Lack of Chemically Induced Mutation in Repair-Deficient Mutants of Yeast

Two genes, rad6 and rad9, that confer radiation sensitivity in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae also greatly reduce the frequency of chemically-induced reversions of a tester mutant cyc1-131, which is a chain initiation mutant in the structural gene determining iso-1-cytochrome c. Mutations induced by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), diethyl sulfate (DES), methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), dimethyl sulfate (DMS), nitroquinoline oxide (NQO), nitrosoguanidine (NTG), nitrogen mustard (HN2), beta-propiolactone, and tritiated uridine, as well as mutations induced by ultraviolet light (UV) and ionizing radiation were greatly diminished in strains homozygous for either the rad6 or rad9 gene. Nitrous acid and nitrosoimidazolidone (NIL), on the other hand, were highly mutagenic in these repair-deficient mutants, and at low doses, these mutagens acted with about the same efficiency as in the normal RAD strain. At high doses of either nitrous acid or NIL, however, reversion frequencies were significantly reduced in the two rad mutants compared to normal strains. Although both rad mutants are immutable to about the same extent, the rad9 strains tend to be less sensitive to the lethal effect of chemical mutagens than rad6 strains. It is concluded that yeast requires a functional repair system for mutation induction by chemical agents.     

Mutagen sensitivities and mutator effects of MMS-sensitive mutants in Neurospora

7 mus (mutagen-sensitive) mutants of Neurospora crassa, which are more sensitive to the toxic effects of MMS (methyl methanesulfonate) than wild-type, were investigated for cross-sensitivities to other mutagens and inhibitors. These mutants have recently been mapped in 5 new genes, mus-7 to mus-11, and mutant alleles from each gene were checked for their effects on mutation frequencies. It was found that mutants in 3 of these 5 genes showed radiation-induced mutation frequencies similar to wild-type. These included 2 alleles of the gene mus-10, which were cross-sensitive only to UV and were the only mutants that produced some viable ascospores in homozygous crosses. The mutant of the second gene, mus-8, was especially sensitive to UV and mitomycin C and produced slightly reduced frequencies of spontaneous mutation. In contrast, the mutant of the third gene, mus-7, was not UV-sensitive but showed some cross-sensitivity to X-rays; mus-7 was highly sensitive to MMS and also to histidine, which inhibits various repair-defective mutants at concentrations well below those that reduce wild-type growth. None of these mus resemble mutants previously found in Neurospora, nor do they conform clearly to mutant types identified in E. coli or yeast. On the other hand mutants in 2 further genes, mus-11, and especially 2 alleles of mus-9, are very similar to uvs-3 of Neurospora and generally resemble mutants that are considered to be defective in "error-prone" repair. They were UV- as well as X-ray-sensitive, and showed strong spontaneous mutator effects but almost no increase in recessive lethal frequencies in heterokaryons after UV-treatments.     

The modification of induced genetic change in yeast by an amino acid analogue

Summary Treatment of diploid yeast cultures with the amino acid analogue, para-fluorophenylalanine (PFPA), at concentrations which caused inhibition of growth, resulted in up to 5 fold increases in the frequency of mitotic gene conversion at two different heteroallelic loci. With haploid yeast cultures, growth in PFPA increased the rate of forward mutation to canavanine resistance by at least 2 fold.Growth of diploids in PFPA prior to exposure to the deaminating agent nitrous acid, the cross-linking agent mitomycin C, the alkylating chemical ethylmethanesulphonate (EMS) and UV light resulted in significant changes in the potency of these diverse mutagens to induce intragenic recombination. For all four mutagens, increased frequencies of gene convertants/viable cell were observed in those cultures which had been exposed to the amino acid analogue prior to mutagen treatment. In haploid WT yeast cells, amino acid analogue incorporation resulted in an enhanced frequency of UV induced forward mutation to canavanine resistance whilst in a DNA repair deficient rad 6 mutant this interaction between UV and PFPA was abolished.The results have been interpreted on the basis of incorporation of the analogue into enzymes involved with DNA replication with a consequent loss of fidelity of such enzymes and increased errors in base incorporation.     

Antimutagenic effects in humans.

