Nonhost resistance to Magnaporthe oryzae in Arabidopsis thaliana

Rice blast, caused by Magnaporthe oryzae, is a devastating disease of rice (Oryza sativa). The mechanisms involved in resistance of rice to blast have been studied extensively and the rice—M. oryzae pathosystem has become a model for plant—microbe interaction studies. However, the mechanisms involved in nonhost resistance (NHR) of other plants to rice blast are still poorly understood. We have recently demonstrated that AGB1 and PMR5 contribute to PEN2-mediated preinvasion resistance to M. oryzae in Arabidopsis thaliana, suggesting a complex genetic network regulating the resistance. To determine whether other defense factors: RAR1, SGT1 and NHO1, affected the A. thaliana-M. oryzae interactions, double mutants were generated between pen2 and these defense-related mutants. All these double mutants exhibited a level of penetration resistance similar to that of the pen2 mutant, suggesting that none of these mutants significantly compromised resistance to M. oryzae in a pen2 background.Key words: nonhost resistance, PEN2, RAR1, SGT1, NHO1Plants face microbial attacks and have evolved innate immunity systems to defend against these threats. The initial step of the immunity signaling pathway is recognition of intra- or extracellular pathogen-derived molecules. Externally oriented transmembrane-type proteins containing leucine-rich repeat (LRR) domains detect extracellular molecules, whereas cytoplasmic sensors possess nucleotide-binding (NB) and LRR domains (NLR).^1,2 The LRR domain serves as a pattern-recognition receptor to detect pathogen-derived molecules or host proteins that are targeted by pathogen peptides that have entered the cell, effectors.³ NLR-type sensors are the substrates of a structurally and functionally conserved chaperone complex that consists of HEAT SHOCK PROTEIN 90 (HSP90) and its cochaperone SUPPRESSOR OF THE G2 ALLELE OF SKP1 (SGT1). REQUIRED FOR MLA12 RESISTANCE 1 (RAR1) regulated the HSP90-SGT1 complex, resulting in the stabilization of NLR proteins. Thus, SGT1 and RAR1 are required for the function of multiple and distinct R genes that encode NLR immune sensors in plants.⁴ Experiments in RAR1-silenced transgenic rice lines showed that RAR1 is not essential for Pib, which encodes an NLR against rice blast fungus.⁵ In contrast, basal resistance to normally virulent races of rice blast fungus or bacterial blight is significantly reduced in RAR1-silenced lines. This result is consistent with earlier reports that RAR1 is involved in basal resistance to virulent Pseudomonas bacteria in Arabidopsis or blast fungus in barley.^6,7 The requirement of SGT1 for immunity in plants is shown mostly by transient silencing of a number of NLR proteins.^8,9 In addition, SGT1 is also required for immune responses triggered by non-NLR-type sensors.¹⁰ This requirement indicates that either SGT1 function is not limited to the NLR sensors, or some unknown SGT1-dependent NLR proteins also operate downstream of non NLR-type sensors. Furthermore, SGT1 is involved in nonhost resistance, indicating that SGT1 may be a general factor of disease resistance.¹⁰ An Arabidopsis mutant, nho1 (nonhost resistance 1), has been isolated on which Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola grows and causes disease symptoms.^11,12 It is significant that this mutant is also compromised in R-gene-mediated resistance to P. syringae.¹¹ Although NHO1 is the flagellin-induced glycerol kinase, whose exact function in NHR remains elusive.^12,13 A possible explanation might be that altered plant glycerol pools either directly or indirectly affect nutrient availability for P. syringae. NHO1 is also required for resistance to the fungal pathogen Botrytis cinerea, indicating that NHO1 is not limited to bacterial resistance.¹² However, these contributions to NHR to M. oryzae in A. thaliana have not been understood.To determine whether these factors were necessary for the resistance to M. oryzae in A. thaliana, the following A. thaliana mutants were inoculated with M. oryzae and monitored by microscopy: rar1-21;¹⁴ edm1-1;¹⁵ nho1-1,¹¹ (all Col-0 background). All these mutants exhibited a level of penetration resistance similar to that of the wild-type plants (data not shown), suggesting that none of these mutants significantly compromised resistance to M. oryzae. We have recently shown that among the penetration (pen) mutants, only the pen2,¹⁶ mutant allowed increased penetration into epidermal cells by M. oryzae.¹⁷ Thus, double mutants were generated between pen2 and these mutants to determine whether these factors were necessary for the resistance to M. oryzae in a pen2 background: pen2 rar1-21; pen2 edm1-1; pen2 nho1-1. All these double mutants exhibited a level of penetration resistance similar to that of the pen2 mutant (Fig. 1), suggesting that none of these mutants significantly compromised resistance to M. oryzae in a pen2 background. This might indicate that NHR against M. oryzae may not be conferred by RAR1- and SGT1-dependent NLR immune sensors. Alternatively, since there has been no report that RAR1 is required for any known transmembrane sensors, such as FLS2, EFR or Xa21, RAR1- and SGT1-independent transmembrane-type immune sensors may be required for NHR against M. oryzae. Future studies will be required to reveal the genetic and mechanistic requirements for NHR in A. thaliana-M. oryzae interactions.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Double mutant analysis to evaluate the role of the defense related genes on resistance to Magnaporthe oryzae in Arabidopsis thaliana. The frequency of M. oryzae penetration on double mutants at 3 days post-inoculation was expressed as a percentage of total appressoria. Data were collected from six independent plants per line. A minimum of 100 infection sites was inspected per leaf. Results represent mean ± standard error of three independent experiments.     

