Structural features of mycorrhizal associations in two members of the Monotropoideae, Monotropa uniflora and Pterospora andromedea

Species in the subfamily Monotropoideae (family Ericaceae) are achlorophyllous and myco-heterotrophic. They have become highly specialized in that each plant species is associated with a limited number of fungal species which in turn are linked to autotrophic plants. This study provides an updated and comprehensive examination of the anatomical features of two species that have recently received attention with respect to their host-fungal specificity. Root systems of Monotropa uniflora and Pterospora andromedea collected from the field were characterized by light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. All roots of both species were associated with fungi, each root having a well-developed mantle, paraepidermal Hartig net, and intracellular fungal pegs within epidermal cells. The mantle of M. uniflora was multi-layered and numerous outer mantle hyphae developed into cystidia of two distinct morphologies. Large calcium oxalate crystals were present, primarily on the mantle surface. The outer mantle of P. andromedea was more loosely organized, lacked cystidia, and had smaller plate-like as well as cylindrical crystals on the surface and between outer mantle hyphae. Fungal pegs in M. uniflora originated from inner mantle hyphae that penetrated the outer tangential wall of epidermal cells; in P. andromedea, these structures were initiated either from inner mantle hyphae or Hartig net hyphae and penetrated radial walls of epidermal cells. With respect to function, fungal pegs occurred frequently in both host species and, although presumed to be the sites of active nutrient exchange, no direct evidence exists to support this. Differences between these two monotropoid hosts, resulting from the mycorrhizal fungi with which each associates, are discussed.     

Comparative studies of ectomycorrhiza formation in Alnus glutinosa and Pinus resinosa with Paxillus involutus

 Mycorrhiza ontogeny and details of Hartig net and mantle structure were compared in ectomycorrhizas synthesized in growth pouches between the broad host range fungus Paxillus involutus and the tree species European black alder (Alnus glutinosa) and red pine (Pinus resinosa). In Alnus glutinosa, a paraepidermal Hartig net was restricted to the proximal (basal) portion of first-order laterals; the hypodermal layer appeared to be a barrier to fungal penetration. Phi-thickenings were present in some cortical cells but these were not related to lack of fungal ingress into the cortex. The mantle was often present close to the root apex but in many roots it was loosely organized and patchy. In several instances, the mantle formed around the root apex was only temporary; renewed root growth occurred without the formation of a mantle. In Pinus resinosa, the Hartig net developed between cortical cell layers of monopodial and dichotomously branched first–order laterals. Fungal hyphae in the Hartig net exhibited a complex labyrinthine mode of growth. The mantle had a pseudoparenchymatous structure and covered the root, including apices of dichotomously branched roots. The Paxillus–Pinus resinosa interaction had all the characteristics of a compatible ectomycorrhizal association. The Paxillus–Alnus glutinosa interaction, however, showed only aspects of superficial ectomycorrhizas, including the presence of a minimal (sometimes absent) and mostly proximal Hartig net and variable mantle development. Sclerotia were produced in the extraradical mycelium of Paxillus involutus when associated with either Alnus glutinosa or Pinus resinosa. Accepted: 22 October 1998     

In vitro synthesis of Pisolithus-Eucalyptus ectomycorrhizae: synchronization of lateral tip emergence and ectomycorrhizal development

 A simple and reproducible in vitro system is described for the synthesis of Pisolithus-Eucalyptus grandis ectomycorrhizae. Hyphal discs from actively growing colonies were placed in large petri dishes containing minimum nutrient agar overlaid with cellophane and allowed to grow for 7 days. Seeds were then surface sterilized and placed above the expanding fungal colonies and the plates slanted. Seedlings that germinated and grew in the presence of fungal hyphae had twice as many lateral root tips as seedlings that germinated before they were transferred onto hyphal mats. In addition, the lateral root tips of inoculated seedlings had a faster maturation rate and emerged closer to the primary root apex than non-inoculated seedlings. All lateral tips emerged in contact with fungal hyphae and the differentiation of ectomycorrhizae was followed by examining lateral tips basipetally along a single primary root. Typical ectomycorrhizae had formed on 4-day-old lateral tips, i.e. a mantle, radially elongated epidermal cells and a Hartig net commencing about 0.3 mm behind the lateral root apex. Thereafter, the mantle continued to thicken and the apical meristem diminished. The Hartig net often surrounded the apex of 11- to 12-day-old lateral root tips. This model system will facilitate detailed studies on synchronized ectomycorrhizal development and associated molecular and biochemical changes. Accepted: 12 January 1996     

