Structural Analysis of the Rubisco-Assembly Chaperone RbcX-II from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The most prevalent form of the Rubisco enzyme is a complex of eight catalytic large subunits (RbcL) and eight regulatory small subunits (RbcS). Rubisco biogenesis depends on the assistance by specific molecular chaperones. The assembly chaperone RbcX stabilizes the RbcL subunits after folding by chaperonin and mediates their assembly to the RbcL₈ core complex, from which RbcX is displaced by RbcS to form active holoenzyme. Two isoforms of RbcX are found in eukaryotes, RbcX-I, which is more closely related to cyanobacterial RbcX, and the more distant RbcX-II. The green algae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii contains only RbcX-II isoforms, CrRbcX-IIa and CrRbcX-IIb. Here we solved the crystal structure of CrRbcX-IIa and show that it forms an arc-shaped dimer with a central hydrophobic cleft for binding the C-terminal sequence of RbcL. Like other RbcX proteins, CrRbcX-IIa supports the assembly of cyanobacterial Rubisco in vitro, albeit with reduced activity relative to cyanobacterial RbcX-I. Structural analysis of a fusion protein of CrRbcX-IIa and the C-terminal peptide of RbcL suggests that the peptide binding mode of RbcX-II may differ from that of cyanobacterial RbcX. RbcX homologs appear to have adapted to their cognate Rubisco clients as a result of co-evolution.     

Structure and function of RbcX, an assembly chaperone for hexadecameric Rubisco

After folding, many proteins must assemble into oligomeric complexes to become biologically active. Here we describe the role of RbcX as an assembly chaperone of ribulose-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco), the enzyme responsible for the fixation of atmospheric carbon dioxide. In cyanobacteria and plants, Rubisco is an approximately 520 kDa complex composed of eight large subunits (RbcL) and eight small subunits (RbcS). We found that cyanobacterial RbcX functions downstream of chaperonin-mediated RbcL folding in promoting the formation of RbcL(8) core complexes. Structural analysis revealed that the 15 kDa RbcX forms a homodimer with two cooperating RbcL-binding regions. A central cleft specifically binds the exposed C-terminal peptide of RbcL subunits, enabling a peripheral surface of RbcX to mediate RbcL(8) assembly. Due to the dynamic nature of these interactions, RbcX is readily displaced from RbcL(8) complexes by RbcS, producing the active enzyme. The strategies employed by RbcX in achieving substrate specificity and efficient product release may be generally relevant in assisted assembly reactions.     

The rbcX gene product promotes the production and assembly of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase of Synechococcus sp. PCC7002 in Escherichia coli

The operon encoding ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) in the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC7002 contains three rbc genes, rbcL, rbcX and rbcS, in this order. Introduction of translational frameshift into the rbcX gene resulted in a significant decrease in the production of large (RbcL) and small (RbcS) subunits of the Rubisco protein in Synechococcus sp. PCC7002 and in Escherichia coli. To investigate the function of the rbcX gene product (RbcX), we constructed the expression plasmid for the rbcX gene and examined the effects of RbcX on the recombinant Rubisco production in Escherichia coli. The coexpression experiments revealed that RbcX had marked effects on the production of large and small subunits of Rubisco without any significant influence on the mRNA level of rbc genes and/or the post-translational assembly of the Rubisco protein. The present rbcX coexpression system provides a novel and useful method for investigating the Rubisco maturation pathway.     

Role of Small Subunit in Mediating Assembly of Red-type Form I Rubisco

Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) is the key enzyme involved in photosynthetic carbon fixation, converting atmospheric CO₂ to organic compounds. Form I Rubisco is a cylindrical complex composed of eight large (RbcL) subunits that are capped by four small subunits (RbcS) at the top and four at the bottom. Form I Rubiscos are phylogenetically divided into green- and red-type. Some red-type enzymes have catalytically superior properties. Thus, understanding their folding and assembly is of considerable biotechnological interest. Folding of the green-type RbcL subunits in cyanobacteria is mediated by the GroEL/ES chaperonin system, and assembly to holoenzyme requires specialized chaperones such as RbcX and RAF1. Here, we show that the red-type RbcL subunits in the proteobacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides also fold with GroEL/ES. However, assembly proceeds in a chaperone-independent manner. We find that the C-terminal β-hairpin extension of red-type RbcS, which is absent in green-type RbcS, is critical for efficient assembly. The β-hairpins of four RbcS subunits form an eight-stranded β-barrel that protrudes into the central solvent channel of the RbcL core complex. The two β-barrels stabilize the complex through multiple interactions with the RbcL subunits. A chimeric green-type RbcS carrying the C-terminal β-hairpin renders the assembly of a cyanobacterial Rubisco independent of RbcX. Our results may facilitate the engineering of crop plants with improved growth properties expressing red-type Rubisco.     

