Immune memory expression to Tnp-Ficoll in CB.20 mice: evidence for a multigenic control

Trinitrophenyl (Tnp)-Ficoll, a class 2 thymus-independent (TI) antigen, generates in most mouse strains Tnp-specific B-memory cells which can be detected in situ 1 week after priming by a heterologous stimulation with Tnp-lipopolysaccharide (LPS) but not by a homologous Tnp-Ficoll challenge. We have investigated the secondary responses raised in CB.20 congenic mice by a homologous challenge in situ occurring at various time intervals after priming. We report that a memory-type response is obtained, culminating when the challenge is performed at 4 weeks; this finding assesses definitely the ability of TI-2 antigens to produce immunological memory under standard conditions. However, the same immunization procedure elicits no memory-type response in the majority of other mouse strains, suggesting a possible genetic control of the expression of memory to class 2 TI antigens. The utilization of F1 hybrids between C57BL/6 and BALB/c and of appropriate congenic strains shows indeed that this memory expression is under multigenic control: Igh-V or closely linked genes are clearly involved but a complementation with other gene(s), located outside the H-2 complex, is required for a memory-type response to Tnp-Ficoll. We have also analyzed the secondary heterologous response to Tnp-LPS in CB.20 mice at different times after Tnp-Ficoll priming. The difference in the kinetic profile of the heterologous (TI-2----TI-1) versus homologous (TI-2----TI-2) secondary responses is discussed in terms of B-memory-cell ontogeny and humoral regulation.     

Generation of immune memory by haptenated derivatives of thymus-independent antigens in C57BL/6 mice. I. The differentiation of memory B lymphocytes into antibody-secreting cells depends on the nature of the thymus-independent carrier used for memory induction and/or revelation

It has been previously reported that trinitrophenylated lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS), a thymus-independent (TI)-1 antigen, elicits an anamnestic response to TNP in C57BL/6 mice. The ability of these mice to mount a secondary response to TI-2 antigens was analyzed. Priming with DNP-Ficoll or DNP-Dextran, both TI-2 antigens, resulted in an increased frequency of TNP-binding B lymphocytes. Evidence is presented that memory cell-induction by DNP-Ficoll does not require functional T cells. The differentiation into antibody-forming cells (AFC) of memory cells generated by DNP-Dextran or DNP-Ficoll cannot be obtained by a challenge with either antigen. There was no indication that the lack of a secondary response to TI-2 antigens was related to suppressive T cells interfering with memory expression. Memory cells induced by DNP-Dextran or DNP-Ficoll can nevertheless be activated by TNP-LPS. In contrast to the restricted sensitivity of TNP-memory cells generated by TI-2 antigens, TNP-LPS-induced memory cells are indifferently susceptible to TI-1 or TI-2 antigenic stimulation. These results are discussed in terms of memory B-cell subpopulations.     

Expression of IgG memory response in vitro to thymus-dependent and thymus-independent antigens

A model is described in which expression of IgG secondary antihapten responses of large magnitude can be initiated in vitro without resorting to in vivo boosting prior to culture. The number of IgG plaque-forming cells (PFC) is frequently as much as 100-fold greater than that of IgM PFC. Spleen cells from mice primed with trinitrophenylated keyhole limpet hemocyanin (TNP-KLH) several months earlier are stimulated in vitro to produce an anti-TNP plaque-forming cell response 7–10 days later. The in vitro IgG response can be elicited with either a thymus-dependent antigen (TNP-KLH) or thymus-independent antigens (TNP-T₄ bacteriophage or DNP-dextran). The kinetics of the responses to these two forms of antigen differ in that the thymus-independent response peaks two days earlier. The IgG response to both forms of antigen requires the presence of 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) even though macrophages are not depleted prior to culture. In the absence of the reducing agent both thymus-dependent and thymus-independent IgG responses were diminished ≥90%. The magnitude of the response to thymus-independent antigens emphasizes the ability of these materials to elicit IgG expression in memory B cells provided optimal conditions for memory development and in vitro expression exist.     

