Supercooling Capacity Increases from Sea Level to Tree Line in the Hawaiian Tree Species Metrosideros polymorpha

Population-specific differences in the freezing resistance of Metrosideros polymorpha leaves were studied along an elevational gradient from sea level to tree line (located at ca. 2500 m above sea level) on the east flank of the Mauna Loa volcano in Hawaii. In addition, we also studied 8-yr-old saplings grown in a common garden from seeds collected from the same field populations. Leaves of low-elevation field plants exhibited damage at -2 degrees C, before the onset of ice formation, which occurred at -5.7 degrees C. Leaves of high-elevation plants exhibited damage at ca. -8.5 degrees C, concurrent with ice formation in the leaf tissue, which is typical of plants that avoid freezing in their natural environment by supercooling. Nuclear magnetic resonance studies revealed that water molecules of both extra- and intracellular leaf water fractions from high-elevation plants had restricted mobility, which is consistent with their low water content and their high levels of osmotically active solutes. Decreased mobility of water molecules may delay ice nucleation and/or ice growth and may therefore enhance the ability of plant tissues to supercool. Leaf traits that correlated with specific differences in supercooling capacity were in part genetically determined and in part environmentally induced. Evidence indicated that lower apoplastic water content and smaller intercellular spaces were associated with the larger supercooling capacity of the plant's foliage at tree line. The irreversible tissue-damage temperature decreased by ca. 7 degrees C from sea level to tree line in leaves of field populations. However, this decrease appears to be only large enough to allow M. polymorpha trees to avoid leaf tissue damage from freezing up to a level of ca. 2500 m elevation, which is also the current tree line location on the east flank of Mauna Loa. The limited freezing resistance of M. polymorpha leaves may be partially responsible for the occurrence of tree line at a relatively low elevation in Hawaii compared with continental tree lines, which can be up to 1500 m higher. If the elevation of tree line is influenced by the inability of M. polymorpha leaves to supercool to lower subzero temperatures, then it will be the first example that freezing damage resulting from limited supercooling capacity can be a factor in tree line formation.     

Cryopreservation of boar semen: equilibrium freezing in the cryomicroscope and in straws

Supercooling causes very abrupt temperature and osmotic changes and can thus lead to freezing damage. Supercooling can be prevented by seeding, using a sample volume and geometry that allows rapid spreading of the ice throughout the sample. In a split-sample comparison of such samples on the cooling stage of a cryomicroscope and seeded at -5 and -15 degrees C, respectively, the percentages of membrane-intact sperm and sperm with acrosomes with a 'normal apical ridge' (NAR) were 72.5+/-3.8 and 75.8+/-2.0 versus 46.3+/-4.8 and 36.0+/-3.7 (means+/-S.E.M., n=4). In ejaculates of 15 unselected AI boars, after seeding at -5 degrees C, the post-thaw % live and % NAR were 66.3+/-10.4 and 74.8+/-7.5, respectively. Our present research is aimed at translating these findings to freezing in straws and at a high sperm concentration. We have designed a novel type of freezing apparatus for controlled-rate freezing of straws, in which supercooling can be effectively prevented in the entire straw. In a split-sample comparison of semen frozen in straws at a sperm concentration of 1.5 x 10(9) cells/ml with nine ejaculates from eight unselected AI boars, we found 54.8+/-1.9% versus 40.7+/-1.7% (means+/-S.E.M.) membrane-intact sperm for the new apparatus and a conventional freezing apparatus, respectively. With bull semen (eight ejaculates from six bulls), we obtained 67.3+/-3.0% versus 59.3+/-2.9% (means+/-S.E.M.) membrane-intact sperm for the new apparatus and conventional freezing, respectively. Additionally, the temperature curve after ice nucleation is of great importance. We have developed a model that allows us to predict that optimal cryopreservation requires a non-linear cooling curve in which the cooling rate varies as a function of subzero temperature.     