SOBIR1 and AGB1 independently contribute to nonhost resistance to Pyricularia oryzae (syn. Magnaporthe oryzae) in Arabidopsis thaliana

ABSTRACT

Rice blast caused by Pyricularia oryzae (syn. Magnaporthe oryzae) is a disease devastating to rice. We have studied the Arabidopsis-P. oryzae pathosystem as a model system for nonhost resistance (NHR) and found that SOBIR1, but not BAK1, is a positive regulator of NHR to P. oryzae in Arabidopsis. AGB1 is also involved in NHR. However, the genetic interactions between SOBIR1, BAK1, and AGB1 are uncharacterized. In this study, we delineated the genetic interactions between SOBIR1, BAK1, and AGB1 in NHR to P. oryzae in Arabidopsis and found SOBIR1 and AGB1 independently control NHR to P. oryzae in Arabidopsis pen2-1 mutant plants. Furthermore, XLG2, but not TMM, has a positive role in penetration resistance to P. oryzae in Arabidopsis pen2-1 mutant plants. Our study characterized genetic interactions in Arabidopsis NHR.

Abbreviations: PRR: pattern recognition receptor, RLK: receptor-like kinase, RLP: receptor-like protein, BAK1: BRASSINOSTEROID INSENSITIVE 1-ASSOCIATED RECEPTOR KINASE 1, BIR1: BAK1-INTERACTING RECEPTOR-LIKE KINASE 1, SOBIR1: SUPPRESSOR OF BIR1-1-1, AGB1: ARABIDOPSIS G PROTEIN ß-SUBUNIT 1, XLG2: EXTRA-LARGE G PROTEIN 2     

ERECTA contributes to non-host resistance to Magnaporthe oryzae in Arabidopsis

ERECTA controls both developmental processes and disease resistance in Arabidopsis. We investigated the function of ERECTA in non-host resistance to Magnaporthe oryzae in Arabidopsis. In the pen2 er mutant, penetration resistance and post-penetration resistance to M. oryzae were compromised. These results suggest that ERECTA is involved in both penetration and post-penetration resistance to M. oryzae in Arabidopsis.     

SOBIR1 contributes to non-host resistance to Magnaporthe oryzae in Arabidopsis

The rate of entry of Magnaporthe oryzae into Arabidopsis pen2 sobir1 plants was significantly higher than that into pen2 plants. The length of the infection hyphae in pen2 sobir1 plants was significantly longer than that in pen2 plants. These results suggest that SOBIR1 is involved in both penetration and post-penetration resistance to M. oryzae in Arabidopsis.     

Variation in resistance and virulence in the interaction between Arabidopsis thaliana and a bacterial pathogen

We examined patterns of variation and the extent of local adaptation in the interaction between the highly selfing annual weed Arabidopsis thaliana and its foliar bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas viridiflava by cross-infecting 23 bacterial isolates with 35 plant lines collected from six fallow or cultivated fields in the Midwest, USA. We used two measures of resistance and virulence: bacterial count in the leaf and symptom development four days after infection. We found variation in resistance in A. thaliana and virulence in P. viridiflava, as well as a significant difference in symptoms between two distinct genetic clades within P. viridiflava. We also observed that both resistance and plant development rate varied with field type of origin (cultivated or fallow), possibly through age-related resistance, a developmentally regulated general form of resistance. Finally, we did not observe local adaptation by host or pathogen, rather we found patterns of variation across populations that depended in part on P. viridiflava clade. These data suggest that the interaction between A. thaliana and P. viridiflava varies across space and is mediated by the selection regime of the host populations and differential performance of the P. viridiflava clades. This is one of a very limited number of studies examining a bacterial pathogen of wild plant populations and one of a few studies to examine patterns of variation in a plant-pathogen association that is not a highly specialized gene-for-gene interaction.     

