Genome economization and a new approach to the species concept in bacteria

The direct experimental evidence presented here shows that Escherichia coli cells can lose a part of their DNA during prolonged starvation. Under stringent conditions cells with a reduced DNA content achieve reproductive advantage over those that maintain their original genome size. Thus, the majority or nearly all of the cells of a long-starved bacterial population undergo genome size reduction. The loss of DNA seems to occur at random in different cells of a population and, thus, their DNA content may vary significantly from one another. The heterogeneity at the DNA level seems to be reflected in conspicuous morphological variability as well. We suggest that, in evolutionary terms, the general dynamics of bacterial genome organization involve two contrasting mechanisms: genome economization (size reduction by DNA loss) and genome loading (acquisition of exogenous DNA and its maintenance in the genome). The former, strengthening the so-called r strategy, might have resulted in the limited genome size of prokaryotes ranging up to 9.5 Mb. The latter explains the widespread horizontal, interspecific gene transfer (general genetic mixing) in bacteria. In the light of the above findings we propose a species concept in bacteria which is comparable to the biological species concept based on reproductive incompatibility.     

Whole genome plasticity in pathogenic bacteria

The exploitation of bacterial genome sequences has so far provided a wealth of new general information about the genetic diversity of bacteria, such as that of many pathogens. Comparative genomics uncovered many genome variations in closely related bacteria and revealed basic principles involved in bacterial diversification, improving our knowledge of the evolution of bacterial pathogens. A correlation between metabolic versatility and genome size has become evident. The degenerated life styles of obligate intracellular pathogens correlate with significantly reduced genome sizes, a phenomenon that has been termed "evolution by reduction". These mechanisms can permanently alter bacterial genotypes and result in adaptation to their environment by genome optimization. In this review, we summarize the recent results of genome-wide approaches to studying the genetic diversity of pathogenic bacteria that indicate that the acquisition of DNA and the loss of genetic information are two important mechanisms that contribute to strain-specific differences in genome content.     

Microeconomic principles explain an optimal genome size in bacteria

Bacteria can clearly enhance their survival by expanding their genetic repertoire. However, the tight packing of the bacterial genome and the fact that the most evolved species do not necessarily have the biggest genomes suggest there are other evolutionary factors limiting their genome expansion. To clarify these restrictions on size, we studied those protein families contributing most significantly to bacterial-genome complexity. We found that all bacteria apply the same basic and ancestral 'molecular technology' to optimize their reproductive efficiency. The same microeconomics principles that define the optimum size in a factory can also explain the existence of a statistical optimum in bacterial genome size. This optimum is reached when the bacterial genome obtains the maximum metabolic complexity (revenue) for minimal regulatory genes (logistic cost).     

Correlations Between Bacterial Ecology and Mobile DNA

Several factors can affect the density of mobile DNA in bacterial genomes including rates of exposure to novel gene pools, recombination, and reductive evolution. These traits are difficult to measure across a broad range of bacterial species, but the ecological niches occupied by an organism provide some indication of the relative magnitude of these forces. Here, by analyzing 384 bacterial genomes assigned to three ecological categories (obligate intracellular, facultative intracellular, and extracellular), we address two, related questions: How does the density of mobile DNA vary across the Bacteria? And is there a statistically supported relationship between ecological niche and mobile element gene density? We report three findings. First, the fraction of mobile element genes in bacterial genomes ranges from 0 to 21% and decreases significantly: facultative intracellular > extracellular > obligate intracellular bacteria. Results further show that the obligate intracellular bacteria that host switch have a higher mobile DNA gene density than the obligate intracellular bacteria that are vertically transmitted. Second, while bacteria from the three ecological niches differ in their average mobile DNA contents, the ranges of mobile DNA found in each category overlap a surprising extent, suggesting bacteria with different lifestyles can tolerate similar amounts of mobile DNA. Third, mobile DNA gene densities increase with genome size across the entire dataset, and the significance of this correlation is dependent on the obligate intracellular bacteria. Further, mobile DNA gene densities do not correlate with evolutionary relationships in a 16S rDNA phylogeny. These findings statistically support a compelling link between mobile element evolution and bacterial ecology.     