Freezing avoidance by supercooling in Olea europaea cultivars: the role of apoplastic water,solute content and cell wall rigidity

Plants can avoid freezing damage by preventing extracellular ice formation below the equilibrium freezing temperature (supercooling). We used Olea europaea cultivars to assess which traits contribute to avoid ice nucleation at sub‐zero temperatures. Seasonal leaf water relations, non‐structural carbohydrates, nitrogen and tissue damage and ice nucleation temperatures in different plant parts were determined in five cultivars growing in the Patagonian cold desert. Ice seeding in roots occurred at higher temperatures than in stems and leaves. Leaves of cold acclimated cultivars supercooled down to ?13 °C, substantially lower than the minimum air temperatures observed in the study site. During winter, leaf ice nucleation and leaf freezing damage (LT₅₀) occurred at similar temperatures, typical of plant tissues that supercool. Higher leaf density and cell wall rigidity were observed during winter, consistent with a substantial acclimation to sub‐zero temperatures. Larger supercooling capacity and lower LT₅₀ were observed in cold‐acclimated cultivars with higher osmotically active solute content, higher tissue elastic adjustments and lower apoplastic water. Irreversible leaf damage was only observed in laboratory experiments at very low temperatures, but not in the field. A comparative analysis of closely related plants avoids phylogenetic independence bias in a comparative study of adaptations to survive low temperatures.     

Expression of a beetle, Dendroides canadensis, antifreeze protein in Drosophila melanogaster

Antifreeze protein 1 (DAFP-1), from the beetle Dendroides canadensis, was expressed in Drosophila melanogaster. Mean thermal hysteresis values (the difference between freezing and melting points), indicative of antifreeze protein activity, in the hemolymph of transgenic flies were found to be as high as 6.23+/-0.10 degrees C (using the nanoliter osmometer). Direct comparisons of the capillary and nanoliter osmometer techniques for measuring THA were made, illustrating the much higher values obtained by the latter. Transgenic Drosophila had supercooling points, both in contact with ice and not, that were slightly, but significantly, lower than wild-type controls (1.5-2.0 degrees C and 2.0-4.0 degrees C, respectively). The results indicate functionality of DAFP-1 in Drosophila melanogaster (the ability of DAFP-1 to inhibit both inoculative freezing across the cuticle and freezing initiated by endogenous ice nucleators). The much larger effects of DAFPs in inhibiting inoculative freezing and ice nucleation in Dendroides canadensis relative to the transgenic Drosophila may partially result from the lower DAFP concentrations and activities in Drosophila, however the absence of multiple types of DAFPs and absence of tissue specific expression may also contribute. Transgenic Drosophila were also able to live significantly longer than controls at 0 degrees C and 4 degrees C, indicating that DAFP-1 is able to increase cold tolerance at above freezing temperatures.     

Antifreeze glycoproteins: influence of polymer length and ice crystal habit on activity

The effect of the ice crystalline habit and the length of the polymer on the ability of the antifreeze glycoproteins (AFGP) from polar fish to depress the freezing temperature of water was investigated. The low-molecular-weight components of the glycoproteins, AFGP- 6–8, are inactive when a solution of such a sample is nucleated at ?6°C. A solution of large AFGP (1–4) is fully functional under the same conditions. The low-molecular-weight components differ from the height-molecular-weight components in that they contain some proline replacing the alanine in the Ala-Ala-Thr · disaccharide polymer unit. In the present experiments, antifreeze activity was examined in the presence of two different forms of ice crystal growth habits, and homodimders of AFGP 6 and 8 were prepared to investigate the function of polymer length and the on antifreeze activity at different degrees of supercooling. The results indicate that the ice crystal growth habit and the introduction of proline into the polymer unit may be responsible for the loss of activity at deep supercooling (?6°C) of AFGP 6–8. The loss in the ability of AFGP to depress the freezing temperature of water at deep supercooling is not solely due to polymer length, as carbodiimide-linked dimers of AFGP 6 do not function under these freezing conditions. A Model of antifreezing action based on Langmuirian adsorption of AFGP on the ice surface and direct competition between water and AFGP molecules for the incorporation sites in the ice crystal lattice is presented.     

Energy and water conservation in frozen vs. supercooled larvae of the goldenrod gall fly, Eurosta solidaginis (fitch) (Diptera: Tephritidae)

Insects that tolerate severe cold during winter may either supercool or tolerate ice forming within the tissues of the body. To compare the relative advantages of freezing and supercooling, we measured rates of CO(2) production and water loss in frozen and supercooled goldenrod gall fly larvae (Eurosta solidaginis). As an important first step, we measured the time required for ice content and metabolic rate to stabilize upon freezing. Ice content stabilized after only three hours of freezing at -5 degrees C, whereas CO(2) production required 12 hours to stabilize. Subsequent experiments found that freezing greatly reduced both water loss and metabolic rate. Comparisons of supercooled and frozen larvae at -5 degrees C indicated that CO(2) production fell 47% with freezing and water loss decreased 35%. As temperature decreased to -10 and -15 degrees C, CO(2) production fell exponentially and was no longer detectable at -20 degrees C with our measurement system. Our results demonstrate that freezing significantly reduces energy consumption during the winter and may therefore improve winter survival and spring fecundity. The advantages of freezing over supercooling would drive selection toward insect freeze tolerance and also toward higher supercooling points to increase the duration of freezing each winter.     

