T cell anergy as a strategy to reduce the risk of autoimmunity

Some self-reactive immature T cells escape negative selection in the thymus and may cause autoimmune diseases later. In the periphery, if T cells are stimulated insufficiently by peptide-major histocompatibility complex, they become inactive and their production of cytokines changes, a phenomenon called “T cell anergy”. In this paper, we explore the hypothesis that T cell anergy may function to reduce the risk of autoimmunity. The underlying logic is as follows: Since those self-reactive T cells that receive strong stimuli from self-antigens are eliminated in the thymus, T cells that receive strong stimuli in the periphery are likely to be non-self-reactive. As a consequence, when a T cell receives a weak stimulus, the likelihood that the cell is self-reactive is higher than in the case that it receives a strong stimulus. Therefore, inactivation of the T cell may reduce the danger of autoimmunity. We consider the formalism in which each T cell chooses its response depending on the strength of stimuli in order to reduce the risk of autoimmune diseases while maintaining its ability to attack non-self-antigens effectively. The optimal T cell responses to a weak and a strong stimulus are obtained both when the cells respond in a deterministic manner and when they respond in a probabilistic manner. We conclude that T cell anergy is the optimal response when a T cell meets with antigen-presenting cells many times in its lifetime, and when the product of the autoimmunity risk and the number of self-reactive T cells has an intermediate value.     

Human dendritic cells sequentially matured with CD4(+) T cells as a secondary signal favor CTL and long-term T memory cell responses

Dendritic cells (DCs) are professional antigen-presenting cells involved in the control and initiation of immune responses. In vivo, DCs exposed at the periphery to maturation stimuli migrate to lymph nodes, where they receive secondary signals from CD4+ T helper cells. These DCs become able to initiate CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses. However, in vitro investigations concerning human monocyte-derived DCs have never focused on their functional properties after such sequential maturation. Here, we studied human DC phenotypes and functions according to this sequential exposure to maturation stimuli. As first signals, we used TNF-α/polyI:C mimicking inflammatory and pathogen stimuli and, as second signals, we compared activated CD4+ T helper cells to a combination of CD40-L/ IFN-γ. Our results show that a sequential activation with activated CD4+ T cells dramatically increased the maturation of DCs in terms of their phenotype and cytokine secretion compared to DCs activated with maturation stimuli delivered simultaneously. Furthermore, this sequential maturation led to the induction of CTL with a long-term effector and central memory phenotypes. Thus, sequential delivery of maturation stimuli, which includes CD4+ T cells, should be considered in the future to improve the induction of long-term CTL memory in DC-based immunotherapy.     

Memory and anergy: challenges to traditional models of T lymphocyte differentiation.

Traditional paradigms suggest that encounter with an antigen converts naive peripheral T cells into memory cells with less stringent requirements for activation and increased capacities for lymphokine production. Recent evidence argues that this view may be over-simplified in two ways. First, an encounter with antigen in the absence of certain costimulatory factors can render a T cell anergic--that is, unable to respond to antigen under normal conditions. Second, although cells of the memory T cell population are more responsive than naive cells to some stimuli, these cells are hyporesponsive in other situations. Intrinsic resistance of memory T cells to elevation of intracellular calcium ion concentrations may contribute to their poor responsiveness to agents that activate naive cells. Thus, aspects of the costimulatory environment can determine whether a resting T cell is activated or rendered anergic and may also influence the kinds of stimuli to which a memory T cell will respond.     

High epitope expression levels increase competition between T cells

Both theoretical predictions and experimental findings suggest that T cell populations can compete with each other. There is some debate on whether T cells compete for aspecific stimuli, such as access to the surface on antigen-presenting cells (APCs) or for specific stimuli, such as their cognate epitope ligand. We have developed an individual-based computer simulation model to study T cell competition. Our model shows that the expression level of foreign epitopes per APC determines whether T cell competition is mainly for specific or aspecific stimuli. Under low epitope expression, competition is mainly for the specific epitope stimuli, and, hence, different epitope-specific T cell populations coexist readily. However, if epitope expression levels are high, aspecific competition becomes more important. Such between-specificity competition can lead to competitive exclusion between different epitope-specific T cell populations. Our model allows us to delineate the circumstances that facilitate coexistence of T cells of different epitope specificity. Understanding mechanisms of T cell coexistence has important practical implications for immune therapies that require a broad immune response.     

