THE SEXUAL LIFE CYCLES OF PFIESTERIA PISCICIDA AND CRYPTOPERIDINIOPSOIDS (DINOPHYCEAE)1

Sexual life cycle events in Pfiesteria piscicida and cryptoperidiniopsoid heterotrophic dinoflagellates were determined by following the development of isolated gamete pairs in single‐drop microcultures with cryptophyte prey. Under these conditions, the observed sequence of zygote formation, development, and postzygotic divisions was similar in these dinoflagellates. Fusion of motile gamete pairs each produced a rapidly swimming uninucleate planozygote with two longitudinal flagella. Planozygotes enlarged as they fed repeatedly on cryptophytes. In <12 h in most cases, each planozygote formed a transparent‐walled nonmotile cell (cyst) with a single nucleus. Zygotic cysts did not exhibit dormancy under these conditions. In each taxon, dramatic swirling chromosome movements (nuclear cyclosis) were found in zygote nuclei before division. In P. piscicida, nuclear cyclosis occurred in the zygotic cyst or apparently earlier in the planozygote. In the cryptoperidiniopsoids, nuclear cyclosis occurred inthe zygotic cyst. After nuclear cyclosis, a single cell division occurred in P. piscicida and cryptoperidiniopsoid zygotic cysts, producing two offspring that emerged as biflagellated cells. These two flagellated cells typically swam for hours and fed on cryptophytes before encysting. A single cell division in these cysts produced two biflagellated offspring that also fed before encysting for further reproduction. This sequence of zygote development and postzygotic divisions typically was completed within 24 h and was confirmed in examples from different isolates of each taxon. Some aspects of the P. piscicida sexual life cycle determined here differed from previous reports.     

LIFE CYCLE OF THE HETEROTROPHIC DINOFLAGELLATE PFIESTERIA PISCICIDA (DINOPHYCEAE)1

The putatively toxic dinoflagellate Pfiesteria piscicida (Steidinger et Burkholder) has been reported to have an unusual life cycle for a free‐living marine dinoflagellate. As many as 24 life cycle stages were originally described for this species. During a recent phylogenetic study in which we used clonal cultures of P. piscicida, we were unable to confirm many reported life cycle stages. To resolve this discrepancy, we undertook a rigorous examination of the life cycle of P. piscicida using nuclear staining techniques combined with traditional light microscopy, high‐resolution video microscopy, EM, and in situ hybridization with a suite of fluorescently labeled peptide nucleic acid (PNA) probes. The results showed that P. piscicida had a typical haplontic dinoflagellate life cycle. Asexual division occurred within a division cyst and not by binary fission of motile cells. Sexual reproduction of this homothallic species occurred via the fusion of isogamous gametes. Examination of tanks where P. piscicida was actively feeding on fish showed that amoebae were present; however, they were contaminants introduced with the fish. Whole cell probing using in situ hybridization techniques confirmed that these amoebae were hybridization negative for a P. piscicida‐specific PNA probe. Direct observations of clonal P. piscicida cultures revealed no unusual life cycle stages. Furthermore, the results of this study provided no evidence for transformations to amoebae. We therefore conclude that P. piscicida has a life cycle typical of free‐living marine dinoflagellates and lacks any amoeboid or other specious stages.     

THE LIFE CYCLE AND TOXICITY OF PFIESTERIA PISCICIDA REVISITED1

Despite use of excellent molecular techniques, Litaker et al. (2002) cannot provide insights about the life history of toxic Pfiesteria piscicida because they showed no data in support of having used toxic strains; rather they presented evidence that they used non‐inducible strains. Litaker et al. did not find amoeboid stages or a chrysophyte‐like cyst stage in several cultures and unequivocally concluded that the stages do not exist in all P. piscicida strains. Thus, they did not consider the tenet that absence of evidence does not constitute proof of absence. Apparent discrepancies between the research by Litaker et al. and previous research on Pfiesteria can be resolved as follows: First, Litaker et al. did not use toxic strains. We have reported findings (similar to Litaker et al.) showing few amoeboid transformations in non‐inducible strains, which manifest some but not all of the forms that have been documented in some toxic strains. We, and others, have documented active toxicity to fish, transformations to amoebae, and chrysophyte‐like cysts in some clonal toxic strains. Second, the data from several recent publications, which were available but not mentioned by Litaker et al. or by Coats (2002) in accompanying commentary, have verified P. piscicida amoebae, chrysophyte‐like cysts, and other stages in some toxic strains through a combination of approaches including PCR data from clonal cultures.     