Penetration and Post-Penetration Resistance to Magnaporthe oryzae in Arabidopsis

The rate of entry of Magnaporthe oryzae into the Arabidopsis pen2 quintuple (pen2 NahG pmr5 agb1 mlo2) mutant was significantly higher than those into the pen2 quadruple (pen2 NahG pmr5 agb1 and pen2 NahG pmr5 mlo2) mutants. The lengths of the infection hyphae in the pen2 quintuple mutant were intermediate between the pen2 quadruple mutants. These results suggest that different genetic networks, consisting of PEN2, PMR5, AGB1, and MLO2, control penetration and post-penetration resistance to M. oryzae in Arabidopsis.     

Characterization of the interaction between Oidium heveae and Arabidopsis thaliana

Oidium heveae, an obligate biotrophic pathogen of rubber trees (Hevea brasiliensis), causes significant yield losses of rubber worldwide. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying the interplay between O. heveae and rubber trees remain largely unknown. In this study, we isolated an O. heveae strain, named HN1106, from cultivated H. brasiliensis in Hainan, China. We found that O. heveae HN1106 triggers the hypersensitive response in a manner that depends on the effector‐triggered immunity proteins EDS1 (Enhanced Disease Susceptibility 1) and PAD4 (Phytoalexin Deficient 4) and on salicylic acid (SA) in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana. However, SA‐independent resistance also appears to limit O. heveae infection of Arabidopsis, because the pathogen does not produce conidiospores on npr1 (nonexpressor of pr1), sid2 (SA induction deficient 2) and NahG plants, which show disruptions in SA signalling. Furthermore, we found that the callose synthase PMR4 (Powdery Mildew Resistant 4) prevents O. heveae HN1106 penetration into leaves in the early stages of infection. To elucidate the potential mechanism of resistance of Arabidopsis to O. heveae HN1106, we inoculated 47 different Arabidopsis accessions with the pathogen, and analysed the plant disease symptoms and O. heveae HN1106 hyphal growth and conidiospore formation on the leaves. We found that the accession Lag2‐2 showed significant susceptibility to O. heveae HN1106. Overall, this study provides a basis for future research aimed at combatting powdery mildew caused by O. heveae in rubber trees.     

第二代测序技术用于水稻和稻瘟菌互作早期转录组的分析

稻瘟菌为了实现对水稻的有效侵染,在侵染水稻时可能通过表达和转运一定数量的效应蛋白进入到水稻细胞,抑制和干扰水稻的先天免疫机制。文章利用Solexa第二代测序技术,通过开展水稻和稻瘟菌互作早期转录组的测定和分析,克隆和鉴定在互作早期表达的稻瘟菌效应蛋白基因。利用序列同源比对,我们从总计约12.5 M条序列标签中,分离和鉴定了338 942条来源于稻瘟菌的序列,并最终定位到779个稻瘟菌预测基因。其中108个基因很可能参与了水稻和稻瘟菌互作过程,42个基因为预测的分泌蛋白基因。通过RT-PCR分析,最终确认了42个预测分泌蛋白基因中有12个基因在侵染水稻早期有显著的表达,而其中有4个基因表现为侵染早期特异表达。文章尝试利用第二代测序技术实现稻瘟菌侵染早期特异表达基因,尤其是分泌蛋白基因的快速克隆和鉴定,为稻瘟菌效应蛋白基因的克隆和功能鉴定提供了较为有意义的探索。     

