Comparative molecular dynamics study of lipid membranes containing cholesterol and ergosterol

Sterol molecules are essential for maintaining the proper structure and function of eukaryotic cell membranes. The influence of cholesterol (the principal sterol of higher animals) on the lipid bilayer properties was extensively studied by both experimental and simulation methods. In contrast, the effect of ergosterol (the principal fungal sterol) on the membrane structure and dynamics is much less recognized. This work presents the results of comparative molecular dynamics simulation of the hydrated dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer containing approximately 25 mol % of cholesterol or ergosterol. A detailed analysis of the molecular properties (e.g., bilayer thickness, lipid order, diffusion, intermolecular interactions, etc.) of both sterol-induced liquid-ordered membrane phases is presented. Presence of sterols in the membrane significantly changes its property, especially fluidity and molecular packing. Moreover, in accordance with the experiments, our calculations show that, compared to cholesterol, ergosterol has higher ordering effect on the phospholipid acyl chains. This different influence on the properties of the lipid bilayer stems from differences in conformational freedom of sterol side chains. Additionally, obtained models of lipid membranes containing human and fungal sterols, constituting the result of our work, can be also utilized in other chemotherapeutic studies on interaction of selected ligands (e.g., antifungal compounds) with membranes.     

Hopanoids,like sterols,modulate dynamics,compaction, phase segregation and permeability of membranes

In recent years, hopanoids, a group of pentacyclic compounds found in bacterial membranes, are in the spotlight since it was proposed that they induce order in lipid membranes in a similar way cholesterol do in eukaryotes, despite their structural differences. We studied here whether diplopterol (an abundant hopanoid) promoted similar effects on model membranes as sterols do. We analyzed the compaction, dynamics, phase segregation, permeability and compressibility of model membranes containing diplopterol, and compared with those containing sterols from animals, plants and fungi. We also tested the effect that the incubation with diplopterol had on hopanoid-lacking bacteria. Our results show that diplopterol induces phase segregation, increases lipid compaction, and decreases permeability on phospholipid membranes, while retaining membrane fluidity and compressibility. Furthermore, the exposition to this hopanoid decreases the permeability of the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa and increases the resistance to antibiotics. All effects promoted by diplopterol were similar to those generated by the sterols. Our observations add information on the functional significance of hopanoids as molecules that play an important role in membrane organization and dynamics in model membranes and in a bacterial system.     

Cholesterol and other membrane active sterols: from membrane evolution to "rafts".

The appearance of "membrane-active sterols" in biological membranes of eukaryocytes is one of the major steps in membrane evolution. This is exemplified best by membrane-active sterols of mammalia. The effect of membrane-active sterols on controlling membrane permeability by reducing average "fluidity" and free volume is well established. Recently it became clear that cholesterol also has a key role in the lateral organization of membranes and free volume distribution. The latter two parameters seem to be involved in controlling membrane protein activity and "raft" formation. Such an effect allows for the fine tuning of membrane lipid composition, organization/dynamics, and function.     

Molecular modelling of membrane sterols with the use of the GROMOS 96 force field

Membrane located sterols determine the structure and function of eucariotic cell membranes. Moreover, they are targets for important antifungal antibiotic amphotericin B. Knowledge about the geometry and dynamics of sterols in the environment of lipidic membranes is necessary to understand their functions. However, due to the dynamic character of the membrane, no experimental data about sterol behaviour on the molecular level is available. Hence molecular modelling simulations could be a source of useful information. The main goal of this paper is to prove the adequacy of the GROMOS 96 force field for molecular simulations of membrane sterols. We focused our attention on the reproduction of characteristic geometrical features observed in the crystal of cholesterol hemiethanolate by molecular dynamics simulations. The results presented clearly indicate that the GROMOS 96 force field can be a useful tool to simulate the highly lipophilic systems. Moreover, interactions responsible for the stability of such systems can also be recognised.     

Elicitins trap and transfer sterols from micelles, liposomes and plant plasma membranes.

