Proton leak in hepatocytes and liver mitochondria from archosaurs (crocodiles) and allometric relationships for ectotherms

It has previously been shown that mitochondrial proton conductance decreases with increasing body mass in mammals and is lower in a 250-g lizard than the laboratory rat. To examine whether mitochondrial proton conductance is extremely low in very large reptiles, hepatocytes and mitochondria were prepared from saltwater crocodiles ( Crocodylus porosus) and freshwater crocodiles ( Crocodylus johnstoni). Respiration rates of hepatocytes and liver mitochondria were measured at 37 degrees C and compared with values obtained for rat or previously measured for other species. Respiration rates of hepatocytes from either species of crocodile were similar to those reported for lizards and approximately one fifth of the rates measured using cells from mammals (rat and sheep). Ten-to-thirty percent of crocodile hepatocyte respiration was used to drive mitochondrial proton leak, similar to the proportion in other species. Respiration rates of crocodile liver mitochondria were similar to those of mammalian species. Proton leak rate in isolated liver mitochondria was measured as a function of membrane potential. Contrary to our prediction, the mitochondrial proton conductance of liver mitochondria from crocodiles was greater than that of liver mitochondria from lizards and was similar to that of rats. The acyl composition of liver mitochondrial phospholipids from the crocodiles was more similar to that in mitochondria from rats than in mitochondria from lizards. The relatively high mitochondrial proton conductance was associated with a relatively small liver, which seems to be characteristic of crocodilians. Comparison of data from a number of diverse ectothermic species suggested that hepatocyte respiration rate may decrease with body mass, with an allometric exponent of about -0.2, similar to the exponent in mammalian hepatocytes. However, unlike mammals, liver mitochondrial proton conductance in ectotherms showed no allometric relationship with body size.     

Proton leak modulation in testicular mitochondria affects reactive oxygen species production and lipid peroxidation

Mitochondrial proton leak can account for almost 20% of oxygen consumption and it is generally accepted that this process contributes to basal metabolism. In order to clarify the role of basal proton leak in testicular mitochondria, we performed a comparative study with kidney and liver mitochondrial fractions. Proton leak stimulated by linoleic acid and inhibited by guanosine diphosphate (GDP) was detected, in a manner that was correlated with protein levels for uncoupling protein 2 (UCP2) in the three fractions. Modulation of proton leak had an effect on reactive oxygen species production as well as on lipid peroxidation, and this effect was also tissue‐dependent. However, a possible role for the adenine nucleotide transporter (ANT) in testicular mitochondria proton leak could not be excluded. The modulation of proton leak appears as a possible and attractive target to control oxidative stress with implications for male gametogenesis. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Phylogenetic differences of mammalian basal metabolic rate are not explained by mitochondrial basal proton leak

Metabolic rates of mammals presumably increased during the evolution of endothermy, but molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying basal metabolic rate (BMR) are still not understood. It has been established that mitochondrial basal proton leak contributes significantly to BMR. Comparative studies among a diversity of eutherian mammals showed that BMR correlates with body mass and proton leak. Here, we studied BMR and mitochondrial basal proton leak in liver of various marsupial species. Surprisingly, we found that the mitochondrial proton leak was greater in marsupials than in eutherians, although marsupials have lower BMRs. To verify our finding, we kept similar-sized individuals of a marsupial opossum (Monodelphis domestica) and a eutherian rodent (Mesocricetus auratus) species under identical conditions, and directly compared BMR and basal proton leak. We confirmed an approximately 40 per cent lower mass specific BMR in the opossum although its proton leak was significantly higher (approx. 60%). We demonstrate that the increase in BMR during eutherian evolution is not based on a general increase in the mitochondrial proton leak, although there is a similar allometric relationship of proton leak and BMR within mammalian groups. The difference in proton leak between endothermic groups may assist in elucidating distinct metabolic and habitat requirements that have evolved during mammalian divergence.     

