X-ray diffraction of bacteriorhodopsin photocycle intermediates

Recent advances in the crystallography of bacteriorhodopsin, the light-driven proton pump, have yielded structural models for all intermediates of the photochemical cycle. For seven of the species, X-ray diffraction data were collected from trapped photostationary states in crystals, and for the two remaining ones the structures of selected mutants are available. The changes of the retinal chromophore, protein and bound water describe, at an atomic level, how accommodation of the twisted photoisomerized retinal to its binding site causes de-protonation of the retinal Schiff base and initiates cascades of gradual conformational rearrangements of the protein. One cascade propagates in the extracellular direction and results in proton release, and the other in the cytoplasmic direction and results in side-chain and main-chain rearrangements, formation of a chain of hydrogen-bonded water, and proton uptake from the bulk. Such local-global conformational coupling, with gradual spreading of a local perturbation over the rest of the protein, might be the uniting principle of transporters and receptors.     

Time-resolved absorption and fluorescence from the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle in the nanosecond time regime

Picosecond transient absorption (PTA) in the 568-660-nm region is measured over the initial 80 ns of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle. After photocycle initiation with 573-nm excitation (7-ps pulsewidth), these PTA data reflect the formation during the initial 40 ps of two long-recognized intermediates with red-shifted (relative to that of BR-570) absorption bands, namely J-625 and K-590. PTA signals at 568, 628, and 652 nm are unchanged for the remainder of the 80-ns photocycle interval measured, demonstrating that no other intermediates, including the proposed KL, are observable by absorption changes. Picosecond time-resolved fluorescence (PTRF), measured at 740 nm, is initiated by 7 ps excitation of the species present at various time delays after the photocycle begins. PTRF signals change rapidly over the initial 40 ps, reflecting, first, the depletion of the ground state BR-570 population and, subsequently, the formation of K-590. The PTRF signal then decreases monotonically with a time constant of 5.5 ± 0.5 ns from its maximum near a 50-ps delay until it reaches a minimum at a delay of ≈ 13 ns. For time delays between 13 and 80 ns, the PTRF signal remains unchanged and slightly higher than that measured from BR-570 alone. The rapid decrease in PTRF signals over the same photocycle interval in which the PTA signals remain unchanged suggests that the retinal-protein interactions involving electronically excited K-590 (K*) are being significantly altered.     

Thermal equilibration between the M and N intermediates in the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin.

The stages in the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (BR) involving the M and N intermediates are investigated using a double pulse excitation method. A first (cycling) pulse at 532 nm is followed, with an appropriate time delay, by a second pulse (337, 406, 446, or 470 nm) which induces the M-->BR back-photoreaction. After depletion by the second pulse a repopulation of M in the millisecond range is observed which is interpreted in terms of a thermal N-->M relaxation. It is thus concluded that a (thermal) M<-->N equilibrium accounts for the biphasic decay of M in the BR photocycle. Other models for this stage of the light-driven proton-pump are therefore unnecessary.     

pH and salt effects on the slow intermediates of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

Purple membrane fragments of Halobacterium halobium were used to investigate pH and salt effects on the kinetics of M ₄₁₂, O ₆₆₀ and BR ₅₆₈. The flash-induced absorbance changes were measured in the 5–9 pH range, at low ionic strength and at 4 M NaCl. The results are consistent with a model which implies a branching in the last part of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.     

Chromophore motion during the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle: polarized absorption spectroscopy of bacteriorhodopsin and its M-state in bacteriorhodopsin crystals.

The three-dimensional crystallization of bacteriorhodopsin was systematically investigated and the needle-shaped crystal form analysed. In these crystals the M-intermediate forms 10 times faster and decays 15 times more slowly than in purple membranes. Polarized absorption spectra of the crystals were measured in the dark and light adapted states. A slight decrease in the angle between the transition moment and the membrane plane was detected during dark adaptation. The crystallization of a mutated bacteriorhodopsin, in which the aspartic acid at residue 96 was replaced by asparagine, provided crystals with a long lived M-intermediate. This allowed polarized absorption measurements of the M-chromophore. The change in the polarization ratio upon formation of the M-intermediate indicates an increase in the angle between the main transition dipole and the membrane plane by 2.2 degrees +/- 0.5, corresponding to a 0.5 A displacement of one end of the chromophore out of the membrane plane of the bacteriorhodopsin molecule.     