T cell suppression by osteoclasts in vitro

T cells are critical regulators of osteoclast differentiation and function in bone, but whether osteoclasts can, in turn, regulate T cell homing, and response to stimuli is unclear. To investigate whether osteoclasts are immune competent cells, the expression of HLA Class II and costimulatory receptors was evaluated by RT‐PCR and immunohistochemistry by comparing osteoclast precursors and mature osteoclasts. T‐cell‐attracting chemokines were measured in the supernatants of confluent cultures of osteoclasts and compared with mesenchymal stromal cells and osteoblasts. T cell proliferation, cytokine production, and apoptosis were assayed in co‐cultures with osteoclasts in the presence or absence of mitogenic stimuli. To define the mechanism of action of osteoclasts, cytokine‐blocking experiments were performed. Our findings revealed that mature osteoclasts constitutively expressed Class II HLA in the membrane and upregulate the expression of CD40 and CD80 during differentiation. Osteoclasts secreted high levels of most T cell chemoattractants and effectively retained T cells in adhesion assays. Moreover, the osteoclasts potently blunted T cell response to PHA and CD3/CD28 stimulation, thus inhibiting proliferation, suppressing T cell TNFα and IFNγ production and decreasing T cell apoptosis by a mostly cell‐contact independent mechanism. In conclusion, osteoclasts are immune‐competent cells which can retain T cells and suppress in vitro T cell response to proliferative stimuli. J. Cell. Physiol. 226: 982–990, 2011. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Heterogeneity of the memory CD4 T cell response: persisting effectors and resting memory T cells

Defining the cellular composition of the memory T cell pool has been complicated by an inability to distinguish effector and memory T cells. We present here an activation profile assay, using anti-CD3 and antigenic stimuli, that clearly distinguishes effector and memory CD4 T cells and defines subsets of long-lived memory CD4 T cells based on CD62 ligand (CD62L) expression. The CD62L(low) memory subset functionally resembles effector cells, exhibiting hyper-responsiveness to antigenic and anti-CD3 mediated stimuli, high proliferative capacity, and rapid activation kinetics. The CD62L(high) memory subset functionally resembles resting memory cells, exhibiting hyporesponsiveness to anti-CD3 stimuli, lower proliferative capacity, and slower activation kinetics. Our results indicate that the memory CD4 T cell pool is heterogeneous, consisting of persisting effectors and resting memory T cells.     

The kinetics and stimulant dependence of cytokine production by blood and bronchoalveolar lavage T cells evaluated at the single cell level.

We have previously shown that bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) T cells from human airways predominantly produce interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) and interleukin 2 (IL-2) when stimulated ex vivo. The kinetics of TH1 and TH2 cell cytokine production by T cells from both blood and BAL were studied to establish the optimal time after stimulation either with pharbol myristate (PMA) and ionomycin or with the more physiological stimulus of anti-CD3 for intracellular cytokine detection of IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-4 and IL-5 in both blood and BAL T cells. The optimal time for positive identification of IL-2 in both blood and BAL was 5 h after PMA/ionomycin stimulation, whereas the first peak for IFN-gamma was found after 5 h in blood but after only 3 h in BAL. T cells from different biological compartments responded differently to each of the stimuli. Whilst anti-CD3 stimulation did not induce TH1 cytokine production in blood T cells, it readily induced both IFN-gamma and IL-2 production in BAL T cells. The kinetics of cytokine production were found to be stimulus dependent. Whilst IL-2 production showed similar kinetics with both stimuli, the kinetics of IFN-gamma production differed between stimuli. We have also examined the effect of five different stimuli on cytokine production by T cells to determine whether different forms of stimulation may selectively stimulate or inhibit different cytokines. Not surprisingly, PMA/ionomycin induced a greater percentage of BAL T cells to produce TH1 cytokines. However, other than modest amounts of the TH2 cytokines IL-4 and IL-5 were not induced by any of the five stimuli.     

Cell surface charge and regulation of cell division of 3T3 cells and transformed derivatives.