Anti-Ia inhibits the activity of B cells but not a T cell-derived helper mediator

The effects of addition of anti-Ia sera to cultures of B cells responding to a number of different stimuli were studied. Anti-Ia sera inhibited the responses of B cells to thymus-dependent and thymus-independent antigens. The effects of antisera directed at different subregions within theI region were examined, using the same anti-Ia serum and mouse strains congenic atI. There was some indication that antisera directed at theI-C region might be more efficient at inhibiting responses to a thymus-independent antigen than to a thymus-dependent antigen. An antiserum to another B-cell surface component controlled by theH-2 complex, the D glycoprotein, had no effect on the response of B cells to a thymus-dependent antigen. By contrast, anti-Ia serum added to cultures had no effect on the activity of a T cell-derived, nonspecific, B-cell helper mediator (NSM). We concluded that the binding of anti-Ia sera to B-cell surfaces inhibited B-cell responses to antigen, either by competing directly with the binding of signal molecules, or by delivering an inhibitory signal to the B cell, such that it was subsequently refractory to stimulatory signals.     

Delayed maturation of the antibody response to type 2 thymus-independent antigens in a partially inbred strain of chicken

The ontogeny of antibody responses to trinitrophenylated (TNP) thymus-independent (TI) antigens was compared in two partially inbred strains of chicken: the SC strain (B2/B2 genotype) and the FP strain (B15/B22 genotype). In the SC chicken, maturation of both the splenic anti-TNP plaque-forming cell (PFC) response and the 19S hemagglutinating antibody response to TI type 2 (TI-2) antigens, TNP-Ficoll and TNP-dextran, were delayed to a significantly later time in ontogeny (20 wk of age) than in the FP chickens (9 wk of age). Four- to 6-wk-old SC chickens were virtually immunologically unresponsive to stimulation with TI-2 antigens. The TI-1 antigen TNP-Brucella abortus was equally immunogenic in both FP and SC chickens of different age groups tested. Kinetic studies of the primary PFC response to TNP-Ficoll in immunologically mature chickens of the SC and FP strains demonstrated a peak PFC response 4 days after antigen injection, followed by a rapid decline in numbers of splenic PFC/spleen on day 6. The results of these studies are discussed in relation to earlier observations that suggested there may be a delay or a defect in the ontogeny of the thymus in the SC chicken.     

Mechanism of the suppressive effect of interferon on antibody synthesis in vivo.

Mouse interferon preparations significantly suppress the in vivo antibody response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC), a thymus-dependent antigen, and to Salmonella typhimurium lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a thymus-independent antigen. It is also possible to effect the late responses of antigen sensitive "memory" cells observed during secondary immunization by administration of interferon prior to primary immunization. The immunosuppressive activity of interferon was time- and dose-dependent. Maximum suppression was produced when animals were given 1.5 times 10-5 units of interferon between 4 and 48 hr before antigenic stimulation. These findings suggested that interferon affects some early event(s) in the process of antibody synthesis which might be related to the general inhibitory effect of interferon on rapidly dividing cells and viral m-RNA translation. In addition, the use of nonadherent spleen cell cultures from interferon-treated mice, immunized in vitro with a thymus-independent antigen, indicated that in this situation the inhibitory effect of interferon was due to an action on B lymphocytes. A variety of soluble "suppressive" factors are secreted by T cells as a consequence of activation by mitogens or specific antigens in vitro. Since T cells are recognized as one of the sources of interferon, it is suggested that interferon should be investigated as a suppressor T cell-produced lymphokine which can regulate B cell expression.     

Functional heterogeneity of virgin and memory B murine lymphocytes revealed by the utilization of cyclosporin A: an overview

The effects of cyclosporin A on the generation and revelation of B memory cells by thymus-independent (TI) antigens was investigated. A class 1 (TNP-LPS) and a class 2 (TNP-Ficoll) TI antigens were used for priming an elicitation. Evidence is presented that cyclosporin A does not interfere with the generation of hapten-specific (TNP) B memory cells by TNP-LPS or DNP-Ficoll. Cyclosporin A does not affect the revelation of B memory cells by TNP-LPS, but inhibits their revelation by TNP-Ficoll. These findings are discussed in terms of two distinct B cell lineages leading to antibody-forming cells and memory cells precursors, and in terms of heterogeneity of B memory cells.     

Carrier-specific immune memory to a thymus-independent antigen in congenitally athymic mice.