The application of antimutagenicity studies to human somatic mutation is discussed, with emphasis on the potential for future studies. Five assay-gene combinations are now available for measuring human somatic mutation in lymphocytes and erythrocytes. Results with these combinations have defined the human background levels, and show clear responses of mutant frequency to a variety of mutagens. The testing of antimutagenic effects on background frequencies is feasible, but has not yet been done. The major uncertainty in such studies is the unknown age of mutant cells in the background, since only the newly forming mutants are potentially susceptible to most antimutagenic treatments. Intervention studies in the face of active mutagenicity and the use of other genotoxicity endpoints, such as chromosome aberrations, micronuclei and DNA adducts, are considered briefly.     

Problems and pitfalls in assessing human T-lymphocyte mutant frequencies

The measurement of 6-thioguanine-resistant frequencies in human T-lymphocytes has been used to quantitate the in vivo HPRT mutant frequency. The data so far indicate a large variability in normal healthy individuals. The reliability with which wells are identified for clonal growth in the assay was investigated using 5 different methods of scoring: visual scoring, uptake of [3H]thymidine (either by cut off point or by statistical analysis), cell count and cytogenetic analysis. None of these methods presented a viable means of scoring the assay. An examination of the statistical precision of the assay under the limitations imposed by the experimental conditions leads to the conclusion that there is a large inherent error associated with the estimated mutant frequencies. Analysis of the T-lymphocyte subpopulations by cell surface monoclonal antibodies also leads us to believe that the observed mutant frequencies may not be representative of the true in vivo mutant frequencies. If the assay is to be used as a sensitive screen for individual or population exposure to possible mutagens, a closer understanding of the biology of the assay is indicated, and a comprehensive reevaluation of the methodology required. The utility of the system for studying qualitative aspects of human mutagenesis is not in doubt.     

Ataxia telangiectasia: the effects of chemical mutagens and x-rays on sister chromatid exchanges in blood lymphocytes

It is now possible to examine in detail exchanges between sister chromatids (SCEs) and to attempt to investigate the relationships of such exchanges to aberration formation and DNA-repair mechanisms. The frequency of SCEs is dramatically increased by chemical mutagens and may reflect the level of DNA damage. Lymphocytes from patients with ataxia telangiectasis (AT) show high levels of spontaneous chromosome damage and are hypersentive to ionising radiations and it was of interest to examine the levels of SCE induced in these cells by various mutagens. The frequencies of SCE after treatment with X=rays or three chemical mutagens were equivalent to those in normal cells. The effects of fluorodeoxyuridine and deoxycytidine on SCE frequencies were also tested.     

X-rays, microwaves and vinyl chloride monomer: their clastogenic and aneugenic activity, using the micronucleus assay on human lymphocytes.

Chromosome aberration assays, sister-chromatid exchange techniques and micronucleus assays are commonly used methods for biomonitoring genetic material damaged by chemical or physical agents. On the other hand, their aneugenic activity, which can lead to hypoploidy and may also be associated with carcinogenesis, has not been thoroughly investigated. In our study we chose the micronucleus assay with a new mathematical approach to separate clastogenic from aneugenic activity of three well-known mutagens (vinyl chloride monomer, X-rays and microwaves) on the genome of human somatic cells. The comparison of frequencies of size distribution of micronuclei in the lymphocytes of humans exposed to each of these three mutagens showed that X-rays and microwaves were preferentially clastogens while vinyl chloride monomer showed aneugenic activity as well. Microwaves possess some mutagenic characteristics typical of chemical mutagens.     

Respiration-deficient Chinese hamster cell mutants: genetic characterization.

We present here genetic experiments with a series of Chinese hamster cell mutants defective in oxidative energy metabolism. The mutations were all shown to be recessive in intraspecies hybrids. Thirty-five mutants were sorted into eight complementation groups, but one of these mutants failed to complement representatives of two distinct complementation groups. The possibility was raised that this is a cell carrying two mutations or a deletion. Because of the greatly different frequencies with which such mutants could be isolated from two different Chinese hamster cell lines, CCL16 (DON) and V79, the stability of representatives from each cell line was examined, and it was found that revertants could be obtained after treatment with mutagens, while spontaneous revertants appeared at unmeasurable or extremely low frequencies, with one exception. The mutant with a very noticeable frequency of spontaneous reversion was defective in mitochondrial protein synthesis, and the question arose whether the mutation was on the mitochondrial genome. A detailed fluctuation analysis of reversion rate and comparison with rates for other mutations was consistent with a nuclear mutation. This conclusion was supported by experiments involving fusions with cytoplasts.     

