Thermodynamics of apocytochrome b5 unfolding.

Apocytochrome b5 from rabbit liver was studied by scanning calorimetry, limited proteolysis, circular dichroism, second derivative spectroscopy, and size exclusion chromatography. The protein is able to undergo a reversible two-state thermal transition. However, transition temperature, denaturational enthalpy, and heat capacity change are reduced compared with the holoprotein. Apocytochrome b5 stability in terms of Gibbs energy change at protein unfolding (delta G) amounts to delta G = 7 +/- 1 kJ/mol at 25 degrees C (pH 7.4) compared with delta G = 25 kJ/mol for the holoprotein. Apocytochrome b5 is a compact, native-like protein. According to the spectral data, the cooperative structure is mainly based in the core region formed by residues 1-35 and 79-90. This finding is in full agreement with NMR data (Moore, C.D. & Lecomte, J.T.J., 1993, Biochemistry 32, 199-207).     

Analysis of folding and unfolding reactions of cytochrome b5

The guanidine hydrochloride- (GuHCl-) induced unfolding and refolding of a recombinant domain of bovine microsomal cytochrome b(5) containing the first 104 amino acid residues has been characterized by both transient and equilibrium spectrophotometric methods. The soluble domain is reversibly unfolded and the equilibrium reaction may be monitored by changes in absorbance and fluorescence that accompany denaturation of the native protein. Both probes reveal a single cooperative transition with a midpoint at 3 M GuHCl and lead to a value for the protein stability (DeltaG(uw)) of 26.5 kJ mol(-1). This stability is much higher than that reported for the corresponding form of the apoprotein (approximately 7 kJ mol(-1)). Transient changes in fluorescence and absorbance during protein unfolding exhibit biphasic profiles. A fast phase occupying approximately 30% of the total amplitude is observed at high denaturant concentrations and becomes the dominant process within the transition region. The rates associated with each process show a linear dependency on GuHCl concentration, and at zero denaturant concentration the unfolding rates (k(uw)) are 4.5 x 10(-5) s(-1) and 5.2 x 10(-6) s(-1) at 25 degrees C. The pattern of unfolding is not correlated with covalent heterogeneity, since a wide range of variants and site-directed mutants exhibit identical profiles, nor is the unfolding correlated with cis-trans Pro isomerization in the native state. In comparison with the apo form of cytochrome b(5), the kinetics of refolding and unfolding are more complex and exhibit very different transition states. The data support a model for unfolding in which heme-protein interactions give rise to two discernible rates of unfolding. From an analysis of the activation parameters associated with each process it is established that two structurally similar transition states differing by less than 5 kJ mol(-1) exist in the unfolding reaction. Protein refolding exhibits monophasic kinetics but with distinct curvature apparent in plots of ln k(obs) versus denaturant concentration. The data are interpreted in terms of alternative routes for protein folding in which a "fast track" leads to the rapid ordering of structure around Trp26 for refolding while a slower route requires additional reorganization around the hydrophobic core.     

A histidine/tryptophan pi-stacking interaction stabilizes the heme-independent folding core of microsomal apocytochrome b5 relative to that of mitochondrial apocytochrome b5

The outer mitochondrial membrane isoform of mammalian cytochrome b5 (OM b5) is considerably more stable than its microsomal counterpart (Mc b5), whereas the corresponding apoproteins (OM and Mc apo-b5) exhibit similar stability. OM and Mc apo-b5 are also similar in that their empty heme-binding pockets (core 1) are highly disordered but that the remainder of each apoprotein (core 2) displays substantial hololike structure. Core 1 residue 71 is leucine in all known mammalian OM b5's and serine in the corresponding Mc proteins. Replacing Leu-71 in rat OM (rOM) b5 with Ser has been shown to (1) decrease apoprotein thermodynamic stability by >2 kcal/mol and (2) extend conformational disorder beyond core 1 and into core 2, as evidenced in part by loss of a near-UV circular dichroism signal associated with the side chain of invariant residue Trp-22. Herein we report identification of a conserved Mc b5 core 2 packing motif that plays a key role in stabilizing apoprotein conformation in the vicinity of Trp-22, thereby compensating for the presence of Ser at position 71: a pi-stacking interaction between the side chains of Trp-22 and His-15 that is extended by hydrogen bonding between the side chains of His-15, Ser-20, and Glu-11. The corresponding conserved packing motif in OM b5's differs in having arginine at position 15 and glutamate at position 20. We also present evidence indicating that the conserved Mc b5 packing motif noted above contributes to the unusually extensive secondary structure exhibited by bovine Mc apo-b5 in the urea-denatured state.     