Immune memory to the DNP epitope coupled to a nonmitogenic thymus-independent carrier, Ficoll, was demonstrated in congenitally athymic outbred Swiss mice. Strong IgM and modest IgG components of this memory were detected. Moreover, this memory was carrier specific since it was elicitable only when DNP-Ficoll primed mice were challenged with DNP-Ficoll and not when similarly primed mice were challenged with DNP coupled to pneumococcal polysaccharide or to keyhole limpet hemocyanin. Ficoll primed mice also demonstrated a memory response when challenged with DNP-Ficoll. These findings indicate that a non-T cell, presumably a B cell, is capable of recognizing the carrier epitopes of this thymus-independent hapten-carrier complex. Unlike their athymic counterparts, euthymic mice of the same genetic background failed to demonstrate the IgM component of this memory, but they did demonstrate modest carrier-specific IgG memory. These results strongly suggest that suppressor T cells are either directly or indirectly important in regulating the IgM memory response of these mice to DNP-Ficoll. Indirect regulation could possibly occur via an antibody-mediated specific immune suppression mechanism.     

Antibody formation in mouse bone marrow. II. Evidence for a memory-dependent phenomenon

Mouse bone marrow is barely capable of plaque-forming cell (PFC) activity in a primary response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC), while PFC activity in the secondary response to SRBC can be clearly demonstrated. This phenomenon was studied by means of cell transfer experiments.T cells, which are involved in an anti-SRBC PFC response, were shown to be very scarce in normal mouse bone marrow. This is considered to be the cause of the low PFC activity in the marrow during the primary response to SRBC.In normal mouse bone marrow precursors of IgM-PFC but not of IgG- and IgA-PFC could be found. Priming with SRBC induced the appearance of IgM-, IgG-, IgA- and T-memory cells in the marrow. These B- and T-memory cells were shown to be specific for the antigen which induced their appearance. It is thought that after a second injection of SRBC the IgM-, IgG- and IgA-memory cells can differentiate with the help of the T-memory cells within the bone marrow into IgM-, IgG- and IgA-PFC respectively.The sequence of appearance of the B-memory cells in the bone marrow was shown to be IgM-IgG-IgA.Six months after the intravenous injection of SRBC, the presence of B-memory cells could be demonstrated not only in spleen and bone marrow, but also in peripheral lymph nodes, mesenteric lymph node, Peyer's patches, thymus and blood. The increase in amount of B-memory cells was most prominent in the spleen.     

In vitro studies of the genetically determined unresponsiveness to thymus-independent antigens in CBA/N mice.

The X-chromosome-linked B lymphocyte defect of CBA/N mice has been studied in vitro by comparing the ability of (CBA/N X DBA/2)F1 (X-/X- X X+/Y) male (X-/Y) and female (X-/X+) spleen cells to respond to the thymus-independent antigen DNP (or TNP)-AECM-Ficoll. (CBA/N X DBA/2)F1 male spleen cells failed to generate significant in vitro anti-TNP antibody responses to DNP- or TNP-AECM-Ficoll, in contrast to spleen cells from F1 female (X-/X+) mice which responded normally to these T-independent antigens. Spleen cells from male F1 mice responded almost as well as F1 female cells to the thymus-dependent antigen, TNP-sheep red blood cells (TNP-SRBC) in vitro. Adding F1 male cells to F1 female cells failed to reduce the response of the latter to DNP-AECM-Ficoll, suggesting that the inability of F1 male cells to respond was not due to active suppression. The response of F1 male spleen cells to TNP-SRBC was not impaired by adding high concentrations of TNP-AECM-Ficoll indicating that the mechanism of unresponsiveness was not tolerance induction in all TNP-specific precursors. Lymphocytes from F1 male mice were capable of forming anti-TNP antibody after stimulation with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in high concentrations; DNP-AECM-Ficoll had no effect on this polyclonal response. B lymphocytes from mice bearing only the X-chromosome of the CBA/N strain thus display a profound defect in B cell activation. This functional defect may represent either an inability of the defective B cells to be activated by thymus-independent antigens or the absence of a sub-class of B cells which respond to thymus-independent antigens.     