Transgenic tobacco plants with improved cyanobacterial Rubisco expression but no extra assembly factors grow at near wild‐type rates if provided with elevated CO2

Introducing a carbon‐concentrating mechanism and a faster Rubisco enzyme from cyanobacteria into higher plant chloroplasts may improve photosynthetic performance by increasing the rate of CO₂ fixation while decreasing losses caused by photorespiration. We previously demonstrated that tobacco plants grow photoautotrophically using Rubisco from Synechococcus elongatus, although the plants exhibited considerably slower growth than wild‐type and required supplementary CO₂. Because of concerns that vascular plant assembly factors may not be adequate for assembly of a cyanobacterial Rubisco, prior transgenic plants included the cyanobacterial chaperone RbcX or the carboxysomal protein CcmM35. Here we show that neither RbcX nor CcmM35 is needed for assembly of active cyanobacterial Rubisco. Furthermore, by altering the gene regulatory sequences on the Rubisco transgenes, cyanobacterial Rubisco expression was enhanced and the transgenic plants grew at near wild‐type growth rates, although still requiring elevated CO₂. We performed detailed kinetic characterization of the enzymes produced with and without the RbcX and CcmM35 cyanobacterial proteins. These transgenic plants exhibit photosynthetic characteristics that confirm the predicted benefits of introduction of non‐native forms of Rubisco with higher carboxylation rate constants in vascular plants and the potential nitrogen‐use efficiency that may be achieved provided that adequate CO₂ is available near the enzyme.     

Is RAF1 protein from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Synechocystis</Emphasis> sp. PCC 6803 really needed in the cyanobacterial Rubisco assembly process?

Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) is responsible for carbon dioxide conversion during photosynthesis and, therefore, is the most important protein in biomass generation. Modifications of this biocatalyst toward improvements in its properties are hindered by the complicated and not yet fully understood assembly process required for the formation of active holoenzymes. An entire set of auxiliary factors, including chaperonin GroEL/GroES and assembly chaperones RbcX or Rubisco accumulation factor 1 (RAF1), is involved in the folding and subsequent assembly of Rubisco subunits. Recently, it has been shown that cyanobacterial RAF1 acts during the formation of the large Rubisco subunit (RbcL) dimer. However, both its physiological function and its necessity in the prokaryotic Rubisco formation process remain elusive. Here, we demonstrate that the Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 strain with raf1 gene disruption shows the same growth rate as wild-type cells under standard conditions. Moreover, the Rubisco biosynthesis process seems to be unperturbed in mutant cells despite the absence of RbcL-RAF1 complexes. However, in the tested environmental conditions, sulfur starvation triggers the degradation of RbcL and subsequent proteolysis of other polypeptides in wild-type but not Δraf1 strains. Pull-down experiments also indicate that, apart from Rubisco, RAF1 co-purifies with phycocyanins. We postulate that RAF1 is not an obligatory factor in cyanobacterial Rubisco assembly, but rather participates in environmentally regulated Rubisco homeostasis.     

Insights into eukaryotic Rubisco assembly — Crystal structures of RbcX chaperones from Arabidopsis thaliana

Background

Chloroplasts were formed by uptake of cyanobacteria into eukaryotic cells ca. 1.6 billion years ago. During evolution most of the cyanobacterial genes were transferred from the chloroplast to the nuclear genome. The rbcX gene, encoding an assembly chaperone required for Rubisco biosynthesis in cyanobacteria, was duplicated. Here we demonstrate that homologous eukaryotic chaperones (AtRbcX1 and AtRbcX2) demonstrate different affinities for the C-terminus of Rubisco large subunit and determine their crystal structures.

Methods

Three-dimensional structures of AtRbcX1 and AtRbcX2 were resolved by the molecular replacement method. Equilibrium binding constants of the C-terminal RbcL peptide by AtRbcX proteins were determined by spectrofluorimetric titration. The binding mode of RbcX–RbcL was predicted using molecular dynamic simulation.