Resolution of the fluorescence equilibrium unfolding profile of trp aporepressor using single tryptophan mutants.

Single tryptophan mutants of the trp aporepressor, tryptophan 19-->phenylalanine (W19F) and tryptophan 99-->phenylalanine (W99F), were used in this study to resolve the individual steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence urea unfolding profiles of the two tryptophan residues in this highly intertwined, dimeric protein. The wild-type protein exhibits a large increase in fluorescence intensity and lifetime, as well as a large red shift in the steady-state fluorescence emission spectrum, upon unfolding by urea (Lane, A.N. & Jardetsky, O., 1987, Eur. J. Biochem. 164, 389-396; Gittelman, M.S. & Matthews, C.R., 1990, Biochemistry 29, 7011-7020; Fernando, T. & Royer, C.A., 1992, Biochemistry 31, 6683-6691). Unfolding of the W19F mutant demonstrated that Trp 99 undergoes a large increase in intensity and a red shift upon exposure to solvent. Lifetime studies revealed that the contribution of the dominant 0.5-ns component of this tryptophan tends toward zero with increasing urea, whereas the longer lifetime components increase in importance. This lifting of the quenching of Trp 99 may be due to disruption of the interaction between the two subunits upon denaturation, which abolishes the interaction of Trp 99 on one subunit with the amide quenching group of Asn 32 on the other subunit (Royer, C.A., 1992, Biophys. J. 63, 741-750). On the other hand, Trp 19 is quenched in response to unfolding in the W99F mutant. Exposure to solvent of Trp 19, which is buried at the hydrophobic dimer interface in the native protein, results in a large red shift of the average steady-state emission.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Tubulin equilibrium unfolding followed by time-resolved fluorescence and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

The pathway for the in vitro equilibrium unfolding of the tubulin heterodimer by guanidinium chloride (GdmCl) has been studied using several spectroscopic techniques, specifically circular dichroism (CD), two-photon Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy (FCS), and time-resolved fluorescence, including lifetime and dynamic polarization. The results show that tubulin unfolding is characterized by distinct processes that occur in different GdmCl concentration ranges. From 0 to 0.5 M GdmCl, a slight alteration of the tubulin heterodimer occurs, as evidenced by a small, but reproducible increase in the rotational correlation time of the protein and a sharp decrease in the secondary structure monitored by CD. In the range 0.5-1.5 M GdmCl, significant decreases in the steady-state anisotropy and average lifetime of the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence occur, as well as a decrease in the rotational correlation time, from 48 to 26 nsec. In the same GdmCl range, the number of protein molecules (labeled with Alexa 488), as determined by two-photon FCS measurements, increases by a factor of two, indicating dissociation of the tubulin dimer into monomers. From 1.5 to 4 M GdmCl, these monomers unfold, as evidenced by the continual decrease in the tryptophan steady-state anisotropy, average lifetime, and rotational correlation time, concomitant with secondary structural changes. These results help to elucidate the unfolding pathway of the tubulin heterodimer and demonstrate the value of FCS measurements in studies on oligomeric protein systems.     

