Comparative analysis of tubulin sequences

1. Information on the structure and evolution of tubulin has been obtained by comparing the available sequence data on 31 alpha-tubulins and 31 beta-tubulins. 2. Similar numbers of conserved amino acids are found amongst both alpha- and beta-tubulins (alpha: 48%, plus conservative substitutions: 72%; beta: 48%, plus conservative substitutions: 70%). About half of them are common to both subunits (23%, plus conservative substitutions: 45%). Four cysteines in the alpha-tubulins and 2 cysteines in the beta-tubulins are conserved. Only one cysteine (position 129) is conserved in all alpha- and beta-tubulins. 3. The longest unbroken stretch of identical amino acids between all the alpha- and beta-tubulins is found in positions 180-186 (Val-Val-Glu-Pro-Tyr-Asn), a region that appears to be important for binding the ribose moiety of GTP. Two other groups of amino acids implicated in GTP binding, one near position 70 and a glycine cluster at position 144 are also quite conserved. 4. Extra length differences between tubulin subunits, presumably present as extensions on the dimer surface, have been observed at position 50 and near position 360 in alpha-tubulins and in one case at position 57 in a beta-tubulin. 5. The introns of tubulin genes, many of them clustered in the first quarter of the tubulin coding region, do not appear to correspond to any particular structural or functional regions. 6. Mutation rates of tubulins vary considerably. The lowest alpha-tubulin homology (62.3%) is between a very divergent Drosophila alpha-tubulin and an alpha-tubulin from the yeast S. cerevisiae. The lowest beta-tubulin homology (63.3%) is between a yeast (S. cerevisiae) beta-tubulin and a mouse beta-tubulin expressed in hematopoietic tissue. In contrast, some mammalian and bird tubulins are almost identical. 7. Tubulin's heterogeneous C-termini are useful for identifying corresponding tubulins of different vertebrate species, many of which are remarkably conserved. Exceptions are the divergent beta-tubulins of erythrocyte and thrombocyte marginal bands. 8. We have proposed a model for tubulin evolution in metazoan organisms in which the release of structural constraints after gene duplication is a major cause of relatively rapid change.     

Alpha/beta inversion of the Euplotes and Oxytricha tubulins.

Immunoblotting studies, using a polyclonal antibody specific for the alpha-tubulin of ciliates and an anti-beta-tubulin monoclonal antibody, demonstrated that the tubulins of the ciliates Euplotes and Oxytricha show alpha/beta inversion although less accentuated than that observed in Paramecium and Tetrahymena. Results suggest that (a) the alpha/beta inversion may be a common characteristic within the Phylum Ciliophora; and (b) the electrophoretic behaviour of the alpha-tubulin may be useful for establishing evolutionary relatedness between the ciliates.     

Acetylation of lysine 40 in alpha-tubulin is not essential in Tetrahymena thermophila

In Tetrahymena, at least 17 distinct microtubule structures are assembled from a single primary sequence type of alpha- and beta- tubulin heterodimer, precluding distinctions among microtubular systems based on tubulin primary sequence isotypes. Tetrahymena tubulins also are modified by several types of posttranslational reactions including acetylation of alpha-tubulin at lysine 40, a modification found in most eukaryotes. In Tetrahymena, axonemal alpha-tubulin and numerous other microtubules are acetylated. We completely replaced the single type of alpha-tubulin gene in the macronucleus with a version encoding arginine instead of lysine 40 and therefore cannot be acetylated at this position. No acetylated tubulin was detectable in these transformants using a monoclonal antibody specific for acetylated lysine 40. Surprisingly, mutants lacking detectable acetylated tubulin are indistinguishable from wild-type cells. Thus, acetylation of alpha- tubulin at lysine 40 is non-essential in Tetrahymena. In addition, isoelectric focusing gel analysis of axonemal tubulin from cells unable to acetylate alpha-tubulin leads us to conclude that: (a) most or all ciliary alpha-tubulin is acetylated, (b) other lysines cannot be acetylated to compensate for loss of acetylation at lysine 40, and (c) acetylated alpha-tubulin molecules in wild-type cells contain one or more additional charge-altering modifications.     

Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (Glomeromycota) harbour ancient fungal tubulin genes that resemble those of the chytrids (Chytridiomycota)

The genes encoding alpha- and beta-tubulins have been widely sampled in most major fungal phyla and they are useful tools for fungal phylogeny. Here, we report the first isolation of alpha-tubulin sequences from arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF). In parallel, AMF beta-tubulins were sampled and analysed to identify the presence of paralogs of this gene. The AMF alpha-tubulin amino acid phylogeny was congruent with the results previously reported for AMF beta-tubulins and showed that AMF tubulins group together at a basal position in the fungal clade and showed high sequence similarities with members of the Chytridiomycota. This is in contrast with phylogenies for other regions of the AMF genome. The amount and nature of substitutions are consistent with an ancient divergence of both orthologs and paralogs of AMF tubulins. At the amino acid level, however, AMF tubulins have hardly evolved from those of the chytrids. This is remarkable given that these two groups are ancient and the monophyletic Glomeromycota probably diverged from basal fungal ancestors at least 500 million years ago. The specific primers we designed for the AMF tubulins, together with the high molecular variation we found among the AMF species we analysed, make AMF tubulin sequences potentially useful for AMF identification purposes.     

Localization of a highly divergent mammalian testicular alpha tubulin that is not detectable in brain.

Sequence analysis of a mouse testicular alpha-tubulin partial cDNA, pRD alpha TT1, reveals an isotype that differs from both the somatic and the predominant testicular alpha tubulins at approximately 30% of the 212 amino acid residues determined. Although this mouse testicular cDNA retains the highly conserved sequence, Glu-Gly-Glu-Glu, found in the carboxyl termini of many alpha tubulins, the protein extends substantially beyond this sequence and does not terminate with a C-terminal tyrosine. Using rabbit antiserum prepared to a novel synthetic peptide predicted from this mouse testis alpha-tubulin cDNA, we have have detected by immunoblot and indirect immunofluorescence an antigenic epitope present in testicular alpha tubulin that is not detectable in brain alpha tubulins. We find that the antiserum specifically binds to the manchettes and meiotic spindles of the mouse testis but not with neural fibers or tubulin extracts of the adult mouse brain. These results demonstrate that at least one of the multiple alpha-tubulin isotypes of the mammalian testis is expressed and used in male germ cells but not in the brain.     

Amino acid sequence data of alpha-tubulin from myxamoebae of Physarum polycephalum

About 96% of the amino acid sequence of an alpha-tubulin from the slime mould Physarum polycephalum has been determined. Of 430 sequenced amino acids, 30 differ from the deduced amino acid sequence of a recently published alpha-tubulin complementary DNA from the plasmodial form of P. polycephalum. The myxamoebal alpha-tubulin differs from all other known alpha-tubulins in one of the last three C-terminal amino acids that are Gly-Glu-Tyr instead of the usual Glu-Glu-Tyr. These last three amino acids are preceded by 11 residues that appear to be particularly susceptible to mutation. No heterogeneity was found whilst sequencing the myxamoebal alpha-tubulin, indicating that only one type of alpha-tubulin is present in myxamoebae. This alpha-tubulin appears to be less conserved than the previously described plasmodial alpha-tubulin, supporting the hypothesis that the structural constraints on tubulin in axonemes have a significant effect on its rate of mutation.     

