Expression of genes for resistance to potato virus Y in potato plants and protoplasts

Plants of several potato clones with major gene resistance to potato virus Y (PVY) developed necrotic local lesions and systemic necrosis after manual inoculation with common (PVY_o) or veinal necrosis (PVY_N) strains of the virus. The clones reacted similarly, although their resistance genes are thought to be derived from four different wild species of Solarium. Mesophyll protoplasts from each clone became infected when inoculated with RNA of PVY_o by the polyethylene glycol method. The proportion of protoplasts infected, assessed by staining with fluorescent antibody to virus particles, was similar to that of protoplasts of susceptible potato cultivars. In contrast, plants of potato cultivars Corine and Pirola, which possess gene Ry from S. stoloniferum, developed few or no symptoms when manually inoculated or grafted with PVY_o. Moreover, only very few protoplasts of these cultivars produced virus particle antigen after inoculation with PVY_o RNA. The extreme resistance to PVY of cvs Corine and Pirola was therefore expressed by inoculated protoplasts whereas the resistance of the necrotic-reacting potato clones was not.     

The novel gene Ny-1 on potato chromosome IX confers hypersensitive resistance to Potato virus Y and is an alternative to Ry genes in potato breeding for PVY resistance

Hypersensitive resistance (HR) is an efficient defense strategy in plants that restricts pathogen growth and can be activated during host as well as non-host interactions. HR involves programmed cell death and manifests itself in tissue collapse at the site of pathogen attack. A novel hypersensitivity gene, Ny-1, for resistance to Potato virus Y (PVY) was revealed in potato cultivar Rywal. This is the first gene that confers HR in potato plants both to common and necrotic strains of PVY. The locus Ny-1 mapped on the short arm of potato chromosome IX, where various resistance genes are clustered in Solanaceous genomes. Expression of HR was temperature-dependent in cv. Rywal. Strains PVY^O and PVY^N, including subgroups PVY^NW and PVY^NTN, were effectively localized when plants were grown at 20°C. At 28°C, plants were systemically infected but no symptoms were observed. In field trials, PVY was restricted to the inoculated leaves and PVY-free tubers were produced. Therefore, the gene Ny-1 can be useful for potato breeding as an alternative donor of PVY resistance, because it is efficacious in practice-like resistance conferred by Ry genes.     

Transfer of resistance to potato leafroll virus, potato virus Y and potato virus X from Solarium brevidens to S. tuberosum through symmetric and designed asymmetric somatic hybridisation

Resistance to potato leafroll virus (PLRV), potato virus Y (PVY^o) and potato virus X (PVX) was studied in symmetric and asymmetric somatic hybrids produced by electrofusion between Solanum brevidens (2n=2×=24) and dihaploid S. tuberosum (2n=2×=24), and also in regenerants (B-hybrids) derived through protoplast culture from a single somatic hybrid (chromosome number 48). All of the somatic hybrids between 5. brevidens and the two dihaploid lines of potato cv. Pito were extremely resistant to PLRV and PVY^oand moderately resistant to PVX, irrespective of their chromosome number and ploidy level (tetraploid or hexaploid). Most (56%) of the asymmetric hybrids of irradiated S. brevidens and the dihaploid line of potato cv. Pentland Crown (PDH40) had high titres of PVY^osimilar to those of PDH40, whereas the rest of the hybrids had PVY^otitres less than a tenth of those in PDH40. Three B-hybrids had a highly reduced chromosome number (27, 30 and 34), but were however as resistant to PLRV, PVY^oand PVX as 5. brevidens. Two asymmetric hybrids and one B-hybrid were extremely resistant to PLRV but susceptible to both PVY and PVX. The results suggested that resistance to PLRV in 5. brevidens is controlled by a gene or genes different from those controlling resistance to PVY and PVX, and the gene(s) for resistance to PVY and PVX are linked in S. brevidens.     