Spectrin folding versus unfolding reactions and RBC membrane stiffness

Spectrin (Sp), a key component of the erythrocyte membrane, is routinely stretched to near its fully folded contour length during cell deformations. Such dynamic loading may induce domain unfolding as suggested by recent experiments. Herein we develop a model to describe the folding/unfolding of spectrin during equilibrium or nonequilibrium extensions. In both cases, our model indicates that there exists a critical extension beyond which unfolding occurs. We further deploy this model, together with a three-dimensional model of the junctional complex in the erythrocyte membrane, to explore the effect of Sp unfolding on the membrane's mechanical properties, and on the thermal fluctuation of membrane-attached beads. At large deformations our results show a distinctive strain-induced unstiffening behavior, manifested in the slow decrease of the shear modulus, and accompanied by an increase in bead fluctuation. Bead fluctuation is also found to be influenced by mode switching, a phenomenon predicted by our three-dimensional model. The amount of stiffness reduction, however, is modest compared with that reported in experiments. A possible explanation for the discrepancy is the occurrence of spectrin head-to-head disassociation which is also included within our modeling framework and used to analyze bead motion as observed via experiment.     

The equilibrium unfolding intermediate observed at pH 4 and its relationship with the kinetic folding intermediates in green fluorescent protein

Folding mechanisms of a variant of green fluorescent protein (F99S/M153T/V163A) were investigated by a wide variety of spectroscopic techniques. Equilibrium measurements on acid-induced denaturation of the protein monitored by chromophore and tryptophan fluorescence and small-angle X-ray scattering revealed that this protein accumulates at least two equilibrium intermediates, a native-like intermediate and an unfolding intermediate, the latter of which exhibits the characteristics of the molten globule state under moderately denaturing conditions at pH 4. To elucidate the role of the equilibrium unfolding intermediate in folding, a series of kinetic refolding experiments with various combinations of initial and final pH values, including pH 7.5 (the native condition), pH 4.0 (the moderately denaturing condition where the unfolding intermediate is accumulated), and pH 2.0 (the acid-denaturing condition) were carried out by monitoring chromophore and tryptophan fluorescence. Kinetic on-pathway intermediates were accumulated during the folding on the refolding reaction from pH 2.0 to 7.5. However, the signal change corresponding to the conversion from the acid-denatured to the kinetic intermediate states was significantly reduced on the refolding reaction from pH 4.0 to pH 7.5, whereas only the signal change corresponding to the above conversion was observed on the refolding reaction from pH 2.0 to pH 4.0. These results indicate that the equilibrium unfolding intermediate is composed of an ensemble of the folding intermediate species accumulated during the folding reaction, and thus support a hierarchical model of protein folding.     

Equilibrium and kinetic studies of protein cooperativity using urea-induced folding/unfolding of a Ubq-UIM fusion protein

Understanding the origins of cooperativity in proteins remains an important topic in protein folding. This study describes experimental folding/unfolding equilibrium and kinetic studies of the engineered protein Ubq-UIM, consisting of ubiquitin (Ubq) fused to the sequence of the ubiquitin interacting motif (UIM) via a short linker. Urea-induced folding/unfolding profiles of Ubq-UIM were monitored by far-UV circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopies and compared to those of the isolated Ubq domain. It was found that the equilibrium data for Ubq-UIM is inconsistent with a two-state model. Analysis of the kinetics of folding shows similarity in the folding transition state ensemble between Ubq and Ubq-UIM, suggesting that formation of Ubq domain is independent of UIM. The major contribution to the stabilization of Ubq-UIM, relative to Ubq, was found to be in the rates of unfolding. Moreover, it was found that the kinetic m-values for Ubq-UIM unfolding, monitored by different probes (far-UV circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopies), are different; thereby, further supporting deviations from a two-state behavior. A thermodynamic linkage model that involves four states was found to be applicable to the urea-induced unfolding of Ubq-UIM, which is in agreement with the previous temperature-induced unfolding study. The applicability of the model was further supported by site-directed variants of Ubq-UIM that have altered stabilities of Ubq/UIM interface and/or stabilities of individual Ubq- and UIM-domains. All variants show increased cooperativity and one variant, E43N_Ubq-UIM, appears to behave very close to an equilibrium two-state.     

