Pushy males and choosy females: courtship disruption and mate choice in the lekking great snipe

We studied the effects of male disruptive behaviour on female mate choice and male mating success in the great snipe, Gallinago media, a lekking bird. Harassment from neighbouring males, a widespread behaviour in lekking animals, was the most prevalent cause of females leaving a male territory. Several lines of evidence show that females did not prefer to mate with males able to protect them from harassment. Males that obtained mating success were no less likely to suffer disruptions and females were no less likely to be disrupted when with their preferred male. Females returned to the male they later mated with, despite being repeatedly chased away by neighbours. The probability that an individual female returned and solicited mating from a male was 15 times higher for the male she was chased away from compared to the neighbour that chased her away. Females returned as often or more to the territory owner after being disrupted, compared to after leaving the territory without being harassed. Our results suggest that female great snipes are extremely choosy, but also that females do not gain direct benefits (harassment avoidance) by mating with certain males. Females appear to have neither direct nor indirect preferences for dominance that could give them such benefits: females appeared choosy despite, not because of, harassment. If females gain indirect benefits (genetically superior offspring) by being choosy, this is also likely to be unrelated to any dominance among males.     

Females prefer to associate with males with longer intromittent organs in mosquitofish

Sexual selection is a major force behind the rapid evolution of male genital morphology among species. Most within-species studies have focused on sexual selection on male genital traits owing to events during or after copulation that increase a male''s share of paternity. Very little attention has been given to whether genitalia are visual signals that cause males to vary in their attractiveness to females and are therefore under pre-copulatory sexual selection. Here we show that, on average, female eastern mosquitofish Gambusia holbrooki spent more time in association with males who received only a slight reduction in the length of the intromittent organ (‘gonopodium’) than males that received a greater reduction. This preference was, however, only expressed when females chose between two large males; for small males, there was no effect of genital size on female association time.     

Female tawny-bellied seedeaters do not prefer more colorful males in choice experiments

Plumage coloration has long been studied as a sexually selected character. The tawny-bellied seedeater, Sporophila hypoxantha, is a sexually dichromatic species, with adult males the more colorful sex and juvenile males indistinguishable from females. We did choice experiments to evaluate female preferences for males that differ in age or plumage coloration. Females were evaluated in three experiments: (1) choice between males with similar breast brightness that differed in age, (2) choice between males of 2 years of age that differed in breast brightness, and (3) choice between males of 3 or more years of age that differed in breast brightness. We also repeated the latter experiment with estradiol-treated females. We did not find a clear female preference for brighter or older males, as females spent the same proportion of time with males of similar breast brightness that differed in age or with males of similar age that differed in breast brightness. Our results do not support the hypothesis that breast brightness is a cue used by female tawny-bellied seedeaters at the time of choosing males. We propose that, in this species, male plumage coloration might play a role in intrasexual competition.     

Female choice and male humoral immune response in the lekking great snipe (Gallinago media)

Parasites and diseases constitute major evolutionary forcesin many natural populations, and thus having an efficient immunedefense to resist infections is crucial for many organisms.Properties of the immune response may also influence mate choicedecisions in many animals. Theory predicts several advantagesfor females when choosing males with superior immune systems.These benefits can be both direct (e.g. increased paternal careand reduced disease transmission) and indirect (good genes).We have investigated female choice with respect to antibodyresponse to two novel antigens in males of a lekking bird, thegreat snipe (Gallinago media). Because of the lek mating system,female choice probably mainly incurs indirect (genetic) ratherthan direct benefits. Males responded to vaccination with diphtheriaand tetanus toxoids by producing specific antibodies to bothantigens. Triggering the immune system had no negative impacton display activities or survival. Males that were chosen byfemales as mates had on average higher antibody response tothe tetanus antigen than their neighbors. We did not, however,find any covariance between the strength of the antibody responseand male mating success.     

Females lay fewer eggs for males with greater courtship success in a lekking Drosophila

The evolutionary basis for female mate choice in lek mating systems has been a common subject of research in animal behaviour. Because males apparently provide only gametes to females in lekking species, most research has focused on possible indirect (genetic) benefits that females might gain by discriminating among males. Despite the emphasis on indirect benefits, it has been recognized that females in non-resource-based systems such as leks could potentially gain direct benefits via mate choice if males varied in fertilization abilities, for example. Previous evidence has shown that females of a lekking Hawaiian Drosophila, D. grimshawi, vary in fecundity when mated to certain males, and that females possess preferences for vigorously courting males. This study tests the hypothesis that D. grimshawi females gain direct benefits by preferentially mating with more sexually vigorous males. Male courtship vigour (performance of wing and head-under-wing displays) and the consequences of female choice on offspring production were evaluated separately using different females. Unexpectedly, matings involving more vigorously courting males resulted in fewer offspring being produced. Reduced offspring number resulted because females laid fewer eggs when mating with males having greater courtship success. These results are discussed in light of sexual conflict and possible multiple mating by females. Females also demonstrated considerable variation in mating behaviour and behavioural variation was correlated with mating benefits. Copyright 2003 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour. Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.      