Contribution of extracellular ice formation and the solution effects to the freezing injury of PC-3 cells suspended in NaCl solutions

The mechanism of cell injury during slow freezing was examined using PC-3 human prostate adenocarcinoma cells suspended in NaCl solutions. The objective was to evaluate contribution of extracellular ice and the 'solution effects' to freezing injury separately. The solution effects that designate the influence of elevated concentration were evaluated from a pseudo-freezing experiment, where cells were subjected to the milieu that simulated a freeze-thaw process by changing the NaCl concentration and the temperature at the same time. The effect of extracellular ice formation on cell injury was then estimated from the difference in cell survival between the pseudo-freezing experiment and a corresponding freezing experiment. When cells were frozen to a relatively higher freezing temperature at -10 degrees C, about 30% of cells were damaged mostly due to extracellular ice formation, because the concentration increase without ice formation to 2.5-M NaCl, i.e., the equilibrium concentration at -10 degrees C, had no effect on cell survival. In contrast, in the case of the lower freezing temperature at -20 degrees C, about 90% of cells were injured by both effects, particularly 60-80% by the solution effects among them. The present results suggested that the solution effects become more crucial to cell damage during slow freezing at lower temperatures, while the effect of ice is limited to some extent.     

Chlorophyll fluorescence monitoring of freezing point exotherms in leaves.

Following supercooling prompt chlorophyll fluorescence and delayed fluorescence from leaves undergo transients simultaneous with the freezing point exotherm. The degree of supercooling and, hence, the temperature at which the exotherm occurs is dependent upon the leaf water content.Winter wheat leaves (Triticum aestivum L.) that had the lowest water content (hardened “Kharkov”) supercooled to a greater degree than those leaves with a higher water content (hardened “Rescue” and unhardened “Kharkov” or “Rescue”).Seeding the leaves with ice increased the temperature at which the exotherm occurred and decreased the difference between varities but not between hardened and unhardened material. Our results suggest that freeze-avoidance via supercooling may be one mechanism in winter wheat for withstanding subfreezing temperatures.     

Multiple stress tolerance in an antarctic terrestrial arthropod: Belgica antarctica

Terrestrial arthropods of the maritime Antarctic experience a diverse range of environmental Stressors including extended periods of ice and snow cover, anoxia, immersion in water of variable pH and salinity, and extensive habitat drying. The collembolan Cryptopygus antarcticus and the mite Alaskozetes antarcticus seasonally depress whole body supercooling points to avoid the lethal effects of freezing. Alternatively, the wingless chironomid Belgica antarctica has a relatively limited supercooling capacity (between −6 and −8 °C) and tolerates extracellular freezing. The lower limit of freeze tolerance remains unchanged near −13 °C throughout the year in B. antarctica. Summer larvae tolerate dehydration to a limit of 35% of initial body weight as well as extended periods of anoxia and immersion in freshwater and saltwater. Two weeks of exposure to variable pH (3–12) induced no mortality.     

Cold tolerance of hatched and unhatched second stage juveniles of the potato cyst-nematode Globodera rostochiensis

Perry R. N. and Wharton D. A. 1985. Cold tolerance of hatched and unhatched second stage juveniles of the potato cyst-nematode, Globodera rostochiensis. International Journal for Parasitology15: 441–445. Hatched second-stage juveniles of Globodera rostochiensis can survive sub-zero temperatures by supercooling when not in contact with water. When frozen in water free juveniles cannot survive ice seeding across the cuticle and concomitant freezing of their body contents. Unhatched juveniles can survive in water, probably because the egg-shell protects the juvenile from ice seeding across from the medium; in this state juveniles survive by supercooling.     

Metastable states of water and ice during pressure-supported freezing of potato tissue

Different ice modifications were obtained during freezing processes at several pressure levels from atmospheric pressure up to 300 MPa. In the pressure range between 210 and 240 MPa, a metastable ice I modification area was observed, as the nucleation of ice I crystals in the thermodynamically stable region of ice III was reached. A significant degree of supercooling was obtained before freezing the tissue water to ice III, which has to be considered when designing pressure-supported freezing processes. The effect of supercooling phenomenon on the phase transition time is discussed using a mathematical model based on the solution of the heat transfer governing differential equations. Phase transition and freezing times for the different freezing paths experimented are compared for the processes: freezing at atmospheric pressure, pressure-assisted freezing, and pressure-shift freezing. Different metastable states of liquid water are defined according to their process-dependent stability.     