CELL CYCLE AND CELL MORTALITY OF ALEXANDRIUM MINUTUM (DINOPHYCEAE) UNDER SMALL‐SCALE TURBULENCE CONDITIONS1

Decreased net population growth rates and cellular abundances have been observed in dinoflagellate species exposed to small‐scale turbulence. Here, we investigated whether these effects were caused by alterations in the cell cycle and/or by cell mortality and, in turn, whether these two mechanisms depended on the duration of exposure to turbulence. The study was conducted on the toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum Halim, with the same experimental design and setup used in previous studies to allow direct comparison among results. A combination of microscopy and Coulter Counter measurements allowed us to detect cell mortality, based on the biovolume of broken cells and thecae. The turbulence applied during the exponential growth phase caused an immediate transitory arrest in the G2/M phase, but significant mortality did not occur. This finding suggests that high intensities of small‐scale turbulence can alter the cell division, likely affecting the correct chromosome segregation during the dinomitosis. When shaking persisted for >4 d, mortality signals and presence of anomalously swollen cells appeared, hinting at the activation of mechanisms that induce programmed cell death. Our study suggests that the sensitivity of dinoflagellates to turbulence may drive these organisms to find the most favorable (calm) conditions to complete their division cycle.     

SEXUAL PROCESSES IN THE LIFE CYCLE OF GYRODINIUM UNCATENUM (DINOPHYCEAE): A MORPHOGENETIC OVERVIEW1

Sexual processes in the life cycle of the dinoflagellate Gyrodinium uncatenum Hulburt were investigated in isolated field populations. Morphological and morphogenetic aspects of gamete production, planozygote formation, encystment, excystment, and planomeiocyte division are described from observations of living specimens, Protargol silver impregnated material and scanning electron microscope preparations. The sexual cycle was initiated by gamete formation which involved two asexual divisions of the vegetative organism. Gametes were fully differentiated following the second division and immediately capable of forming pairs. Either isogamous or anisogamous pairs were formed by the mid-ventral union of gametes. Gametes invariably joined with flagellar bases in close juxtaposition. Complete fusion of gametes required ca. 1 h, involved plasmogamy followed by karyogamy and resulted in a quadriflagellated planozygote. Planozygotes encysted in 24–48 h to yield a hypnozygote capable of overwintering in estuarine sediments. Hypnozygotes collected from sediment in late winter readily excysted upon exposure to temperatures above 15°C. A single quadriflagellated planomeiocyte emerged from the cyst and under culture conditions divided one to two days later. The four flagella were not evenly distributed at the first division and both bi- and tri-flagellated daughter cells were formed.     

MORPHOLOGY AND LIFE CYCLE EVENTS IN PYROPHACUS STEINII (SCHILLER) WALL ET DALE (DINOPHYCEAE)

Cells of Pyrophacus steinii (Schiller) Wall et Dale are round and lens shaped and have an anteroposteriorly compressed theca. The epitheca has a truncated, conical horn and a hexagonally shaped apical pore plate with two arched slits positioned off center. The cingulum is equatorial, narrow, and deep. The hypotheca is flat. The sulcus is narrow, slightly curved, and recessed and does not reach the cell's antapex. The plate formula in these specimens of P. steinii is Po, 8', Oa, 13", 13C, 12"', 3p, 3"", and 8S with a difference in the number of precingular (13") and postcingular (12"') plates. No additional posterior intercalary plates were present (Oap). Pregametic stages of P. steinii were observed during cell division via binary fission, with formation of two cells and multiple division with formation of four and eight cells. These newly formed cells were pale in color and were enclosed in double-layered hyaline membrane. Gametes with gymnodinoid morphology were observed within the parental cells. Planozygotes are large and round and enclosed in double-layered hyaline membrane. Mature cell forms are brown with a microgranular cytoplasm, storage bodies, and a red accumulation body. The hypnozygote exhibits triple-layered hyaline membrane, irregularly shaped and comparable with bulbous processes of Tuberculodinium vancampoae Rossigol resting cysts. Division within a hypnocyst of P. steinii involves shedding the parental theca and the development and emergence of two daughter cells with the size and morphology of pregametic cells.     

ISOLATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF CHLORELLA SOROKINIANA GXNN01 (CHLOROPHYTA) WITH THE PROPERTIES OF HETEROTROPHIC AND MICROAEROBIC GROWTH1

Heterotrophic and anaerobic microalgae are of significance in both basic research and industrial application. A microalga strain was isolated from a wastewater treatment pond and identified as Chlorella sorokiniana Shihira et W. R. Krauss GXNN01 in terms of morphology, physiology, and phylogeny. The strain grows rapidly in heterotrophic or mixotrophic conditions with addition of various carbon sources, and even in anaerobic conditions. The maximum growth rate reached 0.28 d^?1 when using d,l ‐malate as the carbon source, and the protein content of the microalgae was 75.32% in cell dry weight. The strain was shown to be capable of (1) utilizing d,l ‐malate only with light, (2) inhibiting photosynthesis in mixotrophic growth, and (3) growing in anaerobic conditions with regular photosynthesis and producing oxygen internally. This study demonstrates the influence of oxygen (aerobic vs. anaerobic) and metabolic regime (autotrophy, mixotrophy, heterotrophy) on the physiological state of the cell.     

DOES DINOPHYSIS (DINOPHYCEAE) HAVE A SEXUAL LIFE CYCLE?1

A variety of morphotypes (of two size classes) within two wild populations of Dinophysis acuta Ehrenberg and D. cf. acuminata are described. The observation that these two cell types engaged in the formation of couplets (possibly leading to the engulfment of the smaller by the larger cell) suggests that these species may undergo a process of sexual reproduction involving the fusion of anisogamous gametes. This behavior and asexual cell division involved a small portion of the population at any one time and took place rapidly at specific subsurface depths and time of day, the former during the evening, the latter during the morning. Even though definite proof of sexuality by Dinophysis was not obtained, the possiblity that sexual dimorphism exists in several species of the genus is discussed.     

REPLY TO COMMENT ON THE LIFE CYCLE AND TOXICITY OF PFIESTERIA PISCICIDA REVISITED1

Free‐living, marine dinoflagellates are typified by a well‐defined, haplontic life cycle with relatively few stages. The most unusual departure from this life cycle is one reported for the heterotrophic dinoflagellate Pfiesteria piscicida Steidinger et Burkholder. This species is alleged to have at least 24 life cycle stages including amoebae and a chrysophyte‐like cyst form ( Burkholder et al. 1992 , Burkholder and Glasgow 1997a ) not previously known in free‐living marine dinoflagellates. Litaker et al. (2002) redescribed the life cycle of P. piscicida from single‐cell isolates and found only life cycle stages typical of free‐living marine dinoflagellates. The discrepancy between these observations and the life cycle reported in the literature prompted a rigorous study to resolve the life cycle of P. piscicida. Burkholder and Glasgow (2002) took exception to this study, arguing that Litaker et al. (2002) misunderstood the life cycle of P. piscicida and ignored recent publications. We present a rebuttal of their criticisms and suggest a simple way to resolve the discrepancies in the P. piscicida life cycle.     

ISOLATION AND PHYSIOLOGICAL STUDIES ON THREE ISOLATES OF AMPHORA (BACILLARIOPHYCEAE)1

Three clones of the diatom Amphora were euryhaline, able to grow autotrophically at 160 lx (0.001 ly/min) and heterotrophically on glucose and fructose. Furthermore 2 clones grew on glutamate and feast extract. Light-limited growth of individual clones was stimulated by glycerol, galactose, lactate, acetate, aspartate and asparagine, although mannose torn inhibitory at low and high light levels. The half-saturation constant for growth of A. coffeaefomis var. perpusilla Grunow (Cleve) with glucose was 25 μM. Heterotrophic growth rate of this organism became saturated with respect to glucose at 0.5 mM.     

