Control of cell selectivity of antimicrobial peptides

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are promising novel antibiotics, because they exhibit broad antimicrobial spectra and do not easily induce resistance. For clinical applications, it is important to develop potent AMPs with less toxicity against host cells. This review article summarizes the molecular basis for the cell selectivity (bacteria versus host cells) of AMPs and various attempts to control it, including the optimization of physicochemical parameters of peptides, the introduction of d-, fluorinated, and unusual amino acids into peptides, the constraining of peptide conformations, and the modification of peptides by polymers. Pros and cons of these approaches are discussed.     

Designed antimicrobial and antitumor peptides with high selectivity

We report a new class of cationic amphiphilic peptides with short sequences, G(IIKK)(n)I-NH(2) (n = 1-4), that can kill Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria as effectively as several well-known antimicrobial peptides and antibiotics. In addition, some of these peptides possess potent antitumor activities against cancer cell lines. Moreover, their hemolytic activities against human red blood cells (hRBCs) remain remarkably low even at some 10-fold bactericidal minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs). When bacteria or tumor cells are cocultured with NIH 3T3 fibroblast cells, G(IIKK)(3)I-NH(2) showed fast and strong selectivity against microbial or tumor cells, without any adverse effect on NIH 3T3 cells. The high selectivity and associated features are attributed to two design tactics: the use of Ile residues rather than Leu and the perturbation of the hydrophobic face of the helical structure with the insertion of a positively charged Lys residue. This class of simple peptides hence offers new opportunities in the development of cost-effective and highly selective antimicrobial and antitumor peptide-based treatments.     

Membrane interactions of antimicrobial peptides from Australian frogs

The membrane interactions of four antimicrobial peptides, aurein 1.2, citropin 1.1, maculatin 1.1 and caerin 1.1, isolated from Australian tree frogs, are reviewed. All four peptides are amphipathic α-helices with a net positive charge and range in length from 13 to 25 residues. Despite several similar sequence characteristics, these peptides compromise the integrity of model membrane bilayers via different mechanisms; the shorter peptides exhibit a surface interaction mechanism while the longer peptides may form pores in membranes.     

Membrane interactions of antimicrobial peptides from Australian tree frogs

The skin secretions of amphibians are rich in host defence peptides. The membrane interactions of the antimicrobial peptides, aurein 1.2, citropin 1.1 and maculatin 1.1, isolated from Australian tree frogs, are reviewed. Although all three peptides are amphipathic α-helices, the mode of action of these membrane-active peptides is not defined. The peptides have a net positive charge and range in length from 13 to 21 residues, with the longest, maculatin 1.1, having a proline at position 15. Interestingly, alanine substitution at Pro-15 leads to loss of activity. The effects of these peptides on phospholipid bilayers indicate different mechanisms for pore formation and lysis of model membranes, with the shorter peptides exhibiting a carpet-like mechanism and the longest peptide forming pores in phospholipid bilayer membranes.     

Membrane interactions of antimicrobial peptides from Australian tree frogs

The skin secretions of amphibians are rich in host defence peptides. The membrane interactions of the antimicrobial peptides, aurein 1.2, citropin 1.1 and maculatin 1.1, isolated from Australian tree frogs, are reviewed. Although all three peptides are amphipathic alpha-helices, the mode of action of these membrane-active peptides is not defined. The peptides have a net positive charge and range in length from 13 to 21 residues, with the longest, maculatin 1.1, having a proline at position 15. Interestingly, alanine substitution at Pro-15 leads to loss of activity. The effects of these peptides on phospholipid bilayers indicate different mechanisms for pore formation and lysis of model membranes, with the shorter peptides exhibiting a carpet-like mechanism and the longest peptide forming pores in phospholipid bilayer membranes.     

Basis for selectivity of cationic antimicrobial peptides for bacterial versus mammalian membranes