In vitro symbiotic seed germination of South Indian endemic orchid Coelogyne nervosa

Study on the dependence of orchids on fungi for seed germination and seedling development provides a mean for understanding the role of fungi in the orchid development process. The epiphytic orchid Coelogyne nervosa endemic to south India is exploited in an unsustainable manner for its therapeutic value. So a protocol for symbiotic seed germination was established for C. nervosa. We isolated a fungus by plating mycorrhizal root discs of the terrestrial orchid Eulophia epidendreae and identified it as Epulorhiza sp., by sequencing the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) regions of the ribosomal RNA gene. Germination of C. nervosa seeds was higher when inoculated with Epulorhiza sp. Uninoculated seeds of C. nervosa ceased to develop soon after the initiation of germination, and the embryo failed to rupture the seed testa. The isolated fungal hyphae entered the germinating seeds either through the pores in-between the integuments, or through the rhizoids. After the fungal establishment (peloton formation) in embryonic cells, the embryo transformed into a protocorm and after 45 days, 66% of the germinated seeds were transformed into protocorms. Nevertheless, promeristem formation occurred only after fungal association. Sixty-three percent of the protocorms developed their first leaf by 90 days and 62% of these produced a second leaf by 120 days after fungal inoculation. All the seedlings in green leaf stage produced roots and contained fungal pelotons. Our results suggest that the Epulorhiza sp. could be successfully used in the in vitro production of C. nervosa for their reintroduction into its natural environment.     

Structural characteristics of root–fungus associations in two mycoheterotrophic species, Allotropa virgata and Pleuricospora fimbriolata (Monotropoideae), from southwest Oregon, USA

All members of the Monotropoideae (Ericaceae), including the species, Allotropa virgata and Pleuricospora fimbriolata, are mycoheterotrophs dependent on associated symbiotic fungi and autotrophic plants for their carbon needs. Although the fungal symbionts have been identified for A. virgata and P. fimbriolata, structural details of the fungal–root interactions are lacking. The objective of this study was, therefore, to determine the structural features of these plant root–fungus associations. Root systems of these two species did not develop dense clusters of mycorrhizal roots typical of some monotropoid species, but rather, the underground system was composed of elongated rhizomes with first- and second-order mycorrhizal adventitious roots. Both species developed mantle features typical of monotropoid mycorrhizas, although for A. virgata, mantle development was intermittent along the length of each root. Hartig net hyphae were restricted to the host epidermal cell layer, and fungal pegs formed either along the tangential walls (P. fimbriolata) or radial walls (A. virgata) of epidermal cells. Plant-derived wall ingrowths were associated with each fungal peg, and these resembled transfer cells found in other systems. Although the diffuse nature of the roots of these two plants differs from some members in the Monotropoideae, the structural features place them along with other members of the Monotropoideae in the “monotropoid” category of mycorrhizas.     

Mycorrhizae ofMonotropastrum globosum growing in aFagus crenata forest

The achlorophyllousMonotropastrum globosum was found growing in aFagus crenata forest. Samples ofM. globosum and their interpenetrating root systems ofF. crenata were collected to investigate the mycorrhizal association.Monotropastrum globosum mycorrhizae showed thick sheaths, invasion of the epidermal cells by fungal pegs, and Hartig nets, which reached only the first layer of cortical cells. TheF. crenata mycorrhizae also showed thick sheaths, but Hartig nets penetrated deep into the cortex and intracellular hypha were seen in the outer cortical cells. The similarities observerd in the mantle inner plan view and emanating hypha suggest that both mycorrhizae are formed by the same fungus.     

Endophytic fungi from Pecteilis susannae (L.) Rafin (Orchidaceae), a threatened terrestrial orchid in Thailand

Eight endophytic fungi were isolated from roots of the threatened terrestrial orchid, Pecteilis susannae (L.) Rafin. Phylogenetic analysis based on an alignment of internal transcribed spacer regions of nuclear rDNA indicated that seven isolates belonged to the genus Epulorhiza and one to Fusarium. All fungal isolates were cultured with orchid seeds collected from three field sites near Doi Suthep-Pui National Park, Chiang Mai, Thailand. Seed germination and protocorm development were evaluated up to 70 days after sowing. Percent symbiotic seed germination was highest (86.2%) when seeds were cultured with Epulorhiza (CMU-Aug 013). The protocorm development was the most advanced up to stage 2, continued embryo enlargement, or rupture of the testa, and the highest percentage was 17.8% when seeds were cultured with Epulorhiza (CMU-Aug 007). Without fungi, seed germination and protocorm development were 62.1% and 11.1%, respectively. The dependency of P. susannae on fungal symbionts for early seedling development is yet to be determined. Optimizing seed germination and seedling fitness will assist the conservation of this threatened orchid in Thailand.     