Using elicitins, proteins secreted by some phytopathogenic Oomycetes (Phytophthora) known to be able to transfer sterols between phospholipid vesicles, the transfer of sterols between micelles, liposomes and biological membranes was studied. Firstly, a simple fluorometric method to screen the sterol-carrier capacity of proteins, avoiding the preparation of sterol-containing phospholipidic vesicles, is proposed. The transfer of sterols between DHE micelles (donor) and stigmasterol or cholesterol micelles (acceptor) was directly measured, as the increase in DHE fluorescence signal. The results obtained with this rapid and easy method lead to the same conclusions as those previously reported, using fluorescence polarization of a mixture of donor and acceptor phospholipid vesicles, prepared in the presence of different sterols. Therefore, the micelles method can be useful to screen proteins for their sterol carrier activity. Secondly, elicitins are shown to trap sterols from purified plant plasma membranes and to transfer sterols from micelles to these biological membranes. This property should contribute to understand the molecular mechanism involved in sterol uptake by Phytophthora. It opens new perspectives concerning the role of such proteins in plant-microorganism interactions.     

Constraints to growth of annual nettle (Urtica urens) in an elevated CO2 atmosphere: Decreased leaf area ratio and tissue N cannot be explained by ontogenetic drift or mineral N supply

Plant sterols differ from cholesterol in having an alkyl group at Δ-24, and, in the case of stigmasterol, also a Δ-22 double bond. The effects of 10 mol% of three plant sterols (campesterol, β -sitosterol, stigmasterol) and cholesterol on the molecular dynamics and phase behavior in multilamellar liposomes made from different phosphatidylcholine (PC) molecular species have been compared, utilizing the fluorescent probe Laurdan (2-dimethyl-amino-6-laurylnaphthalene). Laurdan reports the molecular mobility in the hydrophilic/hydrophobic interface of the membrane by determining the rate of dipolar relaxation of water molecules close to the glycerol backbone of PC. Our results showed that the Δ-24 alkyl group of plant sterols did not affect their ability to reduce molecular mobility in this region of the PC membranes. However, the plant sterols had a decreased capacity compared to cholesterol to inhibit formation of co-existing domains of gel and liquid-crystalline phases in membranes composed of equimolar dilauroyl-PC and dipalmitoyl-PC. The Δ-22 double bond present in stigmasterol decreased the ability of this sterol, compared to the other phytosterols, to reduce the molecular mobility at the hydrophobic/hydrophilic interface in membranes made of a saturated PC molecular species. However, in membranes made from 16:0/18:2-PC, a lipid species common in plant plasma membranes, stigmasterol was as efficient as other sterols in affecting the polarity and molecular mobility at the hydrophilic/hydrophobic interface of the membrane at 25°C, but was, in contrast to the other sterols, without effect at 0°C. Our results thus confirm as well as contradict the results of previous studies of the interactions between saturated PC and sterols, where other membrane regions were probed. The physiological relevance of the findings is discussed.     

What happens if cholesterol is made smoother: importance of methyl substituents in cholesterol ring structure on phosphatidylcholine-sterol interaction

Although sterols constitute one of the most important molecular species in cells, the reasons for their structure-function relationships in lipid membranes are not well understood. The main objective of this work is to elucidate the recently suggested possibility that the ordering and condensing effects of sterols on phospholipid membranes are related to the smoothness of a sterol. We focus on cholesterol, which has two methyl groups attached to its beta-face, and compare its properties to those of demethylated cholesterol (Dchol), from which the two methyl groups have been removed. Atomic-scale molecular dynamics simulations of lipid membranes comprised of saturated lipids and sterols, either cholesterol or Dchol, provide compelling evidence that despite its smoother structure, the ordering and condensing effects of Dchol are less effective than those of cholesterol. The ordering capability of both cholesterol and Dchol is highly asymmetric with respect to their ring structure, but whereas cholesterol favors the alpha-face, Dchol favors the beta-face. The origin and implications of this difference are analyzed in detail. The picture that emerges from this study supports a view that the two methyl groups at the steroid ring system of cholesterol play an important role in cholesterol-lipid interactions by reducing sterol tilt in the bilayer and hence allowing for an optimal orientation for cholesterol.     

Role of sterols in the interaction of polyene antibiotics with lipid membranes

The problem whether the membrane sterols are indirect acceptors of polyenic antibiotics or they play the role of substances providing conditions (at the expense of putting in order the membrane phospholipids) for formation of conductive complexes (ionic canals) from the antibiotic molecules is discussed. The comparative study on the ability of sterols of various structure (ergosterol, 7-dehydrocholesterol, cholesterol, 5 alpha-cholestan-3 beta-ol) to interact with the membrane phospholipids and to increase the sensitivity of such membranes to amphotericin B showed no correlation between the levels of these properties. The value of the changes in the cross elasticity module (E) of artificial bilayer lipid membranes from egg lecithin on introduction of the above sterols into their composition was used as the criterion for the interaction level. The absence of correlation between the above properties of the sterols indicated that the role of the sterols in interaction of polyenic antibiotics with the membranes could not be considered as the only effect of the sterols on putting in order the phospholipids, which confirmed the hypothesis on the acceptor function of the sterols with respect to polyenic antibiotics. The study of the effect of amphotericin B on the elastic properties of the cholesterol-containing bilayer membranes isolated from egg lecithin showed tha the values of the longitudinal and cross elasticity modules of the membranes did not change during introduction into the membranes of the ionic canals.     