Novel cationic antimicrobial peptides typified by structures such as KKKKKKAAXAAWAAXAA-NH2, where X = Phe/Trp, and several of their analogues display high activity against a variety of bacteria but exhibit no hemolytic activity even at high dose levels in mammalian erythrocytes. To elucidate their mechanism of action and source of selectivity for bacterial membranes, phospholipid mixtures mimicking the compositions of natural bacterial membranes (containing anionic lipids) and mammalian membranes (containing zwitterionic lipids + cholesterol) were challenged with the peptides. We found that peptides readily inserted into bacterial lipid mixtures, although no insertion was detected in model "mammalian" membranes. The depth of peptide insertion into model bacterial membranes was estimated by Trp fluorescence quenching using doxyl groups variably positioned along the phospholipid acyl chains. Peptide antimicrobial activity generally increased with increasing depth of peptide insertion. The overall results, in conjunction with molecular modeling, support an initial electrostatic interaction step in which bacterial membranes attract and bind peptide dimers onto the bacterial surface, followed by the "sinking" of the hydrophobic core segment to a peptide sequence-dependent depth of approximately 2.5-8 A into the membrane, largely parallel to the membrane surface. Antimicrobial activity was likely enhanced by the fact that the peptide sequences contain AXXXA sequence motifs, which promote their dimerization, and possibly higher oligomerization, as assessed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel analysis and fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments. The high selectivity of these peptides for nonmammalian membranes, combined with their activity toward a wide spectrum of Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria and yeast, while retaining water solubility, represent significant advantages of this class of peptides.     

Membrane order perturbation in the presence of antimicrobial peptides by H solid-state NMR spectroscopy

The ²H solid-state NMR spectra of deuterated fatty acyl chains provide direct access to the order of the hydrophobic membrane interior. From the deuterium order parameter profiles of perdeuterated fatty acyl chains the membrane hydrophobic thickness can be calculated. Here we show data obtained from POPC, POPE and mixed POPE/POPG bilayers, representative of bacterial membranes, in the presence of cholesterol or ergosterol and antimicrobial peptaibols. Whereas sterols have a strong ordering effect also on these membranes, the peptides exhibit neutral or disordering effects. By comparing with data from the literature it becomes obvious that cationic amphipathic peptides that probably reside within the interface of phospholipid membranes tend to strongly disorder the packing of the fatty acyl chains, an effect that has been correlated to antimicrobial and DNA transfection activities. In contrast transmembrane sequences or hydrophobic peptides that probably partition deeply into the membrane tend to have only modest disordering activities. The ²H solid-state NMR approach has also been used to monitor the lateral separation of domains rich in anionic phospholipids in the presence of cationic peptides and has thereby provided important insights into their mechanisms of action.     

Cell selectivity and mechanism of action of antimicrobial model peptides containing peptoid residues

To develop a useful method for designing cell-selective antimicrobial peptides and to investigate the effect of incorporating peptoid residues into an alpha-helical model peptide on structure, function, and mode of action, we synthesized a series of model peptides incorporating Nala (Ala-peptoid) into different positions of an amphipathic alpha-helical model peptide (KLW). Incorporation of one or two Nala residues into the hydrophobic helix face of KLW was more effective at disrupting the alpha-helical structure and bacterial cell selectivity than incorporation into the hydrophilic helix face or hydrophobic/hydrophilic interface. Tryptophan fluorescence studies of peptide interaction with model membranes indicated that the cell selectivity of KLW-L9-a and KLW-L9,13-a is closely correlated with their selective interactions with negatively charged phospholipids. KLW-L9,13-a, which has two Nala residues in its hydrophobic helix face, showed a random structure in membrane-mimicking conditions. KLW-L9,13-a exhibited the highest selectivity toward bacterial cells, showing no hemolytic activity and no or less cytotoxicity compared with other peptides against four mammalian cell lines. Unlike other model peptides, KLW-L9,13-a caused no or little membrane depolarization in Staphylococcus aureus or lipid flip-flop in negatively charged vesicles. In addition, KLW-L9,13-a caused very little fluorescent dye leakage from negatively charged vesicles. Furthermore, confocal laser-scanning microscopy and DNA-binding assays showed that KLW-L9,13-a probably exerts its antibacterial action by penetrating the bacterial membrane and binding to cytoplasmic compounds (e.g., DNA), resulting in cell death. Collectively, our results demonstrate that the incorporation of two Nala residues into the central position of the hydrophobic helix face of noncell-selective alpha-helical peptides is a promising strategy for the rational design of intracellular, cell-selective antimicrobial peptides.     

Membrane interactions of designed cationic antimicrobial peptides: the two thresholds