Effect of temperature on cold-hardiness and tissue ice formation in the adult chrysomelid beetle Melasoma collaris L

The freeze-tolerant chrysomelid beetle Melasoma collaris overwinters in plant litter on windswept ridges or covered with snow for 8-9 months in the Norwegian alpine region. Lower lethal temperature, supercooling and melting point depression were correlated to accumulation of glycerol. The lower limit of freeze tolerance was associated with the freezing of 73-75% body water. About 23-15.5% of the body water was osmotically inactive, and the highest percentage was revealed in individuals depleted of glycerol at 21 degrees C. A shift in cooling rate from 1 degrees Cmin(-1) to 1 degrees C every 13.5min lowered nucleating temperature markedly. The alteration in nucleating activity probably arises from the structure of the haemolymph nucleating agent that functions to slow embryo growth at the slow cooling rate. An enhanced supercooling is particularly beneficial in autumn before M. collaris has accumulated glycerol, since supercooled individuals accumulate glycerol in higher concentrations than frozen ones. Freezing at higher temperatures is probably a better survival strategy during brief intervals with pronounced decrease in air temperature.     

Intracellular freezing of glycerolized red cells.

The response of glycerolized human red blood cells to freezing has been evaluated in terms of the thermodynamic state of the frozen intracellular medium. The physiochemical conditions requisite for intracellular freezing, characterized by the cooling rate and the degree of extracellular supercooling, are altered appreciably by the prefreezing addition of glycerol to the cells.Fresh human erythrocytes were suspended in an isotonic glycerol solution yielding a final cryophylactic concentration of either 1.5 or 3.0 m. Subsequently the cell suspension was frozen on a special low temperature stage, mounted on a light microscope, at controlled constant cooling rates with varying degrees of extracellular supercooling (ΔT_sc). The formation of a pure intracellular ice phase was detected by direct observation of the cells.The addition of glycerol produced several significant variations in the freezing characteristics of the blood. As in unmodified cells, the incidence of intracellular freezing increased with the magnitudes of both the cooling rate and the extracellular supercooling. However, the glycerolized cells exhibited a much greater tendency to supercool prior to the initial nucleation of ice. Values of ΔT_sc > ?20 °C were readily obtained. Also, the transition from 0 to 100% occurrence of intracellular ice covered a cooling rate spectrum in excess of 300 to 600 °K/min, as compared with 10 °C/min for unmodified cells. Thus, the incidence of intracellular ice formation was significantly increased in glycerolized cells.     

Freezing avoidance in Andean giant rosette plants

Abstract Frost avoidance mechanisms were studied in Espeletia spicata and Espeletia timotensis, two Andean giant rosette species. The daily courses of soil, air and tissue temperatures were measured at a site at circa 4000 m. Only the leaves were exposed to subzero temperatures; the apical bud and stem pith tissues were insulated by surrounding tissues. The leaf tissues avoided freezing by supercooling rather than by undergoing active osmotic changes. The temperatures at which ice formed in the tissues (the supercooling points) coincided with injury temperatures indicating that Espeletia tissue does not tolerate any kind of ice formation. For insulated tissue (apical bud, stem pith, roots) the supercooling point was around - 5°C coinciding with the injury temperature. Supercooling points of about –13 to - 16°C were observed for leaves. These results contrast with those reported for Afroalpine giant rosettes which tolerate extracellular freezing. The significance of different adaptive responses of giant rosettes to similar cold tropical environments is discussed.     

Freezing of Plant Tissues3

The freezing of plant cells under the microscope was studiedon three types of tissues: Tradescantia staminal hairs, fruitskin, and moss leaf. Cinemicrography was used to record stagesin the freezing processes, which are otherwise un observable.The following phenomena have been demonstrated and discussed:(1) The protective effect of persistent supercooling. (2) Ice-inoculationof cells and factors affecting it. (3) Sequence of ice formationwithin cells. (4) Modes of ice formation as affected by supercooling.(5) Freezing of cell walls and their longitudinal splitting.     