MULTIPLE ROUTES OF SEXUALITY IN ALEXANDRIUM TAYLORI (DINOPHYCEAE) IN CULTURE1

Alexandrium taylori Balech is a cyst‐forming dinoflagellate species responsible for recurrent blooms in Mediterranean coastal waters. The nuclear development of the cells during the sexual cycle and the effect of different external nitrate and phosphate levels were studied. Nuclear fusion of gametes occurred 6–12 h after the complete cytoplasmic fusion. The U‐shaped nuclei fused through the end of one nucleus and the mid‐area of the other. The mobile and biflagellated zygote had a large, U‐shaped nucleus and may follow three different fates: direct division, short‐term encystment (ecdysal), and long‐term encystment (resting). Ecdysal cysts may divide in >24–96 h into two, four, six, or eight cells before germinating. Meiosis presumably occurred in three locations: in the planozygote, within the ecdysal cyst, and in the planomeiocyte (germling) liberated either from ecdysal or resting cysts. The effects of nutrients on these routes were studied in individually isolated sexual stages. (1) Direct divisions occurred mainly under replete conditions (L1), whereas no direct planozygote divisions were recorded in media with no phosphate added (L‐P). (2) Short‐term encystment was larger in media lacking phosphate (L‐P and L/30) than in medium with no nitrate added (L‐N) or under replete conditions (L1). (3) Long‐term encystment was only observed in medium with no nitrate added (L‐N). The long‐lived resting cyst, not previously described for this species, had a clear double wall, an irregular shape, a flat morphology, and a middle orange spot. No cysts germinated in 1–2 months, whereas 86% of the cysts germinated 2–3 months after being formed. A flow cytometry analysis showed that sexual induction and zygote formation were very fast and highly common processes, zygotes being nearly half of the population at days 3 and 5 after the induction of sexuality in the cultures.     

PHAGOTROPHIC FEEDING AND ITS IMPORTANCE TO THE LIFE CYCLE OF THE HOLOZOIC DINOFLAGELLATE,GYMNODINIUM FUNGIFORME1

The holozoic dinoflagellate, Gymnodinium fungiforme Anissimova, has been observed in both asexually and sexually reproducing cultures. Asexual reproduction is characterized by zoosporangium formation and subsequent new cell release. Sexuality is gametic, and planozygotes and hypnozygotes are present. The life cycle is highly dependent on feeding, and in food-depleted cultures the swimming cells rapidly disappear. These are replaced with resistant long-term resting cysts. Despite its small size (8.5–19 μm), G. fungiforme can feed on prey as large as the ciliated protozoan, Condylostoma magnum Spiegel (600–1000 μm in length), or small injured metazoans, and has been cultured phagotrophically with the chlorophyte, Dunaliella salina Teodoresco as a food source. Eleven additional species of algae including 1 chlorophyte, 7 chrysophytes and 3 rhodophytes, however, were not suitable as food sources. Feeding is characterized by the formation of ‘dynamic aggregations’ of hundreds of dinoflagellates that attach to the surface of a prey organism by a peduncle. G. fungiforme ingests the cytoplasm or body fluids of its prey and a feeding aggregation can ingest a C. magnum in 20–30 minutes.     

INTENSE GRAZING AND PREY‐DEPENDENT GROWTH OF PFIESTERIA PISCICIDA (DINOPHYCEAE)1

Grazing and growth of Pfiesteria piscicida (Pfiest) were investigated using batch and cyclostat cultures with Rhodomonas sp. (Rhod) as prey. Observed maximum growth rates (1.4 d^?1) and population densities (2 × 10⁵ cells·mL^?1) corresponded to values predicted by Monod functions (1.76 d^?1; 1.4 × 10⁵ cells·mL^?1). In batch cultures under a range of prey‐to‐predator ratios (0.1:1 to 180:1) and prey concentrations (1000–71,000 cells·mL^?1), Rhodomonas sp. was always depleted rapidly and P. piscicida concentrations increased briefly. The rate of Rhodomonas sp. depletion and the magnitude of P. piscicida population maxima depended on the prey‐to‐predator ratio and prey concentration. Starvation resulted in cell cycle arrest at G1 and G2+M and ultimately the demise of both P. piscicida and Rhodomonas sp. populations, demonstrating the dependence of P. piscicida on the supply of appropriate prey. The depletion of Rhodomonas sp. populations could be attributed directly to grazing, because P. piscicida did not exert detectable inhibitory effects on the growth of Rhodomonas sp. but grazed intensely, with maximum grazing rates>10 Rhod·Pfiest^?1·d^?1 and with no apparent threshold prey abundance for grazing. The results suggest that 1) the abundance of appropriate prey may be an important factor regulating P. piscicida abundance in nature, 2) P. piscicida may control prey population, and 3) high growth and grazing potentials of P. piscicida along with cell cycle arrest may confer survival advantages.     