The cell surface charge of 3T3, 3T6, SV40-3T3 cells and trypsin-, neuraminidase- and serumtreated preparations of these has been characterized by microcell electrophoresis. At 25 °C, density-inhibited 3T3 cells show a decrease in electrophoretic mobility when treated with various stimuli of cell division. This effect is not observed at 25 °C for transformed derivatives. The surface charge configuration of various cell preparations exhibits a thermal transition which is located within a temperature range characteristic of each preparation. These and other results from cell electrophoresis, taken together with those obtained in agglutination studies by other authors, are considered evidence for the occurrence in the plasma membrane of these cells of a twodimensional phase separation. The temperature range of this phase separation is shifted on treating the cells by growth stimuli. This effect might be an indication of a basic trigger mechanism in the cell cycle.     

Activation in vivo of a major antisuppressor T-cell pathway immediately after immunization. III. T-cell requirements for its induction

Immunogenic stimuli rapidly induce a potent mediator with antisuppressor activity which represents complexes of Ig and antigen. The formation of the complexes depends on the interaction of two T cells both of which bear the Ly1 phenotype. The two T cells can be separated on the basis of their sensitivity to antilymphocytic serum and dependency on the presence of thymus. T cells bearing I region coded determinants are essential for the formation of the mediator.     

The JNK cascade as a biochemical switch in mammalian cells: ultrasensitive and all-or-none responses

JNK proteins are ubiquitously expressed, evolutionarily conserved MAP kinases that are involved in stress responses. Recently, it was shown that the JNK cascade in Xenopus oocytes exhibits sustained, all-or-none responses to graded, transient stimuli. Here, we have examined the character of the JNK cascade's response in mammalian cells. The steady-state responses of JNK to sorbitol and anisomycin were found to be highly ultrasensitive in HeLa cells, HEK 293 cells, and Jurkat T cells. The JNK responses were also reversible, not sustained, as was the case in oocytes. Jurkat cells activated their JNK in response to phorbol myristate acetate (PMA), and the response of the entire population of Jurkat cells was graded. However, analysis of subpopulations of the PMA-treated Jurkat cells revealed that the steady-state responses of both JNK and CD69, a T cell surface activation marker, were essentially all-or-none in character. These studies show that the JNK cascade commonly exhibits switch-like responses to a variety of stimuli.     

Antigen receptor-mediated anergy in resting T lymphocytes and T cell clones. Correlation with lymphokine secretion patterns.

The goal of these studies was to define the stimuli and factors that control the induction of anergy in unimmunized resting T lymphocytes. Initial experiments, aimed at establishing the system, showed that exposure of Th1 but not Th2 clones to immobilized anti-CD3 leads to a block in autocrine growth factor production and proliferation upon subsequent restimulation with Ag+APC. Anergy is not prevented by accessory cells, suggesting that this model of T cell tolerance may be due to receptor-mediated inhibitory signals, independent of costimulatory molecules. Culture of small (resting) unimmunized T lymphocytes with anti-CD3 +/- IL-2 induces unresponsiveness to restimulation with anti-CD3, but culture with anti-CD3+IL-4, which stimulates the differentiation of resting cells into IL-4 producers, does not induce anergy. Thus, IL-4-producing clones and bulk populations of IL-4-producing T cells are resistant to Ag receptor-mediated inhibitory stimuli. These results provide experimental models for studying the mechanisms of anergy in normal, unselected, mature T cells, and demonstrate fundamental similarities between cloned cell lines and unimmunized T lymphocytes in the induction of anergy.     

T cell homeostasis

The pool of mature T cells comprises a heterogeneous mixture of naive and memory CD4(+) and CD8(+) cells. These cells are long lived at a population level but differ markedly in their relative rates of turnover and survival. Here, we review how contact with exogenous stimuli, notably self MHC ligands and various gamma(c) cytokines, plays a decisive role in controlling normal T cell homeostasis.     