The mitochondrial uncoupling-protein homologues

Uncoupling protein(UCP)1 is an integral membrane protein that is located in the mitochondrial inner membrane of brown adipocytes. Its physiological role is to mediate a regulated, thermogenic proton leak. UCP2 and UCP3 are recently identified UCP1 homologues. They also mediate regulated proton leak, and might function to control the production of superoxide and other downstream reactive oxygen species. However, their role in normal physiology remains unknown. Recent studies have shown that UCP2 has an important part in the pathogenesis of type-2 diabetes. The obscure roles of the UCP homologues in normal physiology, together with their emerging role in pathophysiology, provide exciting potential for further investigation.     

Long-term calorie restriction reduces proton leak and hydrogen peroxide production in liver mitochondria

Calorie restriction (CR) without malnutrition increases maximal life span in diverse species. It has been proposed that reduction in energy expenditure and reactive oxygen species (ROS) production could be a mechanism for life span extension with CR. As a step toward testing this theory, mitochondrial proton leak, H2O2 production, and markers of oxidative stress were measured in liver from FBNF1 rats fed control or 40% CR diets for 12 or 18 mo. CR was initiated at 6 mo of age. Proton leak kinetics curves, generated from simultaneous measures of oxygen consumption and membrane potential, indicated a decrease in proton leak after 18 mo of CR, while only a trend toward a proton leak decrease was observed after 12 mo. Significant shifts in phosphorylation and substrate oxidation curves also occurred with CR; however, these changes occurred in concert with the proton leak changes. Metabolic control analysis indicated no difference in the overall pattern of control of the oxidative phosphorylation system between control and CR animals. At 12 mo, no significant differences were observed between groups for H2O2 production or markers of oxidative stress. However, at 18 mo, protein carbonyl content was lower in CR animals, as was H2O2 production when mitochondria were respiring on either succinate alone or pyruvate plus malate in the presence of rotenone. These results indicate that long-term CR lowers mitochondrial proton leak and H2O2 production, and this is consistent with the idea that CR may act by decreasing energy expenditure and ROS production.     

Mitochondrial proton leak and the uncoupling protein 1 homologues

Mitochondrial proton leak is the largest single contributor to the standard metabolic rate (SMR) of a rat, accounting for about 20% of SMR. Yet the mechanisms by which proton leak occurs are incompletely understood. The available evidence suggests that both phospholipids and proteins in the mitochondrial inner membrane are important determinants of proton conductance. The uncoupling protein 1 homologues (e.g. UCP2, UCP3) may play a role in mediating proton leak, but it is unlikely they account for all of the observed proton conductance. Experimental data regarding the functions of these proteins include important ambiguities and contradictions which must be addressed before their function can be confirmed. The physiological role of the proton leak, and of the uncoupling protein 1 homologues, remains similarly unclear.     

Mitochondrial H(+) leak and ROS generation: an odd couple

The single-electron chemistry of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation (ox-phos) by default generates reactive oxygen species (ROS). These ROS have roles in both physiologic cell signaling and numerous pathologic situations. One factor that has the potential to regulate ROS generation is the mild uncoupling of ox-phos, i.e., proton (H(+)) leak across the mitochondrial inner membrane. Proton leak has been shown to decrease ROS generation, whereas ROS have been shown to induce H(+) leak, and this suggests the existence of a feedback loop between ROS and H(+) leak. Interestingly, although H(+) leak is detrimental to ATP synthesis, it has been shown to be cytoprotective in several models of ischemic injury. Herein the molecular basis of both ROS generation and H(+) leak will be reviewed and the consequences of their interaction for mitochondrial function discussed.     

Proton leak and hydrogen peroxide production in liver mitochondria from energy-restricted rats

Energy restriction (ER), without malnutrition, is the only environmental intervention that consistently increases maximum life span in laboratory rodents. One theory proposes that a reduction in energy expenditure and reactive oxygen species production is the mechanism responsible for this action of ER. To further test this theory, proton leak, H2O2 production, lipid peroxidation, and protein carbonyls were measured in mitochondria from FBNF1 rats fed either a control or 40% ER diet (onset at 6 mo of age). Liver mitochondria were isolated at 7 and 12 mo of age. Liver weight decreased 25 and 36% at 1 and 6 mo of ER, respectively (P < 0.05). ER resulted in an increase (P < 0.05) in percent total polyunsaturates, n-6 polyunsaturates, and total unsaturates (6 mo only) in mitochondrial lipids. These changes, however, were not associated with significant alterations in mitochondrial function. State 4 respiration and membrane potential were not different (P > 0.05) between groups at either assessment period. Similarly, proton leak kinetics were not different between control and ER animals. Top-down metabolic control analysis and its extension, elasticity analysis, were used at the 6-mo assessment and revealed no difference in control of the oxidative phosphorylation system between control and ER rats. H2O2 production with either succinate or pyruvate/malate substrates was also not different (P > 0.05) between groups at either time point. In conclusion, ER did not alter proton leak or H2O2 production at this age or stage of restriction in liver.     