OBSERVATIONS ON THE MORPHOLOGY AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION OF COOLIA MONOTIS (DINOPHYCEAE)1

The surface morphology of the dinoflagellate Coolia monotis Meunier was compared with the surface morphology of Ostreopsis, The apical pore of C. monotis is similar in architecture to that of Ostreopsis but considerably longer (12 μm) than in O. heptagona (8–9 μm) and O. ovata (6–7 μm). A ventral pore in C. monotis is located on the right ventral margin between apical plate l′ and precingular plate 6″ and is similar in appearance and location to the ventral pore of O. ovata. The longitudinal flagellum (20 μm) in C. monotis is longer than in O. ovata (12 μ). Although Coolia and Ostreopsis appear to be distinctly different and should remain as two separate genera, they appear to be related. Cells of C. monotis divided by binary fission. Doubling time was 3–4 days in the logarithmic phase of growth at 23°C, 12:12 h L:D, 30–90 μE-m^?2·s^?1, and a salinity of 36%. Cultures reached cell densities of 2.5 × 10³ cells·L^?1 after 15 days of growth. The sexual process in C. monotis occurred in Erdschreiber's medium when Danish soil extract was substituted with mangrove sediment extract under the culture conditions described above. Gamete fusion produced large biflagellated planozygotes (70–75 μm diam). Planozygote maturation involved cytoplasmic reorganization, loss of motility, development of a spherical shape (80–90 μm diam), and two to three orange accumulation bodies. The cells at this stage appeared to be thin-walled cysts. Further development included reorganization of cyst contents, emergence of non-motile gametes, and development of chloroplasts, sulcus, and girdle. The nucleus of the newly formed cells occupied 50% or more of the total cell volume. Meiosis occurred in the cyst, but nuclear cyclosis was not observed. Four daughter cells were produced within 36–48 h, and motile gametes developed. The gametes exhibited sexuality for 2 months and completed the sexual life cycle by going through a thin-walled cyst stage.     

A STUDY OF THE SEXUAL REPRODUCTION AND DETERMINATION OF MATING TYPE OF GYMNODINIUM NOLLERI (DINOPHYCEAE) IN CULTURE1

Sexual reproduction of Gymnodinium nolleri ( Ellegaard & Moestrup 1999 ) was studied by intercrossing experiments in all combinations of six clonal strains and backcrossing of five clonal F1 offspring. The results indicated that the conjugation of G. nolleri responded to the existence of more than two sexual types (complex heterothallism) and that compatibility between progeny of one cyst (inbreeding) was the rule. Sexual fusion, planozygote formation and development, cyst formation, and germination and planomeiocyte division were followed using time‐lapse photography. This study revealed many similarities between the sexual stages and life cycle pattern of G. nolleri and the related G. catenatum and the existence under culture conditions of an alternative cycle between vegetative cells and zygotes without a hypnozygote stage. The fate of zygotes, division or encystment, was influenced by the nutritional status of the external medium. The division of G. nolleri planozygotes was promoted by high levels of external nutrients, whereas the maximum percentage of encystment was recorded when phosphates were reduced in the isolation medium. The division of zygotes might be different from both vegetative and planomeiocyte division because it resulted in two‐cell chains with the cells not oriented in parallel.     

THE LIFE CYCLE OE SARGASSUM HORNERI (PHAEOPHYTA) IN LABORATORY CULTURE1

The life cycle of the large dioecious alga Sargassum horneri (Turner) C. Agardh was completed in unialgal culture by controlling photoperiod in relation to the phase of growth. Embryos isolated from a naturally grown female thallus gave rise to early germlings that rapidly formed blades under both short-day (9 h L) and long-day (15 h L) conditions at 20° C Shoot elongation, which followed early blade formation, occurred under the short-day conditions hut not under the long-day conditions. Functional female and male receptacles developed when thalli 8–14 cm long grown under the short-day conditions were transferred to the long-day conditions; gamete fusion occurred when male and female thalli were grown together. Fertilized oospores gave rise to normal thalli in a manner similar to that for in situ plants. Thus, the life cycle of S. horneri was completed in laboratory culture.     

LIFE CYCLE OF A STEPHANODISCUS SP. (BACILLARIOPHYTA)1

Studies of the life cycle of a centric diatom, tentatively identified as Stephanodiscus neoastraea Håkansson & Hickel, showed that sexual reproduction occurred every year in a freshwater lake (Lough Neagh, Northern Ireland). Male and female gametes were produced in cells below 55% of the maximum diameter during a 3–4-week period in late summer, following the return of nitrate concentrations above 10 μM NO_3-N. The frequency of sexual reproduction was linked to the cycle of diameter size reduction and regeneration. The times of largest decreases in cell diameter were during nutrient stress in summer and low light conditions in late autumn, rather than during the main spring growth period. So, environmental conditions (combined with the limited life-spans of individual cells) affected the rate of diameter reduction and, therefore, the length of the life cycle (3–4 years).