Temperature-mediated processes in immunity: differential effects of low temperature on mouse T helper cell responses

A low culture temperature of 27 degrees C inhibited mouse primary in vitro anti-hapten plaque-forming cell responses to a thymus-dependent (TD) antigen (Ag) (trinitrophenyl-keyhole limpet hemocyanin, TNP-KLH). In contrast, the magnitudes of secondary responses to TNP-KLH or primary responses to a thymus-independent (TI) Ag (TNP-lipopolysaccharide (LPS)) were unaffected. The low-temperature-sensitive step in the primary TD response occurred relatively early and preceded interleukin 2 (IL-2) secretion. Furthermore, the low-temperature-induced suppression could be obviated (rescued) by recombinant IL-2 or IL-4, but not by IL-1. Thus, the low temperature appeared to inhibit the function of virgin Th cells by preferentially affecting T cell-derived interleukin synthesis/secretion and not other cellular activities. These results also imply fundamental differences between the activation requirements of memory and virgin Th cells.     

Concanavalin A supernatant recruits antigen-insensitive IgG memory B lymphocyte precursors into an antigen-sensitive precursor pool

Spleen cells from mice primed to trinitrophenyl-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (TNP-KLH) generate IgG anti-TNP memory responses when stimulated in vitro with either thymus-dependent (TD) or thymus-independent (TI) forms of the hapten. When supernatants from Con A-stimulated spleen cells (Con A Sup) were added to such secondary cultures the TI responses to DNP-dextran or TNP-T4 were augmented; the TD response to TNP-KLH was suppressed. Passage over Sephadex and addition of alpha-methyl-D-mannoside did not inhibit augmentation by Con A Sup, indicating that augmentation did not result from direct action of the lectin on the responding cells. Augmentation occurred equally well in cultures that had been depleted of T cells by treatment with anti-Thy-1.2 and complement. Limiting dilution analyses revealed that Con A Sup increased the frequency of TI-responding precursors approximately threefold while causing a concomitant decrease in TD-responding precursors. To determine the relationship of the additional TI precursors and those normally detected in the absence of Con A Sup, the TI-responding IgG precursors were first eliminated through selective suicide by using DNP-dextran plus BUdR and light treatment; subsequently no TI-responding IgG PFC could be detected to DNP-dextran unless Con A Sup was also added. The data suggest Con A Sup may augment the TI responses to DNP-dextran and TNP-T4 by recruiting additional precursors from a memory cell pool formerly insensitive to these forms of antigen.     

The influence of epitope density on the immunological properties of hapten-protein conjugates. I. Characteristics of the immune response to hapten-coupled albumen with varying epitope density

The relationship between the epitope density of hapten-protein conjugates (DNP· BSA), and their immunogenicity in mice has been investigated. As others have found, lightly substituted protein (DNP₅BSA) elicited primary and secondary antibody responses which were mainly IgG. In contrast, DNP₅₀BSA induced a primary IgM response with relatively little IgG, and little or no immunological memory. The transition in immunogenic behaviour from “low” to “high” occurred with a hapten: protein molar ratio around 30. DNP₅₀BSA does not contain any serologically detectable native BSA determinants or neodeterminants resulting from dinitrophenylation. Although this antigen elicits a mainly IgM response as do thymus-independent antigens, antibody production to both DNP₅BSA and DNP₅₀BSA is highly thymus dependent. The possible reasons for the thymus dependence of immune responsiveness to highepitope-density hapten-protein conjugates are discussed.     

Cellular events in tolerance IX: Maintenance of immunological tolerance in the presence of normal B-cell precursors and in the absence of demonstrable suppression

The cellular events involved in immunological tolerance to fluoresceinated sheep gammaglobulin (FL-SGG) were analyzed at the level of hapten-specific B cells. One single iv injection of FL-SGG induced tolerance as measured by challenge with thymus-dependent (FL-KLH) or thymus-independent (FL-Ficoll) antigens in vivo or thymus-independent (FL-LPS) antigen in vitro. As noted earlier, unresponsiveness was maintained until 6–8 weeks after tolerance induction. Limiting-dilution precursor analysis demonstrated a reduction in B-cell precursors on Day 7 after tolerogen treatment; precursor frequencies returned to control levels by 3–4 weeks. This recovery of precursors in the presence of stable tolerance was not due to suppressor activity. Rather, results show that tolerant hapten-specific B cells are clonally anergic and display a reduced burst size in response to antigen. Hence, unresponsiveness is maintained in the presence of apparently normal precursor levels by an intrinsic defect in antigen-specific B cells.     