Correlates of male mating success in the lekking great snipe (Gallinago media): results from a four-year study

To investigate behavioral or morphological traits importantas mate choice cues, we measured selection differentials (s)as the covariances between each trait and male mating success,and directional selection gradients (J3) from multiple linearregression of the standardized traits on male mating success.Data from two leks in four consecutive years were included,and the annual data were analyzed separately. The main findingsare: (1) the distribution of male mating success proved to beless skewed than those found in many other lekking species,(2) only a few traits yielded significant selection gradients,(3) the importance of age on male mating success changed acrossyears, (4) females may use traits with a high variance as matechoice cues, and (5) individual males achieved similar matingsuccesses between years. Attendance and age were the traitsmost consistently correlated with male mating success, but notraits showed significant selection gradients in all years.Our results indicate that variable sexual selection pressuresexisted between years, but the high correlation found betweenthe mating success of individual males in successive seasonsalso indicates that permanent differences in male traits areimportant. Key words: lek, mate choice, sexual selection.     

Females prefer mating males in the carmine triplefin,Axoclinus carminalis,a paternal brood-guarder

Synopsis This study investigates the role of male mating status in female choice patterns in the carmine triplefin, Axoclinus carminalis, a tripterygiid fish that exhibits paternal care. The distribution of daily reproductive activity is clumped, with many males receiving no mates and some receiving three or more. Females in this species do not prefer larger males, and characteristics of the oviposition site appear to have minimal effects on male mating success. When a female is removed from a male early in the daily spawning period, that male attracts fewer additional females for the remainder of the spawning period than does a control male. These changes in mating success are temporary, and do not affect mating success on subsequent days. A preference for mating males or males that are guarding eggs could provide asymmetric benefits for males to defend oviposition sites. This preference for males with eggs could be acting alone or with other factors such as high variance in oviposition site quality to favor the evolution of paternal care in fishes.     

Incubation rhythm in the great snipe Gallinago media

The incubation rhythm of four female great snipe was monitored with telemetric equipment. The mean daily incubation constancy was 90.3 ± 2.0 (SD) per cent, and the mean daily time off the nest amounted to 139.8 ± 28.8 min. The number of recesses per day averaged 8.7 ± 1.9, with a mean duration of 15.7 ± 6.1 min. Generally, the birds incubated for long bouts during the night, and left the nest frequently during the daylight hours.
Recesses were concentrated in the warmest part of the day in cool periods, but were more evenly distributed throughout the day in warmer periods. Recess duration decreased with decreasing temperature. These adjustments minimize egg cooling when the bird is off the nest, and thus allow the incubating bird more time to feed without lowering the mean egg temperature.
Calculations of the cooling rates of eggs indicate that the bird minimizes incubation energy expenditure as far as possible, but without letting the eggs cool beyond the temperature of no embryonic development.     

Attractive males do not sire superior daughters

Much of the recent work on the evolution of female choice has focused on the relative influence of direct and indirect benefits, and particularly whether direct costs can be offset by indirect benefits. Studies investigating whether attractive males benefit females by increasing the viability of their offspring often report mating advantages to sons consistent with the Fisher process, while detecting no or weak viability benefits. One potential reason for this is that sons may trade-off viability benefits with investment in costly traits that enhance mating success, leading to the suggestion that viability benefits may be better detected by examining daughters’ fitness. Here we investigate the relationship between male attractiveness and daughters’ fitness in Drosophila simulans. We measured daughter (and dam) lifetime reproductive success and longevity. We found no evidence that attractive males sire high fitness daughters. Additionally, neither daughters nor dams gained direct benefits from mating with attractive males. However, aspects of daughters’ fitness were related to dam characters.     