The effect of general anesthetics on the proton and potassium permeabilities of liposomes

The pump-leak hypothesis of general anesthesia proposes that anesthetics act by increasing the functional proton permeability of membranes, particularly those of synaptic vesicles. Since transmembrane proton gradients are required for neurotransmitter accumulation, decay of such gradients by an uncompensated anesthetic-induced leak would result in loss of neurotransmitter from the vesicles, followed by synaptic block and anesthesia. We have tested this hypothesis by determining the effect of four different general anesthetics on the relative permeabilities of liposome membranes to protons and potassium ions. In all cases, physiologically relevant levels of anesthetics caused a 200 to 500 percent increment in ionic permeability. There was no marked preference for protons, suggesting that the anesthetics did not induce a leak specific for this ionic species. Instead the anesthetics appeared to produce a more general defect available to both protons and potassium ions which resulted in a functional increment in proton permeability. These observations were compared with available data on proton transport rates by synaptic vesicle ATPase enzymes. The magnitude of the anesthetic-induced leak could not be compensated by the ATPase, which is only capable of a 40 percent increase in rate when uncoupled. We consider these results to be consistent with the pump-leak hypothesis.     

Uncoupling protein-1 (UCP1) contributes to the basal proton conductance of brown adipose tissue mitochondria

Proton leak pathways uncouple substrate oxidation from ATP synthesis in mitochondria. These pathways are classified as basal (not regulated) or inducible (activated and inhibited). Previously it was found that over half of the basal proton conductance of muscle mitochondria was catalyzed by the adenine nucleotide translocase (ANT), an abundant mitochondrial anion carrier protein. To determine whether ANT is the unique protein catalyst, or one of many proteins that catalyze basal proton conductance, we measured proton leak kinetics in mitochondria isolated from brown adipose tissue (BAT). BAT can express another mitochondrial anion carrier, UCP1, at concentrations similar to ANT. Basal proton conductance was measured under conditions where UCP1 and ANT were catalytically inactive and was found to be lower in mitochondria from UCP1 knockout mice compared to wild-type. Ablation of another abundant inner membrane protein, nicotinamide nucleotide transhydrogenase, had no effect on proton leak kinetics in mitochondria from liver, kidney or muscle, showing that basal proton conductance is not catalyzed by all membrane proteins. We identify UCP1 as a second protein propagating basal proton leak, lending support to the hypothesis that basal leak pathways are perpetrated by members of the mitochondrial anion carrier family but not by other mitochondrial inner membrane proteins.     

Analysis of the control of respiration rate, phosphorylation rate, proton leak rate and protonmotive force in isolated mitochondria using the 'top-down' approach of metabolic control theory

The rate of respiration of isolated mitochondria was set at different values by addition of either oligomycin or an ADP-regenerating system (glucose and different amounts of hexokinase). We measured the relationship between respiration rate and membrane potential as respiration was titrated by the addition of malonate under each condition. We used the flux control summation and connectivity theorems and the branching theorem of metabolic control theory to calculate the control over respiration rate exerted by the respiratory chain (and associated reactions), phosphorylating system (and associated reactions) and proton leak at each respiration rate. The analysis also yielded the flux control coefficients of these three reactions over phosphorylation rate and proton leak rate and their concentration control coefficients over protonmotive force. We found that respiration rate was controlled largely by the proton leak under non-phosphorylating conditions, by the phosphorylating system at intermediate rates and by both the phosphorylating system and the respiratory chain in state 3. The rate of phosphorylation was controlled largely by the phosphorylating system itself in state 4 and at intermediate rates, while state 3 control was shared between the phosphorylating system and the respiratory chain; the proton leak had insignificant control. In all states the phosphorylating system had large negative control over the proton leak; the chain and the proton leak both had large positive control coefficients. The protonmotive force was controlled by the chain and by the phosphorylating system; the proton leak had little control.     