Picosecond time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy of K-590 in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

The fluorescence spectrum of a distinct isometric and conformational intermediate formed on the 10(-11) s time scale during the bacteriorhodopsin (BR) photocycle is observed at room temperature using a two laser, pump-probe technique with picosecond time resolution. The BR photocycle is initiated by pulsed (8 ps) excitation at 565 nm, whereas the fluorescence is generated by 4-ps laser pulses at 590 nm. The unstructured fluorescence extends from 650 to 880 nm and appears in the same general spectral region as the fluorescence spectrum assigned to BR-570. The transient fluorescence spectrum can be distinguished from that assigned to BR-570 by a larger emission quantum yield (approximately twice that of BR-570) and by a maximum intensity near 731 nm (shifted 17 nm to higher energy from the maximum of the BR-570 fluorescence spectrum). The fluorescence spectrum of BR-570 only is measured with low energy, picosecond pulsed excitation at 590 nm and is in good agreement with recent data in the literature. The assignment of the transient fluorescence spectrum to the K-590 intermediate is based on its appearance at time delays longer than 40 ps. The K-590 fluorescence spectrum remains unchanged over the entire 40-100-ps interval. The relevance of these fluorescence data with respect to the molecular mechanism used to model the primary processes in the BR photocycle also is discussed.     

Structural changes during the formation of early intermediates in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

Early intermediates of bacteriorhodopsin's photocycle were modeled by means of ab initio quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical and molecular dynamics simulations. The photoisomerization of the retinal chromophore and the formation of photoproducts corresponding to the early intermediates were simulated by molecular dynamics simulations. By means of the quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical method, the resulting structures were refined and the respective excitation energies were calculated. Two sequential intermediates were found with absorption maxima that exhibit red shifts from the resting state. The intermediates were therefore assigned to the K and KL states. In K, the conformation of the retinal chromophore is strongly deformed, and the N--H bond of the Schiff base points almost perpendicular to the membrane normal toward Asp-212. The strongly deformed conformation of the chromophore and weakened interaction of the Schiff base with the surrounding polar groups are the means by which the absorbed energy is stored. During the K-to-KL transition, the chromophore undergoes further conformational changes that result in the formation of a hydrogen bond between the N--H group of the Schiff base and Thr-89 as well as other rearrangements of the hydrogen-bond network in the vicinity of the Schiff base, which are suggested to play a key role in the proton transfer process in the later phase of the photocycle.     

Subpicosecond resonance Raman spectra of the early intermediates in the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin

The resonance Raman spectra are presented for the species formed during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) on a timescale of 800-900 fs. In the ethylenic stretch region two intermediates were found with frequencies of 1,510 and 1,518 cm^-1, corresponding to species with optical absorption maxima at 660 and 625 nm, respectively. This leads to the assignment of the 1,518 cm^-1 band to the J₆₂₅ intermediate. In the fingerprint region, the appearance of a vibration at 1,195 cm^-1 strongly suggests that the isomerization indeed has taken place in a time less than the pulsewidth of our laser. This supports the previous proposals made on the basis of the optical spectra. The spectra are compared with those observed in tens of picoseconds up to nanoseconds.     