Novel cationic antimicrobial peptides (CAPs) designed in our lab-typified by sequences such as KKKKKKAAX-AAXAAXAA-NH(2), where X = Phe/Trp-display high antibacterial activity but exhibit little or no hemolytic activity towards human red blood cells even at high doses. To clarify the mechanism of their selectivity for bacterial versus mammalian membranes and to increase our understanding of the relationships between primary sequence and bioactivity, a library of derivatives was prepared by increasing segmental hydrophobicity, in which systematic substitutions of Ala for two, three, or four Leu residues were made. Conformationally constrained dimeric and cyclic derivatives were also synthesized. The peptides were examined for activity against pathogenic bacteria (Pseudomonas aeruginosa), hemolytic activity on human red blood cells, and insertion into models of natural bacterial membranes (containing anionic lipids) and mammalian membranes (containing zwitterionic lipids + cholesterol). Results were compared with corresponding properties of the natural CAPs magainin and cecropin. Using circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy, we found that peptide conformation and membrane insertion were sequence dependent, both upon the number of Leu residues, and upon their positions along the hydrophobic core. Membrane disruption was likely enhanced by the fact that the peptides contain potent dimerization-promoting sequence motifs, as assessed by SDS-PAGE gel analysis. The overall results led us to identify distinctions in the mechanism of actions of these CAPs for disruption of bacterial versus mammalian membranes, the latter dependent on surpassing a "second hydrophobicity threshold" for insertion into zwitterionic membranes.     

Prokaryotic selectivity and LPS-neutralizing activity of short antimicrobial peptides designed from the human antimicrobial peptide LL-37

To develop novel antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) with shorter lengths, improved prokaryotic selectivity and retained lipolysaccharide (LPS)-neutralizing activity compared to human cathelicidin AMP, LL-37, a series of amino acid-substituted analogs based on IG-19 (residues 13-31 of LL-37) were synthesized. Among the IG-19 analogs, the analog a4 showed the highest prokaryotic selectivity, but much lower LPS-neutralizing activity compared to parental LL-37. The analogs, a5, a6, a7 and a8 with higher hydrophobicity displayed LPS-neutralizing activity comparable to that of LL-37, but much lesser prokaryotic selectivity. These results indicate that the proper hydrophobicity of the peptides is crucial to exert the amalgamated property of LPS-neutralizing activity and prokaryotic selectivity. Furthermore, to increase LPS-neutralizing activity of the analog a4 without a remarkable decrease in prokaryotic selectivity, we synthesized Trp-substituted analogs (a4-W1 and a4-W2), in which Phe(5) or Phe(15) of a4 is replaced by Trp. Despite their same prokaryotic selectivity, a4-W2 displayed much higher LPS-neutralizing activity compared to a4-W1. When compared with parental LL-37, a4-W2 showed retained LPS-neutralizing activity and 2.8-fold enhanced prokaryotic selectivity. These results suggest that the effective site for Trp-substitution when designing novel AMPs with higher LPS-neutralizing activity, without a remarkable reduction in prokaryotic selectivity, is the amphipathic interface between the end of the hydrophilic side and the start of the hydrophobic side rather than the central position of the hydrophobic side in their α-helical wheel projection. Taken together, the analog a4-W2 can serve as a promising template for the development of therapeutic agents for the treatment of endotoxic shock and bacterial infection.     

Membrane interactions and biological activity of antimicrobial peptides from Australian scorpion

UyCT peptides are antimicrobial peptides isolated from the venom of the Australian scorpion. The activity of the UyCT peptides against Gram positive and Gram negative bacteria and red blood cells was determined. The membrane interactions of these peptides were evaluated by dye release (DR) of the fluorophore calcein from liposomes and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC); and their secondary structure was determined by circular dichroism (CD). Three different lipid systems were used to mimic red blood cells, Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus membranes. UyCT peptides exhibited broad spectrum antimicrobial activity with low MIC for S. aureus and multi-drug resistant Gram negative strains. Peptide combinations showed some synergy enhancing their potency but not hemolytic activity. The UyCT peptides adopted a helical structure in lipid environments and DR results confirmed that the mechanism of action is by disrupting the membrane. ITC data indicated that UyCT peptides preferred prokaryotic rather than eukaryotic membranes. The overall results suggest that UyCT peptides could be pharmaceutical leads for the treatment of Gram negative multiresistant bacterial infections, especially against Acinetobacter baumanni, and candidates for peptidomimetics to enhance their potency and minimize hemolysis. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Interfacially Active Peptides and Proteins. Guest Editors: William C. Wimley and Kalina Hristova.     

Structural determinants of host defense peptides for antimicrobial activity and target cell selectivity

Antimicrobial host defense peptides (HDPs) are a critical component of the innate immunity with microbicidal, endotoxin-neutralizing, and immunostimulatory properties. HDPs kill bacteria primarily through non-specific membrane lysis, therefore with a less likelihood of provoking resistance. Extensive structure–activity relationship studies with a number of HDPs have revealed that net charge, amphipathicity, hydrophobicity, and structural propensity are among the most important physicochemical and structural parameters that dictate their ability to interact with and disrupt membranes. A delicate balance among these factors, rather than a mere alteration of a single factor, is critically important for HDPs to ensure the antimicrobial potency and target cell selectivity. With a better understanding of the structural determinants of HDPs for their membrane-lytic activities, it is expected that novel HDP-based antimicrobials with minimum toxicity to eukaryotic cells can be developed for resistant infections, which have become a global public health crisis.     