Evidence for identity between the equilibrium unfolding intermediate and a transient folding intermediate: a comparative study of the folding reactions of alpha-lactalbumin and lysozyme

The refolding kinetics of alpha-lactalbumin at different concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride have been investigated by means of kinetic circular dichroism and stopped-flow absorption measurements. The refolding reaction consists of at least two stages, the instantaneous accumulation of the transient intermediate that has peptide secondary structure and the subsequent slow process associated with formation of tertiary structure. The transient intermediate is compared with the well-characterized equilibrium intermediate observed during the denaturant-induced unfolding. Stabilities of the secondary structures against the denaturant, affinities for Ca2+, and tryptophan absorption properties of the transient and equilibrium intermediates were investigated. In all of these respects, the transient intermediate is identical with the equilibrium one, demonstrating the validity of the use of the equilibrium intermediate as a model of the folding intermediate. Essentially the same transient intermediate was also detected in the folding of lysozyme, the protein known to be homologous to alpha-lactalbumin but whose equilibrium unfolding is represented as a two-state reaction. The stability and cooperativity of the secondary structure of the intermediate of lysozyme are compared with those of alpha-lactalbumin. The results show that the protein folding occurring via the intermediate is not limited to the proteins that show equilibrium intermediates. Although the unfolding equilibria of most proteins are well approximated as a two-state reaction, the two-state hypothesis may not be applicable to the folding reaction under the native condition. Two models of protein folding, intermediate-controlled folding model and multiple-pathway folding model, which are different in view of the role of the intermediate in determining the pathway of folding, are also discussed.     

Modification of trypsin-solubilized cytochrome b5, apocytochrome b5, and liposome-bound cytochrome b5 by diethylpyrocarbonate

The interactions of diethylpyrocarbonate (DEP) with the various forms of cytochrome b5 were studied to gain a better understanding of the factors that influence the extent of modification of the axial histidines of cytochrome b5. Very low concentrations of DEP were able to decrease the heme binding capacity of apocytochrome b5. Moreover, it was shown that two additional histidines, presumed to be the axial ligands (His 39 and 63), were modified in the apo but not the holo form of a given preparation of cytochrome b5. Trypsin-solubilized bovine cytochrome b5 was resistant to the effects of DEP. A 200-fold molar excess of DEP displaced only 15% of the heme in the trypsin-solubilized protein in contrast to an 84% displacement of the heme in the detergent-solubilized protein. However, detergent-solubilized cytochrome b5 which had been incorporated into phospholipid vesicles exhibited the same reactivity with DEP as did the trypsin-solubilized protein. This is attributed to the fact that the two resistant preparations of cytochrome b5 are monomeric in their respective environments while detergent-solubilized cytochrome b5 is known to exist as an octamer in aqueous solutions. Our studies suggest that dissociation of the octamer to the monomer results in a conformational change that decreases the reactivity of the axial ligands of the hydrophilic heme-containing domain of cytochrome b5. Examination of the cytochrome b5 molecule by computer graphics indicates that a tunnel leads from the surface of the molecule to axial histidine 63 and that axial histidine 39 is buried.     

pH-jump-induced folding and unfolding studies of barstar: evidence for multiple folding and unfolding pathways.