Tyrosine and carboxyl protonation changes in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle. 1. M412 and L550 intermediates

The role of tyrosines in the bacteriorhodopsin (bR) photocycle has been investigated by using Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) and UV difference spectroscopies. Tyrosine contributions to the BR570----M412 FTIR difference spectra recorded at several temperatures and pH's were identified by isotopically labelling tyrosine residues in bacteriorhodopsin. The frequencies and deuterium/hydrogen exchange sensitivities of these peaks and of peaks in spectra of model compounds in several environments suggest that at least two different tyrosine groups participate in the bR photocycle during the formation of M412. One group undergoes a tyrosinate----tyrosine conversion during the BR570----K630 transition. A second tyrosine group deprotonates between L550 and M412. Low-temperature UV difference spectra in the 220--350-nm region of both purple membrane suspensions and rehydrated films support these conclusions. The UV spectra also indicate perturbation(s) of one or more tryptophan group(s). Several carboxyl groups appear to undergo a series of protonation changes between BR570 and M412, as indicated by infrared absorption changes in the 1770--1720-cm-1 region. These results are consistent with the existence of a proton wire in bacteriorhodopsin that involves both tyrosine and carboxyl groups.     

The projection structure of the low temperature K intermediate of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle determined by electron diffraction

Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) is an integral membrane protein which absorbs visible light and pumps protons across the cell membrane of Halobacterium salinarium. bR is one of the few membrane-bound pumps whose structure is known at atomic resolution. Changes in the protein structure of bR are a crucial element in the mechanism of proton pumping and can be followed by a variety of spectroscopic, and diffraction methods. A number of intermediates in the photocycle have been identified spectroscopically and a number of laboratories have been successful in reporting the structural changes taking place in the later stages of the photocycle over the millisecond time-scale using diffraction techniques. These studies have revealed significant changes in the protein structure, possibly involving changes in flexibility and/or movement of helices. Earlier intermediates which arise and decay on the picosecond to microsecond time-scale have proven more difficult to trap. Here, we report for the first time the successful trapping and diffraction analysis of bR in a low temperature state resembling the very early intermediate, K. We have calculated a projection difference map to 3.5 A resolution. The map reveals no significant structural changes in the molecule, despite having a very low background noise level. This does not rule out the possibility of movements in a direction perpendicular to the plane of the membrane. However, the data are consistent with other evidence that significant structural changes do not occur in the protein itself.     

Protonation and deprotonation of the M, N, and O intermediates during the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

Transient pH changes were measured with phenol red and chlorophenol red in the 30-microseconds-50-ms time range during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (BR), the light-driven proton pump. At pH greater than or equal to 7, the results confirmed earlier data and suggestions that one proton is released during the L----M reaction, and taken up again during the decay of N. These are likely to be steps in the proton transport process. At pH less than 7, however, the time-resolved pH traces were complex and indicated additional protonation reactions. The data were explained by a model which assumed pH-dependent protonation states for M and N which varied from -1 to 0, and for O which varied from 0 to + 2, relative to BR. If the kinetics of the vectorial proton translocation process were taken as pH independent, this treatment of the data suggested that a residue with a pKa of 5.9 was made protonable in M and N and two residues with pKa's of 6.5 were made cooperatively protonable in O. The additional protons detected are not necessarily in the vectorial proton transfer pathway (i.e., they are probably "Bohr protons"), and while they must reflect conformational and/or neighboring ionization changes in the BR as it passes through the M, N, and O states, their role, if any, in the transport is uncertain.     

The quantum efficiency of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

The quantum yield of the primary photoprocess in light-adapted bacteriorhodopsin (phi 1) was determined at room temperature with low-intensity 530 nm neodymium laser excitation, with bovine rhodopsin as a relative actinometer. The observed value of phi 1 - 0.25 +/- 0.05, and the previously determined parameter phi 1/phi 2 - 0.4 [where phi 2 denotes the quantum efficiency of the back photoprecess from the primary species K (590)] imply that phi 1 + phi 2 approximately equal 1. This feature, also characterizing the photochemistry of rhodopsin, bears on the nature and mechanism of the primary event in both systems.     

