)n sequence. This suggests that the cytogenetic break in Xq27.3 is distinct from the unstable (CGG)n sequence, or that the break followed by the end-to-end fusion creating the ring chromosome was not completely conservative. Analysis of DNA markers on the short arm of chromosome X evidenced a deletion of a large part of the pseudoautosomal region, allowing us to position the genes involved in stature and in some syndromes associated with telomeric deletions of Xp on the proximal side of the pseudoautosomal region.     

Mutation spectra in fragile X syndrome induced by deletions of CGG*CCG repeats

The fragile X syndrome results from expansions as well as deletions of the repeating CGG.CCG DNA sequence in the 5'-untranslated region of the FMR1 gene on the X chromosome. The relative frequency of disease cases promoted by these two types of mutations cannot be ascertained at present because the routine clinical assay monitors only expansions. At least 30 articles have been reviewed that document the involvement of deletions of part or all of the CGG.CCG repeats along with varying extents of DNA flanking regions as well as very small mutations including single base pair changes. Studies of deletion mutants of CGG.CCG tracts in Escherichia coli plasmids revealed a similar spectrum of mutagenic products. The triplet repeat tract in a non-B conformation is the mutagen, not the sequence per se in the right-handed B helix. Hence, molecular investigations in a simple model organism may generate useful initial information toward therapeutic strategies for this disease.     

Stability of triplet repeats of myotonic dystrophy and fragile X loci in human mutator mismatch repair cell lines

At least nine human genetic diseases, including myotonic dystrophy (DM) and fragile X syndrome have been associated with the expansion of CTG or CGG trinucleotide repeats within the disease loci. Little is known about the molecular mechanisms or the genetic control of the expansion of triplet repeats. Mutations in human mismatch repair genes are associated with the increased polymorphism of many microsatellites, including dinucleotide repeats. The effect of mutations in two mismatch repair genes on the size of trinucleotide repeats in the DM and FRAXA loci has been analyzed. PCR and Southern analysis of the triplet repeat regions of the DM and fragile X mental retardation (FRAXA) loci in cell lines HTC116 and LoVo, which contain mutations in both alleles of the hMLH1 and hMSH2 genes, respectively, indicated that the size of the endogenous (CTG)_n and (CGG)_n tracts fall within the range observed in the normal population. This suggests that mutations in hMLH1 or hMSH2 do not result in the instability of CTG or CGG tracts to the levels observed in individuals with myotonic dystrophy or fragile X syndrome. Received: 4 December 1995 / Revised: 29 January 1996, 7 March 1996     

Data on the CGG repeat at the fragile X site in the non-retarded Japanese population and family suggest the presence of a subgroup of normal alleles predisposing to mutate

The fragile X mutation is the result of amplification in the repeat number of p(CGG) _n in FMR-1; alleles with more than 52 repeats have been shown to be so unstable as to mutate in the repeat number in almost every transmission. To improve our understanding of mutations in normal alleles of FMR-1, the following studies were carried out in the Japanese population: a study on length variation in the repeat to determine the allele distribution of the repeat length in a non-retarded population, family studies to observe new mutations in normal allele, and haplotype analyses with microsatellite markers flanking the repeat to confirm estimated mutation rates and founder chromosomes in the fragile X syndrome. Analysis of the p(CGG) _n in 370 unrelated males detected 24 distinct alleles with repeats of 18–44. A comparison with previously reported data suggests the presence of racial/ethnic differences in the allele distribution. No premutation allele was found in 824 unrelated X chromosomes examined by the polymerase chain reaction and Southern blot analysis. Family studies detected one new mutation in a total of 303 meioses. However, the mutation rate was not in accordance with the expected or observed heterozygosities in the population or with linkage disequilibrium observed between the repeat numbers and the haplotypes of the markers flanking the CGG. The haplotype in the chromosome in which the new mutation was found was the same as that frequently found in the Japanese fragile X chromosomes, and the variance in the CGG repeat number was wider in chromosomes with the haplotypes frequently found in the fragile X chromosome than in those with the other haplotypes. These observations suggest that a subgroup is present in normal alleles and that this subgroup is more liable to mutate than others.     