Results

We provide crystal structures of both chaperones from Arabidopsis thaliana providing the first structural insight into Rubisco assembly chaperones form higher plants. Despite the low sequence homology of eukaryotic and cyanobacterial Rubisco chaperones the eukaryotic counterparts exhibit surprisingly high similarity of the overall fold to previously determined prokaryotic structures. Modeling studies demonstrate that the overall mode of the binding of RbcL peptide is conserved among these proteins. As such, the evolution of RbcX chaperones is another example of maintaining conserved structural features despite significant drift in the primary amino acid sequence.

General significance

The presented results are the approach to elucidate the role of RbcX proteins in Rubisco assembly in higher plants.     

Activation of interspecies-hybrid Rubisco enzymes to assess different models for the Rubisco–Rubisco activase interaction

Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) is prone to inactivation from non-productive binding of sugar-phosphates. Reactivation of Rubisco requires conformational remodeling by a specific chaperone, Rubisco activase. Rubisco activase from tobacco and other plants in the family Solanaceae is an inefficient activator of Rubisco from non-Solanaceae plants and from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. To determine if the Rubisco small subunit plays a role in the interaction with Rubisco activase, a hybrid Rubisco (SSNT) composed of tobacco small subunits and Chlamydomonas large subunits was constructed. The SSNT hybrid, like other hybrid Rubiscos containing plant small subunits, supported photoautotrophic growth in Chlamydomonas, but growth in air was much slower than for cells containing wild-type Rubisco. The kinetic properties of the SSNT hybrid Rubisco were similar to the wild-type enzyme, indicating that the poor growth in air was probably caused by disruption of pyrenoid formation and the consequent impairment of the CO₂concentrating mechanism. Recombinant Rubisco activase from Arabidopsis activated the SSNT hybrid Rubisco and hybrid Rubiscos containing spinach and Arabidopsis small subunits at rates similar to the rates with wild-type Rubisco. However, none of the hybrid Rubiscos was activated by tobacco Rubisco activase. That replacement of Chlamydomonas small subunits with plant small subunits does not affect the species-specific interaction between Rubisco and Rubisco activase suggests that the association is not dominated by the small subunits that surround the Rubisco central solvent channel. Therefore, the geometry of a side-on binding mode is more consistent with the data than a top-on or ring-stacking binding mode.     

Evolving improved Synechococcus Rubisco functional expression in Escherichia coli

The photosynthetic CO2-fixing enzyme Rubisco [ribulose-P(2) (D-ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate) carboxylase/oxygenase] has long been a target for engineering kinetic improvements. Towards this goal we used an RDE (Rubisco-dependent Escherichia coli) selection system to evolve Synechococcus PCC6301 Form I Rubisco under different selection pressures. In the fastest growing colonies, the Rubisco L (large) subunit substitutions I174V, Q212L, M262T, F345L or F345I were repeatedly selected and shown to increase functional Rubisco expression 4- to 7-fold in the RDE and 5- to 17-fold when expressed in XL1-Blue E. coli. Introducing the F345I L-subunit substitution into Synechococcus PCC7002 Rubisco improved its functional expression 11-fold in XL1-Blue cells but could not elicit functional Arabidopsis Rubisco expression in the bacterium. The L subunit substitutions L161M and M169L were complementary in improving Rubisco yield 11-fold, whereas individually they improved yield approximately 5-fold. In XL1-Blue cells, additional GroE chaperonin enhanced expression of the I174V, Q212L and M262T mutant Rubiscos but engendered little change in the yield of the more assembly-competent F345I or F345L mutants. In contrast, the Rubisco chaperone RbcX stimulated functional assembly of wild-type and mutant Rubiscos. The kinetic properties of the mutated Rubiscos varied with noticeable reductions in carboxylation and oxygenation efficiency accompanying the Q212L mutation and a 2-fold increase in K(ribulose-P2) (K(M) for the substrate ribulose-P2) for the F345L mutant, which was contrary to the approximately 30% reductions in K(ribulose-P2) for the other mutants. These results confirm the RDE systems versatility for identifying mutations that improve functional Rubisco expression in E. coli and provide an impetus for developing the system to screen for kinetic improvements.     