Comparative structural study ofQuercus serrata andQ. acutissima formed byPisolithus tinctorius andHebeloma cylindrosporum

Ectomycorrhizas were synthesized in pots and growth pouches betweenQuercus serrata, Q. acutissima, and two ectomycorrhizal fungi,Pisolithus tinctorius andHebeloma cylindrosporum. Root morphology and the structure of the mantle and Hartig net were compared using light, fluorescence, scanning and transmission electron microscopy.P. tinctorius initially colonized root cap cells, and eventually produced a highly branched lateral root system with a complete mantle, whereasH. cylindrosporum promoted root elongation with few hyphae on the root apex surface indicating that interaction between roots differs with fungal species. Hartig net structure and hyphal inclusions varied between all the combinations tested. There were structural differences between mycorrhizas ofH. cylindrosporum/Q. acutissima grown in soil and growth pouches, which indicate that the growth pouch environment can induce artefacts in roots. Fruit bodies ofH. cylindrosporum developed in pots withQ. acutissima. AlthoughP. tinctorius has been used to inoculate oak seedlings in the nursery, results of this study indicate thatH. cylindrosporum may also be an effective ectomycorrhizal fungus forQ. serrata andQ. acutissima.     

Extracellular complexation of Cd in the Hartig net and cytosolic Zn sequestration in the fungal mantle of Picea abies – Hebeloma crustuliniforme ectomycorrhizas

Compartmentation of heavy metals on or within mycorrhizal fungi may serve as a protective function for the roots of forest trees growing in soils containing elevated concentrations of metals such as Cd and Zn. In this paper we present the first quantitative measurements by X‐ray microanalysis of heavy metals in high‐pressure frozen and cryosectioned ectomycorrhizal fungal hyphae. We used this technique to analyse the main sites of Cd and Zn in fungal cells of mantle and Hartig net hyphae and in cortical root cells of symbiotic Picea abies – Hebeloma crustuliniforme associations to gain new insights into the mechanisms of detoxification of these two metals in Norway spruce seedlings. The mycorrhizal seedlings were exposed in growth pouches to either 1 mM Cd or 2 mM Zn for 5 weeks. The microanalytical data revealed that two distinct Cd‐ and Zn‐binding mechanisms are involved in cellular compartmentation of Cd and Zn in the mycobiont. Whereas extracellular complexation of Cd occurred predominantly in the Hartig net hyphae, both extracellular complexation and cytosolic sequestration of Zn occurred in the fungal tissue. The vacuoles were presumed not to be a significant pool for Cd and Zn storage. Cadmium was almost exclusively localized in the cell walls of the Hartig net (up to 161 mmol kg ^{? 1} DW) compared with significantly lower concentrations in the cell walls of mantle hyphae (22 mmol kg ^{? 1} DW) and in the cell walls of cortical cells (15 mmol kg ^{? 1} DW). This suggests that the apoplast of the Hartig net is a primary accumulation site for Cd. Zinc accumulated mainly in the cell walls of the mantle hyphae (111 mmol kg ^{? 1} DW), the Hartig net hyphae (130 mmol kg ^{? 1} DW) and the cortical cells (152 mmol kg ^{? 1} DW). In addition, Zn occurred in high concentrations in the cytoplasm of the fungal mantle hyphae (up to 164 mmol kg ^{? 1} DW) suggesting that both the cell walls and the cytoplasm of fungal tissue are the main accumulation sites for Zn in P. abies resulting in decreased Zn transfer from the fungus to the root.     

Mycorrhizal morphology of Monotropastrum humile collected from six different forests in central Japan

A survey of the nonphotosynthetic plant Monotropastrum humile was conducted to determine its mycorrhizal status and characterize the fungal structures observed. Thirteen populations and 40 individuals were collected from six forest types, including coniferous and broadleaf trees, in central Japan. The nearly spherical root system of M. humile intertwines with the root systems of neighboring trees, and individual roots were branched up to third-order structure, forming monopodial-pinnate or monopodial-pyramidal morphologies. In addition to the formation of a fungal mantle and Hartig net in association with the epidermis, fungal penetration pegs consistently were observed around and within the epidermal cells. These structures indicate that the mycorrhizal status of M. humile is of the monotropoid type.     