Expression of the PVYO coat protein (CP) under the control of the PVX CP gene leader sequence: protection under greenhouse and field conditions against PVYO and PVYN infection in three potato cultivars

Coat protein-mediated resistance (CPMR), resistance conferred as a result of the expression of viral coat proteins in transgenic plants, has been illustrated to be an effective way of protecting plants against several plant viruses. Nonetheless, consistent protection has not been achieved for transgenic plants expressing the coat protein of potato virus Y (PVY), the type member of the potyvirus family. In this report, three different potato cultivars were transformed with a chimeric construct consisting of the capsid protein (CP) coding sequences of PVY flanked by the AUG codon and the translational enhancer from the coat protein gene of potato virus X (PVX). These cultivars were shown to express high levels of PVY CP and confer a high degree of protection against PVY^o and PVY^N under both greenhouse and field conditions. In addition, transgenic plants infected with potato virus A (PVA), a related potyvirus, exhibited a delay in virus accumulation, which could be easily overcome with increasing virus concentrations. Received: 26 October 1995 / Accepted: 14 June 1996     

Extreme resistance to potato virus V in clones of Solanum tuberosum that are also resistant to potato viruses Y and A: evidence for a locus conferring broad-spectrum potyvirus resistance

 Extreme resistance to the potato V potyvirus (PVV) was found in four potato cultivars that contain Ry genes from Solanum stoloniferum. When plants of these cultivars, were inoculated by grafting in shoot tips from PVV-infected tomato plants, necrotic symptoms developed in some cultivars, although a full hypersensitive reaction was not elicited, while other cultivars were symptomless. PVV replication was not detected in any of the inoculated plants by ELISA, an infectivity assay of leaf extracts by manual inoculation to Nicotiana benthamiana indicator plants, or by ‘return grafting’ of shoot tips taken from newly developed shoots of the potato plants to virus-free indicator plants of tomato. These methods readily detected PVV infection in inoculated plants of cv ‘Flourball’, which does not contain an Ry gene and is susceptible, and in cvs ‘Maris Piper’ and ‘Dr Macintosh’, which contain gene Nv conditioning a hypersensitive reaction to inoculation. One of the Ry-containing cultivars, ‘Barbara’, has been previously shown to contain two genes that control extreme resistance, defined as no viral replication in intact plants, to the potyviruses potato viruses Y and A (PVY and PVA). These genes are: Ry _sto , which conditions resistance to PVY and PVA, and gene Ra, which conditions resistance to PVA only. It was found that in genotypes from a progeny of the cross ‘Barbara’ (Ry _sto /Ra)בFlourball’ (ry/ra), extreme resistance to PVV segregated with gene Ry _sto . It is proposed that either gene Ry _sto conditions broad-spectrum extreme resistance to the distinct potyviruses PVY, PVA, and PVV or that Ry _sto represents a family of genetically closely linked genes each controlling resistance to a specific virus. Received: 27 December 1996 / Accepted: 9 June 1997     

Novel resistances to four potyviruses in tuber-bearing potato species, and temperature-sensitive expression of hypersensitive resistance to potato virus Y

Novel potyvirus resistance specificities were found in eight tested wild potato species (clones): hypersensitive resistance (HR) to potato Y potyvirus (PVY) strain groups PVY^O in Solanum megistacrolobum and S. polyadenium and PVY^N in S. stoloniferum; HR to potato V potyvirus (PW) in S. maglia, S. polyadenium, S. stoloniferum, S. sparsipilum and S. sucrense, HR to potato A potyvirus (PVA) strain group 1 in S. sucrense, and extreme resistance (ER) to PVA in S. polyadenium. S. commersonii and S. stoloniferum expressed HR to tobacco etch potyvirus (TEV) which has not been reported previously in potato species. The studied clone of S. stoloniferum expressed HR to all potyviruses and potyvirus strains tested. The clone of S. stoloniferum (2n = 48; nuclear DNA content (2C) = 3.6 pg) and S. chacoense (2n = 24; 2C=1.9 pg) were crossed and one hybrid (2n = 36; 2C = 2.9 pg) was obtained. The hybrid expressed HR to all tested potyviruses except PVA, which indicated that HR to PVA was controlled by a gene which is different from the genes (or gene) controlling HR to PVY^O, PVY^N, PVV and TEV in S. stoloniferum. On the other hand, S. chacoense and the hybrid expressed ER to cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV), whereas S. stoloniferum was susceptible to CMV. All tested wild species and the six tested potato cultivars (S. tuberosum subsp. tuberosum) expressed HR to PVV. Expression of HR following infection with PVY^N induced systemic acquired resistance (SAR) in S. chacoense. HR to PVY^N in S. sparsipilum and S. sucrense and to PVY^O in potato cv. Pito was efficiently expressed at lower temperatures (16/18°C) indicated by the development of distinct necrotic lesions and/or vein necrosis in inoculated leaves, whereas the HR was rendered less effective at higher temperatures (19/24°C) which was indicated by the development of systemic infection with leaf-drop and mosaic symptoms.     