Assembly of in Vitro-Synthesized Large Subunits into Ribulose Bisphosphate Carboxylase/Oxygenase Is Sensitive to CI-, Requires ATP,and Does Not Proceed When Large Subunits Are Synthesized at Temperatures [greater than or equal to]32[deg]C

In higher plants, ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) consists of eight large "L" subunits, synthesized in chloroplasts, and eight small "S" subunits, synthesized as precursors in the cytosol. Assembly of these into holoenzyme occurs in the chloroplast stroma after import and processing of the S subunits. A chloroplast chaperonin interacts with the L subunits, which dissociate from the chaperonin before they assemble into holoenzyme. Our laboratory has reported L subunit assembly into Rubisco in chloroplast extracts after protein synthesis in leaves, intact chloroplasts, and most recently in membrane-free chloroplast extracts. We report here that the incorporation of in vitro-synthesized L subunits into holoenzyme depends on the conditions of L subunit synthesis. Rubisco assembly did not occur after L subunit synthesis at 160 mM KCI. When L subunit synthesis occurred at approximately 70 mM KCI, assembly depended on the temperature at which L subunit synthesis took place. These phenomena were the result of postsynthetic events taking place during incubation for protein synthesis. We separated these events from protein synthesis by lowering the temperature during protein synthesis. Lower temperatures supported the synthesis of full-length Rubisco L subunits. The assembly of these completed L subunits into Rubisco required intervening incubation with ATP, before addition of S subunits. ATP treatment mobilized L subunits from a complex with the chloroplast chaperonin 60 oligomer. Addition of 130 mM KCI at the beginning of the intervening incubation with ATP blocked the incorporation of L subunits into Rubisco. The inhibitory effect of high KCI was due to CI- and came after association of newly synthesized L subunits with chaperonin 60, but before S subunit addition. It is interesting that L subunits synthesized at [greater than or equal to]32[deg]C failed to assemble into Rubisco under any conditions. These results agree with previous results obtained in this laboratory using newly synthesized L subunits made in intact chloroplasts. They also show that assembly of in vitro-synthesized L subunits into Rubisco requires ATP, that CI- inhibits Rubisco assembly, and that synthesis temperature affects subsequent assembly competence of L subunits.     

Role of the small subunit in ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase

Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) catalyzes the rate-limiting step of CO2 fixation in photosynthesis, but O2 competes with CO2 for substrate ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate, leading to the loss of fixed carbon. Interest in genetically engineering improvements in carboxylation catalytic efficiency and CO2/O2 specificity has focused on the chloroplast-encoded large subunit because it contains the active site. However, there is another type of subunit in the holoenzyme of plants, which, like the large subunit, is present in eight copies. The role of these nuclear-encoded small subunits in Rubisco structure and function is poorly understood. Small subunits may have originated during evolution to concentrate large-subunit active sites, but the extensive divergence of structures among prokaryotes, algae, and land plants seems to indicate that small subunits have more-specialized functions. Furthermore, plants and green algae contain families of differentially expressed small subunits, raising the possibility that these subunits may regulate the structure or function of Rubisco. Studies of interspecific hybrid enzymes have indicated that small subunits are required for maximal catalysis and, in several cases, contribute to CO2/O2 specificity. Although small-subunit genetic engineering remains difficult in land plants, directed mutagenesis of cyanobacterial and green-algal genes has identified specific structural regions that influence catalytic efficiency and CO2/O2 specificity. It is thus apparent that small subunits will need to be taken into account as strategies are developed for creating better Rubisco enzymes.     

Small Oligomers of Ribulose-bisphosphate Carboxylase/Oxygenase (Rubisco) Activase Are Required for Biological Activity

Ribulose-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) activase uses the energy from ATP hydrolysis to remove tight binding inhibitors from Rubisco, thus playing a key role in regulating photosynthesis in plants. Although several structures have recently added much needed structural information for different Rubisco activase enzymes, the arrangement of these subunits in solution remains unclear. In this study, we use a variety of techniques to show that Rubisco activase forms a wide range of structures in solution, ranging from monomers to much higher order species, and that the distribution of these species is highly dependent on protein concentration. The data support a model in which Rubisco activase forms an open spiraling structure rather than a closed hexameric structure. At protein concentrations of 1 μm, corresponding to the maximal activity of the enzyme, Rubisco activase has an oligomeric state of 2–4 subunits. We propose a model in which Rubisco activase requires at least 1 neighboring subunit for hydrolysis of ATP.     