The size and structure of the DNA genome of symbiont xenosome particles in the ciliate Parauronema acutum

The size and structure of the DNA genome of xenosomes, bacterial endosymbionts of the marine hymenostome ciliate, Parauronema acutum 110-3, were investigated. Renaturation kinetic measurements, determined optically and by hydroxyapatite chromatography, suggested a genome size of 0.34 x 10(9) daltons. Sedimentation rate measurements of DNA gently released from the symbionts yielded molecules of comparable size. The analytical complexity, determined chemically, was 3.03 x 10(9) daltons. Consistent with these and other data is a model for the structure of the symbiont genome in which the DNA exists in the form of nine circularly permuted, double-stranded DNA molecules of unique sequence, each of molecular weight 0.34 x 10(9). It is suggested that xenosomes and certain symbionts found in ciliated protozoa may be extant forms of once free-living bacteria that have adapted to the intracellular environment.     

The distribution of recombination repair genes is linked to information content in bacteria

The concept of a ‘proteomic constraint’ proposes that the information content of the proteome exerts a selective pressure to reduce mutation rates, implying that larger proteomes produce a greater selective pressure to evolve or maintain DNA repair, resulting in a decrease in mutational load. Here, the distribution of 21 recombination repair genes was characterized across 900 bacterial genomes. Consistent with prediction, the presence of 17 genes correlated with proteome size. Intracellular bacteria were marked by a pervasive absence of recombination repair genes, consistent with their small proteome sizes, but also consistent with alternative explanations that reduced effective population size or lack of recombination may decrease selection pressure. However, when only non-intracellular bacteria were examined, the relationship between proteome size and gene presence was maintained. In addition, the more widely distributed (i.e. conserved) a gene, the smaller the average size of the proteomes from which it was absent. Together, these observations are consistent with the operation of a proteomic constraint on DNA repair. Lastly, a correlation between gene absence and genome AT content was shown, indicating a link between absence of DNA repair and elevated genome AT content.     

Phage as agents of lateral gene transfer

When establishing lysogeny, temperate phages integrate their genome as a prophage into the bacterial chromosome. Prophages thus constitute in many bacteria a substantial part of laterally acquired DNA. Some prophages contribute lysogenic conversion genes that are of selective advantage to the bacterial host. Occasionally, phages are also involved in the lateral transfer of other mobile DNA elements or bacterial DNA. Recent advances in the field of genomics have revealed a major impact by phages on bacterial chromosome evolution.     

The minimal genome paradox

The concept of a 'minimal genome' has appeared as an attempt to answer the question what the minimum number of genes or minimum amount of DNA to support life is. Since bacteria are cells bearing the smallest genomes, it has been generally accepted that the minimal genome must belong to a bacterial species. Currently the most popular chromosome in studies on a minimal genome belongs to Mycoplasma genitalium, a parasite bacterium whose total genetic material is as small as approximately 580 kb. However, the problem is how we define life, and thus also a minimal genome. M. genitalium is a parasite and requires substances provided by its host. Therefore, if a genome of a parasite can be considered as a minimal genome, why not to consider genomes of bacteriophages? Going further, bacterial plasmids could be considered as minimal genomes. The smallest known DNA region playing the function of the origin of replication, which is sufficient for plasmid survival in natural habitats, is as short as 32 base pairs. However, such a small DNA molecule could not form a circular form and be replicated by cellular enzymes. These facts may lead to an ostensibly paradoxical conclusion that the size of a minimal genome is restricted by the physical size of a DNA molecule able to replicate rather, than by the amount of genetic information.     

Prokaryotic genes in eukaryotic genome sequences: when to infer horizontal gene transfer and when to suspect an actual microbe

Assessment of phylogenetic positions of predicted gene and protein sequences is a routine step in any genome project, useful for validating the species' taxonomic position and for evaluating hypotheses about genome evolution and function. Several recent eukaryotic genome projects have reported multiple gene sequences that were much more similar to homologues in bacteria than to any eukaryotic sequence. In the spirit of the times, horizontal gene transfer from bacteria to eukaryotes has been invoked in some of these cases. Here, we show, using comparative sequence analysis, that some of those bacteria‐like genes indeed appear likely to have been horizontally transferred from bacteria to eukaryotes. In other cases, however, the evidence strongly indicates that the eukaryotic DNA sequenced in the genome project contains a sample of non‐integrated DNA from the actual bacteria, possibly providing a window into the host microbiome. Recent literature suggests also that common reagents, kits and laboratory equipment may be systematically contaminated with bacterial DNA, which appears to be sampled by metagenome projects non‐specifically. We review several bioinformatic criteria that help to distinguish putative horizontal gene transfers from the admixture of genes from autonomously replicating bacteria in their hosts' genome databases or from the reagent contamination.     