Cholesterol Induces Specific Spatial and Orientational Order in Cholesterol/Phospholipid Membranes

Background

In lipid bilayers, cholesterol facilitates the formation of the liquid-ordered phase and enables the formation of laterally ordered structures such as lipid rafts. While these domains have an important role in a variety of cellular processes, the precise atomic-level mechanisms responsible for cholesterol''s specific ordering and packing capability have remained unresolved.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Our atomic-scale molecular dynamics simulations reveal that this ordering and the associated packing effects in membranes largely result from cholesterol''s molecular structure, which differentiates cholesterol from other sterols. We find that cholesterol molecules prefer to be located in the second coordination shell, avoiding direct cholesterol-cholesterol contacts, and form a three-fold symmetric arrangement with proximal cholesterol molecules. At larger distances, the lateral three-fold organization is broken by thermal fluctuations. For other sterols having less structural asymmetry, the three-fold arrangement is considerably lost.

Conclusions/Significance

We conclude that cholesterol molecules act collectively in lipid membranes. This is the main reason why the liquid-ordered phase only emerges for Chol concentrations well above 10 mol% where the collective self-organization of Chol molecules emerges spontaneously. The collective ordering process requires specific molecular-scale features that explain why different sterols have very different membrane ordering properties: the three-fold symmetry in the Chol-Chol organization arises from the cholesterol off-plane methyl groups allowing the identification of raft-promoting sterols from those that do not promote rafts.     

Coupled sterol synthesis and transport machineries at ER–endocytic contact sites

Sterols are unevenly distributed within cellular membranes. How their biosynthetic and transport machineries are organized to generate heterogeneity is largely unknown. We previously showed that the yeast sterol transporter Osh2 is recruited to endoplasmic reticulum (ER)–endocytic contacts to facilitate actin polymerization. We now find that a subset of sterol biosynthetic enzymes also localizes at these contacts and interacts with Osh2 and the endocytic machinery. Following the sterol dynamics, we show that Osh2 extracts sterols from these subdomains, which we name ERSESs (ER sterol exit sites). Further, we demonstrate that coupling of the sterol synthesis and transport machineries is required for endocytosis in mother cells, but not in daughters, where plasma membrane loading with accessible sterols and endocytosis are linked to secretion.     

Effects of oxygenated sterol on phospholipid bilayer properties: a molecular dynamics simulation

The properties of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC):6-ketocholestanol bilayer at 50 mol% sterol were studied using the molecular dynamics simulation technique. Our simulations were performed at constant pressure and temperature on a nanosecond time scale. Data from this simulation were compared to the results of our previous simulations on DPPC and DPPC-cholesterol bilayers. We conclude that the differences in the properties of membranes with cholesterol and ketocholestanol are due to the difference in 6-ketocholestanol and cholesterol location in the bilayer. The presence of the keto group in ketocholestanol moves the sterol towards the polar region closer to interface with water. We predict that similar mechanisms would govern the properties of membranes with other oxygenated sterols, such as for example 7-ketocholesterol. Results of our simulations are in a good agreement with the data available from the experiment.     

Mechanisms of sterol uptake and transport in yeast

Sterols are essential lipid components of eukaryotic membranes. Here we summarize recent advances in understanding how sterols are transported between different membranes. Baker's yeast is a particularly attractive organism to dissect this lipid transport pathway, because cells can synthesize their own major sterol, ergosterol, in the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum from where it is then transported to the plasma membrane. However, Saccharomyces cerevisiae is also a facultative anaerobic organism, which becomes sterol auxotroph in the absence of oxygen. Under these conditions, cells take up sterol from the environment and transport the lipid back into the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum, where the free sterol becomes esterified and is then stored in lipid droplets. Steryl ester formation is thus a reliable readout to assess the back-transport of exogenously provided sterols from the plasma membrane to the endoplasmic reticulum. Structure/function analysis has revealed that the bulk membrane function of the fungal ergosterol can be provided by structurally related sterols, including the mammalian cholesterol. Foreign sterols, however, are subject to a lipid quality control cycle in which the sterol is reversibly acetylated. Because acetylated sterols are efficiently excreted from cells, the substrate specificity of the deacetylating enzymes determines which sterols are retained. Membrane-bound acetylated sterols are excreted by the secretory pathway, more soluble acetylated sterol derivatives such as the steroid precursor pregnenolone, on the other hand, are excreted by a pathway that is independent of vesicle formation and fusion. Further analysis of this lipid quality control cycle is likely to reveal novel insight into the mechanisms that ensure sterol homeostasis in eukaryotic cells. Article from a special issue on Steroids and Microorganisms.     