The effect of template secondary structure on vaccinia DNA polymerase.

Vaccinia virus DNA polymerase will utilize a substrate consisting of phi X174 DNA primed with a strand of a unique restriction fragment, but the reaction is inefficient. Examination of the reaction products by alkaline agarose gel electrophoresis revealed a few discrete fragments, each corresponding to an extended primer strand. This result implies that specific barriers exist on the phi X174 template which impede, but do not completely halt, the progress of the enzyme. Only a few per cent of the template molecules were completely copied. Similar findings were reported by Sherman and Gefter using Escherichia coli DNA polymerase II and fd DNA (J. Mol. Biol. (1976) 103, 61-76). Several observations suggest that the barriers are regions of template secondary structure. Some barriers are more effective than others, and they increase in both effectiveness and number as the temperature is decreased. The same barriers are observed with T4 DNA polymerase, but none are detected with E. coli DNA polymerase I. Finally, the major barriers are located in regions of the phi X174 sequence known to contain hairpin structures of relatively high stability. The exact stopping point of one of the major barriers is within the duplex stem of a hairpin structure. These results show that DNA polymerases are a useful probe of the secondary structure of a single-stranded DNA.     

Role of replication and CpG methylation in fragile X syndrome CGG deletions in primate cells

Instability of the fragile X CGG repeat involves both maternally derived expansions and deletions in the gametes of full-mutation males. It has also been suggested that the absence of aberrant CpG methylation may enhance repeat deletions through an unknown process. The effect of CGG tract length, DNA replication direction, location of replication initiation, and CpG methylation upon CGG stability were investigated using an SV40 primate replication system. Replication-dependant deletions with 53 CGG repeats were observed when replication was initiated proximal to the repeat, with CGG as the lagging-strand template. When we initiated replication further from the repeat, while maintaining CGG as the lagging-strand template or using CCG as the lagging-strand template, significant instability was not observed. CpG methylation of the unstable template stabilized the repeat, decreasing both the frequency and the magnitude of deletion events. Furthermore, CpG methylation slowed the efficiency of replication for all templates. Interestingly, replication forks displayed no evidence of a block at the CGG repeat tract, regardless of replication direction or CpG methylation status. Templates with 20 CGG repeats were stable under all circumstances. These results reveal that CGG deletions occur during replication and are sensitive to replication-fork dynamics, tract length, and CpG methylation.     

The fragile X syndrome repeats form RNA hairpins that do not activate the interferon-inducible protein kinase, PKR, but are cut by Dicer

We show here that under physiologically reasonable conditions, CGG repeats in RNA readily form hairpins. In contrast to its DNA counterpart that forms a complex mixture of hairpins and tetraplexes, r(CGG)₂₂ forms a single stable hairpin with no evidence for any other folded structure even at low pH. RNA with the sequence (CGG)₉AGG (CGG)₁₂AGG(CGG)₉₇, found in a fragile X syndrome pre-mutation allele, forms a number of different hairpins. The most prominent hairpin forms in the 3′ part of the repeat and involves the 97 uninterrupted CGG repeats. In contrast to the CUG-RNA hairpins formed by myotonic dystrophy type 1 repeats, we found no evidence that CGG-RNA hairpins activate PKR, the interferon-inducible protein kinase that is activated by a wide range of double-stranded RNAs. However, we do show that the CGG-RNA is digested, albeit inefficiently, by the human Dicer enzyme, a step central to the RNA interference effect on gene expression. These data provide clues to the basis of the toxic effect of CGG-RNA that is thought to occur in fragile X pre-mutation carriers. In addition, RNA hairpins may also account for the stalling of the 40S ribosomal subunit that is thought to contribute to the translation deficit in fragile X pre-mutation and full mutation alleles.