Deletional bias and the evolution of bacterial genomes

Although bacteria increase their DNA content through horizontal transfer and gene duplication, their genomes remain small and, in particular, lack nonfunctional sequences. This pattern is most readily explained by a pervasive bias towards higher numbers of deletions than insertions. When selection is not strong enough to maintain them, genes are lost in large deletions or inactivated and subsequently eroded. Gene inactivation and loss are particularly apparent in obligate parasites and symbionts, in which dramatic reductions in genome size can result not from selection to lose DNA, but from decreased selection to maintain gene functionality. Here we discuss the evidence showing that deletional bias is a major force that shapes bacterial genomes.     

Genome Sizes of Desulfovibrio desulfuricans, Desulfovibrio vulgaris, and Desulfobulbus propionicus Estimated by Pulsed-Field Gel Electrophoresis of Linearized Chromosomal DNA

Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) of linearized, full-length chromosomal DNA was used to estimate the genome sizes of three species of sulfate-reducing bacteria. Genome sizes of Desulfovibrio desulfuricans, Desulfovibrio vulgaris, and Desulfobulbus propionicus were estimated to be 3.1, 3.6, and 3.7 Mb, respectively. These values are double the genome sizes previously determined for two Desulfovibrio species by two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis of DNA cut with restriction enzymes. PFGE of full-length chromosomal DNA could provide a generally applicable method to rapidly determine bacterial genome size and organization. Received: 1 October 1996 / Accepted: 5 November 1996     

Novel DNA sequences from natural strains of the nitrogen-fixing symbiotic bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti

Variation in genome size and content is common among bacterial strains. Identifying these naturally occurring differences can accelerate our understanding of bacterial attributes, such as ecological specialization and genome evolution. In this study, we used representational difference analysis to identify potentially novel sequences not present in the sequenced laboratory strain Rm1021 of the nitrogen-fixing bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti. Using strain Rm1021 as the driver and the type strain of S. meliloti ATCC 9930, which has a genome size approximately 370 kilobases bigger than that of strain Rm1021, as the tester, we identified several groups of sequences in the ATCC 9930 genome not present in strain Rm1021. Among the 85 novel DNA fragments examined, 55 showed no obvious homologs anywhere in the public databases. Of the remaining 30 sequences, 24 contained homologs to the Rm1021 genome as well as unique segments not found in Rm1021, 3 contained sequences homologous to those published for another S. meliloti strain but absent in Rm1021, 2 contained sequences homologous to other symbiotic nitrogen-fixing bacteria (Rhizobium etli and Bradyrhizobium japonicum), and 1 contained a sequence homologous to a gene in a non-nitrogen-fixing species, Pseudomonas sp. NK87. Using PCR, we assayed the distribution of 12 of the above 85 novel sequences in a collection of 59 natural S. meliloti strains. The distribution varied widely among the 12 novel DNA fragments, from 1.7% to 72.9%. No apparent correlation was found between the distribution of these novel DNA sequences and their genotypes obtained using multilocus enzyme electrophoresis. Our results suggest potentially high rates of gene gain and loss in S. meliloti genomes.     

Bacterial phylogenetic clusters revealed by genome structure.

Current bacterial taxonomy is mostly based on phenotypic criteria, which may yield misleading interpretations in classification and identification. As a result, bacteria not closely related may be grouped together as a genus or species. For pathogenic bacteria, incorrect classification or misidentification could be disastrous. There is therefore an urgent need for appropriate methodologies to classify bacteria according to phylogeny and corresponding new approaches that permit their rapid and accurate identification. For this purpose, we have devised a strategy enabling us to resolve phylogenetic clusters of bacteria by comparing their genome structures. These structures were revealed by cleaving genomic DNA with the endonuclease I-CeuI, which cuts within the 23S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) sequences, and by mapping the resulting large DNA fragments with pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. We tested this experimental system on two representative bacterial genera: Salmonella and Pasteurella. Among Salmonella spp., I-CeuI mapping revealed virtually indistinguishable genome structures, demonstrating a high degree of structural conservation. Consistent with this, 16S rDNA sequences are also highly conserved among the Salmonella spp. In marked contrast, the Pasteurella strains have very different genome structures among and even within individual species. The divergence of Pasteurella was also reflected in 16S rDNA sequences and far exceeded that seen between Escherichia and Salmonella. Based on this diversity, the Pasteurella haemolytica strains we analyzed could be divided into 14 phylogenetic groups and the Pasteurella multocida strains could be divided into 9 groups. If criteria for defining bacterial species or genera similar to those used for Salmonella and Escherichia coli were applied, the striking phylogenetic diversity would allow bacteria in the currently recognized species of P. multocida and P. haemolytica to be divided into different species, genera, or even higher ranks. On the other hand, strains of Pasteurella ureae and Pasteurella pneumotropica are very similar to those of P. multocida in both genome structure and 16S rDNA sequence and should be regarded as strains within this species. We conclude that large-scale genome structure can be a sensitive indicator of phylogenetic relationships and that, therefore, I-CeuI-based genomic mapping is an efficient tool for probing the phylogenetic status of bacteria.     