Mutational alterations induced in yeast by ionizing radiation

The cyc1-9 ochre (UAA) mutant and the cyc1-179 amber (UAG) mutant of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae were reverted with X-rays and -particles. The amino acid sequence changes of iso-1-cytochromes c from 36 of the intragenic revertants were determined by amino acid analysis and peptide mapping, aided by partial amino acid sequencing of 4 revertants. In addition, the DNA segments encompassing 3 unusual mutations with complex changes were cloned and sequenced. This study and previous studies of 16 other revertants of cyc1-9 and cyc1-179 revealed that ionizing radiation primarily induces single base-pair substitutions; 47 of the 52 revertants arose by transversions and transitions without any apparent preference. However, the A·T→T·A substitution at the first base pair for the cyc1-179 UAG codon, leading to the normal protein, was not detected, nor was it found previously in 32 revertants of cycl-179 obtained spontaneously or induced with various other mutagens; apparently, there is a prohibition of certain base-pair substitutions at certain sites in DNA. In addition, 5 of the 52 revertants arose by multiple changes within a short region of 11 base pairs. These consisted of the deletion of 6 base pairs, the substitution of 3 base pairs, and 3 different kinds of substitutions of two base pairs. Compared to other mutagens previously tested with the cyc1 system, ionizing radiation produces the most random types of base-pair substitutions.     

Inducible DNA-repair systems in yeast: competition for lesions

DNA lesions may be recognized and repaired by more than one DNA-repair process. If two repair systems with different error frequencies have overlapping lesion specificity and one or both is inducible, the resulting variable competition for the lesions can change the biological consequences of these lesions. This concept was demonstrated by observing mutation in yeast cells (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) exposed to combinations of mutagens under conditions which influenced the induction of error-free recombinational repair or error-prone repair. Total mutation frequency was reduced in a manner proportional to the dose of 60Co-gamma- or 254 nm UV radiation delivered prior to or subsequent to an MNNG exposure. Suppression was greater per unit radiation dose in cells gamma-irradiated in O2 as compared to N2. A rad3 (excision-repair) mutant gave results similar to wild-type but mutation in a rad52 (rec-) mutant exposed to MNNG was not suppressed by radiation. Protein-synthesis inhibition with heat shock or cycloheximide indicated that it was the mutation due to MNNG and not that due to radiation which had changed. These results indicate that MNNG lesions are recognized by both the recombinational repair system and the inducible error-prone system, but that gamma-radiation induction of error-free recombinational repair resulted in increased competition for the lesions, thereby reducing mutation. Similarly, gamma-radiation exposure resulted in a radiation dose-dependent reduction in mutation due to MNU, EMS, ENU and 8-MOP + UVA, but no reduction in mutation due to MMS. These results suggest that the number of mutational MMS lesions recognizable by the recombinational repair system must be very small relative to those produced by the other agents. MNNG induction of the inducible error-prone systems however, did not alter mutation frequencies due to ENU or MMS exposure but, in contrast to radiation, increased the mutagenic effectiveness of EMS. These experiments demonstrate that in this lower eukaryote, mutagen exposure does not necessarily result in a fixed risk of mutation, but that the risk can be markedly influenced by a variety of external stimuli including heat shock or exposure to other mutagens.     

Chromosomal instability in mutagen-sensitive mutants isolated from mouse lymphoma L5178Y cells. II. Abnormal induction of sister-chromatid exchanges and chromosomal aberrations by mutagens in an ionizing radiation-sensitive mutant (M10) and an alkylating agent-sensitive mutant (MS1)