Interrelations of M-intermediates in bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

The photocycles of the wild-type bacteriorhodopsin and the D96N mutant were investigated by the flash-photolysis technique. The M-intermediate formation (400 nm) and the L-intermediate decay (520 nm) were found to be well described by a sum of two exponents (time constants, tau 1 = 65 and tau 2 = 250 microseconds) for the wild-type bR and three exponents (tau 1 = 55 microseconds, tau 2 = 220 microseconds and tau 3 = 1 ms) for the D96N mutant of bR. A component with tau = 1 ms was found to be present in the photocycle of the wild-type bacteriorhodopsin as a lag-phase in the relaxation of photoresponses at 400 and 520 nm. In the presence of Lu3+ ions or 80% glycerol this component was clearly seen as an additional phase of M-formation. The azide effect on the D96N mutant of bR suggests that the 1-ms component is associated with an irreversible conformational change switching the Schiff base from the outward to the inward proton channel. The maximum of the difference spectrum of the 1-ms component of D96N bR is located at 404 nm as compared to 412 nm for the first two components. We suggest that this effect is a result of the alteration of the inward proton channel due to the Asp96-->Asn substitution. Proton release measured with pyranine in the absence of pH buffers was identical for the wild-type bR and D96N mutant and matched the M-->M' conformational transition. A model for M rise in the bR photocycle is proposed.     

Spectrally silent transitions in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

The photocycle kinetics of bacteriorhodopsin were analyzed from 0 to 40 degrees C at 101 wavelengths (330-730 nm). The data can be satisfactorily approximated by eight exponents. The slowest component (half-time 20 ms at 20 degrees C) belongs to the 13-cis cycle. The residual seven exponentials that are sufficient to describe the all-trans photocycle indicate that at least seven intermediates of the all-trans cycle must exist, although only five spectrally distinct species (K, L, M, N, and O) have been identified. These seven exponentials and their spectra at different temperatures provide the basis for the discussion of various kinetic schemes of the relaxation. The simplest model of irreversible sequential transitions includes after the first K--> L step the quasiequilibria of L<-->M, M<-->N, and N<-->O intermediates. These quasiequilibria are controlled by rate-limiting dynamics of the protein and/or proton transfer steps outside the chromophore region. Thus there exists an apparent kinetic paradox (i.e., why is the number of exponents of relaxation (at least seven) higher than the number of distinct spectral intermediates (only five)), which can be explained by assuming that some of the transitions correspond to changes in the quasiequilibria between spectrally distinct intermediates (i.e., are spectrally silent).     

Pathways of proton release in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

The pH dependencies of the rate constants in the photocycles of recombinant D96N and D115N/D96N bacteriorhodopsins were determined from time-resolved difference spectra between 70 ns and 420 ms after photoexcitation. The results were consistent with the model suggested earlier for proteins containing D96N substitution: BR hv----K----L----M1----M2----BR. Only the M2----M1 back-reaction was pH-dependent: its rate increased with increasing [H+] between pH 5 and 8. We conclude from quantitative analysis of this pH dependency that its reverse, the M1----M2 reaction, is linked to the release of a proton from a group with a pKa = 5.8. This suggests a model for wild-type bacteriorhodopsin in which at pH greater than 5.8 the transported proton is released on the extracellular side from this as yet unknown group and on the 100-microseconds time scale, but at pH less than 5.8, the proton release occurs from another residue and later in the photocycle most likely directly from D85 during the O----BR reaction. We postulate, on the other hand, that proton uptake on the cytoplasmic side will be by D96 and during the N----O reaction regardless of pH. The proton kinetics as measured with indicator dyes confirmed the unique prediction of this model: at pH greater than 6, proton release preceded proton uptake, but at pH less than 6, the release was delayed until after the uptake. The results indicated further that the overall M1----M2 reaction includes a second kinetic step in addition to proton release; this is probably the earlier postulated extracellular-to-cytoplasmic reorientation switch in the proton pump.     

Photoconversion from the light-adapted to the dark-adapted state of bacteriorhodopsin.