Genome DNA Sequence Variation, Evolution, and Function in Bacteria and Archaea

Comparative genomics has revealed that variations in bacterial and archaeal genome DNA sequences cannot be explained by only neutral mutations. Virus resistance and plasmid distribution systems have resulted in changes in bacterial and archaeal genome sequences during evolution. The restriction-modification system, a virus resistance system, leads to avoidance of palindromic DNA sequences in genomes. Clustered, regularly interspaced, short palindromic repeats (CRISPRs) found in genomes represent yet another virus resistance system. Comparative genomics has shown that bacteria and archaea have failed to gain any DNA with GC content higher than the GC content of their chromosomes. Thus, horizontally transferred DNA regions have lower GC content than the host chromosomal DNA does. Some nucleoid-associated proteins bind DNA regions with low GC content and inhibit the expression of genes contained in those regions. This form of gene repression is another type of virus resistance system. On the other hand, bacteria and archaea have used plasmids to gain additional genes. Virus resistance systems influence plasmid distribution. Interestingly, the restriction-modification system and nucleoid-associated protein genes have been distributed via plasmids. Thus, GC content and genomic signatures do not reflect bacterial and archaeal evolutionary relationships.     

Genome dynamics in major bacterial pathogens

Pathogenic bacteria continuously encounter multiple forms of stress in their hostile environments, which leads to DNA damage. With the new insight into biology offered by genome sequences, the elucidation of the gene content encoding proteins provides clues toward understanding the microbial lifestyle related to habitat and niche. Campylobacter jejuni, Haemophilus influenzae, Helicobacter pylori, Mycobacterium tuberculosis , the pathogenic Neisseria, Streptococcus pneumoniae, Streptococcus pyogenes and Staphylococcus aureus are major human pathogens causing detrimental morbidity and mortality at a global scale. An algorithm for the clustering of orthologs was established in order to identify whether orthologs of selected genes were present or absent in the genomes of the pathogenic bacteria under study. Based on the known genes for the various functions and their orthologs in selected pathogenic bacteria, an overview of the presence of the different types of genes was created. In this context, we focus on selected processes enabling genome dynamics in these particular pathogens, namely DNA repair, recombination and horizontal gene transfer. An understanding of the precise molecular functions of the enzymes participating in DNA metabolism and their importance in the maintenance of bacterial genome integrity has also, in recent years, indicated a future role for these enzymes as targets for therapeutic intervention.     

Human occupancy as a source of indoor airborne bacteria

Exposure to specific airborne bacteria indoors is linked to infectious and noninfectious adverse health outcomes. However, the sources and origins of bacteria suspended in indoor air are not well understood. This study presents evidence for elevated concentrations of indoor airborne bacteria due to human occupancy, and investigates the sources of these bacteria. Samples were collected in a university classroom while occupied and when vacant. The total particle mass concentration, bacterial genome concentration, and bacterial phylogenetic populations were characterized in indoor, outdoor, and ventilation duct supply air, as well as in the dust of ventilation system filters and in floor dust. Occupancy increased the total aerosol mass and bacterial genome concentration in indoor air PM(10) and PM(2.5) size fractions, with an increase of nearly two orders of magnitude in airborne bacterial genome concentration in PM(10). On a per mass basis, floor dust was enriched in bacterial genomes compared to airborne particles. Quantitative comparisons between bacterial populations in indoor air and potential sources suggest that resuspended floor dust is an important contributor to bacterial aerosol populations during occupancy. Experiments that controlled for resuspension from the floor implies that direct human shedding may also significantly impact the concentration of indoor airborne particles. The high content of bacteria specific to the skin, nostrils, and hair of humans found in indoor air and in floor dust indicates that floors are an important reservoir of human-associated bacteria, and that the direct particle shedding of desquamated skin cells and their subsequent resuspension strongly influenced the airborne bacteria population structure in this human-occupied environment. Inhalation exposure to microbes shed by other current or previous human occupants may occur in communal indoor environments.     