To determine the mutual relationships between cell survival and induction of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) as well as chromosomal aberrations (CAs), mutagen-induced SCEs and CAs were analyzed in an ionizing radiation-sensitive mutant (M10) and an alkylating agent-sensitive mutant (MS 1) isolated from mouse lymphoma L5178Y cells. The levels of CA induction in both mutants strictly corresponded to the sensitivity to lethal effects of mutagens, except that caffeine-induced CAs in M10 are considerably lower than those in L5178Y. The results clearly indicate that except for caffeine-induced CAs in M10, mutagen-induced lethal lesions are responsible for CA induction. In contrast, SCE induction in mutants was complicated. In M10, hypersensitive to killing by gamma-rays, methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), and 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide (4NQO), but not sensitive to UV or caffeine, the frequency of SCEs induced by gamma-rays was barely higher than that in L5178Y, and the frequencies of MMS- and UV-induced SCEs were similar to those in L5178Y, but 4NQO- and caffeine-induced SCEs were markedly lower than those in L5178Y. MS 1, which is hypersensitive to MMS and caffeine, but not sensitive to UV or 4NQO, responded to caffeine with an enhanced frequency of SCEs and had a normal frequency of MMS-induced SCEs, but a reduced frequency of UV- and 4NQO-induced SCEs. Thus, susceptibility to SCE induction by mutagens is not necessarily correlated with sensitivity of mutants to cell killing and/or CA induction by mutagens. Furthermore, the spontaneous levels of SCEs are lower in M10 and higher in MS 1 than that in L5178Y (Tsuji et al., 1987). Based on these results, we speculate that M10 may be partially defective in the processes for the formation of SCEs caused by mutagens. On the other hand, MS 1 may modify SCE formation-related lesions induced by UV and 4NQO to some repair intermediates that do not cause SCE formation. In addition, MMS-induced lethal lesions in MS 1 may not be responsible for SCE induction whereas caffeine-induced lethal lesions are closely correlated with SCE induction. Thus, the lesions or mechanisms involved in SCE production are in part different from those responsible for cell lethality or CA production.     

Mutagenicity of the oral carcinogen 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide in cultured BigBlue rat tongue epithelial cells and fibroblasts

Environmental carcinogen exposures contribute to the development of oral cancer and improved test systems for the analysis of such carcinogens are needed. We have previously isolated and characterized an epithelial cell line from the tongue of a BigBlue rat. Now, we have established an immortalized fibroblast cell line from the same organ. We exposed these cells to 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide (NQO), a well-known experimental oral carcinogen in the rat and other species, and measured its cytotoxic and genotoxic (cII transgene mutagenesis) effects. Both cell lines were very sensitive to NQO toxicity and showed dose-dependent mutant frequency responses. At the highest NQO dose tested, 70 ng/ml, the mutant frequency was elevated more than eight-fold above background for the epithelial cells and more than 25-fold for the fibroblast cells. We examined cellular parameters which could affect glutathione-dependent detoxication of mutagens. Glutathione (GSH) contents of the two cell lines were similar. Glutathione transferase (GST) activities were measured with several substrates and were generally higher in the epithelial cells. Although multiple biochemical and biological characteristics of individual cell lines are likely to determine responses to mutagens, the greater sensitivity of the fibroblast cells to NQO mutagenicity is in accord with the lower GST activity and the lower DNA content of these cells. These new cell lines are suitable for in vitro testing of chemicals as possible oral mutagens and for studies of their biochemical mechanisms of action.     

Selection and Preliminary Characterization of Temperature-Sensitive Mutants of Type 5 Adenovirus

Eight temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants that replicate normally at 32 C but poorly, if at all, at 39.5 C have been isolated from mutagenized stocks of a wild-type strain of type 5 adenovirus. Three mutagens were employed: nitrous acid, hydroxylamine, and nitrosoguanidine. Ts mutants were isolated from mutagenized viral stocks with frequencies between 0.01 and 0.1%. All eight mutants had reversion frequencies of 10(-5) or less. Complementation experiments in doubly infected cultures at the nonpermissive temperature separated the mutants into three nonoverlapping complementation groups. Complementation yields ranged from a 2.3- to a 3,000-fold increase over the sums of the yields from the two singly infected controls. Genetic recombination was also demonstrated; approximate recombination frequencies ranged from 0.1 to 15%. Preliminary biochemical and immunological characterization of the mutants indicated that: (i) the single mutant in complementation group I did not replicate its deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) or synthesize late proteins at the nonpermissive temperature but did inhibit host DNA synthesis to 25% of an uninfected control; (ii) the four group II mutants replicated viral DNA, shut off host DNA synthesis, synthesized penton base and fiber, but did not synthesize immunologically detectable hexon; the three mutants in complementation group III synthesized viral DNA, shut off host DNA synthesis, and made immunologically reactive capsid proteins (hexon, penton base, and fiber).     

New Suppressors of Frameshift Mutations in SALMONELLA TYPHIMURIUM

Several new types of suppressor mutants have been isolated. These were identified among revertants of mutants originally generated by mutagens other than the acridine-derived ICR191. The new suppressors correct mutations other than those with runs of C or G which are recognized by the previously described suppressors. Several frameshift mutations are corrected by more than one suppressor type. Apparently, the DNA base sequence near these mutant sites includes sites of action for several distinct suppressor types.     