Extreme resistance to Potato virus Y in potato carrying the Rysto gene is mediated by a TIR‐NLR immune receptor

Potato virus Y (PVY) is a major potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) pathogen that causes severe annual crop losses worth billions of dollars worldwide. PVY is transmitted by aphids, and successful control of virus transmission requires the extensive use of environmentally damaging insecticides to reduce vector populations. Ry_sto, from the wild relative S. stoloniferum, confers extreme resistance (ER) to PVY and related viruses and is a valuable trait that is widely employed in potato resistance breeding programmes. Ry_sto was previously mapped to a region of potato chromosome XII, but the specific gene has not been identified to date. In this study, we isolated Ry_sto using resistance gene enrichment sequencing (RenSeq) and PacBio SMRT (Pacific Biosciences single‐molecule real‐time sequencing). Ry_sto was found to encode a nucleotide‐binding leucine‐rich repeat (NLR) protein with an N‐terminal TIR domain and was sufficient for PVY perception and ER in transgenic potato plants. Ry_sto‐dependent extreme resistance was temperature‐independent and requires EDS1 and NRG1 proteins. Ry_sto may prove valuable for creating PVY‐resistant cultivars of potato and other Solanaceae crops.     

Mapping of extreme resistance to PVY (Ry sto) on chromosome XII using anther-culture-derived primary dihaploid potato lines

The inheritance of extreme resistance to PVY (Ry _sto) by a single dominant locus was confirmed by obtaining a 1:1 segregation ratio in a virus inoculation test with 28 resistant (Ryry) to 29 susceptible (ryry) anther culture-derived dihaploid lines (2n=2x=24) from cv. “Assia” (2n=4x=48) having extreme resistance derived from Solanum stoloniferum in simplex constitution (Ryryryry). Twelve Ry _sto markers selected in AFLP assays using bulked segregant analysis were applied to 106 tested potato cultivars from Germany, The Netherlands and Poland and 19 potato cultivars were identified by these markers as extremely resistant to PVY in alignment with phenotypic data. The locus for extreme resistance (Ry _sto) to PVY was mapped on chromosome XII co-segregating with the SSR marker STM0003. The utility of anther-culture derived dihaploid potatoes for genetic marker development was demonstrated. Marker transferability from diploids to tetraploids provides an optimistic potential for marker-assisted selection in potato breeding programs.     

Hypersensitive response to Potato virus Y in potato cultivar Sárpo Mira is conferred by the Ny-Smira gene located on the long arm of chromosome IX

Potato virus Y (PVY, Potyvirus) is the fifth most important plant virus worldwide in terms of economic and scientific impact. It infects members of the family Solanaceae and causes losses in potato, tomato, tobacco, pepper and petunia production. In potato and its wild relatives, two types of resistance genes against PVY have been identified. While Ry genes confer symptomless extreme resistance, Ny genes cause a hypersensitive response visible as local necrosis that may also be able to prevent the virus from spreading under certain environmental conditions. The potato cultivar Sárpo Mira originates from Hungary and is highly resistant to PVY, although the source of this resistance remains unknown. We show that cv. Sárpo Mira reacts with a hypersensitive response leading to necrosis after PVY^NTN infection in detached leaf, whole plant and grafting assays. The hypersensitivity to PVY^NTN segregated amongst 140 individuals of tetraploid progeny of cvs. Sárpo Mira × Maris Piper in a 1:1 ratio, indicating that it was conferred by a single, dominant gene in simplex. Moreover, we identified five DNA markers linked to this trait and located the underlying locus (Ny-Smira) to the long arm of potato chromosome IX. This position corresponds to the location of the Ry _chc and Ny-1 genes for PVY resistance. A simple PCR marker, located 1 cM from the Ny-Smira gene, can be recommended for selection of PVY-resistant progeny of cv. Sárpo Mira.     