Interspecies migration and evolution of bacteriophages of the genus phiKZ: The purpose and criteria of the search for new phiKZ-like bacteriophages

Some properties of bacteriophages with large (200 kb and more) sequenced genomes have been compared. In contrast to other large bacteriophages from different families, bacteriophages active on pseudomonads of various species (phiKZ-like bacterio phages) have some common features, which suggests their phylogenetic relationship and independence of their evolution as a result of migration among bacteria of this family. Among such common features are the absence in the genomes of these phages of sites sensitive to endonuclease PstI, the absence of genes encoding DNA polymerases that are similar to the known enzymes of this type, possible dependence of replication of the phage genome on bacterial DNA polymerase, and a considerably larger average gene size as compared to that for other phages. Criteria are suggested for searching for novel phiKZ-like bacteriophages: the size of a phag e particle, production by bacteria infected with such phages of a large amount of highly viscous mucus. Taking into account the use of these bacteriophages in therapeutic preparations (due to a broad spectrum of lytic activity) and a poor knowledge of a majority of their gene products, it seems necessary to perform a more comprehensive genetic analysis of phages of this genus or their mutants for selecting those adequate for phage therapy.     

Persistence and stability of genetically manipulated derivatives of Enterobacter agglomerans in soil microcosms

Abstract Molecular methods and conventional plating were applied to monitor Enterobacter agglomerans 339 derivatives carrying a Tn5-Mob or an npt I-cassette in unsterile soil microcosms. The plate counts of the introduced bacteria decreased continuously in time until undetectable on selective media. In contrast, hybridization of the total DNA directly isolated from inoculated soil samples showed that the target sequences detected corresponded to a much higher number of bacteria than indicated by plating. By PCR-amplification and hybridization of the soil DNA we could show that asignificant number of target sequences still persisted in the soil microcosms, even when the inoculated bacteria were not able to make colonies on selective agar plates. The Tn 5 marker caused instabilities in the genome of the bacteria studied. Some of the clones that grew in the soil samples had rearrangements in their genome. The detection of E. agglomerans 339 derivatives carrying the immobile npt I-cassette was also dependent on its location in the bacterial genome.     

Reverse Sample Genome Probing, a New Technique for Identification of Bacteria in Environmental Samples by DNA Hybridization, and Its Application to the Identification of Sulfate-Reducing Bacteria in Oil Field Samples

A novel method for the identification of bacteria in environmental samples by DNA hybridization is presented. It is based on the fact that, even within a genus, the genomes of different bacteria may have little overall sequence homology. This allows the use of the labeled genomic DNA of a given bacterium (referred to as a “standard”) to probe for its presence and that of bacteria with highly homologous genomes in total DNA obtained from an environmental sample. Alternatively, total DNA extracted from the sample can be labeled and used to probe filters on which denatured chromosomal DNA from relevant bacterial standards has been spotted. The latter technique is referred to as reverse sample genome probing, since it is the reverse of the usual practice of deriving probes from reference bacteria for analyzing a DNA sample. Reverse sample genome probing allows identification of bacteria in a sample in a single step once a master filter with suitable standards has been developed. Application of reverse sample genome probing to the identification of sulfate-reducing bacteria in 31 samples obtained primarily from oil fields in the province of Alberta has indicated that there are at least 20 genotypically different sulfate-reducing bacteria in these samples.     

New evidence of an old problem: The coupling of genome replication to cell growth in bacteria

The problem of coordinating genome replication with cell growth in bacteria was posed over four decades ago. Unlike for eukaryotes, this problem has not been completely solved even for Escherichia coli, which has been comprehensively studied by molecular biologists, to say nothing of other bacteria. Current models of the bacterial life cycle solve the coupling problem by introducing a phenomenological hypothesis that considers the dynamic coordination of growth and replication but does not unveil the underlying molecular mechanisms. Here we review the mechanisms regulating genome replication initiation with regards to their coupling to growth processes in the three best investigated bacterial species: E. coli, Bacillus subtilis, and Caulobacter crescentus. A putative correlation between the type of cell growth laws and the actual mechanisms regulating the replication of DNA formed during the process of evolution in various classes of bacteria, is discussed, including those intracellular parasites in which degenerative evolution has discarded most of their genomes. We contemplate the concept of a universal growth law for bacterial cells and some features in the formation of a primitive negative replication regulating mechanism in the context of the coupling problem.