Food supply and breeding occurrences: the West European population of the lekking great snipe Gallinago media (Latham, 1787) (Aves)

For species with very high energetic costs during reproduction we expect occurence during the reproduction season to be dramatically affected by the availability of energy. Recent studies have shown very high energetic costs of lekking for great snipe males, Gallinago media (Latham, 1787) and that breeding great snipes prefer to feed in soft soil with a high abundance of earthworms. We here evaluate the hypothesis that the breeding occurrence of great snipe is restricted to areas with very high availability of food. All the 125 registered great snipe leks in Scandinavia were situated in open habitats along the tree line. The occurrence of leks were analysed in relation to bedrock quality, soil chemistry and earthworm biomass. There was a strong positive relationship between soil pH and earthworm biomass. High pH values were found on or in the close vicinity of base-rich bedrocks. No great snipe leks were documented in areas with acid soil, even if the extent of acid bedrocks along the tree line predicts that 31% of the leks should be situated on acid soils. Hypotheses, including both natural and sexual selection, for why breeding occurrence of great snipe is restricted to areas with high abundance of high quality food are evaluated, and we find indications for this to be a consequence of the very high energetic costs for the lekking males. These costs have probably evolved through female mate choice and indicate that sexual selection may have important consequences for a species distribution. Population-level effects of sexual selection have previously received little attention. The stringent habitat demands here documented may also make great snipes vulnerable to environmental changes and can contribute to explain the dramatic reduction in breeding range of this species in western Europe during the past 150 years (Løfaldli et al ., 1989).     

Male orangethroat darters,Etheostoma spectabile, do not prefer larger females

Synopsis Male orangethroat darters,Etheostoma spectabile, did not show a preference for larger females as measured by the number of matings or time until mating in a field enclosure experiment. The lack of male preference for female size may be due to the male-biased sex ratio at the site (seven males per female) or to low variation in the number of eggs deposited per spawning.     

Female red deer prefer the roars of larger males

Surprisingly little is known about the role of acoustic cues in mammal female mate choice. Here, we examine the response of female red deer (Cervus elaphus) to male roars in which an acoustic cue to body size, the formants, has been re-scaled to simulate different size callers. Our results show that oestrous red deer hinds prefer roars simulating larger callers and constitute the first evidence that female mammals use an acoustic cue to body size in a mate choice context. We go on to suggest that sexual selection through female mating preferences may have provided an additional selection pressure along with male-male competition for broadcasting size-related information in red deer and other mammals.     

Some pollinators do not prefer symmetrically marked or shaped daisy (Asteraceae) flowers

We noted no significant pollinator preference for symmetry in daisy (Asteraceae) flowers. Asymmetry of markings on Gorteria diffusa did not negatively affect pollinator visitation by bee-flies. Nevertheless, the flowers of this species tend to be symmetrically marked. Beetles did not discriminate against artificial daisy flowers which had petals placed in asymmetrical positions. We are sceptical about Moller's (1995) view that the symmetry of flowers is due to pollinator discrimination against asymmetrical flowers.     

Female collared flycatchers learn to prefer males with an artificial novel ornament

We experimentally investigated whether learning from previousexperiences can lead to the establishment of a new mate preferencein a wild population of birds. During year one (2001), 63 femalecollared flycatchers (Ficedula albicollis) bred together withmales that we had provided with a novel trait, a red stripeon their white forehead patch (a sexually selected trait). Somecolor patterns of birds are largely determined by a few genes,and this experiment was designed to mimic the occurrence ofmutations in such genes. In the subsequent year (2002), we foundthat females with previous experience with red-striped maleswere more likely to pair with red-striped males (76%) than withcontrol males. By contrast, naïve females (i.e., with noprevious experience with red-striped males) were not more likelyto pair with red-striped males (44%) than with control males.Females paired with red-striped males produced more offspringthan females paired with control males, suggesting that maleswith the novel trait had become favored by selection. Thus,female collared flycatchers appear to quickly learn to associatea novel trait with a suitable mate that, in turn, leads to assortativemating between local mates (i.e., males with the new trait andfemales with previous experience of the new trait). Our resultsprovide support for the notion that learning may play an importantrole when the co-evolution of preferences and preferred traitstakes different routes in different populations of the samebird species.     

Females benefit from mating with different males in the scorpionfly Panorpa cognata

The adaptive significance of female polyandry has become a recurrentsubject of recent theoretical and empirical research. It hasbeen argued that in addition to direct benefits, such as nuptialgifts or an adequate sperm supply, females may gain geneticbenefits from mating with different males. Females of the scorpionflyPanorpa cognata mate with several males during their lifetime.In an experiment designed to rule out any direct nutritionalbenefit of multiple matings, I found that polyandrous femalesthat mated with two different males achieved a significantlyhigher egg-hatching success than monandrous females that matedtwice with the same male. However, individual males did nottrigger the same response in different females as the egg-hatchingsuccess of different females that mated with one and same maledid not correlate. The results, thus, do not conform to predictionsfrom hypotheses assuming that genetic benefits of polyandryare influenced by the intrinsic genetic quality of males. Theresults are, however, consistent with the genetic incompatibilityhypothesis. Nevertheless, substances from different males transferredduring copulation may synergistically affect zygote viability.Furthermore, I discuss why paternity studies can only explicitlytest the genetic incompatibility hypothesis if there are a prioriexpectations of female-male genome compatibilities.