Production of IL-12 by human monocyte-derived dendritic cells is optimal when the stimulus is given at the onset of maturation, and is further enhanced by IL-4

Dendritic cells produce IL-12 both in response to microbial stimuli and to T cells, and can thus skew T cell reactivity toward a Th1 pattern. We investigated the capacity of dendritic cells to elaborate IL-12 with special regard to their state of maturation, different maturation stimuli, and its regulation by Th1/Th2-influencing cytokines. Monocyte-derived dendritic cells were generated with GM-CSF and IL-4 for 7 days, followed by another 3 days +/- monocyte-conditioned media, yielding mature (CD83(+)/dendritic cell-lysosome-associated membrane glycoprotein(+)) and immature (CD83(-)/dendritic cell-lysosome-associated membrane glycoprotein(-)) dendritic cells. These dendritic cells were stimulated for another 48 h, and IL-12 p70 was measured by ELISA. We found the following: 1) Immature dendritic cells stimulated with CD154/CD40 ligand or bacteria (both of which concurrently also induced maturation) secreted always more IL-12 than already mature dendritic cells. Mature CD154-stimulated dendritic cells still made significant levels (up to 4 ng/ml). 2) Terminally mature skin-derived dendritic cells did not make any IL-12 in response to these stimuli. 3) Appropriate maturation stimuli are required for IL-12 production: CD40 ligation and bacteria are sufficient; monocyte-conditioned media are not. 4) Unexpectedly, IL-4 markedly increased the amount of IL-12 produced by both immature and mature dendritic cells, when present during stimulation. 5) IL-10 inhibited the production of IL-12. Our results, employing a cell culture system that is now being widely used in immunotherapy, extend prior data that IL-12 is produced most abundantly by dendritic cells that are beginning to respond to maturation stimuli. Surprisingly, IL-12 is only elicited by select maturation stimuli, but can be markedly enhanced by the addition of the Th2 cytokine, IL-4.     

Isolated peripheral T cells from GvHR recipients exhibit defective IL-2R expression, IL-2 production, and proliferation in response to activation stimuli

Graft-vs-host reactions (GvHR) following the injection of class I/II MHC disparate parental cells into unirradiated F1 recipient mice result in the development of marked immune dysfunction. Following negative selection using adherence and antibody and complement depletion, highly purified T cells were examined to determine their ability to undergo activation. Three weeks after GvHR initiation, unstimulated splenic T cells from GvHR mice displayed normal CD3 and IL-2R expression but elevated expression of class I MHC and Ly-6A/E antigens. Despite culture with normal F1 accessory cells, both CD4+ and CD8+ GvHR T cells exhibited low levels of proliferation to both Con A and anti-CD3 mAb. Although following exposure for 12 h to either of these stimuli, GvHR T cells expressed normal levels of IL-2R, expression was greatly decreased vs normal T cells between 24 and 48 h. In addition, at no timepoint was detectable IL-2 produced by GvHR T cells. Importantly, mixing experiments did not demonstrate detectable suppressive activity in the purified GvHR T cell subsets. GvHR T cells were also tested for their ability to respond to stimuli in the absence of any accessory cell population. These cells again did not proliferate to levels equivalent to normal T cells. Incubation with PMA and either cytokines (Con A supernatant, rIL-7) or anti-CD3 mAb resulted in only low levels of proliferation in GvHR T cells. Notably, at high ionomycin concentrations together with PMA, GvHR T cells did proliferate to equivalent levels as normal cells. However, with decreasing concentrations of ionophore, these cells failed to proliferate as well as normal cells. In total, these findings demonstrate that GvHR T cells are phenotypically and functionally distinct from normal T cells. The results suggest that GvHR T cells themselves may contribute to the well-characterized immune depression occurring in recipients undergoing GvHR.     

Higher Sensitivity of Foxp3+ Treg Compared to Foxp3- Conventional T Cells to TCR-Independent Signals for CD69 Induction

T lymphocytes elicit specific responses after recognizing cognate antigen. However, antigen-experienced T cells can also respond to non-cognate stimuli, such as cytokines. CD4⁺ Foxp3⁺ regulatory T cells (Treg) exhibit an antigen-experienced-like phenotype. Treg can regulate T cell responses in an antigen-specific or bystander way, and it is still unclear as to which extent they rely on T cell receptor (TCR) signals. The study of the antigen response of Treg has been hampered by the lack of downstream readouts for TCR stimuli. Here we assess the effects of TCR signals on the expression of a classical marker of early T cell activation, CD69. Although it can be induced following cytokine exposure, CD69 is commonly used as a readout for antigen response on T cells. We established that upon in vitro TCR stimulation CD69 induction on Foxp3⁺ Treg cells was more dependent on signaling via soluble factors than on TCR activation. By contrast, expression of the activation marker Nur77 was only induced after TCR stimulation. Our data suggest that Treg are more sensitive to TCR-independent signals than Foxp3^- cells, which could contribute to their bystander activity.     