Characterization of nonhost resistance of Arabidopsis to the Asian soybean rust

Asian soybean rust (ASR), caused by Phakopsora pachyrhizi, is a devastating disease of soybean. We report the use of the nonhost plant Arabidopsis thaliana to identify the genetic basis of resistance to P. pachyrhizi. Upon attack by P. pachyrhizi, epidermal cells of wild-type Arabidopsis accumulated H2O2, which likely orchestrates the frequently observed epidermal cell death. However, even when epidermal cell death occurred, fungal hyphae grew on and infection was terminated at the mesophyll boundary. These events were associated with expression of PDF1.2, suggesting that P. pachyrhizi, an ostensible biotroph, mimics aspects of a necrotroph. Extensive colonization of the mesophyll occurred in Arabidopsis pen mutants with defective penetration resistance. Although haustoria were found occasionally in mesophyll cells, the successful establishment of biotrophy failed, as evidenced by the cessation of fungal growth. Double mutants affected in either jasmonic acid or salicylic acid signaling in the pen3-1 background revealed the involvement of both pathways in nonhost resistance (NHR) of Arabidopsis to P. pachyrhizi. Interestingly, expression of AtNHL10, a gene that is expressed in tissue undergoing the hypersensitive response, was only triggered in infected pen3-1 mutants. Thus, a suppression of P. pachyrhizi-derived effectors by PEN3 can be inferred. Our results demonstrate that Arabidopsis can be used to study mechanisms of NHR to ASR.     

Evidence for functional interaction between brassinosteroids and cadmium response in Arabidopsis thaliana

Plant hormones, in addition to regulating growth and development, are involved in biotic and abiotic stress responses. To investigate whether a hormone signalling pathway plays a role in the plant response to the heavy metal cadmium (Cd), gene expression data in response to eight hormone treatments were retrieved from the Genevestigator Arabidopsis thaliana database and compared with published microarray analysis performed on plants challenged with Cd. Across more than 3000 Cd-regulated genes, statistical approaches and cluster analyses highlighted that gene expression in response to Cd and brassinosteroids (BR) showed a significant similarity. Of note, over 75% of the genes showing consistent (e.g. opposite) regulation upon BR and Brz (BR biosynthesis inhibitor) exposure exhibited a BR-like response upon Cd exposure. This phenomenon was confirmed by qPCR analysis of the expression level of 10 BR-regulated genes in roots of Cd-treated wild-type (WT) plants. Although no change in BR content was observed in response to Cd in our experimental conditions, adding epibrassinolide (eBL, a synthetic brassinosteroid) to WT plants significantly enhanced Cd-induced root growth inhibition, highlighting a synergistic response between eBL and the metal. This effect was specific to this hormone treatment. On the other hand, dwarf1 seedlings, showing a reduced BR level, exhibited decreased root growth inhibition in response to Cd compared with WT, reversed by the addition of eBL. Similar results were obtained on Brz-treated WT plants. These results argue in favour of an interaction between Cd and BR signalling that modulates plant sensitivity, and opens new perspectives to understand the plant response to Cd.     

Mechano-Chemical Aspects of Organ Formation in Arabidopsis thaliana: The Relationship between Auxin and Pectin

How instructive signals are translated into robust and predictable changes in growth is a central question in developmental biology. Recently, much interest has centered on the feedback between chemical instructions and mechanical changes for pattern formation in development. In plants, the patterned arrangement of aerial organs, or phyllotaxis, is instructed by the phytohormone auxin; however, it still remains to be seen how auxin is linked, at the apex, to the biochemical and mechanical changes of the cell wall required for organ outgrowth. Here, using Atomic Force Microscopy, we demonstrate that auxin reduces tissue rigidity prior to organ outgrowth in the shoot apex of Arabidopsis thaliana, and that the de-methyl-esterification of pectin is necessary for this reduction. We further show that development of functional organs produced by pectin-mediated ectopic wall softening requires auxin signaling. Lastly, we demonstrate that coordinated localization of the auxin transport protein, PIN1, is disrupted in a naked-apex produced by increasing cell wall rigidity. Our data indicates that a feedback loop between the instructive chemical auxin and cell wall mechanics may play a crucial role in phyllotactic patterning.     

Competence of roots for race-specific resistance and the induction of acquired resistance against Magnaporthe oryzae

Generally, Magnaporthe oryzae , the causal agent of rice blast disease, is considered to be a typical leaf-infecting plant pathogenic fungus. However, it was recently reported that M. oryzae shares many characteristics in common with root-infecting pathogens and indeed was able to infect roots. Here, we report on studies testing for the capacity of roots of rice and barley to resist infections with M. oryzae . We established that roots of rice plants were colonized by M. oryzae in a manner which is different from the gene-for-gene specificity seen in leaves for the same genotypes. Furthermore, treatment of rice seedlings with benzo-(1,2,3)-thiadiazole-7-carbothioic acid S-methyl ester (BTH), a chemical that protects leaves effectively against blast by conditioning acquired resistance, was not able to prevent colonization of roots by M. oryzae although a reduction in disease levels was observed. Moreover, BTH was not able to protect barley roots against infection with M. oryzae . Taken together, our results suggest that although roots show intrinsic variation in their ability to resist colonization by M. oryzae , neither gene-for-gene incompatibility nor aquired resistance are as effective at blocking the pathogen as they are in leaves.     