Pig sperm tail tubulin. Its extraction and characterization

Axonemal tubulin extracted from pig sperm tails has been characterized by one- and two-dimensional electrophoresis and by one-dimensional peptide mapping. The electrophoretic mobilities of its subunits after reduction and carboxymethylation were similar to those of the major subunits of pig brain tubulin. Sperm tail tubulin subunits also had roughly the same isoelectric points as pig brain tubulin subunits, except that they appeared to have a relatively larger tailing effect. The proteolytic cleavage pattern of the pig sperm tail beta-tubulin closely resembled those of both the tunicate (Ciona intestinalis) sperm beta-tubulin and pig brain beta-tubulin. The peptide pattern of pig sperm tail alpha-tubulin, however, was more similar to that of tunicate sperm tail alpha-tubulin than to that of pig brain alpha-tubulin. This supports the hypothesis put forward in a previous investigation [1] that functionally similar tubulins from taxonomically distant species can be more related than functionally dissimilar tubulins from the same species.     

Posttranslational modification of brain tubulins from the Antarctic fish Notothenia coriiceps: reduced C-terminal glutamylation correlates with efficient microtubule assembly at low temperature

We have shown previously that the tubulins of Antarctic fish assemble into microtubules efficiently at low temperatures (-2 to +2 degrees C) due to adaptations intrinsic to the tubulin subunits. To determine whether changes in posttranslational glutamylation of the fish tubulins may contribute to cold adaptation of microtubule assembly, we have characterized C-terminal peptides from alpha- and beta-tubulin chains from brains of adult specimens of the Antarctic rockcod Notothenia coriiceps by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry and by Edman degradation amino acid sequencing. Of the four fish beta-tubulin isotypes, nonglutamylated isoforms were more abundant than glutamylated isoforms. In addition, maximal glutamyl side-chain length was shorter than that observed for mammalian brain beta tubulins. For the nine fish alpha-tubulin isotypes, nonglutamylated isoforms were also generally more abundant than glutamylated isoforms. When glutamylated, however, the maximal side-chain lengths of the fish alpha tubulins were generally longer than those of adult rat brain alpha chains. Thus, Antarctic fish adult brain tubulins are glutamylated differently than mammalian brain tubulins, resulting in a more heterogeneous population of alpha isoforms and a reduction in the number of beta isoforms. By contrast, neonatal rat brain tubulin possesses low levels of glutamylation that are similar to that of the adult fish brain tubulins. We suggest that unique residue substitutions in the primary structures of Antarctic fish tubulin isotypes and quantitative changes in isoform glutamylation act synergistically to adapt microtubule assembly to low temperatures.     

Congruent evidence from alpha-tubulin and beta-tubulin gene phylogenies for a zygomycete origin of microsporidia

The origin of microsporidia and the evolutionary relationships among the major lineages of fungi have been examined by molecular phylogeny using alpha-tubulin and beta-tubulin. Chytrids, basidiomycetes, ascomycetes, and microsporidia were all recovered with high support, and the zygomycetes were consistently paraphyletic. The microsporidia were found to branch within zygomycetes, and showed relationships with members of the Entomophthorales and Zoopagales. This provides support for the microsporidia having evolved from within the fungi, however, the tubulin genes are difficult to interpret unambiguously since fungal and microsporidian tubulins are very divergent. Rapid evolutionary rates a characteristic of practically all microsporidian genes studied, so determining their evolutionary history will never be completely free of such difficulties. While the tubulin phylogenies do not provide a decisive conclusion, they do further narrow the probable origin of microsporidia to a zygomycete-like ancestor.     

Microtubule diversity in ciliated cells: evidence for its generation by post-translational modification in the axonemes of Paramecium and quail oviduct cells.