Dark and light adaptation of bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane multilayers at less than 100% relative humidity differs from that seen in suspensions. Equilibrium between the two bacteriorhodopsin isomers (bR cis 550 and bR trans 570) in the light-adapted state becomes dependent on the wavelength of actinic light. Excitation at the red edge of the visible absorption band causes dark adaptation in a light-adapted sample. Using polarized actinic and measuring light, we show that acceleration of the dark adaptation through heating by actinic light cannot explain this observation. A light-driven bR trans 570 to bR cis 550 reaction that competes with the well-known 13 cis-to-all-trans light adaptation reaction must exist under our experimental conditions. Trans-to-cis conversion is a one-photon process distinct from the two photon process observed by others in purple membrane suspensions (Sperling, W., C. N. Rafferty, K. D. Kohl, and N. A. Dencher, 1978, FEBS (Fed. Eur. Biochem. Soc.) Lett. 97:129-132). Its quantum efficiency increases monotonously on reducing the hydration level, and is paralleled by an increase in the lifetime of the M410 intermediate of the trans photocycle. We suggest that at this point a branch leads from the all-trans into the 13-cis photocycle. It is probably the same reaction that causes the reduced light adaptation in monomeric bacteriorhodopsin (Casadio, R., H. Gutowitz, P. Mowery, M. Taylor, and W. Stoeckenius, 1980, Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 590:13-23; Casadio, R., and W. Stoeckenius, 1980, Biochemistry. 19:3374-3381).     

On the photocycle and light adaptation of dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin.

Pulsed Nd laser (25 ns, 530 nm) photolysis experiments were carried out at room temperature in aqueous suspensions of dark- and light-adapted fragments of the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium. It is shown that the (50%) 13-cis isomeric component (BR13-cis) of dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin (BRDA) undergoes a photocycle involving a characteristic transient absorbing in the neighborhood of 610 nm. At relatively high excitation intensities BR13-cis is converted to the same 410 nm (M) transient that characterized the photocycle of the all-trans isomer (BRtrans) of light-adapted bacteriorhodopsin (BRLA). This process, which competes with the generation of the "610" species, is attributed to the photo-induced conversion, during the pulse, of BR13-cis (or of its primary photoproduct "X") to a species in the BRtrans photocyte. The relationship between these observations and the mechanism of BRDA hv leads to BRLA adaptation at low excitation intensities (for which a quantum yield limit, 0 less than or equal to (3.5 +/- 0.7) X 10(-2) , is established) is discussed.     

Interconversions among four M-intermediates in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

Halobacterium salinarum displays four distinct kinetic forms of M-intermediate in its bacteriorhodopsin photocycle. In wild-type, there are mainly two species with time constants near 2 and 5 ms. Under various kinds of stress, two other species arise with time constants near 10 and 70 ms. We show that these four species are interconvertible. Increases in membrane hydrophobicity convert the slower to faster forms. Perturbations caused by Triton X-100 or mutations convert faster to slower forms. The fastest form requires a hydrophobic membrane environment near a ring of four charged aspartate residues in the trimer, namely Asp36, Asp38, Asp102, and Asp104 in the cytoplasmic loop regions. Interconversions of the 2-ms and 5-ms species of the wild-type are accomplished by pH-changes. The potential significance of these findings is discussed.     

Lipidic cubic phase crystallization of bacteriorhodopsin and cryotrapping of intermediates: towards resolving a revolving photocycle

Bacteriorhodopsin is a small retinal protein found in the membrane of the halophilic bacterium Halobacterium salinarum, whose function is to pump protons across the cell membrane against an electrostatic potential, thus converting light into a proton-motive potential needed for the synthesis of ATP. Because of its relative simplicity, exceptional stability and the fundamental importance of vectorial proton pumping, bacteriorhodopsin has become one of the most important model systems in the field of bioenergetics. Recently, a novel methodology to obtain well-diffracting crystals of membrane proteins, utilizing membrane-like bicontinuous lipidic cubic phases, has been introduced, providing X-ray structures of bacteriorhodopsin and its photocycle intermediates at ever higher resolution. We describe this methodology, the new insights provided by the higher resolution ground state structures, and review the mechanistic implications of the structural intermediates reported to date. A detailed understanding of the mechanism of vectorial proton transport across the membrane is thus emerging, helping to elucidate a number of fundamental issues in bioenergetics.