Influence of incorporated 5-bromodeoxyuridine on the frequencies of spontaneous and induced sister-chromatid exchanges, detected by immunological methods

We have utilized monoclonal antibody against BrdUrd to detect sister-chromatid exchanges in CHO cells. This technique allows detection of SCEs at very low levels of BrdUrd incorporation. At incorporation level of 0.5%, a frequency of about 2 SCEs/cell/cycle was found. In a UV-sensitive mutant (43-3B) which has an increased spontaneous frequency of SCEs, it is found that this increase is due to incorporated BrdUrd. In MMS- and MMC-treated cells, an influence of BrdUrd on the frequencies of induced SCEs was found only when high concentrations of mutagens were employed.     

Epistasis, photoreactivation and mutagen sensitivity of DNA repair mutants upr-1 and mus-26 in Neurospora crassa

Double mutants were constructed combining mus-26, formerly designated uvs-(SA3B), with other UV-sensitive mutants. Tests of sensitivity of these double mutants to UV and to chemical mutagens revealed that mus-26 and upr-1 belong to the same epistatic group. The UV dose-response curve of mus-26 showed a characteristic plateau in the range of 100-200 J/m2. The same characteristic was also shown in the dose-response curves of upr-1 and the double mutant, upr-1 mus-26. Photoreactivation of UV damage in mus-26, upr-1 and upr-1 mus-26 was defective but not null. Assays were made of the reversion rate of ad-8 in strains that also carried UV-sensitive mutations. The reversion frequencies of the strains with upr-1 and upr-1 mus-26 were very low for the UV dose range below 300 J/m2, similarly to mus-26. Previously reported homozygous sterility of mus-26 was not caused by the mus-26 locus itself, and fertile strains were obtained among progeny. The results of this study suggest that mus-26 and upr-1 have similar properties in DNA repair.     

Factors affecting the quantitation of dose-response curves for mutation induction in V79 Chinese hamster cells after exposure to chemical and physical mutagens.

Using four common mutagens, ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS), methyl methanesulphonate (mms), uv, and X-irradiation, the relationship between dose of mutagen, cellular lethality and frequency of 8-azaguanine resistant colonies in V79 Chinese hamster cells has been examined. Several factors affecting the recovery of mutants including inter and intra-clone metabolic co-operation have been quantitated and their influence on survival response curves examined. Induced mutant frequencies were assayed by two methods in situ, and after replating. After exposure to X-rays, MMS and UV a significantly higher frequency of mutants was observed in replated experiments as compared with the in situ situation, at all survival levels assayed. With EMS, an increment on replating was observed only at high survival levels. The replating data suggest that two types of azgr colonies are produced, i.e. those which contain only azgr cells and those which, due to damage segregation, contain a mixture of azgr and azg8 cells. These mixed colonies appear to be lost by metabolic co-operation when mutation frequencies are assayed in silu. The proportion of mixed to homogeneous colonies differs with different mutagens. Taking into account such factors, EMS and UV irradiation were similarly mutagenic at a given survival level, but at equitoxic doses, fewer mutants were recovered after exposure of V79 cells to MMS and X-rays.     

Induction by Mutagens of Tandem Gene Duplications in the glyS Region of the ESCHERICHIA COLI Chromosome

Four mutagens (ultraviolet light, nitrous acid, the acridine half mustard ICR 372, and niridazole) have been found to increase the frequency of tandem gene duplications in the glyS region of the Escherichia coli chromosome. This result was obtained by quantitating the spontaneous and mutagen-induced reversion frequency of a glycyl-tRNA synthetase (glyS) mutant. Following mutagenesis, as many as 0.2% of the survivors were observed to contain duplications in the glyS region. In addition, several classes of stable revertants of the glyS mutant have been identified.     

Mutagenic specificity in reovirus.

Mutagenic specificity in response to chemical mutagens has been observed with certain temperature-sensitive mutants of reovirus type 3. One mutant induced by nitrous acid reverted specifically with nitrous acid. Three nitrosoguanidine-induced mutants reverted after nitrous acid treatment. These findings thus suggest that analysis of chemical induction of reversion from the temperature-sensitive phenotype may be a useful approach for studying the nature of mutation in animal viruses.