Evidence for utility of the same PCR-based markers for selection of extreme resistance to Potato virus Y controlled by Rysto of Solanum stoloniferum derived from different sources

The tuber‐bearing wild potato species, Solanum stoloniferum, carries a dominant gene, Ry_sto, which confers extreme resistance (ER) to Potato virus Y (PVY). This gene was introgressed to cultivated potato germplasm (Solanum tuberosum) using accessions of S. stoloniferum maintained in European gene banks. It is mainly used in potato breeding programmes in Europe. Ry_sto was recently mapped to potato chromosome XII. However, in this study, a different accession of S. stoloniferum (PI275244; Haw1293) was used as a female parent in a cross to obtain a diploid (2n = 2x = 24) potato population of 112 F1 genotypes. From this accession, ER to PVY has been introgressed to the potato breeding programmes at the International Potato Center (Peru). As expected, ER to PVY was inherited in a dominant, monogenic fashion in the F1 population. Marker‐specific choices of DNA polymerase and adjustments of PCR conditions were made to optimise marker detection. The corresponding gene (Ry_sto) was mapped to the chromosome XII using the previously described and new cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (CAPS) markers, which are based on the restriction fragment length polymorphism loci GP122 (six markers) and GP269 (one marker), and the simple sequence repeat marker STM0003. Four GP122‐based CAPS markers and STM0003 detected the same genotypes expressing ER to PVY. Because of a few recombinants, that is ER genotypes lacking the markers and the genotypes that react with necrosis but contain the markers, the marker distance from Ry_sto was estimated as 15.2 cM in this F1 population. However, the distance may be less if necrosis was considered an altered response also controlled by Ry_sto. The markers also specifically detected independent European potato cultivars that express ER to PVY derived from S. stoloniferum. Phylogenetic analysis of the sequences amplified from the GP122 locus of S. stoloniferum and potato cultivars further confirmed that the Ry_sto gene from independent accessions of S. stoloniferum can be selected using the same markers and the protocols described in this study.     

Changes in glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase and ribonucleases activities during PVY-RNA biosynthesis in infected potato plants

Changes in glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase, ribonucleases activities and chlorophyll content were studied in leaves of plants systemically infected by potato virus Y, necrotic strain (PVY^N). Potato cultivars Jara and Adretta differing in resistance to potato virus Y were used. No statistically significant differences were observed between healthy and infected plants of both cultivars in chlorophyll content. Activity of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase slowly increased in connection with virus multiplication and reached 203.4% of the values of non-infected control in susceptible cv. Jara and 160.4% in the resistant cv. Adretta. Differences between cultivars were significant from 60 d after inoculation (P≤0.05). The activity of ribonucleases quickly increased in the initial period of the experiment and then slowly decreased. Their activities reached 195.6% in susceptible cultivar and 183.5% in the resistant one. Significant differences (P≤0.01) between susceptible and resistant cultivars was found from 18 to 35 d after inoculation. The activities of enzymes corresponded to PVY^N multiplication which was since 40 d considerably higher (P<0.01) in susceptible cultivar in comparison with the resistant one. Thus the activities of studied enzymes could be considered as markers of resistance of potato cultivars to PVY^N multiplication.     