BELL1 and AGAMOUS genes promote ovule identity in Arabidopsis thaliana

Molecular and genetic analyses have demonstrated that the Arabidopsis thaliana gene BELL1 (BEL1) is required for proper morphogenesis of the ovule integuments. Several lines of evidence suggest that BEL1 may act, at least in part, to repress the function of the organ identity gene AGAMOUS (AG) during ovule development. To study the relative roles of BEL1 and AG, plants homozygous for ag, bel1 or both were constructed in an ap2 mutant background where ovules form even in the absence of AG function. The loss of either BEL1 or AG led to a decrease in the number of mature ovules, accompanied by an increase in primordial outgrowths. These data suggest that BEL1 and AG gene products act early in ovule development in a partially redundant manner to direct ovule identity. Development of the abnormal integuments characteristic of the Bel1- mutant phenotype was found to be dependent on AG function. Finally, BEL1 appears to be required for embryo sac development independent of both other aspects of ovule morphogenesis and AG function. This study therefore suggests that both BEL1 and AG are required for several distinct aspects of ovule morphogenesis.     

Imbibition conditions and seed dormancy of Arabidopsis thaliana

The optimal combinations of temperature in the range of 0 to 20°C and duration (1 to 14 days) of imbibition for the induction of germination of Arabidopsis thaliana (L) Heynh., ecotype "Landsberg-erecta", by red light were investigated. At 2°C, 10 days of imbibition are needed tor loss of dormancy, whereas at higher temperatures, e.g 15°C, it is already lost after 1 or 2 days. It is proposed that the development of light-inducible germination is governed by two temperature-dependent processes-the loss of primary or innate dormancy and the simultaneous induction of secondary dormancy. Data are discussed in terms of the availability of phytochrome, the availability of an unknown factor X and changes in sensitivity of the process of germination induction by the far-red absorbing form of phytochrome (Pfr).     

Utilization of mutants to analyze the interaction between Arabidopsis thaliana and its naturally root-associated Pseudomonas

 A model system based on the Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. Ws ecotype and its naturally colonizing Pseudomonas thivervalensis rhizobacteria was defined. Pseudomonas strains colonizing A. thaliana were found to modify the root architecture either in vivo or in vitro. A gnotobiotic system using bacteria labelled with green fluorescent protein revealed that P. thivervalensis exhibited a colonization profile similar to that of other rhizobacterial species. Mutants of A.thaliana affected in root hair development and possible hormone perception were used to analyze the plant genetic determinants of bacterial colonization. A screen for mutants insensitive to P. thivervalensis colonization yielded two mutants found to be auxin resistant. This further supports a proposed role for bacterial auxin in inducing morphological modifications of roots. This work paves the way for studying the interaction between plants and non-pathogenic rhizobacteria in a gnotobiotic system, derived from a natural association, where interactions between both partners can be genetically dissected. Received: 6 January 2000 / Accepted: 20 May 2000     

Genome-level evolution of resistance genes in Arabidopsis thaliana

Pathogen resistance genes represent some of the most abundant and diverse gene families found within plant genomes. However, evolutionary mechanisms generating resistance gene diversity at the genome level are not well understood. We used the complete Arabidopsis thaliana genome sequence to show that most duplication of individual NBS-LRR sequences occurs at close physical proximity to the parent sequence and generates clusters of closely related NBS-LRR sequences. Deploying the statistical strength of phylogeographic approaches and using chromosomal location as a proxy for spatial location, we show that apparent duplication of NBS-LRR genes to ectopic chromosomal locations is largely the consequence of segmental chromosome duplication and rearrangement, rather than the independent duplication of individual sequences. Although accounting for a smaller fraction of NBS-LRR gene duplications, segmental chromosome duplication and rearrangement events have a large impact on the evolution of this multigene family. Intergenic exchange is dramatically lower between NBS-LRR sequences located in different chromosome regions as compared to exchange between sequences within the same chromosome region. Consequently, once translocated to new chromosome locations, NBS-LRR gene copies have a greater likelihood of escaping intergenic exchange and adopting new functions than do gene copies located within the same chromosomal region. We propose an evolutionary model that relates processes of genome evolution to mechanisms of evolution for the large, diverse, NBS-LRR gene family.