The role of sterols in the functional reconstitution of water-soluble mitochondrial porins from plants

Water-soluble porins were prepared from native mitochondrial porins isolated from different plants (pea and corn). In the water-soluble form the porins have lost their channel-forming properties. The water-soluble porins were investigated for the influence of different sterols on their membrane activity and their channel-forming properties in lipid bilayer membranes. Our experiments demonstrated that the water-soluble porins regained channel forming activity when the protein was preincubated with different sterols in the presence of a detergent. The channels formed in lipid bilayer membranes after this procedure regain in many but not all cases the original properties of the native mitochondrial porins. Preincubation with other sterols led to a change in the single-channel conductance or to a complete loss of the voltage dependence. The sterols had also a strong influence on the channel-forming activity of the porins. Preincubation of water-soluble pea porin with the plant sterol -sitosterol resulted in a considerable higher channel-forming activity than with all the other sterols used for preincubation. The role of the sterols in the channel-forming complex is discussed.     

Significance of sterol structural specificity. Desmosterol cannot replace cholesterol in lipid rafts

Desmosterol is an immediate precursor of cholesterol in the Bloch pathway of sterol synthesis and an abundant membrane lipid in specific cell types. The significance of the difference between the two sterols, an additional double bond at position C24 in the tail of desmosterol, is not known. Here, we provide evidence that the biophysical and functional characteristics of the two sterols differ and that this is because the double bond at C24 significantly weakens the sterol ordering potential. In model membranes, desmosterol was significantly weaker than cholesterol in promoting the formation or stability of ordered domains, and in mammalian cell membranes, desmosterol associated less avidly than cholesterol with detergent-resistant membranes. Atomic scale molecular dynamics simulations showed that the double bond gives rise to additional stress in the tail, creating a rigid structure between C24 and C27 and favoring tilting of desmosterol distinct from cholesterol. Functional effects of desmosterol in cell membranes were assessed upon acutely exchanging approximately 70% of cholesterol to desmosterol. This led to impaired raft-dependent signaling via the insulin receptor, whereas non-raft-dependent protein secretion was not affected. We suggest that the choice of cholesterol synthesis route may provide a physiological mechanism to modulate raft-dependent functions in cells.     

Microbial Eukaryotes that Lack Sterols

It is widely held that sterols are key cyclic triterpenoid lipids in eukaryotic cell membranes and are synthesized through oxygen‐dependent multienzyme pathways. However, there are known exceptions―ciliated protozoans, such as Tetrahymena, along with diverse low‐oxygen‐adapted eukaryotes produce, instead of sterols, the cyclic triterpenoid lipid tetrahymanol that does not require molecular oxygen for its biosynthesis. Here, we report that a number of anaerobic microbial eukaryotes (protists) utilize neither sterols nor tetrahymanol in their membranes. The lack of detectable sterol‐like compounds in their membranes may provide an opportunity to reconsider the physiological function of sterols and sterol‐like lipids in eukaryotes.     

Intracellular sterol transport in eukaryotes,a connection to mitochondrial function?