Effects of short- and medium-term calorie restriction on muscle mitochondrial proton leak and reactive oxygen species production

Reductions in cellular oxygen consumption (Vo2) and reactive oxygen species (ROS) production have been proposed as mechanisms underlying the anti-aging effects of calorie restriction (CR). Mitochondria are a cell's greatest "sink" for oxygen and also its primary source of ROS. The mitochondrial proton leak pathway is responsible for 20-30% of Vo2 in resting cells. We hypothesized that CR leads to decreased proton leak with consequential decreases in Vo2, ROS production, and cellular damage. Here, we report the effects of short-term (2-wk, 2-mo) and medium-term (6-mo) CR (40%) on rat muscle mitochondrial proton leak, ROS production, and whole animal Vo2. Whole body Vo2 decreased with CR at all time points, whereas mass-adjusted Vo2 was normal until the 6-mo time point, when it was 40% lower in CR compared with control rats. At all time points, maximal leak-dependent Vo2 was lower in CR rats compared with controls. Proton leak kinetics indicated that mechanisms of adaptation to CR were different between short- and medium-term treatments, with the former leading to decreases in protonmotive force (Deltap) and state 4 Vo2 and the latter to increases in Deltap and decreases in state 4 Vo2. Results from metabolic control analyses of oxidative phosphorylation are consistent with the idea that short- and medium-term responses are distinct. Mitochondrial H2O2 production was lower in all three CR groups compared with controls. Overall, this study details the rapid effects of short- and medium-term CR on proton leak, ROS production, and metabolic control of oxidative phosphorylation. Results indicate that a reduction in mitochondrial Vo2 and ROS production may be a mechanism for the actions of CR.     

Influence of structure,pH and membrane potential on proton movement in cytochrome oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) reconstituted into phospholipid vesicles and subject to a membrane potential, exhibits different characteristics than the free enzyme, with respect to effects of mutations, pH, inhibitors, and native structural differences between CcO from different species. The results indicate that the membrane potential influences the conformation of CcO and the direction of proton movement in the exit path. The importance of the protein structure above the hemes in proton exit, back leak and respiratory control is discussed.     

Hypothyroidism in rats decreases mitochondrial inner membrane cation permeability

We investigated the cation permeability of liver mitochondria isolated from hypothyroid or euthyroid rats by measuring the rate of swelling of respiring mitochondria in acetate salts as a function of membrane potential. Mitochondria from hypothyroid rats have a decreased permeability of roughly 3-fold in the presence of monovalent cations K and tetramethylammonium at any (measured) membrane potential. Since the monovalent cation leak and the proton leak are known to respond similarly to membrane potential our results support the theory that the difference in non-phosphorylating respiration rate between mitochondria from hypothyroid and euthyroid rats is due to a difference in proton leak.     

Loss of UCP2 Attenuates Mitochondrial Dysfunction without Altering ROS Production and Uncoupling Activity

Although mitochondrial dysfunction is often accompanied by excessive reactive oxygen species (ROS) production, we previously showed that an increase in random somatic mtDNA mutations does not result in increased oxidative stress. Normal levels of ROS and oxidative stress could also be a result of an active compensatory mechanism such as a mild increase in proton leak. Uncoupling protein 2 (UCP2) was proposed to play such a role in many physiological situations. However, we show that upregulation of UCP2 in mtDNA mutator mice is not associated with altered proton leak kinetics or ROS production, challenging the current view on the role of UCP2 in energy metabolism. Instead, our results argue that high UCP2 levels allow better utilization of fatty acid oxidation resulting in a beneficial effect on mitochondrial function in heart, postponing systemic lactic acidosis and resulting in longer lifespan in these mice. This study proposes a novel mechanism for an adaptive response to mitochondrial cardiomyopathy that links changes in metabolism to amelioration of respiratory chain deficiency and longer lifespan.     