Formation of Disulphide Cross-Linked Aggregates of Large Subunit from Higher Plant Ribulose-1, 5-Bisphosphate Carboxylase-Oxygenase

The properties of the large and small subunit polypeptides ofpurified wheat ribulose-1, 5-bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase(Rubisco, E.C. 4.1.1.39 [EC] ) were studied. The protein was dissociatedinto subunits by extreme pH or detergent treatment. The separatedsubunits were unable to reassemble into functional holoproteinwhen the starting conditions were restored. Some of the separatedsmall subunit polypeptides retained their ability to form functionalheterologous Rubisco when mixed with large subunits from a cyanobacterialRubisco. The separated large subunits of wheat Rubisco formednon-functional, high-molecular-weight aggregates. Treatmentwith both sodium dodecyl sulphate and thiol reductant was necessaryto disrupt the aggregated structures, which indicates that thelarge subunits had been cross-linked by disulphide bridges.Since added thiol reductant did not prevent aggregation of theseparated subunits during attempted reconstitution, oxidationof the sulphydryl groups apparently took place on contact facessheltered by the secondary and tertiary structures of the polypeptides.High concentration of large subunits or freezing and thawingof the solution stimulated the formation of disulphide cross-linksbetween the large subunits. The presence of small subunits didnot prevent aggregation of large subunits. The results suggestthat large subunits have a tendency to cross-link with disulphidebridges thus preventing proper assembly with small subunits. Key words: Rubisco, aggregates of large subunit, disulphide cross-linkage, assembly of Rubisco     

Proline suppresses Rubisco activity by dissociating small subunits from holoenzyme

Proline caused irreversible inhibition (involving reduction in V(max) without altering K(m) for RuBP) in Rubisco activity. Proline-induced suppression in Rubisco activity did not exceed beyond approximately 65% of the original activity even upon exposure to higher levels of proline for prolonged duration. However, NaCl-induced reduction in Rubisco activity was reversible. Native PAGE analysis of Rubisco-incubated with proline showed the presence of two distinct bands corresponding to approximately 430 and approximately 28 kDa, but that incubated with NaCl showed a single band. SDS-PAGE analysis revealed that the approximately 430- and approximately 28-kDa bands represent octamers of large subunits and dimers of small subunits, respectively. These results demonstrated for the first time that proline suppresses Rubisco activity by bringing about dissociation of the small subunits from the octamer core of large subunits, probably by weakening hydrophobic interactions between them.     

Isolation of a Protein Containing Covalently Linked Large and Small Subunits of Ribulose-1,5-Bisphosphate Carboxylase/Oxygenase from Botryococcus braunii

Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) and a 66-kD protein were co-purified from solubilized microsomal preparations of the green alga Botryococcus braunii by Green A agarose, sucrose density gradient, MonoQ, and gel filtration. The 66-kD protein remained intact after 6 M urea treatment and sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. It could be detected in the soluble fraction of the cell-free extract but appeared to be more abundant in the microsomal preparations. It cross-reacted with antibodies raised against Rubisco holoenzyme, large and small subunits, indicating that the 66-kD protein contains both the large and the small subunits of Rubisco. The N-terminal amino acid sequence of this protein and that of a proteolytic fragment showed high homology with the mature Rubisco small subunits, and the sequence of another proteolytic fragment showed high homology with that of the Rubisco large subunit. It is concluded that the 66-kD protein is produced by cross-linking of large and small sub-units of Rubisco in the cell.     

Inactivation and dissociation of rice ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase during denaturation by sodium dodecyl sulfate

Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) is a key enzyme in photosynthesis and photorespiration. The inactivation and subsequent conformational changes and dissociation of rice Rubisco by SDS have been studied. At low SDS concentrations (0.4 mM), Rubisco completely lost its carboxylase activity and most of its sulfhydryl groups became exposed. Dissociation of small subunits and significant conformational changes occurred at higher SDS concentrations. Increasing SDS concentrations caused only slight changes in CD spectrum, indicating no significant effect of SDS on the secondary structure of the enzyme. The results prove that the active site of Rubisco is more fragile to denaturants than the protein as a whole. The results also suggest that small subunits are more liable to SDS denaturation and thus dissociate first, while the more hydrophobic large subunits remain complexed. The naturally existing hydrophobic surface of Rubisco may be an important factor in the interaction of Rubisco with other macromolecules.