Inheritance of resistance to potato viruses Y and A in progeny obtained from potato cultivars containing gene Ry:evidence for a new gene for extreme resistance to PVA

Extreme resistance in cultivated potato (Solanum tuberosum) to potato viruses Y and A (PVY and PVA) conditioned by the presence of Ry genes introduced from Solanum stoloniferum was described by Cockerham (1970). Cockerham detailed a number of genes which controlled a variety of reactions, including extreme resistance to both viruses (i.e. little or no visible reaction of plants and no viral replication following graft and manual inoculation) controlled by gene Ry _sto. In the present study, cvs Pirola and Barbara, which contain a Ry gene, were found to have extreme resistance to PVY isolates from the ordinary (PVY°), veinal necrosis (PVY^N) and potato tuber necrotic ringspot (PVY^NTN) subgroups, and PVA. The inheritance of this phenotype was examined in seedling progenies obtained by crossing Barbara and Pirola with susceptible cultivars. Segregation data for resistance to PVY and PVA in a progeny involving cv Pirola best fitted a genetical model of one gene controlling extreme resistance to both PVY and PVA, although the possibility that there are two genes, each controlling resistance to one virus but closely linked, cannot be excluded. Segregation data from progenies involving cv Barbara best fitted a genetical model in which there are two independent genes, one controlling extreme resistance to PVA and PVY and a second gene controlling extreme resistance to PVA but not to PVY. This previously unrecognised gene conferring extreme resistance to PVA only, should be given the notation Ra in keeping with nomenclature used for other resistance genes.     

Ny-1 and Ny-2 genes conferring hypersensitive response to potato virus Y (PVY) in cultivated potatoes: mapping and marker-assisted selection validation for PVY resistance in potato breeding

Potato virus Y (PVY) is one of the most important viruses affecting potato (Solanum tuberosum) production. In this study, a novel hypersensitive response (HR) gene, Ny-2, conferring resistance to PVY was mapped on potato chromosome XI in cultivar Romula. In cultivars Albatros and Sekwana, the Ny-1 gene was mapped on chromosome IX. In cv. Romula, the local lesions appeared in leaves inoculated with the PVY^N-Wi isolate at 20 and 28 °C; PVY systemic infections were only occasionally observed at the higher temperature. In cvs. Albatros and Sekwana, expression of the necrotic reaction to virus infection was temperature-dependent. PVY^N-Wi was localized at 20 °C; at 28 °C, the systemic, symptomless infection was observed. We developed the B11.6₁₆₀₀ marker co-segregating with Ny-2 and the S1d11 marker specific for the Ny-1 gene. Fifty potato cultivars were tested with markers B11.6 and S1d11 and marker SC895 linked to the Ny-1 gene in cv. Rywal. These results indicated the utility of these markers for marker-assisted selection of HR-like PVY resistance in potato breeding programs.     

Strong resistance to potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease in potato induced by transformation with coat protein gene sequences from an NTN isolate of Potato virus Y

The potato cv. Igor is susceptible to infection with Potato virus Y (PVY) and in Slovenia it has been so severely affected with NTN isolates of PVY causing potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD) that its cultivation has ceased. Plants of cv. Igor were transformed with two transgenes that contained coat protein gene sequence of PVY^NTN. Both transgenes used PVY sequence in a sense (+) orientation, one in native translational context (N‐CP), and one with a frame‐shift mutation (FS‐CP). Although most transgenic lines were susceptible to infection with PVY^NTN and PVY^O, several lines showed resistance that could be classified into two types. Following manual or graft inoculation, plants of partially resistant lines developed some symptoms in foliage and tubers, and virus titre in the foliage, estimated by ELISA, was low or undetectable. In highly resistant (R) lines, symptoms did not develop in foliage and on tubers, and virus could not be detected in foliage by ELISA or infectivity assay. Four lines from 34 tested (two N‐CP and two FS‐CP) were R to PVY^NTN and PVY^O and one additional line was R to PVY^O. When cv. Spey was transformed with the same constructs, they did not confer strong resistance to PVY^O.     