Cryopreservation of primary cultures of mammalian somatic cells in 96-well plates benefits from control of ice nucleation

Cryopreservation of mammalian cells has to date typically been conducted in cryovials, but there are applications where cryopreservation of primary cells in multiwell plates would be advantageous. However excessive supercooling in the small volumes of liquid in each well of the multiwell plates is inevitable without intervention and tends to result in high and variable cell mortality. Here, we describe a technique for cryopreservation of adhered primary bovine granulosa cells in 96-well plates by controlled rate freezing using controlled ice nucleation. Inducing ice nucleation at warm supercooled temperatures (less than 5 °C below the melting point) during cryopreservation using a manual seeding technique significantly improved post-thaw recovery from 29.6% (SD = 8.3%) where nucleation was left uncontrolled to 57.7% (9.3%) when averaged over 8 replicate cultures (p < 0.001). Detachment of thawed cells was qualitatively observed to be more prevalent in wells which did not have ice nucleation control which suggests cryopreserved cell monolayer detachment may be a consequence of deep supercooling. Using an infra-red thermography technique we showed that many aliquots of cryoprotectant solution in 96-well plates can supercool to temperatures below −20 °C when nucleation is not controlled, and also that the freezing temperatures observed are highly variable despite stringent attempts to remove contaminants acting as nucleation sites. We conclude that successful cryopreservation of cells in 96-well plates, or any small volume format, requires control of ice nucleation.     

Ultrastructural Evidence That Intracellular Ice Formation and Possibly Cavitation Are the Sources of Freezing Injury in Supercooling Wood Tissue of Cornus florida L

Although cellular injury in some woody plants has been correlated with freezing of supercooled water, there is no direct evidence that intracellular ice formation is responsible for the injury. In this study we tested the hypothesis that injury to xylem ray parenchyma cells in supercooling tissues is caused by intracellular ice formation. The ultrastructure of freezing-stress response in xylem ray parenchyma cells of flowering dogwood (Cornus florida L.) was determined in tissue prepared by freeze substitution. Wood tissue was collected in the winter, spring, and summer of 1992. Specimens were cooled from 0 to -60[deg]C at a rate of 5[deg]C h-1. Freezing stress did not affect the structural organization of wood tissue, but xylem ray parenchyma cells suffered severe injury in the form of intracellular ice crystals. The temperatures at which the ice crystals were first observed depended on the season in which the tissue was collected. Intracellular ice formation was observed at -20, -10, and -5[deg]C in winter, spring, and summer, respectively. Another type of freezing injury was manifested by fragmented protoplasm with indistinguishable plasma membranes and damaged cell ultrastructure but no evidence of intracellular ice. Intracellular cavitation may be a source of freezing injury in xylem ray parenchyma cells of flowering dogwood.     

In vitro freezing in microtitre plates applied to tobacco plants transformed with the inaZ gene of Pseudomonas syringae

High throughput assays have been developed to measure the ice nucleation activity of transgenic tobacco, Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Petit Havana SR1 plants expressing the ice nucleation gene, inaZ, from Pseudomonas syringae at a young seedling stage, as well as in leaf tissue. Both assays are carried out in 96-well microtitre plates. The first assay involves direct seeding in vitro, one seed per microtitre plate well containing Murashige-Skoog agar. When seedlings reach the two-leaf stage, they are exposed to freezing temperatures by floating the plates on a circulating alcohol bath set at temperatures colder than -9 degrees C. The second assay involves placing small leaf discs individually in microtitre plate wells containing sterile distilled water. The assays complement each other, give highly reproducible results, are technically simple and enable the detection of freezing events in large numbers of plants. The utility and limitations of these assays are discussed.     

A method for quantitative determination of ice nucleating agents in insect hemolymph

The relationship between the concentration of insect hemolymph ice nucleators in samples of 0.9% NaCl solution and the supercooling points of the samples was determined by using a dilution technique. The supercooling points were only moderately reduced following dilution by a factor of up to 10³, whereas dilution beyond this point caused a marked drop in the supercooling points. The dilution factor corresponding to a 50% reduction in the nucleating activity of native hemolymph is taken as a measure of the concentration of ice nucleators in native hemolymph.This method was used to determine the concentration of ice nucleators in the hemolymph of Eurosta solidaginis larvae from Minnesota and Texas, acclimated to different temperatures. Significant levels of nucleators were found only in larvae from Minnesota, and +5 °C was found to be the optimal temperature for nucleator formation. This comparatively high temperature optimum is interpreted as a physiological adaptation, ensuring sufficient nucleator levels in the hemolymph by the time of the first exposure to freezing temperatures in the winter.