The diversity of microtubular networks was analyzed in quail oviduct and in Paramecium cells using conventional and confocal immunofluorescence as well as pre- and post-embedding EM immunocytochemistry with a variety of anti-tubulin antibodies. The 6-11B-1 monoclonal antibody, specific for the post-translational acetylation of Lys 40 of alpha-tubulin, and a polyclonal antibody raised against Paramecium axonemal tubulin (anti-PA tubulin antibody) both decorated stable microtubular arrays in Paramecium ie ciliary axonemes and a set of microtubular bundles associated with the cortex, suggesting that the two antibodies may be directed against the same epitope. However, several differences in the immunocytological patterns yielded by each antibody on the two cell types were evident. For example, in quail, as in all other Metazoa, the anti-PA tubulin antibody only decorated axonemes enclosed in normal ciliary membrane while it was unreactive on cytoplasmic tubulins. Immunoblotting of peptide maps of axonemal tubulins demonstrated that the epitopes of the two antibodies were indeed completely different. Double immunolabelling of dividing paramecia using a universal anti-tubulin antibody and the anti-PA tubulin one revealed that all newly assembled microtubular arrays were first detected by the universal antibody and, only shortly afterwards, by the anti-PA tubulin one. This provided a strong indication that the anti-PA tubulin antibody is directed against a post-translational modification taking place on already assembled microtubules (MTs) (as previously known to be the case for acetylation and detyrosination). In taxol-treated quail cells undergoing ciliogenesis, massive assembly of MTs and even axonemes occurred in the cytoplasm. These MTs were not decorated by the anti-PA tubulin antibody however, suggesting that in Metazoa the post-translational modification can only take place within the ciliary lumen. The present work provides one further mechanism for generating MT immunological and biochemical diversity post-translationally; this may account for the high multiplicity of tubulin isoforms observed in ciliates which contain very little if any genetic diversity of tubulin genes.     

八肋游仆虫微管蛋白基因家族的鉴定及进化分析

为了系统分析八肋游仆虫(Euplotes octocarinatus)微管蛋白基因家族,从八肋游仆虫大核基因组中共鉴定得到20个微管蛋白基因,基于同源比对及系统进化分析,将其归入α、β、γ、δ、ε及η六个微管蛋白亚家族;多序列比对及Western blot结果显示八肋游仆虫η微管蛋白基因在翻译过程中需发生一次+1位编程性核糖体移码,其移码位点为AAA-TAA;所有自由生纤毛虫都含有多个α和β微管蛋白基因亚型,可能用于组成不同的微管结构。研究为后续深入探讨八肋游仆虫微管蛋白的生物学功能及微管多样性奠定了基础。     

Direct measurement of tubulin and bulk message distributions on polysomes of growing, starved and deciliated Tetrahymena using RNA gel blots of sucrose gradients containing acrylamide.

A method was developed using sucrose gradients containing acrylamide which greatly simplifies the measurement of the polysomal distribution of messages. After centrifugation, the acrylamide was polymerized, forming a "polysome gel". RNA gel blots of polysome gels were used to determine the polysomal distributions of alpha-tubulin and total polyadenylated mRNA in growing, starved (nongrowing) and starved-deciliated Tetrahymena and the number of messages loaded onto polysomes was calculated. These measurements indicated that the translational efficiencies of alpha-tubulin mRNA and total polyadenylated mRNA are largely unaffected when the rates of tubulin and total protein synthesis vary dramatically. Thus, differential regulation of alpha-tubulin mRNA translation initiation does not contribute to the greater than 100-fold induction of tubulin synthesis observed during cilia regeneration and in growing cells. The major translation-level process regulating tubulin synthesis in Tetrahymena appears to be a change in message loading mediated by a non-specific message recruitment or unmasking factor.     

Tubulin evolution: Ciliate-specific epitopes are conserved in the ciliary tubulin of metazoa

Summary In spite of their overall evolutionary conservation, the tubulins of ciliates display electrophoretic and structural particularities. We show here that antibodies raised againstParamecium andTetrahymena ciliary tubulins fail to recognize the cytoplasmic tubulins of all the metazoans tested. Immunoblotting of peptide maps of ciliate tubulins reveals that these antibodies react with one or very few ciliate-specific epitopes, in contrast to polyclonal antibodies against vertebrate tubulins, which are equivalent to autoantibodies and recognize several epitopes in both ciliate and vertebrate tubulins. Furthermore, we show that the anti-ciliate antibodies recognize ciliary and flagellar tubulins of metazoans ranging from sea urchin to mammals (with the exception of humans). The results support the conclusion that although duplication and specialization of tubulin genes in metazoans may have led to distinct types of tubulins, the axonemal one has remained highly conserved.     