PVY-resistant transgenic potato plants expressing an anti-NIa protein scFv antibody

A synthetic gene encoding a single chain Fv fragment of an antibody directed against the nuclear inclusion a (NIa) protein of potato virus Y (PVY) was used to transform two commerical potato cultivars (Claustar and BF15). The NIa protease forms the nuclear inclusion body A and acts as the major protease in the cleavage of the viral polyprotein into functional proteins. Immunoblot analysis showed that most of the resulting transgenic plants accumulate high levels of the transgenic protein. Furthermore, a majority of the selected transgenic lines showed an efficient and complete protection against the challenge virus after mechanical inoculation with PVY^o strain. Two transgenic lines showed an incomplete resistance with delayed appearance of symptoms accompanied by low virus titers, whereas one line developed symptoms during the first days after inoculation but recovered rapidly, leading to a low virus accumulation rate. These results confirm that expression of scFv antibody is able to inhibit a crucial step in the virus multiplication, such as polyprotein cleavage is a powerful strategy for engineered virus resistance. It can lead to a complete resistance that was not obtained previously by expression of scFv directed against the viral coat protein.     

Strain group specific and virus specific hypersensitive reactions to infection with potyviruses in potato cultivars

When 12 potato cultivars were inoculated with isolates (one each) of potato virus Y (PVY) ordinary (Y^o), C (Y^c) and tobacco veinal necrosis (Yⁿ) strain groups, potato virus A (PVA) and potato virus V (PVV), none of them responded hypersensitively to Yⁿ. However, with Y^o, Y^c, PVA and PW specific hypersensitive reactions developed depending on isolate-cultivar combination which were all independent of each other. When field isolates of PVY thought to be Y^oor Y^cwere inoculated to the same 12 cultivars, two did not fit into either strain group giving hypersensitive reactions in only two cultivars instead of seven with Y^oor eight with Y^c. These two isolates may represent a previously unreported PVY strain group (Y^z). When Y^owas graft-inoculated to seedlings of the cross Desiree × Maris Piper (hypersensitive × non-hypersensitive for Y^o), the segregation ratio obtained for non-hypersensitive:hypersensitive reactions was close to 1:1 suggesting that a single dominant gene (Ny_tbr) determining Y^ospecific hypersensitivity may be present in cv. Desiree (simplex condition). In tests using PVV and Desiree × Maris Piper (non-hypersensitive × hypersensitive for PVV) seedlings, the segregation ratio obtained was close to 1:5 indicating that a single dominant gene (Nv) determining PVV specific hypersensitivity may be present in cv. Maris Piper (duplex condition). Cultivars Corine, Pirola and clone G5457(4) which each carry one of the extreme resistance genes (Ry) from Solanum stoloniferum were graft-inoculated with Yⁿ, Y^o, Y^c, PVV and PVA. G5457(4) gave a strong localised hypersensitive reaction in all instances, while cv. Pirola did so with all except PVA to which it was immune. In cv. Corine a severe localised hypersensitive reaction developed with PVA, generalised hypersensitivity with PVV but an immune response with the three PVY strain groups. Large-scale grafting of Yⁿto plants of cvs Corine and Pirola gave no evidence of selection of a strain which overcomes Ry genes.     

Occurrence of potato virus X strain group 1 in seed stocks of potato cultivars lacking resistance genes

Potato virus X (PVX) isolates were obtained from a simple seed potato production scheme or from ware potatoes produced by seed potatoes obtained from it. In this scheme, PVX infection is widespread in seed stocks and most of the potatoes grown lack PVX resistance genes. Thirteen PVX isolates were typed to strain group by inoculation to potato cultivars containing different combinations of hypersensitivity genes Nx and Nb. Six failed to overcome either gene and therefore belonged to strain group 1, four overcame Nb only and were placed in strain group 3 and three were mixtures of the two. All 13 isolates failed to overcome extreme resistance/immunity gene Rx. Naturally infected cultivars of genotype nx.nb contained strain group 1 alone or strain groups 1 and 3, while those of genotype nx:Nb contained only strain group 3. The widespread occurrence of strain group 1 contrasts with the predominant occurrence of strain group 3 in potatoes in the UK. However, it resembles the UK situation before sophisticated seed potato production schemes were introduced and before PVX hypersensitivity genes Nx and Nb were deliberately exploited in potato breeding. Prior infection with potato leafroll virus (PLRV) did not affect expression of hypersensitivity to PVX in inoculated leaves of an nx:Nb genotype.