Equilibrium and kinetic characterization of the high pH-induced unfolding transition of the small protein barstar have been carried out in the pH range 7-12. A mutant form of barstar, containing a single tryptophan, Trp 53, completely buried in the core of the native protein, has been used. It is shown that the protein undergoes reversible unfolding above pH 10. The pH 12 form (the D form) appears to be as unfolded as the form unfolded by 6 M guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) at pH 7 (the U form): both forms have similar fluorescence and far-UV circular dichroism (CD) signals and have similar sizes, as determined by dynamic light scattering and size-exclusion chromatography. No residual structure is detected in the D form: addition of GdnHCl does not alter its fluorescence and far-UV CD properties. The fluorescence signal of Trp 53 has been used to monitor folding and unfolding kinetics. The kinetics of folding of the D form in the pH range 7-11 are complex and are described by four exponential processes, as are the kinetics of unfolding of the native state (N state) in the pH range 10.5-12. Each kinetic phase of folding decreases in rate with increase in pH from 7 to 10.85, and each kinetic phase of unfolding decreases in rate with decrease in pH from 12 to 10.85. At pH 10.85, the folding and unfolding rates for any particular kinetic phase are identical and minimal. The two slowest phases of folding and unfolding have identical kinetics whether measured by Trp 53 fluorescence or by mean residue ellipticity at 222 nm. Direct determination of the increase in the N state with time of folding at pH 7 and of the D form with time of unfolding at pH 12, by means of double-jump assays, show that between 85 and 95% of protein molecules fold or unfold via fast pathways between the two forms. The remaining 5-15% of protein molecules appear to fold or unfold via slower pathways, on which at least two intermediates accumulate. The mechanism of folding from the high pH-denatured D form is remarkably similar to the mechanism of folding from the urea or GdnHCl-denatured U form.     

Relationship between kinetic and equilibrium folding intermediates of creatine kinase

Creatine kinase (CK) is a dimeric enzyme important in ATP regeneration in cells where energy demands are high. The folding of CK under equilibrium and transient conditions has been studied in detail and is found to be complex. At equilibrium in 0.8 M GuHCl, 90% of CK molecules are in the form of a partially structured, monomeric intermediate. We exploit this property to measure kinetics of refolding and unfolding to and from this equilibrium intermediate (EI), using far-UV circular dichroism and intrinsic fluorescence as structural probes. We are thus able to compare the properties of EI and the kinetic intermediate formed during the burst phase in refolding. Native CK and EI unfold with rate constants in seconds and milliseconds, respectively. As is observed for refolding of fully-denatured CK, refolding from EI to the native state shows a burst phase followed by two exponential phases. The burst phase refolding intermediate is inferred to have more structure and greater stability than the equilibrium intermediate. When refolding from the fully-denatured state in 0.8 M GuHCl, the equilibrium intermediate is formed within the dead-time of mixing in the stopped-flow apparatus. The equilibrium intermediate may thus represent a kinetic intermediate formed early during folding.     

Folding of ribonuclease T1. 2. Kinetic models for the folding and unfolding reactions

The slow refolding of ribonuclease T1 was investigated by different probes. Structural intermediates with secondary structure are formed early during refolding, as indicated by the rapid regain of a native-like circular dichroism spectrum in the amide region. This extensive structure formation is much faster than the slow steps of refolding, which are limited in rate by the reisomerization of incorrect proline isomers. The transient folding intermediates were also detected by unfolding assays, which make use of the reduced stability of folding intermediates relative to that of the native protein. The results of this and the preceding paper [Kiefhaber et al. (1990) Biochemistry (preceding paper in this issue)] were used to propose kinetic models for the unfolding and refolding of ribonuclease T1. The unfolding mechanism is based on the assumption that, after the structural unfolding step, the slow isomerizations of two X-Pro peptide bonds occur independently of each other in the denatured protein. At equilibrium a small amount of fast-folding species coexists with three slow-folding species: two with one incorrect proline isomer each and another, dominant species with both these prolines in the incorrect isomeric state. In the mechanism for refolding we assume that all slow-folding molecules can rapidly regain most of the secondary and part of the tertiary structure early in folding. Reisomerizations of incorrect proline peptide bonds constitute the slow, rate-limiting steps of refolding. A peculiar feature of the kinetic model for refolding is that the major unfolded species with two incorrect proline isomers can enter two alternative folding pathways, depending on which of the two reisomerizes first. The relative rates of reisomerization of the respective proline peptide bonds at the stage of the rapidly formed intermediate determine the choice of pathway. It is changed in the presence of prolyl isomerase, because this enzyme catalyzes these two isomerizations with different efficiency and consequently leads to a shift from the very slow to the intermediate refolding pathway.     