Rates of molecular evolution and the fraction of nucleotide positions free to vary

Summary Selective constraints on DNA sequence change were incorporated into a model of DNA divergence by restricting substitutions to a subset of nucleotide positions. A simple model showed that both mutation rate and the fraction of nucleotide positions free to vary are strong determinants of DNA divergence over time.When divergence between two species approaches the fraction of positions free to vary, standard methods that correct for multiple mutations yield severe underestimates of the number of substitutions per site. A modified method appropriate for use with DNA sequence, restriction site, or thermal renaturation data is derived taking this fraction into account. The model also showed that the ratio of divergence in two gene classes (e.g., nuclear and mitochondrial) may vary widely over time even if the ratio of mutation rates remains constant.DNA sequence divergence data are used increasingly to detect differences in rates of molecular evolution. Often, variation in divergence rate is assumed to represent variation in mutation rate. The present model suggests that differing divergence rates among comparisons (either among gene classes or taxa) should be interpreted cautiously. Differences in the fraction of nucleotide positions free to vary can serve as an important alternative hypothesis to explain differences in DNA divergence rates.     

Identification and characterization of axopodial tubulins from Echinosphaerium nucleofilum

Isolated microtubule protein from axopodia of the heliozoan Echinosphaerium nucleofilum, consisting of two major bands on SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE), has been compared to axonemal and cytoplasmic tubulins from both animal and non-animal sources. The upper E. nucleofilum protein band migrated faster than the alpha-tubulins of bovine brain and sea anemone sperm tails but with approximately the same electrophoretic mobility as the axonemal alpha-tubulins of Tetrahymena pyriformis and the alga Chlorogonium elongatum and cytoplasmic alpha-tubulin from the slime mold Physarum polycephalum. The lower E. nucleofilum protein band, however, had a higher electrophoretic mobility than all the beta-tubulins which we have so far examined. It was, nevertheless, a true beta-tubulin as shown by its migration on two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and the general resemblance of its one- and two-dimensional peptide maps to those of other beta-tubulins. The Staphylococcus aureus protease cleavage pattern of the upper axopodial protein band was similar to those of other non-animal alpha-tubulins but quite different from those of the animal alpha-tubulins. In contrast, the two-dimensional tryptic peptide map of axopodial alpha-tubulin was distinct from all of them. For example, a characteristic constellation of peptides common to the peptide maps of the other alpha-tubulins was absent from that of E. nucleofilum. In contrast to Physarum and metazoan tubulins but similar to Tetrahymena tubulin, the axopodial alpha-tubulin had a more basic isoelectric point than the beta-subunit as shown by two dimensional gel electrophoresis. Some of the unusual characteristics of E. nucleofilum axopodial tubulin may not only reflect phylogenetic variation, but also the different functional requirements of axopodial microtubules.     

Characterization of the cold-adapted alpha-tubulin from the psychrophilic ciliate Euplotes focardii

Tubulin dimers of psychrophilic organisms can polymerize into microtubules at temperatures below 4 degrees C, at which non-cold-adapted microtubules disassemble. This capacity requires specificities in the structure and/or in the posttranslational modifications of the tubulin subunits. A contribution to the knowledge of these specificities was provided by the finding that the amino acid sequence of the alpha-tubulin of the Antarctic ciliate Euplotes focardii contains substitutions that, in addition to conferring an increased hydrophobicity to the molecule, modify sites that are involved in alpha-/alpha-tubulin lateral contacts between protofilaments. At the level of the coding sequence, the alpha-tubulin gene of E. focardii revealed an A+T content appreciably higher than in its homologs in ciliates of temperate waters. This was interpreted as an adaptation to favor DNA strand separation in an environment which is energetically adverse.