Comparative investigations on the differentiation of the endodermis and the development of the Hartig net in mycorrhizae of Picea abies and Larix decidua

Summary The differentiation of the endodermis of mycorrhizal roots of Picea abies and Larix decidua was investigated by means of light and transmission electron microscopy and with fluorescence techniques. The initiation and differentiation of the Hartig net were recorded. Differences between the two tree species were found, as were differences between the two tree species and angiosperms. The Casparian band developed immediately after the origin of endodermal cells from the meristem in mycorrhizae of both tree species. In L. decidua only the primary endodermis was present in most mycorrhizal laterals. The secondary structure of the endodermis was restricted to main roots and proximal parts of larch mycorrhizae. In P. abies mycorrhizae, however, the secondary stage of the endodermis developed soon after the primary endodermis and was characterized by regular alternation of short, active passage cells and elongated, rapidly degenerating cells, the inner surface of which was covered by a thick suberin layer. Hartig net development started in P. abies short roots only after the differentiation of endodermis into the secondary stage, whereas in L. decidua, the Hartig net was already initiated at the primary endodermal stage. Differences were specific for tree species.     

Effect of time of inoculation on in vitro ectomycorrhizal colonization and nodule initiation in Acacia holosericea seedlings

The complex interactions that occur in systems with more than one type of symbiosis were studied using one isolate of Bradyrhizobium sp. and the ectomycorrhizal fungus Pisolithus tinctorius (Pers.) Coker and Couch inoculated on to the roots of Acacia holosericea A. Cunn. ex G. Don in vitro. After a single inoculation with Bradyrhizobium sp., bacteria typically entered the roots by forming infection threads in the root hair cells via the curling point of the root hair and/ or after intercellular penetration. Sheath formation and intercellular penetration were observed on Acacia roots after a single inoculation with Pisolithus tinctorius but no radial elongation of epidermal cells. Simultaneous inoculation with both microorganisms resulted in nodules and ectomycorrhiza on the root system, occasionally on the same lateral root. On lateral roots bearing nodules and ectomycorrhiza, the nodulation site was characterized by the presence of a nodule meristem and the absence of an infection thread; sheath formation and Hartig net development occurred regularly in the region of the roots adjacent to nodules. Prior inoculation with Bradyrhizobium sp. did not inhibit ectomycorrhizal colonization in root segments adjacent to nodules in which nodule meristems and infection threads were clearly present. Conversely, in ectomycorrhizae inoculated by bacteria, the nodule meristem and the infection thread were typically absent. These results show that simultaneous inoculation with both microorganisms inhibits infection thread development, thus conferring an advantage on fungal hyphae in the competition for infection sites. This suggests that fungal hyphae can modify directly and/or indirectly the recognition factors leading to nodule meristem initiation and infection thread development.     

Comparative studies on ectomycorrhizae synthesized with various in vitro techniques using Picea abies and two Hebeloma species

Summary Various in vitro synthesis techniques with Picea abies and two Hebeloma species showed that structures of the mantle and Hartig net of synthesized ectomycorrhizae within the given two fungus species are stable. However, thickness of mantle, and penetration depth and number of hyphal cell rows between cortical cells of the Hartig net are dependent on techniques and substrates. Porous glass balls as substrate in the Erlenmeyer technique seem to suppress or delay mantle and Hartig net formation. With the other techniques (growth pouch, open cuvette, Erlenmeyer with a vermiculite-peat moss mixture) development of the mantle is simultaneous with or shortly in advance of Hartig net formation. The ectomycorrhizae of the two tested Hebeloma species are similar and cannot be morphologically differentiated by the in vitro techniques used.     

INTERACTION BETWEEN THE ECTOMYCORRHIZAL FUNGUS PISOLITHUS TINCTORIUS AND ROOT HAIRS OF PICEA MARIANA (PINACEAE)

The ectomycorrhizal fungus Pisolithus tinctorius interacts with roots of Picea mariana to form a typical mantle and Hartig net. Hyphae alter their growth pattern when in contact with susceptible root hairs in the mycorrhizal infection zone and grow acropetally, gradually covering the length of the hair to form a mantlelike structure. Initial contact with the hair may be influenced by a fibrillar material on the root hair surface. Although many root hairs become surrounded by fungal hyphae, they are not penetrated, and therefore are not entry points for this symbiotic fungus.     