Experimental study of the protein folding landscape: unfolding reactions in cytochrome c.

Hydrogen exchange results for cytochrome c have been interpreted in terms of transient hydrogen bond-breaking reactions that include large unfolding reactions and small fluctuational distortions. The differential sensitivity of these opening reactions to denaturant, temperature, and protein stability makes it possible to distinguish the different opening reactions and to characterize their structural and thermodynamic parameters. The partially unfolded forms (PUFs) observed are few and discrete, evidently because they are produced by the reversible unfolding of the protein's several intrinsically cooperative secondary structural elements. The PUFs are robust, evidently because the structural elements do not change over a wide range of conditions. The discrete nature of the PUFs and their small number is as expected for classical folding intermediates but not for theoretically derived folding models apparently because the simplified non-protein models usually analyzed in theoretical studies encompass only a single cooperative unit rather than multiple separable units.     

The equilibrium unfolding of Azotobacter vinelandii apoflavodoxin II occurs via a relatively stable folding intermediate.

A flavodoxin from Azotobacter vinelandii is chosen as a model system to study the folding of alpha/beta doubly wound proteins. The guanidinium hydrochloride induced unfolding of apoflavodoxin is demonstrated to be reversible. Apoflavodoxin thus can fold in the absence of the FMN cofactor. The unfolding curves obtained for wild-type, C69A and C69S apoflavodoxin as monitored by circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy do not coincide. Apoflavodoxin unfolding occurs therefore not via a simple two-state mechanism. The experimental data can be described by a three-state mechanism of apoflavodoxin equilibrium unfolding in which a relatively stable intermediate is involved. The intermediate species lacks the characteristic tertiary structure of native apoflavodoxin as deduced from fluorescence spectroscopy, but has significant secondary structure as inferred from circular dichroism spectroscopy. Both spectroscopic techniques show that thermally-induced unfolding of apoflavodoxin also proceeds through formation of a similar molten globule-like species. Thermal unfolding of apoflavodoxin is accompanied by anomalous circular dichroism characteristics: the negative ellipticity at 222 nM increases in the transition zone of unfolding. This effect is most likely attributable to changes in tertiary interactions of aromatic side chains upon protein unfolding. From the presented results and hydrogen/deuterium exchange data, a model for the equilibrium unfolding of apoflavodoxin is presented.     

Folding of the yeast prion protein Ure2: kinetic evidence for folding and unfolding intermediates.

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae non-Mendelian factor [URE3] propagates by a prion-like mechanism, involving aggregation of the chromosomally encoded protein Ure2. The N-terminal prion domain (PrD) of Ure2 is required for prion activity in vivo and amyloid formation in vitro. However, the molecular mechanism of the prion-like activity remains obscure. Here we measure the kinetics of folding of Ure2 and two N-terminal variants that lack all or part of the PrD. The kinetic folding behaviour of the three proteins is identical, indicating that the PrD does not change the stability, rates of folding or folding pathway of Ure2. Both unfolding and refolding kinetics are multiphasic. An intermediate is populated during unfolding at high denaturant concentrations resulting in the appearance of an unfolding burst phase and "roll-over" in the denaturant dependence of the unfolding rate constants. During refolding the appearance of a burst phase indicates formation of an intermediate during the dead-time of stopped-flow mixing. A further fast phase shows second-order kinetics, indicating formation of a dimeric intermediate. Regain of native-like fluorescence displays a distinct lag due to population of this on-pathway dimeric intermediate. Double-jump experiments indicate that isomerisation of Pro166, which is cis in the native state, occurs late in refolding after regain of native-like fluorescence. During protein refolding there is kinetic partitioning between productive folding via the dimeric intermediate and a non-productive side reaction via an aggregation prone monomeric intermediate. In the light of this and other studies, schemes for folding, aggregation and prion formation are proposed.