Enhanced cell selectivity of hybrid peptides with potential antimicrobial activity and immunomodulatory effect

BackgroundHybridization is a useful strategy to bond the advantages of different peptides into novel constructions. We designed a series of AMPs based on the structures of a synthetic AMP KFA3 and a naturally-occurred host defense peptide substance P (SP) to obtain peptides retaining the high antibacterial activity of KFA3 and the immunomodulatory activity and low cytotoxicity of SP.MethodsTwo repeats of KFA and different C terminal fragments of SP were hybridized, generating a series of novel AMPs (KFSP1–8). The antibacterial activities, host cell toxicity and immunomodulation were measured. The antibacterial mechanisms were investigated.ResultsHybrid peptides KFSP1–4 exerted substantial antibacterial activities against Gram-negative bacteria of standard strains and clinical drug-resistant isolates including E.coli, A.baumannii and P.aeruginosa, while showing little toxicity towards host cells. Compared with KFA3, moderate reduction in α-helix content and the interruption in α-helix continuality were indicated in CD spectra analysis and secondary-structure simulation in these peptides. Membrane permeabilization combined with time-kill studies and FITC-labeled imaging, indicated a selective membrane interaction of KFSP1 with bacteria cell membranes. By specially activating NK1 receptor, the hybrid peptides kept the ability of SP to induce intracellular calcium release and ERK1/2 phosphorylation, but unable to stimulate NF-κB phosphorylation. KFSP1 facilitated the survival of mouse macrophage RAW264.7, directly interacting with LPS and inhibiting the LPS-induced NF-κB phosphorylation and TNF-α expression.ConclusionHybridization is a useful strategy to bond the advantages of different peptides. KFSP1 and its analogs are worth of advanced efforts to explore their potential applications as novel antimicrobial agents.     

Structural determinants of antimicrobial and antiplasmodial activity and selectivity in histidine-rich amphipathic cationic peptides

Designed histidine-rich amphipathic cationic peptides, such as LAH4, have enhanced membrane disruption and antibiotic properties when the peptide adopts an alignment parallel to the membrane surface. Although this was previously achieved by lowering the pH, here we have designed a new generation of histidine-rich peptides that adopt a surface alignment at neutral pH. In vitro, this new generation of peptides are powerful antibiotics in terms of the concentrations required for antibiotic activity; the spectrum of target bacteria, fungi, and parasites; and the speed with which they kill. Further modifications to the peptides, including the addition of more hydrophobic residues at the N terminus, the inclusion of a helix-breaking proline residue or using D-amino acids as building blocks, modulated the biophysical properties of the peptides and led to substantial changes in toxicity to human and parasite cells but had only a minimal effect on the antibacterial and antifungal activity. Using a range of biophysical methods, in particular solid-state NMR, we show that the peptides are highly efficient at disrupting the anionic lipid component of model membranes. However, we also show that effective pore formation in such model membranes may be related to, but is not essential for, high antimicrobial activity by cationic amphipathic helical peptides. The information in this study comprises a new layer of detail in the understanding of the action of cationic helical antimicrobial peptides and shows that rational design is capable of producing potentially therapeutic membrane active peptides with properties tailored to their function.     

Toward insights on antimicrobial selectivity of host defense peptides via machine learning model interpretation

Host defense peptides are promising candidates for the development of novel antibiotics. To realize their therapeutic potential, high levels of target selectivity is essential. This study aims to identify factors governing selectivity via the use of the random forest algorithm for correlating peptide sequence information with their bioactivity data. Satisfactory predictive models were achieved from out-of-bag prediction that yielded accuracies and Matthew's correlation coefficients in excess of 0.80 and 0.57, respectively. Model interpretation through the use of variable importance metrics and partial dependence plots indicated that the selectivity was heavily influenced by the composition and distribution patterns of molecular charge and solubility related parameters. Furthermore, the three investigated bacterial target species (Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus) likely had a significant influence on how selectivity was realized as there appears to be a similar underlying selectivity mechanism on the basis of charge-solubility properties (i.e. but which is tailored according to the target in question).     