Structure and histochemistry of mycorrhizae synthesized between Arbutus menziesii (Ericaceae) and two basidiomycetes,Pisolithus tinctorius (Pisolithaceae) and Piloderma bicolor (Corticiaceae)

Arbutoid mycorrhizae were synthesized in growth pouches between Arbutus menziesii Pursch. (Pacific madrone) and two broad host range basidiomycete fungi, Pisolithus tinctorius (Pers.) Coker and Couch and Piloderma bicolor (Peck) Jülich. P. tinctorius induced the formation of dense, pinnate mycorrhizal root clusters enveloped by a thick fungal mantle. P. bicolor mycorrhizae were usually unbranched, and had a thin or non-existent mantle. Both associations had the well-developed para-epidermal Hartig nets and intracellular penetration of host epidermal cells by hyphae typical of arbutoid interactions. A. menziesii roots developed a suberized exodermis which acted as a barrier to cortical cell penetration by the fungi. Ultrastructurally, the suberin appeared non-lamellar, but this may have been due to the imbedding resin. Histochemical analyses indicated that phenolic substances present in epidermal cells may be an important factor in mycorrhiza establishment. Analyses with X-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy showed that some of the granular inclusions present in fungal hyphae of the mantle and Hartig net were polyphosphate. Other inclusions were either protein or polysaccharides.     

Tricholoma matsutake– an assessment of in situ and in vitro infection by observing cleared and stained whole roots

 Structures present within field-collected Tricholoma matsutake/Pinus densiflora ectomycorrhizas and in vitro infections of P. densiflora roots by T. matsutake were observed by clearing, bleaching and staining whole lateral roots and mycorrhizas. Field mycorrhizas were characterized by a lack of root hairs, by the presence of a sparse discontinuous mantle composed of irregularly darkly staining hyphae over the root surface, primarily behind the root cap, and by the presence of Hartig net mycelium within the root cortex. Hartig net 'palmettis' were classified into three basic structures, each with distinctive morphologies. Aerial hyphae, bearing terminal swellings, were observed emanating from the mantle. Cleared, bleached and stained in vitro-infected roots possessed multibranched hyphal structures within the host root cortex and aerial hyphae bearing terminal swellings were observed arising from the mycelium colonizing the root surface. T. matsutake on P. densiflora conforms to the accepted morphology of an ectomycorrhiza. This staining protocol is particularly suited to the study of Matsutake mycorrhizal roots and gives rapid, clear, high-contrast images using standard light microscopy while conserving spatial relationships between hyphal elements and host tissues. Accepted: 26 August 1999     

Dormancy in Seeds of Charlock: I. DEVELOPMENTAL ANATOMY OF THE SEED

The anatomy of the embryo, endosperm, and testa throughout thedevelopment of charlock seeds is described. In mature seedsthe embryos are morphologically fully differentiated. Each embryoconsists of a shoot meristem with two large cotyledons but noleaf primordia, and a root meristem with a root cap. The embryois surrounded by a single layer of aleurone-like cells derivedfrom the endosperm and enclosed within the testa. Mucilagesand phenols which could greatly retard the diffusion of oxygeninto the tissues of the embryo are found in the testa. Dormancy,which appears to be induced by a shortage of oxygen, is probablyassociated with the presence of these covering layers.     

Global patterns of gene regulation associated with the development of ectomycorrhiza between birch (Betula pendula Roth.) and Paxillus involutus (Batsch) Fr

The formation of ectomycorrhizal (ECM) root tissue is characterized by distinct morphological and developmental stages, such as preinfection and adhesion, mantle, and Hartig net formation. The global pattern of gene expression during these stages in the birch (Betula pendula)-Paxillus involutus ECM association was analyzed using cDNA microarrays. In comparison with nonsymbiotic conditions, 251 fungal (from a total of 1,075) and 138 plant (1,074 in total) genes were found to be differentially regulated during the ECM development. For instance, during mantle and Hartig net development, there were several plant genes upregulated that are normally involved in defense responses during pathogenic fungal challenges. These responses were, at later stages of ECM development, found to be repressed. Other birch genes that showed differential regulation involved several homologs that usually are implicated in water permeability (aquaporins) and water stress tolerance (dehydrins). Among fungal genes differentially upregulated during stages of mantle and Hartig net formation were homologs putatively involved in mitochondrial respiration. In fully developed ECM tissue, there was an upregulation of fungal genes related to protein synthesis and the cytoskeleton assembly machinery. This study highlights complex molecular interactions between two symbionts during the development of an ECM association.