Activation-driven T cell death. II. Quantitative differences alone distinguish stimuli triggering nontransformed T cell proliferation or death.

Clonal deletion is the major mechanism by which T cell tolerance is achieved in vivo. The process of activation-driven cell death, originally characterized with T cell hybridomas, likely represents the mechanism of clonal deletion because it shares a number of properties with the in vivo process, especially the ability to be triggered in an Ag-specific manner, the cell-autonomous nature of the response, and its sensitivity to the drug cyclosporin A. We now have extended our analysis of activation-driven cell death to clonal populations of nontransformed T cells. Activation-driven cell death can be induced in nontransformed T lymphocytes by combinations of mitogenic stimuli. In particular, two mitogenic stimuli at high dose, one a lymphokine and the other delivered via the TCR or another activation structure, are required to induce activation-driven cell death. Activation-driven cell death is an active cell suicide process with attributes typical of physiological cell death, including early nuclear disintegration and a requirement for macromolecular synthesis, and is distinct from death by factor deprivation. Susceptibility to the induction of cell death by antigenic or activating stimulation is a common aspect of most T cells and is consistent with observations that clonal deletion can occur throughout T cell ontogeny. Most importantly, the alternative cellular responses of cell death and cell proliferation in nontransformed T cells appear to be triggered solely as a function of quantitative differences in the doses of identical stimuli. This can be viewed as a dose-dependent switch that determines cell fate. Developmental regulation of this switch may explain the processes of positive and negative selection during T cell ontogeny and also provide a mechanistic rationale for a strategy of selective anti-tumor therapy.     

T cell responses in mammalian diaphanous-related formin mDia1 knock-out mice

Activated T cells rapidly assemble filamentous (F-) actin networks in response to ligation of the T cell receptor or upon interaction with adhesive stimuli in order to facilitate cell migration and the formation of the immune synapse. Branched filament assembly is crucial for this process and is dependent upon activation of the Arp2/3 complex by the actin nucleation-promoting factor Wiskott-Aldrich Syndrome protein (WASp). Genetic disruption of the WAS gene has been linked to hematopoietic malignancies and various cytopenias. Although the contributions of WASp and Arp2/3 to T cell responses are fairly well characterized, the role of the mammalian Diaphanous (mDia)-related formins, which both nucleate and processively elongate non-branched F-actin, has not been demonstrated. Here, we report the effects on T cell development and function following the knock out of the murine Drf1 gene encoding the canonical formin p140mDia1. Drf1(-/-) mice develop lymphopenia characterized by diminished T cell populations in lymphoid tissues. Consistent with a role for p140mDia1 in the regulation of the actin cytoskeleton, isolated Drf1(-/-) splenic T cells adhered poorly to extracellular matrix proteins and migration in response to chemotactic stimuli was completely abrogated. Both integrin and chemokine receptor expression was unaffected by Drf1(-/-) targeting. In response to proliferative stimuli, both thymic and splenic Drf1(-/-) T cells failed to proliferate; ERK1/2 activation was also diminished in activated Drf1(-/-) T cells. These data suggest a central role for p140mDia1 in vivo in dynamic cytoskeletal remodeling events driving normal T cell responses.     

Suppression of T lymphocyte function by measles virus is due to cell cycle arrest in G1

Measles virus suppresses T lymphocyte functions in vitro. When measles virus-infected T lymphocytes are stimulated with PHA or 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate, plus calcium ionophore, the cells secrete IL-2 and express the IL-2R or Tac Ag to a similar extent as uninfected cells, yet proliferation is reduced by 50 to 90%. Stimulated infected T cells also express the cell surface activation Ag 4F2, transferrin R, and HLA-DR. The secretion of IFN-gamma by infected T cells in response to PHA is not suppressed at 24 to 72 h after stimulation. Total RNA synthesis at 48 and 72 h after stimulation is reduced in infected T lymphocytes. Infectious measles virus progeny are produced during this interval. Thus infected T lymphocytes can become activated in response to mitogenic stimuli and the cells support efficient viral replication before the block in cell proliferation.