In vivo immune response to TNP hapten coupled to thymus-independent carrier lipopolysaccharide

Lipopolysaccharide has been utilized as a carrier for the TNP hapten, producing an antigen which induces an in vivo thymus-independent antibody response to TNP as determined using athymic nude mice and their normal littermates. The immune response to TNP-LPS was investigated at both the antibody-forming cell and the serum antibody levels.The primary response to an optimal dose of TNP-LPS (1.0 μg) exhibited unusual kinetics reaching a sharp peak on day 3 of 58,000 anti-TNP PFC/spleen. Serum antibody to TNP was first detected on day 3 and reached a maximum log₂ titer of 17.5 on day 5, an uncommonly high level for hapten-carrier conjugates and most carriers. Both the anti-TNP serum antibody and PFCs were exclusively IgM. No IgG antibody was detected in the primary response through 28 days postimmunization, nor was any detected in any experiment described in this paper. The primary PFC response to 1.0 μg of TNP-LPS was specific for TNP, producing no evidence of polyclonal antibody synthesis. The relative affinities of PFC-secreted antibody were investigated using hapten inhibition. The hapten inhibition curves for TNP-LPS and TNP-SRBC were very similar, indicating that relatively high affinity antibody was elicited by TNP-LPS. The secondary response to this dose following priming with TNP-SRBC or TNP-LPS was similar to the primary response, though the peak was less sharp in both cases. The response to the homologous secondary challenge shifted somewhat, reaching a peak on days 3–4. The effect of various doses in priming or challenging for the secondary response to TNP-LPS was investigated. Using an increased PFC response as a criterion, no dose was optimal for priming or immunological memory to TNP-LPS. While the adoptive primary response to TNP-LPS reached a low level peak on day 7, the adoptive secondary attained a maximum on day 6. This shift in kinetics in intact mice and in adoptive hosts in comparing primary to secondary responses indicated that a state of B cell priming may be induced. However, its full expression may be suppressed by endogenous factors at the time of priming, such as the high level of circulating anti-TNP antibody or residual antigen. Adoptive transfer would remove the cells from these influences, allowing such B cell priming to manifest itself fully.     

Isolation and characterization of an I-A-restricted T cell clone with dual specificity for poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) (GAT) and Mlsa,dl

We have isolated a BALB/c (H-2d, Mlsb) T cell clone (JTL-G12) specific for the synthetic polypeptide antigen poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) (GAT) in the context of self I-A determinants and for Mlsa,d antigens in the absence of GAT. JTL-G12 proliferation in response to GAT was mapped to the Kd, I-Ad subregions by using inbred H-2 congenic and recombinant strains. In addition, monoclonal antibody directed against I-Ad but not Kd or I-As determinants blocked JTL-G12 proliferation in response to GAT presented by syngeneic splenocytes, indicating I-A restriction. The Mls cross-reactivity of this clone was verified by using a panel of inbred strains bearing the Mlsa,b,c,d alleles and by using BXD recombinant inbred strains bearing the Mlsa allele or the Mlsb allele. All of the Mlsa BXD strains of the H-2d or H-2b haplotypes stimulated JTL-G12 in the absence of GAT, whereas all of the Mlsb BXD strains were nonstimulatory. This response pattern is in complete accordance with recognition of the Mlsa determinant encoded by Mls or closely linked loci on chromosome 1. JTL-G12 proliferation in response to GAT/I-Ad and Mlsa,d determinants could be blocked with a monoclonal antibody (GK1.5) directed against L3T4, a structure involved in class II major histocompatibility complex antigen recognition. These results suggest that antigen/class II responsiveness, Mls reactivity, and expression of L3T4 can be properties of a single T cell population.     