The contribution of the leak of protons across the mitochondrial inner membrane to standard metabolic rate

This paper presents and assesses the hypothesis that the proton leak across the mitochondrial inner membrane is an important contributor to standard metabolic rate, and that increases in the amount of mitochondrial inner membrane may be important in causing changes in proton leak and in the standard metabolic rate. The standard metabolic rate of an animal is known to be a function of body mass, phylogeny and thyroid status, and is largely attributed to the metabolically active internal organs. The total area of mitochondrial inner membrane in these organs correlates well with standard metabolic rate over a wide range of body masses in both ectotherms and endotherms. In hepatocytes isolated from rats, proton leak across the mitochondrial inner membrane accounts for about 30% of the resting oxygen consumption, and the distribution of control over respiration suggests that changes in mitochondrial inner membrane surface area will be accompanied by significant changes in the proton leak. This change in the leak will result in significant changes in resting oxygen consumption, but changes in ATP demand may also have a role to play in determining resting respiration rate. Extrapolation of these results to other tissues and other animals suggests that the hypothesis has the potential to explain a substantial proportion of the variation in standard metabolic rate with body mass, phylogeny and thyroid status. However, in most cases the quantitative contribution of proton leak compared to cellular ATP turnover has yet to be experimentally determined.     

Thyroid hormone status and membrane n-3 fatty acid content influence mitochondrial proton leak

Proton leak, as determined by the relationship between respiration rate and membrane potential, was lower in mitochondria from hypothyroid rats compared to euthyroid controls. Moreover, proton leak rates diminished even more when hypothyroid rats were fed a diet containing 5% of the lipid content as n-3 fatty acids. Similarly, proton leak was lower in euthyroid rats fed the 5% n-3 diet compared to one containing only 1% n-3 fatty acids. Lower proton leaks rates were associated with increased inner mitochondrial membrane levels of n-3 fatty acids and a decrease in the ratio of n-6/n-3 fatty acids. This trend was evident in the phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylinositol and cardiolipin phospholipid fractions. These results suggest that a significant portion of the effect of thyroid hormone status on proton leak is due to alterations in membrane fatty acid composition, primarily changes in n-3 content. Both the hypothyroid state and dietary effects appear to be mediated in part by inhibition of the Delta6- and Delta5-desaturase pathways.     

Mitochondrial proton leak: a role for uncoupling proteins 2 and 3?

In mitochondria ATP synthesis is not perfectly coupled to oxygen consumption due to proton leak across the mitochondrial inner membrane. Quantitative studies have shown that proton leak contributes to approximately 25% of the resting oxygen consumption of mammals. Proton leak plays a role in accounting for differences in basal metabolic rate. Thyroid studies, body mass studies, phylogenic studies and obesity studies have all shown that increased mass-specific metabolic rate is linked to increased mitochondrial proton leak. The mechanism of the proton leak is unclear. Evidence suggests that proton leak occurs by a non-specific diffusion process across the mitochondrial inner membrane. However, the high degree of sequence homology of the recently cloned uncoupling proteins UCP 2 and UCP 3 to brown adipose tissue UCP 1, and their extensive tissue distribution, suggest that these novel uncoupling proteins play a role in proton leak. Early indications from reconstitution experiments and several in vitro expression studies suggest that the novel uncoupling proteins uncouple mitochondria. Furthermore, mice overexpressing UCP 3 certainly show a phenotype consistent with increased metabolism. The evidence for a role for these novel UCPs in mitochondrial proton leak is reviewed.     

Differences in proton leak kinetics, but not in UCP3 protein content, in subsarcolemmal and intermyofibrillar skeletal muscle mitochondria from fed and fasted rats

We have investigated the effect of 24-h fasting on basal proton leak and uncoupling protein (UCP) 3 expression at the protein level in subsarcolemmal and intermyofibrillar skeletal muscle mitochondria. In fed rats, the two mitochondrial populations displayed different proton leak, but the same protein content of UCP3. In addition, 24-h fasting, both at 24 and 29 degrees C, induced an increase in proton leak only in subsarcolemmal mitochondria, while UCP3 content increased in both the populations. From the present data, it appears that UCP3 does not control the basal proton leak of skeletal muscle mitochondria.