The effect of C-terminal amidation on the efficacy and selectivity of antimicrobial and anticancer peptides

Cationic defence peptides show high therapeutic potential as antimicrobial and anticancer agents. Some of these peptides carry a C-terminal amide moiety which has been shown to be required for antimicrobial activity. However, whether this is a general requirement or whether C-terminal amidation is required for the anticancer activity of defence peptides is unclear. In response, this study analyses the toxicity of a series of C-terminally amidated defence peptides and their non-amidated isoforms to normal fibroblast cells, a variety of tumour cells and bacterial cells. The toxicities of these peptides to microbial and cancer cells were generally <200 μM. Peptides were either unaffected by C-terminal amidation or showed up to 10-fold decreases or increases in efficacy. However, these peptides all showed toxicity to normal fibroblast cells with levels (generally <150 μM) that were comparable to those of their antimicrobial and anticancer activities. In contrast to previous claims which have been based on analysis of single amidation events, the results of this study clearly show that the C-terminal amidation of defence peptides has a variable effect on their antimicrobial and anticancer efficacy and no clear effect on their selectivity for these cell types.     

Design and characterization of short antimicrobial peptides using leucine zipper templates with selectivity towards microorganisms

Design of antimicrobial peptides with selective activity towards microorganisms is an important step towards the development of new antimicrobial agents. Leucine zipper sequence has been implicated in cytotoxic activity of naturally occurring antimicrobial peptides; moreover, this motif has been utilized for the design of novel antimicrobial peptides with modulated cytotoxicity. To understand further the impact of substitution of amino acids at ‘a’ and/or ‘d’ position of a leucine zipper sequence of an antimicrobial peptides on its antimicrobial and cytotoxic properties four short peptides (14-residue) were designed on the basis of a leucine zipper sequence without or with replacement of leucine residues in its ‘a’ and ‘d’ positions with d-leucine or alanine or proline residue. The original short leucine zipper peptide (SLZP) and its d-leucine substituted analog, DLSA showed comparable activity against the tested Gram-positive and negative bacteria and the fungal strains. The alanine substituted analog (ASA) though showed appreciable activity against the tested bacteria, it showed to some extent lower activity against the tested fungi. However, the proline substituted analog (PSA) showed lower activity against the tested bacterial or fungal strains. Interestingly, DLSA, ASA and PSA showed significantly lower cytotoxicity than SLZP against both human red blood cells (hRBCs) and murine 3T3 cells. Cytotoxic and bactericidal properties of these peptides matched with peptide-induced damage/permeabilization of mammalian cells and bacteria or their mimetic lipid vesicles suggesting cell membrane could be the target of these peptides. As evidenced by tryptophan fluorescence and acrylamide quenching studies the peptides showed similarities either in interaction or in their localization within the bacterial membrane mimetic negatively charged lipid vesicles. Only SLZP showed localization inside the mammalian membrane mimetic zwitterionic lipid vesicles. The results show significant scope for designing antimicrobial agents with selectivity towards microorganisms by substituting leucine residues at ‘a’ and/or ‘d’ positions of a leucine zipper sequence of an antimicrobial peptide with different amino acids.     

Branched antimicrobial peptides

Branched peptides E(RLAR)2, E[E(RLAR)2]2, E(KLAR)2, and E[E(KLAR)2]2 were synthesized on the basis of tetrapeptides RLAR and KLAR and glutamic acid bis(pentafluorophenyl) ester. Their minimal antimicrobial concentrations were shown to decrease along with increase in branching, achieving 12 microM for Escherichia coli cells, which is comparable to antimicrobial activities of temporin, magainin, and dermaseptin. The branched peptides were found not to act on human erythrocytes.     

Branched antimicrobial peptides

Branched peptides E(RLAR)₂, E[E(RLAR)₂]₂, and E(KLAR)₂, E[E(KLAR)₂]₂ were synthesized on the basis of tetrapeptides RLAR and KLAR and glutamic acid bis(pentafluorophenyl) ester. Their minimal antimicrobial concentrations were shown to decrease along with increase in branching, achieving 12 μM for Escherichia coli cells, which is comparable to antimicrobial activities of temporin, magainin, and dermaseptin. The branched peptides were found not to act on human erythrocytes.     

Plant antimicrobial peptides

Plant antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are a component of barrier defense system of plants. They have been isolated from roots, seeds, flowers, stems, and leaves of a wide variety of species and have activities towards phytopathogens, as well as against bacteria pathogenic to humans. Thus, plant AMPs are considered as promising antibiotic compounds with important biotechnological applications. Plant AMPs are grouped into several families and share general features such as positive charge, the presence of disulfide bonds (which stabilize the structure), and the mechanism of action targeting outer membrane structures.