Anti-immunoglobulin antibodies. V. Age-dependent variation of clones stimulated by polysaccharide TI-2 antigens in 129 and MRL mice spontaneously producing anti-gamma-globulin antibodies

The nature of the immune response to two conventional polysaccharide thymus-independent (TI) antigens was investigated in two RF-producing mouse strains, the 129/Sv and MRL/1 pr, as well as in their normal congenic counterparts, 129/J and MRL +/+ animals. An age-dependent variation of clones specific for the TI-2 antigens bacterial levan (BL) and alpha 1, 3 dextran B1355 (Dex) was observed in 129/J mice. Surprisingly, the anti-BL and anti-Dex responses observed for young (1-mo-old) 129/Sv mice far exceeded those of their age-matched controls indicating an accelerated ontogenic development of the immune response to TI-2 antigens. A poor response was observed for both MRL +/+ and MRL/1 pr mice after immunization with BL. More importantly, MRL mice, unlike other H-2k, Igh.Ca strains, were unresponsive to Dex in CFA or saline. MRL mice, however, could respond to the T-dependent form of this antigen, Dex-KLH, suggesting that these mice lack the subset of B cells required to respond to TI-2 antigens. Finally, the most striking observation was the occurrence of isotype-specific RF subsequent to immunization with these antigens in animals prone to develop RF, as well as in aged animals that do not spontaneously produce RF.     

The effect of captivity on the immune response of the killifish, Fundulus heteroclitus L.

Fundulus heteroclitus maintained under laboratory for more than four weeks showed a significantly lower immunocytoadherence (rosette) response to thymus-dependent antigens (SRBC and DNP-BSA) than newly captured fish. There was no comparable effect on scale allograft rejection nor in the response to a thymus-independent antigen (DNP-Ficoll) as measured by the rosette response. This suggests that captivity has a differential effect on a sub-population of lymphocytes analogous to the T-helper cells of mammals.     

Induction of protective immunity against Schistosoma mansoni by a nonliving vaccine. II. Response of mouse strains with selective immune defects

The efficacy of a new vaccination procedure against Schistosoma mansoni, involving intradermal injection of nonliving antigen combined with the bacterial adjuvant Mycobacterium bovis strain bacillus Calmette Guérin, was tested in several strains of mice. Development of protection against subsequent infection was compared with in vivo skin test reactivity and in vitro humoral reactivity to soluble and surface-associated schistosome antigens. Significant levels of resistance and immune response were displayed by many inbred mouse strains, including C57BL/6J, C3H/HeN, and CBA/J, as well as outbred Swiss-Webster mice. However, no definite correlation was observed between the level of any particular immune response and the level of resistance to challenge S. mansoni infection. Development of protective immunity was also examined in mice with various immune defects, to determine whether these responses are relevant to resistance in this model. Animals with defective specific immediate hypersensitivity response due to deficiencies in IgE (SJL/J) or mast cell (W/Wv) production displayed strong resistance as a result of immunization. Likewise, mice bearing the lpsd (C3H/HeJ) or xid (CBA/N) mutations, affecting cellular or humoral response to certain thymus-independent antigens, developed significant levels of resistance after immunization. A/J mice, with defects in cellular recognition of bacterial endotoxin as well as deficiencies in natural killer cell activity and complement function, also showed significant protective immunity. Thus, these reactivities do not appear to be essential to the resistance against S. mansoni induced by the nonliving vaccine. Two nonresponder strains were identified, P and BALB/c. P mice were defective in specific delayed hypersensitivity response as well as resistance to infection. However, BALB/c mice showed no obvious immune deficiencies at the time of challenge. These results agreed with previous findings in mice immunized by exposure to radiation-attenuated cercariae with one exception; BALB/c mice were protected by vaccination with irradiated cercariae but not by the nonliving vaccine. Thus, further examination of immune response in mice identified in this study as high and low responder strains should allow characterization of critical immune resistance mechanisms induced by the nonliving vaccine, as well as immune mechanisms operating in common between these two models of resistance to S. mansoni.     

Inactivation of antigen-responsive clones with antisera specific for IgM or IgD.

The present study examines the isotype of cell surface immunoglobulins involved in triggering a response to thymus-dependent and thymus-independent antigens. Antibodies to immunoglobulin isotypes were used to block the in vitro interaction of receptor IgD and IgM with antigen. The results indicate that both IgD and IgM are necessary to trigger a response to TNP-SRBC but that only IgM is required for responsiveness to TNP-Brucella. Limiting dilution studies indicate that the inhibition of the immune response by antibody occurs at the level of precursor activation and suggest that there is no effect of antibody on subsequent proliferation of the daughter cells.