Eukaryotic cells synthesize sterols in the endoplasmatic reticulum (ER) from where it needs to be efficiently transported to the plasma membrane, which harbors approximately 90% of the free sterol pool of the cell. Sterols that are being taken up from the environment, on the other hand, are transported back from the plasma membrane to the ER, where the free sterols are esterified to steryl esters. The molecular mechanisms that govern this bidirectional movement of sterols between the ER and the plasma membrane of eukaryotic cells are only poorly understood. Proper control of this transport is important for normal cell function and development as indicated by fatal human pathologies such as Niemann Pick type C disease and atherosclerosis, which are characterized by an over-accumulation of free sterols within endosomal membranes and the ER, respectively. Recently, a number of complementary approaches using Saccharomyces cerevisiae as a model organism lead to a more precise characterization of the pathways that control the subcellular transport of sterols and led to the identification of components that directly or indirectly affect sterol uptake at the plasma membrane and its transport back to the ER. A genetic approach that is based on the fact that yeast is a facultative anaerobic organism, which becomes auxotrophic for sterols in the absence of oxygen, resulted in the identification of 17 genes that are required for efficient uptake and/or transport of sterols. Unexpectedly, many of these genes are required for mitochondrial functions. A possible connection between mitochondrial biogenesis and sterol biosynthesis and uptake will be discussed in light of the fact that cholesterol transport into the inner membranes of mitochondria is a well established sterol transport route in vertebrates, where it is required to convert cholesterol into pregnenolone, the precursor of steroids.     

Amphotericin B channels in the bacterial membrane: role of sterol and temperature

Amphotericin B is an antibiotic that forms ion channels in the membrane of a host cell. The change in permeability produced by these channels is greatly improved by sterols; nevertheless, the single channel conductivity remains invariant. Hence, it is proposed that sterols do not act directly, but rather through the modulation of the membrane phase. We look at the formation of these channels in the bacterial membrane to determine the mechanism of its known antibiotic resistance. We found that channels can indeed be formed in this membrane, but a substantial amount of amphotericin B is required. We also study the effects of the antibiotic concentration needed for channel expression as well as the dynamics of channels affected by both sterol and temperature in phosphatidylcholine membranes. The results support the idea that membrane structure is a determining factor in the action of the antibiotic.     

Bilayer thickness and thermal response of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine unilamellar vesicles containing cholesterol, ergosterol and lanosterol: a small-angle neutron scattering study

Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) measurements are performed on pure dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) unilamellar vesicles (ULV) and those containing either 20 or 47 mol% cholesterol, ergosterol or lanosterol. From the SANS data, we were able to determine the influence of these sterols on ULV bilayer thickness and vesicle area expansion coefficients. While these parameters have been determined previously for membranes containing cholesterol, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first time such results have been presented for membranes containing the structurally related sterols, ergosterol and lanosterol. At both molar concentrations and at temperatures ranging from 10 to 45 degrees C, the addition of the different sterols leads to increases in bilayer thickness, relative to pure DMPC. We observe large differences in the influence of these sterols on the membrane thermal area expansion coefficient. All three sterols, however, produce very similar changes to membrane thickness.     

Comparative behavior of sterols in phosphatidylcholine-sterol monolayer films

The ability of sterols other than cholesterol (CHOL) to support membrane functions in membranes that normally contain CHOL as the primary, if not sole, sterol may be due, in part, to how well such sterols can mimic CHOL's behavior and physical properties in membranes. We compared the mixing properties of CHOL, 7-dehydrocholesterol (7DHC), and desmosterol (DES) in egg phosphatidylcholine-sterol monolayer films containing 10, 20, and 30 mol percent sterol, measuring pressure-area isotherms on a Langmuir-Blodgett trough with the aqueous, buffered subphase maintained at 37 degrees C. Under the conditions employed, the pressure-area isotherms for all three sterols were similar, with 7DHC exhibiting slightly larger molecular areas on the water surface at all compositions. These results are discussed in the context of the ability of sterols such as 7DHC and DES to substitute structurally and functionally for CHOL in biological membranes.     

Differential effects of cholesterol and its immediate biosynthetic precursors on membrane organization

Cholesterol is the most representative sterol present in vertebrate membranes and is the end product of the long and multistep sterol biosynthetic pathway. 7-Dehydrocholesterol (7-DHC) and desmosterol are the immediate biosynthetic precursors of cholesterol in the Kandutsch-Russell and Bloch pathway. In this article, we have monitored the effect of cholesterol and its two immediate biosynthetic precursors on biophysical and dynamic properties of fluid and gel phase membranes. Toward this goal, we have used fluorescent membrane probes, DPH and TMA-DPH, and the hydrophobic probe, pyrene. Our results using these probes show that although both 7-DHC and desmosterol differ with cholesterol in one double bond, they exhibit differential effects on membrane organization and dynamics. Importantly, we show that the effect of cholesterol and desmosterol on membrane organization and dynamics is similar in most cases, while 7-DHC has a considerably different effect. This demonstrates that the position of the double bond in sterols is an important determinant in maintaining membrane order and dynamics. These results assume relevance since the accumulation of cholesterol precursors have been reported to result in severe pathological conditions.